╌>

The case of Elliot Rodger. Is it time to change our HIPAA Laws?

  

Category:  News & Politics

Via:  perrie-halpern  •  12 years ago  •  60 comments

The case of Elliot Rodger. Is it time to change our HIPAA Laws?

Legally it all comes down to this: Does a person present a danger to themselves or to others?

This ties the hands of families who try to intervene when a loved one is on the brink. Therefore acts that only family members know are ignored by mental health specialists and law enforcement. 4203_discussions.jpg

A month before Elliot Rodger's rampage, Elliot's parents tried to be proactive upon learning of their son's twisted thoughts and got the police to come to his house. Had the police checked social media, they would have seen that Rodger had severe mental health issues, which they missed despite the warnings of his therapist and parents. Had they searched his house, they would have found his guns and disturbed writings. He was a sick young man, but his parents were trying to do the right thing. Yet their call went unheard, up till the moment the first gun shots where fired, which was already too late. Three young men lay dead from being stabbed. Had law enforcement listened to the parents, they would have found the guns. They would have found intent. And many families would not be mourning the death of their children, including the Rodger family.

I know that there are people out there who feel that this is a gun control issue. I would argue that our HIPAA laws need to be changed. Right now psychologists and psychiatrists spend too much time worrying about being sued for breaking confidentiality and reporting or for not reporting potentially dangerous patients before a tragedy like this one happens. The first line of defense comes from the families yet neither law enforcement nor mental health professionals take seriously the concerns of these families.

HIPAA is meant to protect our privacy from unwanted intrusions from third parties. But when it comes to the psychiatric community, it shouldn't tie their hands to the point that they are afraid to report concerns. It is a reactionary effect from forced commitments by 4204_discussions.jpg families on family members up till the 1970s and while those concerns are valid, we have now gone 180 degrees. Families' hands are tied once a child turns 18. Suddenly, it doesn't matter that the family was involved in their child's mental health till that point. They are no longer allowed to participate, unless the child consents to it and puts their parents on the HIPAA form, and most don't. Yet anyone who has worked with the mentally ill will tell you that many of our sickest children resent treatment and often resent their families. They are not in the right frame of mind to want to have their parents involved in their treatment and are often relieved to have them out of the picture at 18. The law considers them to be adults, yet they didn't wake up on their 18th birthday and suddenly not need their family's help. So we have mentally ill children making potentially life changing decisions on their own. Does something seem wrong to you? It should.

What really needs to be revisited is the HIPAA directive. If a child has had a long history of mental illness before turning 18, parents should be allowed to participants in that child's mental health treatment. Parents' concerns should be treated seriously when they see a change in their child's behavior and should be informed about whether or not their child is staying on track with treatment. When you take the family out of the equation, you have removed one of the most important parts of a child's recovery and even more so, you remove the first line of defense when it comes to determining if their child presents a danger to themselves or to others.

Everyday, parents lose their children to suicide. On terrible days a child acts out on others, as did Elliot Rodger, and on those days everyone pays for our present laws. Parents see it coming yet have no way of relaying this to doctors. Doctors can do nothing because of fear of being sued because of HIPAA. How many more people have to die before we realize that HIPAA needs to be changed when it comes to our psychiatric community? How many more Elliot Rogers have to happen before we acknowledge the real problem?


Tags

jrDiscussion - desc
[]
 
Perrie Halpern R.A.
Professor Guide
link   seeder  Perrie Halpern R.A.    12 years ago

Do I think Parents should be granted rights over adult Children? No I do not. Last thing we need is overbearing and disgruntled parents alarming authorities because they don't like their son or daughters boy friend or girlfriend.

BF, that isn't the case with most parents. Their child didn't become mentally well on their 18th birthday. And obviously we are talking about parents being in contact with mental health people, not them running off willy nilly to the police.

s troubling as these mass killings have been, they are very rare.

Define rare. Seems to me that they are happening more and more. And would you be so philosophical if it was your kid that got killed 2 days ago?

 
 
 
Larry Hampton
Professor Quiet
link   Larry Hampton    12 years ago

Doctors of all kinds make choices out of the fear of litigation, rather than what is best for the patient. It's very, very frustrating and a source of heavy personal stress for many physicians.

 
 
 
Nona62
Professor Silent
link   Nona62    12 years ago

The whole thing is tragic, no matter how one choses to look at it.

 
 
 
Perrie Halpern R.A.
Professor Guide
link   seeder  Perrie Halpern R.A.    12 years ago

I certainly understand that however an adult with mental illness has rights.

And I am not saying that they don't have rights. But a person who was having mental health issues up till their 18th B-day didn't suddenly get the life skills of an adult. It is a process. And these kids are not ready to go it alone. Hence why we pay for their school and other living expenses. If they were truly adults, they would stand on their own two feet. And even then, they would still be just as mentally ill as they were 24 hours before.

 
 
 
Perrie Halpern R.A.
Professor Guide
link   seeder  Perrie Halpern R.A.    12 years ago

Your so right Larry. That is why HIPAA is such a pain in the butt.

 
 
 
Perrie Halpern R.A.
Professor Guide
link   seeder  Perrie Halpern R.A.    12 years ago

Tzia,

I totally agree. In fact, I feel terrible for all the families involved, evenElliot Rodger's. They tried but to no avail.

 
 
 
Nona62
Professor Silent
link   Nona62    12 years ago

That's exactly how I feelalsoPerrie, it's just so awful for everyone involved.

 
 
 
Larry Hampton
Professor Quiet
link   Larry Hampton    12 years ago

Horrible. I can't even imagine.

 
 
 
Perrie Halpern R.A.
Professor Guide
link   seeder  Perrie Halpern R.A.    12 years ago

Thanks John for the feedback. There could be wiser laws on the books regarding this issue, instead of a one size fits all.

 
 
 
Robert in Ohio
Professor Guide
link   Robert in Ohio    12 years ago

There are provisions in the law to allow doctors, analysts,psychiatrists, etc to break privilege and notify law enforcement inthe event they believe their patient is planning a crime or likely to become violent and be a danger to others.

Most states have laws that either require or permit mental health professionals to disclose information about patients who may become violent. Those laws are receiving increased attention following recent mass shootings, such as those in Aurora, Colo., and Newtown, Conn. A New York law enacted Jan. 15, 2013, moves that state's law from a permissive to a mandatory duty for mental health professionals to report when they believe patients may pose a danger to themselves or others but protects therapists from both civil and criminal liability for failure to report if they act "in good faith." New York's new law also allows law enforcement to remove firearms owned by patients reported to be likely to be dangerous.(Note: Please see chart below for update.)

Under ethical standards tracing back to the Roman Hippocratic Oath , doctors and mental health professionals usually must maintain the confidentiality of information disclosed to them by patients in the course of the doctor-patient relationship. With some exceptions codified in state and federal law, health professionals can be legally liable for breaching confidentiality. One exception springs from an effort to protect potential victims from a patients violent behavior. California courts imposed a legal duty on psychotherapists to warn third parties of patients threats to their safety in 1976 in Tarasoff v. The Regents of the University of California . This case triggered passage of duty to warn or duty to protect laws in almost every state as summarized in the map and, in more detail, in the chart below.

Opinions about the laws vary. The American Psychological Association has advocated allowing mental health workers to exercise professional judgment regarding the duty to warn and not to unnecessarily expand dangerous patient exceptions. Mandatory reporting laws, say some professionals, may discourage people from seeking professional help or fully disclosing their intentions; or providers may be reluctant to treat potentially violent patients because they fear liability for failure to properly fulfill the duty to warn.

...

 
 
 
Larry Hampton
Professor Quiet
link   Larry Hampton    12 years ago

That all looks good on paper, but in reality there is basically toolittle room for interpretation, and too much of a risk if every tiny detail isn't done correctly. Yes, breaking privilege is possible, but it's like trying to thread a needle with a backhoe.

 
 
 
screminmimi
Freshman Silent
link   screminmimi    12 years ago

The police "interviewed" him but found no reason to intervene.

They are not qualified to asses mental stability, and when PARENTS call them and ask for help, the named individual should have to talk with someone in the field of psychology before being passed as no threat to themselves or society.

 
 
 
Perrie Halpern R.A.
Professor Guide
link   seeder  Perrie Halpern R.A.    12 years ago

Confusing me, as usual. "Kids" DO stand on their on when they are 18.

Many kids do. There are also a subset that can't. This article is couldn't have made it clearer that I amreferringto kids on the brink. You are confusing yourself.

But you are talking about locking people up. Because this person was not going to be less ofa danger to himself or to others, just because the parents were given more control over his health care. Locking someone up for protection of...himself, without a crime, is not primarily a health care issue or primarily a privacy issue.

First of all, I am not advocating for locking people up. What I am advocating for parents whose children have had mental health issues throughout their teen years, not be cut out of the equation. That they are in fact, a vital part of the equation.

 
 
 
Perrie Halpern R.A.
Professor Guide
link   seeder  Perrie Halpern R.A.    12 years ago

Thanks you Mimi for putting it so succinctly!

 
 
 
Perrie Halpern R.A.
Professor Guide
link   seeder  Perrie Halpern R.A.    12 years ago

It isn't the website that Larry is referring to. It's the doctors that have to make these judgement calls on patients.

 
 
 
Perrie Halpern R.A.
Professor Guide
link   seeder  Perrie Halpern R.A.    12 years ago

Thanks Bruce!

 
 
 
Broliver "TheSquirrel" Stagnasty
Freshman Silent
link   Broliver "TheSquirrel" Stagnasty    12 years ago

Robert's point was that he posted his rantings online before the fact of the killings. Exactly how, without making some kind of watch list, the police are supposed to track these people, I am not sure.

 
 
 
Broliver "TheSquirrel" Stagnasty
Freshman Silent
link   Broliver "TheSquirrel" Stagnasty    12 years ago

So the police were told by his therapist and his parents to look for something, anything apparently, to slow down the twisting of his mind and get him into the system. It would seem to me, therefore, that the police bear most of the responsibility for this error of omission and the HIPAA statutes, however wrong they may be, are ancillary to the discussion. Feel free to elucidate me of the connection.

 
 
 
Petey Coober
Freshman Silent
link   Petey Coober    12 years ago

If I had to guess I would say that cops are going to be averse to interfering with a man of means ... someone who can hire a big gun lawyer .

 
 
 
Larry Hampton
Professor Quiet
link   Larry Hampton    12 years ago

Imho part of the problem is that cops run into freakazoids all the time. Determining which onesare serious/threatening/crazy enough to warrant further evaluation in a facility, would be tough.

 
 
 
Perrie Halpern R.A.
Professor Guide
link   seeder  Perrie Halpern R.A.    12 years ago

What are you advocating? That the parent be given the legal authority to make him take his medication, and watch him 24 hours a day?

They can't do either. He's big. He's nuts. He leaves, if he wants to. Unless you lock him up.

He has a dorm that his parents pay for instead of living at home. He has a car that his parents pay for, which isn't mandatory. He doesn't work, so he needs money from mom and dad. He has shown signs over the last couple of months that have concerned both his parents and his doctor. In his case, maybe a hold would have been in order. It is not true of every case.

 
 
 
Broliver "TheSquirrel" Stagnasty
Freshman Silent
link   Broliver "TheSquirrel" Stagnasty    12 years ago

With the parents in the picture, they may have had some mitigating force through family dynamics.

But, on the other hand, the guy appeared to be insane in that video.... either that or a terrible actor.

 
 
 
Broliver "TheSquirrel" Stagnasty
Freshman Silent
link   Broliver "TheSquirrel" Stagnasty    12 years ago

Which might (have) mitigate(d) his behavior. "Nooooooooo! Mommy, Noooooooo!"

 
 
 
screminmimi
Freshman Silent
link   screminmimi    12 years ago

Petey, the law has the authority to break into ahome, SWAT fashion, without a warrant just because "someone" told them there "might" be illegal drugs or firearms.

There was an article posted just a few days ago about the woman whose mother called the police and told them she was afraid her grown daughter (I believe she was in her 40s) was going to harm herself. They broke down the door, and when she wouldn't come along quietly, tased and handcuffed her, confiscated her handgun which she had a permit to own, took her to jail and detained her... while also filing charges of assaulting a police officer.

In the state of AL, a relative can have a family member locked down for three days for "observation" without any proof at all of mental instability.

A federal law requiring at least one conversation with someone in the psychology field, along with the right of law enforcement and the courts to insist it be done or face involuntary lock down for "observation" should not be that hard to accomplish... if people truly want to address the real problem of assaults with firearms.

 
 
 
Perrie Halpern R.A.
Professor Guide
link   seeder  Perrie Halpern R.A.    12 years ago

Many police have forensic psychologist on staff or on call. This should take care of the problem, Larry.

 
 
 
Perrie Halpern R.A.
Professor Guide
link   seeder  Perrie Halpern R.A.    12 years ago

The police were notified, but the kid seemed "normal" enough and they left without doing a through investigation. In this case, the police are probably going to get into some big time trouble. But yes, HIPAA does make it a problem to get the police involved. If the therapist wasn't involved, the cops would have never even taken note.

 
 
 
Perrie Halpern R.A.
Professor Guide
link   seeder  Perrie Halpern R.A.    12 years ago

Did Police Miss a Chance to Stop Santa Barbara Rampage?

Local police checked in on Rodger on April 30 in response to calls from his parents and a social worker, according to police.

They determined that he did not meet the criteria for an involuntary mental health hold, Deputy Sheriff Bill Brown said.

If they had demanded to search my room, that would have ended everything, Rodger wrote of the police visit in his manifesto.

...

Does anyone see the issue now? It's even plain to a mentally ill person.

 
 
 
Swamijim sez
Freshman Silent
link   Swamijim sez    12 years ago
Legally it all comes down to this: Does a person present a danger to themselves or to others?

Unfortunately, it isn't quite that simple, Perrie. The crucial element is 'when' does an individual move from being 'disturbed' or even 'threatening' to being an immanent danger to self or others...

Elliott Rodger's family clearly knew he was 'troubled' for a fair stretch of time-- he'd been in some form of treatment or therapy & been prescribed psych med (probably anti-depressants);he'd also had some prior contact with LE.

From what I've seen in recentarticles, his therapist saw some of the recent videos and realized the kid was 'decompensating', and alerted the parents-- almost certainly indicating that HIPAA forms had been signed by Elliott allowing his healthcare info to be shared w/ parents. That led to the family notifying LEOs, who 'interviewed' the kid, and since he wasn't gibbering or talking to Elvis or threatening anyone at that time, they apparently decided they didn't have grounds to either search his place or haul him in for a psych consult. From what I've read/heard, the family may not have communicated with LEOs about the videos, or didn't stress them strongly enough; evidently the police didn't view the video posts either before or after their visit to the kid's apt. The bitter truth is that until he 'snapped', Elliott Rodgers would have come across to the cops as a somewhatsulky,self-pitying candy-ass rich boy... which is basically what he was.

When the last video and the 'day of retribution' 140 page homicide/suicide note hit the fan, the family again sought help & went after Elliott--- too late. As with many of the other 'spree' killers, the movement from 'troubled' or 'disturbed' to explosively violent was faster then possible intervention.

Bottom line is: I'm not sure that HIPAA regs actually had much impact in this case at all. The info we have certainly suggests that a) the parents were 'in the loop' w/ access to info from the therapist, and b) the 'duty to warn/duty to protect' regs over-ride HIPAA in this case (as they do in any similar case).

We'd all like to find 'answers' to 'snapping' cases like Elliott Rodger, and 'reasons'/'warning signs' that would forestall these kinds of tragedies.

Unfortunately, the sheer volume of potential 'snappers' is far greater than most of us want torealize, and there simply isn't a method to separate 'the wheat from the chaff' of which of the 'troubled' & 'disturbed' are most likely to become suddenly volatile. It's tempting to say "the cops should have done more", and it may be true... flip side, cops aren't (and probably cannot be) adequately trained to assess mental-health cases, and the other option is that they drag in everybody who gets pissed enough to blurt out "I could choke that sonofabitch till his eyes pop out!"

Suicidal or homicidal thoughts may flash in & out of some folks heads briefly--- while in others it can simmer for months or even years and still not result in action. And when the 'tipping point' is reached, whether it's suicide or homicide (or both) the move fromideation to actionis all-too-often faster than anything that might prevent the tragedy. In Elliott Rodger's case, by the time he was an 'immanent' danger, he was beyond intervention--- people were already dying.

Ultimately, neither parents nor psychiatrists nor cops or courts or 'society' can 'protect' someone from their own darkest impulses--- and when we can't 'protect them from themselves', we can't protect others from them either.

 
 
 
Broliver "TheSquirrel" Stagnasty
Freshman Silent
link   Broliver "TheSquirrel" Stagnasty    12 years ago

Well, there you go:

They determined that he did not meet the criteria for an involuntary mental health hold, Deputy Sheriff Bill Brown said.

This was and is totally separate from the next quoted statement by the (String of expletives deleted) man-child who perpetrated this unholy mess....

If they had demanded to search my room, that would have ended everything,

... Because there was no probable cause to search.

Should they have checked out his online persona? You betcha, and that may have provided the probable cause. But they did not, and as a direct result could not legally have entered his domicile. (This segues into an article from earlier this week.)

 
 
 
Perrie Halpern R.A.
Professor Guide
link   seeder  Perrie Halpern R.A.    12 years ago

Jim,

Obviously, there is no magic answer to this.. but there were points where the ball was dropped, like when the cops made their visit the month before. Had they actually gone into the house and looked around, they would have found guns and the semi written manifesto.

After Joel Steinberg murdered his daughter, NYC looked at how this could have happened. Her teachers had noticed that she had missed many days of school but didn't do anything about it, like report to the school's social worker. Since then, teachers have a similar requirement to report. In fact, if we don't, we can be held liable for harm done to a child. The same thing with NYC police.

Years ago, when my daughter was about 1 1/2, Matt was watching her when he decided that he had a neat photo op when she was sitting on the changing table. He was about to take his picture, when she decided to do a backflip off the changing table and fell directly onto her head. He called 911, but 3 cop cars showed long before EMS to evaluate the home. We were not offended. They were being responsible for her welfare.

 
 
 
screminmimi
Freshman Silent
link   screminmimi    12 years ago

You need to create a culture where people don't feel the need or desire to solve problems with guns.

How long do you estimate it will take to "create" this fairy tale utopia?

No argument, no debate, will address the fact that criminals have guns. As long as criminals have guns and as long as LEOs take sometimes half an hour to arrive at crime scenes in progress, citizens will demand, and rightly so, the right to arm themselves for self defense.

 
 
 
Swamijim sez
Freshman Silent
link   Swamijim sez    12 years ago

The problem is that in every case like this, we can always see in hindsight where the ball was dropped, that decisions that appeared appropriate at the time are later understood to be horribly wrong.

...teachers have a similar requirement to report. In fact, if we don't, we can be held liable for harm done to a child. The same thing with NYC police.

I believe that all states now have 'duty to warn/duty to protect' laws on the books, for teachers, social workers, doctors, psychiatrists and other 'human services' provider, and I'd also point out that we literally have no way of knowing how many hundreds or even thousands of cases like Elliott are handled correctly & tragedy is forestalled--- because those cases don't make the news.

I'll agree that Elliott 'slipped through the cracks', with disasterous & tragic results... I'm (regretfully) forced to the conclusion that no system can be made foolproof, and with the incidence of mental-health cases in our society, there'll be more 'Elliotts' in the future...

 
 
 
Swamijim sez
Freshman Silent
link   Swamijim sez    12 years ago

John, with all respect-- the idea that we can/will somehow"create a culture where people don't feel the need or desire to solve problems with guns" is (unfortunately) way more far-fetched than police hauling folks in for a psych consult...

 
 
 
Swamijim sez
Freshman Silent
link   Swamijim sez    12 years ago
 
 
 
sixpick
Professor Quiet
link   sixpick    12 years ago

Well I look at this thing a little different. Like some said about the pit bulls on another article, they want to neuter the breed, which actually are not all the same.

I say get rid of psychiatrist. A pill is the answer to everything these days. They suppress the child all his life and then expect him to continue suppressing himself when the responsibility is put in his hands to do so. Ain't gonna happen.

Did we as humans evolve, for those evolutionist, into a society that practically every child has a mental problem and has to be on some psychotic medication? How the heck did we make it so long without psychiatrist to prescribe drugs to help us make it from day to day?

Think about it, how many people do you know who has to have a child medicated because he has some sort of mental problem? I think it is rampant today and don't say anything to these parents, the psychiatrist knows best. He's highly educated and they willingly get their child addicted to some psychotic drug at an early age and he doesn't have a chance after that.

Do I think there is a place for it? Yes, but too many children are becoming nuts because the parents have put their total faith in a psychiatrist's diagnostic. Reminds me of chiropractors. The first thing they ask you when you see them is "how is you back doing?" If you say it really hurts, then they come up with a reason it hurts and tell you it will probably take a few more visits to get you in shape.

If you say it is doing quite well, they say it is because of the treatment they have been giving you and it will not take many more before they release you.

If you go to the chiropractor and your back doesn't hurt, don't let that son of gun touch you, because if you do you'll be hurting until your next appointment.

Well I'm not saying this is hardcore fact in every case. Sure there are children and adults who need medication to maintain a normal lifestyle, but if you carry your child to see a psychologist or psychiatrist, walk out of his office after the first visit with a prescription, throw it in the garbage on the way out, look for another doctor and get a second or third opinion if necessary and let each of the doctors know you're really not interested in turning your child a psychotic medication addict unless all other options have been tested.

 
 
 
Perrie Halpern R.A.
Professor Guide
link   seeder  Perrie Halpern R.A.    12 years ago

Six,

There are loads of treatment that kids get without a single Pill Cognitive Behavioral therapy, Dialectical Behavioral therapy, etc. But I actually don't think that pills are the cause of most of these problems. It is our society. And endless stream of violence thrown at our kids from early childhood. From TV and movies to the games our kids play. It desensitizes them. Add to that the lack of person to person interaction kids have with each other. They no longer know the appropriate way to deal with each other without facebook, instagram, twitter.

BTW only psychiatrists can give out drugs. Most kids never get any further than a therapist or a psychologist. No drugs...just talk.

So while I would love to blame big pharm for this, I am not sure if we can.

 
 
 
sixpick
Professor Quiet
link   sixpick    12 years ago

But there are a heck of a lot of children and adults on drugs for mental disorders.

Are too many kids taking antipsychotic drugs?

Consumer Reports

Use is climbing despite questions about how safe the drugs are and how well they work

Published: December 2013
The number of children taking powerful antipsychotic drugs has nearly tripled over the last 10 to 15 years, according to recent research. The increase comes not because of an epidemic of schizophrenia or other forms of serious mental illness in children, but because doctors are increasingly prescribing the drugs to treat behavior problems, a use not approved by the Food and Drug Administration (FDA). And a disproportionate number of those prescriptions are written for poor and minority children, some as young as age 2.
 
 
 
Perrie Halpern R.A.
Professor Guide
link   seeder  Perrie Halpern R.A.    12 years ago

And a disproportionate number of those prescriptions are written for poor and minority children, some as young as age 2.

Yet the majority of these spree killings are not done by poor or minority kids, so the correlation isn't there. And while I do agree with you that kids as young as two shouldn't be put onantipsychotic drugs since they are being used off label, I think it's easy to blame drugs and much harder to look at our society and drugs just being part of our societies problems, that has cause theepidemicof our youth being so detached.

 
 
 
Dowser
Sophomore Silent
link   Dowser    12 years ago

As many of you know, my mother had some mental issues. Her doctor could not speak to me about them, even though he recognized them, tried to help her, and offered her treatment. I did not know this until RIGHT before her death.

At that same time, I would not want my mother calling up someone to ask if I were crazy, even though she thought I was because I taped Total Recall and had the stupidity to loan her the tape to watch the first movie on it, My Fair Lady. Sigh.

So, in the case of a documented mental illness, if someone feels that their child, mother, etc. may need more help, thinking that they may be a danger to themselves or others, speaking with their doctor SHOULD be allowed. However, it would be easy to cross that fine line between concern and revenge. My mother would have invented a concern to exact revenge, I'm sorry to say.

In her case, I begged her to get some medicine to help, and even though the doctor offered her help, she refused it. Sigh. Yet, I couldn't honestly say that she was a danger to herself or to others. So maybe I'm full of it.

All I know is that it was very frustrating, and difficult to deal with, and even after I had the power of attorney, it was impossible to mitigate. I did the best I could, under horrible circumstances. And of course, the brain tumor didn't help. But it was nowhere near the entire problem.

 
 
 
Dowser
Sophomore Silent
link   Dowser    12 years ago

By the time she got them, it was too late. Which was sad.

We have a lot in common, the two of us. I'm glad to say! Grin.gif

 
 
 
Robert in Ohio
Professor Guide
link   Robert in Ohio    12 years ago

Involuntary civil commitment - perhaps those are the laws and processes that need to be revised and better used to avoid situations like this one

 
 
 
Perrie Halpern R.A.
Professor Guide
link   seeder  Perrie Halpern R.A.    12 years ago

I'll agree that Elliott 'slipped through the cracks', with disasterous & tragic results... I'm (regretfully) forced to the conclusion that no system can be made foolproof, and with the incidence of mental-health cases in our society, there'll be more 'Elliotts' in the future...

Swamii, You are right that events that were stopped before they happened don't make the news. Only these tragedies. And I agree that people will always slip through the cracks. It is inevitable.

 
 
 
Perrie Halpern R.A.
Professor Guide
link   seeder  Perrie Halpern R.A.    12 years ago

Mike,

Of course we can't stop all of these events. But often parents see things at home that are indicators of their child's mental state and have no way of getting feedback from the doctors. This is a big problem. As long as the parents are involved with their kids lives, they should be able to have some give and take with their doctors.

Our laws are terribly inconsistent when it comes to adulthood. Take going to college. Parents are REQUIRED to pay, it even has a name... "Parental Share", yet we have no access to our kids grades. Explain that to me.

 
 
 
A. Macarthur
Professor Guide
link   A. Macarthur    12 years ago
 
 
 
Swamijim sez
Freshman Silent
link   Swamijim sez    12 years ago

And predictably, the nut-cases would switch from using guns to bombs in theaters, malls, schools, etc.-- or arson in crowded places. 'Crazy' people are crazy, they aren't stupid.

 
 
 
Perrie Halpern R.A.
Professor Guide
link   seeder  Perrie Halpern R.A.    12 years ago

Probably not, but perhaps they would think twice before harming others. I think we can all agree that the one common denominator isthey are all cowards which is exemplified by many of them taking their own lives after the act of violence has been perpetrated.

Mike,

I am going to respectfully disagree with you. Insanity, by definition means that people are operating out of the norm. They do not see consequences in the same way that normal people do. They have an altered reality and while that is hard for most to understand.... I have seen it first hand. Arming ourselves or not, they will do what they will do.

 
 
 
Perrie Halpern R.A.
Professor Guide
link   seeder  Perrie Halpern R.A.    12 years ago

Marsha,

You did the best that you could do, so don't beat yourself up about it. Our system offers very little to family members who have to deal with their mentally ill family members. If you want to blame anyone, blame the system.

 
 
 
Perrie Halpern R.A.
Professor Guide
link   seeder  Perrie Halpern R.A.    12 years ago

Royal,

Drugs are not the be all and end all. Obviously, other talk intervention is needed, as what goes on in the home. People with mental illness are very good at hiding it from their shrinks, since a session is only 45 min long... but they let it all hang out at home, which is why I advocate for parents being more involved.

 
 
 
sixpick
Professor Quiet
link   sixpick    12 years ago

Why has mental illness in the USA gone up drastically in the last 25 plus years? Some would say it is the violence of everyday living and I tend to agree it plays a part, but the increase in psychotropic drugs given to adults and children play a much more substantial part than most of us realize.

We have become complacent in accepting the authorities conclusions and accepting too many things as fact such as studies done by universities, hospitals, doctors and national organizations largely funded by pharmaceutical companies.

Quite often the studies are skewed somewhat like some of the other hot topics today.

So I am providing a couple videos which are extremely informational and hoping some will have enough interest to view the entire video before finding a reason to discredit it. I hate to say it, but I'm sure within the first 5 minutes of the video a phrase or a word will give them a reason to discard the remainder of the video before they really get to the meat of the matter, but that's the fool I am, doing the same thing over and over and expecting to get a different result.

The first video gives a little information on the subject, but the second video, especially the last half of it is really enlightening. The speaker, Robert Whitaker, is a journalist. (So there you have it, a reason to ignore anything past this point). Robert Whitaker's background in medical science writing is extensive. He was a Knight Science Journalism Fellow at MIT, then Director of Publications at Harvard Medical School. He has won several national awards including The George Poke Award for medical writing and a National Association of Science Writer's Award for best magazine article. A series he co-wrote for the Boston Globe was named a finalist for the Pulitzer Prize in 1998. I think you will find both of these videos are well worth the time invested in viewing them especially if you have children or grandchildren.

 
 
 
sixpick
Professor Quiet
link   sixpick    12 years ago

Yes A Mac, seen that one before, like a thousand times. And I rarely watch NBC, MSNBC and the mainstream media. You've probably seen it 3 or 4 times as much as I have.

 
 
 
screminmimi
Freshman Silent
link   screminmimi    12 years ago

This guy was beyond therapy.

There were other incidents prior to this one. Last year, at a frat party, he became enraged because none of the people there sought him out to talk to him. His rage encompassed both the females and the males. He went out on a balcony where some males were grabbing some fresh air, and tried to throw all of them off it. They instead threw HIM off it and he broke his ankle.

He was so drunk that after he had come to and wandered around a bit he couldn't find the party he was at, wandered into another yard where there was a party, and started causing a disturbance because he couldn't find his sunglasses and was accusing people there of stealing them. The police were called, and he was also questioned about the attempt to throw people off the balcony. He denied it, saying the guys didn't want him at the party and had thrown him off it.

When the parents called police for help, law enforcement should have accessed their files to see if any reports of disturbances had ever been reported on him. It would have given them a starting point and made them more aware of his answers when they questioned him.

In all likelihood, they probably just checked to see if there were any outstanding warrants and if he had ever been arrested. The problem is that most of the young people involved in these types of crimes rarely have a record of being convicted of major crimes. Upon investigation of their backgrounds, most people are so surprised that the person they knew could have done something so heinous. Further investigation usually uncovers minor incidents where police were involved but it never progressed to major case status and was settled right in the police station, never even coming up before a judge in a courtroom.

 
 
 
screminmimi
Freshman Silent
link   screminmimi    12 years ago

Laws are going to have to change to allow a data base of individuals who have needed police intervention for what is usually called minor disturbances.

But the most comprehensive data base in the solar system won't be any good if law enforcement doesn't take the time to check it in cases such as Elliot Rodgers.

 
 
 
screminmimi
Freshman Silent
link   screminmimi    12 years ago

Mental illness doesn't kill people, guns do

... and knives; bombs; cars; baseball bats; hammers; rocks....Smile.gif

 
 
 
Swamijim sez
Freshman Silent
link   Swamijim sez    12 years ago
Laws are going to have to change to allow a data base of individuals who have needed police intervention for what is usually called minor disturbances.

Holy Christ mimi-- listen to what you're saying... What you're asking for is a nationwide (Federal) database that index everybody who ever got a disorderly conduct charge, everyone who ever got charged with disturbing the peace, every kid who got into a fight at a football game, anybody whose neighbors called the cops 'cause the stereo was turned up too loud-- basically anybody who ever got stopped or questioned by police about anything. Setting aside the incredible amount oftime involved in LEOs having to enter all that data, what you're asking for is a surveillance state that's beyond anything the NSA even dreams about.

Are you sure that kind of system is really what you want?

 
 
 
sixpick
Professor Quiet
link   sixpick    12 years ago

And in the studies in the videos the psychotropic drugs to make little Johnny sit in his seat seems to work pretty good for the short term as it is nice he's not running around causing trouble, but in the long run he actually become much more depressed from using these drugs and stopping them is worse sometimes than continuing them as it changes the chemistry of the brain and quite a few end up on disability from mental illness. Not my analysis, but the analysis of scientist studying them.

 
 
 
Perrie Halpern R.A.
Professor Guide
link   seeder  Perrie Halpern R.A.    12 years ago

Sounds reasonable to me.

 
 
 
Robert in Ohio
Professor Guide
link   Robert in Ohio    12 years ago

sounds like a great idea

 
 
 
Nigel Dogberry
Freshman Silent
link   Nigel Dogberry    12 years ago

Nope. We don't punish people for what the might do. We punish them for what they have done. This is America and we all have the right to be as fucked up as we want to be. But, when we do fucked up things we are held accountable.

 
 
 
Nigel Dogberry
Freshman Silent
link   Nigel Dogberry    12 years ago

He should have paid for the things he did. That's the fucked up part for sure. Agree with you there, Gunny. I'm wondering if it would have made any difference. I'm suspecting not. The police and district attorney dropped the ball.

I have a hard time going after people who MIGHT do something or who have expressed fucked up thoughts. Haven't we all, at some point, gone there?

 
 
 
screminmimi
Freshman Silent
link   screminmimi    12 years ago

No, Swamijim, it is not.

I was reacting to the fact that, once again, there had been a run-in with law enforcement not once but twice, both in the same night, prior to this tragedy.

This one is especially troubling because they were asked by the parents to intervene, and they found no reason to be suspicious of him based on the one brief talk. He was in their data base and they never checked.

 
 

Who is online





87 visitors