Biggest loser of the midterm elections? The media.
S E E D E D C O N T E N T
We don't yet know precisely who won the 2022 midterms, but we certainly know who lost.
I'm sorry to say that my colleagues in the political press blew it.
The headlines coming into Tuesday's elections almost uniformly predicted a Democratic wipeout. Here's just a small sampling:
lThe bottom is dropping out of the 2022 election for Democrats
lDemocrats, on Defense in Blue States, Brace for a Red Wave in the House
lRed tsunami watch
lThe Republican wave is building fast
lDemocrats fear midterm drubbing as party leaders rush to defend blue seats
lWhy the midterms are going to be great for Donald Trump
lBreaking down the GOP's midterm momentum
lDemocrats confront their nightmare scenario on election eve as economic concerns overshadow abortion and democracy worries
I pulled those from The Post, the New York Times, CNN, Axios and Politico - but the rest of the news media called it much the same.
I was baffled. What were they seeing that I and, more important, the Democratic operatives I spoke to weren't seeing? Back in mid-August, I wrote a column titled "Why that red wave might end up a ripple." I noted that Democrats had pulled even on the "generic ballot" - which party voters prefer for Congress - at a time in the cycle when the incumbent president's party is almost always losing ground. Democrats' standing receded slightly since then, but the contests remained extremely tight. The races were stable, both in public polling and in the private polling I had seen.
So what happened? Political journalists were suckered by a wave of Republican junk polls in the closing weeks of the campaign. They were also swayed by some reputable polling organizations that, burned by past failures to capture MAGA voters, overweighted their polls to account for that in ways that simply didn't make sense. And reporters fell for Republican feints and misdirection, as Republican operatives successfully created an artificial sense of momentum by talking about how they were spending money in reliably blue areas.
An extraordinary profusion of bad partisan polling flooded the media late in the campaign, coming from GOP outfits such as Trafalgar (which had Blake Masters over Mark Kelly in the Arizona Senate race, Don Bolduc over Maggie Hassan in the New Hampshire Senate race, among others) and Rasmussen (which gave Republicans a five point edge in the generic ballot).
It was telling that Republican campaigns didn't release their own polls to confirm the dubious results Trafalgar and Rasmussen were producing. Still, such polling helped skew handicapping websites. RealClearPolitics, for example, moved Sen. Michael Bennet (D-Colo.) into "toss-up" status in the closing days of his reelection bid. Bennet beat his Republican opponent by double digits.
A couple of reputable polls also came up with some suspicious conclusions. Three weeks ago, a New York Times-Siena College poll caused a news media sensation when it found Republicans with a four point advantage in the generic ballot. (A Monmouth University poll found a similar GOP advantage.) But the Siena poll showed that women were evenly split between Democrats and Republicans, at 47-47. Had the gender gap disappeared entirely for the first time in modern history? Or was there something screwy with the weighting?
Even though early voting figures were astronomical, Gallup asserted days before the election that "Americans are also markedly less enthusiastic about voting in this year's elections than they were in 2018." (The 2022 turnout was exceptionally high.) Gallup also predicted that the "political environment ... should work to the benefit of the Republican Party."
The news media took the faulty assumption that Republicans would enjoy a red wave and plugged in explanations for the imagined outcome. Democrats blew it because they spoke too much about abortion and democracy, and too little about the economy and crime. (In fact, crime and the economy figured prominently in many Democratic campaigns.)
"Did Democrats place a losing bet on abortion?" CNN asked.
Fox News trumpeted: "Biden ridiculed for 'despicable' speech on 'threat' to democracy: 'What delusion looks like.' "
Many outlets asserted that "Democrats are losing Latino voters," as NPR put it.
And some Democrats started a premature circular firing squad, providing the media with quotes to justify the false narratives. "I think we're going to have a bad night," Hilary Rosen said Sunday on CNN. "When voters tell you over and over again that they care mostly about the economy, listen to them. Stop talking about democracy being at stake."
The day before the election, Bloomberg News went with this headline: "Inflation-Focused Voters Defy Biden's Bid to Change the Subject."
On Wednesday morning, that same writer tweeted a bit of a corrective: "Biden, despite his low approval rating and relative absence on the campaign trail, will likely be able to claim best midterm performance for an incumbent president's party in 20 years."
Tags
Who is online
326 visitors
The media was carrying water for the Republicans in this election. Fortunately it didnt matter.
The biggest loser in this 2022 election cycle is the American republic's democracy. The lies, fear, false accusations and threats were not resoundingly defeated. The MAGA still lives, some of its candidates won. Bannon, Stone and the others remain free, untouchable and the pro-Putin factions are amassing wealth as they prepare for round three. This is not over until that is over.
Right now Republican politicians and talking heads are berating Trump. Will it last?
If the MAGA base continues to support Trump the politicians will go back to him because that is where the voters are. The right wing media will go back to him because most of them are worthless.
Personally I believe the life span and very existence of the MAGA and the American ultra right wing depends on the survival of The Putin Regime. And especially if the government replacing it is open, wishes to re-join the world and truly desires to contribute for the betterment of its own people and its new trade alliances.
The next two years are going to be rough....on the Democrats
Since republicans don't have any actual policies, ideas, or plans for actual governing? Personal revenge is much easier than doing the actual work...
Then why are they keeping them a secret? Why don't you explain the republicans' plans for inflation then?
Ignore the riff raff. They are in favor of shaking down other governments for political gain and nefarious money dealings with autocracies and theocracies.
The Trump should not have been impeached he should have been tried for Sedition and Treason.
In 2016 I have to wonder how many people did not vote for Hillary because they thought she had it in the bag because of the media. I also wonder how many Republicans did not get out and vote in 2022 because the media sold them on the big wave and they decided it was in the bag.
The moral of the story is people are lazy, and laziness can have consequences.
Rasmussen (which gave Republicans a five point edge in the generic ballot).
Lol. The final number will be a about a four point edge for Republicans. To pick that out as egregious partisan polling when some Democratic partisan polling had Rubio (who won by 16) losing tells you all you need to know about the seed's agenda. The polling was generally accurate, Republicans just lost more than their share of close elections, costing them the red wave.
Any pundit who was told Republicans would win the popular vote by 4 (swinging it by about 7 points from 2020) , win the suburbs, improve with women (win white women), blacks and Hispanics would predict Republicans would win the house comfortably. The votes just ended up being inefficiently distributed.