Brat Voters Aren’t Anti-Semitic But The Media Sure Are Anti-Christian
On Tuesday, House Majority Leader Eric Cantor was defeated in his Republican primary by college economics professor David Brat. Cantors steak-house budget was actually $50,000 more than Brat spent on his entire successful campaign.
In his acceptance speech, Brat outlined his belief in six principles free markets, equal treatment under the law, fiscal responsibility, constitutional governance, peace through strong defense, and faith and strong moral fiber being necessary for the continuation of the Republic. Sounds pretty reasonable, no? Well, not to folks in most newsrooms, who lost their ever-living minds.
Nobody expected this upset. The vast majority of the media basically hadnt even heard Brats name before he unseated the Houses number two Republican. But that didnt stop them from almost immediately weighing in on what the election meant. Will you be surprised to learn that the media were pretty sure the election meant bad things for the G.O.P.?
1) Latent Super-Latent Anti-Semitism
One common theory proffered by media geniuses, from the New York Times to the New York Daily News to Politico , was that Republican voters in Virginias 7th District had suddenly developed a raging case of anti-semitism.
Im not joking. This was an actual theory that was treated as legitimate.
Keep in mind that Eric Cantor was first elected to Congress by these folks in 2000. They re-elected him six times. He lost this week by 10 points but just two years ago he won his primary by 58 points . Heck, hes been representing many of these voters since he was elected by them to the Virginia House of Delegates in 1992! But many political reporters are pretty sure that what made this election so different was good old-fashioned Jew hatred. A hatred that was for mysterious reasons latent for, what, 22 years? Will Antonin put it well:
And, verily, I say unto you: You shall elect a Jewish man for seven terms, but on the eight term, cast him from thine midst. #BookOfKoch
Will Antonin (@Will_Antonin) June 11, 2014
The general mood of the media in response to Brat winning was what we in my house-with-young-kids term unhinged temper tantrum, but no one showed that better than Reid Epstein, a former Politico reporter now at the Wall Street Journal who simply lost it. Embarrassingly so. Like, I imagine Eric Cantors most devoted and crushed staffers didnt embarrass themselves like this when they rented out the Tune Inn on Wednesday to drown their sorrows and play Creed (?) and Guns & Roses (!) on the juke box . John Podhoretz at Commentary notes, in his blog post An Appalling Cantor Meme :
Reid Epstein of the Wall Street Journal proffered his own version in this cute set of sentences: David Brat, the Virginia Republican who shocked House Majority Leader Eric Cantor Tuesday, wrote in 2011 that Hitlers rise could all happen again, quite easily. Mr. Brats remarks, in a 2011 issue of Interpretation: A Journal of Bible and Theology, came three years before he defeated the only Jewish Republican in Congress. How Brats invocation of Hitler relates to Cantors Judaism is not clear, but Epstein decided to link them, and the link is suggestive, and not in a good way.
Exactly. This is incoherent. Noting that Brat has a negative view of Hitler has what, exactly, to do with him unseating Cantor? Or is it that Brat was warning people that Hitler was not historys last monster? Thats a problem why? What in the h-e-double-hockey-sticks? There are many things political reporters should not do in public. Going full Godwin for all the world to see is probably one of them.
2) No, Really, Were Pretty Sure It Was The Jew Thing
As Podhoretz wrote :
Judaism had nothing to do with his loss, and the only reason for suggesting otherwise is to tar David Brat and the voters of the seventh congressional district in Virginia with the taint of anti-Semitism. Shameful.
It is absolutely reprehensible to throw about such slurs without even a smidgen of evidence and tons of evidence to debunk the charge and was even when it was just progressive activists pushing it. But the media kept at it. Perhaps my favorite example of this was Sheryl Gay Stolbergs Opponent Resonated With Christian Conservatives in a Way Cantor Could Not , in the New York Times. She wrote:
But analysts do say that Mr. Brat who has a divinity degree from Princeton Theological Seminary and often invokes God in his speeches appeals to Christian conservatives in a way that Mr. Cantor simply cannot Mr. Brat, a professor at Randolph-Macon College in Virginia, speaks often about a return to Judeo-Christian values and cites his belief in God.
Oh, you mean like Eric Cantor did here or like he did in this speech for which liberals mocked him? Or do you mean like Eric Cantor invoked God twice in the first paragraph of his remarks to Values Voters? Like that?
3) The Media Just Dont Get Religion
Its hard to pick a favorite example from various other temper tantrum throwers but Im going to go with Charles Pierce of Esquire . Take it away, Charles (emphasis mine):
As for the winner, Brat seems a very bad combination of serious religious quester and devout Randian economist, a combination that would have had Ms. Rand herself reaching for the opium pipe. He got his undergraduate degree at Hope College in Michigan, which is run by the Reformed Church in the United States, a conservative evangelical wing of the United Church Of Christ. He then got a Masters in Divinity at Princeton, which is a very conservative seminary and now, according to his website, Dave attends St. Marys Catholic Church with his wife Laura and their two children: Jonathan, 15 and Sophia, 11. So either hes a Douthatian convert, god help us, or his faith is all over the lot, which may account for his rather startling announcement last night that he won because God was speaking through the voters of the Seventh Congressional District of the Commonwealth of Virginia.
1) Its the Reformed Church in America , not the Reformed Church in the United States .
2) Theyre not conservative.
3) Theyre not the evangelical wing of the United Church of Christ. I mean, what does that even mean, in terms of church polity? They are in fellowship with various mainline church bodies such as the Presbyterian Church (USA), the Evangelical Lutheran Church in America and the United Church of Christ.
4) You couldnt call Princeton Theological Seminary, which is associated with the aforementioned PCUSA, conservative and you really couldnt call it very conservative. You couldnt even call it these things before the 1920s or 1930s, during the Modernist controversy that led to J. Gresham Machens departure. Are you insane?
But really, Charles, Im sure the rest of the article is totally worth paying attention to.
4) About God Working Through Means
After his victory, Dave Brat said :
God acts through people, and God acted through the people on my behalf. [] Were just celebrating like crazy tonight, just an unbelievable miracle.
Now, this is not really controversial for people who are familiar with Christian teaching regarding vocation as well as God working through means. In the course of telling us not to worry, Jesus talks about how God provides us with clothing. And we know that the means of that provision will typically be through other people (the seamstress, the tailor, the shop owner, the retail worker, etc.). The Christian knows the bread we eat comes from God and also that God uses the means of the baker (and other folks) to get it to us. So, as Brat puts it since hes a Christian, God acts through people. When he says that God acted through the voters to nominate him to this new office, thats just an acknowledgement that this blessing he just received came from God, using our political systems electoral means. Please note how Religion News Services senior news correspondent Cathy Lynn Grossman (previous noteworthy tweets here and here ) responded to this:
@hotelkeys @mollyesque Would that be the same God who acts through people whose people elected Obama when he carried Virginia? Cathy Lynn Grossman (@CLGrossman) June 11, 2014
Oh snap! Except that, you know, I have about zero doubt that Brats response would be, Yep! The same God! But other than that, she got him! Not that I really get why religion reporters would want to take such a hostile posture even when it didnt reveal their ignorance of the people and teachings theyre supposed to cover.
5) Its Brats Fault Were Confused About Princeton
Brat noted in his campaign bio that Daves journey led him to Princeton where he obtained a Masters in Divinity and on to American University where he earned a Ph.D. in Economics. That education has led him to a career serving the Commonwealth.
The media were pretty sure he was lying. See, they didnt know that there was a well known seminary called Princeton Theological Seminary. Princeton Theological Seminary and Princeton University have reciprocity and share campus space and usually some faculty but theyre separate institutions. A good example of the genre was the Washington Posts Brat didnt go to Princeton Univ. The story claims that Brat did biographical inflation and note that Princeton University says they have no record of him but they found out the real truth from, well, Brat and his totally public, easily available C.V. Excellent sleuthing there. Journalist Joshua Green, who says his father is a liberal theologian who spent time at Princeton Theological Seminary, wrote:
This @washingtonpost story on Dave Brat not really having a Princeton degree is utter hogwash http://t.co/X3hHc57pzv
Joshua Green (@JoshuaGreen) June 11, 2014
1) Princeton Theological Seminary is every bit as distinguished as Princeton University
Joshua Green (@JoshuaGreen) June 11, 2014
2) Brats masters of divinity *couldnt* have come from Princeton U because school doesnt offer that degree
Joshua Green (@JoshuaGreen) June 11, 2014
3) Good example of media ignorance re: religiona point drummed into my head for years by theologian dad
Joshua Green (@JoshuaGreen) June 11, 2014
who will be attending a Princeton Theological Seminary conference on Karl Barth this weekend, if anyones up for that
Joshua Green (@JoshuaGreen) June 11, 2014
Implicit in odd @washingtonpost attack on Brat is idea that theologians, seminarians cant be intellectual elite http://t.co/X3hHc57pzv
Joshua Green (@JoshuaGreen) June 11, 2014
6) Hes a Calvinist-Christian Reconstructionist-Catholic
On Brats web site , he says he attends St. Marys Catholic Church. But Times Elizabeth Dias says otherwise:
Everyone: Brat is not Catholic. He is a Calvinist.
Elizabeth Dias. (@elizabethjdias) June 11, 2014
A request for substantiation of this went unanswered . Dias did share her negative views of Brats writings on economics and religion. Others in the blogosphere are pretty sure hes a Christian Reconstructionist , something that mostly exists in the fever dreams of American reporters rather than in reality.
7) Bonus Tracks
This Huffington Post reporter was pushing out the Jewish angle as well as this one:
RT @Sandlapp : @aterkel @tanehisicoates @SamLachman Cantor lost to someone who quoted the New Testament in his acceptance speech.
Amanda Terkel (@aterkel) June 11, 2014
Indeed, Brat didnt just quote the New Testament but Jesus . Thats not even legal any more is it?
Great work, reporters. You didnt really shed much light on Dave Brat, free market economics professor, but you did reveal much about your treatment of politicians with religious views you dislike.
Tags
Who is online
104 visitors

Why is it that if you ore offended by a Christian making a comment about their belief you are considered liberal. But if you are offended by a Muslim making a comment about their belief you are considered racist? Seems a little hypocritical to me.
Well at least you would be Fair in that you would criticize each equally. But in reality, that is not the way it happens. Not in this country. Perhaps with Muslims people are afraid of deadly reprisals.
My question was not an attack on you. It was an honest question based on observation of the treatment of the two religions in this country.
Take a look at this short video;
...
Of course these folks were cleared of all charges stemming from this wrongful and unconstitutional arrest, but be honest now. Do you think there is any way that if these were Muslims reading the Koran that they would have been arrested in the first place?
John would never be offended by a Muslim making a comment about their belief, 96.
It's not any worse for a Christian to say, "G_d wanted me to win" than it is for a Muslim to say, "Allah wills it," yet I've never seen anyone comment about bad that sounds.
It's a catch-all phrase for Muslims regardless of what they do or say. If they make a statement about wiping Israel off the face of the planet... "Allah wills it." If they are talking about suicide bombers being killed along with innocent civilians... "Allah wills it."
There is nothing wrong with what Brat said; that is his belief, and there will be Christians all over the country who will believe he is delusional if they don't agree with Brat's agenda. You are making an attempt to derail the thread, John. This about the liberals and die-hard Cantor adherents claiming that an entire state is anti-Semitic... which is ridiculous.
Guess this question was too daunting to answer.
I didn't see him reading his rights. I guess they don't have to do that anymore.
Ever increasingly powerful government.
The fact is the man could preach on a street corner as the policeman said, but it is against the law to preach on government property. If he had stood on the adjoining property it would have been ok.
There is a war on Christianity and Judaism in this country and world. Some participate in this war by using humorous jokes and and some cut the heads off of them.
So, let me understand
Is it being stated that Republicans don't elect Jews to Congress because Republicans are largely anti-semitic?
In the last few days, I asked "why is there only one Jewish Republican in Congress," an indisputable fact I ASKED WHY THAT WAS I did not offer a reason or theory (for the record, I think Jonathan provided a plausible answer).
And in the article in which I asked the question, I specifically said that Cantor lost NOT because of his religion, NOT because (as I originally thought) that his opponent attacked him for being in favor of amnesty for illegal immigrants, RATHER BECAUSE THOSE VOTERS IN CANTOR'S DISTRICT WERE FED UP WITH HIS CONNECTIONS TO WALL STREET, AND, MOST OF ALL, HIS ELITIST-LIKE FAILURE TO BE ATTENTIVE TO HIS OWN CONSTITUENTS.
It apparently isn't even his opponent's Tea Party affiliation --
CANTOR'S LOSS, IMO, is the opening shot of AN ANTI-INCUMBENT WAVE, a REPUDIATION OF ONE OF THE MOST GLARING OBSTRUCTIONISTS IN A DO-NOTHING CONGRESS.
I believe any challenger would have defeated Cantor in the primary and that a Democrat (Trammel) will defeat the Tea Party candidate (Brat) in the election for the Virginia 7th District seat in the House in the November election.
The POPULIST SHIT-STORM IS UNDERWAY!
I don't know how you can continue with that A Mac, really.
The Jews comprise 2% of the United States population.
25% of the Jews live in New York.
Almost everyone of the rest of them live in the New England States and California.
And they have voted overwhelmingly Democrat for decades.
There just aren't enough of them in the Red States to have enough clout to win an election.
Are we suppose to vote based on religion now. I know you're going to say people voted for Dave Brat for religious reasons and some of that may be true, but it is only part of it. In today's world people will vote against you if you are a Christian, Jew or any other religion.
Have you ever won the lottery? Ever wondered why you haven't if that is the case?
Sorry A Mac, got a call and just thought you were back on the hate Jew thing, but I see you're onto something else. Now it is the guy who won wants smaller government, power back to the people, government by the laws of this country, free market,...... well just let him say it again.
You don't have a problem with that, do you?
He merely articulated what baseball players do when they reach home plate after a home run. They look to the sky, kiss their hands and reach up. When you watch a ballgame, do you curse under your breath when the batter does this? It's his prerogative. Brat just put it to words. He's a believer, and he was thanking his creator, modestly giving someone other than himself credit for his success.
What the fuck? Can't a guy just show his feelings without being labeled a freak?
I'm not continuing, Six; I indicated that I regard Jonathan's explanation as the most plausible one possible. Jewish voters for the most part and Jewish legislators as well, because they are a minority, like most minorities, are best served by liberal government and serve best as such as well.
How did you miss or misinterpret my comment? It's just above yours again
"Free Market" is a Tea Party/Republican buzz term for "no regulations" -- and the near collapse of the global economy in 2008 should be evidence enough that there must be regulations in the marketplace. Wall Street is enjoying the most prosperous time in history YET BITCH ABOUT REGULATIONS. The American tax payers bailed out their criminal asses. So, I'm against NOT, a "free market," rather what Brat really means, AN UNREGULATED MARKET GIVING ALL EDGES TO CORPORATIONS AND NONE TO THE CONSUMER.
"Equal treatment under the law" -- tell that to those being disenfranchised by voter suppression laws under the guise of Voter ID/Fraud where no evidence of fraud exists (that proven by a five year study conducted by the Bush Administration, et al).
"fiscal responsibility" -- can't have that without regulations
"constitutional governance" -- can't have that without the 4th and 14th Amendments
"peace through strong defense" -- that would be one component of peace, but not the only one
"faith and strong moral fiber being necessary for the continuation of the Republic" -- "attitude reflects management"
But I believe Calvinists tend to believe that successes in life is a sign of god's favor. Am I wrong? If brat is a catholic, he is obviously not a Calvinist.
They guy won a primary. He's not even a Congressman.
He has articulated his position in a clear and understandable manner. The voters know exactly what they will get if they elect him.
You can disagree with any percentage of his planks, but you really can't ask for much more in the way of straightforward talk, and dare I say honesty. But he's still not a Congressman. I think it's big of him to show all of his cards at this point.
I wasn't directly addressing your comment. More like the totality of the thread.
I do not know what denomination he is. I really don't know what the reward system is in any faith, other than my own.
I hope we're past that A Mac. It was my mistake. I didn't read your entire comment, received a call and then saw what I had written was incorrect in addressing your comment.
By the way with that buzz word..... Is it like when Ed Schultz said they show their contempt by being silent?
No problem at all.
BTW, fly fishing in the woods tomorrow and hoping for a few nice fish (catch and release of course) and some summer stream/lake/forest and sunset pix maybe even butterflies on Mountain Laurel.
Brat and his family belong to the Presbyterian Church , and yes, he does identify himself with Calvinism. Even more interesting are his views on the intersection of economics and Protestantism.
LOL... you're right, John, it was silly and uncalled for.
There just seem to be a lot of restrictions and criticisms of things that Christians do lately. There is a requirement that they separate their public lives from their faith; however, that requirement does not fall on Muslims.
I didn't say I didn't like it, John.
What I don't like is the bias against Christians that isn't shared by Muslims. I am not a Christian, but fair is fair.
Actually, it makes me cringe when a politician or any public servant brings G_d into the picture in any manner other than their private life. Most people who are very devout have a tendency to begin to believe that the deity speaks only to and through them, and it creates a messiah complex.
Also, some Christians are so fanatical about their interpretation of Biblical sayings they develop prejudices that are set in stone.
We can only hope A Mac is correct and this is an anti-incumbent wave.... ALL ACROSS THE BOARD IN BOTH PARTIES!
Once more, we agree.
The American electorate has the power to bring about term limits by voting out those who self-serve rather than serve!
The Bush regulators looked the other way during the Sub-Prime fiasco.
And Republicans have tried to end/weaken Dodd-Frank and many Democrats have looked the other way on that.
Bush Administration Ignored Warnings of Pending Financial Meltdown
So lemme get this straight, AMac,
GWB brought us into war in Iraq without a plan. No strategic plan, no exit plan. Obama takes the reigns, is not able to improve on the mess at all, and the fiasco of Iraq will always be Bush's fault, in spite of Obama's ineptitude.
----------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Bill Clinton, with HUD Secretary Cisneros move to fulfill the dream of maximum American homeownership by making rules and laws and capital very inviting for an entirely new strata of American. Over the next 8 years, the weight upon the GSEs gets heavier and heavier, and collapses with the financial meltdown, during the Bush Administration.
But that's Bush's fault too.
I call bullshit.
I call double standard.
I call politically polarizing nonsense.
Bush created a set of circumstances that defy "improvement," not the least of which is al Maliki.
It's like a massive forest fire set by an arsonist; the firefighters (new fire chief as well) must put out the fire but there will always be the reality that many of the "plants and animals" and some of the "geography" will be irreplaceable.
Bush lied to get it started, Wolfowitz told the military there would be no insurgency, the taking out of Sadaam destabilized the region -- resulting in an Iran that no longer has to deal with him.
Cheney said it would be a "slam dunk," the "Iraqi oil would pay for the war," "we'd be greeted as liberators," Rice warned us of a "mushroom cloud" --
You can't put the toothpaste back in the tube, Jonathan.
It was a moronic, insidious, egotistical, delusional, blood-money-profiteer plan.
And here's the most important perspective; not Obama, not anyone can bring back 4,400 dead American military personnel, 100,000 Iraqis nor un-ruin the countless lives Bush's lie-of-a-war has cost.
That's the real crime!
You indeed got it straight Jonathan.
There's a colloquial acronym for it.
FUBAR!
On the the sub-prime meltdown, as I posted, it could have been averted but Bush regulators and Bush failed to heed the warnings.
On the Home Ownership
Bush drive for home ownership fueled housing bubble
Those are my cases. You made yours, I made mine.
I'm willing to continue, or, call it "IMPASSE".
I think that what surprised me the most here is the magnitude of the defeat after 6 successful runs. How could the attitude of the voters have changed that much in so short a time?