CROSS: No Justice for Gibson Guitars
May 30, 2014
Bill Frezzarevivesthe Gibson Guitars case in a piece published in Forbes. The whole affair stands asan appalling example of the law run amok. The owners believe they suffered heavy-handed treatment fromthe feds due tothe protectionist interests of labor unions and environmentalists. But when the law can be warped to satisfy the whim of any bureaucrat or power-holder, thats not protectionism, thats tyranny. More specifically, the Gibson Guitars case epitomizes the tyranny of non-objectivelaw .
Lumber Union Protectionists Incited SWAT Raid On My Factory, Says Gibson GuitarCEO
Henry. A SWAT team from Homeland Security just raided our factory!
What? This must be a joke.
No this is really serious. We got guys with guns, they put all our people out in the parking lot and wont let us go into the plant.
Whoa.
What is happening ? asks Gibson Guitar CEO Henry Juszkiewicz when he arrives at his Nashville factory to question the officers. We cant tell you. What are you talking about, you cant tell me, you cant just come in and We have a warrant! Well, lemme see the warrant . We cant show that to you because its sealed.
While 30 men in SWAT attire dispatched from Homeland Security and the U.S. Fish and Wildlife Service cart away about half a million dollars of wood and guitars, seven armed agents interrogate an employee without benefit of a lawyer. The next day Juszkiewicz receives a letter warning that he cannot touch any guitar left in the plant, under threat of being charged with a separate federal offense for each violation, punishable by a jail term.
Up until that point Gibson had not received so much as a postcard telling the company it might be doing something wrong. Thus began a five-year saga, extensively covered by the press, with reputation-destroying leaks and shady allegations that Gibson was illegally importing wood from endangered tree species. In the end, formal charges were never filed, but the disruption to Gibsons business and the mounting legal fees and threat of imprisonment induced Juszkiewicz to settle for $250,000with an additional $50,000 donation piled on to pay off an environmental activist group.
What really happened at the Nashville plant?
Henry Juszkiewicz bought the troubled Gibson Guitar company in 1986. With revenues having dropped to below $10 million a year, the iconic 84-year old guitar maker was bleeding cash and on its way to bankruptcy. Since then, Juszkiewicz turned Gibson around, making it into an international powerhouse, growing at better than 20 percent a year compounded, with current annual revenues rumored to be approaching $1 billion.
A great American success story? Yes, but Gibsons very success made it a fat target for federal prosecutors, whom Juszkiewicz alleges were operating at the behest of lumber unions and environmental pressure groups seeking to kill the market for lumber imports. This case was not about conservation, he says. It was basically protectionism.
Two months before the raid, lobbyists slipped some arcane supply-chain reporting provisions into an extension of the Lacey Act of 1900 that changed the technical definition of fingerboard blanks, which are legal to import.
With no clear legal standards, a sealed warrant the company has not been allowed to see too this day, no formal charges filed, and the threat of a prison term hanging over any executive who does not take due care to abide by this absurdly vague law, Gibson settled. Youre fighting a very well organized political machine in the unions, Juszkiewicz concluded. And the conservation guys have sort of gone along. Hey, whats not to like about $50,000?
And this isnt an isolated incident. Just ask Harvey Silverglate, Boston lawyer, activist, civil liberties advocate, and author of Three Felonies a Day: How the Feds Target the Innocent . As he explains, the Feds routinely take advantage of the vagueness of many of our laws by starting from the target and working backwards, selectively prosecuting people they want to go after by charging them with crimes they often dont even know exist.
We are in terrible trouble as a nation under law, he says. When you have a system predicated on jurisdictional interests rather than on specific, identifiable, understandable, definable violations of law, there is a great opportunity for tyranny. As a result, just about any businessperson, especially in highly regulated industries, can be construed by a prosecutor to have committed three or four arguable felonies a day. If for some reason the authorities are eyeing you and they look closely enough at your daily activities, they can find something. That makes us all very vulnerable.
Worse, 95 percent of federal cases never go to trial, because Justice Department prosecutors have engineered the system to make it too risky to go to trial, often railroading people who are innocent. They have built a conviction machine, not a system of justice.
Federal criminal law is not bound by the accepted rules of common law. Congress, the courts, and prosecutors can criminalize everyday conduct without having to prove that the accused intended to violate a known legal duty.That intent used to be fundamental to the mens rea required for criminal liability.It no longer is, and this is a direct result of the mushrooming administrative state in which we live. The convoluted content of many laws implemented through regulation arent even clear until after theres a guilty plea or conviction, essentially giving prosecutors a blank check. Throw unchecked prosecutorial discretion into the mix and you have a recipe for legal nightmares straight out of Kafka. This is the great flaw in the federal criminal justice system. We didnt really see the flaw in all its dangerous, florid iteration until the mid 1980s, when federal prosecutors began to take advantage of this gigantic hole.
This is neither a Democratic problem nor a Republican problem. Abuse of justice by federal prosecutors has ballooned under both parties. Until the American people wake up to the threat and demand change, things will only get worse.
Henry Juszkiewicz and Harvey Silverglate are my guests on this weeks RealClear Radio Hour . Listen to them tell their stories in their own words here .

Unfortunately we have the perfect storm right now.
We have a president who is a narcissist and has decided the other branches of government are insignificant.
We have the Senate controlled by a man who will support the president completely in everything he does whether it is good for the country or not and has been the biggest obstruction to getting this country back on its feet than anyone else.
We have a Speaker of the House, although he is of the opposing party, but must have read the little black book or something on him, who will not take up the fight.
We have a crooked Attorney General who is in Contempt of Congress and nothing has been done about it and supports the president who actually saved both of their asses with his Executive Privilege over "Fast and Furious".
And lastly we have the regulatory agencies who are not elected that are writing the laws as the president sees fit with no oversight.
I want to add this as well. We have different Federal Agency like the IRS and NSA who don't want anyone to jeopardize their jobs so they are supporting the president totally in the upper echelons and it appears there is no limit in what they will do.
And this is also very important. We have way to many people who don't care what policies are being promoted as long as they get their benefits or the person is cool. The American people are too complacent.
I knew there had to be more reasons besides gun insanity why I don't want to step foot into the USA.
If I were a freedom-loving American I would try to start a movement among all owners of guitars to try to force the government to change its policy and recompense Gibson Guitars for the wrong they have done it.There is no oversight on federal prosecutions nor on the purpose of the laws being created . But congress keeps on producing more & more destructive laws . At some point the entire system will just fall apart .
Proving selective enforcement is very difficult since it would require access to the entire database of charges brought by the feds . No one has access to those records except the FEDS themselves ...
Good Gosh!
My best friend, who plays French horn for the Baltimore Symphony has a Gibson guitar, and it is fabulous. (Needless to say, she is also a fabulous guitar player.) Gibsons are wonderful guitars. What was the wood they were importing?
Thanks!
If I were a freedom loving Chinese citizen , I wouldn't even know where to start . There is so much ham handed government abuse there it would be a mountain of problems that would need to be solved .
It really was the same thing everyone else was importing which was used for the fretboard. Let me see what I can find. I kept up with this when it first happened. The fact is Gibson and Peavey are the only two American made guitar companies of any size who aren't unionized. That was the jest of it plus the owner of Gibson had donated money to the Republicans. Another one of those Ben Carson deals. Let me see what I saved on this.
None of the unionized companies were attacked by the DOJ.
Gibson is the only guitar company targeted by the Obama DOJ under the Lacey Act -- Tennessee is a right-to-work state.
Fender, Taylor, Rickenbacker, Danelectro, Carvin, MusicMan, and ESP are in California; Spector is in New York; Martin is in Pennsylvania; Guild, Ovation, and Hamer are in Connecticut; Alvarez is in Missouri; B.C. Rich is in Kentucky; Heritage is in Michigan; Washburn is in Illinois. -- All are forced-union states. [emphasis for Martin added]
Peavey is another guitar and electronics company, located in the right-to-work state of Mississippi. -- Since 2009, Peavey has been the target of multiple lawsuits filed by a competitor, MUSIC Group, which alleges that Peavy products fail to meet federal safety and emissions standards.
This first happened not long after Obama was elected the first time and you remember how he played up to the unions and they would haul people in from all over the country to help get Obama elected. The most frequent visitor to the White House was Stern SEIU's leader.
Unions - democrats - Unions - democrats - Unions - democrats - 'nuff said.