Tell Me Again, Why Did My Friends Die in Iraq? (opinion)
It was probably chilly that December day in Fallujah back in 2004. A man you probably never heard of, Lance Cpl. Franklin Swegeralong with thousands of Marines and soldierswas engaged in some of the worst combat since Vietnam.
"Everythings OK mom, dont worry about me," he told his mother two weeks before. "I think Im going to make it."
In less than ten days, the city would be for the most part, secure. Its residents would need years to rebuild after the destruction, and its children would see an astronomical rise in birth defects and other abnormalities.
But for Sweger, Dec. 16 would be the last day to fight. "He was the one who was kicking in the doors and going in first," his father Frank Sweger told MySanAntonio.com.
Along with his infantry platoon from 1st Battalion 3rd Marines, he was going house-to-house, kicking in doors as he had likely done since the battle had started on Nov. 7. But as he entered one room, friends told me later, he was shot and killed by an insurgent lying in wait.
He was on his last deployment and would've gone on to college. He was funny, a good person, and just 24 years old. Why did he die? .... - http://www.slate.com/blogs/business_insider/2014/01/04/why_did_we_invade_iraq.html
~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~
Lance Corporal Franklin Sweger died with 100 of his fellow solders who were killed along with 600 wounded and an estimated 800 Iraqi civilian deaths, for George Bush, the neocons and the corporations in their quest for OIL.
In January, 2014, ABCs Diane Sawyer announced t he Iraq War was aboutcreating a future .
A short time after, ABC correspondent Terry Moran continued that theme, explaining that "after a decade of US-led war to plant democracy in Iraq , much of Fallujah has now fallen to Al-Qaeda." So we were there to plant democracy?
You will note how slowly the corporately owned MSM is trying to rewrite history.
No more War for Oil.
Tags
Who is online
106 visitors

Most wars are senseless and could have been avoided, this one SHOULD have been avoided.
I know first hand the devastation that war can leave. I have fought honoably for OUR country and would do it again in a heartbeat if OUR country were to ask me to.
I also find war offensive, but I find articles like this one just as offensive as war.....a Flag covered coffin of a soldier being used to protest the war.
just how are you any different than our government,....they use the soldier to fight the war and you use the soldiers Flag coverd coffinto protest the war.....
There is no justifying the 4489 Americans killed over 100,000 US wounded (not including allies) and the over 122,208 documented Iraqi citizens killed, as a result of apprehending Hussein.
And are they any better off today? That is debatable.
I have to agree. It is disrespectful of the dead who gave their lives for their country.
Still, this war was a waste of their lives. Young men who gave their lives for a lie.
There is always a lesson in the aftermath of all wars.
IMHO, the lesson of the Iraq war is that we have to measure the benefit versus the cost of having relationships with countries that fundamentally despise us. Most of the time, the cost outweighs the benefit.
Our relationship with most countries in that region was originally based upon our need for petroleum. There is still a great deal of oil beneath these countries, and many Western corporations stand to profit from extracting that energy. Our need, however, has diminished, mainly due to our own increase in reserves, and our continued drive for alternative fuels.
There's no need to gladhand these thugocratic dictatorships any longer. If you want to do business there, you should be doing so at your own risk.
Beyond the fact that this war was based on a lie... and the hundreds of young men and woman who died... by killing Saddam, what we did was create a power vacuum with Iran, since it was Saddam who kept them in check. Now we have an out of control Iran, no oil and no democracy building.
What a horrible waste of our young people.
But what a gain for Haliburton!
It is naive to think that oil, or energy, or resources is or was not worth fighting for.
I would stipulate that it is NO LONGER worth fighting for.
It is a pleasant illusion to use the word "corporation" in place of "me," to blame, unless you have sworn off using energy, or stopped buying or using products made or delivered using that energy.
Many people make statements about that through what they will no longer use or patronize, in order to reduce dependency. Collectively, they pale in comparison to the discovery of new reserves, and technology that reduces dependency.
Would they necessarily think that it was worth it, and is that judgement determined or affected by what YOU think?
"Worth", in any discussion is subjective; it is surely in the eye of the beholder. I have not experienced the loss of a family member in war, and I feel very fortunate about that. My empathy for families with losses runs deep. I cannot fathom their sense of loss. Was it worth it for them? It varies from family to family, war to war. I'd venture to guess that a great many who lost loved ones in Iraq would say that it was not worth it. Probably many, many more than in other wars.
I agree
Afghanistan isn't/wasn't worth it either.
Totally.
All wars are a waste of lives, but they are not based on lies. WWII, there were the realities that Hitler and Emperor gave us. There were no lies about death camps and the bombing of Pearl Harbor. We were defending the world's freedom and our own. This war was over oil, which we never got. Instead we got instability and a very dangerous Iran. It was hegemony at it's worst.
Iraq today; ( Thu Mar 20, 2014)
Special Report: Iraqi forces, images testify to atrocities in new fighting
Those whom are ultimately responsible for this human carnage, will pay for this...one way or another.
IMO, none of the ''wars'' after Korea were worth it. What did we accomplish in Nam, Beirut, through to the present wars? Nothing, but the loss of our men and women.
Jason,
I have no interest in acting in Syria. You ask what was wrong with killing Saddam? Saddam kept Iran in check. He kept them from going nuclear. Now we have to deal with fake deals that will lead to a nuclear Iran.
Tell Me Again, Why Did My Friends Die in Iraq?
It's simple , 2 reasons :
1] It provides a target for Al Qaeda attacks away from the US borders
2] S. Hussein was destabilizing the middle east and had to be deposed just to reestablish order for the region even if not for Iraq .
Says who? That conspiracy theory has been going around for years yet it has been disproved over and over.
...
There was no lie. But even if there was one, do you actually think we were going to let Hitler take over Europe, or Japan the East? The papers were covering the war well... so the public knew what was going on. I have actual copies of clippings from my mother in law. What we were suffering from was isolationism from WWI.If FDR didn't enter the war, the world we know today wouldn't exist.
I am not saying that Saddam was a nice man... he was a horror. But he did keep Iran in check. And because we had this need to make to him out, we have the Muslim Brotherhood in Iraq and a nearly nuclear Iran. It was a big fail.
And it was none of our business. After 9/11 we should have concentrated on Afghanistan. Maybe we would have accomplished something there. But as it stands now, that place is also going to go to hell in a handbasket the moment we leave. But at least we had a reason to be there... not like in Iraq.
I totally agree with you Kavika.
1. No.
Allegations of a link between Saddam Hussein and al-Qaeda were made by U.S. Government officials who claimed that a highly secretive relationship existed between former Iraqi President Saddam Hussein and the radical Islamist militant organization Al-Qaeda from 1992 to 2003, specifically through a series of meetings reportedly involving the Iraqi Intelligence Service (IIS). [1] In the lead up to the Iraq War , U.S. President George W. Bush alleged that Iraqi President Saddam Hussein and militant group al-Qaeda might conspire to launch terrorist attacks on the United States , [2] basing the administration's rationale for war , in part, on this allegation and others . The consensus of intelligence experts has been that these contacts never led to an operational relationship, and that consensus is backed up by reports from the independent 9/11 Commission and by declassified Defense Department reports [3] as well as by the Senate Select Committee on Intelligence , whose 2006 report of Phase II of its investigation into prewar intelligence reports concluded that there was no evidence of ties between Saddam Hussein and al-Qaeda. [4] Critics of the Bush Administration have said Bush was intentionally building a case for war with Iraq without regard to factual evidence. On April 29, 2007, former Director of Central Intelligence George Tenet said on 60 Minutes , "We could never verify that there was any Iraqi authority, direction and control, complicity with al-Qaeda for 9/11 or any operational act against America, period." [5]
2. Eh. Everything is destabilizing in the ME. We should have taken care of Afghanistan and cut our losses.
Try again . That's not what I said . What I did say is hard to dispute but that is no reason to throw up a distraction .Stop putting words in my mouth .
Some things are far worse than others . Are you aware that Hussein launched missile attacks on Israel ? The US was forced to intervene to prevent a nuclear attack in the middle east . Also attacking another oil sourcing country [Kuwait] was a MAJOR destabilization making other events minor by comparison .
''when all his democratic bills did not work''.
Please explain the following bills that did not work.
CCC, SSA, TVA, WPA, HOLC. to name just a few that seemed to work pretty well.
Well I thought so, too Kavika. But I wanted to address the reasons for getting into the war.
1. I don't understand the difference between your two statements. The word distraction was not in your first comment.
2. Yes I did know and so do a lot of other countries. Tell me, what do you think that Iran is going to do with the bomb? You want to see destabilization.. that will be a winner.
Huh ? Are you doing what you used to do with Dennis P. Mc ? Stop it this instant . Playing dumb will get you nowhere ... I know you too well to fall for it...
Your talent for distraction continues . What happens or doesn't with Iran has no bearing on the past events in Iraq.Nice try though .
Tarleton regarding comment:
"hippies"... ??? ... Dam that is dated.
HEY Tarleton!!! .... the 1960's was over 40 plus years ago in the last Century.
We now live in the 21st Century and it is 2014.
Umm.. excuse me... but maybe you are not expressing what you want to say well, and I am just asking for clarity in your statement. And yeah Rich, I wouldn't pull that chit on you, so why would you think that I would?
Presently, of course not. It's a done deal, the moment we went in and took out Saddam. Everything we or any other nation does, has it's fallout, and in this case, the fall out from not having a strong man in Iraq is a more dangerous Iran.
LoneRanger01, regarding post:
I would hope that anyone that serves our country, would think and discern the reasons why the governmentis asking them to invade another country and kill its citizens. Instead of just blindlyvolunteeringand going alongwith out any thought or consideration just because the Government asked.
I disagree, I find it infinitely more offensive whencivilian politician's used political power to lie and manipulate the country into a war of choice with no real national or defense interest at stake, but instead to aide their corporate cronies so that they canluxuriate in war profiteering, at the expense and abuse of our sons and daughters in the military; and the resulting flag draped coffins of their nefarious and dishonorable miss-use of our military are the real offense in that instance.
Those two things do not equate as exactly the same.
The Government uses the young in their criminal wars of choice to murder thousands of foreigners who were not a direct threat to national security; for war profiteering, and the result of their efforts are the broken and destroyed bodies of; tens of thousands of foreign nationals that our powerful military murdered andthosedead American young people in thoseflag draped coffins.
The exposure of those coffins show the terrible price of the corrupt Governments criminal war for profit, andthat to me is what I perceive as the real offense.
Gunny, regarding reply:
No.
It's not.
Showing the results that come about when politicians miss-lead and lie us into wars of choice for profit, is not a dishonor to our war dead, the dishonor happened when our military was abused by corrupt civilian politicians who miss-usedour valiant military's service for war profit instead of for national defense.
The results of such miss-use of the military is terrible and must be exposed and shown for what it is instead of hiding it away and pretending it did not happen.
What are you talking about?
I expressed an opinion about the article, correctly pointing out the dishonorable abuse of our valiant military by corrupt politicians for war profit. That is not a political leaning; being against corruption and war profiteering is non-partisan and patriotic.
As for your strange comment about "abusing their sacrifice" that makes no sense. I expressed my honest opinion on the topic, pointing out the real offense and abuse where it originated from (our corrupt war for profit politicians and the ~ Military Industrial Complex) the fact that I exercised my freedom of speech to advocate against the political crimes of war profiteering that got them and thousands of innocent foreign civilians murdered, is exactly what our brave military Women and Men sacrifice themselves for.
Freedom of speech and the right to your own opinion, I and many fellow Americans advocate to honor their sacrifice, by pointing out the wrong that was done to themso that people will not be fooled again into another war of choice for profit so that thousands more won't be sacrificedfor the benefit of a few morally depraved war profiteers.
That does not dishonor their sacrifice, on the contrary; itdoes the opposite.
OK , sorry . You are throwing out a distraction . Reread my comment . Here it is repeated :
1] It provides a target for Al Qaeda attacks away from the US borders
By having a shooting war to attract the Al Qaeda attacks they stopped trying to attack the US mainland . Clear ?
You said :
That is accurate BUT it doesn't matter . That was motivation [for public consumption ] to get us into the war .
Irregardless of the public spin the effects of the war were , as I said , to provide a red flag for the Al Qaeda bull to charge at in Iraq . But the US ass was untouched by these attacks ... OLE !
War is hell. War doesn't make any sense nor is war the best answer. War involves lying, treachery and evil; and honor, goodness and sacrifice.
It is naive to believe the the US hasn't seen this war coming for a long time, or to think that this war (Iraq is only one theater) is over. We've only scratched the surface; it will be many years yet before we see the end of Islamofascism.
Hell, no!
Gunny Said:
Ain't that the truth!
The lies that started WWII were told by Hitler.
It has fallen to the U.S. for many decades.
That's the problem in a nutshell. Nowhere in the US constitution does it state or imply that the US should be the "worlds policeman".
Even within moral boundaries of the "Just War" principles, it does state or imply that righting the worlds wrongs is a duty of free nations.
I'm stating that if you don't have anything intelligent to add, say nothing.
Kavika, regarding comment:
You're right those wars accomplished nothing, except for a tiny group of war profiteers that made obscene amounts of money from all that death and carnage.
The young soldier mentioned in this article was killed when he entered a dark building by the enemy hiding within.
Not long before we officially ended the Iraq war there was an article posted on MSNBC news along with a picture of the first war dogs going to Iraq. I had been questioning for some time why they had not been used ahead of vehicles to check for IEDs as they can sniff out explosives, and why they had not been used more heavily in clearing dwellings; we seemed to be losing so many the way the young man in this story was lost.
Then I read that Muslims do not like working with dogs; Islam views them as "unclean" and while they are okay to hang around and clean up garbage they are not the beloved companions and pets and partners other countries view them. It's one reason you can hear Muslims refer to us as "infidel dogs."
Therefore, war dogs were scarce to none in theatre in Iraq because of this aversion.
I didn't post this with the intention to debate anyone as to whether war dogs were used in Iraq or whether they are being used in Afghanistan.I am repeating here what I read in a news article; the article was accompanied by a huge color photo of military men in uniform loading German Shepherds onto a plane.
I am still not clear about your meaning. If you are saying thatAl Qaeda was distracted by the war and therefore not operative here in the US, then you would still be wrong. During that period, they were not only operative in the US (they tried to take down several planes at once, but the plot was foiled) but they also did the UK and Madrid bombings. We were just lucky and had good intel.
Dennis,
Spot on.
Gene,
So did my uncle, who worked his whole life as a Marine and in intelligence, and back in the day, there was a limit on what anyone knew, since most of the stuff was restricted or redacted. Still, after working there for a long time, from what he read, it wasn't true.
I guess we will have to agree to disagree.
I have to agree with Gunny on this. It is the dead and the family of the dead that feelings should be considered, and they find it disrespectful. I was against the war, but I am also against using the dead to make a point.
Is that what the US is fighting for? To curb or destroy Islamofascism? Hmmm, here all along I thought the US Military was fighting for the corporations and oil.
The US military serves the US constitution; and, yes, greed and avarice have always grabbed onto coat-tails when the opportunity presents itself. However, if we think that not fighting for protection of interests and rescources is a credible course, Imho we are only fooling ourselves, and our enemies are grateful.
I didn't say they weren't operative here . I said they were distracted . The main manpower of Al Qaeda has been involved with Iraq . The numbers attempting attacks in the US was greatly reduced .
Petey,
Or we got better at early detection. There is no way to know this for sure, either way.
I would say both happened . And the combination has greatly reduced successful mainland US attacks [ to zero ?] .
I agree Jason . In fifty years when things settle out in Iraq there may end up being a vast change to their political & social landscape ... but not next month & not next year .
All this nonsense about what we're fighting for is BS. The military doesn't declare war, congress does. They (congress) can say what ever they want, regarding why we are fighting.
There are two, and only two reason that the grunt is fighting. One, he is fighting for his life. Two, he is fighting for his buddies. IMO, they don't give a shit about the politicians reason, mom, apple pie or any nonsense that the politicians come up with. Or what the American public believes they are fighting for.
You don't let your buddies down, you cover their six. PERIOD. You don't leave anyone behind. That is a rule, burned in your mind. You owe only them. You owe nothing to the politicians and there ilk.
This is what it's like, and why you don't leave anyone behind. Even at the cost of your own life.
Fuck the rest of the bullshit.
Gunny, regarding reply:
What are you saying Gunny? .... that all veterans think alike and have the exact same opinion and that you are the representative spokes person that has been assigned to tell the world that all veterans think like you do and so have your exact opinion on the matter?
I've had family and people that I have met that were combat veterans from WW2 to korea to Vietnam to Iraq to Afghanistan, and in my conversations with them I have found a variety of opinions and thoughts on the subject of war and their experiences in combat.
Like the rest of the population veterans have differences of opinions, that's why we had the Veterans against the War organization protesting the Vietnam war and it is no different today.
I would venture to say that most veterans would be dishonored and offended to understand the manipulation and abuse of their service by the Government that sent them into harms way with thelies and betrayalthat over paid crony capitalist politicians perpetrated against themshilling for the oil corporations andwar profiteers.
Gunny, regarding comment:
And for those that lost friends and loved ones who were manipulated into fighting for a lie just to line the pockets of the profiteering warmongers betrayal leaves a bitter sad flavor that the apologist for the corrupt will never know.
Gunny, regarding your dumb name calling:
Really ..... dullstarone?
Sad thing is you probably think you're being clever and don't realize how dumb it is and how it contributes nothing to the discussion.
Westborw? ..... that comment is even less credible and dumber then your childish name calling.
The Westboro fanatics protest against the fallen because according to them GOD had them killed because he hates as they say (please excuse the slur) "Fags"
How does that equate with what I posted?
Is there a problem with your cognitive function or do you have a reading comprehension problem.
I will restate my opinion to help you understand:
The real dishonor that the fallen suffer originated when their service was abused by corrupt government officials in powerwithmanipulative fear mongering lies and distortions of truth,with the intentto line the pockets of the war profiteering contractors and oil corporations at the expense of those that serve and the foreign nationals whose land we invaded and bombed based on immoral Greed for profit.
And that you are not despite what you may believe the spokesperson for all veterans because they all think and have the same exact opinion that you do.
Pointing out the truthis not a dishonor to their memory nor is it the same as what the Westboro fanatics say in their demonstrations.
I stand by what I said and I completely reject your characterization.
AeonPax, regarding article:
Thank you AeonPax and my thumbs up for your truthfularticle.
And thank you Justice For Trayvon&Jordon for your kind words.
This might be an excellent comment BUT since you have proven yourself to be ahistoric on numerous past occasions I suspect the same lack of knowledge applies here as well . However , feel free to expand on your comment . I await your proof that you actually know something besides your own opinions & the talking points they arose from .
Gunny,regarding reply:
Translation:
I disagree with your replies and I can't disprove them with valid points of my own so, I will respond by calling you a childish name.
"If you curse our honored dead by using them as political tool then you are no better than those of Westboro."
You characterization of what I said is a distorted and out of context misrepresentation ofwhat I said and meant.
Of course I do it is my opinion and you failed to prove me wrong and so by default I would naturally stand by what I said.
Oh Pu-Leeez ... you can't even prove your own point or even understand my point.
Don't thank me, you did it to yourself.
Gunny, regarding reply:
You're repeating your self Gunny, what's the matter ran out of things to say.
Gunny, regarding reply:
Hey don't blame me for your lame postings, it's all you.
Petey Coober, regarding comment:
You know Petey,in the last dozen orso times that you have posted to me you have repeated the same thing about me not knowing history and you follow that up with off topic personal insults and name calling, which I don't mind because for me it is not as big a deal as it is for you, and I understand that you have this childish notion that no one can disagree with you.
But you have become tiresome and boring because you just repeated the same thing over and over, you bring nothing interesting or new to the table and so intellectually speaking the exchanges with you have become as I said, irrelevant, boring and not worth the bother.
Since you have no real points to make beyond your talking point dribble and your obsessive need to engage me with a back and fourth out of some sort of childish grudge because of your inability to accept that not everyone will think like you,
I've decided to let you go and so this will be my last communication to you from this point on I will ignore you.
I'm sorry butyou just aren't that interesting, but not to worry I'm sure you'll find someone else to obsess over and give your sad life some excitement.
buh bye ... Petey
Exactly, and fuck Rumsfeld for criticizing current foreign policy, fuck you Donald!!!!!!!!!!!!!! you fucking failure loser!
Gunny, regarding bazzar comment:
Why would I feel shame when you post lame comments?
That is a very strange thing to say, are you all right?
Do you take meds?
Bf,
"My country right or wrong is like saying; My mother, drunk or sober." - G.K.Chesterton
That only works when a commander in chief (and his staff) are telling the truth.
And where, pray tell, in the US Constitution does it give congress the right to declare war based on lies? Besides, Iraq was NOT a "declared war."
Where does theConstitution say a war must be about "truth" ?
And where, pray tell, in the US Constitution does it say war must be based on the truth?
''Iraq was NOT a declared war''. Yet, there we were., like many wars before it.
I'm sure it means a great deal to the WIA, KIA and those that survived, that it wasn't a ''declared war''. /s
So which CiC (and staff) have ever told the truth? Who's truth, your's? Mine?Politics and politicians by their very nature, are built on deception and ruse. We pay them to do exactly that, even though we fret and complain about it.
Your understanding seems to not include the English language . I clearly asked for you to expand on your comment ... but did you ? No . Instead you chose the childish tit-for-tat road . Thanks for once again clearly demonstrating that no one is home in the "brightstar" head ...
Nice dodge, YOU were the one who made the point only congress can declare war and yet there was no war declared. Bringing up the US victims of war is not an answer.
Bush/Cheney were behind lying about the grounds for an invasion of Iraq which caused the casualties you mentioned. The US service personnel fulfilled their oaths which is noble and honorable. Lying about the cause of that war is immoral.
It was a "UN action" which the US agreed to by treaty.
First off, I don't dodge anything. Next, if you going to highlight my comments, don't take them from two different comments, and string them together.
You seemed to have missed my point. I didn't say that any war that was declared, or not declared, was valid. What I pointed out, was that no matter what the politicians say, it's the grunts that suffer the concequences, not the policiticans.
''Bringing up the US victims of war is not an answer''. You are correct, it isn't an answer, what it is, is a reminder of what war does, whether declared or not declared. If you have survived, you have to live with the aftermath, not the politicians or the general public that weren't there.
As for Bush/Cheney lying, remember most all politicians supported it, both dems and repubs. Even the ones on the ''Intelligence committe''...
If you want to point out politicians that have lied, you can go back to Spanish, American war. Or LBJ and Vietnam. Bush/Cheney are nothing new in that.
No.
You have a delightfully obscure or perplexing way of stating that.
Points;
1) At issue here is not lying politicians... (they all lie)
2) ...nor is it past wars based on lies.
3) The topic is the criminal lies that lead up to the needless deaths, wounded and suffering brought to US service people and their families plus innocent Iraqi citizens. Bush and Cheney should have been tried for crimes against humanity and the constitution.
4) Obama's defense of the immoral invasion of Iraq makes him just as culpable as Bush/Cheney. There are dozens of ways Obama could have deflected the (true) charge of hypocrisy from Putin, without justifying the bloody lies that made the Iraq war, a criminal enterprise.
5} There's a saying; "If a million people believe a foolish thing, it is still, a foolish thing."
dennis smith, regarding comments:
CIA and Military personal began our involvement in Vietnam during the Eisenhower administration, JFK was going to pull out the CIA and U.S. militaryadvisors to disengage from Vietnam, not long after putting thoseorders in place, JFKwas assassinated.
Then LBJ reversed Kennedys plans to pull out of Vietnam and started to make war profiteering preparations. The Gulf in Tonken resolution was base on the lie that the nearly non existent Vietnamese navy attacked the super power navy of the United States.
Thus began the criminal war for profit in Vietnam, resulting in the deaths of nearly 60,000 American Military personal and the wounding and disfigurement of many more and the deaths of millions of innocent Vietnamese Civilians and wounding and disfigurement of many more.
All because of respectable suit and tie wearing psychopaths in Washington who operated on the depraved morality that murdering and torturing human-beings for profit is justified as long as money was made.
So did Johnson, he got approval from both sides to go to war in Vietnam.
Gunny, regarding question:
Can't say with exact certainty, the exact reason or reasons of JFK's assassination. But I do know that the lone gunman and the magic bullet theories are false and I do know their was some conspiracy, unfortunately the conspirators covered their tracks and it looks like the conspirators had thepower to manipulate the Government, Media Information, Law Enforcement etc....
So they got away with it.