Legally insane Chicago Judge wants her $182,000 job back
Can a suspended Cook County judge return to the bench after being declared legally insane at the time she shoved a sheriffs deputy in 2012?
For the first time in Illinois, attorneys on the case say, a judicial disciplinary panel has begun tackling the question of whether a judge whose psychotic episodes can apparently be controlled through medication should be allowed to return to the bench.
Judge Cynthia Brim, 55, testified before the Illinois Courts Commission for more than two hours on Friday in a bid to save her $182,000-a-year job. The seven-member panel made up of judges from outside of Cook County as well as two citizens will later issue a written decision.
Brim was found not guilty of misdemeanor battery by reason of insanity last year for shoving a sheriffs deputy outside the Daley Center during a manic episode in March 2012. A day earlier, while on the bench, she broke into an extended rant while presiding over a traffic court call at the Markham courthouse.
I just broke like a pencil, Brim told the commission Friday, saying she was feeling stressed that day because there was only one courtroom deputy present for a busy call. It was totally inappropriate for me to say what I did at that time or any other time.
Brim was effectively suspended from her duties as a judge after the battery charges were filed but was nonetheless returned to the bench by voters weeks later. She has continued to collect her $182,000 salary since her 2012 suspension.
On Friday, Brim said she was once again able to fulfill her duties as judge. Over the last two years, she said, she has consistently taken her medications a requirement of her probation in the battery case and has not had any psychotic episodes.
I can serve as a judge with full capability as long as I continue to take the medication as prescribed, she said. I've had two years to think about this, and I have a different perspective and understanding of my condition. I realize now I have to stay on my medications and see a psychiatrist on a regular basis.
But John Gallo, an attorney for the Judicial Inquiry Board that filed the disciplinary charges, questioned whether it was proper to return Brim to the bench.
If she was allowed to serve again, parties who had important cases before her would soon learn about her past and wonder about her ability, he said.
Theyre looking at a judge who said to a court that she was at one point in time...insane, Gallo said.
Brim bears some responsibility for putting herself in the position that led to her highly public breakdown in 2012, he said.
Judge Brim decided to go without any kind of psychiatric treatment of any sort after 15-plus years of these episodes while she was a sitting judge, Gallo said.
Brim, who has been hospitalized at least nine times for mental illness since 1994, acknowledged she had once been carried out of a Bridgeview courtroom on a stretcher after going catatonic during her court call. Her physicians had repeatedly allowed her to discontinue taking mood-stabilizing drugs, she said, but she wasnt diagnosed with a bipolar type of schizoaffective disorder until 2009.
Still, she had once gone off medication on her own and in the two years before her 2012 breakdown had stopped taking medications or seeing a psychiatrist or therapist.
But her psychiatrist, Dr. Roueen Rafeyan, told the commission there was only at most a 10 percent chance that Brim would ever have another relapse and he said others in stressful, important fields can function with the illness.
There are heart surgeons who have the same diagnosis and operate on patients all day long, he said.
Brims attorney, James Montgomery, suggested that the commission could allow the judge to return to the bench for two years and then revisit the case if it was concerned about her continued stability.
http://www.chicagotribune.com/news/local/breaking/chi-judge-wants-back-on-bench-after-insanity-ruling-20140328,0,7568123.story?track=rss

Even though she was suspended in 2012 and declared legally insane, she has been collecting her $182,000 annual salary. The Cook County idiots in Chicago who pay her and the voters who re-elect these lunatics should also be declared insane.
This is insane. She is insane. Cook County is insane. Those who re-elected her are insane. Even suggesting that she still receive her salary for two years while suspended is insane. The idea that she be reinstated, knowing that any case she sits could be called into question and have to be retried, possibly causing the city to have to pay out on a lawsuit, is insanity.
WTH is wrong with people in Cook County? If she pulls out a freaking gun in court one day because she has an episode and shoots the deputy next time, who will take responsibility for it? Certainly not her.
In many states, a person convicted of domestic violence may never own a firearm.
This is just as crazy. She shouldn't be a judge.
The legal system will be sitting around waiting for the relapse and will have to pick up the pieces again when she goes over the hill. Nope, she doesn't belong on the bench. There are enough crazy judges out there.
If we knew all the facts in all the mass murders that have occurred during the last 10 to 15 years, I bet we would find nearly everyone of them involved legally prescribed drugs by psychiatrist. This is not to say there are many insane people doing various jobs including surgeons and judges who are not on legally prescribed mind altering drugs or diagnosed as insane.
It seems all these mass murderers have given everyone around them the opportunity to have this knowledge including doctors, but we continually ignore it until they really go off their rocker.
I know people who may have suffered a little or more depression. What's the first thing they do? They go and see a psychiatrist and he/she prescribes some mind altering drug for them. Before long they turn into real nut cases.
I believe we are putting too much faith in psychiatrists and their drugs in this society. How did we survive all those years without them? I remember this psychology teacher in college who was crazy as a bat. Never had a class that compared to his.
Grump, I know several judges, some of them traffic judges, and every damn one of them own guns they carry into the court rooms and keep under their robes. If they don't wear robes they keep them on their person or somewhere within easy reach where they sit. They are terrified of some disgruntled nut attacking or shooting them in the courtroom.
I'll bet this woman has had a gun for years, and I'll bet no one has asked her to surrender it; and if they have, and if she surrendered a legal one, she has procured another one.
She is flat out nuts, and she has a gun. Bet on it.
How's that mirror looking today, John?
Sadly, for the Cook County Justice System, all of her cases starting from the time she was initially diagnosed, can and should be appealed. She did not have the mental faculty to perform her duties which tinted each and every case.
IF she is allowed to return to the bench, any adjudication she makes will instantly be questioned and challenged by the defense this will just serve to undermine the judicial process in Cook County. Very bad choice I think.
I don't know why she wants the job back; she hasn't been doing it for two years and has been drawing the salary anyway.
So we have three politicians in California indicted for criminal actions, one of them for treason, and they are merely "suspended" and still drawing their pay... while their constituents are without representation and special elections cannot be held to replace them because they refuse to resign.
And in Cook County (Chicago) we have a fruit loop judge who has been absent from the bench for two years who has been "suspended" and still drawing an obscenely large salary, PLUS we have to guess her stand-in has been drawing at least the same.
It's no wonder our country is so damn broke. These are only a couple of butt-stupid plays we KNOW about. There's no telling what else is hiding under the porch.
Power mad ?
I live in Illinois, but I live in Lake County. . . THANK YOU JESUS!!
Stop talking about yourself in this negative way in public John . The rest of us know about your propensity for verbal diarrhea but try not to let it get you down ...
Money hungry?
Oppps! My bad... it was me. I was in a big rush.