A Multi-Generational Look at Social Security Fundng
![]()
The sense of doom expressed in one younger readers comment about the Social Security system opened an intergenerational conversation about the programs actuarial predicament.
I would be fine with seeing my contributions to Social Security and Medicare decline substantially or disappear because I know that the program will not exist for me, Collin Slattery of New York City wrote in response to a recent column by Paul Krugman. My generation will never see one dollar from Social Security. Not one.
Mr. Slattery reflects a widespread view. Half of all adults younger than the Baby Boom generation believe they will receive no Social Security benefits at all by the time theyre ready to retire, according to a Pew Research Center poll in 2014 .
The programs shortfalls are entirely fixable, Mr. Krugman wrote in Republicans Against Retirement .
No, Social Security does not face a financial crisis; its long-term funding shortfall could easily be closed with modest increases in revenue, he wrote.
Eleven readers responded to Mr. Slattery, mostly in an effort to dispel concerns about the programs sustainability.
I believed that when I was your age also and yet, here it is 40 years later going strong, Lori Bell wrote from West Union, Iowa . A simple raising the cap on the amount of income taxed would fix the problem for many years after you retire also.
Your generation will see much more than one dollar from Social Security, Scott Mentink of Vashon, Wash. , wrote. Even if nothing were ever done to shore Social Security up, there is enough money coming in to pay modestly reduced benefits far into the future.
Government data support their arguments. The Congressional Budget Office said in 2010 that imposing the Social Security tax on higher incomes would eliminate shortfalls. Right now, income above about $120,000 is not taxed for Social Security.
And the Social Security Administration projects that taxes will generate enough income to pay around three-quarters of benefits until 2089.
http://takingnote.blogs.nytimes.com/2015/08/24/my-generation-will-never-see-one-dollar-from-social-security/?ref=opinion
Tags
Who is online
55 visitors

The views of solvency and long term survival of social security benefits for the multiple generations of the current work force are varied -
Simply lift the cap. Problem solved.
Cerenkov
Not exactly, you raise the payout as well, but could tax the benefits over a certain amount back into the fund.
Kavika
I am starting to think that will happen sooner rather than later
So long as those who received the lower payroll taxes will be just as satisfied with lower social security payouts when they become eligible - I have a feeling when that time comes we will hear "it was a government decision why should I be penalized with a lower benefit"
Dear Friend RIO: Social Security is the best domestic government program inU.S. history.
Funding while expanding, not contracting it is really a very simple matter.
Here is a toast to the greater good.
Enoch.
Enoch
Thanks for the perspective
It is absolutely essential to the nation taking care of its elderly in manner commensurate with their great contributions to the nation throughout their working lives.
I would also place Medicare on that same pedestal of great programs with social security, though it has problems (that can be fixed) and requires improvements (which can be made) it is also essential to the well being of our senior citizens.
Thanks for your valued feedback my friend
Dear RIO: Social Security and Medicare are I agree, vital to seniors, others, and reflect he best of us as a country.
Periodic adjustments to update is in order for both. If done correctly, each can expand, not contract benefits going into three centuries.
Less socialism for the rich. More and better use of government for the many. Enough of class warfare for and buy the top of the economic pyramid.
We are a nation of the 100%. High time our policies reflected that.
We need as a country to get our programs more in line with our traditional humanitarian and spiritual values.
It starts with using technology to exp-land employment, reduce pollution, make tax laws fair and rational, and insure trade agreements benefit us as a nation. There is more to it than that. But its a good place to start.
E.
All taxes should be payroll taxes. Yay! No more tax returns and no way to tax interest or investment income or other non-paycheck income. How about separate trust accounts for Social Security, Health Care and Defense? People could see which accounts were draining most of their paychecks.
A robust economy, with more people gainfully employed, will both reduce the government's burden of care (especially for those whose only disability is being unemployable) and increase it's revenue.Of all our financing problems, Social Security's is theleastmysteriousand there arestraightforwardsolutions (more than one).
Social security is the institutionalization of the age old practice (still in use in most of the world) of the young taking care of their elders. It is sad that our downward mobility has left our young unable to take care of their elders and, in some cases, to depend on them past their adulthood. A revived economy will correct all of this.Social Security was intended only as a"safety net"(to catch those jumping out of tall office buildings, on Wall Street, when theirmarketinvestments tanked). I am happy my Social Security benefits werenotinvestedin the same private sector "financial instruments" as my 401-Ks and IRAs. Hopefully, future retirees will not be as reliant on thesafety netas are current ones, and will benefit from retirement incomes fromprivateretirement accounts, built from a well-performing economy. Hooray for the day when Social Security income will be thesmallest share(a supplement) to private pensions.Social Security shouldneverbe privatized.Everyone is free to get their private retirement investments toout-performtheir Social Security "investment".
If you raised the benefits such that the benefits remained proportional to the pay-in, I would find that barely acceptable. I say "barely" because that means more of my money is being "invested" (LOL) by the government rather than by me personally. I have a better track record.
Likely, they may have already seen dollars from Social Security. Do they get a birthday present from Grandma? If so, Grandma has the money to pay for it, thanks to SS. What if their mom or dad dies, and there is no money for a college education? SS will help pay for their college. What if their mom is in an accident? SS will pay for her to have the $$ to live on, despite her disability.
Besides, when did it all become about them? I've paid into SS all my working life, and gladly! Fret not, you young ones. The world will still revolve around you...
Grandma and Grandpa are dead and didn't get back what they put in. The tax on American businesses through the matching contribution is part of the reason almost nothing is made in America anymore. We've priced ourselves out of the global market. China doesn't care about grandmas birthday present.
Dean
That is the difference between us and them. I prefer us and our approach
Dowser
Excellent points
Along with those presents, the inheritances (no matter how meager) that grandma and grandpa leave behind are bolstered and protected by their social security as well.
Your points on survivor ones are excellent
As have I and millions of others who feel the same way
Thanks for the feedback
There is a difference between social security disability and the regular social security payments which should not be conflated into one thing in my view
I agree with you that 401(k) plans and pensions should and must play a part in future retirement income.
Thanks for the feedback and perspective
?????
Enoch
All great ideas
Thanks you
Well perhaps you are the expert that will be consulted when changes are finally implemented, it certainly will not be me
Thanks for the back and forth