╌>

Ben Carson: Obamacare worst thing ‘since slavery’

  

Category:  News & Politics

Via:  96ws6  •  12 years ago  •  52 comments

Ben Carson: Obamacare worst thing ‘since slavery’

Dr. Ben Carson didnt mince words: Obamacare is the worst thing that has happened in this nation since slavery.

Dr. Carson made the declaration about President Obamas sweeping health care mandate Friday during a speech at the Values Voter Summit.



It is slavery because it aims to make all of us subservient to the government, he said. It was never about health care. It was about control.

Dr. Carson further compared the new health care reform to policies envisioned by Vladimir Lenin, one of the fathers of socialism and communism.

Socialized medicine is the keystone in the establishment of a socialist state, Dr. Carson told the audience of some 2,000 supporters of traditional values.

Such a comment may seem paranoid to some, he said, but I would say if you know anything about history, how could you not bring it up?

When people in the executive and legislative branch dont have to participate, but everybody else has to, thats not America, thats Russia, he added.

http://www.washingtontimes.com/news/2013/oct/11/ben-carson-obamacare-worst-thing-slavery/


Tags

jrDiscussion - desc
[]
 
A. Macarthur
Professor Guide
link   A. Macarthur    12 years ago

A stupid statement when he said it months ago and just as stupid every time someone runs with it.

It is slavery because it aims to make all of us subservient to the government, he said. It was never about health care. It was about control.

All of us? Really? Will someone explain the logistics of that?

Are those with pre-existing condiitions whose lives might now be healthier if not saved -- are they slaves?

How about children who are covered for the first time in their lives -- slaves?

Feeding incendiary, dumb one-liners to willing, zeal-without-knowledge dupes is more communistic/fascist- like than enabling people to obtain health insurance/care!

 
 
 
96WS6
Junior Silent
link   seeder  96WS6    12 years ago

Perhaps, but anyone familiar with history can't argue this point:

Socialized medicine is the keystone in the establishment of a socialist state,

 
 
 
Perrie Halpern R.A.
Professor Guide
link   Perrie Halpern R.A.    12 years ago

I have to agree with that. I met Ben Carson at a lecture he gave in neurology at Hopkins. He's a doctor, not an economist. And while I am not a fan of this hybrid form of healthcare, to say:

It is slavery because it aims to make all of us subservient to the government

Hyperbole like that is just a turn off.

 
 
 
A. Macarthur
Professor Guide
link   A. Macarthur    12 years ago

Socialized medicine is the keystone in the establishment of a socialist state,

We are not a country with "socialized medicine".

Socialized medicine is a term used to describe and discuss systems of universal health care that is, medical and hospital care for all at a nominal cost by means of government regulation of health care and subsidies derived from taxation . [ 1 ] Because of historically negative associations with socialism in American culture, the term is usually used pejoratively in American political discourse. [ 2 ] [ 3 ] [ 4 ] [ 5 ] [ 6 ] The term was first widely used in the United States by advocates of the American Medical Association in opposition to President Harry S. Truman 's 1947 health-care initiative. [ 7 ] [ 8 ] [ 9 ]

The original meaning was confined to systems in which the government operates health care facilities and employs health care professionals. [ 10 ] [ 11 ] [ 12 ] [ 13 ] This narrower usage would apply to the British National Health Service hospital trusts and health systems that operate in other countries as diverse as Finland, Spain, Israel, and Cuba. The United States' Veterans Health Administration , and the medical departments of the U.S. Army , Navy , and Air Force , would also fall under this narrow definition. When used in this way, the narrow definition permits a clear distinction from single payer health insurance systems, in which the government finances health care but is not involved in care delivery. [ 14 ] [ 15 ]

More recently, American conservative critics of health care reform have attempted to broaden the term by applying it to any publicly funded system. Canada's Medicare system and most of the UK's NHS general practitioner and dental services, which are systems where health care is delivered by private business with partial or total government funding, fit this broader definition, as do the health care systems of most of Western Europe. In the United States, Medicare , Medicaid , and the U.S. military's TRICARE fall under this definition. Although, in specific regard to military benefits of a (currently) volunteer military, such care is an owed benefit to a specific group as part of an economic exchange, which muddies the definition yet further.

Most industrialized countries, and many developing countries, operate some form of publicly funded health care with universal coverage as the goal.

According to the Institute of Medicine and others, the United States is the only wealthy, industrialized nation that does not provide universal health care . [16] [17]

Jonathan Oberlander , a professor of health policy at the University of North Carolina, maintains that the term is merely a political pejorative that has been defined to mean different levels of government involvement in health care depending on what the speaker was arguing against at the time. [ 10 ]

The term is often used by conservatives in the U.S. to imply that the privately run health care system would become controlled by the government, thereby associating it with socialism , which has negative connotations to some people in American political culture. [ 18 ] As such its usage is controversial, [ 4 ] [ 5 ] [ 6 ] [ 10 ] and at odds with the views of conservatives in other countries prepared to defend socialized medicine such as Margaret Thatcher . [ 19 ]

 
 
 
Dean Moriarty
Professor Silent
link   Dean Moriarty    12 years ago

It's a form of slavery to steal my earnings and hand it over to them to pay for their healthcare. Nothing should be government subsidized. Not business not schooling not housing, food stamps or healthcare. They all make the free man a slave to the government.

 
 
 
Hal A. Lujah
Professor Participates
link   Hal A. Lujah    12 years ago
If that's how you are defining theft, then nearly everything that your federal tax contributions are going towards is theft, since it doesn't benefit you directly. That's how government works. It's not feasible to manage a population by ensuring that every penny contributed by each citizen is going towards the exclusive benefit of that citizen - which is why libertarianism is such a farce.
 
 
 
CM
Freshman Silent
link   CM    12 years ago

Thank you Hal, you responded to DM before I could, DM, perhaps your social security contributions as well as your medicare contributions should have been placed into a saving account such as Ben Carson suggests, with a pittance of interest and you can withdraw from that account until it is depleted, then just die already as the Republicans and Paul Ryan suggests...Just saw Ben Carson on the View, repeating GOP talking points to push their agenda, what a phony he is...

 
 
 
Hal A. Lujah
Professor Participates
link   Hal A. Lujah    12 years ago
... says the guy who is currently relying on socialized healthcare. Go figure!
 
 
 
Dean Moriarty
Professor Silent
link   Dean Moriarty    12 years ago

I never should have allowed the federal government to steal my earnings for social security in the first place.

 
 
 
CM
Freshman Silent
link   CM    12 years ago

Oh BoooHooo!!!!!! and if they did not deduct FICA from your earnings, what would you do today?? unless you are independently wealthy, you would still need that $$$$$$...

 
 
 
A. Macarthur
Professor Guide
link   A. Macarthur    12 years ago

I never should have allowed the federal government to steal my earnings for social security in the first place.

Do you like driving on paved roads, do you think police and fire companies are useful, street lights, schools, a military?

Emergency Services and Law Enforcement

Core safety services provided by most communities include fire and rescue and law enforcement. Tax dollars help support new, expanded or renovated fire stations, police departments and equipment and vehicles. They also help support enough staff to effectively manage community needs. Well-staffed and -managed fire stations ensure optimized response times to fires and emergencies. An adequately funded police force ensures community coverage to deter and respond to criminal activity.

Water and Sewer

The public works department typically oversees community provision of water and sewer services. Tax dollars go to developing, modifying and updating the infrastructure that supports underground sanitation and water flow to commercial and residential buildings. On top of the tax dollars that support improvements and repairs, residents usually pay monthly bills for water and sewer services.

Transportation

A significant portion of tax revenue is expended on roadways and transportation systems that support personal mobility and economic viability in communities. Road development, improvement and repairs are ongoing and require significant investments. As communities grow, roads are often expanded to adapt to increased traffic flow. Potholes and deteriorating road conditions require constant repairs. City transportation or public works also repaints road lines as they fade. The community also budgets a certain amount of revenue to snow removal during winter months. Developing and maintaining public transportation facilities and systems is also common, such as with local subways or buses, airports or boating docks.

Parks and Recreation

Most communities have a parks and recreation department that oversees parks, other public land areas and community recreational programs. Budgets in this department go to new park developments, equipment repair, yard and tree maintenance and parking lot and sidewalk snow removal. Landscaping and maintenance of public cemeteries is also sometimes necessary. Community tax dollars may also support recreational programs, including ball field upkeep, sports leagues and weekend outdoor events and programs for youth and seniors.

Facilities and Community Centers

Public buildings and community centers require development, expansion and maintenance as well. Property taxes are often increased to fund new products, such as an aquatic center, library or community center. Tax money also goes toward operation of municipal government, including the payment of salaries to the mayor, council members and office staff. Each year, repair and maintenance budgets are established for upkeep on all public buildings and facilities.

How about

Defense and international security assistance:
The largest component of this category is the national defense function (050). In addition, this category includes the international security assistance subfunction (152) of the international affairs function.

Social Security:
This category consists of all expenditures in the Social Security function (650), including benefits and administrative costs.

Medicare, Medicaid, and CHIP:
This category consists of the Medicare function (570), including benefits, administrative costs, and premiums, as well as the Grants to States for Medicaid account and the Childrens health insurance fund account (both in function 550).

Safety net programs:
This category of programs includes all programs in the income security function (600) except those that fall in the following two subfunctions: federal employees retirement and disability (602) and general retirement and disability insurance (601). The latter contains the Pension Benefit Guarantee Corporation and also covers programs that provide pension and disability benefits to certain small groups of private sector workers.

Interest on debt:
This category contains the net interest function (900).

Remaining program areas:
This category includes all federal expenditures not included in one of the five categories defined above. The subcomponents of this category that are displayed in the graph are defined as follows:

  • Benefits for federal retirees and veterans: This subcategory combines the veterans' benefits and services function (700) and the federal employee retirement and disability subfunction (602, which is part of the income security function).
  • Transportation: This subcategory consists of the entire transportation function (400).
  • Education: The education subcategory combines three subfunctions of the education, training, employment, and social services function: elementary, secondary, and vocational education; higher education; and research and general educational aids (subfunctions 501, 502, and 503 respectively).
  • Science and medical research: This subcategory consists of the general science, space, and technology function (250), and the health research and training subfunction (552).
  • Non-security international: This subcategory consists of the international affairs function (150) except for international security assistance, which is included with defense, above.
  • All other: This subcategory consists of all other federal expenditures.
 
 
 
Dean Moriarty
Professor Silent
link   Dean Moriarty    12 years ago

Not everyone is a financial failure. I'd rather have control over MY money.

 
 
 
96WS6
Junior Silent
link   seeder  96WS6    12 years ago

We are not a country with "socialized medicine".

Not yet, but we are on our way. When this system fails you will be advocating single payer won't you?

 
 
 
CM
Freshman Silent
link   CM    12 years ago

Do you like driving on paved roads, do you think police and fire companies are useful, street lights, schools, a military?

Perhaps DM would have preferred living in the 1500's before electricity, but, they may have had kerosene for lighting, thing is, if you want modern conveniences, there is a price to pay, if you want your VA or Medicare health care benefits, you have to contribute..

 
 
 
96WS6
Junior Silent
link   seeder  96WS6    12 years ago

You are assuming that SS will never becomes insolvent. The government has already proven they will take money out of SS for pretty much anything they want. I don't really think any of us (especially those under 20) can really count on SS being there for us.

 
 
 
CM
Freshman Silent
link   CM    12 years ago

Yea, you can thank Ronald Reagan for that...

 
 
 
Dean Moriarty
Professor Silent
link   Dean Moriarty    12 years ago

4247_discussions.jpg

I'd eliminate all Medicare, Medicaid and scrip, Safety net programs, Social security, Interest on debt and cut defense spending by eighty percent. Government has grown out of control, has stripped us of the our freedom and is greatly hindering our economic opportunity.

 
 
 
96WS6
Junior Silent
link   seeder  96WS6    12 years ago

Gee AMAC,

All the stuff you listed is EXACTLY why I don't expect to be able to collect SS. You see, SS was never meant to be used for all those wonderful things (that is what income tax is supposed to be for). According the government SS is for

  • People who already have retired;
  • People who are disabled
  • Survivors of workers who have died; and
  • Dependents of beneficiaries.

The reason it is becoming insolvent is because the government uses it for things it is not meant for, and by doing so are stealing from all of us.

Here is the official government document on SS if you are inclined to read it.

...

 
 
 
Hal A. Lujah
Professor Participates
link   Hal A. Lujah    12 years ago
Sorry old people ... remember all that money you paid for social security? Please exit your homes and go quietly die some place, because a successful person with no conscience said so.
 
 
 
96WS6
Junior Silent
link   seeder  96WS6    12 years ago

SS is not supposed to be used for any of those things. See my reply to AMAC. This is why SS is in trouble. The government has used it for things they shouldn't be using it for.

 
 
 
A. Macarthur
Professor Guide
link   A. Macarthur    12 years ago

I advocated Single Payer long before the ACA. Still do.

What's the problem with Single Payer? Do you have any real knowledge of Single Payer?

Do you have a problem with a public option, lower premiums due to a larger coverage pool and the elimination of a for-profit system?

Learn before rejecting based on one-line partisan b.s. .

What is Single-Payer Healthcare?

Adapted from PNHPs website .

Single-payer is a term used to describe a type of financing system. It refers to one entity acting as administrator, or payer. In the case of healthcare, a single-payer system would be setup such that one entitya government run organizationwould collect all healthcare fees, and pay out all healthcare costs.

In the current US system, there are literally tens of thousands of different healthcare organizationsHMOs, billing agencies, etc. By having so many different payers of healthcare fees, there is an enormous amount of administrative waste generated in the system. (Just imagine how complex billing must be in a doctors office, when each insurance company requires a different form to be completed, has a different billing system, different billing contacts and phone numbersits very confusing.)

In a single-payer system, all hospitals, doctors, and other healthcare providers would bill one entity for their services. This alone reduces administrative waste greatly, and saves money, which can be used to provide care and insurance to those who currently dont have it.

Access and Benefits

Everyone would receive comprehensive medical benefits under single-payer. Coverage would include all medically necessary services, including rehabilitative, long-term, and home care; mental healthcare, prescription drugs, and medical supplies; and preventive and public health measures.

Care would be based on need, not on ability to pay.

Payment

Hospital billing would be virtually eliminated. Instead, hospitals would receive an annual lump-sum payment from the government to cover operating expenses a global budget. A separate budget would cover such expenses as hospital expansion, the purchase of technology, marketing, etc.

Doctors would have three options for payment: fee-for-service, salaried positions in hospitals, and salaried positions within group practices or HMOs. Fees would be negotiated between a representative of the fee-for-service practitioners (such as the state medical society) and a state payment board. Government would serve as administrator, not employer .

Financing

We propose an equitable financing program in which everyone pays their fair share. Under this program, all employers and employees will pay a modest payroll tax. This will produce a dramatic savings for those responsible private employers and state and local governments which currently purchase health insurance for their employees. By drawing on the immense wealth that has accrued to the richest Americans and large corporations over the past 25 years, 95% of people will pay less for their healthcare than they are currently paying . Some of the key components to financing HR 676:

  • Eliminates all employer contributions to private insurance premiumsreplacing them with a modest payroll tax of 4.5% (in addition to the 1.45% currently paid towards Medicare).
  • Eliminates all individual premiums, co-pays, deductibles and nearly all other out-of-pocket costsreplacing them with a modest payroll tax of 3.3% (in addition to the 1.45% currently paid towards Medicare).
  • Relieves state and local governments of the immense burden of paying insurance premiums for medical coverage for their current and retired employeesreplacing them with a modest payroll tax of 4.5% (in addition to the 1.45% currently paid towards Medicare).

Administrative Savings

The General Accounting Office projects an administrative savings of 10 percent through the elimination of private insurance bills and administrative waste, or $150 billion in 2002. This savings would pay for providing medical care to those currently under served.

Cost Containment

A 2004 economic study published in The New England Journal of Medicine determined that a national single-payer healthcare system would reduce costs by more than $400 billion a year despite the expansion of comprehensive care to all Americans. No other plan projects this kind of savings.

Different Perspectives on the Benefits of Single-Payer

Patients

Each person, regardless of ability to pay would receive high-quality, comprehensive medical care, and the free choice of doctors and hospitals. Individuals would receive no bills, and copayment and deductibles would be eliminated. Most people would pay less overall for health care than they pay now.

Doctors

Doctors incomes would change little, though the disparity in income between specialties would shrink. The need for a wallet biopsy before treatment would be eliminated; time currently wasted on administrative duties could be channeled into providing care; and clinical decisions would no longer be dictated by insurance company policy.

Medical endorsements include the California Nurses Association/National Nurses United (160,000), PNHP (9,000), the American Public Health Association (30,000), American Association of Community Psychiatrists, Massachusetts Academy of Family Practice, American Medical Womens Association (13,500), Alameda-Contra Costa Medical Society, American Medical Students Association, D.C. Medical Society, National Medical Association (6,500), American College of Physicians (Illinois Chapter), Long Island Dermatological Society, Islamic Medical Association, the Nurses Network for a National Health Program, and the D.C. chapter of the American Medical Association.

Hospitals

The massive numbers of administrative personnel needed to handle itemized billing to 1,500 private insurance companies would no longer be needed. A negotiated global budget would cover operating expenses. Budgets for capital would be allocated separately based on healthcare priorities. Hospitals would no longer close because of unpaid bills.

Insurance Industry

The need for private insurance would be eliminated. One single payer-bill currently in the House (H.R. 1200) would provide one percent of funding for retraining displaced insurance workers during its first few years of implementation.

Business

In general, businesses would see Single-Payer limit their health costs and remove the burden of administering health insurance for their employees. Read more about how single-payer helps small business in our Small Business Brochure .

Congress

Single-payer would be the simplest and most efficient healthcare plan that Congress could implement. It would be based Medicare, one of the most successful national healthcare programs.

 
 
 
CM
Freshman Silent
link   CM    12 years ago

I am all for caring for our veterans, what I do not like, is those same veterans, who are been cared for by the taxpayers, (people currently working and paying taxes) are been denied health care and called moochers when it is their tax dollars continuing the program for veterans and medicare recipients...

 
 
 
Dean Moriarty
Professor Silent
link   Dean Moriarty    12 years ago

Half the old people haven't forgotten about the money the government stole from them. Many of the old people that had their money stolen are now dead and never got their money back.They were against social security from the very beginning. I remember my grandfather telling me what a crock it was and he dug graves by hand during the depression.

 
 
 
96WS6
Junior Silent
link   seeder  96WS6    12 years ago

So how about stopping collecting new monies now and paying of those who have contributed? Well that wouldn't work because the government has already raped SS and if no one pays into a PONSI scheme it falls apart.

 
 
 
CM
Freshman Silent
link   CM    12 years ago

You are living in the wrong country in the wrong century, there is a trip been planned to Mars, it would be similar to the early settlers, perhaps that would be more to your liking...I'll find the link for you, and you're welcome...

 
 
 
A. Macarthur
Professor Guide
link   A. Macarthur    12 years ago

You are assuming that SS will never becomes insolvent.

And you are assuming it will.

Raise the ceiling on paying into the system and lower the percentage rate of payment; rather than the ceiling being approximately $104,000 annual income, let's have the folks making millions or billions pay on all of their income -- just like the working poor and middle class.

Congress lacks the balls to do this because they don't want to be accused of "raising taxes".

 
 
 
96WS6
Junior Silent
link   seeder  96WS6    12 years ago

Sigh, I will say this for the thousandth time. LIMITED government is NOTHING like NO government. Why is it that every time someone suggests budget cuts or cutting a useless branch of government you start crying about anarchy? Is that really all you got?

You know people from opposing parties have made the ridiculous claim that libertarians want to get rid of government. BS! there is nothing wrong with LIMITING government. ESPECIALLY in a country where government is growing out of control.

Tell you what, if you don't think we need to shrink government please tell me how long you think this can continue:

As of May 1, 2014, the official debt of the United States government is $17.5 trillion ($17,474,314,085,413). [1] This amounts to:

$54,987 for every person living in the U.S. [2]

$142,695 for every household in the U.S. [3]

102% of the U.S. gross domestic product. [4]

556% of annual federal revenues. [5]

* Publicly traded companies are legally required to account for "explicit" and "implicit" future obligations such as employee pensions and retirement benefits. [6] [7] [8] The federal budget, which is the "federal government's primary financial planning and control tool," is not bound by this rule. [9] [10]

* At the close of the federal government's 2013 fiscal year (September 30, 2013), the federal government had roughly:

$7.8 trillion ($7,849,000,000,000) in liabilities that are not accounted for in the national debt, such as federal employee retirement benefits, accounts payable, and environmental/disposal liabilities. [11]

$23.8 trillion ($23,768,000,000,000) in obligations for current Social Security participants above and beyond projected revenues from their payroll and benefit taxes, certain transfers from the general fund of the U.S. Treasury, and assets of the Social Security trust fund. [12]

$27.3 trillion ($27,300,000,000,000) in obligations for current Medicare participants above and beyond projected revenues from their payroll taxes, benefit taxes, premium payments, and assets of the Medicare trust fund. [13]

 
 
 
Dean Moriarty
Professor Silent
link   Dean Moriarty    12 years ago

Why would a guy making millions or billions need the government to steal his earnings and do his saving for him. It's his money not the governments.

 
 
 
96WS6
Junior Silent
link   seeder  96WS6    12 years ago

OK so you are proposing to raise the amount I pay into SS and shafting me out of what I was promised to pay back. (giving me less back) Sounds like the system isn't working anymore. BTW after SS gets back to where it looks like it may survive what will stop the government from pulling this crap again?

...

So when they screw us like this again are we just supposed to keep on paying more in and getting less back and sit back, STF up, and be happy about it?

YOU ARE IGNORING HISTORY!

 
 
 
A. Macarthur
Professor Guide
link   A. Macarthur    12 years ago

SS is not supposed to be used for any of those things. See my reply to AMAC. This is why SS is in trouble. The government has used it for things they shouldn't be using it for.

I was speaking of taxes generally; and the "government" that used SS for other things

Right-Wing politicians and pundits who advocate destroying Social Security have two rationales:

1) As part of their antipathy to "big government," they do not believe that the federal government should provide retirement benefits to the elderly or support for disabled people, widows and orphans.

2) They would like to see their friends on Wall Street make billions by administring retirement accounts if Social Security is ended.

Unfortunately, in their battle for the hearts and minds of Americans, Right Wingers have been shameless about distorting the truth about Social Security. Some of their lies are listed below, along with the true facts.

LIE: Social Security is going bankrupt
TRUTH: Social Security is NOT going bankrupt. In fact, Social Security today has a $2.6 trillion surplus and can pay out every benefit owed to every eligible American for the next 27 years. From that point forward, it will be able to provide 75-80 percent of all benefits.

LIE: Social Security is contributing to the federal deficit
TRUTH: Not just a lie, but impossible! By law, Social Security is funded by the payroll tax and has not contributed one penny to the federal deficit. With a separate funding source and separate fiscal system, it is completely detached from the federal operating budget.

The federal deficit was caused primarily by three things: 1)unfunded wars in Iraq and Afghanistan, 2) Bush-era tax cuts for the wealthiest, 3) a toothless financial regulatory system that let Wall Street and banks destroy our economy, losing millions of jobs and the income tax revenues that went with them.

LIE: We have to raise the retirement age because people are living longer
TRUTH: Retirees are living about the same amount of time as they were in the 1930s. The reason average life expectancy is higher is mostly because many fewer people die as children than they did 70 years ago. What's more, what gains there have been are distributed very unevenly --since 1972, life expectancy increased by 6.5 years for workers in the top half of the income brackets, but by less than two years for those in the bottom half. But those intent on cutting Social Security love this argument because raising the retirement age is the same as an across-the-board benefit cut.

LIE: Benefit cuts are the only sure way to "fix" Social Security
TRUTH: Social Security doesn't need to be fixed. But if we want to strengthen it, here's a better way: Make the rich pay their full share. If the very rich paid taxes on all of their income, Social Security would be sustainable for decades to come. Right now, high earners only pay Social Security taxes on the first $106,000 of their income. But conservatives insist benefit cuts are the only way because they want to protect the super-rich from paying their fair share.

LIE: The Social Security Trust Fund has been raided and is full of IOUs
TRUTH: The Social Security Trust Fund is NOT fullof IOUs, it is full of U.S. Treasury Bonds. And those bonds are backed by the full faith and credit of the United States. The reason Social Security holds only Treasury Bonds is the same reason many Americans do: The federal government has never missed a single interest payment on its debts. President Bush wanted to put Social Security funds in the stock market -- which would have been disasterous -- but luckily, he failed. So the trillions of dollars in the Social Security Trust Fund, which are separate from the regular budget, are as safe as can be.

LIE: Illegal Immigrants are collecting Social Security
TRUTH: Neither immigrants -- legal or illegal -- nor anyone else is able to collect Social Security benefits without someone paying Social Security payroll taxes into the system.

And

1) President Reagan appointed Greenspan as chairman of the 1982 National Commission on Social Security Reform (aka The Greenspan Commission)

2) The Greenspan Commission recommended a major payroll tax hike to generate Social Security surpluses for the next 30 years, in order to build up a large reserve in the trust fund that could be drawn down during the years after Social Security began running deficits.

3) The 1983 Social Security amendments enacted hefty increases in the payroll tax in order to generate large future surpluses.

4) As soon as the first surpluses began to role in, in 1985, the money was put into the general revenue fund and spent on other government programs. None of the surplus was saved or invested in anything. The surplus Social Security revenue, that was paid by working Americans, was used to replace the lost revenue from Reagans big income tax cuts that went primarily to the rich.

5) In 1987, President Reagan nominated Greenspan as the successor to Paul Volker as chairman of the Federal Reserve Board. Greenspan continued as Fed Chairman until January 31, 2006. (One can only speculate on whether the coveted Fed Chairmanship represented, at least in part, a payback for Greenspans role in initiating the Social Security surplus revenue.)

6) In 1990, Senator Daniel Patrick Moynihan of New York, a member of the Greenspan Commission, and one of the strongest advocates the the 1983 legislation, became outraged when he learned that first Reagan, and then President George H.W. Bush used the surplus Social Security revenue to pay for other government programs instead of saving and investing it for the baby boomers. Moynihan locked horns with President Bush and proposed repealing the 1983 payroll tax hike. Moynihans view was that if the government could not keep its hands out of the Social Security cookie jar, the cookie jar should be emptied, so there would be no surplus Social Security revenue for the government to loot. President Bush would have no part of repealing the payroll tax hike. The read-my-lips-no-new-taxes president was not about to give up his huge slush fund.

- See more at:
 
 
 
A. Macarthur
Professor Guide
link   A. Macarthur    12 years ago

Why would a guy making millions or billions need the government to steal his earnings and do his saving for him. It's his money not the governments.

I'll answer that if you tell me why the SS Trust fund was raided to pay for tax cuts for those millionaires and pay for the Iraq war loans we got from China?

 
 
 
96WS6
Junior Silent
link   seeder  96WS6    12 years ago

The PEOPLE should decide what parts of government should or should not exist. The problem with our current government is every time there is an incident they create some new inefficient and useless branch of government to deal with it. I will use the Department of homeland security as an example. We don;t need it, it is an inefficient money eating monster that we got along just fine without for over 100 years.

 
 
 
A. Macarthur
Professor Guide
link   A. Macarthur    12 years ago

OK so you are proposing to raise the amount I pay into SS and shafting me out of what I was promised to pay back.

No I'm not; RAISE THE CEILING and LOWER THE RATE more money comes into the system but individuals contribute at a lower percentage rate.

The likelihood would be greater benefits because of more money going into the fund. Why should someone earning $1 million not pay into SS on the last $896,000 of income while others pay on every penny from $104,000 on down each year?

 
 
 
Dean Moriarty
Professor Silent
link   Dean Moriarty    12 years ago

The money never should have been stolen from us to be raided by our incompetent government in the first place. Giving your savings to the government to manage is like giving crack to a junkie.

 
 
 
CM
Freshman Silent
link   CM    12 years ago

but congress still gets their medical care off veterans tax dollars.

Another reason Congress and the rest of the Washington DC crowd, should be removed from their FREE Medical Care benefits..they make enough money to pay their own...

 
 
 
CM
Freshman Silent
link   CM    12 years ago

I'd eliminate all Medicare, Medicaid and scrip, Safety net programs, Social security, Interest on debt and cut defense spending by eighty percent. Government has grown out of control, has stripped us of the our freedom and is greatly hindering our economic opportunity.

Dean: Did you want me to get that link for the trip to Mars?? you can be one of the early settlers...

 
 
 
A. Macarthur
Professor Guide
link   A. Macarthur    12 years ago

Giving your savings to the government to manage is like giving crack to a junkie.

I try and respond to every comment and question and response; and my responses are generally logical, plausible and backed by specifics -- with which anyone is free to disagree.

But these one line-empty-rhetoric quips make conversations frustrating and pointless.

Say something; don't give us these platitudes and quips.

 
 
 
Perrie Halpern R.A.
Professor Guide
link   Perrie Halpern R.A.    12 years ago

Gene,

There is no doubt that our vets have gotten screwed from the VA. But this has been going on since the Civil War. The term "red tape" came from how hard it was for war vets to get the pay that was due to them. They literally had to go to Washington to get paid and their records were tied in red tape that they would then cut, review and get their back pay.

But that aside, it still has nothing to do with SS. And I don't see anyone saying that they will give that up.

But for those who say that they don't need SS or the government to put aside their money for retirement... let me give you this fact. Americans don't save. We are the country who saves the least. Right now, most of you don't have enough money to get you past 10 years after 65. What do you suppose would happen then? History should be able to answer that question.

 
 
 
96WS6
Junior Silent
link   seeder  96WS6    12 years ago

John,

Your definition of libertarianism exposes your complete ignorance on the subject.

 
 
 
Hal A. Lujah
Professor Participates
link   Hal A. Lujah    12 years ago
Anyone who thinks that "the people" are capable of making rational and informed decisions about shutting down entire branches of government, is definitely NOT someone who should even be consulted on such matters in the first place. That's a big flaw with libertarians - thinking that they and their limited brood are smarter or more knowledgeable than they need to be to make their pipe dreams work.
 
 
 
96WS6
Junior Silent
link   seeder  96WS6    12 years ago

HAL

You are suggesting letting the government reduce waste and reduce their own size???? ROFL! Yea right! Because it is already working so well! 24.gif

While you may think the government knows what is best for you (and after reading some of your posts you may very well be right) I know what is best for me.

 
 
 
Hal A. Lujah
Professor Participates
link   Hal A. Lujah    12 years ago
You know what's best for you, eh? So I guess you trust yourself to figure out how to deal with nuclear waste, maintain a safe potable water supply, ensure food supplies are uncontaminated, educate people from K though grad school, build a suspension bridge, keep the pharmaceutical industry honest, etc. etc. The system isn't perfect, and it will never be perfect, but thinking that handing all the critical decisions over to the people and removing all oversight is the answer is beyond stupid. No offense, but I wouldn't trust you to plan a parade, much less keep an infectious disease at bay.
 
 
 
96WS6
Junior Silent
link   seeder  96WS6    12 years ago

Hal,

We were talking about government spending waste and shrinking the size of government, not nuclear waste and disease control. Try to stay on topic, once again Hal...LIMITED government is not the same as NO government, try to stay with me here.

 
 
 
96WS6
Junior Silent
link   seeder  96WS6    12 years ago

Why should someone earning $1 million not pay into SS on the last $896,000 of income while others pay on every penny from $104,000 on down each year?

Because the rich folks that buy you a few puppets to chose from every election want it that way.

 
 
 
Hal A. Lujah
Professor Participates
link   Hal A. Lujah    12 years ago
That is such a lame cop out. I just gave you a wide range of government functions, and it doesn't even scratch the surface of critical infrastructure - and all you have to offer is the same tired ass expression without a single example of what it means. You clearly have no idea how critical and complicated the functions of government are, all you have is an empty mantra.
 
 
 
96WS6
Junior Silent
link   seeder  96WS6    12 years ago

OK Hal,

How come every time a new challenge comes up it is met by a new useless bureaucracy?

Are the current institutions that frigging useless???? This is a good point eh? Our government is already so out of control it is very inefficient.

Let's choose the Department of Homeland security. With this new multi-billion dollar branch of government and all the wonderful things it does, one would think it would lighten the load on one or hopefully many other bureaucracies, so they shrank...why is it that never happens. Look at what DOHS does and ask yourself who was doing all this BS before this new department was created, then ask why THEY still need more money....it never ends.

 
 
 
pat wilson
Professor Quiet
link   pat wilson    12 years ago

41.gif 41.gif 41.gif

 
 
 
A. Macarthur
Professor Guide
link   A. Macarthur    12 years ago

Because the rich folks that buy you a few puppets to chose from every election want it that way.

Wow! The last thing I anticipated was an honest response albeit one spoken tongue-in-cheek.

many a true word is spoken in jest
  1. 1.
    proverb
    a humorous remark not intended to be taken seriously may turn out to be accurate after all.
 
 
 
Dean Moriarty
Professor Silent
link   Dean Moriarty    12 years ago

Someone making a million a year should not pay anything into social security. They don't need social security.

 
 
 
A. Macarthur
Professor Guide
link   A. Macarthur    12 years ago

Someone making a million a year should not pay anything into social security. They don't need social security.

And someone making a million a year doesn't need a tax break paid for by those making far less! Nor should a Wall Street bankster get a bonus larger than the average middle class salary a bonus paid for by the same tax payers who bailed the bastard out!

Shall I go on?

OK.

Nor should 1 out of 4 corporations pay no taxes.

Nor should offshore accounts be able to evade taxes.

More?

Just ask.

OK then.

Nor should corporate lobbyists be able to write corporate loopholes into the tax code.I could go on and on.

But I think I'll go to bed now and resume providing perspective tomorrow.

 
 
 
Hal A. Lujah
Professor Participates
link   Hal A. Lujah    12 years ago
I have no problem whatsoever with a massive pruning of the defense budget. If that's what you're focus is on then say so, but that is not the standard libertarian ideal of how to reduce the size of government. The functions of government, and how it interfaces with the private sector, are far too complicated to suggest simply hacking off branches. Defense is the only part of the tree that is clearly overgrown and wildly unmanageable.
 
 
 
96WS6
Junior Silent
link   seeder  96WS6    12 years ago

Hal,

The defense budget is one among many that need "trimming" and it would help a lot if the government didn't invent an entire bureaucracy to solve problems that we already have a bureaucracy in place to supposedly handle.

 
 

Who is online




100 visitors