Black Residents Reject Trader Joe’s Because It Would Attract Too Many White People
The Trader Joes grocery chain has withdrawn plans to build a store in the heart of a predominantly black neighborhood after a black leadership group fought the move.
The Portland Development Commission was set to give the grocer a large discount on property thathad been vacant for years, pricing it at just over $500,000, down from an appraised value of $2.9 million, according to The Oregonian.
The Portland African American Leadership Forum sent a scathing letter in December to city leaders, saying the plan would price residents out of the area and the groupremains opposed to any development in North/Northeast Portland that does not primarily benefit the black community.
Trader Joes wouldincrease displacement of low-income residents and increase the desirability of the neighborhood, for non-oppressed populations, PAALF wrote.
[This decision] reflects the citys overall track record of implementing policies that serve to uproot, displace and disempower our most vulnerable community members, the letter said.
Trader Joes bowed out amid the controversy.
We run neighborhood stores, and our approach is simple: If a neighborhood does not want a Trader Joes, we understand, and we wont open the store in question, a company spokesperson said in a statement to The Oregonian.
But not everyone is happy about the outcome.
There are no winners today, Adam Milne, owner of Old Town Brewing Co., told The Oregonian. Only missed tax revenue, lost jobs, less foot traffic, an empty lot and a boulevard still struggling to support its local small businesses.
http://www.bizpacreview.com/2014/02/08/black-residents-reject-trader-joes-because-it-would-attract-too-many-white-people-99333

This sounds like anti-urban development.
I am sure a vacant piece of property is better for the neighborhood than a business that employs people and pays taxes.
Looks the Leadership Forum wants to keep "them" out of the neighborhood.
You mean like - - - integration???????
Say it isn't so.
(This was supposed to respond toJ4T's comment below).
This is racism and would not be tolerated by a white group. It's disgusting that a black group can do it with impunity.
John
Indeed
Ever heard of urban development and neighborhood revitalization?
John
I have been to a number of Trader Joes, seen people of all ethnic backgrounds and never once noticed anything that would indicate that "other than white" people were not welcome
J F T
Finally some reasonable and believable feedback
Thanks for that tidbit of informaiton
Actually I think the corporate response was that if theLeadership Forumdoes not want a business to buy the vacant lot and put a viable business employing people and paying taxes in their neighborhood that the corporation will simply go elsewhere.
scremminmimim
You mean you don't think it is right or that it would be accepted for a white neighborhood group to demand that the city not allow a black owned business into their neighborhood?
Double standards are at least standards I guess
No it isn't right. It has never been right. I grew up in Alabama, in the country, and the country store was owned and operated by an elderly black couple, so sometimes I overlook the sarcasm, RIO.
Not all the stereotypes fit all the situations you people imagine.
scremminmimi
I was agreeing with you my friend
I think the action to keep the business out of the neighborhood was wrong as well
I was referring to the double standards of the Leadership Forum in Portland
My bad, RIO, I apologize.
no worries
sorry my comment could have been clearer
You are making bullshit excuses here, John. Call it what it is. It is racism.
That is racism. It excludes anyone but the black community, making that area of Portland exclusive to the black community.
Yes, it does. They do not want the store there because they do not want anything but blacks setting up in that area of Portland. They stated so in the letter. If the area is run down because of the element living there, the black leaders have done nothing to build it up and want it to stay that way, so much so that they don't want anything moving in that will build it up and attract other ethnicities, including whites.
That is the epitome of racism.
Come on, JT. Blacks go to KFC as well. This is getting ridiculous.
I don't eat KFC any more either, Gunny, because they appear to endorse racism against Indians.
S b L r
I agree which is what grabbed my attention when I saw the article and made me decide to share it and get some comments
John
So if a neighborhood group of white people opposed the opening of a minority owned business or a business associated with minorities to preserve their neighborhood it would be okay with you?
J F T
Ojay, would you be okay with a group that opposed a Popeye's franchise being opened in their neighborhood because it would attract the wrong kind of people to the neighborhood?
I wouldn't assume to speak for any population-be it white or black as there's far more to it than just my opinions being fact. Seems you paint with far too wide a brush, JFT.
As is your assumption of 'gentrification', John. Far too much assumption based on far too few facts.
Did they say they didn't?
"I don't think the controversy here involves white skin."
You obviously haven't thought much about it then.
Well I see complaints against gentrification is alive and well. Do any of you have any suggestions other than keeping the whites out? Any suggestions? I mean, do you think it is better to leave it the way it is or just give some suggestions as to what you think would be better. I'm open to any suggestions.
Randy,
This must be some west coast thing. Here on the east coast, everyone goes to Trader Joes. Harlem even has a Whole Foods. They are even talking about putting a Trader Joes into the where I used to work, Brownsville, Brooklyn, and you don't get poorer than that, and who wants it? The black leadership:
J F T
And there would be jobs and more income for residents and more taxes to pay for improving their neighborhoods
Perrie
Same situation in NE Ohio and W Pa
scremminmimi
Indeed it is
So what shakes on the west coast?
hmmmm....I thought we were all for the dissolution of segregation. Wouldnt creating an atmosphere wherein blacks and whites could co-exist be beneficial. In a sense, Trader Joes could have been an ambassador of racial peace in that area. But alas, 'twas not to be....and the tension lives on.
And the Blacks in Portland evidently want to keep the division, racism and segregation to continue in full force. So much for Equality, eh? Wonder what the NAACP and CORE would have to say about that? Jesse??? Al?????
G G and G
Could of, would of, should of
They just opened one here recently, though I haven't been there (other markets a lot closer), in our Euro/African/Central and South America/Middle Eastern/Far Eastern melting pot here in WNY.
I have to echo your question, Perrie, what gives on the West Coast?
1stwarrior
I am sure the reverends will have little to say about this since it does not support their agenda
Nonsense
Dude. I go to Popeyes (whenever I can find one). I'm white. You used a Broad Brush. Use a smaller one.
And dammit all, there's no Popeye's here.
Meaning wishful thinking?
I'm still getting the hang of everybody's posting styles after a long hiatus, so I'm not certain which direction you are taking here.
No meaning I agree with you that the introduction of Trader Joes could have been a good thingfor theneighborhood
Cool. Thanks for clarifying. Like I say, still getting used to the styles of many of our members.
"Gentrification - the buying and renovation of houses and stores in deteriorated urban neighborhoods by upper- or middle-income families or individuals, thus improving property values but often displacing low-income families and small businesses."
And this is a problem why John?
And you know that for a fact, right? Then tell me why my rent went DOWN because of gentrification - in California???
Didn't think you did or could.
Thanks for your response.
No one has addressed the point that a business on the vacant and dilapidated property would raise property taxes for the area, create jobs and perhaps draw other businesses into the area that would do the same.
Or let property fall further into disrepair, depressing property values and producing no tax revenues for the city
One is a positive step forward and one is inaction and even a step backward.
This is probably the reason the scathing letter was sent. The slum lords who rent to the black people in the area are likely black and don't want the status quo changed. They like it the way it is.
If property taxes are raised they would be required to raise rents on tenants who would rebel because they would not be able to pay the higher rents. They would move, leaving the properties empty and the slum lords without the income.
John
This was about a store opening not a housing development of homes priced higher than the residents can afford
I trust that if the situation is reversed and a predominantly white neighborhood does not want to allow a minority owned or oriented business into their town that you will feel the same way
Yeah - I wanted to clarify what you just said - it don't always happen. But, surely the Black leadership knows this - so why would they not want to be a part of the planning/development?
So, we're back to greed again, eh?
We're back to that quicksand area politicians, businessmen and activists try to avoid in reality yet use as talking points to amass money for campaigns and donations to charities...
they are saying that blacks can only thrive in a low rent run down atmosphere and they cannot assimilate with successful whites.
And before anyone jumps on my case about this, I am only putting into words what the black leaders of this Portland area pussy-footed around about in the letter they sent. If they had any idea how to get this area off its butt and on its feet to benefit the black community that is there they would have already done so; they don't.
All they know is that they can't have a Trader Joe's, which would bring a white influence to the area, set up shop there because it would be a negative influence on the black community and drive them out.
They said it, I repeated it.
This makes no sense. Usually when an area is improved what goes up is the cost of housing, not real estate tax, and that is even a big if. It's just one business on ground that no one is using.
In NYC, theparadigm has been that when business has moved into depressed areas, everyone benefit and no one had their property tax increased. The people who were the most screwed by the system, were the artist community. They would move into loft spaces that were no longer being used, convert them to livable space, and since this was not housing previously, the landlords could do with them as they pleased, which was price them out. That isn't what is going on here, and I have to wonder why a neighborhood wouldn't want to better itself.
Perrie
The point was that the business will be paying property tax, income tax, payroll tax those are the taxes that would be created (when I said raised I meant raised as revenue for the city)
I meant that tax revenue would rise not tax rates
Sorry for being uncear
So why would these black leaders not want this business there? Is there a lot of drug dealing in the area and they are afraid a successful business would bring in better law enforcement scrutiny and ruin it?
Something is just not right with this scenario unless the guys who own the local stores raking in the money from the food stamps from the poor in that area are the guys who wrote the letter.
Follow the money.
John
Thanks
I read the articles and gleaned the following -
The leadership forum wanted to use the Trader Joe's deal as leverage to gain concessions and money from the city/state and Trader Joe's decided not to be part of the group's struggle with the city.
The second article likens the building of Trader Joe's on a vacant lot to displacement -displacement of nothing I guess since the lot is vacant.
That the Leadership Forum is shocked that Trader Joe's decided to go elsewhere is laughable as there actions to try and put Trader Joe's on the middle of the forum's attempts to leverage money out of the city/state are the exact and only reason that Trader Joe's will not be in there neighborhood.
Perhaps they will build a park or a ball field on the property that will benefit the community more than a business would have anyway
I am not sure who owns the food stores in the local area. In most on NYC poorest neighborhood, the shop owners are Latino or Asian. The Latinos live in the area and so this is their lively hood and I get that. The Asians don't and there has been tension in the past.
If the local shop owners are from the area, I can understand why they wouldn't want a shop like that opening. In which case, they would complain to their leaders, and their leaders who probably get more than just their vote, would listen to these shop owners. Other than that, I don't get it.
It is amazing to me that a black community organizer with no roots in the community in question, can write a letter disrupting a planned project that the majority of the community seems to have wanted, and that would have benefited the residents and the city.
The Indian tribes need to send a few people to her leadership training sessions.
I think Trader Joe's made the right decision to just move on and let the great leaders of the this community continue to do the same great job they have done so far which has not helped the community evidently. Let the people have what they want.
According to the links posted by John, from reading those articles, the people in the community wanted Trader Joe's and were looking forward to having the store there as a corner stone to building up the area. They are upset about the store pulling out and say the organization that wrote the letter doesn't speak for them.
John
It seems that Trader Joe's was in negotiations with the city and the Leadership Forum inserted themselves into the middle of the negotiations at which point Trader Joe's decide to go elsewhere.
Hopefully, the Forum will have another group lined up to buy the proper and create a business.