A Young College Grad Calls My Show
Last week, on my radio talk show, I received a call from Jeff, a 21-year-old in North Carolina. I have abridged it and edited it stylistically.
JEFF: I wanted to respond to your question about America being feared in the world. You brought up Syria. I think its a little naive, and maybe thats not even the right word, to boil down such complex international issues into just good and bad. Like to say that America, for you, represents good. And to just boil down the Syria situation into good and bad is to underestimate the complexity of the situation. Because if the United States were to get involved there, you know, there might be consequences for us in that region that I think would be definitely more bad than good.
DP: Like what?
JEFF: If we were to depose Assad, there could be a power vacuum and that could create more problems than we intended.
DP: There are two separate questions here. One is: Should the United States be feared by bad regimes? The other is: What should the United States do? Theyre not identical. So lets deal with the first: Would you acknowledge that it would be good if countries like Putins Russia, Iran or North Korea though I dont compare Putin to North Korea feared us? And do you think they do?
JEFF: I think thats a really good question. If I had the answer to that I think Id be secretary of state.
DP: Its not that tough a question. What we should do is a tough question. But whether America should be feared by bad regimes is not a tough question.
Let me just throw in a tangential comment that I think is important: I presume you went to college.
JEFF: Oh, yeah.
DP: The reason I presume that you went to college is that you were taught and this is no knock on you whatsoever since anyone who takes liberal arts courses, in political science in particular, is taught what you just told me: You cant divide between good and bad, because its too complex.
But thats not accurate. There is a good and bad. Yes, sometimes there is bad and worse in Syria today, for example. But between Syria and the United States the difference is between bad and good. Would you agree that its between bad and good between Syria and the United States?
JEFF: As an American, absolutely.
DP: Wait a minute. Thats a terrible answer. I dont want you to answer me as an American. I want you to answer me as a moral human.
JEFF: I can only answer you as an American. I cant answer you as anyone else.
DP: Thats not true. If I asked you how much two and two is, you wouldnt answer me as an American.
JEFF: Heres my only comment, I would just, you know, hesitate to boil down international issues of such complexity, with multiple variables, to, Its simply good or bad. And thats my only comment.
DP: Thank you for calling.
What Jeff said is what I was taught at college. It is heartbreaking to hear how effective left-wing college indoctrination continues to be, with its morally obfuscating concepts such as too complex.
The morally obvious fact is that the United States is overwhelmingly a force for good both in the world and within its borders, and Syria is overwhelmingly a force for evil both in the world and within its borders. Yet, colleges have taught for at least two generations that such judgments are illegitimate.
If you want to judge whether Sweden or Denmark is better, thats complex. Or whether Iran or Syria is more evil. That, too, is complex. But between Denmark and Syria, there is no moral complexity.
The other revealing comment my caller made was that he could only say as an American that America was a better country than Syria.
This, too, reflects a fundamental left-wing doctrine taught at colleges that there are no moral truths, and we can only subjectively observe the world as members of a group. There are, therefore, black truths, white truths, rich truths, poor truths, male truths, female truths. Accordingly, for example, since men do not get pregnant, they cannot morally judge abortion.
To Jeffs credit, he listens to a radio show that so differs from what he was taught in college. There is therefore some hope that he will eventually realize how much nonsense he was taught at college. Dangerous nonsense.
Tags
Who is online
120 visitors

Good and bad is relative and very subjective. There is no straight answer especially when it is framed with this statement;
That opinion borders on sheer lunacy. In fact, Dennis Prager's ( The Dennis Prager Show ) question was so biasedly framed to to absolutely negate itself for intellectual discussion aside from posing a false dichotomy....like Bill O'Reilly does.
Where did you go to college?
When he says he can only speak "as an American" it almost seems as though he is afraid to give an opinion straight from his heart and will instead follow the popular course.
I would be more comfortable speaking for myself. It's a huge responsibility to speak "as an American," implying that most Americans feel the same about issues.
Don't know anything 'bout Bill, but I agree with what you're saying Aeon - there is no straight answer. Depending on the person questioned, their experiences, beliefs and culture - good and bad are two very distinctly subjective answers.
If you complete AeonPax's comment and put the entire theme of the article into her comment, I would have to say the United States is overwhelmingly a force for good in the world and within its borders compared to Syria as the statement is compared to it in the article. Many American's have fought for other people in other countries to relieve them of tyrants and I doubt you'll find many wars Syria has fought in other countries to free people. They've been known for supporting terrorism more than anything and whether you are American or any other freedom loving country you should be able to recognize that.
As an American do I think the United States has always been on the right side of history? No. If you look at the history of every other country in this world I don't think you could name one that has.
It's comforting for people to live in a world of black and white... I get that... makes thing's easy and direct...
Sadly, there is no such thing as a black and white life. I guess that makes me a left-wing college indoctrinated, morally bankrupt, jezebel?
Regardless, I do not look at a person and decide from what they did in the last 30 seconds everything about them. There are shades and nuances to every situation; some of which can be teased out through correlation and maybe used to determine causation.
Everything IS complex. If it wasn't we could easily group people in large swatches and call all white people this thing and all black people that thing; all women this and all menthat... but that ISNT true.
Even here on NT, the very second you assume and say something general about anyone, they almost always immediately take affront that you've generalized them. And that is true for everyone. That is true for individuals, groups, affiliations, countries, planets, and solar systems.
You cannot decide the ultimate right and wrong for everyone based on yourself. And you definitely can't make that decision "moral". You are not moral because you did everything the way you were taught... that isn't morality...
Morality is a societal stick and you cannot use your own stick to beatother people with.
In my opinion, the US has no right to beatit's stick into another country; end of story.The only way people will be happy with a revolution or a turn over of their government is if it is an internalstruggle.
Let's say in the distant future (or not so distant), the president becomes more and more autocratic and is making huge decisions on his/her own... government influence is rampant and people are living like it's 1984... in that instance I would NOT want another country (regardless of what utopia they have managed to find) come in and reform our government. I wouldn't care if their economy rained gold from the sky and they cured their hunger, energy and political strife... it's none of their business!! We would just trade one dictator for another... even if the alternative gave away food and money... it's still NOT HAPPENING.
I can't imagine the rage and indignation of people in Syria, Iraq, and countless other places in that region because the US can't keep their damn fingers out of the oil rig/cookie jar. Make no mistake, the so called freedom we spread there was not given freely, and it hasn't mean a pig's dick to any of the actual residents there.
So people can call me morally bankrupt... fine by me... I'm not the one acting like I know what is best for other people... it isn't my call.
Very nice, I really appreciate your comment Miss D!
There are some issues which are universal , among them the laws of supply and demand . People who are uneducated about this theory assume that it can't be applied everywhere and everywhen ... but they're wrong .
I understand what you are trying to say, Mike. At least I think I do.
As a moral human being I feel it is wrong to kill except in defense of yourself or someone else; and as a moral human being, I feel if you are going to kill someone you should be face-to-face with them in an acknowledgement that you know what you are doing and to whom you are doing it.
As an American.... let the drones fly, unmanned so as to save American servicemen, and while I don't want to see innocents killed along with the target, especially children, I will not advocate stopping drones from targeting the enemy and soullessly taking them out.
The 1st Barbary War ... aggression or justified self defense ?
Reeeeealy ? Do you have any idea of what the 1st Barbary War was about ? It looks like you pulled that info out of the air . But by all means lets see links to your sources ...
Barbary Wars :