╌>

Most Ineffective Legislator in Congress - 23 Years in Office = 0 Bills into Law

  

Category:  News & Politics

Via:  pokermike  •  12 years ago  •  3 comments

Most Ineffective Legislator in Congress - 23 Years in Office = 0 Bills into Law

In his 23 years in Congress, Rep. Robert E. Andrews (D-N.J.) has written 646 different pieces of legislation . That is a vast array of bills, covering a vast number of subjects: childrens pajamas , relations with Taiwan , commemorative coins and trade duties on licorice .

But all of Andrewss bills had one thing in common.

They didnt become law.

Only four of Andrewss hundreds of bills have ever passed the House of Representatives. But none of them passed the Senate, so none made it to the presidents desk.

Even in Congress, where the vast majority of bills fail, that is an unusually awful batting average. By those numbers, Andrews would be Americas least successful lawmaker of the past two decades.

Andrews, 56, said Tuesday he would resign in two weeks , taking a position at the law firm Dilworth Paxson . In an interview Tuesday, he insisted that these statistics dont capture his true record in Congress.

The reason, he said, is that the classic idea of how lawmaking works an idea becomes a bill, the bill gets a debate, and the debate ends with a vote does not mean much on todays Capitol Hill.

Im Just a Bill on Capitol Hill is not the way this works. Freestanding bills almost never happen, Andrews said, referencing the Schoolhouse Rock cartoon about how a bill sings and dances its way through Congress.

Instead, lawmaking is now done with massive pieces of legislation crammed full of ideas that might have little to do with one another. What looks like failure, Andrews said, is actually his success at working the new system.

You should ask yourself how many of the ideas that were a seed planted in the bill that germinated in a larger bill. Thats the way this really works, he said. In all, he estimated, about 110 of his ideas have become law after being stuck into somebody elses bill.

Andrews has spent the past two decades as a semi-liberal backbencher with no real leadership roles in the House. Andrewss legislative clout was reduced sharply when Republicans took the House in 2011, and also by lingering allegations that he used campaign funds to pay for personal and family trips.

But a look at Andrewss bills shows that his lawmaking ambitions have been enormous, even when his power was not.

Since Andrews arrived in Congress, no other representative has introduced more bills. In second place is Rep. Carolyn B. Maloney (D-N.Y.) , followed by Rep. Don Young (R-Alaska) , Rep. Charles B. Rangel (D-N.Y.) and former congressman Ron Paul (R-Tex. ).

But all of those other lawmakers have managed to pass something into law sometime in their career. Maloney has had nine bills signed into law. Young has had 76. Rangel has had 38. And even Paul had one, a minor bill to convey a piece of federal property in Galveston, Tex.

Andrews has not. The closest he has come has been to watch a senator introduce a bill similar to one of his and then see that Senate bill become law. Thats happened twice, according to Joshua Tauberer , whose site govtrack.us allows users to track and compare vast amounts of data on Congress.

Although it was the companion bills to Andrewss that were enacted, Tauberer said, he should get some credit for their success.

Only one of the two companion bills will actually become law, but the work to get either enacted may have been shared by the two sponsors equally, Tauberer said. Its helpful to keep companion bills in mind when quantifying legislative activity.

In one case, in 1992, both Andrews and Sen. Frank R. Lautenberg (D-N.J.) introduced bills to name a federal courthouse in Camden, N.J . Lautenbergs version was the one the president signed.

Also, in 1999, both Andrews and Sen. Jeff Sessions (R-Ala.) introduced bills that changed the rules governing benefit plans run by churches. It was Sessionss bill that, after significant amendments, became law.

The many other bills submitted by Andrews have, over the years, included 11 related to Taiwan, often seeking to show U.S. support for that country in its disputes with China. He has sponsored five bills to mint a commemorative coin in honor of Korean immigrants. And he has introduced at least 30 bills that would lower duties on chemicals used in manufacturing everything from licorice extract to methoxycarbonyl-terminated perfluorinated polyoxymethylene-polyoxyethylene .

And he struck out every time.

At least on paper.

People think ... well, you introduce a bill, and then you walk around and try to get people to co-sponsor it and then it passes, Andrews said. You know, that happens about as often as a black swan.

Instead, Andrews says, he introduces bills so that he has legislative language ready for an opening. That opening, usually, is what Hill staffers call a moving vehicle a giant piece of legislation that, unlike most of Congresss inert bills, actually has a chance of passage.

What happens in 90 percent of the [cases] is that certain bills move because they have to, Andrews said often because some important deadline is about to expire. And those bills carry with them hundreds of ideas, or thousands of ideas that people have worked on over the years.

Andrews said he has learned how to get his ideas on board by stockpiling legislative language that can be easily picked up and inserted into larger legislation.

As evidence of his success, he cited changes to the military health-care program Tricare and rules about insurance coverage of orthotic devices. Some other ideas have changed government policy without being passed in any form: In 2012, Andrews trumpeted a decision by mortgage firms Fannie Mae and Freddie Mac to require prompt decisions on short sales. Andrewss actual bill to require that change had died on Capitol Hill.

Link: http://www.washingtonpost.com/politics/andrews-proposed-646-bills-passed-0-worst-record-of-past-20-years/2014/02/04/3240bb4e-8dbb-11e3-833c-33098f9e5267_story.html?hpid=z3


Tags

jrDiscussion - desc
[]
 
pokermike
Freshman Silent
link   seeder  pokermike    12 years ago

It figures a politician from my home state of NJ would be the most ineffective Congressman in the past two decades. In addition to his uselessness, it appears he is also corrupt. Regardless of party affiliation or ideological leaning, I think we can all agree guys like this have no place in office.

Thankfully, he is resigning his office in two weeks.

The Garden State Democrat got caught spending campaign funds on perks like a family trip to Scotland, travel to Tinseltown with his daughter, and even a high school graduation party.

Rep. Andrews has also earmarked more than $1.5 million for Rutgers University School of Law, his wifes employer.

  • Thirteen-term member of Congress representing New Jerseys 1st district
  • Used campaign funds on personal perks and privileges for his family, and earmarked more than $1.5 million for his wifes employer
  • Under investigation by the House Ethics Committee
  • Previously named to CREWs Most Corrupt in 2012
 
 
 
Perrie Halpern R.A.
Professor Guide
link   Perrie Halpern R.A.    12 years ago

LOL Mike,

He seems to be pretty quiet, too. I have never heard of him and being a from NY, you would think I would have.

 
 
 
pokermike
Freshman Silent
link   seeder  pokermike    12 years ago

I had never heard of him either. I was from North Jersey and his district was down in the Camden area. His brain-dead constituency overwhelmingly re-elected him in 2012 by a nearly 68%-30% margin. This despite publicized reports of his spending $30,000 in campaign funds the previous year for the family vacation to Scotland.

All this argument over voter-ID doesn't go far enough. They should add either an IQ test or an EEG to test for brain activity before one is allowed to vote in this country.

 
 

Who is online


91 visitors