╌>

Transgender Surgery Isn't the Solution-- Drastic physical change doesn't address underlying psycho-social troubles, WSJ.--Paul McHugh

  

Category:  News & Politics

Via:  len  •  12 years ago  •  29 comments

Transgender Surgery Isn't the Solution--   Drastic physical change doesn't address underlying psycho-social troubles, WSJ.--Paul McHugh

The government and media alliance advancing the transgender cause has gone into overdrive in recent weeks. On May 30, a U.S. Department of Health and Human Services review board ruled that Medicare can pay for the "reassignment" surgery sought by the transgenderedthose who say that they don't identify with their biological sex. Earlier last month Defense Secretary Chuck Hagel said that he was "open" to lifting a ban on transgender individuals serving in the military. Time magazine, seeing the trend, ran a cover story for its June 9 issue called "The Transgender Tipping Point: America's next civil rights frontier."

Yet policy makers and the media are doing no favors either to the public or the transgendered by treating their confusions as a right in need of defending rather than as a mental disorder that deserves understanding, treatment and prevention. This intensely felt sense of being transgendered constitutes a mental disorder in two respects. The first is that the idea of sex misalignment is simply mistakenit does not correspond with physical reality. The second is that it can lead to grim psychological outcomes.

The transgendered suffer a disorder of "assumption" like those in other disorders familiar to psychiatrists. With the transgendered, the disordered assumption is that the individual differs from what seems given in naturenamely one's maleness or femaleness. Other kinds of disordered assumptions are held by those who suffer from anorexia and bulimia nervosa, where the assumption that departs from physical reality is the belief by the dangerously thin that they are overweight.

BN-DF486_mchugh_D_20140612171103.jpg

A man who looks into the mirror and sees himself as a woman Getty Images

With body dysmorphic disorder, an often socially crippling condition, the individual is consumed by the assumption "I'm ugly." These disorders occur in subjects who have come to believe that some of their psycho-social conflicts or problems will be resolved if they can change the way that they appear to others. Such ideas work like ruling passions in their subjects' minds and tend to be accompanied by a solipsistic argument.

For the transgendered, this argument holds that one's feeling of "gender" is a conscious, subjective sense that, being in one's mind, cannot be questioned by others. The individual often seeks not just society's tolerance of this "personal truth" but affirmation of it. Here rests the support for "transgender equality," the demands for government payment for medical and surgical treatments, and for access to all sex-based public roles and privileges.

With this argument, advocates for the transgendered have persuaded several statesincluding California, New Jersey and Massachusettsto pass laws barring psychiatrists, even with parental permission, from striving to restore natural gender feelings to a transgender minor. That government can intrude into parents' rights to seek help in guiding their children indicates how powerful these advocates have become.

How to respond? Psychiatrists obviously must challenge the solipsistic concept that what is in the mind cannot be questioned. Disorders of consciousness, after all, represent psychiatry's domain; declaring them off-limits would eliminate the field. Many will recall how, in the 1990s, an accusation of parental sex abuse of children was deemed unquestionable by the solipsists of the "recovered memory" craze.

You won't hear it from those championing transgender equality, but controlled and follow-up studies reveal fundamental problems with this movement. When children who reported transgender feelings were tracked without medical or surgical treatment at both Vanderbilt University and London's Portman Clinic, 70%-80% of them spontaneously lost those feelings. Some 25% did have persisting feelings; what differentiates those individuals remains to be discerned.

We at Johns Hopkins Universitywhich in the 1960s was the first American medical center to venture into "sex-reassignment surgery"launched a study in the 1970s comparing the outcomes of transgendered people who had the surgery with the outcomes of those who did not. Most of the surgically treated patients described themselves as "satisfied" by the results, but their subsequent psycho-social adjustments were no better than those who didn't have the surgery. And so at Hopkins we stopped doing sex-reassignment surgery, since producing a "satisfied" but still troubled patient seemed an inadequate reason for surgically amputating normal organs.

It now appears that our long-ago decision was a wise one. A 2011 study at the Karolinska Institute in Sweden produced the most illuminating results yet regarding the transgendered, evidence that should give advocates pause. The long-term studyup to 30 yearsfollowed 324 people who had sex-reassignment surgery. The study revealed that beginning about 10 years after having the surgery, the transgendered began to experience increasing mental difficulties. Most shockingly, their suicide mortality rose almost 20-fold above the comparable nontransgender population. This disturbing result has as yet no explanation but probably reflects the growing sense of isolation reported by the aging transgendered after surgery. The high suicide rate certainly challenges the surgery prescription.

There are subgroups of the transgendered, and for none does "reassignment" seem apt. One group includes male prisoners like Pvt. Bradley Manning , the convicted national-security leaker who now wishes to be called Chelsea. Facing long sentences and the rigors of a men's prison, they have an obvious motive for wanting to change their sex and hence their prison. Given that they committed their crimes as males, they should be punished as such; after serving their time, they will be free to reconsider their gender.

Another subgroup consists of young men and women susceptible to suggestion from "everything is normal" sex education, amplified by Internet chat groups. These are the transgender subjects most like anorexia nervosa patients: They become persuaded that seeking a drastic physical change will banish their psycho-social problems. "Diversity" counselors in their schools, rather like cult leaders, may encourage these young people to distance themselves from their families and offer advice on rebutting arguments against having transgender surgery. Treatments here must begin with removing the young person from the suggestive environment and offering a counter-message in family therapy.

Then there is the subgroup of very young, often prepubescent children who notice distinct sex roles in the culture and, exploring how they fit in, begin imitating the opposite sex. Misguided doctors at medical centers including Boston's Children's Hospital have begun trying to treat this behavior by administering puberty-delaying hormones to render later sex-change surgeries less onerouseven though the drugs stunt the children's growth and risk causing sterility. Given that close to 80% of such children would abandon their confusion and grow naturally into adult life if untreated, these medical interventions come close to child abuse. A better way to help these children: with devoted parenting.

At the heart of the problem is confusion over the nature of the transgendered. "Sex change" is biologically impossible. People who undergo sex-reassignment surgery do not change from men to women or vice versa. Rather, they become feminized men or masculinized women. Claiming that this is civil-rights matter and encouraging surgical intervention is in reality to collaborate with and promote a mental disorder.

Dr. McHugh, former psychiatrist in chief at Johns Hopkins Hospital, is the author of "Try to Remember: Psychiatry's Clash Over Meaning, Memory, and Mind" (Dana Press, 2008).

http://online.wsj.com/articles/paul-mchugh-transgender-surgery-isnt-the-solution-1402615120?KEYWORDS=transgender


Tags

jrDiscussion - desc
[]
 
Sean Treacy
Professor Principal
link   Sean Treacy    12 years ago
Common sense ! I'm sure it will result in hate crime charges.
 
 
 
sixpick
Professor Quiet
link   sixpick    12 years ago

I should have done that when I was a young fellow. Then I could have become a lesbian, still gotten what I was looking for and it would have probably been a whole lot easier too. Grin.gif

 
 
 
1ofmany
Sophomore Silent
link   1ofmany    12 years ago

It's good to know that there are still doctors who don't think reality should be bent to accommodate a mental disorder.

 
 
 
Hal A. Lujah
Professor Participates
link   Hal A. Lujah    12 years ago
All this philosophizing and armchair diagnosis overlooks one very critical fact - those who undergo sexual reassignment are ultimately much happier with the results than they were before. It's like those who have a lame or deformed foot - normal people can't grasp how someone could opt to have a body part removed when it isn't medically necessary, but post op interviews with them indicate immense relief to have that appendage gone. Who is anyone to stand in the way of someone else's happiness, so long as what makes them happy isn't hurting anyone else?
 
 
 
Sean Treacy
Professor Principal
link   Sean Treacy    12 years ago
Those who undergo sexual reassignment surgery are so happy that they kill themselves.Did you read the article?
 
 
 
Hal A. Lujah
Professor Participates
link   Hal A. Lujah    12 years ago
I see no link for an article, so I assumed it was just more of Len's hyperbolic drivel. I would read it if he would post a reputable source, since Len himself is hardly a reputable source. However, it stands to reason that having gender disorder increases one's potential for committing suicide, regardless of whether they have or don't have the surgery. The stress of living in the wrong body is bad, as is the stress of living in a world that sees you as a freak. It is up to society to change the second one.
 
 
 
1ofmany
Sophomore Silent
link   1ofmany    12 years ago

The stress of living in the wrong body is bad, as is the stress of living in a world that sees you as a freak. It is up to society to change the second one.

No, it's up to the person with the mental disorder to get treatment rather than expect society to see a freakishly mutilated body as normal.

 
 
 
Hal A. Lujah
Professor Participates
link   Hal A. Lujah    12 years ago
So the person who has their deformed leg amputated is a freak whether they have it amputated or not? Are you that guy who points at the disabled and whispers jokes to your buddy, since you feel it is not your responsibility as a member of society to see people as equals, regardless of their physical or mental challenges?
 
 
 
1ofmany
Sophomore Silent
link   1ofmany    12 years ago
So the person who has their deformed leg amputated is a freak whether they have it amputated or not? Are you that guy who points at the disabled and whispers jokes to your buddy, since you feel it is not your responsibility as a member of society to see people as equals, regardless of their physical or mental challenges?
Thinking you're born in the wrong body is a mental disorder not a physical deformity. But, yeah,if you're a woman with whacked off titties and a beard, then I'm gonna snicker.
 
 
 
Hal A. Lujah
Professor Participates
link   Hal A. Lujah    12 years ago
As an American, it is your right to slog through life as a judgmental elitist. Carry on.
 
 
 
Perrie Halpern R.A.
Professor Guide
link   Perrie Halpern R.A.    12 years ago

 
 
 
Len
Freshman Silent
link   seeder  Len    12 years ago

Hal>>All this philosophizing and armchair diagnosis overlooks one very critical fact - those who undergo sexual reassignment are ultimately much happier with the results than they were before. It's like those who have a lame or deformed foot - normal people can't grasp how someone could opt to have a body part removed when it isn't medically necessary, but post op interviews with them indicate immense relief to have that appendage gone. Who is anyone to stand in the way of someone else's happiness, so long as what makes them happy isn't hurting anyone else?

You obviously did not read the seed which was not written by me but by the former psychiatrist in chief at Johns Hopkins Hospital, and which was published in the Wall Street Journal. As such, he had many years of case histories at the ready as a result of which Johns Hopkins Hospital terminated their performance of such surgery.

Only a fuzzy-minded liberal would look askance at such authoritative testimony as "hyperbolic drivel" not "from a reputable source." If he provided 100 pages of supporting stats it would have made no difference to you because, for liberals, theiridealizedopinions will always veto facts.

I provided no link 'cause you need a WSJ subscription to have access.

 
 
 
1ofmany
Sophomore Silent
link   1ofmany    12 years ago
As an American, it is your right to slog through life as a judgmental elitist. Carry on.
. . . and when it comestime for the end, the men will look like the women and the women like the men.
 
 
 
1ofmany
Sophomore Silent
link   1ofmany    12 years ago

Only a fuzzy-minded liberal would look askance at such authoritative testimony as "hyperbolic drivel" not "from a reputable source." If he provided 100 pages of supporting stats it would have made no difference to you because, for liberals, their idealized opinions will always veto facts.

If you keep talking, Hal is going to reconsider becoming a lesbian who'sin a love triangle with a horse and a cheese sandwich.Grin.gif

 
 
 
Hal A. Lujah
Professor Participates
link   Hal A. Lujah    12 years ago
I did read through it, but it's always more credible when its source is provided. The problem with conservatives is that they see the words "elevated risk", and suddenly their agenda has been justified. As I stated above, living with gender disorder is stressful regardless of surgical enhancement. It is not possible to predict whether a person would not have committed suicide if they wouldn't have undergone the surgery, since they were in crisis either way.

I see this article as steering an agenda towards an unknowable conclusion of data. Perhaps this is more about doctors lessening their risk of lawsuits, than it is about genuinely caring for those who suffer from a crippling mental disorder. Consenting adults should be allowed to make this decision themselves, and not have the decision made for them by those unaffected by the disorder, using loosely interpreted data. The same goes for assisted suicide for those who are chronically lacking a quality of life due to health issues.
 
 
 
Len
Freshman Silent
link   seeder  Len    12 years ago

Hal, if you do not object to a "consenting adults" making a decision to self-mutilate, why are you concerned about a similar decision to commit suicide?

I am concerned about either or both.

Once you amputate your penis your second thoughts will be of no avail.

 
 
 
Hal A. Lujah
Professor Participates
link   Hal A. Lujah    12 years ago
The suicide comment was completely unrelated to gender reassignment surgery results. I brought it up because the manner in which it is dealt with legally, by people serving political agendas, who have no appreciation for what people who suffer certain terminal illnesses go through.The decision to hack off your penis is not a hastily made one. From what I understand, it involves a lengthy process of counseling, and is by no means a given freedom in its current state. I've heard of cases where psychologists were not convinced that subjects were good candidates, and refused to sign the required consent forms.
 
 
 
Hal A. Lujah
Professor Participates
link   Hal A. Lujah    12 years ago
I'm into Swiss and Arabian women, not Swiss cheese and Arabian horses.
 
 
 
Dowser
Sophomore Silent
link   Dowser    12 years ago

Well, look. I know of three gay psychiatrists. They all went through the same thing in their training, where they themselves undergo analysis, and one is contemplating gender reassignment surgery. Frankly, I find it to be a bit barbaric to label those who wish to be reassigned as having a psycho-social illness or troubles. They are normal people, they just feel that they were born in the wrong body.

You know, God made gay people too. He loves them just as much as the rest of us. Can't we just leave other people be? If an operation and series of hormone medications make them feel better about themselves, who am I to judge? And why shouldn't Medicare/Medicaid pay for it? If it requires a label of an illness to justify the paying of it, then, by all means, jump through the hoops and do it. As Rhett said to Scarlett, "Frankly my dear..."

Yeah, it's my tax dollars at work, and I'd rather pay for this than a lot of other things we spend money on.

 
 
 
Len
Freshman Silent
link   seeder  Len    12 years ago

And if a TG commits suicide 20 years later who are you to judge though you supported his/her surgery and helped finance it?

 
 
 
1ofmany
Sophomore Silent
link   1ofmany    12 years ago
Personally, I don't want to subsidize cosmetic surgery to satisfy somebody's delusion that they were born in the wrong body. They should be looking for psychiatric treatment, not subsidized surgery.
 
 
 
Dowser
Sophomore Silent
link   Dowser    12 years ago

Frankly, my dear...

I'm not a 'life at any cost' kind of person. Never have been. Maybe I've lived through too many family members lying there so miserable, suffering, in pain, can't get better and can't die. There are certain cases where I feel that suicide is an option, and I also feel that God understands.

Do you have any statistics on transgendered people who have committed suicide? I'd really like to see them. For my own education.

 
 
 
Dowser
Sophomore Silent
link   Dowser    12 years ago

That's fine. Let's use your tax dollars to buy that new nuclear warhead and mine to pay for their surgeries. Smile.gif

 
 
 
Hal A. Lujah
Professor Participates
link   Hal A. Lujah    12 years ago
Good answer Dowser!
 
 
 
1ofmany
Sophomore Silent
link   1ofmany    12 years ago
"Let's use your tax dollars to buy that new nuclear warhead and mine to pay for their surgeries"Fine by me if you can get a tranny to detonate with the force of a nuclear bomb.
 
 
 
Dowser
Sophomore Silent
link   Dowser    12 years ago

Unfortunately, I don't think you can...

 
 
 
Hal A. Lujah
Professor Participates
link   Hal A. Lujah    12 years ago
I don't really think that matters, since we already have thousands more nuclear warheads than it would take to extinguish mankind.
 
 
 
1ofmany
Sophomore Silent
link   1ofmany    12 years ago
Instead of a city leveling strategic nuclear weapon, we could make a lower yield tactical tranny bomb for battlefield use. And before you say it, it's no more ridiculous than surgically attaching fake titties to a man at tax payer expense because he's deranged and thinks he should have been a woman.
 
 
 
Len
Freshman Silent
link   seeder  Len    12 years ago

From the seed:

A 2011 study at the Karolinska Institute in Sweden produced the most illuminating results yet regarding the transgendered, evidence that should give advocates pause. The long-term studyup to 30 yearsfollowed 324 people who had sex-reassignment surgery. The study revealed that beginning about 10 years after having the surgery, the transgendered began to experience increasing mental difficulties. Most shockingly, their suicide mortality rose almost 20-fold above the comparable nontransgender population. This disturbing result has as yet no explanation but probably reflects the growing sense of isolation reported by the aging transgendered after surgery. The high suicide rate certainly challenges the surgery prescription.

 
 

Who is online





104 visitors