╌>

Firing Teachers: Mission Impossible

  

Category:  News & Politics

Via:  robert-in-ohio  •  12 years ago  •  26 comments

Firing Teachers:  Mission Impossible

A very interesting article about an important aspect of educational reform in the U.S.

Please get past the title and consider the issues raised in the article.

If theres one thing thats important to good schools, its good teachers. Thats the premise of a groundbreaking lawsuit now being heard in Los Angeles Supreme Court that challenges entrenched California state laws protecting the jobs of public school teachers who are grossly ineffective.

The nine student plaintiffs in Vergara vs. California argue that laws protecting even abysmally incompetent teachers violate the guaranteed civil right of the states children to access a decent education.

The outcome of the case could have big implications for New York. Despite the states highly visible new teacher evaluation law and a perception of radical change under the Bloomberg administration, a scandalous reality remains: Here, as in California, it is virtually impossible to dismiss a grossly ineffective teacher.

This is because the particularly crucial New York State law governing teacher dismissal, 3020-a, was left essentially untouched by both the contentious new teacher evaluation legislation and recent city reforms.

Under that law, only the state can dismiss a teacher and it rarely does.

I recently completed an in-depth study of a decade of official reports on the states dismissal hearings for New York City teachers. My analysis shows that the problem of extraordinary job protection for grossly ineffective teachers in New York is worse than many understand.

Even attempting to get the state to dismiss a teacher is prohibitively expensive and burdensome. According to the New York State School Boards Association, the average 3020-a proceeding for a single incompetent teacher extends for 830 days and costs taxpayers $313,000.

Over the 10-year period I studied (1997-2007), just 12 of New York City teachers (of whom there are 75,000 at any given time) were dismissed for incompetent teaching. Teachers who had years of unsatisfactory ratings; who were proven over months of hearings to be grossly incompetent; who were verbally and physically abusive to children, parents and colleagues, or who simply failed to come to work for days and weeks on end were returned to classrooms.

My analysis further reveals that the minimum level of teaching effectiveness required for tenured teachers to keep their jobs in New York City schools is defined not by the schools (much less parents and communities) but behind closed doors in arbitration proceedings controlled by the state.

In practice, teachers are dismissed only if they are proved to have been grossly ineffective and incorrigible, without even a remote possibility of improving. That is, the operative state standard for returning a teacher to the classroom is not demonstrated effectiveness, but a teachers potential capacity to be even marginally competent in the future.

The new state evaluation law, currently wrapped up in debate over the Common Core standards, is supposed to change this by making it far easier to fire teachers who are rated ineffective two years in a row.

But in the first year of the new evaluation system, just 1% of teachers received that rating. And all dismissals will still go through 3020-a, which makes removal almost impossible.

The vast majority of New York Citys teachers are responsible, effective and hardworking, and the problem of grossly ineffective teachers is often dismissed as just a few bad apples. Yet if even just 1% of the citys teachers are ineffective, then over 10,000 students in New York City have an ineffective teacher every day.

New York Citys new chancellor, Carmen Faria, knows that removing ineffective teachers is essential to creating good schools. While serving as principal of PS 6 on Manhattans Upper East Side in the 1990s, she replaced 80% of the schools teaching staff not by dismissing them, which is illegal under state law, but by persuading them to leave, usually for positions in other, less-demanding schools.

Ironically, as New York Citys schools chancellor, she now has no formal power to replace even one teacher.

This a crucial educational equity issue. A child assigned to the classroom of a grossly ineffective teacher is denied the opportunity for the sound, basic education guaranteed by the New York constitution.

New Yorks laws should be ensuring that all children have effective teachers, not making it impossible to cut loose those who are incompetent, indifferent or even abusive.

Lets hope Vergara prevails in California. And lets overturn dysfunctional New York State laws that protect ineffective teachers jobs at the expense of children and the public schools.

( Published as an Op-Ed in the New York Daily News: http://nydn.us/1fnQfns )


Tags

jrDiscussion - desc
[]
 
Robert in Ohio
Professor Guide
link   seeder  Robert in Ohio    12 years ago

I am a staunch supporter of education (pre-K, Kindergarten, public schools, charter schools, private schools, church schools, vocational schools, technical post secondary institutions, colleges, universities, community colleges, on-line educational opportunities and any other types I have missed). I have three sons and three grandchildren that have all gone to public schools and state colleges (one not old enough yet) and they are all doing well. I am retired now and find great satisfaction in helping out at the local Jr/Sr High as a tutor and mentor in our village now that I am retired and have a lot of spare time.

I am also very aware of the failings of the education system in our state and country and the need for reform and do not for one minute think that all of the problems are caused by the teachers or the teachers union. I personally think that the failure of parents to be properly and aggressively involved in their childrens education is the primary reason for the downward spiral fo the American school systems.

All of that being said, when I came across the story above I was not surprised at the information provided but it is a reality that is part of the problem one that must be dealt with. I have great memories of my time in school and remained in contact with a couple of teachers that changed my life for over forty years after I graduated because they were still a source of good advice and knowledge well into my later life.

I am not bashing and no one should bash teachers with a broad brush, but this story highlights the need for real reform in the way teachers are evaluated, retained and promoted and most importantly how the teachers who are mis-suited for the career field are moved out of it.

 
 
 
screminmimi
Freshman Silent
link   screminmimi    12 years ago

Nothing illustrates the difficulty of getting rid of teachers that absolutely need to go more than the story that came out last year of the male teacher who was accused by several female students of inappropriate touching and sexual harassment. He received probation by the courts.

Through some sort of convoluted process involving the teacher's union, the man, who was less than a year from retirement and receiving his pension, was allowed to show up at an empty classroom for the remainder of the school year, sit there and read a book all day, then go home, which fulfilled the requirement he needed to retire at the end of that school year and draw his pension off the taxpayers for the rest of his life, including free medical insurance.

 
 
 
Broliver "TheSquirrel" Stagnasty
Freshman Silent
link   Broliver "TheSquirrel" Stagnasty    12 years ago

Where was this?

 
 
 
Aeonpax
Freshman Silent
link   Aeonpax    12 years ago

When I still lived in Milwaukee, I was 19 and had a daughter entering 1st grade public school. Milwaukee Public Schools or MPS. That's how I got my start battling teachers, principals and educational bureaucrats.

 
 
 
screminmimi
Freshman Silent
link   screminmimi    12 years ago

I don't remember, Brolly. There was a spate of stories about such teachers and the problems of getting rid of them last year when there was a teacher strike in one of the major areas, and then in another area... New York, maybe Chicago?.. there was talk about firing a bunch of teachers because students had performed poorly, and it sparked stories such as this.

Another story came to light about a teacher who had tied a Special Ed student to a chair and struck him and instead of being fired was merely transferred to another district where he, too, was allowed to just show up to a classroom and catalogue a private library for someone.

It seems no matter what teachers do, they never really receive punishment, they just get transferred... sort of like the catholic priests when they were caught abusing children.

 
 
 
Broliver "TheSquirrel" Stagnasty
Freshman Silent
link   Broliver "TheSquirrel" Stagnasty    12 years ago

In the first case, the district may have looked at the cost of firing the man and the cost of just letting him serve out his time till he retired and decided that the latter was cheaper.

Also, when allegations of inappropriate touching or anything such as sexual harassment are leveled at anybody, We must be careful not to damn them before the courts have heard the case and made a decision. IF he got probation, then it was probably determined that his infractions were not serious enough to merit jail time, or there was just not enough evidence to convict him so the DA gave him a plea deal. Either way the situation was adjudicated.

I have seen cases that were eventually thrown out that the accused never recovered from.

 
 
 
Robert in Ohio
Professor Guide
link   seeder  Robert in Ohio    12 years ago

Wow

That is beyond reason

I am going to try and find that story

Thanks for the tip

 
 
 
Robert in Ohio
Professor Guide
link   seeder  Robert in Ohio    12 years ago

Broliver

In the first case - do you think that is a reasonably effective and appropriate approach to the issue. What should the cutoff be - 1 year till retirement, 2 years , 10 years...

I agree that there is room to argue about whether jail time is deserved but there is no way the teacher should not have been fired. That type of behavior is not desirable in those teaching our children is it?

 
 
 
Robert in Ohio
Professor Guide
link   seeder  Robert in Ohio    12 years ago

A P

I also lived near Milwaukee, just north of the city for awhile, and remember a lot of parents being concerned with the state of the schools in the city.

I also remember the stark differences between schools downtown and in the suburbs.

But that is not totally the point, because I also knew a handful of teachers some that worked downtown and some that worked out in the burbs and the most dedicated and best teachers (IMHO) were those working downtown.

Keeping good teachers and getting rid of bad teachers seems a logical approach to me

 
 
 
Aeonpax
Freshman Silent
link   Aeonpax    12 years ago

My battle(s) had a a lot to do with ineffective and marginal teachers. WEAC or the Wisconsin Education Association Council, goes out of they way to protect such teachers.

 
 
 
96WS6
Junior Silent
link   96WS6    12 years ago

Sorry, the Union forbids the firing of teachers no matter how horrific they are.

 
 
 
Robert in Ohio
Professor Guide
link   seeder  Robert in Ohio    12 years ago

96

Well forbid is a strong word, but I agree that they are seldom supportive of the removal of a teacher (even if the term is loosely applied to someone)

Smile.gif

 
 
 
Robert in Ohio
Professor Guide
link   seeder  Robert in Ohio    12 years ago

A P

My boys were already in college (and beyond) but I heard similar stories from colleagues at work

 
 
 
screminmimi
Freshman Silent
link   screminmimi    12 years ago

For a while there were a lot of stories on the Internet about abusive teachers that had been secretly video taped in classes. There had been students who had reported abuses to parents, parents who had gone to administration and administration who had dismissed the allegations.

It all seemed to go back to the teachers union and the power it wielded, and the lack of ability to get a teacher who was guilty of actual criminal behavior out of a school, let alone a teacher who was incompetent. Many parents had gone to the local authorities about teacher incidents and were told they would have to take it up with the school. In the end, these parents had to just transfer their children, and in some cases, move.

 
 
 
Perrie Halpern R.A.
Professor Guide
link   Perrie Halpern R.A.    12 years ago

The issue here is the practice of tenure. A teacher is reviewed for at least 3 years in the NYC school system at which point they are granted tenure. Once this happens, a principal has a very hard time removing the teacher. Until 2010, when a teacher was removed, they were sent to "The Rubber Room", where they had to report everyday to do nothing, until their hearing. This process usually lasted about 2 years. Now, what is happening is that they closed the rubber rooms, and give them positions that don't involve children until their hearings. The system is flawed, but also, teachers can and are removed from the classroom for stupid reasons. It isn't just bad or incompetent teachers, but teachers who one child has made a complaint (usually of some sort of physical discipline) and is removed.

While I do agree that the system is broken, it isn't just the fault of the unions, but the practice of tenure. Teacher evaluation should be an on going process, but often it is plagued by politics of the area. In the NYC school system, evaluations should be based on administrative personnel, but often a small group of parents have more power.

In the rest of NYS schools, teachers are often fired long before tenure, since they find ways to hold up tenure. Again, depending on the school district, a small group of parents pressure the administration into action. Often this has nothing to do with how well the teacher is performing, but who they are, and often political.

If we are talking about making our schools places of excellence, then the whole system needs to be trashed. Tenure gone, evaluations done by a proper team trained to do this and on a regular basis, merit pay for teachers who go beyond the call of duty. That would be a good start.

 
 
 
Robert in Ohio
Professor Guide
link   seeder  Robert in Ohio    12 years ago

Perrie

As always thanks for your perspective

In this case expert perspective un my opinion

I agree 100% that the problem is not entirely because of the unions and that tenure itself versus annual evaluation and basically retaining your job through your performance

I also agree that most parts of the system need to be overhauled or replaced but doubt that we can simply blow it up and start over, so changes will need to be made in manageable chunks in order to fix the system.

I also agree that along with eliminating poor performers that superior performers need to be rewarded with bonuses, educational grants, choice assignments etc

 
 
 
Robert in Ohio
Professor Guide
link   seeder  Robert in Ohio    12 years ago

scremminmimi

It is not all the unions' fault in my view

Student behavior, teacher competence and professionalism, parental involvement, administration presence and involvement are all factors in creating a safe, challenging and productive atmosphere in the classroom

 
 
 
screminmimi
Freshman Silent
link   screminmimi    12 years ago

I also agree that along with eliminating poor performers that superior performers need to be rewarded with bonuses, educational grants, choice assignments etc

Isn't it ironic, though, that the best teacherswould best serve the public by being placed in the worse performing schools....

 
 
 
Robert in Ohio
Professor Guide
link   seeder  Robert in Ohio    12 years ago

I donot view that as ironic

It is very logical in my view to place the most productive assets in the areas thatpose the greatest challenge since those top assets are more likely to achieve success than people of lesser skill and dedication to educational success of our children.

Great teachers thrive on challenge and doing what others think cannot be done.

The best teachers would have the best chance of transforming a poor performing school into a successful educational endeavor

 
 
 
Perrie Halpern R.A.
Professor Guide
link   Perrie Halpern R.A.    12 years ago

It is very logical in my view to place the most productive assets in the areas thatpose the greatest challenge since those top assets are more likely to achieve success than people of lesser skill and dedication to educational success of our children.

Great teachers thrive on challenge and doing what others think cannot be done.

This is so true. I worked 20+years in one of the worst inner city schools. I did this by choice. I can also tell you that I had the privilege of working with some of the best teachers I have ever met. Our school always met it's educational goals, despite the fact that our students came to school tired, poorly clothed, hungry, etc. We met all their needs with clothes drives from the teachers, a wonderful social worker who worked her self to the bone, and at least 2 good meals a day. The students who were tired, many of who were taking care of younger family members so that the parents could work, we gave nap time, too. We had volunteer after school programs.

Where my kids went to school, the teachers were well paid, but had very little heart in their jobs. They were good at what they taught, but they didn't love their work. It was a job.

 
 
 
screminmimi
Freshman Silent
link   screminmimi    12 years ago

When I went to school all my teachers but a few were good teachers who seemed to love their jobs and their students and cared about whether they learned the subjects being taught. They brought life to the classrooms; even the math teachers had us doing things such as baking deserts in the Home Ec class, taking us to the Shop class to measure boards for a bird house, things of that nature, to show us how math is used in every day life.

It was a shock to me when my grandchildren lived with me and I had to deal with their teachers and the principal of the school they transferred to.

 
 
 
Broliver "TheSquirrel" Stagnasty
Freshman Silent
link   Broliver "TheSquirrel" Stagnasty    12 years ago

He was removed from the presence of children, wasn't he?

It was relayed that the teacher only had a year left.

Would you rather your school district payed 1 million dollars to get him terminated or would you rather they payed the 50-60K till he was retired? That is the question that the school board members looked at, I am sure, and the answer to that question informed their decision as to how to proceed.

Situations are not always one way or the other, but frequently are more nuanced. The Teacher may have been falsely accused and didn't want the attorneys fees, so he accepted or maybe even suggested the plea bargain as a means to make the problem go away.

The truth is, I don't know, and neither do you, so it is rather silly to sit and compose conjecture on something that we do not know the specifics on.

I agree, if found by a court to have committed an infraction, then the process of termination should be recognized by the contract so as to lessen the risk to children.

 
 
 
sixpick
Professor Quiet
link   sixpick    12 years ago

If we are talking about making our schools places of excellence, then the whole system needs to be trashed. Tenure gone, evaluations done by a proper team trained to do this and on a regular basis, merit pay for teachers who go beyond the call of duty. That would be a good start.

This stands out to me like Enoch's comment to Jerry paraphrased as "No one is truly gone until the last person they touched is gone."

Fortunately for me my father was one of my teachers every year I went to school. He was in every class I was enrolled in. He knew if I studied or if I goofed off. He knew if I caused no trouble or if I got into trouble. He knew all my teachers better than I did. What a drag.

 
 
 
Robert in Ohio
Professor Guide
link   seeder  Robert in Ohio    12 years ago

Perrie

Thanks for those points

It is interesting to think about the teachers we had and loved were the ones who cared about learning (ours and theirs) and did whatever it took to help the kids in their charge

I had a few of them and was lucky for it and so were your students

 
 
 
Robert in Ohio
Professor Guide
link   seeder  Robert in Ohio    12 years ago

scremminmimi

It is indeed a different world in the schools today and the relationship and participation level of parents in the process has changed significantly over the years as well.

 
 
 
Robert in Ohio
Professor Guide
link   seeder  Robert in Ohio    12 years ago

Sixpick

I know you are being sarcastic but I must point out that the participation and support you describe from your father is a wonderful thing that all children should want and cherish

My father was not one of my teachers, but I learned more from him about life and myself than from any class in school

 
 

Who is online


90 visitors