Wash. mudslide kills 29; searchers seek survivors
" SEATTLE (AP) -- Rescue crews searched into the night for survivors from a massive mudslide in Washington state that killed at least three people, after hearing voices from the debris field pleading for help.
The slide of mud, trees and rocks happened about 11 a.m. Saturday morning. Several people - including an infant - were critically injured and at least six houses were destroyed.
Snohomish County Fire District 21 Chief Travis Hots said at a news briefing late Saturday that searchers weren't giving up on finding more people.
"We have people who are yelling for our help, and we are going to take extreme risks," Hots said.
It wasn't clear how many people might still be alive, he said.
"This is still a rescue mission until we determine otherwise," Hots said.
The slide also blocked the North Fork of the Stillaguamish River, which prompted an evacuation notice because water was rising rapidly behind the debris. Authorities worried about severe downstream flooding if water suddenly broke through the blockage.
The landslide also completely covered State Route 530 near the town of Oso, about 55 miles north of Seattle. It was at least 135 feet wide and 180 feet deep and hit just before 11 a.m., Snohomish County authorities said...."
http://mynorthwest.com/174/2479544/Deadly-Mudslide

Almost 200' feet deep of massive dirt landing on the road is deep !
I would think they would have a difficult time finding everyone in time. Here is an overview of the hillside that gave way.
Next is an: An aerial view of the Stillaguamish River leading up to the landslide, ...
My condolences to the family and friends of the victims; and I do hope they find survivors.
Is there no way a warning could have been given to these people to evacuate? Or was an evacuation ordered and they just tried to ride it out? People take such chances with their children sometimes.
Thank you for your kind thoughts, mimi. I hope they find more survivors, too.
You have an interesting thought; it does seem like there would have been some clues that the integrity of the ground was loosening or changing. To my knowledge, it was instantaneous. Flooding downstream is the concern now.
My cousin lives in Hawaii. His wife was so ticked off when they first moved there several decades ago because she wanted to build their house on the side of a cliff for the spectacular view. He told her no, he just didn't trust cliffs, even though at the time Hawaii was not experiencing a big problem with mud slides. He charters sight-seeing flights around the islands and wanted his home close to where his business was.
She is now grateful he won that battle. The sight she picked out crumbled and fell into the ocean two years ago after torrential rains when Hawaii began experiencing weather changes.
How fortunate they didn't live on that cliff!
There have been a lot of landslides here along the Puget Sound (and in the other west coast states). The soil composition is different in different areas, so I can see how some geologists might give the Ok at times, but as you point out, saturation and erosion happens. In some cases, the land is grandfathered for construction, before studies were performed; people tear down the old cabin or storage building and build new (tho, they have to follow current regulation for staying away from the bank or water of any source, and have to maintain their bank if they have one. The property owner is forced to keep a valid bank account on file with a specified amount in it for the government so that if the owner fails to maintain their bank for erosion control, the Gov will automatically deduct the fine!! I can understand charging the owner a fine, but not being forced to maintain a bank account for their access. They expect to access the homeowners property at will, and make deductions using their own assessments. Unbelievable they can get away with that. I know this, because it's the reason why I chose not to build on a piece of property I owned).
I *think* the people in the report might have been in a plateau area of the hill and the land they built on gave way. I'm not certain.
In my area, there are several contractors that cleared hills with beautiful distant views, and put in developments with 5 acre parcels, bulldozed plateaus for construction sites with good drainage and community gray water systems, and followed recommended erosion controls. It rains a lot here. I wonder what is eventually going to happen.
mimi and anyone else that might be interested - here's an update. The situation is getting worse. It appears "neighborhoods" are involved and have "quicksand" like conditions, making it impossible to help people trapped in their homes. Water from the river must be spilling into all of that mud. It said the part of the slide that is damning up the river is rising at two feet an hour..omg! Do these people have to be buried alive? There must be a way to save them.
"
What a horrible thing to have happen. The latest news said the the danger from the river is subsiding.
I hope that they, by whatever means can get more survivors out, if there are any.
Thank you, Kavika! Oh me, too.
It said helicopters would fly over to see if anyone made it past the mud. It's too bad they aren't able to use them in some other way as well---landing on or hovering over houses' roofs or something to check for survivors.
I'll look for another update.
Sunday update from same source about blocked river:
" Inslee said there were no plans to move the debris blocking the river. "The river will find its way over the days and weeks to come," he said at a news briefing Sunday.
The National Weather Service in Seattle said Sunday afternoon that water is clear as it flows through the new channel, indicating that "we can expect a steady release of water through the blockage rather than any sudden burst or rapid rise."
John Pennington from the Snohomish County Department of Emergency Management said the area where the slide occurred has a history of unstable land. He said a slide also happened there in 2006.
Authorities believe the slide was caused by ground water saturation from recent heavy rainfall.
David Montgomery, an earth and space sciences professor at University of Washington in Seattle, said these deep-seated slides tend to occur from rainfall over months or seasons. "It can raise the water table in a slope and that decrease its stability," he said. "This was a big deep one, a giant slump."
There may be many factors, but "the very wet month of March that we had is clearly a factor," he added. All that rain can raise the groundwater table in a slope and undermine its stability, he said.
The weather service's Brent Bower said Sunday about a quarter- or half-inch of rain is expected in the area Monday night and Tuesday. "It'll make things messy but it's not going to affect the river much," he said."
Mudslides are really bad news . This is not something to be near when it let go .
Definitely! When it first happened, there were people trapped in the massive 180' pile of dirt, trees and rocks. You can see it piled up on the road in the background:
How scary!!
Read this morning that a few years ago a report had been commissioned by theStillaguamish tribe there on the impact that the building on that mountain side would have on the salmon in the river should it give way, because they had ancestral fishing and hunting rights there.
The report's opinion was that the homes were in danger and there were three options. One was to move the course of the river 500 feet; one was to move the course of the river 2,000 feet; one was to move the homes.
It seems as though the deaths, the tragedies, could have been prevented. The article I read did not go into any reasons why nothing was done.
Here's another of the same area:
Too much rain here!
Egilman, thank you for the slide info and updates!
People do it - take big chances. I almost did it in 2004. Then someone that came in after me took advantage of all of the permits and site plans I had in place and built. It was only 50' up, but the eroding bank was obvious (and it was geologist approved -saying it was happening slow enough that a few more centuries would likely still be able to use it - but will the rains increase, was my concern).
It was my understanding the Indians wanted the study done because they were concerned all the building on top was going to impact the load; combining that with the storms and rainfall the slide would not be a gradual thing as nature intended but a sudden massive avalanche that would dam the river and disrupt the salmon fishing which was guaranteed to them, as well as hunting rights on the mountain which would disappear along with the game when the mountainside fell into the river.
The developers overbuilt the top of the mountain.. at least that's what I got out of it. The river could have been diverted to protect the salmon but evidently nothing was done (probably the cost was too prohibitive for the sake of a tribe of Indians) and most likely the homeowners were not informed (I'm just guessing here) of the danger. Or maybe they thought they had more time to do something. The study was done in 2004, I think.
Exactly what the tribes feared - happened, didn't it. I think that was a travesty that their requests weren't met to protect their rights. As I mentioned, it was known that the river was undercutting the hillside causing instability above - that factor alone should have prevented construction.
This is such a tragedy. My condolences to all that lost loved ones.
Thank you, tzia. Mine as well.
This is sort of reminiscent of people who build their million dollar homes in areas clearly marked as fire prone.
lol... that happens in some areas here, too, and a lot in California.