The near future - We’re going to see much worse income inequality. And unless we take some humanitarian actions, the truth is, they’re going to starve and live in poverty and then die.
The PBS Newshour transcript of the segment:
Do labor-saving robots spell doom for American workers? , PBS Newshour, July 30, 2015
TRANSCRIPT
GWEN IFILL: We have shown you before the rising role that automation and robots play in some parts of the work force.
Tonight, we have a more sobering and perhaps somewhat eerier picture of how those trends are gathering force more quickly than anticipated.
Economics correspondent Paul Solman looks at the promise and perils of the rise of the robot, part of our weekly series Making Sense, which airs every Thursday on the NewsHour.
PAUL SOLMAN: The 11th hole at Stanford University. Chad Grays an OK golfer, but his caddy is really hard to beat.
CHAD GRAY, CaddyTrek: Its going to go wherever you want it go. Follows you like a puppy dog.
PAUL SOLMAN: Meet the robot CaddyTrek.
CHAD GRAY: It has two ultrasound bars that send a signal back to the remote thats on my back pocket here.
JERRY KAPLAN, Author, Humans Need Not Apply: Its an incredibly simple piece of technology.
PAUL SOLMAN: But the implications for Americas caddies, and millions of other workers, are ominous, says computer scientist and serial entrepreneur Jerry Kaplan. Kaplan has his own labor-saving schlepper, an R2-D2 designed to make local deliveries.
This is the Stanford Jackrabbot.
PAUL SOLMAN: Jackrabbot?
JERRY KAPLAN: Yes.
PAUL SOLMAN: As in robot?
JERRY KAPLAN: Thats right. Its like a jackrabbit, but its a robot. Its designed to operate in socially appropriate ways in pedestrian spaces.
PAUL SOLMAN: Jack looks harmless enough. But he, like CaddyTrek, is the shape of things to come.
JERRY KAPLAN: Were about to see a significant increase in the acceleration in the rate of automation.
PAUL SOLMAN: And the age-old fear of displaced workers, says Kaplan, is finally, irrevocably upon us.
JERRY KAPLAN: What happens to people who simply cant acquire or dont have the skills that are going to be needed in the new economy?
PAUL SOLMAN: Well, what is going to happen to them?
JERRY KAPLAN: Were going to see much worse income inequality. And unless we take some humanitarian actions, the truth is, theyre going to starve and live in poverty and then die.
PAUL SOLMAN: Kaplan offers that grim prognosis in a new book, Humans Need Not Apply. He knows, of course, that automation has been replacing labor for 200 years or more, for decades, eliminating relatively high-paying factory jobs in America, and that new jobs have more than kept pace, but not anymore, he says.
Youre the guy from the same-day delivery piece.
Now, by pure chance, a case in point happened to notice Jackrabbot being put through his paces. Wed met Mike Cannon a few months earlier when shooting him delivering packages for Google Express.
MIKE CANNON, Google Express: So, Im delivering DNA samples to all of the various labs on campus.
PAUL SOLMAN: And you were just watching us shoot.
MIKE CANNON: And it caught my attention. I thought, thats my replacement.
(LAUGHTER)
COMPUTER VOICE: Hi Im OSHbot.
PAUL SOLMAN: At a hardware store in Silicon Valley, OSHbot.
Doorknobs.
COMPUTER VOICE: Sure. Follow me.
PAUL SOLMAN: Are you serious?
MAN: Yes.
PAUL SOLMAN: A joint venture between the Lowes chain of stores and a startup called Fellow Robots. Without ever needing a coffee or bathroom break, its voice recognition software, fluent in multiple languages, and laser sensor safety technology can do a better job than many of Americas five million or so retail workers.
JERRY KAPLAN: Maybe 50 percent of the retail clerks could be replaced by this kind of technology. And, of course, this is just the beginning.
PAUL SOLMAN: Now OSHbots inventor, Marco Mascorro, disputes that his baby would put anyone out of work.
So you dont see OSHbot replacing people?
MARCO MASCORRO, OSHbot Inventor: No, I dont think so. I think this is really a tool that helps people find things in a store with very specific information.
PAUL SOLMAN: And if you think, well, OSHbot still seems a bit clunky as a replacement for humans
MAN: After you, Kema.
COMPUTER VOICE: Thank you.
PAUL SOLMAN: in downtown Palo Alto, Suitable Technologys Beam telepresence robot sells itself, with no humans on site at all.
WOMAN: Hi, guys. Hows it going?
MAN: Good, how are you?
MAN: Hey, how are you?
WOMAN: Beam is a smart presence system, so it allows us to beam in anywhere in the world where we have a Wi-Fi connection and maneuver this device on our keyboards here.
PAUL SOLMAN: Turn around, would you? Do a 360 for me.
JERRY KAPLAN: The problem in retail is staffing. You have people standing around in the stores often just waiting for people to come in.
PAUL SOLMAN: Right.
JERRY KAPLAN: And then you have got customers at other times that are waiting and cant get help.
PAUL SOLMAN: And already, says Taylor Sewitt, beaming in from Upstate New York:
MAN: We have had a couple of banks actually start to use them, where, if all of a sudden a secondary location gets swamped, you could have a couple of tellers from the first location actually beam into that second location, and now you have instantly doubled the staff, without actually doubling the staff and hiring twice as many people.
PAUL SOLMAN: Kema Johnson was in Utah.
WOMAN: And sit here in the desert, where I want to live, but I can still work in California.
PAUL SOLMAN: Is there any sensitivity on your part about replacing people?
MAN: Well, I dont think its as much as replacing people. We definitely want to stay away from automation, because somebody needs to be on Beam at all times.
PAUL SOLMAN: What do you mean its not automation? Youre the personification of automation.
MAN: Ultimately, for us, wed like to give more jobs to people that they wouldnt normally be able to have or do, like myself and Kema.
PAUL SOLMAN: But if youre in Utah and you are servicing lots of customers in maybe multiple stores, right?
JERRY KAPLAN: Correct.
PAUL SOLMAN: You are replacing the jobs of people who would be in the stores themselves. Isnt that just obvious?
WOMAN: Well, a person still needs to operate the device. Were not robotic, so to speak.
PAUL SOLMAN: Are they being defensive about not replacing jobs?
JERRY KAPLAN: Because youre talking to two people that have jobs. The one youre not interviewing is the person who didnt get a job working in this store here locally.
PAUL SOLMAN: I was also not interviewing the heads of companies that provide robots at local hotels, robots that can thin out lettuce crops.
JERRY KAPLAN: The reaction people have here seems to be similar to, if you called up a tobacco company and said, I would like to do a story on smoking and health.
PAUL SOLMAN: So when you called up companies for this shoot to appear on the PBS NewsHour, they said, not if its about displacing labor?
JERRY KAPLAN: I found the doors would immediately slam shut: Oh, no, we make people more productive. Well, making people more productive puts other people out of work.
PAUL SOLMAN: Now, in fairness, not everyone in the Valley was afraid to admit that robots are labor-saving devices.
Are you OK with the fact that this is going to replace thousands, maybe tens of thousands of caddies?
CHAD GRAY: Absolutely. And this technology can be applied to other types of jobs as well, porters, bellhops, stockroom clerks, anywhere where heavy lifting is involved.
PAUL SOLMAN: Of course, new jobs are being created in Silicon Valley. Thats why entrepreneur Vivek Wadhwa confidently told us this in 2012.
VIVEK WADHWA, Wadhwa.com: The convergence of these technologies will create jobs in areas we cant even think of.
PAUL SOLMAN: But these days, Wadhwa is singing a different, dolorous tune.
VIVEK WADHWA: Technologys moving faster than anyone believes. And it is going to disrupt industries and create unemployment on a scale that we havent imagined before.
PAUL SOLMAN: Why did you used to think it wasnt going to be a problem?
VIVEK WADHWA: Because I believed what people of Silicon Valley do, that technology will make everything all right. I have had debates with a whos-who of Silicon Valley, and I sit back and think, these people live in their own world, that they dont know poverty, they dont know despair. They dont know what the impact of unemployment is.
JERRY KAPLAN: People in the Silicon Valley believe that what were doing is Gods work, and we are making the world a better place.
PAUL SOLMAN: Around the corner from Stanfords Robotics Lab, the universitys world class art museum provided a last symbolic stop.
JERRY KAPLAN: Here we are in paradise, but were standing in front of Rodins The Gates of Hell.
PAUL SOLMAN: So, in your dystopia, there are millions of Americans who literally are out of luck and are facing a grim future, because they simply dont have the skills to sell in the new economy.
JERRY KAPLAN: I think thats true. Heres the good news. The U.S. economy has doubled, reliably, about every 40 years for several hundred years now. So, when you look out 40 years from now, were going to have twice as much wealth as we have today. The question is, whos going to get that wealth? Is it going to be concentrated in the hands of an elite, or is it going to be distributed more widely?
PAUL SOLMAN: Good question.
This is economics correspondent Paul Solman, reporting, in as human a way as is still possible, for the PBS NewsHour from Silicon Valley.
http://www.limitstogrowth.org/articles/2015/07/31/labor-saving-robots-mean-job-elimination-for-humans/
Tags
Who is online
55 visitors

PAUL SOLMAN: Of course, new jobs are being created in Silicon Valley. Thats why entrepreneur Vivek Wadhwa confidently told us this in 2012.
VIVEK WADHWA, Wadhwa.com: The convergence of these technologies will create jobs in areas we cant even think of.
PAUL SOLMAN: But these days, Wadhwa is singing a different, dolorous tune.
VIVEK WADHWA: Technologys moving faster than anyone believes. And it is going to disrupt industries and create unemployment on a scale that we havent imagined before.
PAUL SOLMAN: Why did you used to think it wasnt going to be a problem?
VIVEK WADHWA: Because I believed what people of Silicon Valley do, that technology will make everything all right. I have had debates with a whos-who of Silicon Valley, and I sit back and think, these people live in their own world, that they dont know poverty, they dont know despair. They dont know what the impact of unemployment is.
JERRY KAPLAN: People in the Silicon Valley believe that what were doing is Gods work, and we are making the world a better place.
JERRY KAPLAN: I think thats true. Heres the good news. The U.S. economy has doubled, reliably, about every 40 years for several hundred years now. So, when you look out 40 years from now, were going to have twice as much wealth as we have today. The question is, whos going to get that wealth? Is it going to be concentrated in the hands of an elite, or is it going to be distributed more widely?
I strongly suspect that in the not too distant future we will become a nation of of basically two classes. The landed rich and the servants and serfs who wait on them and live on their land. The rich will become the new nobility and anyone who is not rich and voted Republican in the meantime, will be just as fucked as those of us who didn't. If you are not rich and you vote Republican, then you are an idiot. Thankfully I'm betting I die before I have to see my nation come to that.
This guy completely changed his mind in just three years.
Are you going to pee pee on every thread tonight Gronk ? If so, I have to go get my industrial strength rodent repellent.
Automation will eliminate millions of jobs held by low skilled workers. That's a snowball that can't be stopped. How all these people will make a living is the elephant in the room.
you have passed the boredom threshold for me
go annoy someone else
Do you have a link for that ?
The gap closed by the rich getting temporarily less rich. However it is just a Market Correction an the Market will slowly work it's way back up to historic levels and then people will convince themselves, like they always do, that it's going to just keep going up and in another 4 years we'll have another correction and they'll panic...again.
Beside the rich getting slightly and temporarily less rich does close the gap, but only because they (the rich) went down a bit and it was not a step toward income equality because it didn't do anything to help the poor and needy rise higher. It's all relative.
Nonsense. Such double talk should be beneath even you.
You are out of touch with reality.
And yet you're the one preparing to surrender to our new robot overlords.
Maybe global warming will destroy us all before the robots? Or an ice age? Or the hole in the ozone layer? Those are good odds...
That's exactly my point. Stop railing about inequality; you don't care about that. You want poor people to make more money. That's a bit more admirable a position than blatant envy and a desire to pull others down.
It's no different from the holy roller wackos that claim Armageddon is coming.
I don't know about everyone else here, but I prefer to talk to a person.
Telling where something is, or even showing me, is one thing, but I somehow always to have more questions that I don't think a robot is going to be able to answer. In the doorknob example above, I would want to know if I can put one of my antique doorknobs on the mechanism, or if I have to stay with the shiny brass one. What if I only need the mechanism, not the knob? Does it have clear instructions? Are there any tricks to installing it? People are invaluable!
I'm pretty tired of the endless menus that one must listen to, any time you call the bank, the doctor's office, the pharmacy, the grocery, the cell phone company...
It is the difference between science and religion.
It doesn't serve a "free market" purpose to recognize this reality, because when this happens the "welfare" ranks are going to skyrocket.
You are badly confused. Nothing new about that.
I have said numerous times on this forum that the working people need to make more money. They should make it at the expense of corporate profit, rather than from increased revenue to the companies from raising prices. I have said this many times on these threads.
It sounds like you've been spending too much time on Alex Jones Infowars site. Are you prepping yet?
I've never seen any of your posts before, Mr. Speaking for the Newstalkers. Are you confused? Or is it a gender identity issue?
If that's not what you want you should use real language.
I did. However I don't want income inequality to be based on the notion that if the rich get a little less rich, then that equals happy times for the poor. That is what I said. Did you not read what I wrote? Or not understand it?
I guess business is not a competitive environment ? If a company gets overcome by competition every one in it loses their jobs ... but who cares ?! Yawn ...
Just keep dialing "0" ...