Obama Broke U.S. Law, Did Not Inform Congress Before Transferring Prisoners Off Gitmo In Bergdahl Trade
The discussion about trading for Bowe Bergdahl has been ongoing for some time. This of course is questionable, since the U.S. has always held the position that it will not negotiate with terrorists or trade terrorists for hostages. This the Obama regime has clearly broken today, the impact of which will yet be felt, as he has now painted a target on the back of every American.
Yet in any discussion of the question, the Obama regime has assured Congress that it would be advised.
Note this in August 2012 in an NBC article on Bowe Bergdahl:
U.S. officials stress that the transfer, if it occurs, will be done in accordance with U.S. law, which requires Congress to be notified before any detainees are moved from Guantanamo.
But today, there was no notice given to Congress as required by law:
McKeon/Inhofe say Obama violated law by not notifying Congress of Gitmo transfers to secure #Bergdahl release.
Chad Pergram (@ChadPergram) May 31, 2014
McKeon/Inhofe: Our joy at Sergeant #Berghdal s release is tempered by the fact that President Obama chose to ignore the law..to achieve it
Chad Pergram (@ChadPergram) May 31, 2014
Hse Intel Cmte Chair Rogers: I am extremely troubled..that the (US) negotiated with terrorists..to swap 5 sr Taliban leaders.. #Bergdahl
Chad Pergram (@ChadPergram) May 31, 2014
McKeon/Inhofe on Bergdahl release: Our terrorist adversaries now have a strong incentive to capture Americans.
Chad Pergram (@ChadPergram) May 31, 2014
Hse Intel Cmte Chair Rogers: I believe this decision will threaten the lives of American soldiers for years to come. #Bergdahl
Chad Pergram (@ChadPergram) May 31, 2014
So he knew it was the law, he said he would follow it and then he broke it flagrantly in a way that threatens Americans for years to come.
Nickarama | May 31, 2014 5:25 pm

I don't think most will understand the implications of this and the long term effect.
I wouldn't be too concerned Six. Wary of course, but not too concerned.
Even though Pres Regan traded arms for hostages, back in the mid 80's, the Republic still stands and there wasn't a drastic increase in US citizens being taken hostage over the last 30 years as far as I know, because of what he did.
I haven't dug too deep into this yet but my first understanding is that the 5 that were released from Gitmo were more Taliban than Al Qaeda, which would make this more of a prisoners of war swap than the strait up arms for hostages that Pres Regan pulled.
My main thought on this is whole matter would be, "Welcome home Solder!".
I am happy that he is coming home, but.....
It appears that the U.S. now indeed negotiates with terrorists and now they (all of them) know it
Concerning
The US have been negotiating with terrorist, ever since Reagan said "We do not negotiate with terrorist" it depends on the circumstances, I am glad he is coming home...
I am also glad he is coming home, I am concerned about the next and the next person that is taken hostage in order to barter for the release of more terrorists being held by the U.S.
I wonder who the Mexicans would accept in exchange for the marine they are holding?
That's the way I was thinking about the exchange as well John, a prisoner of war swap more than "a negotiating with terrorist for hostages" situation.
For better of for worst the Taliban were the governing authority of Afghanistan when we went in.
They may be a quasi Government in exile now, controlling a large portion of Afghanistan, but they are still a governing entity. If we were doing something similar with Saudi Arabia's Royal family would that also be called "Negotiating with Terrorist"? After all that's where most of the 9-11 assholes came from.
Obama has, again and again and again and again, broken the law and his oath to office.
Welcome home Soldier.
ArkansasHermit - Good answer.
I see your concern with this, Six; but in the long run, were I the family of the soldier, I wouldn't care what was done in order to get him back. In this case, I, too, will consider it an exchange of prisoners.
WELCOME HOME, SOLDIER!
Bowe is giving a press briefing right now on CNN. Why does he still have his long hair and beard?
Never mind, I think that's his dad Bob speaking.Yeah no shit, the guy thinks he's Ghandi or something.
Maybe we could have Obama act on his own without notifying Congress and have him call Mexico and do a prisoner trade.
We could give them 100 prisoners from our jails consisting of illegal immigrants serving time for murder, rape, child molestation and anything else we come up with for U.S. Marine Sgt. Andrew Tahmooressi.
We could just drop them off at the border and make sure they made it home safely to blend back into Mexican society. Now that would be a good trade.
Very. The guy is obviously enamored with his own voice.
Illegal Aliens Six - Illegal Aliens.
Are these Gitmo detainees still in custody ? If so [and they won't be released for a year ] their legal status may be confused ...
Most of the previous comments are disgusting in my opinion, if that were your Son/Daughter you would be over joyed, it doesn't matter if the father keeps talking on and on, he is trying to come to grips that his son will be home soon...welcome back home soldier...
Instead of disgusting I will say insensitive, it bothers me that there is so much criticism and not enough understanding as to how these parents are coping with what happened to their son...been in captivity for 5 years, its going to take a lifetime for parents and son to get back into a normal American lifestyle, I hope the best for this family....
Once an investigation is done, we will have the details, in the meantime, I am glad he was not killed....
Not sure if you are a parent of not...
You want to talk about insensitive CM. What about a MARINE stuck in a Mexican jail where there is no doubt to whether he deserted his post or not?
We don't really know the whole story on him, but there's no way he could have done anything really bad in Mexico. It would have taken an idiot to try.
He fought for his country and that imposter in Washington could get him out of prison and back home here in the USA if he wanted to do it.
Now that is insensitive!
And he released murderers, rapist and others into the streets of this country just for spite. Now that is insensitive CM!
Unattended parks and monuments were suddenly attended which added cost that wasn't there before to keep Americans from visiting or even getting a drink of water out of spite and punishment because he didn't get his way. Now that is insensitive CM!
Not getting on you personally CM, because I know you can't see it. If you could, you wouldn't feel the same way as you do.
I Disagree, that soldier in Mexico had three guns in his vehicle, if he missed his exit, he should have stopped at the border immigration/customs check point and explained he missed his exit, there should be a US check point just before you go over the border, then a Mexican check point, well that's the way it is set up going into Canada, then explain himself at the US check point, I think there may be a turn around at that place, I do not have details on any of these soldiers, Don't think I believe the explanation of the one in Mexico, don't know why the one in Afghanistan was captured, but he has spent his 5 years as a prisoner...
Sorry, my mistake. See I'm being brainwashed.
Never mind CM.
Never mind CM.
Ok Six, glad you saw the other point of view LoL!!!!
How 'bout 38,000 released criminal Illegal Aliens into our streets and neighborhoods - That is insensitive - and just plain stupid.
The investigation was done five years ago and it was determined he deserted his post, willingly, and that four U. S. servicemen died while searching for him - sickening - purely sickening.
What are you all talking about???? give me a LINK...
I know the difference...Is that not a good reason to get him back to be questioned??? We do not know what his mental state was, As far as the 5 been released, I hope they were just not released without some kind of tracking device and I do not mean an ankle bracelet...there are all kinds of technology...
A human microchip implant is an identifying integrated circuit device or RFID transponder encased in silicate glass and implanted in the body of a human being. A subdermal implant typically contains a unique ID number that can be linked to information contained in an external database, such as personal identification, medical history, medications, allergies, and contact information.
I hope they did not just release 5 people and not do something as described above..
Catch and Release
Interior immigration enforcement in 2013
Here is one you will like:
Well, if it's LAW you're concerned with
Well, we've gone forward.
And again, if you're indignation is with regard to ignoring LAWS
Bush, Cheney, Rumsfeld, Rice, the Bush legal advisors, et al, should have been tried for war crimes!
The selective indignation from the right-wing is the ultimate hypocrisy and double standard.
Get your indignation ducks in chronological order not anti-Obama political bullshit order.
Here ya go A. Mac - I've helped you get out of your rut - "The selective indignation from the right left-wing is the ultimate hypocrisy and double standard."
"Get your indignation ducks in chronological order not anti-Obamait's always bushes fault 'cause we know no other answer for obama'spolitical bullshit order."
Your welcome.
I'm not justifying an oversight of the law; I am inquiring as to the selective indignation .
There would be no Gitmo nor its attendant violation of the Geneva Conventions and the ploy of calling it "outside U.S. legal jurisdiction" by the Bush Administration.
More than 500 detainees were released or transferred from Guantanamo while George W. Bush was president. A White House executive order issued on the second day of Obama's presidency said, "The federal government has moved more than 500 such detainees from Guantnamo, either by returning them to their home country or byreleasing or transferring them to a third country."
And technically, they were "transferred" then as now!
Further
Shall I go on?
So, if we're going to castigate one, to do so with integrity, we must castigate all who act in the same manner. That's my issue.
Anyone want to discuss the pros and cons of the transfer itself, let's have that discussion. But to AS USUAL, castigate Obama for virtually anything and everything while looking the other way on those who set the precedents.
That's a cop out; I did not say nor imply "it's always Bush's fault." I said it's hypocritical to start the indignation train under Obama's Administration while not expressing equal indignation against ALL WHO PERPETRATED THE SAME INDISCRETIONS/ILLEGALITIES.
This issue is about a "prisoner transfer" done hundreds of times under Bush. Wrong is wrong (if indeed this is a legal indiscretion).
We're talking NOW - not THEN. Hell, Hoover was bad too.
I'd like to see some links about the "prisoner transfer" done hundreds of times under Bush. Betcha that'd surprise the hell out of him since he transferred NO prisoners during his terms.
I'M TALKING SELECTIVE INDIGNATION.
Just state that whatever sanctions may be implemented against Obama in this matter should be retroactively implemented against any/all who have perpetrated the same.
Otherwise, the indignation is partisan not objective.
A crime/violation is not negated because the perpetrator is no longer on the scene of the crime.
OK>
Further
istwarrior,
I think you and I may have some overlapping in our backgrounds; if so, we both know that frequently, litigation and adjudication of a given matter hinges on a single word in a law or contract or other valid agreement.
And I believe you may agree that if laws and sanctions are not employed even-handedly, that it undermines the credibility of the bodies/individuals who selectively accuse, indict, prosecute, fail to prosecute and punish or fail to punish in order to satisfy an agenda.
Yes'sir - however, but - The actions Bush took, from the Executive Order to Col. Wilkerson's statement, Congress was aware and approved.
What was done then has no bearing on what was done now. In the Now - there was an exchange of prisoners/deserter - there were negotiations with terriorists for the release of said prisoners. In the Then - there was none.
Bush, Clinton, Bush, Ford, Reagan, Kennedy, Johnson, Nixon - hell, even Carter- NONE of them negotiated with terriorists - none of them exchanged prisoners/deserter.
No precedence was established to follow for Obama - he unilaterally, without Congressional knowledge nor approval, (well - kinda doubt the knowledge bit) made the decision to make the exchange.
That is today's news - the release/negotiations - and that is the topic of discussion.
Trying to keep it the way Cohen would have kept it - concise andprecise with no opportunity of misunderstanding.
It's only "off-topic" because you don't want to address the selective implementation.
I haven't taken a position one way or the other on Obama's action; I'm inquiring about
Cite for me the law(s) violated by Obama's action, when it became the law, and, if/when and by whom the law was VIOLATED IN THE RECENT PAST (LIKE WHEN GITMO BECAME THE HOLDING PLACE FOR DETAINEES TO BE TRANSFERRED IN SUCH A MANNER), and, if so violated, why just NOW it's an issue with those who deem it one.
Don't give me William Henry Harrison, give me timely, relevant and connected particulars. Those who want "NOW" to begin with Obama's inauguration are pissing in my face and telling me "it's raining!".
Ya' wanna play lawyer, let's play like you'd have to play if the discussion was objective and two-sided not, you cry foul and no one gets to ask you to why you're all right with "justice delayed".
So, again I ask, why the selective indignation; if both administrations violated law, let's have a headline and story to that effect!
Now, if you want to go with Obama saying one thing and doing another I'm with you.
Im not really sure what youre trying to get at 1stwarrior.
You say;
"The actions Bush took, from the Executive Order to Col.Wilkerson's statement, Congress was aware and approved."
Well when Pres Obama signed the 500+ pages of the National Defense Authorization Act for Fiscal Year 2014 he also signed off on his objections with a signing statement which happened to have the following in it ;
"Section 1035 of this Act gives the Administration additional flexibility to transfer detainees abroad by easing rigid restrictions that have hindered negotiations with foreign countries and interfered with executive branch determinations about how and where to transfer detainees. Section 1035 does not, however, eliminate all of the unwarranted limitations on foreign transfers and, in certain circumstances, would violate constitutional separation of powers principles. The executive branch must have the flexibility, among other things, to act swiftly in conducting negotiations with foreign countries regarding the circumstances of detainee transfers."
Since I could find the pertinent Statement in minutes I have to assume that Congress was aware of it as well.
"Bush, Clinton, Bush, Ford, Reagan, Kennedy, Johnson, Nixon - hell, even Carter - NONE of them negotiated with terriorists"
Youre joking right?
Link:
" After the North Koreans captured the U.S.S. Pueblo in 1968, President Lyndon Johnson apologized for spying as part of negotiations to secure the release of 83 American prisoners.
In 1970, President Richard Nixon pressured Israel, Switzerland, West Germany and Britain to release Palestinian prisoners after two airlines were hijacked by the Popular Front for the Liberation of Palestine.
During the Iran hostage crisis of 1979 to 1981, President Jimmy Carter agreed to unfreeze $8 billion in frozen Iranian assets after more than a year of negotiations with the Iranian revolutionaries.
In perhaps the most famous swap, after seven Americans were captured in Beirut, Lebanon, President Ronald Reagan agreed to send missiles to Iran in what became known as the Iran-Contra scandal.
President Bill Clintons administration sat down with Hamas in attempts to negotiate peace with Israel. His administration also worked directly with the Taliban nearly two decades ago on several occasions to see if the group would hand over Osama bin Laden and other al-Qaida leaders."
"No precedence was established to follow for Obama"
Oh come on now. Hell even ;
"George Washington, John Adams and Thomas Jefferson "accommodated what today would be viewed as terrorists," Reiss wrote. "They each authorized payment to the Barbary pirates, and the U.S. Senate even ratified a treaty that enshrined the annual provision of naval supplies as protection. "
"A century later, President Teddy Roosevelt granted demands from the descendants of those pirates to secure the release of captured American resident Ion Perdicaris"
Right or wrong there is a ton of precedence for what this current Pres did, from the use of the Signing Statement through the people he negotiated with and on to the actions he completed.
Controversial? To some.
Unique? Not in the least.
(sorry, couldn't get the block quotes to work, had to use italics)
Here's why it's not about Obama, Bush or transparency in government.
This is not a situation where the issue is trying to prove or disprove whether an individual committed a particular act; no one disputes what Obama did in terms of the transfer of prisoners.
The ISSUE IS WHETHER OR NOT THE PROCEDURE BY WHICH THE TRANSFER WAS MADE, IS A VIOLATION OF LAW AND SINCE OTHER PRESIDENTS HAVE USED SIGNING STATEMENTS/EXECUTIVE ORDERS WITH IMPUNITY (as was done in this situation), this is not about Obama, RATHER ABOUT WHETHER OR NOT A PRESIDENT CAN USE SIGNING STATEMENTS/EXECUTIVE ORDERS, WITHOUT VIOLATING U.S. LAW!
The fact that Obama detractors (and their shill publications) waited until Obama used the executive order/signing statement to raise their indignation, tells me that they couldn't give a flying fuck about the transfer or the law; if they did, this issue would have arisen from the same "plaintiffs" when it happened in the past.
It did not.
The process is "on trial" here and because it was not placed there by the same birthers/deathers/fast-and-furiousers/IRSers/Benghaziers the OBAMA-SCANDAL-MONGERS (BTW, all of which have LEGALLY gone nowhere BECAUSE THE ONES BRINGING THE ALLEGATIONS HAVE NOT MET THEIR MANDATE TO SATISFY A BURDEN OF PROOF), once again, it's not about what's on-the-table, it's about, a la Rush Limbaugh "I hope he fails!"
Should this become a matter of LEGITIMATE LEGAL INQUIRY, I GUARANTEE THAT PRECEDENT will be mentioned early on.
Yes'sir - that's what I'm doing.
Lot of your information I hadn't seen, so I will definitely apologize for being so uninformed.
My issue is he violated a law he signed into effect six months ago - and, he also broke his own word of negotiating with terrorists - but, that is nothing new.
Signing statements are not legal actions - they are excuses that can't/usually won't be used in court. They have no legal weight.
Thanks for the info - I will remember it.
Hey, no biggie 1st.
Heck, I didn't even mention Pres. Bush, back in 2005, saying the US would not negotiate with the Iraqis shooting at our troops while at the same time, behind the scene, he was doing just that. I haven't looked it up but I believe we cut a deal with them saying we would pay a little something, something to them if they would just stop shooting at our guys. It was mostly the Sunnis that took us up on the deal.
I believe that in the privet sector such a deal is called, "Paying Protection Money".
Could be wrong but I think that signing statements just haven't been challenged in court yet, so with their long history of use I'd say they are a legal tool available to any sitting Pres. until the Supreme Court judges otherwise.
In his signing statement the Pres. said the 30 day notice was Congress' way of infringing on the Executive Branch's ability to negotiate in a timely manner so he was not OK with that restriction, thinking it unconstitutional.
If Congress has a problem with signing statements then they should take that problem to the courts and let them decide, once and for all.