╌>

Donald Trump wants to deport 11 million migrants: is that even possible?

  

Category:  News & Politics

Via:  randy2  •  11 years ago  •  27 comments

Donald Trump wants to deport 11 million migrants: is that even possible?

458_discussions.jpg?width=750 Donald Trump makes his point in Dubuque, Iowa: Im a great manager. I know how to manage things. Photograph: Charlie Neibergall/AP

Removing all the countrys undocumented migrants is easier said than done but the wartime forced relocation of 110,000 Japanese Americans offers some clues.

A confrontation between Republican presidential candidate Donald Trump and Univision anchor Jorge Ramos in Iowa on Tuesday may be remembered most for Trumps decision to throw Ramos from his news conference. Trump said Ramos was out of line for speaking out of turn.


But the confrontation also yielded a significant policy question with urgent implications for the Trump candidacy and, seemingly given that Trump is currently a double-digit frontrunner in the polls for the US as a whole.

A central plank of Trumps immigration plan calls for deporting the estimated 11 million undocumented migrants currently living in the United States, and then repatriating the good ones back to the US again. After regaining entry to the news conference, Ramos asked Trump how that would work.

How are you going to deport 11 million people? Ramos said . By train, by bus? Are you going to bring the army?

Trump replied that the process would be very humane and that it would work because he was a great manager.

Were going to do it in a very humane fashion. Believe me. I have a bigger heart than you do. Were going to do it in a very humane fashion, Trump said.

You know what its called? Management Im a great manager. I know how to manage things. I hire unbelievable people. What were doing here will work great.

Once I win, youre gonna see things happen.

Trumps proposed roundup and mass deportation of the nations undocumented immigrants represents a substantial logistical challenge.

If history is a guide, the effort would consume significant budgetary and law enforcement resources, could precipitate a national social crisis and might expose the country to reparations claims for decades to come.

The last large-scale roundup of US residents by the federal government, the internment of people of Japanese descent during the second world war, ultimately encompassed only about 110,000 arrestees, most of whom originally lived in a few major cities on the west coast. They were moved into camps in western states not across an international border.

There are 100 times that number of undocumented immigrants currently living in the United States, according to a Pew Research Center analysis of government data, and the migrants are not regionally clustered they live everywhere.


Making his challenge even more difficult, Trump has said he would not break up families through forced deportation, instead sending legal US residents outside the country along with undocumented family members (presumably with a right of return).

Trump has not said how he would handle cases in which the legal US residents in question preferred to stay put. In such cases, presumably, the families would be broken up after all, because while Trump is famous for saying youre fired!, no president has the power to tell a US citizen: Youre deported!

Families would face excruciating decisions. Would an undocumented migrant from Guatemala take her daughter, whose status in the US might be protected by one of Barack Obamas executive actions sheltering young migrants, back to Guatemala with her, not knowing whether or when either of them might be allowed to return? Or would mother leave daughter in the United States, in hopes of her finding greater opportunity? How much time would they be given to decide, following the mothers arrest for being undocumented?

But first, the government would have to identify whom to arrest. Census and employer records and a law enforcement focus on hubs for undocumented migrants could serve to identify early cases, but the process would probably become quickly more difficult and intrusive. Happily for Trump, a 2012 supreme court ruling on an Arizona law upheld the ability of law enforcement to check the immigration status of people they stop. (Critics of the lawsay it amounts to officially sanctioned racial profiling.)

Big numbers, regional dispersion and civil rights intrusions are not the only challenges that would face President Trump. There is also a problem of the national will. Unlike in the spring of 1942, in the shadow of the Japanese attack on Pearl Harbor, there has been no galvanizing event to swing public support behind drastic action against an entire group of residents, in the form of mass arrest and background checks.

As with many issues in US law enforcement, additionally, there would be daunting jurisdictional challenges to overcome. Rogue metropolitan areas that currently serve as sanctuary cities places where immigration status is often overlooked would have to be brought in line by the federal government. Local police would have to be required to cooperate, in what would be an unprecedented and constitutionally unfounded assertion of federal authority.

The effort would face profound budgetary and infrastructure challenges. Municipalities would be stretched to cover police overtime. The state, justice and labor departments as well as federal agencies including the border patrol, immigration and customs enforcement, and citizenship and immigration services, would probably be swamped with identifying, processing and executing actionable cases. There would be an opportunity cost to deferring the other work of those agencies. Potential national guard deployments would tax the military and military families.

Once everybody was arrested, a delicate public relations campaign would be needed to hedge against the risk that images of farm workers in zipties filing on to trains, crying grandmothers, overwhelmed immigration services centers, convoys of buses, or angry employers would provoke more general outrage and civil unrest.

The more humane the effort to move the migrants, the higher housing and transportation costs would rise. The government would probably face legal fees tied to defending civil rights lawsuits, loss-of-livelihood lawsuits, wrongful imprisonment lawsuits, constitutional challenges and more. And any mistake or abuse of rights could expose the government to vast claims for damages. A future federal commission to examine the episode could likewise prove costly.


The internment of Japanese Americans and people of Japanese descent does, however, perhaps hold some useful lessons for Trumps proposed effort. Here are four:

A small proportion of people will relocate themselves

An estimated 5,000 people of Japanese descent complied with a government request that they voluntarily evacuate themselves from designated military zones on the Pacific coast to inland states. That ended up being less than 5% of the total people the government decided to move, but it was a start.

Get the US Census Bureau involved

It took more than 50 years before documents emerged to force the US Census Bureau to admit that it had helped with the second world war internment by giving law enforcement agencies names and information about individual Japanese Americans and Japanese living in America. Nowadays, with computers, the Census Bureau would be an even more powerful ally.

Use diverse transportation and public infrastructure

Trucks, buses and trains were used to move Japanese and Japanese Americans to racetracks and fairgrounds before they were placed in prison. There are fewer racetracks and fairgrounds these days, but many more stadiums, and no shortage of buses.

Budget generously for potential reparations

The Civil Liberties Act of 1988, signed into law by Ronald Reagan, no spendthrift, offered a formal presidential apology and $20,000 to every survivor of the internment with contemporary legal status in the United States. Thats about $40,000 in current dollars. Ultimately about 80,000 payouts were made for a grand total of $1.6bn.

No monetary payments can ever fully compensate loyal Japanese Americans for one of the darkest incidents in American constitutional history, President George HW Bush said upon signing follow-up legislation to enlarge the reparations fund. We must do everything possible to ensure that such a grave wrong is never repeated.


Tags

jrDiscussion - desc
[]
 
Randy
Sophomore Quiet
link   seeder  Randy    11 years ago

Donald Trump wants to deport 11 million migrants: is that even possible?

No.

 
 
 
Kavika
Professor Expert
link   Kavika     11 years ago

He might want to take a long look at history. When therewere deportations of Mexicans back in the 1930's on the West Coast, even some American Citizens of Mexican decent were sent back to Mexico. Yeah, you read that right, ''American Citizens'' were deported.

No, it's not possible to deport 11 million migrants.

 
 
 
Randy
Sophomore Quiet
link   seeder  Randy    11 years ago

Of course it is, but it sounds good to the morons who are Trump fans. He says wouldn't break up families, but any attempt to deport American citizens would be immediately be challenged in court, would be on a fast track to the SCOTUS and lose. Waste of time.

Also, in order just to find all of them it would be a Herculean task, cost a fortune and take decades to do. Then there is the task of what to do with them before they're deported. You can't just house them in local jails and prison while you gather enough to make shipment of them affordable, so that would mean huge interment camps. How much is that going to cost and how much will it cost to house, feed and guard them while they're still here? It won't be the local people because they will not pay for a tax increase, so it would have to come out of the federal budget.

Who is going to gather them all up? Local police are already working under a strained budget in most place, so they're not going to do it. There will be some states that will refuse to activate the National Guard to do it, so Trump would have to Federalize them and also use the regular Army to go door to door, of everyone in the country and make them prove that they are Americans, because illegal aliens are not just here from Mexico and Central America. They are here from all over the world. You can't just ask Hispanics and expect to get rid of all of them. Every person in the United States would have to be checked so illegal aliens would not get left behind. The United States military would be doing law enforcement duties in America. Is the public going to stand for that? No.

Then there is the huge (there's that word again) economic hit on agribusiness, which would lead to massive increases in just about every area of food consumption. Agribusiness and the processors are owned by large, mostly republican, companies. Are they going to sit still for losing the bulk of their workers and money? Not likely.

Saying you're going to deport all illegal aliens and then let just the "good ones" back in (BTW, how do they know that the ones they let back in are only the good ones?) is a good slogan and always get's a big cheer from the Trumpians, but will it actually work?

Not a snowball's chance in Hell.

P.S. The idea of really building a wall across our Southern border would cost so much you'd have to pay illegal aliens under the table to do it and while the illegal aliens are building it, more and more illegals are just going to legally fly over it with a visa and not go back. And make Mexico pay for it? They'll laugh in his face. No matter how much in Tariffs he puts on Fords coming here from there (which would really piss off the auto makers, who have incredible clout in D.C.)

The Donald has been smoking way too much weed if he thinks he can do it.

 
 
 
96WS6
Junior Silent
link   96WS6    11 years ago

459_discussions.jpg Will this help? May have to make a few trips, but I would settle for just deporting the ones that are convicted criminals.

 
 
 
Kavika
Professor Expert
link   Kavika     11 years ago

In my area if they deported Hispanic illegals, nothing would get done around here.

Many of the U.S. citizens are nothing but meth heads and have nowork ethic. There are plenty of jobs, but our meth heads find that welfare/food stamps are a better way.

96, I'd load that bus up with what we have here that passes for citizens and you can have them.

Randy, this is a story well worth reading. ...

 
 
 
96WS6
Junior Silent
link   96WS6    11 years ago

Like I said, I would settle for just deporting the illegals with criminal records.

 
 
 
Kavika
Professor Expert
link   Kavika     11 years ago

I agree that the convicted criminals should and must be deported, 96.

 
 
 
Uncle Bruce
Professor Silent
link   Uncle Bruce    11 years ago

is that even possible?

Yep. You do it one wetback, or goat fucker at a time.

 
 
 
96WS6
Junior Silent
link   96WS6    11 years ago

convicted criminals should and must be deported

I wish someone would tell BO that.

 
 
 
Randy
Sophomore Quiet
link   seeder  Randy    11 years ago

Like I said, I would settle for just deporting the illegals with criminal records.

Same here. And would want comprehensive immigration control the includes a real, doable, path to citizenship for the rest.

 
 
 
Randy
Sophomore Quiet
link   seeder  Randy    11 years ago

Randy, this is a story well worth reading. ...

A sad and very racist story. I am glad that California at least did apologize. Kicking out legal American citizens, even ones that were born here, would never be able to happen these days with the large numbers of civil rights organizations. You can not get away with deporting someone who was born in this country, just because you don't like his or her race. Dozens of civil right organizations would join legal forces and it would never make it past the SCOTUS, because if it could happen to those Americans, then it could happen to any American, no matter their race or legal status.

Also, who is going to check the papers of every last person in America? Because that's the only way it could be done. It would take decades, cost hundreds and hundreds of billions of dollars and then it would stop, because not too many decades from now, Hispanics are going to be the major political force in this country. They days of this being a strictly white run country have passed and are disappearing in the rear view mirror.

Foreign born criminals, yes. Other then that, no.

 
 
 
96WS6
Junior Silent
link   96WS6    11 years ago

I agree there should be a comprehensive guide to immigration as well. I think that anyone that serves in the military with honorable discharge should be one path, I think that anyone that can hire an American should be another.

Unfortunately "a path to citizenship for the rest" is not only the opposite of comprehensive, but down right irresponsible. Sorry but I don't think that anyone who came over here to live off our entitlement system should be given a path. We already have more of those than we can handle already. If you can support yourself and whoever else you brought over and are a productive member(s) of society, great! If you came here to live off of the work of others, get the funk out!

I also think any current programs or benefits available for immigrants that are not available to American citizens should be abolished as part of a "comprehensive" plan.

 
 
 
Randy
Sophomore Quiet
link   seeder  Randy    11 years ago

Sorry but I don't think that anyone who came over here to live off our entitlement system should be given a path.

I suppose I would think the same thing if that was a common experience, but it's not. I have known many illegals out here in California and I have never met one who wanted to live off from our entitlement system. In fact they generally steer well clear of them because they don't want to be noticed and deported. Also many of them have been here for decades. Most of them have children and grand children who were born here and are therefore American citizens. Everyone of them that I have met works hard (many in the fields in the hot sun, working jobs that are not being taken away from anyone here who would do...or even could) and many of them own businesses and homes and hire others.

The ones who come here to live off from our entitlements are boogie men that the right has created. Are there some, sure, but I have never met one, even after more then 25 years living in Phoenix and Los Angeles. Are some criminals? Certainly and they need to go. But the idea that most of them or even any kind of significant number of them are here to collect entitlements is a myth.

 
 
 
96WS6
Junior Silent
link   96WS6    11 years ago

Yep, All we have to do is verify those who aren't criminals and who can support themselves and deport the rest. Looks like we are in agreement.

 
 
 
Randy
Sophomore Quiet
link   seeder  Randy    11 years ago

Deport the criminals, give everyone else a path to citizenship through paying all back taxes, passing a criminal background test, speak English, be given a temporary worker card (so those not yet working can safely apply for jobs without fear) and allow them to apply for citizenship. They wait the usual 5 years, take the test (that most natural born Americans can't passSmile.gif ) and if the pass the test, swear them in as citizens.

The idea of them going back to their home country and then get at the back of the line is absurd and they'll never do it...and they will get away with staying here illegally. The idea is to bring them out of the shadows, not drop them into a hole.

 
 
 
Randy
Sophomore Quiet
link   seeder  Randy    11 years ago

They have and his administration is.

 
 
 
96WS6
Junior Silent
link   96WS6    11 years ago

Bums can't pay back taxes. Like I said before, ship the ones that can't/won't support themselves back. Deporting is not sticking them in a hole and you yourself said there isn't that many that are bums so this should be no problem.

I would also be fine with anyone that wants the bums to stay to put their own money where their mouth is for once and take one into their own home and take care of them with their own money instead of heaping it on collective the back of taxpaying citizens. In other words, feel free to speak with/for your own money, not mine or anyone else's.

Oh and securing the border must also be part of a comprehensive plan so the bums and criminals can't come back. I'm sure the windfall from all the new taxes collected will cover this expense.

 
 
 
Randy
Sophomore Quiet
link   seeder  Randy    11 years ago

Many, if not most, of the ones who can't support themselves are not bums. Most of them want work, but are afraid to apply. If we legislate that fear away, they will become productive, tax paying, workers and future American citizens

I wish I had the money to sponsor one or more. However I believe this problem can be solved by a bi-partisan bill. Like the one John Boehner won't bring to the floor because he knows it would pass with a lot of Democratic votes and fewer GOP votes, which would be embarrassing. That is putting party before country...as usual.

BTW, define securing the border, because there is no way we're going to build a wall. So, National Guard? Federal troops? The Army? The Marines? Obama already doubled the number of Border Patrol Officers. How would you secure the border? I think saying that is a straight up cop out, because it will never be secure enough for most right wingers. Never. It's become a throw in comment that is meaningless.

 
 
 
Randy
Sophomore Quiet
link   seeder  Randy    11 years ago

We deport illegal immigrants, they don't fit in and it's against the law to be in our country without permission or without a valid and curent visa.

How.

 
 
 
Randy
Sophomore Quiet
link   seeder  Randy    11 years ago

Simplistic nonsense. Not worthy of a serious reply.

 
 
 
Larry Hampton
Professor Quiet
link   Larry Hampton    11 years ago
No. Of course it's not possible...Donald Rump is an even bigger idiot that he looks like.
 
 
 
96WS6
Junior Silent
link   96WS6    11 years ago

Most of them want work, but are afraid to apply. If we legislate that fear away, they will become productive, tax paying, workers and future American citizens

Well right, let's compromise, we should probably give them a chance but leaving it open ended is irresponsible and unacceptable. How about they get one year to be able to show they can support themselves before deportation?

I wish I had the money to sponsor one or more. However I believe this problem can be solved by a bi-partisan bill.

See how you are. Right away you want to put it on the taxpaying citizens. I'm tired of "oh I would love to be able to financially carry out my brilliant idea but I need your tax money to do it"

BTW, define securing the border, because there is no way we're going to build a wall.

Why the hell not? With all this new tax money it will be a cinch and crate a lot of jobs. Plenty of other countries have done it. Look at Israel's High tech fences. Ever hear o f the great wall of China? That's a hell of a lot bigger than what we need and they did it centuries ago. Dismissing building a simple and effective wall is ridiculous. After it is built keep enough people to patrol it properly. Electrify it if necessary and patrol it properly (make sure no one gets in) If this requires deadly force, so be it.

If you want to debate the huge cost savings of this over the multitudes overwhelming the entitlement system for their remaining lifetime I'll be happy to.

 
 
 
pat wilson
Professor Quiet
link   pat wilson    11 years ago

If his polls stay high I guess the primaries will tell what happens.

 
 
 
Randy
Sophomore Quiet
link   seeder  Randy    11 years ago

I'm tired of "oh I would love to be able to financially carry out my brilliant idea but I need your tax money to do it"

And I'm tried of people who say they have different way to handle this problem, but are completely unrealistic. There are 11 million of them, of course it's going to take taxpayer money (which is something Trump never takes about), like say about $100 million dollars, just for a start. You want them gone? Be prepared for the costs of doing it.

Of course here is not going to be a wall. If the logic is to build a wall for the costs of hundreds and hundreds of millions of dollars and it won't be built anyway and BTW is he going to build it right down the center of the Rio Grande? The Mexicans won't let it be built on their side and the border runs right down the center, so if we build it on our side we'd be consigning our half of the river to Mexico and give up a whole hell of a lot of water rights. Then there's the costs of paying off all of the people whose land we'd be taking through eminent domain, but we still have to pay them something. We have to pay them a reasonable amount. Millions and millions of dollars of reasonable amounts. That alone has to be one hundred million by itself.

Once this magical wall is built, which will take years and we won't be able to afford to build unless we use illegals to build it, there will be no tax savings because the illegal aliens will still be here. And rounding them up, besides being impossible to do, will cost another couple of million dollars, so get out your checkbook, because we're all going to be paying for something that won't work anyway. It's all just a fantasy, so wake up from the dream.

Did you ever hear of the song "It's Cheaper to Keep Her"? Well it's a lot cheaper to put them on the road to taxpaying citizens, rather then trying to deport them, that's is impossible to do anyway! I'd rather they be legal and paying taxes, now wouldn't you? It'll save us several hundred million of dollars and we'll never get them all unless you check the citizenship of every person within the American border, because a lot of the illegals aren't even Hispanic.

Deporting 11 million (or up to 20 million, depending on who you ask) illegals is not going to happen. It is just impossible to do. It's a right wing fantasy dream that they need to wake up from and see the real world. It's not going to happen.

 
 
 
Perrie Halpern R.A.
Professor Guide
link   Perrie Halpern R.A.    11 years ago

Yep. You do it one wetback, or goat fucker at a time.

Hey Bruce... Stay classy. /sarc

 
 
 
jennilee
Freshman Silent
link   jennilee    11 years ago
Could be possible. We won't know until we give it a try. Start with criminals. As soon as they are caught, send them out. Every one. Every time.
 
 
 
96WS6
Junior Silent
link   96WS6    11 years ago

Of course here is not going to be a wall. If the logic is to build a wall for the costs of hundreds and hundreds of millions of dollars

BFD! A few hundred million is a drop in the bucket compared to a lifetime of entitlements for say a few hundred thousand people. Or even 50 thousand people. Hell, it's a drop in the bucket compared to a few Billion. This is not even considering you are not solving the problem of the constant influx of more illegals. With all the engineering marvels we have built in this country, you honestly don't think we can handle a frigging wall?

Really, I can't see how any intelligent being could think they can even begin to argue the ROI on what it costs to keep them out against the amount of entitlements to take and keep them all in and not solve the problem so it keeps getting worse and millions more keep coming. Face it, there is no way in hell we can afford NOT to build a wall or some sort of system to secure he borders.

It is painfully clear a welfare state cannot survive without securing the borders. Besides, think of all the jobs it would create. This is desperately needed infrastructure my friend.

Once this magical wall is built, which will take years and we won't be able to afford to build unless we use illegals to build it,

You may be on to something here. How about we use the ones that can't support themselves to build it and offer that as a path tocitizenship?

there will be no tax savings because the illegal aliens will still be here.

Now you are just being argumentative. Why on earth are you trying to shift the conversation. We have been doing nothing but talking about a path for those that can be productive members of our society and figuring out a way to stop the incoming flow, and how to get rid of the criminals and those who plan to live off the system... Which MUST be done. There is no way in hell we can keep this up. Who the hell has said a peep about keeping them illegal during this whole conversation? All we have been discussing are paths to citizenship.

BTW I know it is going to take tax payer money, I was just trying to drive a point home. That point is that there are a lot of common sense people that will be against any scheme to provide a path to citizenship that does not address stopping the problem of the constant flow of more illegals from happening. (or at least drastically cut it down.... like 90+%) It is plain common sense that we can't afford to continue this way. There will never be enough money for it.

 
 

Who is online

devangelical


75 visitors