╌>

State of K-12 Education: The Adults Have Taken the Focus Away from the Kids

  

Category:  News & Politics

Via:  robert-in-ohio  •  12 years ago  •  29 comments

State of K-12 Education: The Adults Have Taken the Focus Away from the Kids

By: Michelle Rhee, Founder / CEO at StudentsFirst

Just using the words education and industry in the same breath might cause teachers and some parents to shudder.

However, putting those words next to each other is a reminder that the American public education system does have an end-goal: to deliver the product of well-educated young people and thereby a well-educated country.

In those terms, its an industry in distress. Today, four out of five African-American 4th graders read below grade level. On international assessments our kids rank 26th in math, 21st in science, and 17th in reading. And workforce projections say that the U.S. economy will be short 3 million college-educated workers by 2018.

Thats why its worth taking stock of the American public education system. And here are five takeaways of the current state of our effort to provide every child with an effective, excellent education:

Were Not Adequately Focused on Students

Decisions that affect our public schools are too often made based on the desires of adults rather than the needs of kids. Take, for example, teacher evaluations. Studies show that robust evaluations improve teacher quality and benefit kids. And of course every parent wants to know how well their childs teacher is doing. But when we try to have that public conversation, the focus somehow turns to educators challenges things like managing classroom time and administering standardized tests rather than whats best for student achievement.

We Get Caught Up in Crazy Debates That Distract

Theres an argument common to those who apologize for the sad state of American public schools today, and thats poverty. Sure, poverty matters. It would be ridiculous to say otherwise. But its a distraction to use poverty as a scapegoat and, until its solved, refuse to discuss how to improve failing schools and refuse to address the low achievement levels among poor and minority students. Just because a solution wont fix every single problem our kids face doesnt mean we should give up trying. I know that every child has the ability to achieve at high levels regardless of their background, and thats solely where organizations like StudentsFirst should focus.

Adult-Focused Political Lobbying Organizations Have a Stranglehold on Education

If ever there was an indicator that American public education is an industry, just look to the lobbying organizations that control education policy. Teachers' unions spend incredible amounts of money on politics. In California alone, the California Teachers Association spends tens of millions of dollars a year on lobbying and political campaigns far more than any other industry including big oil, according to the LA Times. The Common Core is an illustration of this political power. Despite 45 states helping to write the standards and voluntarily adopting them, their implementation has been hijacked by unions urging lawmakers to turn back and undo all of the progress that has been made. Politicians fear getting on the wrong side of the unions (and the resulting loss of campaign financial support) so they give in. Kids pay the price

Reform is Working

Were seeing that reform works. On a variety of recent assessments, we have seen an uptick in achievement for kids in D.C. and Tennessee. Results of the 2013 biannual NAEP test known as The Nations Report Card and considered the gold standard of assessments showed that while the rest of the countrys performance was relatively flat, students in D.C. and Tennessee posted historic gains. Their gains on the four assessments 4th and 8th grade reading and math were larger in total than any state in the last decade. And those gains were across the board; low-income, African-American and Hispanic kids all made significant progress. President Obama even called out those states in his State of the Union speech earlier this year.

Change is Happening Far Too Slowly

While were seeing some positive changes in statehouses toward reforming public education with a focus on students, its happening far too slowly. It takes legislative sessions and election cycles and years of handwringing just to make incremental changes. There are proven, results-driven improvements we can make right now. Why are we waiting? Even in cases where significant progress is made, its too easily rewound; in New York City the new mayor is working to roll back the progress his predecessor, Mike Bloomberg, made in giving parents and students the power to seek out the learning environment best for them by growing a network of charter schools.

It may sound callous to refer to a well-educated population as a product. But how can our nation expect to solve any major challenge whether fixing education, creating jobs, or expanding health care if we cant focus on the outcome we want in the first place?

Those of us who care about American public schools have a responsibility to focus on delivering a great education for all students. But right now, were distracted.


Tags

jrDiscussion - desc
[]
 
Robert in Ohio
Professor Guide
link   seeder  Robert in Ohio    12 years ago

I have seeded and read numerous articles regarding the state of education in the U.S., what is wrong with the system and what can and needs to be done to return the U.S. education system to its former position as the world leader in quality education.

There are many opinions on what is wrong with education and how it can be fixed and Michelle Rhee as an opinion which is worth considering as we pressure our elected officials to formulate and execute the reforms that are needed.

One line in the article read particularly true to me

Decisions that affect our public schools are too often made based on the desires of adults rather than the needs of kids.

There is more emphasis and posturing for political positioning than real effort towards reform from all parties involved and from the media talking heads.

 
 
 
jennilee
Freshman Silent
link   jennilee    12 years ago
Kids need to learn the basics of reading, writing, and math in a safe environment, taught by people who understand how children learn. You are correct in saying that the emphasis has gotten to be on what the teachers need, what the admins want, and how to satisfy every but the child. Time to go back old school because these new ways sure aren't giving us any quality education.
 
 
 
jennilee
Freshman Silent
link   jennilee    12 years ago
And I need to learn to proof-read before I hit reply!
 
 
 
Petey Coober
Freshman Silent
link   Petey Coober    12 years ago

In California alone, the California Teachers Association spends tens of millions of dollars a year on lobbying and political campaigns far more than any other industry including big oil

That's sick . Dems are perpetually bellyaching about big oil . But look who the real pigs are ...

 
 
 
Broliver "TheSquirrel" Stagnasty
Freshman Silent
link   Broliver "TheSquirrel" Stagnasty    12 years ago

Too Much attention goes to things that are totally outside the students experience. I would posit that so much attention is focused on whether teachers are unionized or not is quite the distraction. Every day, it seems, there is a new story about the so called harm that teachers unions are doing to the country. All of this hand wringing over what is really a very small percentage of teachers performing below standards, and that causes the unions to be in the news also, just to remind people that teachers have one of the hardest jobs and quite often for too little pay.

So yes, we are distracted from the actual job of teaching our youth by the constant attacks on teachers.

Sometimes I wish that every person in the US had an obligatory term as a teacher so that they could see how difficult it really is and appreciate just how many hours a day a teacher puts towards educating our children. I think then maybe some of this bullshit would quiet down.

Do it! Go out and teach! If you survive the first week, think about what we are asking our teachers to perform every day that they work.

 
 
 
Perrie Halpern R.A.
Professor Guide
link   Perrie Halpern R.A.    12 years ago

Sometimes I wish that every person in the US had an obligatory term as a teacher so that they could see how difficult it really is and appreciate just how many hours a day a teacher puts towards educating our children. I think then maybe some of this bullshit would quiet down.

Do it! Go out and teach! If you survive the first week, think about what we are asking our teachers to perform every day that they work.

Bravo Brolly!!!

 
 
 
Robert in Ohio
Professor Guide
link   seeder  Robert in Ohio    12 years ago

jennilee

Thanks for the feedback and the perspective on this important issue.

I am not so sure that the emphasis has totally shifted to what the teachers want and need as much as the emphasis has shifted to making education a political football that is moved up and down the field by both teams (parties) with no intention of scoring but rather with a desire to get the crowd yelling and to get as much camera time as possible without really having to do anything.

Thanks again for the feedback

 
 
 
Robert in Ohio
Professor Guide
link   seeder  Robert in Ohio    12 years ago

jennilee

Your point of view was clear

 
 
 
Robert in Ohio
Professor Guide
link   seeder  Robert in Ohio    12 years ago

Petey

So worse than many other special interest groups but a clear indication of the point f the story

Thanks for the perspective

 
 
 
Robert in Ohio
Professor Guide
link   seeder  Robert in Ohio    12 years ago

Broliver

I totally agree that teachers' unions are not the only or even the major problem with our declining education system.

Any parent who is not serving as a teacher (or at t east a teaching assistant) at home with the same focus and vigor they provide to their "real job" is not much of a parent in my view. A key problem with our education process f late, in my view, is declining parental involvement.

This is not a we (public) versus them (teachers) situation and shouldn't be portrayed as such but either side, it must be a cooperative effort or it does not work. Teachers' union are neither the problem nor the solution to the crisis we face, but merely a factor in the process, just as new funding strategies for education are a factor, better preparation for our teachers is a factor, other factors include a more appealing career path to retain the best teachers, an evaluation process that allows for the elimination of poor performing teachers (tenure be dammed), parental involvement and improved resources for the children and the teachers.

Appreciate your perspective

 
 
 
Robert in Ohio
Professor Guide
link   seeder  Robert in Ohio    12 years ago

Perrie

You echo a very good point made by Broliver

I have been a teacher/instructor of children and adults and neither is easy and those that excel at it and stay with it are valuable assets to our society.

 
 
 
screminmimi
Freshman Silent
link   screminmimi    12 years ago

Want to know what is wrong with our education system? It's simple... TRYING TO FIX WHAT WASN'T BROKEN IN THE FIRST PLACE! It started with replacing phonics with "whole word" reading and went down hill from there. "New Math" was next. In some schools in the South, "Shurley English" replaced standard English. Every time someone gets a wild hair and wants to play with education, the asinine fools in Congress at the federal level and the idiots at state level say, "How much are you donating to have your idea/name bandied about? Okay, we'll change it!"

This is what happened when a father tried to help his son with math homework. It has gone viral. It concerns Common Core. Please read:

http://l.yimg.com/os/publish-images/lifestyles/2014-03-25/8ef7c930-b44a-11e3-84f5-9547b2943d40_commoncorephoto.png" /> Facebook/The Patriot Post A Facebook update from a father frustrated with the Common Core math program at his son's school is making the Internet rounds after the father Jeff Severt expressed (via what looks like a kid's homework assignment) how convoluted the teaching approach is.

The worksheet posted to Facebook shows the elaborate Common Core (CC) formula for solving a math problem (as opposed to the simple strategy of subtracting the smaller number from the larger one). It instructs the student to explain why a fictional kid named "Jack" should be using common core strategies to solve the problem: Jack used the number line below to solve 427 - 316. Find his error. Then write a letter to Jack telling him what he did right, and what he should do to fix his mistake.

Severt's response reads, Dear Jack, Dont feel bad. I have a Bachelor of Science Degree in Electronics Engineering, which included extensive study in differential equations and other higher math applications. Even I cannot explain the Common Core mathematics approach, nor get the answer correct. In the real world, simplification is valued over complication. Therefore, 427 - 316 = 111. The answer is solved in under 5 seconds 111. The process used is ridiculous and would result in termination if used. Sincerely, Frustrated Parent.

The Facebook post (which by Tuesday had generated 4,400 likes, 4,300 shares, and 700 comments debating the issue) coincides with news that on Monday, Indiana became the first state to formally withdraw from the Common Core standards.

 
 
 
Robert in Ohio
Professor Guide
link   seeder  Robert in Ohio    12 years ago

scremminmimi

Hard to argue that a primary problem we are facing in the decline in quality education and the struggle to reform and improve is

TRYING TO FIX WHAT WASN'T BROKEN IN THE FIRST PLACE!

Thanks for the feedback and perspective

 
 
 
screminmimi
Freshman Silent
link   screminmimi    12 years ago

Every time I try to put this into words, I get all tangled up in the explanation but,

when this country was a baby, 99% of the people were illiterate and couldn't do any math. Along came a handful of teachers. The "hand" was usually a small one, because though some teachers were male, the majority of them female.

These teachers came from prim, proper schools in very civilized situations to rough, uncouth territories and one room classrooms, where the students came in all sizes and ages. In cold weather, unless a parent designated a male child to arrive early and start the wood burning stove for her, the teacher had to haul in the wood and start the fire.

She usually lived alone in a small room attached to the school, she had left everything and everyone she had known all her life... yet she managed to teach these children, some of them already in their teens... who THEN went home and TAUGHT THEIR PARENTS how to read, write, and do basic math.

These small handful of teachers managed to educate, basically, the entire nation, using phonics, ABCs, basic math, and basic English... which is what people my age were taught when we started school, and which brought the US into being the greatest nation in the world.

WTH were doing in allowing every delusional conceited jackass who thought they knew a "better way" to come along and mess it up? When the scores of America's children started dropping, instead of trying more new ways, why didn't we go back to what worked? Instead of piling on more and more homework that is driving kids to drop out of school, leaving them with no time for breathing or recreation... why hasn't someone said, "BACK OFF!"

Why hasn't some freaking fool said, "Hey, it has been medically proven that adults have to have time during the day for breaks, it fries the brain if they don't have down time."

If a child/student has to get up at 5:30/6:00 in order to be at school for classes to start at 8:00... and rides a bus that doesn't get them home until 4:00/4:30... and has homework that doesn't get completed until 9:00 ... that child is an "employee" of the school/state for a total of 15 HOURS!

The number of school days has increased and now I'm hearing school boards want to increase them again. It's out of control.

 
 
 
Aeonpax
Freshman Silent
link   Aeonpax    12 years ago

Critiques on your post;

1) Please make the print smaller and in a white font color.

2) Next time you post a union bashing article, please state so. I hate wasting my time.

 
 
 
Robert in Ohio
Professor Guide
link   seeder  Robert in Ohio    12 years ago

A P

Regarding your critique

Skip my articles if you so choose, otherwise accept them as presented

Only the closed minded would see this as only a union-bashing article and perhaps if you read the comments I made about unions not being the only problem or even the biggest problem facing education in the U.S.

 
 
 
screminmimi
Freshman Silent
link   screminmimi    12 years ago

Aeon, who is your comment directed to?

 
 
 
Robert in Ohio
Professor Guide
link   seeder  Robert in Ohio    12 years ago

scremminmimi

Interesting historical perspective on the origins of effective education

I agree with the points about the origins of education

However, I disagree that homework is the motivating factor that leads to dropping out of school and as to the homework load - my three boys had significantly less homework than I did when in school and mu grandchildren have significantly less homework than their fathers did.

I also do not consider children to be employees of the of the school

Thanks a lot for the feedback and perspective

 
 
 
Aeonpax
Freshman Silent
link   Aeonpax    12 years ago

Awwwww, must I?

 
 
 
Larry Hampton
Professor Quiet
link   Larry Hampton    12 years ago

Too often we allow nonsensical approaches...

Bizarro Common Core kindergarten math homework stumps DAD WITH Ph.D.

Here is the latest in the never-ending litany of frighteningly stupid Common Core math worksheets. This one comes from the father of a kindergarten student in the Research Triangle area of North Carolina.

I have a Ph.D., and I have no idea what is supposed to be done with this homework assignment, the flummoxed father told The Daily Caller.

He sent the bizarre worksheet to TheDC on the condition of anonymity because he didnt want to risk having his child be the subject of any reprisals from school employees.

I can tell you that my five-year-old brought this home as kindergarten homework Thursday, he said. It was a single page worksheet, with the Dear Parent section stapled to the top.

The doctoral dad added that he did research some of the terms on the worksheet enough to know that K.OA.1 is Common Core language. (TheDCs cursory Google search of the term K.OA.1 brought up Kindergarten Common Core Math with the second hit.)

The baffled parent also noted that the subtraction stories worksheet is copyrighted by Houghton Mifflin.

I did consider that this was some sort of mistakethat is, the wrong instructions were attached to the worksheet, the kindergarten father told TheDC. But, notice, the headers seem to match.

The Ph.D.-holding dad also spied the apparently misspelled word transprancy [sic] just above the picture.

I have no idea what transprancy means, he observed. It is disturbing to think about how much thought goes into the curriculum. And by that, I dont mean how little thought, but just that: How much.

This math lesson such as it may be is just one more in the constantly burgeoning inventory of sad and hideous Common Core math problems.

Just this month, for example, Twitchy exposed a stupid, overly complicated set of Common Core math problems involving number bondsand so much more. Those problems were also being inflicted on kindergarteners. (RELATED: Heres PROOF that Common Core aims to make Americas children cry)

 
 
 
Robert in Ohio
Professor Guide
link   seeder  Robert in Ohio    12 years ago

Afraid so, skip the articles altogether or accept them as they come

 
 
 
Robert in Ohio
Professor Guide
link   seeder  Robert in Ohio    12 years ago

I ran across an intersting letter to the editor in the NYT which is relevant to the subject at hand

To the Editor:

Long ago, a wise second-grade teacher told me to leave my daughter alone to stop hovering and worrying, to just let her be. Among all the pieces of advice well-meaning people gave me over the years, that was unquestionably the best. Its advice more parents need to hear and need to take.

It is a given that all parents want what they see as best for their children. But now, especially in New York City, that natural desire has devolved into a battle to secure a spot in the schools that seem to have the best chance of hoisting children, rung by rung, up the ladder to the pinnacle: the Ivy League.

Parental involvement used to mean support for both the child and the school attending parent-teacher conferences and making cookies for P.T.A. bake sales. Everyone assumed that there were different spheres of influence; parents stayed home and educators ran schools.

But at some point parents began to see schools less as places for children to learn and grow and more as incubators for college applications, places for studding rsums with unusual sports (fencing rather than soccer), unusual instruments (French horn rather than violin), honors classes even for kids who cant handle them or dont want to. We have fallen prey to an epidemic of galloping expectations.

Singular parental demands are undermining the purposes of a foundational institution of our society. It is past time for parents to be reminded what education is: not a ladder to some far-off plateau of success, but a garden where each student is helped to flourish in her own way and develop in his own time.

 
 
 
Robert in Ohio
Professor Guide
link   seeder  Robert in Ohio    12 years ago

Larry

Like all other things, common core has positives and negatives

The concept of common core curriculum is sound, but to truly attain the goals the program has will require other changes and reforms of the education process and schools of the country.

Appreciate the perspective

 
 
 
Larry Hampton
Professor Quiet
link   Larry Hampton    12 years ago

Agreed.

Yet the very fact that something this assinine (per the example above) clearly demonstrates that curriculum is not being developed with a clear sense of direction, methodology, or expectations. The main goal seems to be to implement rediculous ideology ahead of proven results, regardless of the success.

 
 
 
Robert in Ohio
Professor Guide
link   seeder  Robert in Ohio    12 years ago

Larry

In my view, if the common core curriculum was implemented systematically as part of comprehensive education reform, which included (but was not limited to) newer. more modern facilities, technologically current equipment as resources, dedicated, professional, qualified and well compensated teachers and most of all involved parents and engaged students it would have a much higher chance for success

 
 
 
screminmimi
Freshman Silent
link   screminmimi    12 years ago

About Common Core:

Critics call the program a one-size-fits-all approach to learning that ignores cultural and individual differences. They also argue that not all students are ready to advance at the same time, that the CCs teaching methods overly complicate basic subjects, and that the program limits teachers from freely shaping their curricula. Another complaint: The program doesnt properly prepare students for the future according to retired University of Arkansas Professor Sandra Stotsky, CC founder Professor Jason Zimba admitted in March 2010 at a Massachusetts Board of Elementary and Secondary Education meeting that being prepared for college meant being ready for a nonselective two-year community college, not a selective four-year institution.

In December, an outspoken mother testified at the Arkansas Board of Education that the Common Core program overcomplicated simple math problems. As an example, she gave the board a basic fourth-grade division problem which CC requires students to solve by using 108 steps . And in November, a Tennessee teen criticized Common Core during a school board meeting, saying, "Somewhere our Founding Fathers are turning in their graves pleading, screaming, and trying to say to us that we teach to free minds." Videos of both speeches went viral.

 
 
 
Larry Hampton
Professor Quiet
link   Larry Hampton    12 years ago

Perhaps we will have to just agree to disagree. It just seems to me that no amount of teacher/parent involvement, or technology can make an overly-complicated-turd-of-a-math-lesson any more valuable.

" width="400" />e.

 
 
 
Robert in Ohio
Professor Guide
link   seeder  Robert in Ohio    12 years ago

I checked out your link, it is the commentary of a single individual, hardly a thorough look at or general opinion about common core

But as you wish, I am content to agree to disagree and thank you for the feedback

 
 
 
Robert in Ohio
Professor Guide
link   seeder  Robert in Ohio    12 years ago

scremminmimi

I agree that one size fits all is seldom a solution in of itself for any problem or challenge.

But the ideology of the common core could be a basis for curriculum reform as part of overall education process and content reform. It is not the answer totally, but there are good reasons for a basic set of curriculum that all are taught and then freedom to add to that base should be given as well.

As always appreciate the feedback

 
 

Who is online




106 visitors