The Rabbi Cardinal O’Connor Never Knew: His Grandfather -- NY Times, ALISON LEIGH COWAN, 6/10/2014
While the cardinal was well-known as a defender and friend of the Jewish people, he was apparently unaware that his mother was born Jewish, the daughter of a rabbi. Credit Fred R. Conrad/The New York Times
BRIDGEPORT, Conn. In his 16 years as the Catholic Churchs top official in New York, Cardinal John Joseph OConnor was a staunch friend and defender of the Jewish people.
He spoke often about what he had seen at Dachau as a Navy chaplain. He used his platform as head of the Archdiocese of New York to support Soviet Jewry, and played a role in the Vaticans recognition of the state of Israel. Mayor Edward I. Koch, a Bronx-born Jew who worked closely with the cardinal, proclaimed that he loved him like a brother.
Yet there was something Cardinal OConnor apparently never knew: His mother was born a Jew, the daughter of a rabbi.
MORE: http://www.nytimes.com/2014/06/11/nyregion/cardinal-john-joseph-oconnor-jewish-mother-genealogy.html?module=Search&mabReward=relbias%3Ar
Tags
Who is online
104 visitors

Fascinating story, Len. It's a shame thatCardinal OConnor never knew.
Very interesting.
Cardinal Lustiger was also Jewish and knew it; even more fascinating.
Len,
They are technically Jewish, by Jewish law, but in reality they are not... they are quite Catholic.
Of course!
But Hitler would have considered them Jewish and "treated" them as such.
But, if either had decided to return to Jewish practice, they would have been instantly accepted without a need to convert.
Cardinal Lustiger was certainly circumcised but Cardinal O'Conner would have needed to become so. If he was medically circumcised at birth he would have needed a ritual circumcision -- drawing a drop of blood.
It's true about Hitler...
I am not a fan of Jewish law about linage. It had purpose before there was DNA, but now I think that either parent should count, especially if you were raised in the faith.
Judaism is a family as much as a religion. This is why the title question is so important. Schiffman states that the principle of matrilineal descent is traceable to Deut. 7:3,4, and was in operation by Ezras time; the fifth century, B.C.E. (Ezra 9:2;10:2,3,11;Neh. 10:31;13:23,24).
At first glance this appears balanced. But Rashi explains otherwise.
Rashis interpretation of Deut. 7:4: For he will turn away your son from following Me i.e., the heathens son, if he marries your daughter, will turn away your [grand]son whom your daughter will bear to him, from following Me. This teaches us that your daughters son, born of a heathen man, is called your son, but your sons son, born of a heathen woman, is not called your son, but her son. For Scripture [first says, Do not give your daughter to his son, and do not take his daughter for your son. Then it follows with For he will turn away your son.... However], referring to do not take his daughter, it does not say For she will turn away your son... [because he is considered her son, not yours (Kid. 68b).
At the beginning of Christianity Jesus and virtually all the apostles were Jewish. The split that began Christianity did not come till later, when Paul relaxed the requirements for entering the [Jewish] family and pagans in huge numbers began to join without following the halakhic requirements for conversion; namely circumcision, immersion, and accepting the yoke of the Commandments.
In his book on the subject, Who Was a Jew, (Ktav Publishers). Prof. Lawrence Shiffman concludes: In retrospect, [the laws of matrilineal descent and conversion] maintained the identity of the Jewish people. Had the rabbis relaxed these standards, accepting either semi-proselytes or the earliest Christians into the Jewish people, Christians would quickly have become the majority within the expanded community of Israel. Judaism as we know it would have ceased to exist even before reaching its codification in the Mishna and the other great compilations of the tannaitic tradition. --- The ultimate parting of the ways for Judaism and Christianity took place when the adherents to Christianity no longer conformed to the halakhic definitions of a Jew.
The halakhic requirements result in some paradoxical situations, as liberal Jews are quick to note. A Jewishly born apostate is still considered Jewish (as in Jesus time), whereas an observant child of a non-Jewish mother is not. Such a child, understanding halakha and wishing to preserve unity in Judaism, can always undergo formal conversion. (For application of the Law of Return, Israel does not recognize apostates as Jews except in special circumstances.)
The Reform and Reconstructionist movements have changed the age-old requirements for reasons they believe to be equitible and just. In doing so, however, these movements are jeopardizing the unity of the Jewish people and, arguably, increasing the trend towards assimilation by reducing the necessity for spousal conversion. Rabbi Irving Greenberg has expressed concern that this situation may lead to two different Jewish peoples; that people from these groups will not intermarry.
When asked to reconsider his stand, Reforms Rabbi Alexander Schindler responded that he could not because the new system has been in effect for too many years. The response to Schindlers statement was along the lines, Then how do you expect [Conservative and Orthodox] Jews to reconsider a law that has been in effect for more than 2000 years?
Len,
I disagree with this and I don't see how it affects who is a Jew. If a person is raised as a Jew, lived their life as a Jew, then why make them any less of a Jew. It is actually insulting. But more so, DNA evidence has shown this. Ironically, most Jewish men y chromosome can follow a linage back two thousand years, most Jewish females mitochondrial DNA is full of non-Jewish lineage. So the idea that the female lineage is all that important , is not supported by science.
Science supports the idea of mth*'r F*%^ *rs ?
Hey this is an interesting theological discussion. Get with the program....
Hey you give nice g-d, Robert.
I respect your opinion but, ultimately, it depends on whether standards are necessary, and whether anyone can become a Jew just by declaring it in one sentence, as Muslims do.
A lot of gentiles call themselves "Messianic Jews" and worship the Trinity. They have Torahs and pray in Hebrew including the Sh'ma.Are they Jews?This is a reprise of what happened 2000 years ago, as I wrote. Should we have kicked the early Christians out of Judaism?
People want to convert to Judaism but ignore Jewish law completely. Should they be admitted?
According to Halakha a sinning Jew is still a Jew but should sinning gentiles be considered Jews just by their say-so?
Seems to be working OK for the Muslims. Not so good for the Jews.
And that is the ultimate fraud, pitched at mostly Jews. By definition, believing in Jesus, is what makes you not a Jew. The first Christians made that clear. They were Jewish Christians... Not Jews. The main difference is that Jews are clear of what they Messiahs job is, and it is totally different from what Christians believe, even Jewish Christians.
You tell me... what do you think happened to them?
Why would they bother if that is their attitude? Obviously highly unlikely.
But more so, you have diverted the discussion. That most Jewish woman are descendants of non Jewish woman.. hence why femail lineage idea is so irrelevant.
Again, being the Jews are so popular worldwide/sarc, why would a gentile say they are a Jew unless they behave and embrace Judaism. So I guess my answer would be yes, provided that they either have a parent that is Jewish or have converted of their own freewill.
Your thesis that this proves non-Jewish descent is a fallacy because conversion, Halakhic conversion, is perfectly legitimate. A convert is considered as if they were present at Sinai.
What you are proposing is accepting children of mothers who do not convert.
I have been debating missionaries on-line for over 20 years and am very familiar with their reasoning. I have met religious Messianics who keep kosher and observe the Sabbath. They resent being rejected from Judaism.
But Jesus is not the only difference between Jews and Christians. Christianity is a religion of faith whereas Judaismhas traditionally beena religion of law. Also, Christianity is simply a religion whereas Jewsare a "nation." A gentile (or born Christian)who does not believe in Jesus is not considered a Christian whereas a Jew who becomes a cardinal, or an atheist,is still considered a Jew.
You said you do not agree with this fact but it maintains the "belonging" ofConservative, Reform, and secular Jews as members of the Jewish nation. Otherwise each group could reject the others as bonafide Jews.
Rabbi Joseph Soleveitchik, ZTL, has written that the Jewish people is bound by covenant at two levels--the covenant of fate and the covenant of destiny. (also called the covenant of Egypt and the covenant of Sinai.) --- In the Holocaust all Jews learned that their fate was one. --- A Jew that shares this experience need not share any of the values or purposes of the Jewish people in order to be Jewish. The covenant of destiny however reflects chosen, voluntary existence for the purpose of the realization of Jewish values and Jewish purpose in history. --- Living out the covenant of destiny implies living a Jewish way of life, a search for Jewish expression in all areas of existence. Commitment to the covenant of destiny involves creation and development of the heritage -- not only preserving it. Thus the disagreements between groups can be understood as competition to realize the covenant as destiny.
Rabbi Soloveitchik ruled that Orthodox Jews share the covenant of fate with all Jews. Therefore they have all the obligations to other Jews -- not least to accept them -- that flow from such shared fate. While there are significant and fundamental disagreements over destiny and values, Soloveitchik suggests that these differences be argued out in the framework of shared community rather than rejecting the other as the enemy; someone outside the camp.
Rabbi Yitz Greenberg extends the model by suggesting that a movement is legitimate if it, and the Jews within it, chose the covenant of fate. This includes Conservative, Reconstructionist, Reform and even many secular Jews. It excludes such groups as Jews for Jesus, though they may be Jewish as individuals, because the group disassociates itself from Jewish fate by joining Christianity. This model paves the way for frank and thorough criticism - even devastating analyses and critiques - of the others practices or views without shaking the fundamental dimension of theirlegitimacy.
Len,
We don't know what the practices were 2000 or more years ago. Maybe some of the woman converted, maybe some didn't. But the bottom line is that their children considered themselves Jewish.
You seem to have lost track of what the discussion was. The Cardinal's mother was a Catholic by choice. Yet, he could be a Jew just because she was by what? Genes? Yet if his father was a Jew and not his mother, he would not be a Jew. The mother rule makes no sense. It goes on for generations of people who never even know that they are Jews. I know one such person, who found out that technically he's Jewish, but he was going to be a minister. I have a girlfriend who's mother is Jewish, her dad Italian, married 2 Italians and had two sons and baptised them. They are not Jews. On the other hand, I know families where the Dads are Jewish and raised their kids Jewish, had them bar Mitzvahed. They married Jews. They are Jews.
I think it's time for all denominations to get together and figure out what tenants they need to preserve to maintain and define the faith. But mother's line isn't it anymore.
I am basing my view on Halakha; age-old law.
Making it up as you go along is a cause of dissolution as more denominations appear and scatter apart rather than getting together. As it says in Judges, "In those days there was no king in Israel. Everyone did as he pleased."
Liberal rabbis invite Muslims into their synagogues for "dialogue" but never an Orthodox Jew.
Len,
May I point you to this:
It would seem that it is the Orthodox that have a problem with the rest of the Jewish community. Even in Israel, this is the case.
There are many Orthodox groups and they have different attitudes. Rabbi Soloveitchik was my rabbi's teacher and mentor.
I was not suggesting reconstitution of the defunct organization; merely of local contacts.My rabbiparticipated fully in apanel at Beth Sholom and attended a ceremony at the Reconstructionist Synagogue. He is completely open to dialog.
As are the other many synagogues, of all denominations, Len. And if there is ever to be a way to figure out these differences, that is the way it should be.
That's an easy one Robert.
Corinthians 3:11
For no one can lay any foundation other than the one already laid, which is Jesus Christ.
And
Matthew 16:18
And I tell you, you are Peter, and on this rock I will build my church, and the gates of hell shall not prevail against it.
In the Guide for the Perplexed, Part 1-Ch. 36, Maimonides wrote:
Even of [Jesus] who imagined that he was the Messiah but was put to death ... , Daniel had prophesied, as it is said, Also the children of the violent among your people shall lift themselves up to establish the vision; but they shall stumble (Dan. 9:14).
"Has there ever been a greater stumbling than this? For all the Prophets declared that the Messiah will be the deliverer of Israel..., gathering their dispersed and confirming their commandments. But [Jesus] caused Israel to perish by the sword, their remnant to be dispersed and humbled. He induced them to change the Torah and led the greater part of the world to err and serve another besides The Lord.
No human however is capable of fathoming the designs of the Creator for their ways are not His ways, neither are His thoughts their thoughts. All these events (relating to Jesus), and even those relating to [Muhammad], were nothing but a way of preparing the way for the King Messiah. It will reform the whole world to worship God with one accord; as it is said, For then I will make the peoples pure of language, so that they all invoke The Lord by name to serve Him with one accord (Zeph. 3:9).
"How can this be? The entire world has been filled with the doctrine of the Messiah, the Torah and the Mitzvoth (Commandments). The doctrines have been propagated to the distant isles and among many peoples, uncircumcised of heart and flesh. They discuss these subjects which contradict the Torah. Some declare that these Commandments were true, but are abrogated presently and have lost their force; while others assert that they are of mystical significance and have no simple meaning -- that the King has already arrived and revealed their hidden significance. But when the (true) king Messiah arrives and succeeds, is exalted and lifted up, they will immediately recant and acknowledge the falsity of their assertions.
In the Eighteenth Century, Jacob Emden was even more emphatic. The founder of Christianity conferred a double blessing on the world: on the one hand he strengthened the Torah of Moses, and emphasized its eternal applicability. On the other hand he bestowed favor on the pagans by removing idolatry from them, imposing upon them strict moral obligation. There are many Christians of high quality and excellent morals. Would that all Christians live in conformity with their precepts! They are not required, like Jews, to observe the law of Moses, nor do they sin in associating other beings with God in worshiping a triune God. They will receive a reward from God for having propagated a belief in Him among nations that never had heard His Name: for He looks into the heart.