╌>

White House Expected ‘Euphoria’ Over Bergdahl’s Release

  

Category:  News & Politics

Via:  pokermike  •  12 years ago  •  96 comments

White House Expected ‘Euphoria’ Over Bergdahl’s Release

MSNBCS Chuck Todd observed Tuesday that the White House was caught off guard by the disastrous public roll out of their prisoner exchange for Army Sergeant Bowe Bergdahl.

Todd and Andrea Mitchell agreed that the White House had likely thought there would be some euphoria around this, the only POW that was remaining in Afghanistan, that there would be a rally around the flag. That didnt happen.

They were expecting criticisms of Gitmo, criticisms of the detainees that were chosen, Todd said. They did not expect this criticism of the attempt to go get Bergdahl in the way that it was done.

Todd noted the White Houses change of tone over the last several days, using as an example a Pentagon spokesperson who defended Bergdahls rescue in the New York Times today by citing the Navys policy of rescuing sailors who go overboard, regardless of whether they fell out of the ship or jumped themselves. That wasnt necessarily what they were saying on Sunday.

http://freebeacon.com/national-security/chuck-todd-white-house-expected-euphoria-over-bergdahls-release/


Tags

jrDiscussion - desc
[]
 
pokermike
Freshman Silent
link   seeder  pokermike    12 years ago

Trading a probable deserter and possible enemy collaborator for 5 hard-core Taliban murderers, now who could possibly anticipate a problem with that?

 
 
 
pokermike
Freshman Silent
link   seeder  pokermike    12 years ago

On top of this whole fiasco, the President trots out the father with the Taliban beard and his own checkered past. He wasn't more than a few words into his statement before he came out with some Arabic version of Allahu Ackbar.

 
 
 
1ofmany
Sophomore Silent
link   1ofmany    12 years ago

There was euphoria . . . by the Taliban. I bet they were hurling turbans in the air and slapping hands over this one.

 
 
 
sixpick
Professor Quiet
link   sixpick    12 years ago

I hear they've been killing a lot of goats.

 
 
 
sixpick
Professor Quiet
link   sixpick    12 years ago

White House Expected Euphoria Over Bergdahls Release

Not at all pokermike, they did it for two reasons in my opinion. The first reason was to get the VA scandal off the front page and the second reason is it has become Obama's preferred method of closing Gitmo down. Pay attention to future prisoners released. I think Obama just put 2 or 3 on Burmuda. Now you say, how can he do that? I think the UK is wondering the same thing.

 
 
 
1stwarrior
Professor Participates
link   1stwarrior    12 years ago

So, as usual, the law he signed in December that says he can't do this without Congressional approval is another - "I did it my way." - sad.

 
 
 
Sean Treacy
Professor Principal
link   Sean Treacy    12 years ago
This reeks of desperation to get the va scandal off the front pages. This was the easiest way to gain some instant favorable coverage with a military angle as a bonus.

No doubt they assumed the mainstream media would carry the water on this as they have so many times in the past. Susan rice could talk up what a great soldier he was, and the media would play up the return of the lost hero angle. They assumed the research into his background would limited to the right wing internet sites, which they would dismiss with their usual cries of racism.

I think the White House is amazed that mainstream news sites have bothered to due their job.
 
 
 
pokermike
Freshman Silent
link   seeder  pokermike    12 years ago

Along with most everyone else, it appears the troops are not falling for the Administration's BS over this:

Hagel, visiting troops in Afghanistan, was met with silence when he told a group of them in a Bagram Air Field hangar: This is a happy day. We got one of our own back. It was unclear whether the absence of cheers and applause came from a reluctance to display emotion in front of the Pentagon chief or from any doubts among the troops about Bergdahl.

4154_discussions.jpg

 
 
 
A. Macarthur
Professor Guide
link   A. Macarthur    12 years ago

Trading a probable deserter and possible enemy collaborator for 5 hard-core Taliban murderers, now who could possibly anticipate a problem with that?

"Probable", "possible". That's definitive for a right-wing Obama-hater.

More right-wing scandal bullshit based on speculation for the sole purpose of playing the "Obama Scandal" game.

The ONLY WAY THE ACTIONS OF BERGDAHL CAN BE LEGITIMATELYDETERMINED IS VIA THE UNIFORM MILITARY CODE OF JUSTICE!

And the only way that happens is to follow the protocol WHICH CAN NOT HAPPEN UNLESS HE IS BROUGHT BACK, questioned, possibly indicted and tried.

Every fucking thing Republican scandal-mongers can throw to its legion of Obama-haters for campaign money has been and will be fair game.

And all under the bullshit lie they call "patriotism"!

A true patriot would insist that due process under the law precede judgment. I hate when someone pisses in my face and tells me "it's raining".

If one day one of you Benghazi, Birther, Deather, Fast-and-Furiouser, IRSer, etc. boys are tried in a kangaroo court, for once, I'll enjoy jury duty.

And I know in advance, no matter what the charge, you'll probably be guilty.

Possibly.

But WTF, because of your political persuasion, evidence or lack thereof, for me, will be irrelevant.

I don't know what Bergdahl did or did not do AND NEITHER DO ANY OF YOU. But I'd like to see an investigation Fox News, Ted Cruz and a bunch of yooze (you righties) would prefer a firing squad.

There are amendments other than NUMBER 2.

Hmmmmmm devotees of Number Two.

Poetic.

 
 
 
1stwarrior
Professor Participates
link   1stwarrior    12 years ago

OMG - two peas in a pod - and both of you probably think Marlowe wrote all of Shakespeare's plays and that Addison was actually Shadwell in disguise.

 
 
 
pat wilson
Professor Quiet
link   pat wilson    12 years ago

Like you, AMac, I'd like to see an investigation and I think we will. I really want to hear his story in his own words. This case is peculiar on many levels.

 
 
 
1stwarrior
Professor Participates
link   1stwarrior    12 years ago

And strange too Pat.

 
 
 
A. Macarthur
Professor Guide
link   A. Macarthur    12 years ago

two peas in a pod

That addresses not one of the points made about the Uniform Code and protocol and investigation, let alone satisfying the burden of proof for the endless allegations of "Obama scandals", none of which have gone anywhere legally and live on only in the Republican echo chambers.

If I had gone into an arbitration back in my career days with a pile of "probably" and "possibly" bullshit with no evidence to back my case, my client would have lost his/her appeal and my employer would have fired my ass the minute he read the transcript indicating how I embarrassed him and the organization I worked for.

Mocking me for laying out the way things work in the real world, and, for how "justice" is established through various due process criteria, is to show either an inability to make any viable counter point and/or to demonstrate the attendant frustration by scoffing the messenger.

If you want a discussion/debate, let's have one, otherwise, if you don't have the goods, appear on Fox or alongside the Darryl Issa or Ted Cruz or Lindsey Graham types, or, with some other empty can that bangs out non-verifiable cacophony for subjective haters.

One-liners and quips don't cut it in serious conversations.

 
 
 
A. Macarthur
Professor Guide
link   A. Macarthur    12 years ago

Pat,

The only people who don't want an investigation (on either side of the aisle) are those who fear what the truth may be.

 
 
 
Sean Treacy
Professor Principal
link   Sean Treacy    12 years ago
Congratulations, Mr. President! And identical congrats to your sorcerers apprentice, National Security Adviser Susan Rice. By trying to sell him as an American hero, youve turned a deserter already despised by soldiers in the know into quite possibly the most-hated individual soldier in the history of our military.

I have never witnessed such outrage from our troops.

Exhibit A: Ms. Rice. In one of the most tone-deaf statements in White House history (were making a lot of history here), the national-security advisor, on a Sunday talk show, described Bergdahl as having served with honor and distinction. Those serving in uniform and those of us who served previously were already stirred up, but that jaw-dropper drove us into jihad mode.

But pity Ms. Rice. Like the president she serves, shes a victim of her class. Nobody in the inner circle of Team Obama has served in uniform. It shows. That bit about serving with honor and distinction is the sort of perfunctory catch-phrase politicians briefly don as electoral armor. (At this point in your speech, maam, devote one sentence to how much you honor the troops.)

I actually believe that Ms. Rice was kind of sincere, in her spectacularly oblivious way. In the best Manchurian Candidate manner, she said what she had been programmed to say by her political culture, then she was blindsided by the firestorm she ignited by scratching two flinty words together. At least she didnt blame Bergdahls desertion on a video.

The president, too, appears stunned. He has so little understanding of (or interest in) the values and traditions of our troops that he and his advisers really believed that those in uniform would erupt into public joy at the news of Bergdahls release as D.C. frat kids did when Osama bin Ladens death was trumpeted.

Both President Obama and Ms. Rice seem to think that the crime of desertion in wartime is kind of like skipping class. They have no idea of how great a sin desertion in the face of the enemy is to those in our military. The only worse sin is to side actively with the enemy and kill your brothers in arms. This is not sleeping in on Monday morning and ducking Gender Studies 101.......
 
 
 
Sean Treacy
Professor Principal
link   Sean Treacy    12 years ago
This deserves highlighting:President Obama did this to himself (and to Bergdahl). This beautifully educated man, who never tires of letting us know how much smarter he is than the rest of us, never stopped to consider that our troops and their families might have been offended by their commander-in-chief staging a love-fest at the White House to celebrate trading five top terrorists for one deserter and featuring not the families of those soldiers (at least six of them) who died in the efforts to find and free Bergdahl, but, instead, giving a starring role on the international stage to Pa Taliban, parent of a deserter and a creature of dubious sympathies (that beard on pops aint a tribute to ZZ Top). How do you say outrageous insult to our vets in Pashto?
 
 
 
A. Macarthur
Professor Guide
link   A. Macarthur    12 years ago

And in the absence of an investigation with transparency, none of the demagoguery means dick!

The National Review is as biased a right-wing rag as is any left-wing rag.

Piling-on, partisan editorial commentary only undermines the credibility of those "righteously indignant" hypocrites who declare in the absence of a satisfied burden of proof, the motives and outcomes of everyone (on all sides but their own).

Both President Obama and Ms. Rice seem to think that the crime of desertion in wartime is kind of like skipping class. They have no idea of how great a sin desertion in the face of the enemy is to those in our military.

You don't know that desertion occurred; what captive under such circumstances wouldn't say what his captors told him to say? Until you and all the other scandal-mongers call for an investigation and full disclosure in a transparent venue, you're just Issa-clones.

 
 
 
pat wilson
Professor Quiet
link   pat wilson    12 years ago

yes and peculiar.

 
 
 
pat wilson
Professor Quiet
link   pat wilson    12 years ago

I haven't heard of anyone not wanting an investigation. Right now I think everyone does.

 
 
 
sixpick
Professor Quiet
link   sixpick    12 years ago

First and most important is we are obligated by oath to bring Bergdahl home to the USA.

It is pretty obvious he is guilty of desertion based on listening to several members of his platoon saying he willingly walked off with a canteen and a compass leaving his weapon and everything else behind. Also in the search for him it was noted people said there was a American soldier asking where he could find the Taliban. He isn't convicted, but there sure are a lot of people saying things that would indicate he is guilty. I really hate it for all who have died if he is from his actions, Bergdahl, the military personnel, and the American citizens.

He was suppose to get with Congress about his actions and he didn't. If he didn't want to follow the law he accepted, then he should have vetoed it instead of signing it.

And also he is aware he broke the law, because he said not contacting Congress was just an oversight. Now if you can believe that, I want go any further on that issue.

Bergdahl will be go to trial on accusations for treason hopefully once in the USA and able to do so. Everyone is not blessed with the strength necessary to be a soldier and other mental disabilities can change a strong person into a coward and a weak person into a hero.

Bergdahl was the only POW, not the last since the war started in 2001 as far as I can see.

Six people died searching for him and I have to say I feel a great deal of sympathy for them.

Even Senator Feinstein, who I usually disagree with said it came as a surprise, no consultation and said Obama didn't follow the law. I don't need info on Bush or anyone else. This is an entirely different situation and can not be compared to any past events.

As I said under obligation of oath we had to do all we could to bring him home, but Obama has this bad habit of thinking he is Emperor of the United States.

No offense, but if anyone can't say Obama has been caught in more lies than any other president this country has ever experience or is doing his best to run this country somewhat like Chevez ran Venezuela that person is suffering from blind faith.

What bothers me is there is a real MARINE in prison in Mexico and Obama could get him out if he would, but he hasn't. Obama hasn't done anything but aid our enemies and shun our allies since he has been in office. Everyone knows how I feel about him. You can call me an Obama hater but the fact is he just makes me sick because with the aid of the media and his minions he has been able to fool so many for far too long.

 
 
 
Spikegary
Junior Quiet
link   Spikegary    12 years ago

Knowing a little of how these things work, I doubt that this happened that fast to cover the scandal. I'm sure there have been back door discussions going on for quite a while about this. The government kept the faith and brought home this member of the service. How he became a POW, whether by accident, on purpose or by just plain stupidity will be discovered by those debriefing him. I hope that he will face whatever justice he should face when it's all said and done.

 
 
 
Spikegary
Junior Quiet
link   Spikegary    12 years ago

Good stuff 1st! Thta got my early morning smile going!

 
 
 
Spikegary
Junior Quiet
link   Spikegary    12 years ago

Kind of like blaming an embassy attack on an unknown piece of crap anti-muslim film? She deserves to be rewarded for being the designatedwhippin' mulefor the administration.

 
 
 
1stwarrior
Professor Participates
link   1stwarrior    12 years ago

And of course his letter saying he's leaving 'cause his country sux means ?????

 
 
 
A. Macarthur
Professor Guide
link   A. Macarthur    12 years ago

I haven't heard of anyone not wanting an investigation. Right now I think everyone does.

Wanting an investigation and following protocol, is proper and sound thinking; but "convicting" in one's mind based on, rather than evidence, weak-ass pap like the individual "probably," "possibly," and/or "is most likely" guilty, that in order to satisfy and promote a political agenda, is dangerous.

The Obama-haters don't want an outcome based on truth or proof, they want any outcome they can use to play the Obama-Scandal game. These are the faux-patriots who want to "water the tree of liberty" by pissing on the parts of the Constitution that don't suit their purpose and apotheosizing the parts the do.

It has been and continues to be the "I hope he fails" crowd -- the bumper sticker ideologues who wish everything bad for America in order to make Obama look bad.

Hateful and stupid

" Cutting off the nose to spite the face " --

Disadvantage yourself in order to do harm to an adversary.

 
 
 
A. Macarthur
Professor Guide
link   A. Macarthur    12 years ago

Kind of like blaming an embassy attack on an unknown piece of crap anti-muslim film? She deserves to be rewarded for being the designatedwhippin' mulefor the administration.

Kind of like playing the "Benghazi/birther/deather/Fast-and-Furious/IRS/" and other cards, none of which became part of a winning hand, but only because
of the failure to satisfy that little requirement regarding the burden of PROOF.
Details ain't they a pain in the ass?
 
 
 
Spikegary
Junior Quiet
link   Spikegary    12 years ago

And I'm sure they have and will be interviewed and their stories will also be put into the record. No military lawyer is interested in taking this guy to the court room without iron clad evidence in the bag, what is called due dilligence.

Personally, I think this guy is guilty as hell and deserves to go to jail, but my opinion means nothing in this case.

 
 
 
A. Macarthur
Professor Guide
link   A. Macarthur    12 years ago

Personally, I think this guy is guilty as hell and deserves to go to jail, but my opinion means nothing in this case.

Finally a lucid, honest statement.

FYI

846. ARTICLE 46. Opportunity to obtain witnesses and other evidence

by admin on Jul.22, 2010, under 07. Trial Procedure

The trial counsel, the defense counsel, and the court-martial shall have equal opportunity to obtain witnesses and other evidence in accordance with such regulations as the President may prescribe. Process issued in court-martial cases to compel witnesses to appear and testify and to compel the production of other evidence shall be similar to that which courts of the United States having criminal jurisdiction may lawfully issue and shall run to any part of the United States, or the Commonwealths and possessions.

 
 
 
1ofmany
Sophomore Silent
link   1ofmany    12 years ago

The trial counsel, the defense counsel, and the court-martial shall have equal opportunity to obtain witnesses and other evidence in accordance with such regulations as the President may prescribe. Process issued in court-martial cases to compel witnesses to appear and testify and to compel the production of other evidence shall be similar to . . .

They may have an equal opportunity to obtain evidence itself may not be may be heavily weighted to one side. For instance, a number of soldiers are coming forward with very damning statements saying that the only possible explanation for Bergdahl's behavior is that he was captured while deserting. But we haven't heard Bergdahl's side of the story yet.

 
 
 
Petey Coober
Freshman Silent
link   Petey Coober    12 years ago

...
"One of the reasons he joined [the army] was to go and help and he believed in what we were doing to help Afghan people,"

Holy crap ! He joined the army to help people ... That is one confused lad . And of all the people to help ... Afghanis . More confusion .

 
 
 
1ofmany
Sophomore Silent
link   1ofmany    12 years ago

Troops don't comment on policy, and frankly their opinions in this matter are completely beside the point. Hagel wasn't seeking a referendum on Bowe's suitability as a soldier, he was sending the message to each soldier in the room that the USA will get you back. Even if you are a deserter.

Perhaps silence was their own message back to Hagel . . . "thanks for nothing."

 
 
 
Petey Coober
Freshman Silent
link   Petey Coober    12 years ago

The sound of silence ?

 
 
 
A. Macarthur
Professor Guide
link   A. Macarthur    12 years ago

Holy crap ! He joined the army to help people ... That is one confused lad.

Petey, perhaps you will recall that Dick Cheney et al in the Bush Administration (and its shills), once the WMD bullshit was outed, the Saddam Hussein and al - Qaeda connection was outed went with the "We will be greeted as liberators in Iraq and will be met in the streets with candy and flowers" bullshit.

Again, we do not know what Bergdahl's story is; that's why there needs to be an investigation.

Once more, selective indignation.

 
 
 
A. Macarthur
Professor Guide
link   A. Macarthur    12 years ago

Along with most everyone else, it appears the troops are not falling for the Administration's BS over this:

Did you read that on their faces in the photo, or, did you simply read their minds by placing your forehead against the photo.

What color underwear did Hagel have on while making his presentation?

Oh, what are Friday's Mega Millions Jackpot numbers -- I'm off to purchase a ticket.

One more thing

Gimme a break.

 
 
 
A. Macarthur
Professor Guide
link   A. Macarthur    12 years ago

Really AMAC, you've always specialized in one liners so before you call out others proceed to the nearest mirror and enjoy the reflection of hypocrisy!

The difference is that my one-liners are directly related to those they address, and, are specifically in conjunction with the content of those they address.

If a comment is foolish or unfounded on its face, it gets an editorial one-liner in return; think of it as "victim-provoked".

We enjoyed the same self righteous holier than thou attitude on News vine and thank you for demonstrating that here as well.

Flattering to have such a devoted follower as yourself.

BTW this is an insult with truth.......You sir are a tool!

I suspect you spend a lot of time with tools I ask with all due respect if you have them monogrammed.

If you are going to call out others, check your most recent posts. My advice is to stay away from quips if you plan on criticizing others for them.

Sincerely,

The hypocrisy Interventionist!

Since you're the self-appointed expert, go back and see if any of my insult/quips are made in the absence of context, or, if they generally, if not invariably follow the block-quoted, inaccurate, nonsensical and/or ill/uniformed statements to which they refer.

Editorial commentary, including sarcasm and satire are accepted forms of journalism.

Further, one of Newton's Laws of Motion can be applied to social, political and other circumstances, namely, for every action, there is an equal and opposite reaction.

My one-liners and quips are never stand-alones; the comments/quips you cited are quite aptly-placed bits of sarcasm.

If you require them explained, perhaps you are not the interventionist you deem yourself qualified to be.

And, if this forum were a hockey game, you'd be penalized for being the "third-man-in".

My quip regarding the photo of Hagel and the troops came in response to the comments that appeared above it, namely

Along with most everyone else, it appears the troops are not falling for the Administration's BS over this:

Hagel, visiting troops in Afghanistan, was met with silence when he told a group of them in a Bagram Air Field hangar: This is a happy day. We got one of our own back. It was unclear whether the absence of cheers and applause came from a reluctance to display emotion in front of the Pentagon chief or from any doubts among the troops about Bergdahl.

Note the first comment editorial in nature and, coming from a source that is consistently Obama-bashing. The second comment attempts to validate the first, and how - by reading faces, minds?

Address the explanation for my commentary, not the fact that I made it and you don't like it.

As for "tools," if you're going to be a critic in a journalistic setting, your tool box may be a bit light.

You have mocked me on several occasions while in the process, adding nothing in the way of point-counter-point rebuttal. As far as I understand, you're an expert in on personal defense -- I respect that and therefore expect that you will thus respect my ability to defend myself when attacked.

Hey, that makes us kindred spirits!

Finally, my comment/quip regarding the 2nd Amendment was an editorial comment directed at those who regard that Amendment as "written in stone," eternally inalterable, that despite the Constitution's inclusion of methods to change itself, AND, TO THOSE WHO ARE SELECTIVELY WILLING TO IGNORE OTHER AMENDMENTS, THOSE THAT DON'T SUIT THEIR AGENDA (in this thread, with regard to "Presumption of Innocence" and Bergdahl).

There are those herein who have him "guilty" based on "hearsay," "probability," "possibility," "most likely," -- but not based on investigation, indictment, trial and verdict. And I dare say, those to whom I refer are "strict constructionists" when it comes to the 2nd Amendment.

I never duck a question, BF, and I never take a position without giving the specifics as to why.

 
 
 
1ofmany
Sophomore Silent
link   1ofmany    12 years ago

I'm indignant about what the Bush administration did and I'm indignant about what the Obama administration does. If you're only indignant about Bush's actions, then who's actually being selective here? Obama has never designated detainees as POWs and, in fact,has argued just the opposite. Therefore, our leaving Afghanistan does not trigger the need to immediately release them. Obama said that Bergdahl's health was in danger. However, he was simply undernourished (as opposed to malnourished). Obama said that he would not release detainees unless the threat they posed could be mitigated. If he has a plan for mitigation, then I have yet to hear it. Compounding all of this is the allegation that Bergdahl is a deserter. Whether he's a deserter or not, why do these circumstances warrant Obama ignoring the law?

 
 
 
A. Macarthur
Professor Guide
link   A. Macarthur    12 years ago

Whether he's a deserter or not, why do these circumstances warrant Obama ignoring the law?

Once again; I am neither defending nor ignoring the violation of a law; I have asked several times now

1) If the use of a signing statement/executive order is a violation of law, why have other President's been able to do so with impunity, and

2) Why are those who accuse Obama of doing so, just now coming to the table with their indignation AS IF HE WERE THE FIRST AND ONLY PRESIDENT TO PROCEED THUS?

Selective allegation and selective indignation.

I have been consistent with this.

I have also questioned the willingness of those who defend unwaveringly, some parts of the Constitution while showing no regard, even disdain for others if it does not suit their agenda -- and I have stipulated which Amendments and which ideologues are at issue.

I get questions about my questions but not attempts to answer them.

 
 
 
Miss_Construed
Freshman Silent
link   Miss_Construed    12 years ago

When so many troops have said the same thing about this moron its most likely true.

No sarcasm... pure honesty.

I hope this never happens to you.

 
 
 
Miss_Construed
Freshman Silent
link   Miss_Construed    12 years ago

I dont think the negotiation of 5 to 1 was well done by any means. And it seems to lead me down conspiracy alley (as I've said)...

But this vehemence against this guy is absolutely abysmal. And to drag his father into it...

This is truly dirty reporting.

If the guy deserted or otherwise acted the fool, let him get here and defend his actions. He's still an American soldier and worth being retrieved from enemy hands. Just because my price on him is lower than the administration and I disagreed with the administration's tactics doesnt mean he is worth nothing. Some of the comments here are just pure vitriol.

I would hope that in this country we are still entitled to our fair shake in court one day for a mistake/charges and don't end up having ourselves and our family crucified by what amounts to a rumor mill.

This situation went really sour, really quick.

 
 
 
Miss_Construed
Freshman Silent
link   Miss_Construed    12 years ago

What bothers me is there is a real MARINE in prison in Mexico and Obama could get him out if he would, but he hasn't. Obama hasn't done anything but aid our enemies and shun our allies since he has been in office. Everyone knows how I feel about him. You can call me an Obama hater but the fact is he just makes me sick because with the aid of the media and his minions he has been able to fool so many for far too long.

Well it took five years to get Bergdahl back... the marine has only been in Mexico for a month. The government moves too damn slow.

Hopefully there is some negotiation for the marine going on and he will be expedited quickly and for less cost than 5 terrorist prisoners in exchange.

 
 
 
1ofmany
Sophomore Silent
link   1ofmany    12 years ago

I have no idea to whom these questions are addressedso I take themas rhetorical since I don't happen to hold the views on which the questions are premised.

 
 
 
A. Macarthur
Professor Guide
link   A. Macarthur    12 years ago

I have no idea to whom these questions are addressedso I take themas rhetorical since I don't happen to hold the views on which the questions are premised.

They have been addressed throughout the thread primarily in response to those who have failed to question why one President's use of the Executive Order/Signing Statement is a violation of law but none of the many others' are apparently not.

I'm glad you do not hold the views on which my questions are predicated; nevertheless, others do manifest the myopia and selective indignation about which they inquire.

 
 
 
A. Macarthur
Professor Guide
link   A. Macarthur    12 years ago

A shot in the dark AMac.......because Obama is the current one in the WH. The others are history... Just a guess to answer your question. I could be wrong.

The particular practice of Presidents using Executive Orders/Signing Statements is not new I'd like to know why Obama's use of the Executive Order (a Presidential option which began as an act of Congress), is being questioned, and, called a "violation of the law" by some in this thread, BUT NOT THE QUESTION REGARDING THE PROPRIETY AND VIABILITY OF THE EXECUTIVE ORDER ITSELF.

Actually, I know why I'm just watering the Tree of Liberty with a couple of juicy questions. It ain't about the love of law, it's about the dislike of Obama.

 
 
 
1ofmany
Sophomore Silent
link   1ofmany    12 years ago

I just want to point something out here. The outrage over Bergdahl is coming primarily from other soldiers who view him as a deserter/traitor and who resent the fact that other soldiers died trying to retrieve him. They also resent trading himfor 5 Taliban commanders who can ultimately orchestrate their deaths. They don't pretend to be impartial and they don't have to be because they're not on a jury. They also have information that you may not and will put more trust in each other than you may think iswarranted.This is not atypical of a civil setting. If your daughter said that a man broke into the house and raped her, you would likely believe it to be true and wouldn't need (or want) to hear anything the alleged rapisthad to say. However, you would not be on the jury nor would any other family member because you are all biased. That goes for your friends, her friends, and even other women who have been raped. The press is not a court and the general public is not a jury. Everybody can say whatever they want but should bear in mind that Bergdahl hasn't given his side of the story yet.

 
 
 
Miss_Construed
Freshman Silent
link   Miss_Construed    12 years ago

I get that.

What I dont get is attacking his father for his beard. Or deliberately making him out to be sided with the enemy without giving due process.

Yes the media can say what they want, but they should be held accountable for acting like complete asses and saying such horrible things about someone as off the cuff commentary. Until consumers who watch this drivel step out of the rumor mill mentality, the news commentators are going to eat this shit up and serve it over and over for us all to wallow in.

It's a sad situation and a definite comment on the current society.

Attack the decision, don't hang the man without trial.

 
 
 
1ofmany
Sophomore Silent
link   1ofmany    12 years ago

It's not for the political hell of it. It is a kneejerk reaction every time there is the slightest controversy involving an action of President Barack Obama. A good percentage of the political right hate him , many of those because he is black and/or because he went to an radical black church for a number of years . . .

The outrage came primarily from other soldiers. Are they all right wing bigots who are just trying to trip Obama up because he's black?

In a sane country, this prisoner exchange would be a page 4 story in the newspapers and worth about one minute on the nightly news.

In a sane country, the President would follow the law and the defense to criticism wouldn't be "they just hate me because I'm black."

 
 
 
1ofmany
Sophomore Silent
link   1ofmany    12 years ago

I agree that the press leaves a lot to be desired. Instead of investigative reporting they tend toward superficial national enquirer type commentary. The only way tocorrect that is to educate ourselves and each other on the facts. So keep talking.

 
 
 
1ofmany
Sophomore Silent
link   1ofmany    12 years ago

The reason they're not POWs is that both Bush and Obama have refused to designate them as such. Anyway, what difference does it make whether they were involved in terrorist activities outside Afghanistan? Are you suggesting that they pose no risk because their future activities are limited by past behavior?

 
 
 
A. Macarthur
Professor Guide
link   A. Macarthur    12 years ago

if Bergdahl was a deserter or not, this was NOT a POW exchange, the 5 in GITMO were not given POW status.

When someone has a vow to destroy America and Americans they are terrorists.

IF!

We don't know that yet! There has been no formal investigation, no indictment, no trial, no conviction. Bergdahl, may be guilty of what is currently "hearsay," but in America, we begin with the "presumption of innocence" not "innocence until charged." And allegations must satisfy a "burden of proof".

Obama broke the law and yet his foot kissers say it is ok.

As for breaking the law, I ask you too, dennis, when did an Executive Order became a violation of the law? Did it just become illegal since Obama took office? "Foot kissers" as you see it, "haters" as I see it.

Fiat justitia ruat caelum

None of the so-called "Obama Scandals" have gone anywhere because the so-called "investigations" have been political theater (Isaa doesn't allow witnesses to testify if they do not corroborate his allegations).

Expecting evidence rather than unproven allegations as a protocol on behalf of the accused, isn't "foot kissing," it's the American System of Justice."

 
 
 
A. Macarthur
Professor Guide
link   A. Macarthur    12 years ago

Does a criminal act cease to have happened because the perpetrator has left the crime scene and time has passed?

Are the victims of crimes un-victimized because they were victims last week?

If Obama's use of an Executive Order is a violation of the law, were all of the others I bothered to link for you?

Can you just imagine a defense attorney begin a case with the request

"Your Honor, the defendant, my client, allegedly committed a crime, allegedly broke a law months ago.

Let's get over it and live in today."

You did not answer my questions; you gave a canned rationalization as to why you and the others won't answer them.

If Obama broke a law that other Presidents broke literally hundreds of times, why is it that we're not questioning why that is?

staredecisis|ste()r dissis|nounLaw

thelegalprincipleof determining pointsinlitigation according toprecedent.

ORIGINLatin, literallystand by things decided.

 
 
 
Sean Treacy
Professor Principal
link   Sean Treacy    12 years ago
is a kneejerk reaction every time there is the slightest controversy involving an action of President Barack Obama.Physician, heal thyself...
 
 
 
Sean Treacy
Professor Principal
link   Sean Treacy    12 years ago
None of the Obama scandals have gone anywhere...

Obama is Teflon. Just look at his approval ratings over the last year. He's a rock star. Democrats are fighting to have him campaign for them. Or not.

Just today a poll was released in which the American people believe that the George w. Bush administration was more competent than the Obama administration. Can't get much lower than that.
But those scandals are meaningless because Obama hasn't been impeached, yet. Put him on Mount Rushmore, he's yet to be convicted of a high crime!
 
 
 
1stwarrior
Professor Participates
link   1stwarrior    12 years ago

What Executive Order A. Mac???

 
 
 
1stwarrior
Professor Participates
link   1stwarrior    12 years ago

"is so that Obama could be attacked"

OMG John - why don't you just ask him if you can move in????

 
 
 
1stwarrior
Professor Participates
link   1stwarrior    12 years ago

Seriously? Probably didn't see them. I'll look a little closer Grin.gif

 
 
 
A. Macarthur
Professor Guide
link   A. Macarthur    12 years ago

"What Executive Order A. Mac???"

I have throughout this thread referenced Executive Orders/Signing Statements and other extensions of Presidential authority, Obama NOT THE FIRST AND ONLY PRESIDENT TO USE THEM, and, not nearly as often as some of his predecessors.

Has he been hypocritical in denouncing their use in the past, only to use them himself once taking office I think so; but that's not the issue here. The issue is whether or not he violated a law.

Once again, we're questioning my questions but not answering them.

________________________________________

Signing statements and Sgt. Bergdahl

Among the various disputes over the negotiated release of prisoner-of-war Sgt. Bowe Bergdahl is the interesting shift in theObama administrations justification of its executive powers and its denial that is doing so.

From the beginning of his term, President Obama sought to move away from the claims of inherent presidential powers which marked much of the George W. Bush administrations logic underpinning its unilateralism, to one derived from statutory authority granted by Congress. That is, he argued that he could act because Congress said he could act, rather than from a notion of presidential prerogative.

Now, this was easier for Obama, of course, because of the various extensions of that statutory authority not least the Military Commissions Act, the FISA Amendments Act and the reauthorization of the Patriot Act passed during the Bush administration (some with then-Sen. Obamas support).

Further, at least one of the crucial statutes underpinning the presidentsdiscretionary powers over the past decade,the September 2001 Authorization for the Use of Military Force (AUMF) , is immensely broad, and critics efforts to amend it have failed to gain traction.

 
 
 
Sean Treacy
Professor Principal
link   Sean Treacy    12 years ago
I'm curious about the executive order as well....no,mention of an executive order that I've seen... Signing statements are not executive orders.
 
 
 
A. Macarthur
Professor Guide
link   A. Macarthur    12 years ago

I'm curious about the executive order as well....no,mention of an executive order that I've seen... Signing statements are not executive orders.

I have used several terms throughout denoting extensions of Presidential authority. That's what Obama used rather than getting Congressional approval.

You can split hairs with me but the question still remains, "Did Obama break the law in transferring prisoners by going around Congress?"

I've cited four different ways he could do it without breaking the law.

If you still care to argue that point, I'll again cite the extensions available to a President.

 
 
 
Sean Treacy
Professor Principal
link   Sean Treacy    12 years ago
Executive orders are not the issue. Signing statements are. Just a few years ago, democrats believed the use signing statements were an impeachable offense. A quick google search can find hundreds of articles clambering for bush's impeachment. Yet democrats don't care when Obama does it.Clearly, the only explanation is democrats hated george bush because he was white.
 
 
 
1ofmany
Sophomore Silent
link   1ofmany    12 years ago

If you don't see why the fact that their past activities were confined to Afghanistan is relevant I am probably out of answers for you.

If you convey reasoning through an osmotic process then I agree you have no answers for me.

 
 
 
A. Macarthur
Professor Guide
link   A. Macarthur    12 years ago

My comment is not about executive orders, it is that Obama broke the law by not letting Congress know in the required 30 day period. Even many Dems are furious about that.

No, dennis, he did not. I have in this thread cited four different extensions of Presidential authority by which Obama could get around Congress.

If you want, I will list them again.

A good day to you as well my friend.

 
 
 
A. Macarthur
Professor Guide
link   A. Macarthur    12 years ago

Executive orders are not the issue. Signing statements are. Just a few years ago, democrats believed the use signing statements were an impeachable offense.

I have several times in this thread stated that I find it hypocritical, but MORE CLEARLY, regardless of who believed what, hypocrisy and acting illegally are not synonymous.

Obama had at least four options regarding Bergdahl, none of which led to the impeachment of any President.

As for hating Bush, you and the other Obama-bashers have no room to talk. I'd be more than happy to post the volumes of events, dates, videos, testimonies, etc. regarding Bush "indiscretions."

 
 
 
A. Macarthur
Professor Guide
link   A. Macarthur    12 years ago

Nice double talk but no cigar. all those are still in the past, get over it and live in the now. Its just what democrats throw up when they cant justify their comments.

It's only double talk to those unaware of, or, unable to grasp analogous circumstances.

Adjudication is most often predicated on precedent and case law; we don't "get over" those precedents and re-write the or disregard those precedents.

You can demagogue Democrats but you can't avoid reality (unless your a posteriori "knowledge" is derived from Fox News, Ted Cruz or bumper stickers).

" Whats past is prologue " _ Shakespeare

The phrase means that history influences and sets the context for the present. The quotation is engraved on the National Archives Building in Washington, D.C. [ 1 ]

 
 
 
1ofmany
Sophomore Silent
link   1ofmany    12 years ago

If Obama's use of an Executive Order is a violation of the law, were all of the others I bothered to link for you?

A MAC -- I'm having some difficulty following your line of reasoning perhaps because it's premised on an implicit assumption that iscontrary to mine. Executive Orders are not illegal per se and I don't recall seeing anyone ever argue that they are. All they do is direct agencies under the executive control of the President on how to implement policy. If the order is contrary to law, the order may be illegal. However, if the law attempts to restrict executive authority granted by the Constitution, then the law may be unconstitutional in whole or in part. Whether I think a particular Executive Order is legal depends on the order.

Executive signing statements are different in that their primary or exclusive purpose is an attempt to modify a law that was properly enacted. This is beyond the role of the President and threatens to conflate the legislative and executive powers that the Constitution separates. For that reason, I oppose signing statements period no matter who uses them.

In this case, as I think about it, the President may haveConstitutional authority as commander and chief (or some other broad power) to approve prisoner exchanges. This is so whether or not any Executive Order or signing statement is issued. Even so, it seems to me that the President should veto the law rather than sign it with the intent ofignoring its terms. After all, Congress only asked to be notified. If Obama decides to sign a law and then ignore it, the problem is entirely of his own making.

Do you have a differnt view?

 
 
 
1stwarrior
Professor Participates
link   1stwarrior    12 years ago

Well A. Mac - you and John think the Dems walk on water and anything and everything they do is perfectly great. If any comment from ANYONE even references a Repub, Jeezzzz - you two guys get into such an uproar that it's hilarious to read with all the new names, accusations, slippy dances and pure back-stabbing.

Yup - two peas in a pod. Now, can you discuss this further without the POLITICAL slanting and name-calling? Didn't think so.

 
 
 
1stwarrior
Professor Participates
link   1stwarrior    12 years ago

And, no, a signing statement is not an Executive Order - they are worlds apart - "If the President feels a law is unconstitutional or otherwise ill-advised, the President canvetothe law instead of signing it. At this point Congress canrespondin various ways. It is also argued that the President has a duty not to sign a law which in a given circumstance would be unconstitutional, because the President takes an oath to "preserve, protect and defend" the Constitution. (Article II, Section 1). The U.S. Supreme Court is the ultimate arbiter of whether a law is constitutional or not (Marbury v. Madison, 5 U.S. 137 (1803).

Unlike vetoes, signing statements are not part of thelegislative processas set forth in the Constitution, and have no legal effect. A signed law is still a law regardless of what the President says in an accompanying signing statement."

 
 
 
A. Macarthur
Professor Guide
link   A. Macarthur    12 years ago

A MAC -- I'm having some difficulty following your line of reasoning perhaps because it's premised on an implicit assumption that iscontrary to mine. Executive Orders are not illegal per se and I don't recall seeing anyone ever argue that they are. All they do is direct agencies under the executive control of the President on how to implement policy. If the order is contrary to law, the order may be illegal.

I did not state nor imply that Executive Orders or Signing Statements and/or at least two other extensions of Presidential authority, are illegal. In fact, my questions assume the opposite -- that in fact, Obama did not violate any laws by going around Congress and transferring prisoners. He could have used the Executive Order, a Signing Statement, and/or other options as I have linked in one of my comments and below.

I've asked, "if Obama broke the law by using any extension of Presidential authority regarding Bergdahl (or any other action for that matter), then why

1. Have other Presidents who have used such options done so with impunity, and

2. Why are those taking exception to Obama's action -- calling it illegal -- not asking the same question? Do they believe that Obama is the first and only President to have used such an extension of authority?

Of course, "2." is rhetorical. I'm certain those calling what Obama did, "illegal," know other Presidents have used their authority extensions and gone around Congress, and more often than has Obama; and I know their feigned ignorance (or, actual ignorance) is the reason.

So 1ofmany, I think we pretty much are in agreement.

Even so, it seems to me that the President should veto the law rather than sign it with the intent ofignoring its terms. After all, Congress only asked to be notified. If Obama decides to sign a law and then ignore it, the problem is entirely of his own making.

Do you have a differnt view?

Agreed; it's hypocritical and selective on Obama's part unless he stipulates that he acted in concert with

The Military Commissions Act, the FISA Amendments Act and the reauthorization of the Patriot Act passed during the Bush administration, or

At least one of the crucial statutes underpinning the presidentsdiscretionary powers over the past decade,the September 2001 Authorization for the Use of Military Force (AUMF) immensely broad and without amendments

 
 
 
A. Macarthur
Professor Guide
link   A. Macarthur    12 years ago

Well A. Mac - you and John think the Dems walk on water and anything and everything they do is perfectly great.

When I state that's what I think, you can quote me on it, otherwise, that's simply hyperbole used in place of a viable rebuttal.

Now, can you discuss this further without the POLITICAL slanting and name-calling? Didn't think so.

As a matter-of-fact, if you've been following my comments rather than trying to read my mind and do vegetable metaphors, you'd know I've given 4 SPECIFIC EXTENSIONS OF PRESIDENTIAL AUTHORITY BY WHICH OBAMA COULD HAVE MADE THE BERGDAHL TRANSFER WITHOUT FIRST GOING TO CONGRESS.

And since you're into reading my thoughts, I will close my eyes and concentrate real hard on those 4 EXTENSIONS so you won't have to run through the entire thread looking for them.

If any comment from ANYONE even references a Repub, Jeezzzz - you two guys get into such an uproar that it's hilarious to read with all the new names, accusations, slippy dances and pure back-stabbing.

For the record, all of my comments have direct connection to the article and I never take a position without giving my specific reasons as to why, and, always invite rebuttals and discussion.

Even my sarcasm and quips and editorial comments are reactive and not pro-active. One can always track them back to who and what provoked them.

OK, what am I thinking now?

 
 
 
1stwarrior
Professor Participates
link   1stwarrior    12 years ago

You like suisi and peanut butter - but not together - and you wish Longmire was on tonight instead of next Tuesday.

I don't know A. Mac - I've combed this thread quite extensively (not wearing my reading glasses at the moment) and can find no four points. Are you sure it was in this thread?

 
 
 
A. Macarthur
Professor Guide
link   A. Macarthur    12 years ago

You like suisi and peanut butter - but not together - and you wish Longmire was on tonight instead of next Tuesday.

Damn, 1st, how'd you do that?

I've combed this thread quite extensively (not wearing my reading glasses at the moment) and can find no four points. Are you sure it was in this thread?

Not having much hair, I don't relate well to combs, but because you're a friend

FOUR EXTENSIONS OF PRESIDENTIAL AUTHORITY BY WHICH OBAMA AND OTHER PRESIDENTS CAN BYPASS CONGRESS (on various matters)

Executive Orders

Signing Statements

The Military Commissions Act, the FISA Amendments Act and the reauthorization of the Patriot Act passed during the Bush administration, or

At least one of the crucial statutes underpinning the presidentsdiscretionary powers over the past decade,the September 2001 Authorization for the Use of Military Force (AUMF) immensely broad and without amendments

I hasten to add that although we often disagree and exchange barbs, it's never personal and I consider you a friend.

Really, how'd you know about the sushi and peanut butter?

 
 
 
Petey Coober
Freshman Silent
link   Petey Coober    12 years ago

Holy crap ! He joined the army to help people ... That is one confused lad.Holy crap ! He joined the army to help people ... That is one confused lad.

Yeah that's what I said . Why is it blank now ?

Once more, selective indignation.

Where do you see indignation ? Why did you go on your usual Dick Cheney rant ? [I know why ; Its just what you do ...You don't need a reason . You just like to vent . Blchhh !]

 
 
 
A. Macarthur
Professor Guide
link   A. Macarthur    12 years ago

If you can't see the irony, you can just attack the messenger.

Oh, you have.

But let's see "helping people," "being greeted as liberators (that's done by people who believe they've been you know HELPED!)

'Course Cheney, when he said that, was just covering his ass because the WMD thing was found to be bullshit, and, the ass-covering went on -- "spreading democracy across the Middle East, "the Iraqi oil will pay for the war," "slam dunk," but

I reiterate; When people greet other people in the streets as "liberators," and give those liberators candy and flowers, it's because they feel they've been

HELPED!

So you see, to imply that one person who ALLEGEDLY talked of "helping" people and, then mock him for it, while not saying dick* about another guy who LIED HIS ASS OFF ABOUT HELPING SOME OTHER PEOPLE

That's selective indignation!

And, as you indicated, I "just like to vent".

And now I have.

* Notice how I cleverly snuck in that reference to Cheney.

I can f'n vent with the best of 'em

 
 
 
Petey Coober
Freshman Silent
link   Petey Coober    12 years ago

Fine . So perhaps you can explain who he helped and in what way ... cuz I'm not seeing it .

BTW I still think that anyone who joins the army to "help people" is confused . Disagree?

 
 
 
A. Macarthur
Professor Guide
link   A. Macarthur    12 years ago

Fine . So perhaps you can explain who he helped and in what way ... cuz I'm not seeing it .

Petey,

We don't know if Bergdahl actually made the statement most of what we've heard or read is "hearsay". You were indignant about the hearsay account of a soldier who allegedly claimed to want to help the Afghan people.

If you are going to question the sincerity of an (alleged) stated intent of "helping people," and in the political context of this discussion to boot -- which btw is ultimately to bash Obama -- then question a bona fide hypocritical such statement.

 
 
 
Petey Coober
Freshman Silent
link   Petey Coober    12 years ago

question the sincerity of an (alleged) stated intent of "helping people,"

I didn't say he was insincere . I said he was confused . Don't you know the diff ?

 
 
 
1stwarrior
Professor Participates
link   1stwarrior    12 years ago

And the President here is the head of the Court Martial Board, not Obama.

 
 
 
A. Macarthur
Professor Guide
link   A. Macarthur    12 years ago

Why would his wanting to help the Afghan people, represent confusion?

If Cheney had been sincere about "liberating" Iraqis, would that not been the military involved in a war intended to help an oppressed people?

I agree -- you did say "confused." And there indeed is a significant difference between confusion and insincerity.

Point conceded, Petey.

 
 
 
A. Macarthur
Professor Guide
link   A. Macarthur    12 years ago

And the President here is the head of the Court Martial Board, not Obama.

I posted that information to detail the process of determining innocence or guilt through the gathering and presentation of evidence the formal process under the UCMJ as opposed to hearsay and speculation.

 
 
 
1stwarrior
Professor Participates
link   1stwarrior    12 years ago

Just finished the greatest snack in the world - club crackers, sardines and peanut butter - 'bout as close as I could get to suishi in Albuquerque Grin.gif

My disrupted thought process on your comments above is - the Defense Authorization Act of 2014, that Obama signed in December, specifically states that he HAS to notify and discuss with Congress 30 day prior to any form of release or transfer of the GITMO prisoners. Taking it a bit further, the DAA supersedes the four listed by you.

Executive orders have the full force of law when they take authority from a power granted directly to the Executive by the Constitution. The authority to release or transfer prisoners are not directly granted by the Constitution.

Signing Statements have no affect in law - they are explanatory documents as an addendum to the law being signed.

AUMF does not allow release or transfer of prisoners - however, it does allow the President to declare a "police" action or combat responseof less than 60 days without authorization from Congress.

FISA, I believe, is superseded by AUMF which "could" have beensuperseded bythe DAA of 12/14/14 in this particular action.

Just my thoughts.

 
 
 
Petey Coober
Freshman Silent
link   Petey Coober    12 years ago

I agree with your point about Cheney . His lack of understanding of middle eastern culture led to his "sincere confusion " about what to expect . At this point in time it looks like a disaster but in 50 years ... who knows .

 
 
 
A. Macarthur
Professor Guide
link   A. Macarthur    12 years ago

I don't keep a log but at the point I removed you as a friend it was for that reason.

And now we're on "manhood" are we?

You're the one in denial.

There are almost 600 pages of your comments eventually I may dig them up but no matter; I didn't make it up.

 
 
 
A. Macarthur
Professor Guide
link   A. Macarthur    12 years ago

Just admit you use quips too, it's ok. Lying about it isn't!

Already did that in detail; pay attention then you're lack of information won't necessitate calling me a liar.

Once again we already had this exchange

Really AMAC, you've always specialized in one liners so before you call out others proceed to the nearest mirror and enjoy the reflection of hypocrisy!

The difference is that my one-liners are directly related to those they address, and, are specifically in conjunction with the content of those they address.

If a comment is foolish or unfounded on its face, it gets an editorial one-liner in return; think of it as "victim-provoked".

We enjoyed the same self righteous holier than thou attitude on News vine and thank you for demonstrating that here as well.

Flattering to have such a devoted follower as yourself.

BTW this is an insult with truth.......You sir are a tool!

I suspect you spend a lot of time with tools I ask with all due respect if you have them monogrammed.

If you are going to call out others, check your most recent posts. My advice is to stay away from quips if you plan on criticizing others for them.

Sincerely,

The hypocrisy Interventionist!

Since you're the self-appointed expert, go back and see if any of my insult/quips are made in the absence of context, or, if they generally, if not invariably follow the block-quoted, inaccurate, nonsensical and/or ill/uniformed statements to which they refer.

Editorial commentary, including sarcasm and satire are accepted forms of journalism.

Further, one of Newton's Laws of Motion can be applied to social, political and other circumstances, namely, for every action, there is an equal and opposite reaction.

My one-liners and quips are never stand-alones; the comments/quips you cited are quite aptly-placed bits of sarcasm.

If you require them explained, perhaps you are not the interventionist you deem yourself qualified to be.

And, if this forum were a hockey game, you'd be penalized for being the "third-man-in".

My quip regarding the photo of Hagel and the troops came in response to the comments that appeared above it, namely

Along with most everyone else, it appears the troops are not falling for the Administration's BS over this:

Hagel, visiting troops in Afghanistan, was met with silence when he told a group of them in a Bagram Air Field hangar: This is a happy day. We got one of our own back. It was unclear whether the absence of cheers and applause came from a reluctance to display emotion in front of the Pentagon chief or from any doubts among the troops about Bergdahl.

Note the first comment editorial in nature and, coming from a source that is consistently Obama-bashing. The second comment attempts to validate the first, and how - by reading faces, minds?

Address the explanation for my commentary, not the fact that I made it and you don't like it.

As for "tools," if you're going to be a critic in a journalistic setting, your tool box may be a bit light.

You have mocked me on several occasions while in the process, adding nothing in the way of point-counter-point rebuttal. As far as I understand, you're an expert in on personal defense -- I respect that and therefore expect that you will thus respect my ability to defend myself when attacked.

Hey, that makes us kindred spirits!

Finally, my comment/quip regarding the 2nd Amendment was an editorial comment directed at those who regard that Amendment as "written in stone," eternally inalterable, that despite the Constitution's inclusion of methods to change itself, AND, TO THOSE WHO ARE SELECTIVELY WILLING TO IGNORE OTHER AMENDMENTS, THOSE THAT DON'T SUIT THEIR AGENDA (in this thread, with regard to "Presumption of Innocence" and Bergdahl).

There are those herein who have him "guilty" based on "hearsay," "probability," "possibility," "most likely," -- but not based on investigation, indictment, trial and verdict. And I dare say, those to whom I refer are "strict constructionists" when it comes to the 2nd Amendment.

I never duck a question, BF, and I never take a position without giving the specifics as to why.

 
 
 
A. Macarthur
Professor Guide
link   A. Macarthur    12 years ago

I was discussing myself? I reflect on my own behavior. Something i believe is healthy for people.

Unfriended? ouch....how hurtful.

You were alluding via innuendo.

As for the un-friending, it's trivial in perspective -- no question; it represents a gesture of disdain in response to one.

Nothing more, nothing less.

 
 
 
A. Macarthur
Professor Guide
link   A. Macarthur    12 years ago

1stwarrior,

The Administration determined that the notification requirement should be construed not to apply to this unique set of circumstances, the statement reads.

In these circumstances, delaying the transfer in order to provide the 30-day notice would interfere with the Executives performance of two related functions that the Constitution assigns to the President: protecting the lives of Americans abroad and protecting U.S. soldiers.

Because such interference would significantly alter the balance between Congress and the President, and could even raise constitutional concerns, we believe it is fair to conclude that Congress did not intend that the Administration would be barred from taking the action it did in these circumstances.

 
 
 
1stwarrior
Professor Participates
link   1stwarrior    12 years ago

Not questioning - just elaborating for those who don't know the Military Code of Justice.

 
 
 
1stwarrior
Professor Participates
link   1stwarrior    12 years ago

You have to have a war to have prisoners of war. Our last war was WWII - Congress approved that one.

The "War on Terror" is little Georgie's words right after 9/11 and his decision to go kill the murderous Saddam who had put out a hit order on Daddy. These guys are enemy combatants but not of an approved war.

They are terrorists and were incarcerated as a result of activities of their "organization" (huge difference between country and organization - ya think?) against U. S. activities in the Middle-East. They are not POW's.

 
 
 
1stwarrior
Professor Participates
link   1stwarrior    12 years ago

Oh, Cheney had a GREAT grasp of the Middle East situation - $$$$$$$$$$$$$

 
 
 
A. Macarthur
Professor Guide
link   A. Macarthur    12 years ago

still no concrete justification to your ramblings.

None that you're willing to accept or able to comprehend perhaps.

It has nothing to do with my "image," that's an ad hominem attack-the-messenger substitute for viable debate.

I provide information and never duck a question; if that pokes a finger in your insecurity, it's not about my trying to "better" anyone.

This is a discussion forum and comments like yours drive members off threads, or off the site altogether. When you disagree, give your reasons on the issue, not your feelings about a member's motives or character.

 
 
 
A. Macarthur
Professor Guide
link   A. Macarthur    12 years ago

Just admit you use quips too, it's ok. Lying about it isn't!

Ah! That brings back one of the "mockery" incidents to which I referred.

I'll rephrase my comment about your mocking me.

It wasn't that you mocked me per se --rather, it's that you tried to ridicule my raising of a potentially serious situation, one that put NT in jeopardy via a plan to squelch discussion.

You not only implied that I was making up a kind of fairy tale -- you quipped that I'd next be seeing "unicorns," and implied that I was either lying or delusional.

Calling a member, or, by innuendo or snarky quip, accusing a member of lying or being less than mentally stable, is a tactic of yours. Ridiculing/mocking content with counter-information, even in the form of a quip, is fair game. Going after a member or his motives (as long as he has backed his position) is not.

The "mocking" incident I referred to, had to do with a group from the old news talkers, which, while meeting on another website, discussed planning to dissuade and disrupt and thwart discussions by "wearing down the liberals" -- by just being relentless in disagreement. They were discovered and outed by one of our members and there was quite a heated reaction to follow.

Although you did the mockery/disbelief (liar) thing, even after Bruce corroborated what I reported, you didn't have the character or courtesy to merely acknowledge that my information was neither fantasy, fabrication nor false.

As for the removing you as a "friend," that was as close as I could get to putting you on "Ignore," a feature unavailable on NT.

Quips and one-liners have their place when they point out or allude to outrageous or clearly misrepresented (mis)information," hyperbole or hate-mongering and/or unwarranted ridicule including personal attacks.

And it's quite normal for someone who did not initiate a personal pissing contest, to shoot back in kind (although that too is not helpful to the site).

 
 
 
A. Macarthur
Professor Guide
link   A. Macarthur    12 years ago

If they cant accept opin ions then they dont need to be on forums. Right Seems I have heard that before from you and JR and JV and Hal. and jwc2blueballs.

I see you're back!

Now I will type real slow so you and yours can understand.

We will never agree on politics, so no need to do your oneupsmanship.

Thats ONE UPS MAN SHIP. That y'all are so famous for.

Anything in there that's content-related, or, is it entirely ad hominem?

It's not about accepting opinions, it's about having discussions that emanate from divergent opinions. Once you've gone to the personal stuff, you invite more-of-the-same as individuals tend to want to defend themselves. And, you begin to destroy the discussion.

You made a comment discounting all in the past as being viable in going forward; I RESPONDED TO YOUR COMMENT.

You couldn't rebut the response so here we are with the character assassination. You hit -- you got hit. Apparently, those who disagree with you all have ego problems.

The Prosecution rests.

 
 

Who is online

afrayedknot
Eat The Press Do Not Read It


128 visitors