Holder: Change laws to let ex-convicts vote
WASHINGTON Attorney General Eric Holder called Tuesday for the repeal of state laws that restrict the voting rights of millions of former prison inmates.
In a speech to the Leadership Conference on Civil and Human Rights at Georgetown University Law Center, Holder said it is "time to fundamentally re-think laws that permanently disenfranchise people who are no longer under federal or state supervision.''
"These restrictions are not only unnecessary and unjust, they are also counterproductive,'' the attorney general said. "By perpetuating the stigma and isolation imposed on formerly incarcerated individuals, the laws increase the likelihood they will commit future crimes.''
The proposal is an extension of a broader plan first announced by Holder last year to revamp the U.S. criminal justice system, including the re-integration of thousands of former offenders who are returning to communities every year from prison.
Holder said former offenders "continue to face significant obstacles,'' citing laws in 11 states that bar millions from voting.
"Across this country today, an estimated 5.8 million Americans are prohibited from voting because of current or previous felony convictions,'' Holder said. "That's more than the individual populations of 31 U.S. states. And although well over a century has passed since post-Reconstruction states used these measures to strip African Americans of their most fundamental rights, the impact of felony disenfranchisement on modern communities of color remains both disproportionate and unacceptable.''
He said 2.2 million African Americans, or nearly one in 13 African-American adults, are banned from voting because of the laws. In three states Florida, Kentucky and Virginia that ratio is one in five. In Florida, Holder said, 10 percent of the entire population is disenfranchised as a result of the state's prohibitions on ex-offenders.
"The history of felony disenfranchisement dates to a time when these policies were employed not to improve public safety, but purely as punitive measures intended to stigmatize, shame and shut out a person who had been found guilty of a crime,'' Holder said.
Since 1997, Holder said 23 states have enacted changes, including in Virginia where last year the voting rights of former inmates with non-violent felony convictions began to be restored.
"I applaud those who have already shown leadership in raising awareness and helping to address this issue,'' Holder said, citing the efforts of Democrats and Republicans, including Sen. Rand Paul, R-Ky. "His vocal support for restoring voting rights for former inmates shows that this issue need not break down along partisan lines.''
Civil rights advocates said the attorney general's proposal was necessary to the full re-integration of offenders when they are released from prison.
"Citizens with criminal convictions who are living and working in our communities should have the responsibility and the right to participate in our democracy by voting,'' said Myrna Perez, deputy director of the Democracy Program at the Brennan Center for Justice. "The attorney general's announcement is a significant step forward for democracy.''
In Florida, a spokesman for Republican Gov. Rick Scott said Holder's remarks would not have any bearing on the current state constitution, which "prescribes that individuals who commit felonies forfeit their right to vote.''
"For those who are truly remorseful for how they have wrecked families and want to earn back their right to vote, Florida's constitution also provides a process to have their rights restored," spokesman Frank Collins said. That process requires applicants to win approval from the governor and two cabinet members before voting rights are restored.
In Iowa, where former offenders once had their voting rights restored automatically after completing their terms according to an executive order issued in 2005 by then-Gov. Thomas Vilsack, they now must apply for reinstatement and be approved by Gov. Terry Branstad, a Republican.
In 2011 Branstad rescinded Vilsack's order and replaced it with the application requirement.
"The governor believes that when an individual commits a felony, it is fair they earn their rights back by paying restitution to their victim, court costs and fines,'' spokesman Jimmy Centers said. "Iowa has a good and fair policy on the restoration of rights for convicted felons, and to automatically restore the right to vote without requiring the completion of the responsibilities associated with the criminal conviction would damage the balance between the rights and responsibility of citizens. Too often, victims are forgotten and it is important victims of felonies and serious crimes receive their restitution.''
http://www.usatoday.com/story/news/nation/2014/02/11/holder-voting-rights-ex-felons/5377119/
Tags
Who is online
91 visitors

Another wonderful idea from Holder. Unbelievable!
When they get out they have to work and pay taxes; every item they purchase, goods and services, they pay taxes. If they are integrated back into society and contributing to it, they deserve the privilege of voting.
I agree Mimi. They have paid for the crime, and if they are participating in our society in a meaningful way (i.e. taxes) they should have the right to vote. This isn't the "Scarlet Letter".
Great, I'm looking forward to voting once again.
Yea well if our inept government could handle a system like that I would agree. The sad truth is that many are repeat offenders and that would mean we would need a system in place to monitor when they get out and get back in, when they start paying taxes again (what about those in for tax evasion?) Based on the ACA website price tag I would estimate 300 million to build a system to accomplish this that is so bug ridden it doesn't work. Any more ideas?
Bad ass, Kavika! LOL!
Why would we need a new system? Every convict that comes out of jail is on probation. It is up to the probation officer to keep tabs on what they are doing, which includes meaningful employment. It really is no harder than that.
Well, even a broken clock is right 2 times a day.
I'm on the fence about this.
One the one hand, if you've paid your debt to society, you should have your rights restored to you. If the debt wasn't large enough, then you shouldn't have been freed. But you were.
On the other hand, there should always be reminders of your criminality, whatever degree of severity was involved. We are too quick to forgive, and that causes us to shrug off otherwise serious and egregious violations of our laws. Not having the right to vote is an appropriate stigma to attach to people. It is not a public display of shame, but a private reminder of one's overstepping where there should have been none.
So you are saying branches of the government would just have to cooperate...like the CIA and FBI?
It's a first for me, too, BF.
One of the reason so many are repeat offenders is because of the attitude of society when they come out and try to assimilate, especially the very young who idealistically think that once they have done their time they are entitled to a fresh start.
They come out and find out that society never forgives nor forgets and they may as well be wearing that scarlet letter Perrie mentions in her post. In addition, they have the mandate of being on probation and having to pay a probation officer every month plus restitution or go back into prison... something that is hard to do when you can't get anyone to give you a job.
In desperation to try and stay out of the hell of prison, they turn to the one thing guaranteed to put them back in, in an effort to try and pay their fines... crime.
Plus, they are burdened with a host of "rules" that can land them back in prison if they are found violating them. The main one that burns me up is the one that says they are not allowed to be around or drink alcohol, a legal beverage in every state in the Union.
This means they cannot attend any social functions where it is being served or indulge in a beer in their own home. I do not drink at all and have no fondness for drunks; but to say that someone cannot have a cold one in their own home or attend a family gathering where the rest of the crew is sure to have alcoholic beverages for fear of being sent back to prison is the height of two-faced old fashioned religious right wing stupidity.
I am saying that when you are let out of jail, you go on parole. This is done state by state, and since voting is the responsibility of the state, each parole officer can quickly identify which ex-cons are in compliance and report those that are not. This is the way it works even when an ex-con leaves the state (think Magen's law). So it doesn't involve the CIA (BTW they usually only deal with national security)or the FBI, who doesn't deal with ex-cons at all.
Again, got to agree with ya Mimi.
Jonathan,
First, as a nation, we have the highest percentage of prison than any other western country. That should tell you something. One of the things is that we have people in jail for crimes that are barely crimes, like drug usage, or white collar crimes, or over zealous DA's. I personally know of two such cases. One never did time, since the charge was ridiculous, and the other was screwed, since he had no idea he was involved in a crime. He was just a lawyer issuing an IP and had nothing to offer the DA, so they punished him, since the ring leader fled the country.
Also, once you have been punished (jail), that should be the end of it. You have been punished. You had time removed from your life that you can never get back. Time is the one thing that is irreplaceable in life.. I can't think of anything worse.
Finally, since these inmates do come out after jail, shouldn't we as a society want to try to get them back on the straight and narrow, so that we are not warehousing them again and again? Part of that is reintegrating them into society, and voting is a way of doing that. Parole is supposed to be a period of reintegration under supervision.That should be enough.
"I do solemnly swear (or affirm) that I will faithfully execute the office of President of the United States, and will to the best of my ability, preserve, protect, and defend the Constitution of the United States."
From the Constitution of the United States:
Article I
Section 1
All legislative Powers herein granted shall be vested in a Congress of the United States, which shall consist of a Senate and House of Representatives
Article II
Section 1
1: The executive Power shall be vested in a President of the United States of America.
Section 3
he shall take Care that the Laws be faithfully executed
Article [X]
The powers not delegated to the United States by the Constitution, nor prohibited by it to the States, are reserved to the States respectively, or to the people.
I have no basis to debate anything you've said. In fact, I'll go one step further to say that I completelyagree with your first two paragraphs.
You are, however, addressing a completely different problem.
Your problem does indeed exacerbate the problem that the article poses, but that's not a reason to change the law; it's a reason to change the system that causes these excessive incarcerations. Should we give parolees the vote because the criminal justice system is busted? I don't know. But I DO know that, if the criminal justice system is busted, it should be fixed.
That's got nothing to do with the conflict we're addressing.
Sure I did. I explained it in an earlier comment:
and
At the possible expense of going in circles, I addressed my misgiving of that in my original post:
On the other hand, there should always be reminders of your criminality, whatever degree of severity was involved. We are too quick to forgive, and that causes us to shrug off otherwise serious and egregious violations of our laws. Not having the right to vote is an appropriate stigma to attach to people. It is not a public display of shame, but a private reminder of one's overstepping where there should have been none.
Joanne,
I am missing your point. I am not advocating for convicts to run for office.
The CIA/FBI reference was simply to illustrate the fact that our government doesn't work with itself.
I agree. If you are a productive citizen, you deserve all the rights and privileges of said citizenship.
Oddly enough 96, our member Flameaway is finding out that in this department, the authorities that deal with this, seem to work very well... maybe, even over zealously well.... and yet move very slowly when it comes to giving you your day in court.
Whatever point she is trying to make, voting for the president of the United States is a national thing so the rules governing who is allowed to vote should be decided by Congress, not on a state by state basis.
As far as allowing "criminals" to vote, once having served their sentence, they are no longer criminals, thus should be allowed to vote, and should not be burdened by all the nonsense that is part and parcel of the rules dumped on them by probation.
You can't integrate into society if you are being kept apart from it by restrictive rules that actually serve no purpose.
Private or public, what purpose does shame do? If the system has seen the convict as "punished", do we as a society continue to shame, either publicly or privately? It's like punishing a child. We do so to correct a behavior, and not to shame. Furthermore, people who lack shame, are considered sociopaths, and should never leave the correctional system.
Years behind bars with family and friends knowing this, should be enough shame.
Spot on!
Agreed, 96.
Imo, the problem, as with most laws, is the one-size-fits-all notion. Some ex-convicts have earned their civilian rights back into society (the nature of the crime should be considered--serving time doesn't necessarily correlate to repeat causation), and some haven't. They just served time.
Someone that went to jail on principle, rather than an act that 'did' cause harm, should be given different considerations. I think the issue should be handled and monitored - case by case.
Dennis,
I have lived in England, and they have laws that are enforced as do most of the western world. It doesn't explain why we have the highest percentage of people in jail.
Please explain. Are you saying that we have too many laws on the books?
Every other year isn't an election year. If we limited ourselves to non election years to stop what might look like political motivation (personally I think most things are politically motivated even in non-election years) then nothing would get done. Wait! Nothing is getting done. Proved my point!
Dennis, I agree. Haven't we seen legislation or information that will increase large numbers of people to vote for it (as an incentive), and therefore, the candidate - will be promoted; legislation or information that will decrease that candidate's popularity is held until after the election. Sometimes it never happens; it was just dangling a carrot for votes.
I still say, as I implied in my other comment..and you might be implying the same, that we have too many laws that are only for taxation to make money for the Feds. Have you noticed things are often only a 'crime' until they can come up with a tax for it - then it's perfectly legal--that's ludicrous. We have too many laws that fall into that category sending people to jail on 'principle' that didn't cause themselves or anyone else any 'harm.'
Here, let me put the pieces together for you. You did all the writing, Per.
Private or public, what purpose does shame do?
And then
Furthermore, people who lack shame, are considered sociopaths,
Admittedly, shame is a powerful tool. And grossly underused. There are many reasons why people who go to jail often end up there again. Lack of shame is one of those, even if it does represent a small factor.
That's my understanding too, Egilman.
Jon,
The presumption here is that most prisoners are sociopaths. This, in fact, is not the case. The reason that most people are repeat offenders is usually for the same crime. Recidivism is more often not for the lack of feeling shame, but more the circumstances that an individual keeps finding themselves in after prison. Disenfranchisement is one of those circumstances. So in either case, shame is not an effective tool, unless revenge is what we are talking about.
EG,
I am a bit confused to your point.
The point is - most get their rights once they aren't on parole, if that is their situation. Some are automatic, some have to apply - but they have to prove themselves worthy of responsibility, if they apply.
Hodor.
Egilman,
Just quoting this excerpt so you know which comment of yours I'm referencing:
I don't see why you needed to reiterate the article points when you previously made the clear and concise point that most states give suffrage, and when it needs to be proven that someone is a reformed, responsible, civilized person - then, they too, are granted their rights. It's part of our 'justice' system - part of what is supposed to be a deterrent to future crime - losing our freedoms.
I do agree that it 'seems' like a mindset would come with feeling like a criminal if they are restricted - if they are treated like one, but it isn't that way if they have proven they have reformed.
The reason we have the highest % of criminals incarcerated people is that for the most part we have laws and they are [selectively] enforced (for the benefit of the "for profit" prison corporations.)
- corrected for accuracy.
True. I also tried to take this from a 'votes' perspective, looking up on the internet if there are more liberals than conservatives in prison (lol), knowing that would be a difficult comparison to tally. I only found one conservative site that dared tackle the answer, and that really isn't enough for consideration.
Why now? I agree, that's a valid question. President Obama has been in Office since '09.