╌>

High court upholds Mich affirmative action ban

  

Category:  News & Politics

Via:  z  •  12 years ago  •  14 comments

High court upholds Mich affirmative action ban

kzBhj5h.jpg WASHINGTON (AP) The Supreme Court on Tuesday upheld Michigan's ban on using race as a factor in college admissions despite one justice's impassioned dissent that accused the court of wanting to wish away racial inequality.

The justices said in a 6-2 ruling that Michigan voters had the right to change their state constitution in 2006 to prohibit public colleges and universities from taking account of race in admissions decisions. The justices said that a lower federal court was wrong to set aside the change as discriminatory.

The decision bolstered similar voter-approved initiatives banning affirmative action in education in California and Washington state. A few other states have adopted laws or issued executive orders to bar race-conscious admissions policies.

Justice Anthony Kennedy said voters chose to eliminate racial preferences, presumably because such a system could give rise to race-based resentment. Kennedy said nothing in the Constitution or the court's prior cases gives judges the authority to undermine the election results . - http://www.sfgate.com/news/politics/article/High-court-upholds-Mich-affirmative-action-ban-5420677.php

~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~

Two issues here; a) States Rights and b) Affirmative Action.

Discuss.


Tags

jrDiscussion - desc
[]
 
Miss_Construed
Freshman Silent
link   Miss_Construed    12 years ago

I think race based college admission measuring sticks should be replaced with familyincome based college admission measuring sticks. That is becoming the true measure of race in America today.

As for states rights... that's a historically tough subject when it comes to race especially when it comes to race matters ineducation. Because of precedent, I think it is relatively easy for the SC to over rule state decisions in this area. I don't think it's necessarily out of line historically or in the present. There is a reason most of these rules and laws were enacted at the federal level.

 
 
 
Robert in Ohio
Professor Guide
link   Robert in Ohio    12 years ago

Kennedy said nothing in the Constitution or the court's prior cases gives judges the authority to undermine the election results.

Clear and concise!

 
 
 
Sean Treacy
Professor Principal
link   Sean Treacy    12 years ago

fairness 1

racism 0

 
 
 
Petey Coober
Freshman Silent
link   Petey Coober    12 years ago

African Americans would still get a disproportionate percentage of the attention, because African Americans are disproportionately represented in the lower class.

Do you have any numbers for us John Looser ?

 
 
 
Petey Coober
Freshman Silent
link   Petey Coober    12 years ago

That-a-way to dodge supplying real info and doing real work . Thanks for proving how lazy & useless you can be ... once again . 112.gif

 
 
 
Petey Coober
Freshman Silent
link   Petey Coober    12 years ago

Stop wanting everyone else to do your work for you.

You advance a theory but refuse to offer supporting evidence . When asked to do so you say :

number of pointless Petey questions per 24 hour period

So instead of support you call my question pointless . Your whole NT existence is pointless ...

I put up more corroborating information in a day than you do in a month.

You don't know what corroboration is . Your deep & profoundly complete ignorance of a huge variety of subjects insures that .

is it your position that African-Americans are not disproportionately represented in the lower classes?

No . If you want more details get off your lazy ass and get us some numbers .

 
 
 
Aeonpax
Freshman Silent
link   seeder  Aeonpax    12 years ago

Affirmative Action only applies to organizations that take in federal dollars, whether it's through grants, loans or contract. This also applied to anyone doing business with the government. I do not work for an Affirmative Action employer because we take no federal money.

As I see it, "Affirmative Action" while it had good intentions, was flawed from its inception. In many cases, it forced organizations to "lower the bar" for qualifications when determining eligibility to work or go to school at certain colleges.

 
 
 
Aeonpax
Freshman Silent
link   seeder  Aeonpax    12 years ago

1) Who said we are all equal under the eyes of the government? Nothing in the constitution says that and "equal justice under law" is an off-shoot of the 14th Amendment jurisprudence. "All men are created equal" is in the Declaration of Independence, not the Constitution.

2) Money is the highest form of discrimination and lack of the same should not be a barrier against those who wish a higher education.

 
 
 
Aeonpax
Freshman Silent
link   seeder  Aeonpax    12 years ago

Petey, if it were within my power, I'd shut you out of any and all threads I post. You add NOTHING to discussions and it would be worthwhile for anyone wishing an intellectual, albeit logically argumentative discussion, to ignore you completely.

 
 
 
Robert in Ohio
Professor Guide
link   Robert in Ohio    12 years ago

Or perhaps a system based solely on merit, where people are judged by their academic achievement and potential rather than on an arbitrary demographic.

That sounds fair for all

 
 
 
Miss_Construed
Freshman Silent
link   Miss_Construed    12 years ago

I would be okay with merit if judgment of merit could somehow level opportunity.

For example... would a person who had a 4.0, played violin, sports, got a 1800 SAT score have more merit if they did all these things because they went to a suburban school with all the programs and their parents gave them the opportunity to do so, or if they went to an inner city school and had to seek out those programs with a single mom at home and a part time job to help put food on the table?

I think the weight of social class, whether race or financial, would weigh these two students differently in judgment... but you could never know these details without this information.

In looking though, I did find that some schools have transitioned to a class based system to avoid the race based one. However, they still seek out race information to keep their campuses "diverse". I really think diversity weighting on skin color is rather dated. If anything diversity should go to class and religion anymore to teach tolerance between them. But that's just my opinion.

 
 
 
Robert in Ohio
Professor Guide
link   Robert in Ohio    12 years ago

Miss_D

That no system would be perfect I accept

But any system based on a demographic rather than merit is inherently discriminatory, in that a deserving student could be denied an opportunity because he or she was or was not rich/poor, black/white, rural/urban/suburban, natural citizen/naturalized citizen/foreign visitor, etc etc

Perhaps potential should also play a role in that a student who achieved a level of merit by overcoming obstacles or without adequate support would certainly show great potential

Would you agree to that?

 
 
 
Miss_Construed
Freshman Silent
link   Miss_Construed    12 years ago

I have seen the lowering of the bar as well, however, on the flip side of that some students lack in the same general opportunity from start of education.

For example, I went to a public high school in the middle of nowhere. The highest math class offered at my public high school was pre-calculus and it was an independent study class that I took alone my junior year. I also took Chemistry 2 and Physics (just general physics) the same way.

I had awesome math and science teachers who really pushed me... but the fact of the matter was that no one in my district that year was interested in learning any more math or science than they had to in order to graduate high school.

I was accepted into a very competitive engineering school because of where I went to high school. I had decent scores, yes, but they were scores in classes most people finished their freshman years in high school and moved on.

I was definitely on a list of students accepted because of my background and motivation; not because of my scores or qualifications.

The people I met at that school were in AP programs and had completed college calculus level up to vector calculus as well as chemistry through organic chemistry. They were miles ahead of me because of the school districts they came from where they were offered that kind of opportunity.

I wont argue that it's notflawed... but I will be thankful for what the concept gave me.

 
 
 
Petey Coober
Freshman Silent
link   Petey Coober    12 years ago

So ... this means you too won't be fetching any numbers to prove a point ? Why am I not surprised ... completely useless and now no longer even charming .

 
 

Who is online

JBB


84 visitors