science versus zealotry
I recently wrote an article which attempted to identify what the weakness is in current loud climatology today .
http://thenewstalkers.com/forum/topics/alarmist-headlines-not-a-substitute-for-hard-work
I put some serious work into it and stayed faithful to the known data in the field . In the end I got very little response from the CO2 talking crowd . When I linked to the article as part of an NT comment I was quite disappointed when I got a response which was merely a dismissal of me personally and nothing about my arguments at all .
This kind of flippant crap is what I would have expected from a one-sided political site and not NT . With that in mind here is my purely political response .
The difference between science & zealotry :
Science , when done properly , is about letting the data make statements instead of interposing one's worldview . The data is king , not the politics or belief system of the author . Anyone who is reasonably numerate will tend to draw the same conclusion from a good analysis .
Zealotry is just the opposite . The facts and the data are unimportant . All that matters is the politics or belief system of the author . This amounts to sessions of preaching to the choir . This kind of fruitless ranting has no effect on the uncommitted readers of such pablum except to occasionally force them to reject the author as a reliable source .
So here is my POV about climatology the way it is practiced today . It is mostly not about science . It is instead an attempt to politically dominate the national dialogue . This kind of Tony Robbins approach to life does not work for science . It never has and never will . Hard work with occasional lucky breaks is the real lot for scientists . Being the alpha male might win physical or political contests but it won't establish a scientific legacy . Worshiping Al Gore's hyperbole is as far from science as one can get . But oddly enough that is what passes for science in some circles . How did science get so perverted ?
Tags
Who is online
92 visitors

Although hardly any of us have experienced what Ayn Rand experienced as a child, many still condemn her and anything she has written. Coming from a violent changing life in Russia living during a time of revolution which had a life long effect on her. She was radical, but it can be understood why she would be.
In her book Atlas Shrugged all science was controlled by the people who ran the government and it is scary to see this is the way science is viewed today as well. The comparison of her book and society today is not as extreme at this time, but it is easy for some to see the direction we are headed when science is settled and there is no longer any room for debate or discussion.
I have only a passing knowledge of Ayn Rand so I cannot comment knowledgeably about that . It dawns on me that the Orwell novel "1984" also had such a nightmarish view of future science . Books like these should be an important part of any science curriculum at institutions of higher learning . But instead they focus on socialist philosophy . Obama undoubtedly has a mentor at Harvard who is guiding him through his environmentally based presidency . Jobs ? Not important .
The problem was exacerbated by 2 events :
1] the discovery that CO2 levels in the atmosphere are increasing rapidly
2] the fictionalization of the subsequent global average temperatures by Prof. Michael Mann [his infamous hockey stick graph] . This man's abuse of the data to force people to see a non-existent connection between CO2 levels and temperature is a manipulation of science dialogue which rivals some of the greatest propagandists of the ages : people like Stalin and even Hermann Goering .
Oh now now...
Darwin was said to be a zealot... remember? He wasn't wrong
All he had was his journal and personal observations. No dino bones involved.
On the other hand, almost everything I studied as an anthro major, is now wrong.. with some basic concepts being held true... it isn't even called anthropology but palo anthropology. No missing link. No dilma between Peking Man vs. Lucy. We know we came from Africa. We even know now that homosapians lived with Neanderthals. In fact, every white person on this earth is between 2-4% Neanderthal genetically. There is no more carbon dating 14 anymore.. we have all of this
My point is, that probably the truth lies somewhere between the two camps. That yes the earth is warming and probably we are adding to it. But until our metaphorical carbon dating catches up, better to be safe than sorry.
Petey said:
I would submit that science is not attempting to dominate the political scene, but politicians are attempting to gain traction by dividing the electorate around the issue using scientific uncertainties, since scientists can never totally agree on one thing. This is good for science, because it fosters an attitude that is continually questioning, but bad for public policy because a scientific answer is, in the mind of the general public, supposed to be the right answer.
Since there are two or more versions of what is happening or going to happen, this lack of consensus allows the people who want to be elected to use the issue as a traction issue. Because they have set it up as a traction issue, the dialog that transpires on most sites is polarized and this goes back to the (somewhat limited) idea that there is only one correct answer to any given problem. If there is only one correct answer to a problem, then it follows that the people who think differently than any one person are by definition wrong. This is not the best way to make friends and influence people, but it happens to get people elected.
That said, I feel that we should err on the side of caution when addressing these issues, looking at what the worst case scenarios are with each choice and allowing those choices to be made whereas not to take the more dangerous course, which, in this case, would be to do nothing.
I wish you would make up your mind . Is it warming or is it undergoing "climate change" ?
BTW I am not necessarily disagreeing with either of your above points BUT it is essential to identify precisely what human activities [if any] are having those effects . Obsessing about CO2 [just because it is increasing ] does not demonstrate a connection . Until someone derives a better quality model to predict [correlate ] with observed climate then there is no reason to take action on anything . The problem with acting on the unlikely cause of CO2 is that it obscures what are the real causative agents . That is what I discussed in detail in this article :
...
They don't have to TOTALLY agree . But there needs to be a degree of quality in the working model . So far any attempt to explain what is happening based on CO2 has been almost useless . There are measures for the quality of a model . Those models are currently completely inadequate in quality . That is because relying heavily on CO2 levels has little predictive value . That is why I said that it is essential to do the hard work of developing a good working model . I expect that it would need to rely on other factors besides [or in addition to ] CO2 .
By forcing the public to swallow the myth of CO2 as a cause they are doing a tremendous disservice to the cause of science . Convincing the funding agencies that the cause has already been identified means that other avenues won't be properly explored .
Caution about what exactly ? That is the precise problem . The causative factors need to be identified before we can exert caution .
Incidentally there has been a history of not being cautious in the world of sci/tech :
I never mentioned the phrase climate change, did I? So what do I have to make up my mind about?
The phrase "climate change" can mean anything, from getting warmer to colder and wetter or dryer. It is an inaccurate phrase. Warming is what is at issue when one talks about the effects of mankind on climate. CO2 is not the only greenhouse gas, either. Let us not forget methane, nitrous oxide and fluorinated gases. Ah yes... but the bulk of the question falls on the CO2 since it is the most abundant of the greenhouse gases right?
How did you determined that CO2 is the unlikely caused? Any tests that I am unaware of? You see, the real issue here is that neither you nor I can neither prove nor disprove that CO2 impacts our climate not only directly nor to what extent can we, because we can not test any hypothesis. So what are we left with?
Darwin.
Darwin the zealot who believed that animals evolved. No scientific method used other than observation and his journals of data. Are we reenacting the "Scopes monkey trial"? I won't mind playing John Scopes, since it's only befitting.
It would be ridiculous to think that the billions of people on this planet do not contribute to its health or its deterioration.
When some of our largest lakes have warning signs not to wade in the water or swim in it due to health hazards, there has to be an acknowledgement that humans drastically affect the environment.
Totally agree Mimi!
Find me a model that gives good quality results based on CO2 alone . In fact any model at all ... There are none .
There are measures for quality of model fit . None of them I have seen have a good fit [over time ] . If you know of any please inform us of them .
BTW , do equal %ages of CO2 fill the the atmosphere at all altitudes ?
Robert,
You know, I happen to agree with you here. The only way to work out what is going on, is to question... and nothing in science is above questioning, especially when so much lies on the line. I also think that without both sides of the discussion and challenging of the data by peers, there will always be people who will never believe the findings.
The issue is what changes need to be made , not that none be made . I think CO2 levels is looking at the wrong factor . Just because it is increasing doesn't mean it is at fault .
Exactly my point . It is zealotry not science . And all this talk about being cautious is a ploy to give influence to the big dogs of climatology ... Michael Mann and his hockey team .
I agree.
Why?
That may be true.. or not...
There are measures for a model which fits the data well . Show me just one that works well and I will show it the interest it deserves . But obsessing about CO2 just because it is known to be increasing it not analysis . It is paralysis .
BTW the most recent info I saw indicated that CO2 level increases have decelerated ...
There are no real models at all. Only observations from data from both camps. That was my point.
Damn glad you asked that question. My source material is from John Wiley & Sons (the bringer of food to my table) and comes from 1961.. long before this whole debate... so no agenda there. You can all read for yourselves.
Thanks for the link . I'm looking it over .
When you say "real" I'm guessing you mean what I was referring to as ones with good fit . In the statistics game when your models don't fit you need to find out what is wrong . If your independent variables are not up to the task you need to find some that are ... CO2 is not adequate by itself as an explanatory variable .
I wrote this article partly in response to Dowser's article about melting glaciers and water quality :
I have it on the best of authorities, my own, that the world, the earth, the planet, is not going to be doomed by anything that humanity does. The same cannot be said for the billions of people and other creatures living on the earth. The earth itself will continue until the sun blows up or burns out, or until some other body strikes it, and hard. If geologic scale history is our guide, then we have several millions of years to inhabit the planet.
Not much compared to geologic time is the lifespan of a human, or several generations, or even the entirety of homo sapiens existence.
Erring on the side of caution means just this: If you think there is a possibility that what you are doing is going to cause you harm, but you are not sure, you don't do it. But to the world of humans who just have to have their goddamned money above all else, stopping and looking at the situation becomes job killing solutions. This is what I refer to when I speak of humanities fundamental flaw in its relationship to money, this ability to perceive that something is wrong with the way we are doing things yet continue to do them because they are too expensive to change.
Who made up the concept of money? Was it squirrels? Deer? Maybe Fowl? No, it was us, humankind, who came up with the concept, but now we are enslaved by the very concept that we created. When we should be looking at the creation of new technologies as a netgain and an opportunity to create jobs, just like the space race, all we see is that jobs will need to be displaced and mayhaps change... and the anti -change zealots are just as loud as the pro-change zealots so that we cannot know or trust the information from any sourcebecause it all becomes suspect unless we ourselves have a doctorate in climate science and still that is not enough because you will have your views vetted by the pharisees of either camp. Then enter the politicians....
Fuck this shit. All I want to do is to live and be comfortable without worrying that what I am doing is contributing to some future generations hardship.
Oh, yeah I forgot. Shit rolls downhill. Another of the scare tactics those who have money and won't let anybody else have it cause it is mine, allllll mine! We all know that the cost of anything that a manufacturer, shipper or the likeincursis passed on directly tothe end user. Nope, if we gotta pay that extra 2 cents we are going to make sure that the customer pays that 2 cents and it will appear on his bill, because you know that we can't take that two cents and absorb it within our healthy profit margin. That would be communist or... something... Bad.
Yup, Classic. I dont want to do my job; youshouldn'teither. That is the way to solveproblems....
Brolly....I think you have it nailed!
In the case of climate changes related to human activities , the idea of killing as much economic activity as possible in order to alleviate unknown future events borders on insanity . That is certainly not science . Science would explore precisely what is causing the potential for problems [if any] before taking destructive actions which affect people's lives today . There is some of that science being done BUT it doesn't get the scare headlines . As a result the real issues that should be addressed are going to be ignored in favor of turning things into a political football . Stop talking about solving problems if all you really want is a rugby match without protection .
You know nothing about how pricing is done in business . Thanks for showing your ignorance on this topic .
The continuation of this issue is happening in the news right now . Obama has come up with stringent new EPA regulations to greatly reduce coal consumption . He sees only the potential of 1 side of the issue . The other side ?
In the immortal words of William J. Clinton : "It's the economy stupid ." .
How would you know what I know?
From a sarcastic rant that I posted on NT?
A few years ago, you were for getting away from carbon based fuels and moving towards fuel cells and other alternate sources (can't find the link and I am going to play my guitar) regardless of the global warming or climate change... so why is that now destructive to jobs? Just because somebody in government said it?
You obviously don't recognize sarcasm and hyperbole when you see it, which is strange because that is how you responded.....
Sarcastic eh ... I'm gonna need a *s tag from you .
Anything that increases the cost of fuel is destructive to the economy . Here is my latest edition to this trilogy :
...
Isn't it grand!
Oops ... I left out the link to my 3rd publishing in this trilogy :
Petey said:
I am going to assume that you mean energy in general, or, at least, that is what I am going to comment on. In our current situation, if the replacements are done in a rational manner, I see no reason to think that the alternate sources of energy cannot be segued into place. ( link )
Before you say it, I know that this link tells of coals problems and such matters as dark spreads, but the reality is that Germany is moving towards a time when coal has become unprofitable. For whatever reason Germany has chosen this path, they have gone down it, and how is Germany's economy doing?
That knowledge and a little thought tells me that you are likely to resist change purely for the sake of resisting change, and without an objection other than it disturbs the status quo, aka, destroying jobs, never noting that some other aspect of the economy picks up where that leaves off, because of a certain inelastic demand for energy.
And who says that energy has to be Grid Based? That is a severe restriction. Thestructureof the economy today probably makes you money, so you don't want tofuck with things, and I understand that type of impulse. I also understand that the world is changing, whether we like it or not, andthereare some actions that we can take that would be moreprofitable than others going forward. I would much rather see anindependent,stand alone unit where the whole process is self contained than asystemwhere we have to rely on thesuccessiveinteractions of acomplex and distant mechanism.
Robert, you have been smoking too much magic-fairy ass crack....
Petey said:
No. That is not what is proposed. No one poses questions like that. They pose the question like this: Can the burning of carbon based fuels have potentially a great impact, and if so, how large is it likely to be?
Well I can . Until electric energy storage is greatly improved [cheaper] solar & wind will be very limited in what they can add to the US power supply . I think those days are coming but we are not there yet . In any case there are also geographical & seasonal limitations for solar & wind . Solar has quite a large potential in the southwest .
Other locations less so .
See that is the problem . People don't know the difference between an energy source and an energy storage/delivery system . Fuel cells are not an energy source . They still require fuel . Energy sources are things like fossil fuels and renewable energy ; Also things like nuclear power ...
Another problem is that transportation still is largely based on petroleum derived fuels . Until such time as electric vehicles becomes a major part of transportation we are going to be dependent on petroleum . I am confident that will occur eventually but I don't know what the time frame is .
If you are talking about people installing rooftop solar , there are many locations that cannot be done .
I have already explained that CO2 is not the issue no matter how many alarmist headlines I read . Climatology has not identified what the factors are that bring about AGW . Just because CO2 has increased does not mean that is the factor to blame . My previous article went into the details ... I even pointed to some other possible contributing factors for the issue of glacier melting and sea ice shrinkage .
I'm going to look over that link about Germany before I comment further .
Here is a dire looking quote from that link :
The situation is clear: power plants that can no longer operate economically and that are not needed to maintain system stability will be withdrawn, EON SEs Chief Executive Officer Johannes Teyssen told reporters in Dusseldorf, Germany, on March 12. If this trend continues unabated, we will very soon see serious capacity shortages. And in that case absolute security of supply would no longer be axiomatic.
But if you look at the whole article, the situation can and is being addressed by bringing more natural gas plants online. You need to see the whole picture and not just one discreet part of it.
On Point had a good synopsis of the proposed regulations .
It is your view that carbon is not the issue,. That is not my view. I interpret the data differently than you do.
From the Eon CEO :
So, Europe is ready to go with the cap and trade, it has been used successfully here and abroad: Why can't we?
If they have a background in statistical modeling they would be aware of what to look for in a math model .
In the case of climatology there are many studies which question aspects of the one-sided conclusion ... and they present objective evidence to support their positions . Bottom line ; there is NO consensus .
And that is where the public can relate . There are many attempts to suppress one side of the debate . When that happens it is not science . Science is about a dialogue , not a contest for alarmist headlines .
Not exactly . I'm saying that CO2 is not the issue . There are other forms of carbon which may be a problem .
How is Europe doing economically ?