╌>

Building a Palestinian state, one city at a time

  

Category:  News & Politics

Via:  the-irascible-harry-krishner  •  12 years ago  •  68 comments

Building a Palestinian state, one city at a time

While still struggling with Israeli bureaucracy, panoramic view and affordable prices bring much attention to newly constructed West Bank city of Rawabi, which is expected to be populated next year.

5161890097298490362no.jpg The city is planned to spread over 6 million squared meters, and its first stages include 630 housing units which have already been almost entirely sold, in buildings of four and five floors.

Meanwhile, three schools, a mosque, a church, a large amphitheater and a soccer field are all being built in the city. The construction of a large commercial center with stores, a hotel, a hi-tech center and a cinema complex is nearly finished; a kilometer away from there, a logistics center for light industry has been established.

516188601000100490366no.jpg

The profile of the residents expected to reside in Rawabi fits the unusual sight of the city in the Palestinian landscape. Some 70% of those who purchased apartments are newly married couples and relatively young people from the northern West Bank; most have academic degrees and a steady job, and only 11% are single. Among those who purchased apartments are Arab-Israelis who bought a second apartment, and are planning to use it during the weekends, as well as East Jerusalem residents who are hiding the transition for fear of losing their Israeli IDs. ( Link )


Tags

jrDiscussion - desc
[]
 
Krishna
Professor Guide
link   seeder  Krishna    12 years ago

Palestinian flag waves over the future city

516188912622462490490no.jpg

Note: this is in the "occupied" West Bank.

Hmmmmm . . .

 
 
 
screminmimi
Freshman Silent
link   screminmimi    12 years ago

An entire city has been built? Three schools? And it sounds as though the entire city will be populated with only the elite, the cream of the crop. The entire project sounds like a "Stepford Wives" on steroids for Arabs.

 
 
 
Kavika
Professor Expert
link   Kavika     12 years ago

A mosque and a church, in the ''occupied West Bank''. Seems some are doing well under the occupation.

 
 
 
Petey Coober
Freshman Silent
link   Petey Coober    12 years ago

three schools, a mosque, a church

Aha ! There is no way the Palests would have added the church on their own . Nice touch towards multiculturalism .

 
 
 
Pedro
Professor Quiet
link   Pedro    12 years ago

This is right in line with my philosophy on how these disputed areas should be handled. David Ben-Gurion would be proud of this development.

 
 
 
Chloe
Freshman Silent
link   Chloe    12 years ago

This is so good to read! I'd say it should only get better from here! Yes, why haven't we heard more of this? Hmmm... for sure. Thanks for letting us know, Krish!

 
 
 
Krishna
Professor Guide
link   seeder  Krishna    12 years ago

This is right in line with my philosophy on how these disputed areas should be handled

Well, apparently the current Israeli gov't agrees with you!

 
 
 
Krishna
Professor Guide
link   seeder  Krishna    12 years ago

An entire city has been built? Three schools? And it sounds as though the entire city will be populated with only the elite, the cream of the crop.

Well, if Gaza is actually "the world's largest outdoor concentration camp" as the haters claim,

then surely this would qualify the West Bank as the world's second largest concentration camp!

 
 
 
Krishna
Professor Guide
link   seeder  Krishna    12 years ago

This is so good to read! I'd say it should only get better from here! Yes, why haven't we heard more of this? Hmmm... for sure.

Probably because most of the Arab world is terribly opposed to anything that betters the lives of the Palestinians (they want to keep them suffering as much as possible, for propaganda purposes-- hence the horrendous condition they suffer in refugee camps in Syria, Lebanon, etc) and much of the "politically correct mainstream media" in the west doesn't want to do anything that pisses any of the 21 Arab countries (and/or any of the 55 Islamic countries).

Thanks for letting us know, Krish!

You're welcome Smile.gif

And its really something to think about-- not only are those evil Zionists permitting this, but they are permitting Palestinian flags to fly, and apparently there are enough Palestinians with enough money to afford these apartments.

 
 
 
Chloe
Freshman Silent
link   Chloe    12 years ago

Ok, I see. Thank you! Smile.gif

 
 
 
Petey Coober
Freshman Silent
link   Petey Coober    12 years ago

That is typical middle eastern Arab "thinking" . There is no reason to tear down anything . Building is the answer .
By building more cities like Rawabi everyone wins . Of course winning is an alien concept to Arabs in that region as it is to leftist Americans . They only see victims everywhere they go .

 
 
 
Aeonpax
Freshman Silent
link   Aeonpax    12 years ago

1. Article source -

2. Tacky decor. Look at the 60's furniture. Who'd live there?

3. " a fifth-floor 180-squared-meters four-bedroom apartment is offered at a price of $110,000". - It's not priced like government housing in the US. The average Palestinian makes $377 a month ( source ) It does not include the cost of camera's and microphones built into each room. *

4. "The city is built first and foremost for Palestinians. Arab-Israelis are Palestinians just like a Palestinian residing in Jordan is a Palestinian," - This really does not help your average Palestinian.

Summary - Good first attempt, sort of. However, the entire project smacks of social engineering similar to what the US does for blacks.


* just kidding.

 
 
 
Kavika
Professor Expert
link   Kavika     12 years ago

It's like offering American Indians reservations with US military forts in them overseeing them. They do, it's called the BIA.

 
 
 
Chloe
Freshman Silent
link   Chloe    12 years ago

AP, Your point #3 gave me a thought; reminds me of our housing debacle in giving loans to people that can't afford it, but do it anyway -- then the banks/government have an excuse to pull money from the taxpayers calling for a bailout -- and we know who wins with that deal. Could something like that happen there?

 
 
 
Krishna
Professor Guide
link   seeder  Krishna    12 years ago

So...when will the West Bank Israeli invas....er..."settlements" be torn down?

Why do you thinks Muslims should be allowed to build homes disputed territories... but not Jews? Why the advocacy of ethnic cleansing? A "judenfrei" Palestine?

Judenfrei ("free of Jews") or Judenrein ("clean of Jews") was a Nazi term to designate an area " cleansed " of Jewish presence during The Holocaust . [ 1 ]

While Judenfrei referred merely to "freeing" an area of all of its Jewish citizens, the term Judenrein (literally "clean of Jews") was also used. This had the stronger connotation that any trace of Jewish blood had been removed as an impurity. [ 2 ]

 
 
 
Krishna
Professor Guide
link   seeder  Krishna    12 years ago

The Palestinians lose because, when the national lines are finally drawn, they will have foreign invader cells in their country.

Not if the Palestinians have any say in the peace negotiations:

Abbas: 'Not a single Israeli' in future Palestinian state (Link )

So while the Palistinians are apparently hoping to ethnically cleanse the West Bank to make it judenfrei, it should be noted noted that a whopping 20% if Israeli citizens are Arabs (where they are allowed democratic rights such as the right to vote, etc. Something they would not have in neihbouring Arab countries).

"Judenfrei":

Judenfrei_Bydgoszcz_synagoga.jpg Description

English: Jewish Synagogue in Germanoccupied Bydgoszcz (Poland). Inscription in German language means: "This city is free of Jews". September 1939.
Polski: Synagoga w okupowanej Bydgoszczy. Wywieszony na murze napis w j. niemieckim gosi: "To miasto jest wolne od ydw". Wrzesie 1939
 
 
 
Krishna
Professor Guide
link   seeder  Krishna    12 years ago

giving loans to people that can't afford it,

1. What makes you think these people can't afford it? (Link?)

Although much Palestinian propaganda would try to make you believe that Palestinians living in the disputed territories are living in concentration camp conditions, the fact is that many are living quite comfortably.

2. Who do you think would be supplying the loans?

3. What would be their motivation to give loans to people who can't afford these homes?

 
 
 
Chloe
Freshman Silent
link   Chloe    12 years ago

Krishna, thanks for that info. I don't know about the Palestinians as a people, how they live or what incomes are like for them; I was just commenting in regards to AP's comment, "The average Palestinian makes $377 a month ( source )." If they 'can' afford their loans, then that's good and default won't be an issue.

2. Their governments' banks or groups they are associated with?

3. The same motivation that our corrupt government had?

 
 
 
pokermike
Freshman Silent
link   pokermike    12 years ago

AP's comment "The average Palestinian makes $377 a month is untrue. The article at her cited source explains the $377 was set as the minimum monthly wage for a Palestinian worker in 2012. Actually, the average Palestinian makes $641/month, still not a heck of a lot but not $377 either.

Probably the one group who can easily afford these units will be some of the terrorists recently released by Israel. Though many of them are actual cold-blooded mass murderers, their financial future is guaranteed by the Palestinian government on the West Bank. The worst of the worst murderers and terrorists, those who were imprisoned for 25 years will receive a cash payment of up to $50,000 (covering a down payment of nearly half the purchase price of one of these new apartments). In addition they are given monthly salaries by the Palestinian Authority based upon how many years they were incarcerated. Here is the breakdown of the highest paid:

25+ $3,975/month

15-25 years $2,840/month

Apparently, for many Palestinians crime does pay, even murderers of women and children.

 
 
 
Larry Hampton
Professor Quiet
link   Larry Hampton    12 years ago

When one reads the article, it's striking how similar in ways, it is to so many other articles published in newspapers everyday: "New developement underway, investors hopeful with sale of most units beforehand". Funny how easy it is to forget that much of this area being referenced is growing, vibrant, modern and suburban. Expansion and growth are happening whether anyone likes it or not; and, it sounds like there are many young families not only in need of housing, but bring an industrious, hardworking and family oriented stability to the equation. This will lead to more valuable relationships between many neighbors, regardless of ethnicity, nationality, or even religion. When folks kids start growing-up together, bonds are formed that will surpass those of culture. Perhaps not many at first, but within a couple of generations or so...it will make a difference.

Can anyone even imagine how much money this region could make in tourism alone, if there was more stability? Holy smokes, palestinians could be getting filthy stinking rich and live like kings if they only took advantage of their situation! They could have ultimate destination spots for vacationers lookin' for sun, surf, history and culture. They live right on the door-step of the largest start-up and technology sector ouside of silicon valley. They would have access to the finest medical care not just in the region, but in the world.

They could enjoy lives of prosperity, happiness and hope for their children, instead of fear, disparity and certain hopelessness.

 
 
 
Kavika
Professor Expert
link   Kavika     12 years ago

Unfortunetly that is not what their leadership wants Larry.

 
 
 
Larry Hampton
Professor Quiet
link   Larry Hampton    12 years ago

I know, frickin sad ain't it?

I wonder sometimes just how aware the average middle-class, educated palestinian is? I'm guesssing very much so, for some to many. If that is true then it is going to take a revolution the scale and true outcome of which, would dwarf anything that the "arab spring' coulda dreamed of being. It seems to me that the average Palestinians are the only ones that truly hold the key to true peace and prosperity; but, that key is also being held hostage by Arab countries and entities that would continue to use them as pawns. Palestinians must rescue their opportunity, and it will require much sacrifice and willingness.

 
 
 
Aeonpax
Freshman Silent
link   Aeonpax    12 years ago

"the average Palestinian makes $641/month,"

Do you have a source for that? Of course not....why am I even asking, My source was from the Israeli government itself.

One other source states about the same thing;

  • The Palestinian Central Bureau of Statistics June 10 released a survey showing that Palestinian average income has been reduced by 50 percent since September 2000, Le Figaro (France) reports. The average monthly income went down from $500 to $280 in the West Bank, and from $400 to $240 in Gaza; 63.3 percent of Palestinians today live under the poverty line, the survey further says. In other news, The main UN relief agency assisting Palestine refugees has launched an urgent appeal to the international community for $103 million to support its emergency activities in the second half of 2003. The UN Relief and Works Agency for Palestine Refugees (UNWRA), the largest development and emergency relief agency in the Middle East, said the funds are needed to provide food aid, shelter, medical care and counseling for children who have been traumatized by violence - ...

Facts...gotta love em.

 
 
 
Chloe
Freshman Silent
link   Chloe    12 years ago

That's very interesting, Pokermik. Thanks for the clarification on incomes. Interesting on the benefits for those terrorists.

 
 
 
Larry Hampton
Professor Quiet
link   Larry Hampton    12 years ago

This I believe it is what Pokermilk is talkin' about. can't speak for him, but given the tenor of his point,,,I'd say it's probable.

 
 
 
pokermike
Freshman Silent
link   pokermike    12 years ago

3. " a fifth-floor 180-squared-meters four-bedroom apartment is offered at a price of $110,000". -It's not priced like government housing in the US. The average Palestinian makes $377 a month ( source ) It does not include the cost of camera's and microphones built into each room. *

AP, Your first statement was a blatant misrepresentation of the average monthy wage not the minimum monthly wage (see your comment above).

Now your new source is from 2003. How relevant is that to what we are discussing? Figures from an eleven-year old blurb, even if factual at that time, are no longer applicable.

BTW, I got my $641 figure from the link Larry provided in his comment. I already know you are going to dismiss it as propaganda from the evil Israeli government.

 
 
 
Aeonpax
Freshman Silent
link   Aeonpax    12 years ago

What new source? I just reposted the the source I originally stated. You got a link, post it yourself. I'm not your secretary.

I see you don't like facts. All's more the pity.

 
 
 
Petey Coober
Freshman Silent
link   Petey Coober    12 years ago

Coming from someone who prefers conspiracy theories to properly researched science

talking about facts is laughable ...

 
 
 
Aeonpax
Freshman Silent
link   Aeonpax    12 years ago

Chloe,

First off, the posted article had no link or source, I had to find it I read the full article there.

The cost of the apartment ($110,000) looks to be like a condo price.

Finding out the average income of a Palestinian, per month/year is not easy, unless of course I go to biased sources. Even then, I could not find a straight answer. The wage of $377 per month is correct. The source, The Times of Israel, stated flatly that the monthly income of A Palestinian went down to $377, which is at present. Source - ... -

Another source states this;

  • The average monthly income went down from $500 to $280 in the West Bank, and from $400 to $240 in Gaza; - ...

There is another news service I found but I have that I didnt feel like bringing up when I wrote my first reply but seeing how Ive gone this far, there is another article by CNN about the Rawabi project here;

A brief summery;

1) This is being built by a private developer. While both the Palestinian Authority and the Israeli government have cooperated with this project, it is not being paid for or managed by either government. The developers name is Bashar Masri who is a Palestinian American. (source - )

2) Marsis project has already provided short term construction jobs for 5,000 Palestinians and he hopes to create 1,500 jobs once the construction is done.

3) Though more affordable than other West Bank properties, at $60,000 to $170,000, their price tag is aimed at the middle class. (See CNN article)

 
 
 
Chloe
Freshman Silent
link   Chloe    12 years ago

Thanks AP! Lots of links and info.

I had wondered what the risk of default might be for certain residents. 40,000 residents possible, currently 5000 employed while the project is under construction, with 1500 more jobs hoping to appear... but then what when the project is complete, and the Palestinian government said it's broke and can't help. I had wondered if this was a potential housing debacle that will get sliced and diced for wealthy investors to take advantage of...speculation of course, but if they are hoping for government assistance if needed, it sounds like it's not gonna happen.

 
 
 
screminmimi
Freshman Silent
link   screminmimi    12 years ago

@pokermilk:

Probably the one group who can easily afford these units will be some of the terrorists recently released by Israel. Though many of them are actual cold-blooded mass murderers, their financial future is guaranteed by the Palestinian government on the West Bank. The worst of the worst murderers and terrorists, those who were imprisoned for 25 years will receive a cash payment of up to $50,000 (covering a down payment of nearly half the purchase price of one of these new apartments). In addition they are given monthly salaries by the Palestinian Authority based upon how many years they were incarcerated. Here is the breakdown of the highest paid:

25+ $3,975/month

15-25 years $2,840/month

Apparently, for many Palestinians crime does pay, even murderers of women and children.

You left out the part where we, US citizens, are supplying the funds to pay the Palestinian terrorist murderers, as well as those who do not work at all.

We recently increased the amount we send to Palestine to support the unemployed there and the murderers; it was the subject of article in either the New York Post or the Jewish Press two or three weeks ago. I almost posted it on NT but at the time we were carrying several articles on Israel and I decided not to; I almost kept the article for future reference but was having some computer problems and let it go.

Not long after there was a news story about some states reducing food stamps and stopping extended unemployment benefits and I was thinking about the hypocrisy of sending billions to a country that hates us for its people to live perpetually on our welfare and cutting benefits to our own.

 
 
 
Aeonpax
Freshman Silent
link   Aeonpax    12 years ago

Reading and comprehension skills are not your forte. I said I "prefer" the article. I didn't say I "believe" it.

 
 
 
Aeonpax
Freshman Silent
link   Aeonpax    12 years ago

The US has given $118,247,000,000 in assorted aid to Israel since 1949 - page 30, CRS (Congressional Research Service) entitled; US Foreign Aid to Israel .

 
 
 
screminmimi
Freshman Silent
link   screminmimi    12 years ago

Israel isn't a terrorist nation hell bent on killing everyone who is not Jewish.

Israel is a nation that has a majority of people who actually work and produce cutting edge technology, medical breakthroughs, things of that nature.

Israel is a nation that sends relief workers to other countries that experience natural disasters.

Need I go on?

By the way, the knife-wielding terrorists in China responsible for the deaths of 27 subway riders and the injury of many more were identified by the Chinese authorities as Muslim terrorists. The news source stated they are having a great deal of trouble in by Muslims in the area where the attack took place. Don't think they mentioned any Israelis being the cause of concern in China, though.

 
 
 
Aeonpax
Freshman Silent
link   Aeonpax    12 years ago

I just wanted to make the point that "aid" works both ways. The rest of your reply is non sequitur.

 
 
 
Chloe
Freshman Silent
link   Chloe    12 years ago

"You left out the part where we, US citizens, are supplying the funds to pay the Palestinian terrorist murderers, as well as those who do not work at all."

Mimi,

I didn't know that. Do you know, does our government fund the PA directly, or does it go somewhere else first and is given to the PA after the fact? Has that always been the case, or has it been since Obama?

 
 
 
Krishna
Professor Guide
link   seeder  Krishna    12 years ago

1. Article source -

For those unfamiliar with Ynet: Jerusalem Post has a rightest slant, Ha'Aretz has a leftist bias, Ynet is centrist.

2. Tacky decor. Look at the 60's furniture. Who'd live there?

Your are entitled to your particular tastes in interior decorating. But as too who would live here? Rather well to do Arabs, actually. And based on the article, I would say that many fairly well to do Arabs do indeed want to live here! (read the article for more information).

3. " a fifth-floor 180-squared-meters four-bedroom apartment is offered at a price of $110,000". - It's not priced like government housing in the US. The average Palestinian makes $377 a month ( source ) It does not include the cost of camera's and microphones built into each room. *

Yup, these homes are not designed for the "average" Palestinian. The people building these, as well as their financial backers, have two goals: to make money (both entities are private corporations not any government entity ), and to help accelerate the formation of a future Palestinian state .

4. "The city is built first and foremost for Palestinians. Arab-Israelis are Palestinians just like a Palestinian residing in Jordan is a Palestinian," - This really does not help your average Palestinian.

As mentioned inn the article, this is not a government project!!! It is being done by private corporations, which have the right to build what they choose. If you think these privately run entities should build housing for less well off Palestinians, you are free to write them an email to that effect, to organize protest demonstrations-- or even to get some people together to organize a protest.

But the governing body in the area (do you evn know who that is?) does not have the power nor the desire to forbid them from building this.

Summary - Good first attempt, sort of. However, the entire project smacks of social engineering similar to what the US does for blacks.

Well, if its "social engineering" its an attempt at social engineering by Arab entities-- not any government! (And, in fact, aside from their goal of making money (in your opinion, should private corporations in Arab areas be allowed to do that?)

In addition, there is something a bit rare for privately run corporations, there is an attempt at social engineering. But its not to keep down poorer Palestinians. Rather, its goal is actually rather altruistic-- to help yo advance the formation and growth of an independent (and prosperous) Palestine!!!

DOH!

 
 
 
Larry Hampton
Professor Quiet
link   Larry Hampton    12 years ago

Are you as concerned about neighborhoods full of fanatical Palestinians living in what may not be a future Palestinian state? Why not?

You mention fanatical Israelis, do you believe that everyone inthese neighbors are fanatics and/or Israeli? What will happen to neighborhoods filled with average hardworking Israelis and palestinians?

Of course, Israelis and Palestians both should know better than to grow, raise families, and attempt to prosper. They should just follow along with the status quo, remain in a constant state of tension, and allow themselves to be used as tools.

 
 
 
Krishna
Professor Guide
link   seeder  Krishna    12 years ago

It doesn't matter the supposed intentions of the nation of Israel (which are suspect at best).

Do you believe the intentions of the Palestinian government of Gaza (the barbaric terror group Hamas) are not "suspect"? Are you familiar by any chance with their goal, as openly stated in their Charter?

But you seem to be unaware of the fact that while the intentions of Israel do matter, as do the intentions of both rival Palestinian gov'ts, neither will totally get their way in a final peace accord. What Kerry is currently seeking is a deal between all three parties (Israel, Hamas, and the PA) that absolutely must have some coompromises by each of the three parties!

And this will not be accom0lished by the use of force (whether by conventional armed forces or terror groups).

The fact is

lol Smile.gif .

You silly goose! That is not a fact. It is some bizarre idea you just made up! Tongue.gif

that when a Palestine state is established there will be settlements of fanatical Israelis within their border

Where can I get some of that stuff that you are smoking? 24.gif

All 4 parties (the U.S. brokers, Israel, and the two independent Palestinian governments know full well that there will be no Israeli settlements within the borders of any new Palestinian state that would be created. (If the Palis don't block an agreement yet again Frown.gif ).

The settlements currently occupy something like 3% of West Bank land. The major ones are just east of Jerusalem, close to any future border.The best guess is that Israel will keep this tiny bit of land, and in return will give an equivalent area of what is now part of Israel to the new state in return.

that will need to be cleared out and that will be a violent action if it's done by the Palestinians or the Israeli's.

Unlike when Israel withdrew from Gaza, there will be no settlemts in the new "Palestine" to be cleared out. The borders will be drawn around them.

The more the current right wing Israeli government allows settlements, the bloodier the removal of them will be when it has to happen.

There were a lot of settlemts in Gaza. My guess is they occupiied a vastly larger percentage of Gaza land than the current settlements in the West Bank do. But unlike the West Bank, the settlers in Gaza had to be removed-- by force (IDF troops ). But not nearly as much Israeli blood was shed as you would've hoped for.

Here's the best coverage (with lots of photos) I've found showing how IDF troops followed Sharon's (Peace Be Upon Him) decision to force the settlers to leave Gaza and turn Gaza over to the Palestinians to govern (another opportunity for you to "get smarter here"):

Exodus From Gaza

The forcible evacuation of August 2005

J EWS have lived on and off in Gaza for millennia, long before Islam or Christianity were founded, and for many centuries before the concept of a Palestinian nation was born.

In the past, others have driven Jews out of this strip of land that hugs the eastern coast of the Mediterranean. But in August 2005, in a period of just seven days, 21 Jewish communities were forcibly removed by their own government, as Israel became the first country in modern history to relinquish land acquired in a defensive war to an enemy that had not yet made peace with it.

It was the Israeli armys largest ever non-combat operation, involving 45,000 soldiers and policemen. Most of the world welcomed the unilateral withdrawal. Israelis were evenly divided: on the eve of the pullout a Tel Aviv University poll showed 48 percent of Israelis supported the plan, hoping that it would improve the life of Palestinians and lead to an end, or at least to a sharp drop, in acts of violence and the daily outpouring of genocidal propaganda in Palestinian society directed towards Jews.

Virtually not a single Jewish resident of Gaza left voluntarily. Many had to be carried out by soldiers and police. In some cases water cannon and batons were used, but there was no serious violence.

After the residents had gone, the Israeli army, at the behest of the Palestinian Authority, destroyed the settlements, leaving only the synagogues, which it was hoped the Palestinians would respect. On September 12, 2005, the last Israeli soldier left Gaza, and it took just 15 minutes for the first abandoned synagogue to be set alight.

exodus1.jpg A Jewish woman weeps as Israeli soldiers surround the settlement of Neve Dekalim, in southern Gaza, on August 18, 2005, and prepare to move in. Even those Israelis who strongly backed the plan were greatly saddened to see Jews dragged from their homes.

The leftist novelist David Grossman wrote in Haaretz : These are days of mourning for all Israelis. We can mourn today for the passion, the pioneering spirit, the purposefulness that for years pulsed through Gush Katif and which will soon dissipate like smoke, and for the fabric of life there that will be shredded come tomorrow.

Lots more can be found HERE.

 
 
 
Petey Coober
Freshman Silent
link   Petey Coober    12 years ago

Muslim terrorists are also non sequitur . Just be sure you aren't nearby when they take out a knife in order to cut off your sequitur .

 
 
 
Krishna
Professor Guide
link   seeder  Krishna    12 years ago

Among those who purchased apartments are Arab-Israelis who bought a second apartment, and are planning to use it during the weekends, as well as East Jerusalem residents who are hiding the transition for fear of losing their Israeli IDs.

Many Arabs with israeli citizenship who leave near where it seems future borders will be drawn (in the event of a peace deal) are fearful of losing their israeli citizenship!

And that says a lot about the difference between the way Arabs are treated in Israel-- and the way they are treated in Arab countries!

 
 
 
Krishna
Professor Guide
link   seeder  Krishna    12 years ago

And yet, some self-appointed "experts" on NT are in full denial:

Rather than push the indigenous people onto bantustans and engage in collective punishment when they resist occupation, either create a viable Palestinian state (which I think is no longer possible) or let the Palestinians return and make one state. The alternative is endless conflict.

"Bantustan"?

WTF?

(Here's the link to this totally bizarre comment. Yes,there's more...)

 
 
 
1ofmany
Sophomore Silent
link   1ofmany    12 years ago

I'd be more than happy to repeat all of my "bizarre" comments here if you like and more. Anyway, this is a complex built with Palestinian and Qatari money for fat cat Palestinians and has nothing to do with those crowded onto bantustans like Gaza.

http://

 
 
 
Krishna
Professor Guide
link   seeder  Krishna    12 years ago

Anyway, this is a complex built with Palestinian and Qatari money for fat cat Palestinians and has nothing to do with those crowded onto bantustans like Gaza.

You miss the irony. Israel is not stopping the Palestinians from building this-- this would not have ever taken place in Apartheid South Africa. It is giving the right to do what they want. So, having the freedom to do that, look what they are building. Its their choice!

and has nothing to do with those crowded onto bantustans like Gaza.

Crowded bantustan"? Gaza was ruled by Egypt-- then by Israel. Israel withdrew-- there's not a single Jew left in the entire place. The Arabs in Gaza are now ruling it as they see fit.

But the propaganda about how trrible life is there is just that-- propaganda. The Palestinians there have self-rule-- they rule as they see fit. (Remember, they elected Hamas-- a brutal terror group-- to govern them). Do you think they'd be better off in another Arab country-- Egypt? Syria? Iraq? Yemen? Libya? Life is not easy under a brutal terror gov't (Hamas)-- but this "bantustan" is better than in those other Arab countries:

Arab propaganda makes you believe that there is nothing but suffering in Gaza... Some images, though, will never be on your tv. Why ? Because Gaza is not at all what you think it is. And billions of oil money are spent to make sure that you will continue to think this way...


 
 
 
1ofmany
Sophomore Silent
link   1ofmany    12 years ago
"You miss the irony. Israel is not stopping the Palestinians from building this-- this would not have ever taken place in Apartheid South Africa. It is giving the right to do what they want. So, having the freedom to do that, look what they are building. Its their choice!"I see no irony. Whether or not South Africa would have permitted this complex does not, to me, have anything to do with resisting a colonial occupation. If the NAZIs permitted the French collaborators to build such a complex, would it negate the validity of the French resistance? And no I'm not saying Jews are NAZIs. As for propaganda, it works both ways. There are many articles on Palestinian conditions but, even if they were not true, Palestinians still have the right to resist. More importantly, they will resist no matter what we think.
 
 
 
Petey Coober
Freshman Silent
link   Petey Coober    12 years ago

Palestinians still have the right to resist.

Resist what ?

 
 
 
1ofmany
Sophomore Silent
link   1ofmany    12 years ago
"Resist what ?"Being controlled.
 
 
 
Krishna
Professor Guide
link   seeder  Krishna    12 years ago

Resist what ?

Resist democracy. Resist equality for minorities, those with different beliefs-- or anyone who is different. Resist any 21st century ideas.

Of course there are many who don't resist-- yes, there are progressives.but their views are most highly resisted:-- the "resistance in action":

 
 
 
Krishna
Professor Guide
link   seeder  Krishna    12 years ago

But the best example of Palestinian "resistance" of progress and human rights is by far Hamas:

 
 
 
Petey Coober
Freshman Silent
link   Petey Coober    12 years ago

Hamas is far worse in terms of control than Israel ever was . But the pervasive racism of the Gazans prevents them from seeing that . They elected Hamas . Now they are stuck with them because Hamas refuses to hold another election . That is what abusive control is like ... Then there was the slaughter of Fatah members a few years ago to wrest CONTROL from them .

Fools are easily persuaded to avoid freedom and its responsibilities . Falling for racist rhetoric is a symptom stupidity . Gaza in a nutshell ...

 
 
 
1ofmany
Sophomore Silent
link   1ofmany    12 years ago
Krishna posted a pretty picture of a planned Palestinian complex and essentially wondered why anyone would complain about living like that. Of course, it's for rich people but I'll skip that for the moment. I'll ask a similar question about us. The American colonies didn't have it that bad. We had nice cities. Some people were quite wealthy, lived in mansions, had servants etc. Yet they violently revolted against the British crown. Why did we need to be free of domination yet others do not?
 
 
 
Petey Coober
Freshman Silent
link   Petey Coober    12 years ago

Why did we need to be free of domination yet others do not?

Definite causes ... instead of racist rants against Jews ?

 
 
 
1ofmany
Sophomore Silent
link   1ofmany    12 years ago

Why did we need to be free of domination yet others do not?

Definite causes ... instead of racist rants against Jews ?

So we should be free for whatever reason we like but they should be dominated because you don't like their views. We are perfectly justified in freeing ourselves by force of arms. They, on the other hand, are supposed to beg peacefully for independence until the sun burns out.

 
 
 
Dean Moriarty
Professor Silent
link   Dean Moriarty    12 years ago
Wtf it looks like Indian ruins from hundreds of years ago. They need to hire some of the architects from Dubai. Those guys know how to build a city.
 
 
 
1ofmany
Sophomore Silent
link   1ofmany    12 years ago

Not being from the USA I'm no expert on its history, but I always thought the revolution against the British crown had nothing to do with colonialism or domination, but it was caused by taxation (especially taxation without representation).

How can you separate the cause from the effect? The causes of the revolution are directly related to a dependent colonialstatus. We fought for independence to break the colonial relationship. I recognize that our colonial arrangement wasdifferent than one created throughconquestbut, to me, breaking a chain is breaking a chain.

 
 
 
Krishna
Professor Guide
link   seeder  Krishna    12 years ago

Krishna posted a pretty picture of a planned Palestinian complex and essentially wondered why anyone would complain about living like that. Of course, it's for rich people

You completely missed the point.

People constantly complain about "The Occupation:, "Apartheid", "Genocide", etc, etc. Basically, that the Israeli presence gives no freedom to Palestinians to act as they wish.

However, here's something pretty amazing-- they gave the Palestinians the right to create their own new city. That would never happen under Apartheid!!!

And beyond that, the Israelis aren't even dictating to the Palis what type of city they should build. They even gave the Palis freedom to decide that themselves, rather than dictating it.

Given the extraordinary freedom the Palis had to make that choice (believe me-- there's no way these things would happen under Apartheid)...the Palis made their decision. its seems a bit far-fetched that when Israel allowed them that freedom of choice... to blame Israel for what the Palis themselves!

And BTW, even beyond that: they allowed them to fly the "Palestinian flag" (the flag of what it is assumed will be a soverign nation)-- WTF kind of brutal occupation is that?

Palestinian_flags.jpg

 
 
 
Larry Hampton
Professor Quiet
link   Larry Hampton    12 years ago

Apartheid is a stupid and false analogy, that belittles what South Africans suffered and fought through, and does nothing to promote understanding or peace in the Middle East. What Apartheid is though in this instance, is a sound-bite talking point used by the BDS movement to try and lend legitimacy to their cause, by demonizing Israel. It is in essence, pure BS to use it in describing the I/P situation.

 
 
 
1ofmany
Sophomore Silent
link   1ofmany    12 years ago
"You completely missed the point. People constantly complain about "The Occupation:, "Apartheid", "Genocide", etc, etc. Basically, that the Israeli presence gives no freedom to Palestinians to act as they wish . . ."I got your point but I disagree with the premise. Independence is the right to set your own rules. It's not the degree to which someone controls you but rather the fact that they can control you as they see fit when they want. Even a velvet cage is still a cage. One other commonality that Israel has with South Africans the length of time it took for Americans to understand what the rest of the world already knew i.e. That apartheid is wrong. To me, you give people the opportunity to break the chain that binds you. If they won't listen and you have no other effective alternative, then break it yourself.
 
 
 
1ofmany
Sophomore Silent
link   1ofmany    12 years ago
"Apartheid is a stupid and false analogy, that belittles what South Africans suffered and fought through, and does nothing to promote understanding or peace in the Middle East. What Apartheid is though in this instance, is a sound-bite talking point used by the BDS movement to try and lend legitimacy to their cause, by demonizing Israel. It is in essence, pure BS to use it in describing the I/P situation."To me, the analogy is sound. However, in the end, the Palestinians will be independent. You can do it the easy way or the hard way but it will happen.
 
 
 
Larry Hampton
Professor Quiet
link   Larry Hampton    12 years ago

Independence is the right to set your own rules. It's not the degree to which someone controls you but rather the fact that they can control you as they see fit when they want.

If only Hamas, the Arab league, and nearly every other Arab country understood and abided by such logic, they would free the Palestinians from being used as idiots and spoilers; and, allow them to chose their own path. Perhaps even, the Palestinians should have enough gumption and balls, to fight their true hamas/Arab/Persian masters, for freedom, have a true "arab spring" ,and free themselves from those binds they have allowed to be put on them by the same. Until then, Israel has no choice but to defend themselves.

 
 
 
Krishna
Professor Guide
link   seeder  Krishna    12 years ago

What Apartheid is though in this instance, is a sound-bite talking point used by the BDS movement to try and lend legitimacy to their cause, by demonizing Israel. It is in essence, pure BS to use it in describing the I/P situation."

True-- most of the ignorant assholes who make that accusation have no idea what life is like in Israel:

hebrewu.png

 
 
 
Larry Hampton
Professor Quiet
link   Larry Hampton    12 years ago
 
 
 
Krishna
Professor Guide
link   seeder  Krishna    12 years ago

Independence is the right to set your own rules. It's not the degree to which someone controls you but rather the fact that they can control you as they see fit when they want.

Agreed. Which raises two relevant questions:

1. There are some 20+ Arab countries. In how many of them do the people "set their own rules". In how many of them is there totalitarian rule of either a secular dictatorship or an Islamist state?

2. What makes you think that if/when there is a third independent Palestinian state created (the two existing Palestines where Arabs have total self rule being Gaza and Jordan), it will be any different than the 20 or so others that now exist?

 
 

Who is online