Star Trek: Strange New Worlds - S2 E4 - Among the Lotus Eaters
July 6, 2023
'Star Trek: Strange New Worlds' Season 2 Episode 4 Recap: Memories Worth a Thousand Cuts
"Among the Lotus Eaters" delivers an action-adventure mystery that dredges up tragic memories for Captain Pike and gives Ortegas her superhero moment.
By Samantha Coley
Star Trek: Strange New Worlds Season 2 delivers its fourth episode with an action-adventure story featuring high stakes and a fascinating concept that scrapes the surface of the potential emotional depths within. "Among the Lotus Eaters" sees Captain Pike (Anson Mount), La'an (Christina Chong), and Doctor M'Benga (Babs Olusanmokun) stranded on a pre-warp planet and struck with the loss of their memories. With a mystery rooted in lore from the original series and a ticking timer engulfing everyone on the planet and in its orbit, Pike must face some demons buried in his past in order to live in the present.
Written by Kirsten Beyer and Davy Perez, and directed by Eduardo Sanchez, "Among The Lotus Eaters" picks up a thread from the unaired Original Series pilot, "The Cage." In that episode, Pike mentions a mission that went horribly wrong on Rigel VII, in which he lost a yeoman, and multiple people died after he found himself trapped and forced to fight one of the planet's warriors. The impossibly high standard that Pike holds himself to is very telling, and this episode both allows the Captain some emotional introspection and pushes him to let himself get close to people.
"Among the Lotus Eaters" opens with Captain Pike preparing a delicious-looking pasta dish with his mother's sauce recipe in anticipation of a cozy night in with his on-and-off romantic partner Captain Batel (Melanie Scrofano). Their two ships are working together to map a binary star system and while it's quiet they try to sneak in some personal time with each other. Almost immediately, their date night is interrupted by various inquiries from both of their crews, but it's nothing urgent so they settle in. She's brought him a gift from an archaeological dig, a token to "bring lost sailors home," and he's ready to show her his appreciation when they're interrupted again by a call from the Admiral for Batel.
The Ready Room
Tags
Who is online
39 visitors
I didn't realize this episode was rooted in Pike's mention of Rigel VII in "The Cage" until I read it in the recap. That's really cool.
I thought this was a decent episode, but I also thought there were a few plot holes:
BTW, that memory-blocking radiation has some serious military potential, but we've never heard of it before (in the future, of course). That's something every bad alien race bent on conquest would want. Imagine what it could do to a potential target planet or ship. Looks like the writers did it again — they added a plot device with huge consequences to the canon, and probably just expect it to be forgotten.
Still, a decent episode, IMO.
As a bonus, the final scene gave us a zoom-out from Pike's quarters, so now we know exactly where they are — port side, on the edge of the saucer section, right next to what I think is the centrally-located mess hall.
Pike's quarters are circled, and the arrow points at those three running lights on the bow, indicating the center of the ship.
She didn't really show much enthusiasm for the assignment. I see this as being sort of like nobody resenting Riker for when he was forced to argue for Data's disassembly in Measure of a Man.
Pike asked the question, but I never felt it was adequately answered, either.
Ah. Great comparison.
I felt like this episode illustrated one of our stranger tendencies as humans - the tendency to become angry when it is revealed to us that we have been fooled. When Pike learns that his memories aren't actually contained in a casket in the palace, as he's been led to believe, he becomes enraged and unstable. He has clung so tightly to the lie that he can't face the truth.
Fiction reflecting reality for many in present society. Unfortunately, the enraged and unstable part is probably part of it, too.
I always look forward to reading what everyone else saw or didn't see, because it brings up stuff that I never think of.
I think that this is an essential emotion and what separates us from our Vulcan guides.
Can someone here remind me what Rigel VII is known for in later shows?
And why was the ep call Among "The Lotus Eaters"? Did I miss something?
Ugh, nevermind... Now I feel dumb.... re: Rigel VII.
I looked it up. Apparently the phrase comes from Greek mythology.
From Wikipedia:
In Greek mythology, the lotus-eaters (Greek: λωτοφάγοι, translit. lōtophágoi) were a race of people living on an island dominated by the lotus tree, a plant whose botanical identity is uncertain. The lotus fruits and flowers were the primary food of the island and were a narcotic, causing the inhabitants to sleep in peaceful apathy. After they ate the lotus, they would forget their home and loved ones, and only long to stay with their fellow lotus-eaters.
The title seems to be a reference to the loss of memory among Rigel VII's inhabitants.