The CFPB, which oversees transactions in the financial sector for the federal government, decided to no longer conduct employee reviews because there were just too many apparent significant disparities between the races, ages, and locations of its employees.
According to American Banker , this new policy is set to cost over $5 million dollars, as it will now pay employees as if they received the highest evaluation score. The previous system ranked staff on their performance from a scale ranging from one to five, with five being the best score a CFPB staffer could receive after a review of their work on the job
.
This development comes right before the agency is scheduled for a Wednesday hearing to investigate allegations that it practiced retaliatory actions towards certain employees. News reports have circulated that the alleged discriminations were race-based and that the CFPB implemented their new policies to alleviate that problem.
CFPB Director Richard Cordray explained in a staff email that the change was apparently not related to the previous race-based allegations.
We have determined that there were broad-based disparities in the way performance ratings were assigned across our employee base in both 2012 and 2013, Cordray stated in the email. These differences indicate a systemic disadvantage to various categories of employees that persisted across divisions, offices, and other employee characteristics.
Some have found this new policy to be misguided and believe it to be an overcorrection that will ultimately punish top performers in the department.
Treating the agencys highest-rated employees the same as its lowest-rated ones is the opposite of fairness, Thomas Brown, a columnist for Bankstocks.com, wrote in a Wednesday piece lambasting the decision . Hard-working, conscientious workers (and, yes, the federal government does have those) deserve to be treated better and paid more than workers who, say, persistently show up late and turn in shoddy work.

The nation is sinking into mediocrity led by the government.
This has always been a problem in government. Positions are classified at certain pay grades depending on the complexity of the work. In my experience, performance evaluations become increasingly subjective for employees classified at higher grades. Understandably, different supervisors in different departments will rate performance differently. You minimize that by creating uniform core competencies, among other things. The goal has always been to encourage employees to aspire to outstanding performance, which may result in a bonus. Giving a bonus for unimpressive performance disincentivises outstanding performace andeffectively raises the entire pay scale across the board for no legitimate reason other than management can't manage. If this agency operates on appropriated funds, then Congress should strike the $5 million pay increase from the budget. If the agency is too lazy to do proper performance ratings, then performance should be presumed satisfactory (as opposed to outstanding) with no pay increase.
The lowest common denominator is now the standard of excellence
A truly progressive attitude toward superior performance
No surprise from a government agency. I expect some agencies/departments award a cash bonus to employees who manage to avoid indictments while carrying out their "duties".