╌>

DOJ: Police Response in Domestic and Sexual Violence Calls Violate Survivors' Civil Rights

  

Category:  News & Politics

Via:  jerry-verlinger  •  12 years ago  •  46 comments

DOJ: Police Response in Domestic and Sexual Violence Calls Violate Survivors' Civil Rights

While police abuses such as racial profiling or police brutality are well understood as civil rights violations, police misconduct in enforcing domestic and sexual violence laws is not.
e3b4ad1ed0c5d030807286d9fa3ec020.jpg?width=380
Far too often, survivors of domestic and sexual violence face disbelief, victim-blaming and shaming, hostility, and a refusal to investigate, or even record, their reports from police. In Puerto Rico, the
ACLU found that police failure to enforce domestic violence laws contributed to the highest per capita rate in the world of women killed by their intimate partners. The Puerto Rico Police Department also systematically underreported rape crimes and rarely took action when their own officers committed domestic violence, allowing 84 officers who had been arrested two or more times for domestic violence to remain active. In Washington DC, Human Rights Watch described serious problems with police documentation and investigation of sexual assault cases. In Norristown, PA and many other towns across the U.S., police penalize victims of domestic violence who reach out for law enforcement assistance, including by threatening eviction, pursuant to local ordinances.

While police abuses such as racial profiling or police brutality are well understood as civil rights violations, police misconduct in enforcing domestic and sexual violence laws is not. For years, the ACLU has argued that systemic problems in policing and domestic violence can violate survivors' civil and human rights because they are often rooted in discriminatory attitudes about women, as well as about people of color, immigrants, and LGBT people. Victims of these crimes may be denied equal protection under the U.S. Constitution when domestic or sexual violence is treated less seriously than other offenses. Due process violations may also occur when police affirmatively condone the violence, or when a victim is put at greater risk as a result of police action.

Last Thursday, the Office of Community Oriented Policing Services, the Office for Victims of Crime, and the Office on Violence Against Women of the Department of Justice issued a crucial
joint statement on addressing gender discrimination in policing. Because "gender bias plays a role in undermining the effective response by law enforcement to crimes against women," the statement announced that the prevention of sex-based discrimination by law enforcement is a "top priority" of the Civil Rights Division of DOJ in its oversight of law enforcement agencies. Indeed, in the last two years, DOJ launched groundbreaking investigations into departments in Puerto Rico , New Orleans , Maricopa County, AZ , and Missoula, MT to address grave concerns about their policing of domestic and sexual violence.

The joint statement and these investigations send a critical message about the importance of law enforcement accountability. In the statement, DOJ notes that many law enforcement agencies need to improve their response to all forms of violence against women, encouraging jurisdictions to "review and revise policies, protocols, and, most importantly, practices, to ensure they are free from gender bias." The statement includes a list of resources for law enforcement on how to appropriately address domestic and sexual violence, but does not give further guidance on how the Constitution and federal laws apply to protect victims or the fundamental elements of effective law enforcement responses to domestic or sexual violence. Such guidance would give greater clarity to law enforcement agencies seeking to strengthen their practices, as well as better informing survivors of domestic and sexual violence about their civil rights. We urge DOJ to continue to develop its work in this area.

politics.gif?32&width=180

Sandra Park Staff Attorney
ACLU Womens Rights Project


Tags

jrDiscussion - desc
[]
 
1stwarrior
Professor Participates
link   1stwarrior    12 years ago
Holder needs to go - and real soon.
 
 
 
Jerry Verlinger
Freshman Silent
link   seeder  Jerry Verlinger    12 years ago

Holder needs to go - and real soon.

Why? do you actually think Holder is sending instructions to all the PDs in this country and telling them not to prosecute domestic violenceperpetrators?

The DOJ is being pro-active regarding this problem, what do you want from them?

They are also conducting investigations in almost every major city in the country for excessive reports of police brutality. Something that should have been done when Bush was in office, because the cops have been out of control with their guns and batons for the last 10-15 years.

 
 
 
Jerry Verlinger
Freshman Silent
link   seeder  Jerry Verlinger    12 years ago

My suggestion is to have a team of Lesbian, transgendered, gay police officers to address the protected class citizens.

My suggestion is for you to either postconstructivecomments that add to the discussion, or don't post any comments at all.

What, do you think this forum is some kind of joke?! How old are you anyway?

 
 
 
Petey Coober
Freshman Silent
link   Petey Coober    12 years ago

What an interesting comment . Reality is not as simple as the shriekers perceive it to be ...

 
 
 
Petey Coober
Freshman Silent
link   Petey Coober    12 years ago

The Russel is sooo grumpy all the time . Clowning is the only way to combat terminal seriousness 36.gif ...

 
 
 
screminmimi
Freshman Silent
link   screminmimi    12 years ago

This is good news as a declaration; now, if follow-through is conducted at all levels, including in the courtrooms by judges, we will be getting somewhere.

Very, very good article, Jerry.

 
 
 
1stwarrior
Professor Participates
link   1stwarrior    12 years ago

Show me your facts Jerry and I "may" reconsider Eric Holder's past history for the 6 years he's held that office. Maybe DOJ "is" conducting an investigation - but it sure wasn't Holder's idea and when he gets wind of it, he will probably put a stop to it 'cause it may offend his ethical beliefs that no one is guilty, no matter how much evidence is produced.

 
 
 
screminmimi
Freshman Silent
link   screminmimi    12 years ago

That's true, Robert. But on the whole legislators and courts have been shamefully lax in passing and enforcing laws to protect the women who do attempt to get away from abusive and violent relationships.

Even when a man has violated a restraining order, he is allowed to bail out of jail on the charge, and many domestic abuse charges are met with only a suspended sentence and/or probation.

 
 
 
1stwarrior
Professor Participates
link   1stwarrior    12 years ago
Keep on trying to post, but for some reason is really, really running slow.Responding to you Jerry - I have only read 'til Sep 2012, but the link covers his "career" since '08. I don't like how he picks and choses what he's going to handle and why.
 
 
 
1stwarrior
Professor Participates
link   1stwarrior    12 years ago
 
 
 
Neale Osborn
Freshman Silent
link   Neale Osborn    12 years ago

The use of these poor, mentally ill women to advance a political agenda is disgusting. While I certainly do understand the desire to "just do SOMETHING" to address the problem of domestic abuse, there comes a point where we have to say "Enough!" I am NOT advocating ignoring their plight. Nor am I advocating NOT punishing their attackers/mates for the assaults. However, when a person returns to the 'tender mercies" of the person abusing them, time after time, you have to wonder why we should continue to interfere.

Freedom, liberty, individual responsibility- ALL of these come with a price tag. And that tag can be brutal- if you insist on making the same bad choice over and over again, you cannot then blame others for your plight. I could not strike a woman unless I needed to defend my life or the life of another. I could not, have not, stood idly by while a woman is being beaten by her "mate". But I HAVE walked away when she went back for the 3rd time, calling me a bastard for breaking his jaw in order to stop the attack. Suicide is a sad, wasteful event. But it IS your right. And returning to a man who has beaten or raped you is a slow form of suicide.

 
 
 
Neale Osborn
Freshman Silent
link   Neale Osborn    12 years ago

Upon re-reading my comment, I see where it would be possible to get the impression that I think ALL women who are abused WANT to be abused. That is NOT the case at all. It is only the women who repeatedly shrug off attempts to help them escape the abuser, and return to him time after time, that I believe have some odd, possibly even subconscious, desire to be abused. Being abused by your mate the first time is no more your fault, no matter what, thanthe rape of a womanis her fault.

 
 
 
Petey Coober
Freshman Silent
link   Petey Coober    12 years ago

Comment removed off topic [ph]

 
 
 
Neale Osborn
Freshman Silent
link   Neale Osborn    12 years ago

Police do not care about protecting or serving. They are there to clean up the mess, and enforce the laws. Individual cops MAY desire to protect you, but the institution does not. And just as parents do not care about fair, they care about quiet, cops do not care about protecting, they care about the law.

And, as with Egilman, I live where the AVERAGE response time is greater than 20 minutes (despite the State Police having a station less than 6 minutes away at speed limit speeds). The Sheriff who did the interview for my CCW (Let's not go there, my wife insisted) told me that with the number of armed home invasions from meth heads, only an idiot does not have a weapon easily accessible in their home.

 
 
 
Neale Osborn
Freshman Silent
link   Neale Osborn    12 years ago

The fact that politicians prefer victims to fawn over rather than upstanding citizens protecting themselves and society speaks volumes to the slide this country has taken in the last 60 years...

Politicians, police, and liberals all prefer to see a woman dead in an alley, raped then strangled with her own pantyhose, rather than see her leaning over the hood of a cop's car reloading her pistol and telling them why there's a dead rapist lying in the alley. Because THAT woman does not need the politician, the cop, or the liberal to "protect" her out of everything she has.

 
 
 
Aeonpax
Freshman Silent
link   Aeonpax    12 years ago
  • Politicians, police, and liberals all prefer to see a woman dead in an alley,

great_post_twins.jpg

 
 
 
Jerry Verlinger
Freshman Silent
link   seeder  Jerry Verlinger    12 years ago

It's troubling that I have to tell you that on your own article.

It's troubling that I have to consider reporting you for flamebaiting, lucky for you, I'd rather burn your ass with your own flame.

I offer up solutions for the problem.

You offer up wise ass, stupid, flame-baiting bullshit, is what you offer.

Where is your solution?

My solution is to expose as much of this police misconduct as possible to make more people aware how we are slipping into a police state.

As for my age Jerry? I am happily married my friend.

Since when can 5 year olds get married?

 
 
 
Jerry Verlinger
Freshman Silent
link   seeder  Jerry Verlinger    12 years ago

Maybe DOJ "is" conducting an investigation - but it sure wasn't Holder's idea and when he gets wind of it, he will probably put a stop to it 'cause it may offend his ethical beliefs that no one is guilty, no matter how much evidence is produced.

Come on 1st, that's a little over the top. At this timejustabout everymajorcityinthecountryisunderinvigilationfor having too many excessive force and brutality complaints.

We've posted articles about some of them in the Police Brutality & Misconduc t forum

New Jerseys' Largest Police Force to be Monitored by DOJ For Failur...

Another US City PD Under Investigation: Feds Probe San Diego Police...

Police Brutality in America - A Growing Problem

According to an article posted by The Root in 2011, the U.S. Justice Department, allegations of wrongdoing by police departments across the country have mushroomed to unprecedented levels. According to Thomas Perez, the assistant attorney general for the Civil Rights Division, at least 17 U.S. police departments are under investigation for various civil rights violations, "more than at any time in the division's history," Perez said in testimony before the Senate Judiciary Committee. Read More ;

 
 
 
Jerry Verlinger
Freshman Silent
link   seeder  Jerry Verlinger    12 years ago

Let's face it Jerry, it is accepted behavior.

Not really, the "clowning" is being discussed in the NT Moderators Discussion group

It is also the reason there will always be turmoil here.

Most of the clowns are the same wise asses in high school that tried to make up for their lack of intelligence by goofing off. Many of them haven't grown up and show up on these sites to entertain themselves. When they wander onto my threads and start throwing their flamebaiting around, I figure it's my turn to entertain myself and just burn their ass with their own flame.

 
 
 
Jerry Verlinger
Freshman Silent
link   seeder  Jerry Verlinger    12 years ago

If I wrote that Jerry, you would be instant messaging Perrie begging her to ban me, suspend me or purple coward my comment.

Whatever BF, how about getting back on topic.

 
 
 
Jerry Verlinger
Freshman Silent
link   seeder  Jerry Verlinger    12 years ago

"The Russel is sooo grumpy all the time . Clowning is the only way to combat terminal seriousness ..."

Knock it off Petey.

You might want to read this comment ,..... you' re at the head of the class.

 
 
 
Neale Osborn
Freshman Silent
link   Neale Osborn    12 years ago

Not really, the "clowning" is being discussed in the NT Moderators Discussion group

REALLY? Well, don't be getting too full of yourselves- clowning is NOT a CoC violation.

Most of the clowns are the same wise asses in high school that tried to make up for their lack of intelligence by goofing off. Many of them haven't grown up and show up on these sites to entertain themselves. When they wander onto my threads and start throwing their flamebaiting around, I figure it's my turn to entertain myself and just burn their ass with their own flame.

So, let me see if I get this right- because you're ALSO a mod, you get to boot people off your articles for behavior of whichYOU personally disapprove. The rest of us, being denied the right to moderate our own threads, have to tolerate people whose behavior WE disapprove, or run whining to the mods for "help". I'm thinking this is a bullshit way to run things. Actually, I KNOW it is. My biggest complaint with NV was when they took away author-moderation, and only let group owners moderate in their groups er, nations. And my single biggest worry about NT was that same policy. IN MY OPINION, this needs to be changed. Because, quite simply, certain mods are using their mod-power to enforce their personal bias rather than the CoC. And yes, Jerry, you are one of them.

 
 
 
Jerry Verlinger
Freshman Silent
link   seeder  Jerry Verlinger    12 years ago

No law will protect women who refuse to leave a violent abuser.

Actually they do. If the woman stayswiththe guy, the police are obligated to respond to every call andarrest the guy every time. From there it's up to the courts to deal with.

Most courts are issuing restraining orders the first or for sure the second time a guy is brought in. But the guy has to be brought in, and that's where a lot of the the problem lies.

 
 
 
Neale Osborn
Freshman Silent
link   Neale Osborn    12 years ago

Arresting the offender every time he breaks the law does not really protect her, any more than a restraining order does. After all, the second part of this quote is dead on.

The Constitution is a restraining order against the federal government. Im not going to say a word about the effectiveness of restraining orders against criminals.

ROs do not work against government OR the other criminal class.

 
 
 
Jerry Verlinger
Freshman Silent
link   seeder  Jerry Verlinger    12 years ago

Well, don't be getting too full of yourselves- clowning is NOT a CoC violation.

"Clowning", when it's off topic or of no value, IS in fact a CoC violation.

So, let me see if I get this right- because you're ALSO a mod, you get to boot people off your articles for behavior of whichYOU personally disapprove.

So let me see,...... NO, you have wrong. A Mod cannot boot anyone off their own articles. If they feel someone is off topic or making asshole no value jokes, they have to call in another mod to delete the comment, then, only if the second Mod agrees there is violation will it be deleted.

I don't understand, you've being here since July 2012, you certainlyshould know, a moderator cannot moderate on their owndiscussions or even a discussion they have participate in.

The rest of us, being denied the right to moderate our own threads, have to tolerate people whose behavior WE disapprove, or run whining to the mods for "help". I'm thinking this is a bullshit way to run things.

Don't you know the NT Code of Conduct and that "bullshit" way to run things was presented to, voted on, and approved by the membership of NewsTalkers? Or were you out that day?

Self moderated articles allows the author or seeder, to deleted any comment they do not agree with or is posted by someone they do not like. Didn't work...... that's why the NV ptb disallowed it, and that's why the NT membership won't approve it. Actually, you can ask Perrie, I wanted to allow self moderated threads, but I'm in the minority so......

We gotta play by the rules Neale, if you want to play on unmoderated threads go to the Heated Discussion forum.

Meanwhile, we're off topic here. If you want to discuss this further, I suggest you write an article and post it to the NewsTalkers Community group.

 
 
 
Jerry Verlinger
Freshman Silent
link   seeder  Jerry Verlinger    12 years ago

Deluded by "orders of protection." Deluded that the police will protect them, or that the police can protect them.

Orders of Protection do not always work. But if an OP is in effect and it is violated, a 911 call can get the cops there quickly and the violator will be arrested immediatelyon the basis of the OP, facing an automatic 6 months for Contempt of Court.

 
 
 
Neale Osborn
Freshman Silent
link   Neale Osborn    12 years ago

Orders of Protection do not always work. But if an OP is in effect and it is violated, a 911 call can get the cops there quickly .........

.............and pick up her body. ROs, OPs, all a waste of time and money. No one respects them but the lawyers who charge you to get them, and the judges paid to pass them out.

 
 
 
Jerry Verlinger
Freshman Silent
link   seeder  Jerry Verlinger    12 years ago

Out here in the sticks we have only staties,

Not true Ambi, you also have the Rensselaer County Sheriff who handles OP violations, as they are usually issued by a county court judge. Also, the Staties have sub-stations all over the place and usually can respond to a call pretty quickly, if they can't they will call in the county cowboys.

 
 
 
Dean Moriarty
Professor Silent
link   Dean Moriarty    12 years ago

It's still a good idea to have a gun on hand. Your first line of defense is yourself and the nearest donut shop could be half an hour away.

 
 
 
Jerry Verlinger
Freshman Silent
link   seeder  Jerry Verlinger    12 years ago

No one respects them but the lawyers who charge you to get them, and the judges paid to pass them out.

That's bullshit. I personally know of a case where Warren County Criminal Court Judge John S. Hall issued an OP the second time a guy was brought in for smacking his girlfriendaround, even though the girl did not request the order.

She later asked the order to be lifted and was turned down. The Judge said he did not have time to bearranging these guys because their girlfriends did not have enough sense to stay away from them. I was there, I heard him say it.

The back story is, Hall had this guy before on DV charges involving a different girlfriend, and the guy was also facing felony drugtraffickingcharges.

You do not need a lawyer to get an OP and the Judges are on a fixed salary as they attempt to handle an overloaded court calender.

 
 
 
Neale Osborn
Freshman Silent
link   Neale Osborn    12 years ago

Call it bullshit if you want- your opinion is granted the same weight I grant the opinions of other people here- not much- because I know how 99.9% of judges handle OPs and ROs. Because I've helped clean up the mess left behind when these wastes of paper are ignored. I've seen a woman denied an emergency grant of an NJ CCW by a judge who listened to the DA rather than the hospital report (12 broken bones, including 2 ribs and a jaw) when the DA swore that a restraining order would protect her just fine. She was murdered by her ex-boyfriend 2 weeks later. An OP or an RO isn't evenworth the paper it is printed on, because the paper had value when it was still clean.

 
 
 
Perrie Halpern R.A.
Professor Guide
link   Perrie Halpern R.A.    12 years ago

An author has the right to keep people on topic. Stay on topic.

 
 
 
Perrie Halpern R.A.
Professor Guide
link   Perrie Halpern R.A.    12 years ago

To set the record straight:

  1. The author sets the tone of their article. Some don't mind clowning while (off topic comments) while others do. If an author requests no clowning, then no clowning. Otherwise, no problem
  2. An author can't self delete a comment, even if they are a mod. They must get another mod. They can't kick a person off an article either.

I hope this sets the record straight.

 
 
 
Neale Osborn
Freshman Silent
link   Neale Osborn    12 years ago

Well, Perrie, It does. That doesn't change what Jerry is, which is a crappy moderator, but OK.

 
 
 
Petey Coober
Freshman Silent
link   Petey Coober    12 years ago

"Clowning", when it's off topic or of no value, IS in fact a CoC violation.-


Fair enough Jerry . Here's what you need to do to be taken seriously on this issue : Clearly explain what about the topic any clowning does NOT address . If you can't do that then the clowning will continue to be on topic . It's that simple . It is up to you to clearly delineate what the topic is . In my experience some seeders are so focused on their ultra-serious POV that they refuse to recognize simple disagreement .

And here's another thing you need to do . Give advance warning in your article that off topic comments will not be permitted . If you don't do that you should EXPECT to see blowback ...

 
 
 
Perrie Halpern R.A.
Professor Guide
link   Perrie Halpern R.A.    12 years ago

Yes they can, but they can't threaten a member with it, i.e. "I'm going to kick you off if you say that again" Authors can warn a member of possible CoC violations and that they are breaking the CoC at which point the author should get a mod have the member removed if there is a pattern of violations. They should get a mod by email or IM and show a pattern of behavior and the mod will remove them from the article.

It is better if you have specific rules to your article to spell it out in beginning or the article or seed, so there is clarity about behavior expected from participating. This way removal from the article can happen quicker.

 
 
 
Perrie Halpern R.A.
Professor Guide
link   Perrie Halpern R.A.    12 years ago

This is the comment? [rolls eyes]. If you guys can't stay on topic, get off the article.

 
 
 
Jerry Verlinger
Freshman Silent
link   seeder  Jerry Verlinger    12 years ago

We are in Dutchess County and do have our own sheriff and deputy

Sorry about that Ambi, for reason Rensselaer came to mind which is in Rensselaer County, Your in Rhinebeck, (much nicer town) right, Dutchess County. Actually every county in the state has a Sheriff Dept., but you have way more than a Sheriff and a Deputy.

You have the Sheriff, the Under Sheriff, plusa total of 550 deputies and staffersin the department, and although I don't know how many of them are uniformed patrol deputies, I would imagine there are quite few. Dutchess is a fairly well populated county for it's size with about 300,000 people in about 825 sq. miles.

If you want live in the sticks, come to Warren County we have about 65,000 people in 932 sq. miles.

 
 
 
Perrie Halpern R.A.
Professor Guide
link   Perrie Halpern R.A.    12 years ago

No Petey, it doesn't work that way. The author can say what is off topic, within reasonable limits. If you don't like the way they handle an article or their limits, stay off those of their articles. That is the way it has always been done. Now this will end any more meta on Jerry's article. Any further comment about this issue will be deleted

 
 
 
Jerry Verlinger
Freshman Silent
link   seeder  Jerry Verlinger    12 years ago

Call it bullshit if you want- your opinion is granted the same weight I grant the opinions of other people here- not much- because I know how 99.9% of judges handle OPs and ROs.

Everybody's opinion does carry the same weight around here Neale, including yours. So, if you feel those opinions are notworthmuch, you're in there also.

If you're called in to 'clean up' the cases where they do not work, then of course, in all of those cases you are aware of the OP's's failed. But you do do not know how many OP's and RO's areactualized , and how many of them failed.

I said they do not always work, but many do. Here are some stats from the National Institute of Justice ;

Research varies, but violation rates have been found to range from 23 percent over two years , 35 percent within six months , to 60 percent within twelve months , and in between at 48.8 percent within two years.

  • A majority (51 percent) of abusers sentenced concurrently for abuse-related offenses and no-contact violations reabuse their victims.
  • The rearrest rate for new abuse for abusers specifically convicted of civil protection order violations is 44 percent
  • Criminal no-contact orders, 48 percent
  • All other domestic violence offenses ranged from 25 to 39 percent.

So, " An OP or an RO isn't evenworth the paper it is printed on... ", is obviously aninaccurate statement.

 
 
 
Jerry Verlinger
Freshman Silent
link   seeder  Jerry Verlinger    12 years ago

Re; Times Topicsarticle;

I don't like how he picks and choses what he's going to handle and why.

That's probably because you're a conservative and we happen to have a progressive administration in Washington at this time.

We'll have to see what happens in 2016, but I don't think Hillary's AG will have a much different attitude. Sorry abut that.

 
 
 
Jerry Verlinger
Freshman Silent
link   seeder  Jerry Verlinger    12 years ago

"Eric Holder, our contemptuous attorney general, must resign"

That's the opinion of FOX NEWS .... doesn't matter what they think.

 
 

Who is online




106 visitors