What Ed Schultz Said About the Holocaust will Shock You
MSNBC loudmouth Ed Schultz is no stranger to controversy. Though the liberal often earns theire of conservatives for his inflammatory remarks, Schultz offered on Monday a very disturbing view of history when he tweeted that homosexuals, not Jews, were the true victims of Hitlers holocaust.
On Monday, Schultz tweeted the following tweet:
The actual tweet has been deleted.
Schultz revisionism for the sake of pandering to homosexual activists is simply nauseating. While it is certainly true that Hitlers genocidal regime did target homosexuals, to trivialize the persecution of the Jews is both insensitive and shocking.
An estimated 6 million Jews were murdered during the holocaust. Another 5 million were murdered- these people consisted of homosexuals, blacks, gypsies, mentally and physically disabled and various others who were considered enemies of the state.
Though it is important to remain mindful that the holocaust was not exclusively an elimination of Jews and honor all the victims of Hitlers regime, for Schultz to purposefully skew history in this way is unacceptable and, frankly, too-closely akin to holocaust denial.
The question now is: Will the left call Schultz on his behavior? Or will they sweep it under the rug as they so often do for liberals?
Tags
Who is online
80 visitors

While homosexuals were targeted, along with gypsies and other 'unworthy' types, jews suffered far higher numbers of murder from their nazi leaders.
But, what the heck, MSNBC lackeys trying to re-write history......next it will be that the palestinians suffered far more at the hands of the Nazis than the jews......
So many on the left are asprogressive and tolerantas they are bright .
I thinking what if a conservative talk show host had said the same thing? How do you think the media would have been reacting today? There is so much biased, in your face biased journalism, if you can call it that today, it's really sickening.
Nope there is no coverage of this on MSMBC, NBC, CBS, ABC, CNN or even Associated press or any other liberal media source, which most Americans are most likely to receive their news.
No different when Ben Rhodes changed the talking points (proven in email) and obstructed by Obama Administration for one and one half years and the video was covered well with all the main stream media sources as the reason for the terrorist attack in Benghazi.
And the newscasters at CBS were told not to mention David Rhodes President of CBS was Ben Rhodes brother, the White House Deputy National Security Adviser to the President who changed the talking points.
Folks, if you watching just those stations and liberal or conservative news sources, you're getting screwed on getting the whole story and maybe that is why you are unable to completely evaluate what the real truth is.
At least I'm not.
Before or after you do that, why don't you show me how MSNBC, NBC, CBS, ABC, CNN or Associated Press feel about it with a link to an article from them?
And besides looking at the author in this article, why don't you notice this is just one of many and are we going to attack the author of the article or the author of the tweet?
Talk about idiotic!
Much like the people that think Rush Limbaugh should be national news over anything that he says?
Priceless. A die hard liberal makes an abhorrent statement about the holocaust and the guy who uses rawstory as a source is upset that a conservative site was one of the many sources that reported on it.
Ed Schultz is a liberal blow hard and I dont imagine this is his first or last hyperbole argument.
I think all of the commentators on all of the channels should be fined for historical inaccuracies. Although who would judge historical inaccuracy would be kind of difficult...
If they all got fined every time they tried to be revisionists, maybe they would stick to the facts more. Then again, they get paid for sensationalism... so I only expect this trend to get worse.
The story is that Schultz is trying to minimize who were the mass victims of the Holocaust, to gain favor with a specific demographic, which is wrong. No he didn't denigrate Jews in any way specifically, but what he did do was revisionism, which is not very journalistic, is it?
You should have heard the carp he was spewing just prior to the failed Walker recall election.
Notice how John ignores what Perrie said and goes on to make apologies for the thoughtless tweet ... Thanks for being such a liberal asswipe John .
No not on the evening news but they do end up on the radical left wing web sites you favor and in turn end up being seeded here by you.
The details
Tom Kludt May 13, 2014, 12:16 PM EDT
I'll bet he doesn't like catfish either.
A Mac, you know this tweet would be all over those stations I mentioned earlier had anyone that was not considered Liberal done the same thing. Just how many Jews were persecuted?
Let's see....
The Holocaust (from the Greek holkaustos : hlos , "whole" and kausts , "burnt") also known as Shoah ( Hebrew : , HaShoah , "the catastrophe"; Yiddish : , Churben or Hurban , from the Hebrew for "destruction"), was the mass murder or genocide of approximately six million Jews during World War II , a programme of systematic state-sponsored murder by Nazi Germany , led by Adolf Hitler and the Nazi Party , throughout the German Reich and German-occupied territories.
Of the nine million Jews who had resided in Europe before the Holocaust, approximately two-thirds were killed. Over one million Jewish children were killed in the Holocaust, as were approximately two million Jewish women and three million Jewish men. A network of over 40,000 facilities in Germany and German-occupied territory were used to concentrate, hold, and kill Jews and other victims .
5 to 15 thousand ok.
The fact is Spike Lee said he wanted to kill white people and didn't like interracial couples and he made them feel bad, but Sterling (who is a jerk) is the racist all by himself according to the Liberal media.
And they are worried more about the humanity execution of a fellow who raped and killed a 20 year old girl and would hang Sterling if they could. Tell me where are the priorities? Where is the moral standing of the news stations?
We all know that Nazis murdered the Jews during WW2, why is there even a question here ?
I think that it is safe to say that there are all kinds of idiots on both sides of the aisle.
The tweet is all over the internet on every right-wing site shall I post the links?
And I know as much about the Holocaust as anyone on this site so you don't need to talk down to me on that subject.
Schultz's tweet, which I'm not convinced he just posted as alleged that is, as a stand alone comment, not in any context nor, in response to another tweet is not likely, as Schulz knows that the Jews were Hitler's primary target and scapegoats for a failing economy.
Poorly worded for sure, Schultz was saying in response to Gohmert (I'll paraprase) -- Homosexuals were not "haters" as Hitler's regime identified them, instead, they were really VICTIMS, really (among) the ones being persecuted in Hitler's Germany."
If righties are dumb enough, or, choose to play dumb, and believe that Schultz would out-of-the-blue, simply post the tweet as represented, no context, no part of a dialogue/debate, it's on them.
"Hi, I'm Ed Schultz; oh, by the way, homosexuals were really the ones being persecuted, etc. "
Just like that? Really?
Just a few weeks ago, this site and liberal new sources were awash with claims that Paul Ryan was racist because of the subtext liberals imagined they could divine from what Paul Ryan actually said in a radio interview as opposed to his actual words. The text of the interview itself was completely void of race but liberals were sure, absolutely sure that it was a"dog whistle" and that Ryan was in fact a raging racist.
As as aside, the irony of the liberals constantly hearing dog whistles is pretty funny.James Taranto put it very well: The thing we adore about these dog-whistle kerfuffles is that the people who react to the whistle always assume its intended for somebody else, he wrote. The whole point of the metaphor is that if you can hear the whistle, youre the dog. Funny how its always the liberals associating statements with negativeimplicationswithblacks. So the next time you hear someoneyammeringabout dog whistles, remember they are the one who made theunflattering connection with blacks.
Putting that aside, the same people who cry racist at imagined subtext are now completely happy to ignore and excuse the ACTUAL text of this asshole's statement. What's more, he's said it twice. This wasn't a mistake or a poor choice of words...He said the exact same thing twice in public forums, months apart.
Imagine if Hannity or someone similar said Catholics were the "real" targets of the Nazis. After all many moreCatholicsthan homosexuals were exterminate by the Nazis. The same people who soblithelydismiss Schultz's revisionist history would be calling for the head of Hannity. The double standards are amazing.
I explained it; you choose to ignore the explanation.
Schultz DID NOT SAY homosexuals were the real targets of Hitler; he was saying that, unlike Louis Gohmert's comparison of people who call out anti-gay folks as "haters", that such people are like Nazis who, called homosexuals "haters."
Schultz's comment, though poorly worded, explained that homosexuals were not haters, that they were really the ones being persecuted and NOT THEMSELVES HATERS.
The righties, either too stupid to realize the obvious, or, intentionally misrepresenting it to mean that "homosexuals rather than Jews were Hitler's target," do this kind of misrepresentation often and regularly
GOP's demented Benghazi! disease: Why conservatives so ...
NewsBusters (blog) - May 5, 2014
Highly Cited - Reuters - May 4, 2014
Your one-stop guide to the Republican Party's scandal wish list
MSNBC - May 8, 2014
In-Depth - Huffington Post - May 7, 2014
Opinion - New York Times - May 9, 2014
Blog - Slate Magazine (blog) - May 6, 2014
In-Depth - Fox News - May 9, 2014
The five stages of GOP scandal -mongering: A reader's guide
In-Depth - CNN - May 8, 2014
Opinion - Los Angeles Times - May 8, 2014
In-Depth - CBS News - May 7, 2014
NJ Republicans criticize bridge scandal panel before Drewniak ...
Will GOP's Beefed- Up Voter Outreach Work in Illinois?
Christie says bridge scandal will end up a 'footnote' in his career
In-Depth - New York Daily News - 22 hours ago
On Capitol Hill, it's all about priorities
Opinion - gulfnews.com - May 13, 2014
Why Hasn't the GOP Treated Fort Hood Like Benghazi?
Chris Christie: 'Limited options' to fix New Jersey
NorthJersey.com - 9 minutes ago
Is Benghazi Really A Damaging Political Scandal ?
In-Depth - Daily Beast - 8 hours ago
Oh well, have a good day A Mac.
I agree.
Me too; but there are still things that must be addressed on an issue-by-issue basis.
"Schultz DID NOT SAY homosexuals were the real targets of Hitler."
Ed Schultz: " Gay People were really the ones being persecuted in Hitler's Germany."
You can perform all the linguistic gymnastics you want to make his statement tolerable but all that does is reinforce my point. When its a liberal you torture the language to excuse, when it is a conservative, you torture it to condemn.
And you can delude yourself to thinking that out-of-the-blue, Schultz, having no knowledge of the Holocaust (with no context cited by his tweet-reporter), just blurted out, "hey folks, homosexuals were really the ones persecuted, etc. (and not 6 million Jews)."
I cited the context and explained what you don't want to understand.
Here's how one right-wing site embellishes the misrepresentation even further.
Forget The Jews: Ed Schultz Says Gays Were The Real Victims Of The Holocaust
...
By Robert Gehl on May 12, 2014
So now it's "Forget the Jews" is it? Where'd that come from, Sean?
Robert Gehl
Have a Benghazi day, Sean.
BTW, I don't believe the tweet has been confirmed; if/when it is, I'll comment on that.
Well, Carp are bottom feeders, like Schultz and those who post off sites like his....but....Catfish on the other hand? A different class of dinner altogether....
At least when it happened on Colbert's official account, he immediately acted to ensure the problem was fixed and made public his actions....not so much for Schultz. And Six does have a point when it comes toselective outrage.
((((((Dowser))))))
As I've come to expect from you, you've said it very succinctly.
It was a stupid choice of words. He shouldn't have said it. Culling your archives to tell people everyone else is bad to take the light off this is a waste of time. He said it, he's an idiot, as if everyone with any sense doesn't already know that. You piling reams of evidence against the other side serves nothing but to make you look like an unofficial apologist for this assclown.
What? Not one of those who jumped on the yet-to-be-substantiated tweet have registered one word about the fact that a right-wing "reporter" has embellished the tweet by adding the words "Forget the Jews" to the alleged rest of the comment.
But the lying POS knew enough to not put his addition in quotation marks in his headline because he knows he made it the fuck up to further incite the willingly-and-without-proof righteously indignant.
One would think all of you Holocaust scholars would know that Hitler's Ministry of Propaganda DID EXACTLY THIS KIND OF THING -- repeat a lie until the zeal-without-knowledge dupes bought it, then add to the lie with embellishments!
So okay -- you believe that Schultz made the tweet -- I'll assume (foolishly) that if the reported tweet turns out to be a phony story, that you'll all drop in to say "OUR BAD". And if it turns out the report is accurate, I'll drop by to re-explain (third time) what it may have meant in a context.
BUT YOU ALL KNOW FUCKIN' WELL THAT THIS "Forget The Jews" addition is pure right-wing bullshit bullshit that was not reported as having been in the tweet. So, are you just going to let it dangle out there in order to put gasoline on the fire that made have been started by an "arsonist" and not Schultz?
Integrity anyone?
When someone levels an allegation, be it ethically or legally, that individual has the obligation of satisfying a so-called "burden-of-proof". If that individual (along with all who take his allegation and run with it) does not only fail to furnish proof (a tweet can be photoshopped and faked FYI) but subsequently adds a lie to the allegation, common sense tells us to be suspicious.
If the truth is on your side, why add a lie?
Rhetorical question.
(((((((((((((((((Spikegary)))))))))))))))))
dennis,
There is not yet any proof that Schultz made the comment, just an alleged screen shot of what the "shooter" says was taken down soon after he shot it. And the fact that all of the usual right-wing web sites ran with it does not constitute proof.
I paraphrased the alleged Schultz tweet based on a story Schultz ran regarding Louis Gohmert's comment in which he (Gohmert) compared people who regard anti-homosexual individuals as "haters", to Nazis who called homosexuals "haters".
Schultz's alleged tweet, IF IT ACTUALLY WAS MADE, can be explained by my paraphrasing which is more plausible than the idea that Schultz, out-of-the-blue, just decided to tweet that "homosexuals were really the ones persecuted in Hitler's Germany". IF THAT WAS ACTUALLY TWEETED, I TAKE IT TO MEAN THAT THE HOMOSEXUALS PERSECUTED BY NAZI'S WERE REALLY THE VICTIMS OF HATERS and NOT THEMSELVES HATERS.
And with the lie added to a headline on the right wing site/article I quoted and linked to, makes me even more convinced that the alleged tweet is either out of context, mis-quoted or a fake.
The alleged tweet-screen shot did not mention Jews, but the headline I cited begins with the words "Forget the Jews" which was not in the screen shot and served only to make the original tweet more incendiary. The author of the headline knew better than to put the Forget the Jews in quotation marks because he knows Schultz was not alleged to have said that.
If the tweet screen shot is real is true, why add a lie to embellish it?
I respect you dennis and we have always disagreed respectfully; that is why I bothered to explain myself again I owe you that respect.
My "need" to paraphrase is quite like me ; I never duck a question and I systematically and with specificity challenge that which I believe to be incorrect, fraudulent and insidious.
The tweet screen shot could easily be faked by anyone with an agenda and a basic knowledge of Photoshop/image editing.
Maybe I'll create one to piss off those who simply accept the "tweet" on its face value.
There dennis, took me three minutes. Piece of cake.
Here's a screen shot that shows what tweets actually look like, JR.
And no one has definitively substantiated nor debunked it, so, we don't know for sure. WHAT WE DO KNOW IS THE HEADLINE I'VE CITED AND THE ADDITION OF AN INCENDIARY PHRASE THAT WAS NOT A PART OF THE ORIGINAL STORY; THAT MAKES ME DOUBT THE WHOLE STORY.
We'll see.
Kat Braybrooke @ codekat Follow
Like many @ Mozilla staff, I'm taking a stand. I do not support the Board's appointment of @ BrendanEich as CEO. # Prop8 http:// bit.ly/1jS479A
How can a company striving for openness appoint someone who funds opposition to same-sex marriage? By Matt Andrews
Sydney Moyer @ sydneymoyer FollowI'm an employee of @ mozilla and cannot reconcile having @ BrendanEich as CEO with our org's culture & mission. Brendan, please step down.
please step down.
And he did.
And it was covered on the left wing media which is the mainstream media as I've been informed.
And Chick fil a was covered heavily by the same left wing media, which is the mainstream media, but
it was like this fellow never said or did anything to upset anyone. Funny how that works.
I agree; but I'll wait a bit.
Note the sentence structure on my twitter screen shot of Schultz tweets roughly 65-70 letters/characters across the field per sentence. Now look at the alleged screen shot in the article and the sentence configuration.
Can you find another Schultz tweet configured like the one that was allegedly his in this article? Let me know. Post it and I'll concede.
I'll wait to decide what I think about this.
And here's another extended misrepresentation
Ed Shultz tweets it was gays, not Jews, most persecuted in Nazi Germany
Wednesday, May 14, 2014 at 2:08 PM EDT
...
Glenn Beck changes the language of the alleged screen shot but knowing it's bullshit, is careful not to put it in quotation marks!
The right wing, communist, marxist, Leninist, socialist, Nazi all have one thing in common and that is collectivist.
Those are all tweets you guys are looking at there. This was a #Edshow which is a hash tag, not in the normal tweets.
I don't know if it is true or not. I've never known Ed to say anything out of line, have you?
Here's a funny one though on one of Ed's tweets where he says President@BarackObama finally takes a stand against Republican obstruction. buswk.co/1irTHQO Tell #Edshow where you stand.
Imagine that, after waiting for almost two year before getting this information requested from the Obama Administration and having to go to court to get it, Obama is finally taking a stand against Republican obstruction from the most transparent administration in history, which by the way has been debunked by by not only the conservative media, but the liberal media as well.
Well said Perrie.
Yeah, the story is; but the story is not yet substantiated. One guy claims he saw it and moments later it was gone but he managed to take a screen shot just in time.
We'll see.
Predictably, every right-wing site has the so-called screen shot and the "story" -- and like so many others like it, it may be one of those dishonest e-mails that become right-wing gospel even long after they've been outed.
Think about it. Under what circumstances does an educated person spontaneously blurt out TWEET such an obvious distortion of a well-documented horror of history?
Someone please put in print here for me write under your avatar/name the following: "Ed Schultz actually believes what's in the alleged tweet and really thinks that what's in the tweet is correct."
Then tell me that you agree with Rush Limbaugh that Schultz said it to please the "gay lobby." Then ask yourself, "Why TF would Schultz do that isn't there a Jewish "Lobby", and one that's likely much larger than a"gay lobby"?
Think.
I think Liberals have a selective reading, hearing and seeing disability.
He's such a nice fellow, isn't he?
See what I mean. One person was let go. Can't you people recognize a liar when you hear one?
Whether or not Schultz is a "nice fellow" has nothing to do with whether or not the alleged tweet is real.
If you can't make the case, you can't make the case and trying to make it by innuendo, character assassination or any means but with relevant information is bogus.
And I thought we were talking about a tweet the sequester has nothing to do with the issue at hand, but Six, out of respect to you, I responded to your comment.
All your video and comment do is emphasize that no one has yet provided evidence that the screen shot is legitimate and that weakens your argument by making it look like desperation.
The sequester was supported by Obama as a way of keeping the world economy from crashing due to the Republican/Tea Party threat not to honor the debt ceiling and pay the bills that CONGRESS racked up. It would have eroded America's credit rating and had a ripple effect in that the world's strongest economy was willing to become a deadbeat because of one political party's willingness to hold its country hostage!
The Tea Party tried it a second time nevertheless and Obama was saying in the second video, "NO! NOT THIS TIME!" Recall the government shutdown precipitated by the Tea Party when Obama wouldn't give in.
Posting things either out of context or, in a disingenuous misrepresentation via fragmented context is not flattering to those who do so!
Look at the video as you play it and see the logo at the bottom right. Was it edited by the Examiner?
And tell us more about the "one person let go" and then I'll tell you about all the people who were hurt by the shutdown better yet
And should military personnel have been deprived of pay?
...
And what does the sequester and Obama have to do with the so-called "tweet"?
And I agree. I think I said earlier that I didn't know if it was real or not, but if I didn't I'm saying it now. I don't know if it is real or not. But I've heard Schultz say many things anyone other than a Liberal would have been ostracized for in the past. When people in high positions have brothers, sisters, parents and children working for the media and the White House corruption in the media is a result. And I can honestly say I see a issue with it in our media as it is and isn't presented to us through the mainstream media today.
And I have to say if it isn't or wasn't real, I believe Ed Schultz would have said it wasn't real or explained it but I haven't seen anything, doesn't mean you or someone else has put it up before this comment, but I haven't heard a word of denial from Ed Schultz about it, which would be highly unusual.
While all of that may or may not be true, it does not address whether or not the alleged tweet is true. If it's not in the mainstream media, could that not be because it's a bogus allegation and only "news" to the right wing web sites and their followers.
I have addressed dozens of such "reports" posted here THAT WENT NOWHERE BECAUSE THEY WERE SIMPLY FRAUDS.
It's unethical/fraudulent to post lies knowingly and just as unethical to perpetuate them knowing the are both defamatory AND UNSUBSTANTIATED!
All I said was if it was not true, I just can't believe some left wing site would have not already put up articles to defend it. I've already said I didn't know if it were true or not. Like many other articles on here put out by some organization that doesn't even warrant a wikipedia article were put out as being significant and true.
I couldn't tell you if it is true. That's one reason I like to hear it from the horse's mouth as evidence, which we know is not always what it seems, but still at least you hear it and then can debate it.
I didn't put this up here to promote a lie. I put it up here just like anyone else puts articles up. You've debated it well and now I have my doubts, but at the same time I have always seen left wing sites step in to defend anything that isn't true or twist it around. This is not to say the right wing doesn't twist things as well.
Did it ever occur to you that left wing sites might investigate the veracity of the allegation before just calling it a fake? That unlike all the right-wing sites that just ran with it as with all the other debunked fake e-mails and phony accusations?
We'll see; and if I find anything definitive either way, I'll post it.
Total agreement, dennis.