Chick-fil-A location at DIA paused after Denver Council cites chain's LGBT stances
Chick-fil-A's reputation as an opponent of same-sex marriage has imperiled the fast-food chain's potential return to Denver International Airport, with several City Council members this week passionately questioning a proposed concession agreement.
Councilman Paul Lopez called opposition to the chain at DIA "really, truly a moral issue on the city."
His position comes despite ardent assurances from the concessionaires who have operated other DIA restaurants that strict nondiscrimination policies will include protections based on sexual orientation and gender identity.
RELATED: Chick-fil-A flap: Read Denver council members' joint statement
Robin Kniech, the council's first openly gay member, said she was most worried about a local franchise generating "corporate profits used to fund and fuel discrimination." She was first to raise Chick-fil-A leaders' politics during a Tuesday committee hearing.
The normally routine process of approving an airport concession deal has taken a rare political turn. The Business Development Committee on Tuesday stalled the seven-year deal with a new franchisee of the popular chain for two weeks.
Should the committee reject the lease, an individual member if one is willing could introduce the concession deal in the full council. Ten of the 13 members attended Tuesday's meeting, and none rose to defend Chick-fil-A, although some didn't weigh in.
"We can do better than this brand in Denver at our airport, in my estimation," new member Jolon Clark said.
Legal considerations
At the committee's next meeting, Sept. 1, city attorneys likely will brief the committee behind closed doors on legal considerations affecting the decision.
City leaders in Chicago attempted to block a new Chick-fil-A location for similar reasons three years ago, ultimately backing down after reaching an agreement with the chain. Mayors in Boston and San Francisco vowed to fend off any foray by Chick-fil-A into those cities. The issue continues to flare on some university campuses .
But legal scholars often have come to the company's defense, raising company leaders' First Amendment rights.
The issue is new for the Denver council.
"This discussion the way it's unfolding here hasn't quite happened before in terms of a contract decision that you all have been asked to make, in all my years here," assistant city attorney David Broadwell told the committee Tuesday. He said he was caught off guard by the controversy.
A previous Chick-fil-A franchise operated at DIA briefly a decade ago. This time, Atlanta-based Concessions International and Denver's Delarosa Restaurant Concepts have a 60-40 partnership for a location in Concourse B's food court, replacing a Steak Escape.
Mike De La Rosa, Delarosa's president, said the licensing agreement requires sharing 7 percent of royalties with Chick-fil-A, a proportion that Councilman Albus Brooks said was lower than he'd expected.
"Any and all hiring, promotion any and all of those decisions are made by us," De La Rosa told the committee. "We have a long history of diversity, all those kind of things, between both companies. These would not be issues."
In a statement, Chick-fil-A corporate officials said that their company is "focused on providing everyone great food in an atmosphere of genuine hospitality. We hope to welcome all guests to any of our locations, including a proposed licensed location at the Denver International Airport."
Questions raised
Several council members including four on the six-member committee raised questions related to Chick-fil-A's religion-influenced operation, which includes keeping all franchises closed on Sundays.
Most focused on political firestorms sparked by remarks made by Chick-fil-A's now-CEO Dan Cathy, reaching a peak in 2012 after court decisions favorable to same-sex marriage. The company also came under fire for donations made by charitable arms to groups opposing LGBT causes.
Last year, Cathy said publicly that he regretted inserting the company into political debates . Its foundations also cut back on donations to groups that some considered anti-gay.
Kniech asked De La Rosa, "If the national corporation with which you are affiliated once again puts themselves at the center of a national debate about depriving people and their families of rights, would you as a concessionaire have any ability to influence that?"
"I don't believe so," he said.
"I don't think you would, either," Kniech said. "And that's my concern."
Lopez compared Chick-fil-A's past politics to divisive remarks made this year by Republican presidential candidate Donald Trump about immigration and other issues, saying: "I would throw up in my mouth a little bit if we did business with Trump."
Kniech, Lopez and other members said DIA's reputation was at stake, although airport officials view the concession as a big potential money-maker.
DIA has estimated the restaurant's first-year sales at $4.1 million, with $616,278 paid each year in concession fees. Chick-fil-A restaurants typically generate more in six days a week, DIA says, than most fast-food concessions that are open all seven.
DIA officials told the committee that they started with a dozen concession proposals for the space.
Neil Maxfield, the senior vice president of concession, noted that a 2013 survey of airport users "identified Chick-fil-A as being the second-most sought-after quick service brand at the airport, second to Chipotle," which didn't apply for the space.
http://www.denverpost.com/news/ci_28668633/denver-council-hits-pause-chick-fil-at-dia

Ah, more government reprisals for free speech. How American.
Yes a nice example of liberal tolerance.
Such are the wages of sin for Chick-fil-A.
Chick Filet is being blackballed for the same position Obama held in 2012.
Remember when homosexuals used to plead for tolerance? Guess they don't really believe in it for other people.
Businesses that discriminate in the public space need to just STFU when their discrimination bites them in the ass.
Note all speech is protected under the 1st Amendment but "equal protection under the law is guaranteed under the 14th so ya' can't have it both ways.
Possibly you missed the part about conservative INtolerance. Interesting that it appears some would tolerate those who discriminate but not those who speak out against intolerance.
I've eaten there . Their food is great . Enjoy your used condom !
Speaking out about intolerance is not that same as discriminating in the name of tolerance, attacking people in the name of tolerance and trying put a small mom and pop shop out of business in the name of tolerance.
Tell me Amac. Do you think it is OK to force a priest to marry a same sex couple? Do you think it is OK to force a Rabbi to perform a Christian marriage?
You see you can't really have a fair discussion about intolerance for things like same sex marriage without taking into consideration the reasoning of someone who doesn't want to do something against their religion, and therefore, talk about religious intolerance.
Well actually I suppose you could since it seems to be happening all the time but that doesn't change the fact that it is very short sighted, slanted, and well, intolerant.
How does the discrimination against any demographic represent "discriminating in the name of tolerance?"
Let me know.
As long as they only use language & not actions it is not real discrimination . They have the right to free speech .
How did Chick-fil-a discriminate?
Let's review what really happened.
Let me know how you think this is discrimination.
Let me also post that he want a little further in another interview:
Feel free to let me know how this amounts to discrimination as well.
Me too.
Some of their money goes to propagate and promote discrimination. So (math guy that you are) here's an axiom "THINGS EQUAL TO THE SAME THING ARE EQUAL TO EACH OTHER."
Money talks and bullshit walks!
Donating money to an organization does not amount to discrimination and the matter that you may not like who they donate to does not change that fact. I would think with your legal background you would know this.
It appears that you are OK with discrimination against a company that has done nothing wrong.
The problem you seem to have with them is the CEO's opinion on same sex marriage, and that that they donated to some organizations you disagree with.
Because of this you you cheer discrimination against them.
THAT, my friend, is intolerance.
Discrimination in the name of God violates the very ideology it reference as justification
John 13:34
Hey, I felt free.
Donating to an organization that promotes discrimination, that by citing ideology and/or religious tenets as justification, is legal so is castigating the donor and the recipients.
Live by the sword, Dude!
BTW, I agree that government should NOT prevent them from opening a location!
I would however advocate not patronizing any of their locations.
They have their opinion -- I have my opinion.
Castigating? Fine. However, discriminating based on it IS illegal.
I am glad to see you have added this.
This is a free country and this is EXACTLY how these situations should be handled. Kudos to your boycott! If you don't like what they are doing, by all means, take your money elsewhere! Feel free to do your best to enlist as many as you can as well if you think this is a cause worth taking, but let's not discriminate and be fair as to keep the same tolerance across the board. Eh?
Discriminating by way of a personal boycott is legal and I reiterate, as much as I disagree with the ideology of Chick-fil-A, they should not be prevented from opening locations for that reason.
But understand, when an individual or entity takes a position, bitching about the fallout is wanting to have it both ways.
Pick a fight don't cry when the counter punches come.
Glad to hear that, I wish more were as objective and fair.
Looks like you were posing this the same time I was posting:
This is a free country and this is EXACTLY how these situations should be handled. Kudos to your boycott! If you don't like what they are doing, by all means, take your money elsewhere! Feel free to do your best to enlist as many as you can as well if you think this is a cause worth taking, but let's not discriminate and be fair as to keep the same tolerance across the board. Eh?
As long as it is a punch you get back (fair fight) and not a knife or a bullet. (governmental discrimination)
Essentially we agree, 96, not ideologically, but certainly in terms of what constitutes fair and reasonable reaction.
It doesn't really matter if the owners of Chick Fil A agree with gay marriage or not, it is the law of the land as it should be. What is important is that they make a damn good chicken sammidge and I fly into Denver quite a bit. Sure would be nice to munch a Chick Fil A while waiting on a plane. Why deprive myself of a tasty treat just because someone disagrees with me? That's just silly.
Well that is a very mature take on the subject, one that seems lacking for many. I say boycott if you want. My problem with many people on these subjects is that they call themselves "tolerant" as they encourage discrimination and intolerance towards those they disagree with. Why is it that the self proclaimed "tolerant" crowd are the biggest hypocrites?
Some folks just take politics way too seriously. If I only hung out with folks who agreed with me, I wouldn't have any friends. That would suck. Politics is amusing and at times quite entertaining, but at the end of the day, it ain't all that.
That applies to both sides of the aisle, my friend.
That's why I said "self proclaimed tolerant".
If you were at a farmer's market and you came across a booth that had some luscious heirloom tomatoes, would you buy them or would you first ask the ideology of the guy selling them?
We certainly agree on what constitutes fair and reasonable action. Actually, just because I am defending Chick-fil-a's right to open a restaurant does not necessarily mean we disagree on ideology, you have made an assumption, that being said I think there ARE cases in which refusing to do something against your religion or beleifs should not be viewed as discrimination. Example: I don't think a gay couple should expect any priest they want to marry them, regardless of that priests religion any more that I think a gay person should be forced to have heterosexual relations.
LOL good point Chucky. I suppose people who do business and blab their ideologies take a risk. However, I think the risk they should be taking is that you will take your money elsewhere. Not that you will try to put them out of business or vandalize their shop because you disagree with them.
Sean T.:
Sean, What you have just said is ridiculous. Remember when some young black people sat down at lunch counters in the Jim Crow South, or refused to ride at the back of the bus, etc.? In essence, you're saying those black people were "intolerant" of those white-owned business people who would not let them sit down at the lunch counter. You're saying they should be more tolerant of bigots and bigotry ... and just to go ahead with their program.
Where I come from, folks who talk like that are called a-holes. We're pretty intolerant of such a-hole-ish-ness 'round here where I live.
I don't know if I've just violated the CoC in saying so. Probably not, as folks 'round here often say a-hole-ish things and get away with it. Perhaps I can find another, kinder, sweeter way of letting folks know when what they say might come off as a-hole-ish to the kinder, gentler folks who prefer not to be a-holes?
Interesting question; if the guy was just peddling his wares and not both pontificating his ideology and letting it be known that he was funding it as well, it would be a non-issue and I would buy or pass on the tomatoes based on their appeal.
That's the point, IMO. Once ideology and business are co-mingled with the intent of publicizing the (forgive the pun) "marriage" to make a statement, both the benefit or backlash is on the business.
Make a statement using the name of your brand for leverage, take a stand and do so to capitalize on the backs of a group of human beings who have nothing to do with your business, whose actions do not directly affect you, and that because you can't practice your religion without doing so
Tough shit if it comes back to bite you in the ass.
An individual or entity that condemns another without provocation and does so based on Christian beliefs needs to learn more about Christianity
Matthew 26:52
It was a bit more complex than that.
I'm not responding directly TO Petey, here. I'm responding ABOUT his post. I do not speak with Petey.
Petey distinguishes between action and speech, and that's fine. I can't help wondering how folks like Petey feel about millions of dollars being spent to get a message out? Is that an action or a speech?
" the S. Truett Cathy -family-operated WinShape Foundation , had donated millions of dollars to political organizations seen as hostile to LGBT causes by LGBT rights activists "
Yes, we have been discussing that. Amac has pointed out their donation habits. As I said before, donating to organizations does not amount to discrimination, regardless of whether you like those organizations or not, and discriminating based on who they donate to or their opinion of same sex marriage is illegal.
96WS6 :
" .... As I said before, donating to organizations does not amount to discrimination, regardless of whether you like those organizations or not...."
Is that so?
So this must then include donations to the Klu Klux Klan, Neo Nazi organizations and Al-Qaeda?
Although I agree with both of you on opening new locations, it seems what is under discussion here is whether a particular city council should be renewing a lease / contract (?) at a city airport. I think a city council has every right to prefer another customer in such cases, if it so suits them.
But I'll tell you quite honestly that I think these are complicated and muddy waters we're in here. Both ethically and legally. Just because I said what I said does NOT mean I'm not open to discussion on it. I am.
Denver will back down before letting a court decide against them.
I seriously doubt any reasonable court will rule that the Denver City Council HAS to vote to have a Chick-fil-A in their airport. By that logic after all of the other restaurants sue to be allowed in their the entire airport would be nothing but just a great big mall food court with no room even for the airplanes. Or are all airports going to be required, under a court order, to have a Chick-fil-A in them?
Yes, perhaps.
But let us put ourselves empathetically in the shoes of of the Denver City Council members who have to approve or disapprove a contract renewal at a city airport (if I have these details correct). They have their constituents to contend with, and whatever ethical / moral commitments they have as civil servants. Let's honestly try to be in their shoes a moment or two and wonder how we would respond to such a situation as they are in.
Absolute agreement brother, with the proviso that it runs both ways. People that proselytize their non-religious beliefs shouldn't be calling justifying bad behavior by those beliefs.
But there is always the oddball situation....
WHAT ABOUT GOVERNMENT?
We hear a lot about how government should not hold to religious belief, but should government actually take action against religious belief?
Because we hear a lot about that also.
And I am going to have to disagree (respectfully) with some of the people in this disscussion about Chick-fil-A. I think their food is just awful! Granted, I haven't been to one in several years, but if they still taste as terrible as they did before, yuck! I'm glad they created all of this controversy about themselves, because it adds a political reason to avoid them, not just a culinary one.
You obviously have better choices to offer as suggestions . What would they be ?
Something like, Sampson's Sawdust Sandwiches. No smoking allowed.
I have eaten at a lot of fast food restaurants in my life and I put them right on the bottom, so pick any major franchise and it'll be better. How about a Der Wienerschnitzel? Even though they don't actually have Wienerschnitzel on the menu?
Now if they put a White Castle's in there, now you're talking some good eats! The turkey sliders are incredible! Back in my heavy dope smoking days (in the Air Force) I once ate (while very, very high) 23 of their turkey sliders, a small fries and a Coke while sitting on the curb at a White Castle's in Bloomington, MN, the whole time under the watchful eye of two of Minnesota's finest sitting in their car eating and watching me and my friends. I think if I tried that today it would kill me. But what a way to go!
Regardless of what kind of situation they are in, breaking the law and discriminating against a business that has done nothing wrong from a legal standpoint is unacceptable and illegal.
I have never seen a law that says you MUST have a Chick-fil-A at your local airport. Proving discrimination against them would be damned near impossible.
Dude!?!? one of them straight up said they don't want to let them in becase of who they may donate their own money to:
and...
He said this in response to theirbeliefsof marriage.
Did you read the article. The vote is over, now they are trying to block it fromopeningin the airport.
Still works for me...they gotta right to change their minds...it's the American way...
Would it still "work for you" if it was a company owned by Homosexuals and they were being blocked because these folks decided they didn't want a restaurant owned by Homosexuals in "their" airport? If not, can you explain your double standard? Why is it OK to be intolerant to the religious community and not the LGBT community? Is Hypocrisy the American way IYO?
Personally, I think both are unacceptable.
White Castle ? Are you racist ?! Anyone who eats at White Castle has taste up his ass ! But thanks for proving that to the unbiased readers who were previously undecided . As I said B4 chic-fil-a is excellent . And I'm not even getting a free coupon to say that ...
I suppose I should have included "legal" as part of the description of the organizations they donate to. Making a comparison to Al-Qaeda and the like is a bit dramatic, don't you think? Can you point out any illegal or terrorist activities the organizations that they have donated to have participated in?
I think it's up to the City Council who run the airport to decide what restaurants they want servicing their customers. It's seems to me that, according to those on the anti-gay side are saying that pro-gay rights people like myself are being intolerant when we point out the anti-gay agenda of a particular company, but that according to the right wing, we have to tolerate anything any religious company says. The position Chik-fil-A is taking is not just a religious one, it is also a political one and it's come back to bite them in the ass. To them I say, tough shit. Deal.
I guess it's being intolerant for someone YOU don't agree with to point out the intolerance of others. It's you who is being intolerant by claiming that they don't have the right to choose and/or block which restaurants they want or do not want at their airport. If there are people in Denver who disagree, then let them run or support a candidate who they do agree with.
Hypocrite thy name is liberal.
Sock puppets Say what?
Chick fil a does not discriminate. DIA does.
Good for them. They are free to do so. Government reprisals are unconstitutional.
Again. I fail to see how anything he said amounts to discrimination. He was stating his own opinion/beliefs on based on his own religion.
Do you believe it is discrimination in the name of God because he said he believes that some people think they know better than God what constitutes Marriage, and that he believes they are trying to redefine God's definition of marriage?
Is it discrimination because his opinion/beliefs are contrary to yours?
Does he lose the right to voice or hold his own beliefs if they are contrary to yours?
Who has he discriminated against by voicing his opinion?
I eat there about once a week. Their chicken is pretty good. Viva freedom!
Nope. That's discrimination. A government agency cannot punish a company for its owners' view. This isn't Cuba.
I doubt it. Whenever the liberal mob wants to punish a company they say it isn't very good. Generally, they are lying. Chick fil A has excellent chicken.
Your tastes are suspect. They have the best chicken fast food, hands down. Your ideology blinds you.
Typical liberal response. A state government violates the constitution. However, since it is for a partisan cause you believe in, you are willing to look the other way. Hypocrisy is ugly.
Hmm, the way you lumped that statement it looks like you think they should be able to block a restaurant they don't want in their airport based solely on who owns it whether it be because the owners are religious, Homosexual, Lesbian, or for racial reasons as well.
What exactly are you trying to say?
I am clearly saying it is not OK for them to bock any of them for any of those reasons. All are unacceptable.
It is also illegal to block them for political reasons. You are letting your emotions on the subject cloud your judgement. They have broken no laws and it is not OK to block them for what they believe, or if they are black, or if they are gay, if they are blind, if they are Amish, or if their skin is purple....you get where I'm going with this?
BTW people who advocate for equal rights for all groups are not "anti gay"
Good thing that he would only throw up in his mouth a little bit...
But my taste buds open my eyes wide and have for years. I have always hated Chick-fil-A. Their food sucked way back when I was more interested in partying then politics. I have tried to give them a chance, but, before I knew or cared about any of the political stances of the owners, their food still stunk. It's always been bad. Sorry, but no ideology here on this. Their food is just terrible and I would still think so if they were owned and operated by a married gay couple.
No matter how you want to state it and your thought process is getting more convoluted with every post) the truth remains that DIA has a right to allow to open, not open or block any restaurant chain they want to. Just so they don't do it on religious grounds and they are not. They are doing it on political grounds and the Constitution doesn't say that a business has a right to open a restaurant wherever they want to. DIA has a right to boycott Chick-fil-A.
I think everyone is missing the point.
This restaurant is NOT owned by Chik-Fil-A. Clearly stated in the article. Seems that people are overlooking that one little tidbit.
So effectively, the DIA IS discriminating against two business owners based upon who they choose to affiliate with. their only connection the Chik-Fil-A is that they will be paying 7% of theor profit stream for the rights to used the Chik-Fil-A brand. Which by the way is the second most desirable franchise to have in an airport concourse. The most desirable (Chipotle) not submitting to open in DIA. they are only open 6 days a week and they generate twice as much revenue to DIA than anyone else does.
So what is happening here is the best choice is being targeted for not their beliefs but for their choice to do whatever they can to maximize the profitability of their business.
They are imprinting their political/religious opinions upon two business men that have no connection to Chik-Fil-A at all because of Chik-Fil-A's religious/political positions, which are not theirs.
That my friends is discrimination against the two business men who did file for the space.
So the question is can an employee of a government agency use their political position to openly discriminate upon the basis of their personal beliefs?
Those that say they can ARE revealing their hypocrisy.
The choice is a simple one. Are we going to have a discriminatory government agency or not?
We can't when it comes to gay marraige, correct? what is the difference?
None, there is no difference.
If they can ban or disenfranchise these two businessmen because of who they affiliate with, then any country clerk can disenfranchise any potential marriage couple by who they choose to affiliate with.
They are both government agencies.
You can't have it both ways my liberal friends.
Despite its massive size, the DIA has a limited space available for restaurants. To me, this should be a decision based on business goals-- which business is more likely to produce more profits for the airport. I would hesitate to put in a Chik-Fil-A restaurant if it were to be located between a Lee's Famous Recipe Chicken and KFC. Or, if the airport feels that a restaurant open 7 days a week is what they want, rather than 6 days a week-- I can see that a 6 day restaurant would generate a lower profit for the airport. Chick-Fil-A's stance on gay marriage should have nothing to do with it-- and everything to do with the business aspect.
Like the Godfather said, it's business, not personal.
We rarely eat at Chick-Fil-A, because my son is a vegetarian, and there isn't much on the menu that he can eat. They usually donate 200 burgers to our high school band activities, for which I am grateful. I find them to be quite tasty, especially when compared to the hot dogs we, the band moms, fix.
On a lighter note, remember when Denver's airport luggage handling system was a total failure? 20 years ago, about? Well, I worked at the international engineering firm that designed that system. I flew into the Denver airport to consult on an ethylene glycol problem that was leaking into their baggage handling facility from de-icing the planes, and, of course, they lost my luggage...
I'm of the same mind Dowser. If there not open on Sundays, which is a heavy travel day, what's the point of them being there.
Did you ever find your luggage.
Regardless of if they are discriminating because of the owners choices or because of the CEO's position on marriage they are still discriminating.
The point from a business standpoint, as pointed out in the article, is they produce twice the revenue over those six days that any other does in seven days.
That is why they were selected, a proper business decision. place the most profitable business, that generates the most revenue, in the space. In this case, with that being the focus, how many days they are open is irrelevant.
I can't find in the article where it states that they produce twice the revenue in six days that any other does in seven days.
''DIA has estimated the restaurant's first-year sales at $4.1 million, with $616,278 paid each year in concession fees. Chick-fil-A restaurants typically generate more in six days a week, DIA says, than most fast-food concessions that are open all seven.''
And the 6 vs 7 day thing is not irrelevant, customer service is part of it. Sunday is a heavy travel day, and I would think that having a restaurant open all 7 days would be part of the decision making.
Is the airport open 7 days a week? Chick-fil-A isn't. Seems simple to me: Have the restaurant open 7 days a week, so people can eat. Forget about how homophobic and backwards they are, The rest of the world has, 'cause they (supposedly) make better chicken and people have forgotten how to do that.
My luggage went on to LA, but returned the next day, thankfully! Much better than the time I went to work in New York, but my luggage went to London and stayed at the Ritz Hotel for a week.
Quoted from the OP's article above...
The link to the original article where the OP obtained it is the Denver Post one the last link in the extant article.
Here.
...
When they mention 4.1 million in sales, they are talking only about the franchise about to open at DIA, not all Chik-Fil-A's. Most airport concessions don't come anywhere near those figures, and that at 7 days a week.
Absolute sound business decision to allow them in. Best use of the space with the greatest potential for positive return. Absolute political hackery to keep them out.
And like I said, if anti religious bias can keep them out of the airport, then religious bias should be able to keep people out of the county clerks office.
Everything being equal.
Except Chik-Fil-A is the company and product that brings in the money, More than any other but one. Despite their being open only six days.
So are you saying they should take less and not give the passengers what they want because of a very few people's personal beliefs?
Especially when those few get to make the decisions for everyone?
What does that do to the county clerks?
I see, it is only liberal anti religious government officials that get to make decisions, the rest that have different views should be ignored.
Still don't see where they make twice as much in 6 days vs the 7 day opening.
As they stated that they are only paying a fee to Chik Fil A. They should be able to be open 7 days a week, which would be even more revenue for the airport/themselves/Chik. That is a good business decision, plus it serves the multitude of travelers that are there on Sundays.
When you buy a franchise, your stuck with the rules that come with it. Chik-Fil-A is open 6 days a week.
But they stand to make millions, and the airport put a nice chunk of change into their coffers also.
If they are allowed to based upon a few peoples personal preferences and opinions.
They may have the right, but is it right.
Not at all, I am saying that Chik-fil-a should allow its Franchisees to be open whenever they wish, instead of forcing their (the few at corporate) religious views on the franchisees, the employees thereof and the real and potential customers who walk by a closed storefront on Sunday.
This is where you depart from the true libertarian ideal. If you look at it from that point of view, by not allowing them to be open when they wish, the Franchiser is depriving the Franchisee of potential profits.
Before you say it, I know that these are the conditions that the franchisees signed onto. But it seems to take the idea of religious liberty and turn it on it's head, because you have the few imparting their religious views on the many, with money and employment as their cudgel. Kind of reminds me of Animal Farm: All creatures are created equal, but some are more equal than others.
If indeed it is a franchise, then it would seem that the owners of Chik are the ones pushing their personal preferences on others. Namely DIA. Why not allow them to be open on Sundays?
Chik-Fil-A is not pushing anything on anyone especially DIA.
Chik-Fil-A is not the business that want's to open in DIA.
The two companies that have gone in together to do it. they will also be paying franchise fees to Chik-Fil-A to use their program, products and name.
Chik-fil-A is not doing a damned thing in all this.
Two local Denver businessmen are.
This is what is so asinine about all this. Chik-Fil-A has nothing to do with it.
Just seems to me that people are abusing others cause of a very tenuous connection to a company they dislike.
The funny thing is the more they do this, the more Chik-Fil-A's business grows.
Those two businessmen could decide to do some other franchise I guess, and not make anywhere near the money for themselves and the airport. And they can remain open for 7 days.
So what is the real issue?
It sure as heck isn't about good business. Is it?
It's a Chik Fil A franchise, of course they have something to do with this.
How can it be a franchise of Chik fil A and be a tenuous connection. That is nonsense.
If the relationship was tenuous why isn't it open 7 days a week. That would be good business. More revenue for all parties involved. If, as they say they generate more revenue in 6 days than others in 7 days, good business would say to be open the 7th day.
Any straw to keep the hate for Chik-Fil-A justified? It's their business model, it works for them. Chik-Fil-A didn't force these two gentlemen to pick their business model, they chose it cause it makes the most money in that position than any other. That is the only basis of it being Chik-Fil-A.
Who am I to say different.
I say fine, take the franchise elsewhere and put a seven day a week business in there.
Seems like to me they really want hundreds of thousands less money.
The hours and days of the week argument is a strawman.
To get that nit pickey to claim it is all about Chik-Fil-A is actually pretty ludicrous.
Actually no, I'm not departing from the Libertarian ideal, this represents that you do not really understand what the Libertarian ideal is. And it is not all Ayn Rand.
I do not see where anyone is forced into anything here. Chik-Fil-A has their business model, it works for them. the two business men didn't choose it cause they were forced to, they chose it cause in that position in DIA it's the business model that turns the most profit. The only one that returns more refused to be entered in the selection process. (Chipotle)
Religion has nothing to do with it, Another straw man argument.
To that I answer "NO, NOT LEGALLY!"
But to balance the scales, when a company like HOBBY LOBBY cites "religious beliefs" to discriminate against its employees with regard to certain aspects of mandated health insurance coverage, that constitutes a double standard!
If "religious beliefs" cannot be used to preclude that which addresses "the common good," the "general welfare," that in conjunction with the public space then they should not be justification to preclude anythingthat government provides or mandates for the benefit of its citizens.
To that I answer "NO, NOT LEGALLY!"
But to balance the scales, when a company like HOBBY LOBBY cites "religious beliefs" to discriminate against its employees with regard to certain aspects of mandated health insurance coverage, that constitutes a double standard!
If "religious beliefs" cannot be used to preclude that which addresses "the common good," the "general welfare," that in conjunction with businesses in the public space then they should not be justification to precludeanythingthat government provides or mandates for the benefit of its citizens.
Let's not be hypocritical.
Why would you say that I hate Chik fil A? That is a straw man if I ever heard one.
My argument isn't a straw man as you well know. Everything that I pointed out is for maximizing revenue and profits for the parties involved. And providing 7 day service at a large airport.
Fairly simple IMO.
Still waiting for some of our more liberal friends to address the issue of why it is ok to call for a government employee to resign their position for a sincerely held religious belief to not issue marriage licenses to gay couples, but it is ok for government employees to call for the rescinding of a signed contract because of their sincerely held anti religious beliefs.
What is it, the sincerely held anti religious beliefs trumps sincerely held religious beliefs?
Or is it really that there is two standards in play?
WE have had numerous people on the board voicifierably expound on this.
I would like to hear just one of them try to justify the in-opposite positions.
How is it that one persons beliefs trump anothers?
Some animals are more equal than others I guess.
Please please explain this one to me.
The have already done a study showing Chick-fil-a will bring in more money than any other restaurant that applied for the position in spite of the fact they are only open 6 days.
This is why I posted the article. It is obvious discrimination. It doesn't matter how many days a Taco Bell is open if they bring in say 10,000 a week if Chick-fil-a is open 6 days a week and brings in say 15,000 a week does it? You have already maximized profits in spite of being closed one day a week. So it looks like we are actually on the same page here. It has been shown bytheir own study that Chick-fila is the best choice and now they are down to discrimination to keep them out. They have no other excuses because the money is there. This is EXACTLY what makes this a blatant case of discrimination.
96, no they are not maximizing profits and providing a 7 day a week service. If they were open 7 days, than they would be maximizing profit.
To me, it has nothing to do with their stance on LBGT community.
Yeah 96, we see this.
discrimination is good if it's for a good cause,
discrimination is not good if it is for a bad cause.
The ends justify the means, no matter who it hurts in the process.
The whole 6 day.7 day argument is a deflection from the real issue here. They are doing exactly what they claim they hate so much, and refuse to recognize it. Blatant outright discrimination.
But in this case, it suits the liberal purpose, so it all good.
You guys are kind of missing the point without some important information.
We don't know what the terms of service are to run a business in the airport. If the TOS says you must be open between X time and Y time then it applies to all businesses. Same with days of the week. If the TOS says that they must be open 7 days, then it applies to all business.
It is as simple as that. Discrimination only counts if there this is arbitrary and the TOS does not specify.
we are not missing the point, they are already approved and in the process of getting ready to open on a signed and sealed deal.
One has to assume, arguendo, that DIA's TOS has already been met, since they have already given approval.
the issue is that a subcommittee of the full council has decided that it really doesn;t want Chik-Fil-A in the airport in solidarity with the LGBQ agenda.
So they are trying to rescind an already in place deal after the fact, based upon their own personal beliefs.
Discrimination in a nutshell.
the arguments we are dealing with here are trying to deflect away from that fact.
Wrong.
They may have been unaware that they are not open on Sunday.
In my village, there was supposed to be a Stop and Shop put in. Contracts were signed and it was thought to be a done deal. But the Stop and Shop neglected to tell them that they were not going to provide their own parking. The village stop the building of the shp. There was a law suit brought onto the village, but at the end of the day, the village won, since it is part of their TOS for businesses of X size.
Kav,
Right straight out of the posted article, it has everything to do with the committee members stances in support of the gay agenda.
Sorry sweets you are the one wrong this time...
Again right out of the posted article.
Chik-Fil-A has been a 6 day a week establishment since they started and they had a franchise in DIA before. It is real hard (next to impossible) for anyone to argue that DIA didn't know about it.
NWM. I read the article and am aware of what the commission brought up.
To me, my opinion on this has nothing to do with Chik fil A stance on LBGT. My comments are made on maximizing profits and having 7 day customer service.
So what you saying Kav is that your limiting your comments towards what you consider to be good sense business practices. and taking the discussion away from DIA and the LGBQ issue some members have raised.
On a purely business sense yes I would agree with you. 7 days a week is better than 6 days a week given a good profitable business model. You make more money that way.
But in the context of the article and the issues raised, it's irrelevant.
How's that? I have been constantly saying discriminating against any group is unacceptable.
I think you just didn't like it when I flipped the coin and asked if you would be OK with it if they were discriminating against other groups in exactly the same manner. (which you chose not to answer)
The "political reason" you state is because they don't like their religious beliefs, which is religious discrimination. Just because you OK with with the discrimination of one group over another does not magically change the fact that it is still discrimination.
The 40/60 relationship then goes to what Kavika is say. They have to honor their previous contract, but they don't have to with the new one. There are other concessions that could make more revenue for the airport being open 7 days a week.
It may be because of the LBGT community, but they do have a legal ground to do so. Also if the LBGT community has such an impact, than they would also try to close down the other branch, which apparently, they are not.
WTF are you talking about? Chick Filet isn't discriminating against anyone who wants to eat at Chick Filet. Gays,Mexican bandits, muggers, buggerers, bushwhackers, hornswogglers, horse thieves, bull dykes, train robbers, bank robbers, ass-kickers, shit-kickers and Methodists are all allowed to eat there.
All as they ask for is the ability to exercise free speech.I know how scary free speech is to most liberals so I kinda understand how you can confuse free speech with preventing blacks from eating.
The LGBT hate campaign against Chick Filet is un-american and the epitome of intolerance in action.
Want to call me an asshole? Have at it. I don't care.
What this committee is holding up is the lease the final act before opening the doors. Usually a formality. the partnership already has a defensible contract in place that has to be complied with. they have already put all the investment into the site, the restaurant is already built and they are in the process of staffing it.
This is a monkey wrench being thrown into the works by a subset (4) of the full 13 member commission. the Chik-Fil-A will open of that there is no question if the legal advise correctly interprets the law. otherwise they will be spending a lot of money on legal fees and still lose.
Also in the article above...
This tactic has been tried before and failed. they have been under contract for seven years now. A little late to back out without repercussions.
I agree 100% and this is why I posted the article. There have already been several liberals cheering this but when you ask if it would be OK if they were being discriminated against in exactley the same way because the owners are Homosexual/Black/Mexican/Lesbian ect, ect ect?...CRICKETS!
The rest of the world has, 'cause they (supposedly) make better chicken and people have forgotten how to do that.
KFC is far superior, IMHO.
I thought religion had nothing to do with it, that is what you said to me just up the thread a bit.
Libertarian ideal : You have the right to do what you, as an individual, want to do, so long as by exercising your rights you do not hinder others in the exercising of theirs.
The two issues have nothing to do, one with the other, except for the fact that religion is involved in both of them.
They don't.
Question: Is it the right of two United States Citizens to marry?
Answer: Yes .
By the clerk claiming that the mere issuance of the marriage licenseviolates her deeply held religious beliefs and therefore she cannot issue the license, and by the law the issuance of said licences being a part of her job description, there is a conflict of interest set up. By her not issuing the licenses as is her civic duty per the law, she is, in effect, removing the rights of the couples to be civilly married. There is no place for religion in civic duties. Period. If she refuses to do her duties as outlined and perpetuate the conflict of interest, then she should find another job.
As for the DIA incident, it really seems like the proverbial tempest in a tea-pot, timed to give the most publicity, maybe to try and gainconcessions(pun intended) from Chik-Fil-A. I doubt that 3 or 4 members of a 13 member board could stop the deal. Shrug.
You ask about, " ...government employees to call for the rescinding of a signed contract because of their sincerely held anti religious beliefs."
Speaking of strawmen, it is not because of their anti-religious beliefs, it is ostensibly because of their beliefs that hiring and firing might be affected by the religious beliefs of the Chik-Fil-A corporation, even though the two concessionaires are the ones under license to run the operation. The government employees views on religion and their views on the day to day operations of the DIA concessions are two totally separate things.
Libertarian ideal: You have the right to do what you, as an individual, want to do, so long as by exercising your rights you do not hinder others in the exercising of theirs.
Religion has everything to do with what I was talking about: Being open seven days a week. Religion, christianity in specific, holds that the seventh day is the day of rest, and according to most observers of the faith, this day is Sunday. Most municipalities and states of the United States used to have "blue laws" that encoded proscribed activities on Sunday as a reflection of the predominance of the faithful in the electorarate. To say that the main corporation is not following these same proscriptions is laughable. It was made plain a while ago that this was exactly what they were doing.
Ayn Rand was not a libertarian, she was an extreme idealist who wrote romance novels and spoke on her Objectivist Ethics. I used to have a great deal of respect for the woman, until, by practice, I found her ideals to be impractical and harsh, even inhumane. Who mentioned her, anyways? I was talking about Chik-fil-a.
The Religious preferences in how Chik-Fil-A sets up their franchises, is not the issue, it isn't the issue for the franchisee's nor the full council.
You created a strawman argument above seperate from the DIA issue to make an argument against Chik-Fil-A.
The issue ion DIA is the final lease. the DIA commission subcommittee has refused to issue it by placing a two week delay on it in an attempt to kill the opening of the franchise. there are ways around that mentioned in the article already so that isn't an issue here.
The plain statements of the sub-committee members is that their decision to refuse to issue the lease is directly because of Chik-Fil-A's position of LGBQ issues. The problem here is they are not contracting with Chik-Fil-A. they are contracting with a local partnership. their refusal is based upon either their political beliefs or their anti religious bias, or a combination of both. They aren't hurting Chik-Fil-A at all.
So my statement is directed thus.
If, as you are arguing, that these government employees can use their personal political or ideological ideal to not do what they are already contracted to do.
Why are anyone of such political/religious persuasion making the argument that doing the same to a gay marriage couple is not the same thing.
IT IS THE SAME THING! Using your religious/political ideals as justification for not doing your job.
It is not ok for the county clerks to do this, but it is ok for the DIA commission sub-committee to do this.
It is an identical issue.
Now, I know that what the sub-committee is doing is only temporary I don't think DIA wants to spend the millions it is going to take to get out of a seven year old contract right at the point of concluding said contract. So eventually they will get their lease. SO what they are doing is really in essence moot.
Now the county clerks, I believe that eventually the gay couple will eventually get their marriage license. (and they have a right to do so, as my libertarian beliefs tell me they do) But my Libertarian beliefs also say that the clerk has the right to personally refuse to issue them herself according to her true belief. The issue in that case is in her post as county clerk can she stop the whole office from issuing said licenses. I don't believe she can.
The point I'm making is this.
Strictly about ideological justification. On the one hand some here are arguing that government employees can justifiably use their personal beliefs to refuse to do their job.
But in the other case those same people are claiming that another government employee of the opposite political/religious personal beliefs cannot use their beliefs to refuse to do their job.
That is what I'm pointing out in a nutshell.
The inconsistency of those on the board who are making those arguments.
Now I'm calling it inconsistency, some will call it hypocrisy.
Whichever it is, it IS DISCRIMINATORY POLITICAL BIAS. And it is completely demonstrated right here on the board in full view in the open light of day. So well demonstrated it can't be denied.
Despite the seriously well argued efforts to deflect away from that point.
They are saying these things and it is being argued that is has nothing to do with their own political beliefs.
Well take this up with the article writer, that isn't my point. my point deals with this...
Your trying to argue that they are not using their personal political beliefs to make this decision, where the members themselves are saying that they are.
Culminating in this..
Makes this...
A bold faced lie.
Now I know that pride will not allow anyone on this board to admit such, But if the county clerks cannot do what they are doing, then this commission cannot either.
My luggage ended up in Alaska when I was flying from North Carolina back to Phoenix one time, however I told the airline (Delta, if I remember right) that I'd be on another business flight to Pittsburgh the next day and when I got there it was waiting for me at a service counter.
Chik-fil-A is not a place of worship.
I am sorry, but as much as you wish it were so, just saying that the two are the same does not make it so. The only thing that those quotes proved is that you have blind spots.
NWM said:
The way they set up their franchise is not my concern, as long as it holds to the laws governing such and places no burden on the benefits and the hiring or firing of employees, which was the ostensible concern of the council members. This concern, whether founded in reality or not, was stated because of a public stance* taken on the issue of same sex marriage by the CEO of the company. As such, religion has nothing directly to do with the matter. (For the record, I think that the CEO's staements were blown far out of proportion, as is this current issue.)
As I said, it was ostensibly these reasonsthat were given.
You have no evidence that the members of the council are in fact Anti-religious, do you? You just made that up out of your preconceived notions that because they are against one person's publicly stated opinions about one issue and the fact that Chick-Fil-A is not open on Sunday, that they have to be anti-religious. Poppycock.
For some reason it seems that you want to carry water for Chick-Fil-A and the company's CEO, so you conflate issues that are clearly and demonstrably different to build an easily disprovable argument.
So, what it really boils down to is this:
And in the other case we have:
According to you and your very own argument, these two cases are equal, when they are clearly and most unambiguously not the same. The first has no bearing on the aspects of religion or the free practice thereof, except in the twisted logic that a corporation can have some religious bent. The second is a violation of the CotUS as recently interpreted by the Roberts Court.
No, not at all. Read the sentence, man. If you cannot see that they are two separate things, then I would suggest meditation to control your blood pressure.
---------------------------------
*(This stance resonated with a lot of people in their market area because a very large part of the population of those areas, which include the bible belt, have their heads up their collective asses and would gladly start a theocracy, 'cause, you know, the world is only six thousand years old and the bible is infallible as printed, but only if it is the King James II version. The other ones only claim to be the word of God.)
If Chik-fil-A were a church, it would explain why I'm an atheist...
Now Church's chicken on the other hand! Mmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmm!
Sorry Brolly, I was VERY CLEAR in my point, I'm not conflating anything, I"m not supporting either side in this and I agree that both this and the Chik-Fil-A position on gays were blown WAY out of proportion.
It is you making a huge assumption that I am taking a side. therefore conflating their arguments on top of mine.
I clearly stated my position on this right here. and it was aimed at one thing.
You are a fairly smart intelligent gent one of the smarter ones on this board. I'"m surprised you missed my clear statement of what my position was all about. More accurately, STUNNED that you obviously missed it.
Here, allow me to restate....
AS you can clearly see it is aimed directly as the board members who wish to conflate any reasonableness to the whole issue with their ideological bias. And in doing so dismiss or bypass the clearly stated point.
You can do believe whatever, but DONT ever put fucking trash words in my mouth, if anything,
I WAS VERY CLEAR IN MY INDICTMENT OF THE IDEOLOGICAL POSITIONS TAKEN BY SOME ON THIS BOARD. It was clearly stated and effectively argued and posited in a way that made it plain for all to see. So plain it is like reading the large print alphabet over the blackboard in elementary school
In a manner that any denial is a proven lie.
You can continue your argument, but it is plainly an ideological one that has no basis in reality. I proved my case, you don't like it too fucking bad. Repeating your argument only makes you look bad trying to defend an indefensible ideological position.
You can't have it both ways. The arguments on this board over the last two weeks over those two issues prove that some here want it exactly that way. They want their ideological cake and be able to eat it also.
hypocrisy knows no bounds in some people around here.
And yes I was trying to be conciliatory by calling it inconsistancy, but now I will call it like it is, HYPOCRISY in the extreme.
You have not proven anything. Period. You get really touchy about someone pointing out a clear and evident hole in your logic and the ways in which you view things.
The board members may have been, and probably were, elected because of their political bias. I don't know, and quite frankly couldn't care less. That is how people win elections in the US. You don't like it? Elect someone else.
LOLOOLOLOLOLOLOL
One case: Public employee refusing to do her job because it conflicts with her religion. FAIL. Fire her. She is breaking the law which she is sworn to uphold.
Second case: People doing their public jobs as they see fit (whether that is reasonable or not is not the issue) using the stances, and yes, biases that got them elected. That is what politicians of any stripe do, because one person's bias is another's righteous cause. Getting hopping mad about it won't change one thing.
Obviously, you do not like it, but that is just hard cheese.
Like I said, take up meditation, it may keep you from having a stroke.
Good Day.
Holy cow! That was a mess, Randy!
Typical deflection, I wasn't posting about them, I was posting about the positions of the people on this board.
As you so aptly have demonstrated.
An elected clerk, as you put it...
And the DIA commission doing the exact same thing.
You think the elected county clerk should be removed from her position, given her obvious biases, but the elected commissioners are all fine and dandy righteous in their biases about their commitment to LGBQ issues.
The only difference is, political ideology. YOURS.
Enjoy your hypocrisy. (thank you for stating it plainly in demonstration)
Good day.
NO.
I think that the clerk should be removed from office beccause she is not doing her job. Did you get that: Her Job. What is her job? Part of it is to issue marriage licences, not to get her nighty in a knot and decide that she just won't issue marriage licences at all. So she is in violation of the law. Get a grip.
One is about someone not following the law and the constitution, the other is about someone following the law. Can't make it much plainer than that. One is breaking the law, the others are not, in fact, as weird as it may seem, they are actually doing their job as intended, however convoluted their logic. That is it, period.
Any other thing that you lay on the issue is an example of bias: Your bias.
Don't like LGBTs? Don't be one. Just leave them alone. Your blind spot is a mile wide on this one.
Don't like what your elected officials are doing,? Be one! Elect one that you think will do a better job.
Just don't come on here and have a conversation with me, telling me that I am biased as if you have no biases of your own. What a ridiculous position. You do have biases and they are evident in every one of your posts.
Everyone has biases. We are all people. Don't you dare to go all holier than thou and act as if you are the final arbiter of what is bias and what is not, because every time you have started screaming about bias, you have put your own on display, bigtime.
Talk about hypocrisy.
Yes, because she is in violation of the law.
That only enters into the matter tangentially as the reason she is violating the law.
Yup. They are doing their jobs.
Again, tangential, unless it isyoutalking about it, then those two issues come up because you are upset about the SCotUS's decision finding that marriage is a right of two people of whatever sex, presumably because you hold similar convictions to the county clerk. This is your bias. Admit it. It won't kill you. It might even free up and mollify a little bit of anger. But don't say that you are not biased, because it is self evident that you are.
You still claim that I'm making it about them, and I am NOT.
I am making it abut you and all those who think like you.
You claim that those commissioners are doing their job and using their biases is ok, well she is doing her job and her biases are not ok.
You can try to defend that all you want. But the hypocrisy shows thru.
Trying to lay your bias off me as my bias, chuckle, huge smoke screen. trying to change the topic into what you want it to be, huge deflection.
BIAS? really BIAS? This is YOUR BIGGEST ASSUMPTION!
Many many times on this board I have directly stated what two people chose between them is none of my business, and that any two people have the right to marry.
AND I have stated it repeatedly, in no uncertain terms.
YOU are assuming that I believe in the manner you think I should to complete your smokes screen of bullshite trying to deflect AWAY from the obvious political bias you have and the political discrimination you SUPPORT!
The fact that you must tell a lie about my beliefs to claim a bias is proof positive of the bullshite your concocting to create your false dichotomy to salve your own butthurt from being exposed like you have been.
It's juvenile, it's laughable, and it's exposed for the whole world to see.
Two gays want to marry, it's no skin off my ass, it is between them and their god. NONE OF MY BUSINESS. That's as Libertarian as it gets as any true Libertarian will tell you.
so imparting your ideals of what a libertarian believes in, on me to claim I'm biased is as illogical as can be.
YOU SIR ARE EXPOSED AS THE FRAUD YOU ARE! Your logic is improvised tripe and is actually illogical.
Thank you for playing.
I could say the same about you. You really don't like it when you are shown as completely illogical, do you? Tsk. Tsk.
Your central tenant to the argument was this:
I have torn this argument down because it undermines your whole "hypocrisy" meme.
Without further ado:
Buzzzeerrr. Wrong.
She is not doing her job, and that is the problem. I could give a rats ass what the hell she does on her own dime, but she is getting paid to give people marriage licenses and she is not doing that. It is not her function to decide who they go to.
The board is doing its job by looking out for the interests of the public, no matter how poor a job it may be doing. Misguided? Probably, but that is politics. Incompetent? Maybe. Biased? Definitely. Show me one person who harbors no bias and I will show you a fiction. The problem is, you refuse to accept that you are biased. Here is an example:
Really? Who are those that think like me? Liberals?
Good news Chick-Fil-A won. DIA gives them the thumbs up.
I knew damn well they would.
Let's take a closer comparison. A baker does not want to bake a cake for a gay marriage and the airport sites the owner of the restaurants religious views as the only reason to deny them. (since the study was already done on a 6 day week this is reality anyhow)
Now is it still OK for the airport? Is it OK for the baker?