Is this really a hate crime ? I'm confused ...
LINK
http://news.yahoo.com/transgender-student-sexually-assaulted-school-000702175.html
Transgender student sexually assaulted at school
By GARANCE BURKE and LISA LEFF | Associated Press March 4 , 2014
SAN FRANCISCO (AP) A transgender teenager was beaten and sexually assaulted by three boys in a bathroom at a suburban San Francisco public school, police said, marking the second time a transgender student reported being the target of violence at the campus.
The 15-year-old student, who is biologically female but identifies as male, told officers he was leaving a boy's bathroom late Monday morning at Hercules Middle/High School when the assailants pushed him inside a large stall and attacked him, Hercules police Detective Connie Van Putten said.
Van Putten said the boys reportedly made disparaging remarks to the student, allowing police to treat the case as a hate crime. The victim said he didn't know the boys.
"He walked himself to the health center, and was obviously very upset when he talked to officers," Van Putten said. "He is doing as well as can be expected under the circumstances."
It was the first assault of a transgender student made public since a new California law went into effect on Jan. 1 guaranteeing students the right to use the bathrooms and locker rooms that match the gender with which they identify.
But even before the law took effect, the West Contra Costa Unified School District, which includes Hercules Middle/High, gave transgender students their choice of which school facilities to use, district spokesman Marin Trujillo said.
The bathroom where the attack occurred is between a custodial office and a classroom. Trujillo would not say how long the student victim had been using the boys' restrooms at school but stressed that it would have been permitted even if the law had not been passed.
"We have transgender students at our elementary, middle and high schools and have been making these types of accommodations for many years already," he said.
Opponents of the new law recently tried to repeal it at the ballot box but failed to gather enough signatures to qualify a referendum for the November election. School officials suspect the campaign may have indirectly played a role in Monday's attack by fueling fears among parents and students, Trujillo said.
"We believe as a district, and the superintendent does, that the latest efforts by the petitioners to bring down the law has stirred up a lot of hate and it is showing up in the wrong places," he said.
The teen was taken to a hospital for treatment and released to his parents, No suspects or witnesses have been identified, and detectives on Tuesday collected physical evidence and interviewed students at the campus of 1,800 students in grades 6-12 about 20 miles northeast of San Francisco.
Citing privacy rules and the ongoing investigation, neither police nor school officials would provide details about what happened in the bathroom or the nature of the student's injuries.
Last fall, another transgender student went public with an account of what life was like for her at Hercules High after she got into a fight with three other girls that was caught on a cellphone video that went viral. The transgender teenager, Jewlyes Gutierrez, a biological male who identifies as a female, said she had repeatedly complained about being harassed at school before the brawl.
No one was seriously injured in the fight, but Gutierrez, 16, was charged with misdemeanor battery. Civil rights groups and the president of the school board have called on prosecutors to drop the charge after questioning why she was the only one to face a possible criminal penalty.
Carolyn Laub, executive director of the Gay-Straight Alliance Network, which supports and trains student organizations that serve gay, lesbian, bisexual and transgender students, said Monday's attack indicates that Hercules High has serious safety problems that have nothing to do with the new law.
"This is a horrible incident with a young person who has been sexually assaulted. It's not about bathrooms," Laub said. "It's an attack and it happened at a school where violence has been rampant and allowed to escalate to where something like this has been allowed to occur."
Trujillo said it was wrong to put Gutierrez' experience and Monday's assault in the same category and denied that the school has unusual behavior problems.
In a national survey of more than 8,500 young people between ages 13 and 20, the Gay, Lesbian and Straight Education Network found that more than 75 percent of those who self-identified as transgender reported being verbally harassed at school because of their gender identity.
More than 32 percent of the transgender respondents said they had been physically assaulted at school, according to the 2011 survey by the New York-based organization that advocates for policies to improve the school experiences of gay and transgender youth.
========
update : [Hat tip to Aeon Pax ]
Transgender Student Recants Sexual Assault Report
http://abcnews.go.com/US/wireStory/police-investigate-assault-transgender-teen-22770897

So he was assaulted by gays? How can that be hate? Isn't all crime hate crime? Hate crime statutes are just another mechanism to keep people under control for longer.
Hate crime statutes are such bullshit. What happened was wrong, but how do you prove hate?
I have been told that the little girls room is worse than the little boys room. I have tried to make my own assessments, but have been thwarted thus far.
I don't expect that is an option . If [s]he wants to be considered to be a boy [s]he must of necessity use the boys facilities . The fact that the boys don't perceive things that way is the reality . What if a girl used the boys room ?
What would be the reaction to that ?
Apparently that is the basis for declaring this a hate crime . But in that case disparaging remarks made to "loose"women during a rape would also be a hate crime . If that is the case then the top of this odd hate-crime box has been completely blown off . Leave it to weirdafornia to come up with a real mess like this ...
Speak for yourself . I enjoy peeing while standing up . I also enjoy handling power tools while I'm up on a ladder . Its my male imperative & I insist on exercising it ...
Don't forget spitting while you are walking through the lumber yard being a male imperative.
In Wisconsin, going out on the opening of gun deer season is also a male right of passage. It was rumored that the women went to strip clubs.
And no, women's bathrooms are usually less clean than the mens room from about Jr. High on up.
So if they had been polite it wouldn't be a hate crime. I see the light. Oh, never mind, that was just the hound pushing on the floor based rheostat for my lamp by the computer.
MMMMM, power tools. They have a good feel anywhere.
She/he would not have been assaulted in a girl's bathroom where she belongs.
If a facility wishes to accommodate transgender people they should provide suitable facilities -- that means private individual restrooms rather than group restrooms with stalls.
Probably the same reaction as at most of the clubs that have unisex restrooms. Gets kinda kinky really.
Well ... I am far from a legal scholar and am completely unqualified to address this issue but as far as I can tell the answer is yes . Did I mention that I'm confused ?
That brings up all kinds of other issues which have not been addressed . What happens if a girl uses the boys room but is assaulted when she does ? I'm sure there are other issues but that's the 1st one which comes to mind ...
I guess I'm old fashioned . I've never seen such facilities . What happens if you wave your organ at a girl ?
So am I Petey. This whole hate crime thing is a legal quagmire and ... our world is really screwed.
I'm thinking that maybe this particular "boy" will acquire a new perception of "his" gender identity after this . But who knows ...
Then obviously you are an intruder and must be dealt with appropriately by the sexual education police.
Bbbbut officer ... I was just shaking off the last few drops . Surely that is not against the law ?!
It is a legal quagmire and there are going to be some major snafus coming because of it .
I don't think these kind of rules are global yet . Maybe moving to Latin America is starting to look better ...
We'll teach you how to shake it, boi.
OH NO !
I won't forget that even though it has been awhile since I've been to a lumber yard . Is there anything about the article that makes you confused ?
I'm confused.
That's all ya got ? I'm disappointed ...
Nothing in the article states the assailants were gay.
You're right about the article . But the issue of what is meant by "gay" is also confused in this case . Since the "actual gender" of the victim is confused what can you accurately say about the assailants ?
This is sad. Like women who report a false rape, this only makes it harder for those who are truly harassed and assaulted.
The intolerance and stupidity displayed in this thread by the "usual suspects", is not surprising.
Thanks for the update . But no thanks for your characterization :
You are going to have to back up that accusation with specifics . However , this is where you usually disappear .
Specifics? It would appear by your reply, a guilty conscience is it's own accuser.
Is this really a hate crime ? I'm confused ...
Comment deleted:
comment no longer relevantin view of new info from update.
So if I am in CA I can dress like a girl and get all the looky-loo I want in the girls locker room/bathroom? Does anyone else see potential problems with this?
I have a problem with this. Everyone is going to call this biological girl a "he" because that is the gender "he" self identifies with. The school even allows transgender students to use any bathroom they want, regardless of how the girls in the school might feel about having a male in their restroom.
But when it comes to taking a statement about an assault, the police in lollyland assign who??? Well, they assign a FEMALE investigator to interview the sensitive little "boy" about "his" sexual assault.
Make up your freaking minds, people.
I asked for specifics . All you did was imply unfounded accusations about me . Real classy /S
Nope . The meaningless comment is still here . You can delete it anytime you want though .
Summing up after the update :
The hate crime may have disappeared but not the police ready to react harshly against males [& seemingly only the males ] . The story pointed out that there were examples of discrimination & abuse from girls against gendered confused boys . But aren't those considered hate crimes ? If not are those examples of gender discrimination by the police in favor of females ?
Interesting that there are elementary and middle school kids that are transgender. I wouldn't have guessed.
Petey, I'm not sure that I understand why it would be something other than a 'Hate Crime.' Maybe you wouldn't mind explaining your title implication. My thoughts are that a gay or lesbian probably wouldn't like a transgender because they aren't a genetic homosexual; why would the boys want a girl in their bathroom. I would think the full assault would be a hate crime--the rape part might be using the same thinking as the stories we read about prison rape of a rapist (child molester) -- they hate him.
Yes, desparaging remarks directed at someone in particular to degrade, insult and ridicule are due to "hate," yes?
Just screw the thugs under any old law... they ganged up and beat someone up.
Please note that definitions 3 and 4 were the only definitions available half my life time ago.
Now then, as to my use of the term gay in my reply, I suppose I should have placed (sarc) in there somewhere. I'm just old enough to think that people might have some discernment capabilities, but it seems the older I get the wronger I get.
I said "assailants", period. Your confusion on other matters pertaining to this case are irrelevant to my correcting a fact.
AP, Thanks for noticing that. I thought I missed a sexual orientation mention of the assailants judging by other comments, so I went with that thought in forming my original opinion. This should definitely be a rape and physical assault charge, rather than a hate crime, even though they verbally attacked the victim. Rape would seem to trump verbal abuse and hate.
Chloe,
In my LGBT group, we are troubled and divided in regards to the transgendered plight. While transgendered are under the LGBT umbrella, in reality transgenders represent the least populated subgroup what what is generically called "Gay."
Hate crimes against the transgendered are easy enough to take issue with but the sociological implication of shared bathroom facilities, specifically for the under 18 group is another matter. The right to privacy is at issue here for which both sides have equally compelling legal, moral and ethical concerns.
AP, true, there is an ambivalence involved.
I'm not in accord with their movement, and the bathroom issue is a prime discrepancy, as you noted.
Even if she is a gay transgender (now that sounds like an oxymoron! I would think her heterosexuality would be causing the attraction, rather than a genetic homosexuality. Are there people that consider themselves both gay and transgender?) - the privacy, ethical and legal concerns are still relevant.
I agree. It would seem "hate" would be listed as the cause, but the actual assault would be the basis for charges.
lol... I agree with your thinking. My conclusion is that gay/lesbian is strictly sexual orientation based, but transgender doesn't have to indicate sexual preference, so it's not an orientation - just an identity preference - that could be hetero or homosexual based on their genetics/epi-marks.
Gays are no different than anyone else. We are mothers, fathers, sisters and brothers. We have jobs, many go to worship, shop, complain about crime and taxes and serve in the military. WE love our country and are concerned about its future.
The ignorant, on this issue, are stuck on semantics and spew their own fears and hatred into a concern they know absolutely nothing about.
The bottom line here is about is not just specifically about violence against the Transgendered (or all Gays in general) but in a larger sense, how society will eventually need to adjust to the individual concerns of the Transgendered.
I realize that you are not in union with my own beliefs on this but as a matter of sowing the seeds for a more understanding and loving society, this issue must be confronted.
Certain groups in the US, the handicapped for example, have fought hard to assert their own rights for facilities that are compliant to their own needs, and so to it is with the Transgendered.
Transgender sexuality is a sexual orientation.
Oh... so it's to include someone asexual. Thanks for pointing that out!
Something is confusing about this...hormones determine preference; if there is no sexual preference, then why would they care to change? It would have to be identity. I wonder what part of our physiology would affect identity preference if there was lack of hormones?
I follow your thoughts. It sounds like some kind of mental motivation if they don't have the determining chemistry. Maybe something like a childhood memory of someone they liked or idolized. Possibly a movie or rock star! 51 gender identities - wow!
Defining a Hate Crime
It is indeedthe motivation of prejudice/bias/bigotry that turnsassault, arson (or whatever) into a 'hate crime'-- setting fire to a church, synagogue or mosque is a hate crime; setting fire to a bank is not. Kicking your neighbor's ass while screaming'goddam opera-lover' is not a hate crime; kicking your neighbor's ass while screaming'goddam faggot' is.
I thought those scenarios were really interesting. Laws. We need them, but it seems like they should make sense (or maybe I don't have any sense??!!). I think the crime should be based on the act, not who it affects. ..I think.
Mike,
In the course of 200 years, our society has adjusted to the influx of many new ideas, cultures, innovations and technologies. To each one, there was always resistance; always and many times it has been violent resistance. That is the human condition.
Regardless of the rationalizations, justifications and excuses, society as a whole eventually adjusted to these new things and life went on.
This issue is no different and no one said change isnt painful.
Hate Crime enhancers are laws that the people demanded and your legislators passed into law. I've never been a proponent of the "Hate Crime enhancers". To me, all violent crimes involve hate in one degree or another. As a possible method to detour or prevent such crimes, they have failed miserably.
I think so too. There's motivation. I'm thinking hate in violent crime, or something mentally disordered or disturbed - emotional anxiety (child molestation? Or bestiality?); robbery - could be hate, but I'm guessing there could be jealousy in some cases, maybe.
Enhancers don't sound like a good idea to me, either.
Bear in mind that hate crime issues are an outgrowth of Federal civil-rights laws, Chloe. A large part of the reason Federal law defined & put the FBI in charge of investigating 'hate crimes' was that firebombings of black churches & murder of civil-rights activists in the south was simply not investigated or deliberately sidetracked by State or local law enforcement. The Federal statute allowed invididual victims, witnesses or activist groups to report the incidents of assault, arson, murder, directly to be FBI when local 'justice' simply labeled the crimes as 'unsolved'.
The 4th paragraph of the FBI statement is telling when you read 'between the lines'--
So... is this 'Big Brother', the Federal gov't 'intruding' into States rights and 'interfering' with local law enforcement, or is this a situation where Federal authority is necessary to keep minority citizens from being victims of assault, arson or murder motivated by hatred that may be condoned by a majority (possibly including cops & judges)in their immediate area?
And once we've entered into the arena of 'civil rights', to whom should those rights be accorded? If there is in fact a need for some oversight to keep black folks from being beaten, burned out or killed simply because they're black, shouldn't that same scenario apply to Native Americans, Hispanics, Jews, Muslims, or gay folks? Considering somewho post here on NT ranting about 'queers', 'faggots' & 'freaks of nature', or finding ways to explain away a black kid being shot for having the radio turned up too loud, it's hard not to think that 'hate crime' is worthy of a little scrutiny...
AP ,
In my simple minded engineering approach to the overwhelmingly complex social issue of bathrooms I would suggest this :
Have the usual male & female bathrooms . Then add a 3rd set of bathrooms for "other" . I leave it to you to come up with an appropriate symbol to put on the door . I would suggest a large red & blue question mark .
True - and they are doing their job as intended - ensuring protections for the individual.
In your last paragraph, I still wonder if "hate" is too hard to prove, or any motivation, for that matter - people lie to get what they want, or 'out of' what they don't want. It seems the crime (the harm or assault) itself is what should be addressed. I don't like hate. I wish there was a magic wand that we could wave to cause everyone to remove their ill thoughts towards others and their motivations to harm them, as well as accept that we are all different, have different lifestyles and values. But, there isn't one.
Jealousies, righteousness, religious tenets affect those motivations of hate that turn into assault, yet I don't know how we can prove or stop those motivations; sure wish we could. We can't force people to accept differences. I try to promote tolerance of others that we don't like or want to harm in some way, hoping it will help prevent thoughts of some form of abuse.
There is some confusion here. The Matthew Shepard and James Byrd, Jr., Hate Crimes Prevention Act of 2009 now allows for a prosecuting attorney to try a suspect using this law which contains enhanced penalties due to its classification as a hate crime. -
The law expanded a person's protected characteristics of race, religion, ethnicity, nationality, gender, sexual orientation, gender identity, and disability. - and allows for much harsher penalties, also known as "enhancements.
A person can be tried for simple assault and battery* and if convicted, faces a standard sentencing guideline for that crime.
If the prosecuting attorney feels the crime of assault and evidence also meets the characteristics of a hate crime, then he or she can try the person under the Hate Crimes law where the sentencing guidelines can allow for penalties than can be twice as harsh.
The caveat here is that hate crime prosecution is difficult and provides an additional level of proof and evidence is needed.
The elements of a hate crime are:
a) There must be an underlying criminal act.
b) The motivation for the crime must be hate or bias towards a particular class or group defined by such characteristics as race, religion, disability, sexual orientation, gender, ethnicity, or national origin.
c) The perpetrator must have selected the victim of the crime based on a perception or belief that the victim or the victims family, friends, or associates belong to that group or class.
For this reason, many perceived hate crimes are tried as standard crimes. If the prosecution fails to get a conviction using the Hate Crime law, that person cannot be retried using the law without the hate crime enhancements, thats double jeopardy.
*example
Please see the update that was added to the article ... It was all a lie perpetrated by the transgender in the story .