╌>

Tribal Justice Targets Outsiders After 35-Year Ban

  

Category:  News & Politics

Via:  spikegary  •  12 years ago  •  117 comments

Tribal Justice Targets Outsiders After 35-Year Ban

Ruling Allows Tribal Justice Rule of Non-Members

Three American Indian tribes are getting the authority to prosecute non-members in domestic violence cases on reservations under a pilot program announced Thursday by the Justice Department.

The program, which grants new authority to prosecutors in the Pascua Yaqui Tribe of Arizona, the Tulalip Tribes of Washington state and the Umatilla Tribes of Oregon, was hailed by the tribes as an important expansion of their justice systems. A 1978 Supreme Court decision struck down tribes' jurisdiction over non-members, which meant they had to hand those criminal cases to federal or state prosecutors.

Good-these rights should never have been removed from the owners of the lands......


Tags

jrDiscussion - desc
[]
 
Spikegary
Junior Quiet
link   seeder  Spikegary    12 years ago

I think this ruling is overdue at best. What say you?

 
 
 
Larry Crehore
Freshman Silent
link   Larry Crehore    12 years ago

If you violate tribal laws then you should stand before tribal justice, provided the violations were on tribal lands. I applaud the ruling. Now let's see if they will stand behind it.

 
 
 
1stwarrior
Professor Participates
link   1stwarrior    12 years ago

I'm waiting to see how they tie this in with the Tribal Law and Order Act which gives more power and jurisdiction to the tribes Grin.gif

 
 
 
Larry Crehore
Freshman Silent
 
 
screminmimi
Freshman Silent
link   screminmimi    12 years ago

Completely agree with you, Spikegary! It is long overdue. Now let's see if the appeals process will overthrow the verdicts of the Tribal courts... that is the sticking point.

 
 
 
Kavika
Professor Expert
link   Kavika     12 years ago

The 1978 ruling was a travesty. It's about time that the authority is returned to the tribes. One only has to know that in excess of 70 per cent of violent crimes against Native women, on the rez, were committed by non-Indians.

It should be noted that Alaska Native women WERE NOT covered by VAWA. Another travesty that there is no excuse for.

 
 
 
Larry Hampton
Professor Quiet
link   Larry Hampton    12 years ago

The law of the land should be just that.

Good ruling.

 
 
 
Kavika
Professor Expert
link   Kavika     12 years ago

All tribes will be able to arrest/prosecute in 2015. Tribes can request to be availed of the opportunity before the 2015 date.

 
 
 
Kavika
Professor Expert
link   Kavika     12 years ago

Tribal sovereignty has nothing to do with the ''law of the land'' Robert. The ''law of the land'' is the same on reservations as it is elsewhere in the U.S. With the exception that ''law'' wasn't enforced on the reservations. Now it will be, sorry if that isn't to your liking.

I guess that you'll have to, ''get over it''.

 
 
 
Kavika
Professor Expert
link   Kavika     12 years ago

Robert, I think that you should, get over, your get over.

What are the other benefits of sovereignty that I go on about endlessly? I think that you should open your closed mind and actually read what articles I post. There are a myriad of things that I post that are not related to Indians. Do you take the time to check those out? Probably not, then you wouldn't have anything to whine about.

With the change in the law, at least now, the non-Indians don't get off scott free, they will actually have to face the law. How interesting that is going to be.

Yup, ''the law of the land'' is coming to the rez.

BTW, Don't you have any comment on the ''law of the land'', your the one that brought it up with your snide comment.

I don't know why this ''gets to you''. It's the law, and your a big law and order guy. I would think that you'd be overjoyed that equal rights were being addressed.

 
 
 
Enoch
Masters Silent
link   Enoch    12 years ago

Dear Friend Spikegary: Anything which gets justice for those who are abused, and reduces present and future abuse is astep forward.

As a Chaplain, I have for decades witnessed first hand the long term after effects of those abused on their lives. It is heart breaking.

For me this isn't a political back and forth. This is real world, and serious. Sometimes abuse is deadly serious.

Nothing is going to work 100% right all the time every time. That said, whatever helps should be supported to the hilt.

Peace, Justice, Equal Protection, and Abundant Blessings for One and All.

Enoch.

 
 
 
1stwarrior
Professor Participates
link   1stwarrior    12 years ago

Not true - the Constitution states that treaties, with foreign nations and Indian tribes, are the "Law of the Land". However, the courts, specifically SCOTUS, don't read it that way.Frown.gif

 
 
 
1stwarrior
Professor Participates
link   1stwarrior    12 years ago

True, the issue exists on and off the reservations for Indians and non-Indians. However but (and I'll do more research on this tomorrow), there is more violence on the reservations against Indian women by non-Indians, male and female, per population count, than there is off the reservation against non-Indian women.

Kavika's statement of 70% of the violence against Indian women by non-Indians is an accurate number. Another accurate number is that the SD/ND/MN FBI district has only arrested and prosecuted 5% of the offenders, primarily, according to them, because they don't have the man-power - hence, the passage of the two laws - TLOA and VAWA - in an effort to get the tribes involved in the law enforcement and penalty phases.

 
 
 
1stwarrior
Professor Participates
link   1stwarrior    12 years ago

Robert - I would really love to get into a serious discussion with you regarding this article and the facts supporting it from other sources than NBC (short fill story at best). Example -

Study by the DOJ as to what the present status of crime in Indian Country completed in 2011 prior to the passage of TOLA by Congress in 2012. The other references supporting the 43 page study are:

American Indians and Crime, NCJ 203097, BJS Web, December 2004.

2005 American Indian Population andLabor Force Report. U.S. Department
of the Interior, Bureau of Indian Affairs, 2005.

The Urban Institute. Tribal Youth in the Federal Justice System, NCJ
234549, May 2011. Available at .

One thing pointed out in the report are the number of PL-280 states (six of them having jurisdiction on reservations), "maybe" 68% that occurred were reported - BUT - due to manpower and priorities, 15% were investigated.

" The purposes of the Tribal Law and Order Act are: Clarify the responsibilities of the federal, state, tribal, and local governments with respect to crimes in Indian Country; increase coordination and communication among federal, state, tribal, and local law enforcement agencies; empower tribal governments with the authority, resources, and information necessary to safely and effectively provide public safety in Indian Country; reduce the prevalence of violent crime in Indian Country and to combat sexual and domestic violence against Alaska Native and Native American women; prevent drug trafficking and reduce rates of alcohol and drug addiction in Indian Country; and increase and standardize the collection of criminal data to and the sharing of criminal history information among federal, state, tribal, and local officials responsible for responding to and investigating crimes in Indian Country ." - Bur eau of Justice Assistance (January 5, 2012). "TLOA" . Archived from the original on April 10, 2013.Also - h ttp://www.whitehouse.gov/blog/2010/07/29/tribal-law-and-order-act-2...

Additionally, in support of my comments, anything and everything you wanted to know about the why, how, when, where and who of either Act (TOLA/VAWA), go here -

A good rendition to substantiate the need for these acts would take roughly 100 pages, which is why I'm just listing references. If you wish to discuss any of the information listed in the references - I'm wide open for it.

Seriously - thanks for your input - I enjoy the opportunities you present.

 
 
 
1stwarrior
Professor Participates
link   1stwarrior    12 years ago

Here ya go Robert - two things on "sovereignty" -

"sovereignty noun (Concise Encyclopedia)

In political theory, the ultimate authority in the decision-making process of the state and in the maintenance of order. In 16th-century France Jean Bodin used the concept of sovereignty to bolster the power of the king over his feudal lords, heralding the transition from feudalism to nationalism. By the end of the 18th century, the concept of the social contract led to the idea of popular sovereignty, or sovereignty of the people, through an organized government. The Hague Conventions, the Geneva Conventions, and the United Nations all have restricted the actions of sovereign countries in the international arena, as has international law."

"Tribal sovereignty in the United Statesis the inherent authority ofindigenous tribesto govern themselves within the borders of theUnited States of America. Thefederal governmentrecognizes tribal nations as "domestic dependent nations" and has established a number of laws attempting to clarify the relationship between the federal, state, and tribal governments. TheConstitutionand later federal laws grant local sovereignty to tribal nations, but do not grant fullsovereigntyequivalent to that of foreign nations, hence the term "domestic dependent nations"."

More specifically, check the three cases listed as the "Marshall Trilogy" for SCOTUS definition of what Tribal Sovereignty is and what it encompasses -

  • Johnson v. M'Intosh(1823)
  • Cherokee Nation v. Georgia(1831)
  • Worcester v. Georgia(1832)


Now, in relations to your comment about domestic abuse on a reservation, the reference in the article to the 1978 case deals with the Squamish v. Oliphant case where Mr. Super Supreme Court Justice Rehnquist stated - not opined - but stated -Indians don't have authority to capture nor prosecute a non-Indian on the reservation - NO MATTER WHAT THE CRIME. Well - that put the Indian world on its ear. However, later, the "Lara" fix changed "some" of that ruling, but the tribes still couldn't prosecute a non-Indian for commission of a Major Crime on the reservation - only the FBI could/can do that.

 
 
 
screminmimi
Freshman Silent
link   screminmimi    12 years ago

Mr. Super Supreme Court Justice Rehnquist stated - not opined - but stated -Indians don't have authority to capture nor prosecute a non-Indian on the reservation - NO MATTER WHAT THE CRIME. Well - that put the Indian world on its ear. However, later, the "Lara" fix changed "some" of that ruling, but the tribes still couldn't prosecute a non-Indian for commission of a Major Crime on the reservation - only the FBI could/can do that.

Which left people on reservations, especially women and children, wide open to pedophiles and rapists, since the FBI kept saying over and over that they didn't have the manpower to prosecute... NOT TO MENTION...

it was dangerous for an Indian to be caught off the rez to even report a crime to the local authorities so that the FBI could even begin to get involved in the process, as most local authorities did not, and do not, give a rat's ass about what happens to Indians.

As a case in point, look up the Bontas, who were run off the highway, pulled from their vehicle, and beat with chains and baseball bats. When authorities arrived, the deputies asked the Indians, "What did YOU do to cause this?" (Well, the answer of course, was, "I was caught being Indian off the rez.")

The sheriff arrested Mr. Bonta, though he was covered in his own blood and threw him in jail. Mrs. Bonta, her daughter and son-in-law had to be taken to the hospital. The criminals who did this were led by the sheriff's son, the local leader of the skinheads.

When Mr. Bonta got out of jail, it took him over a week to find his car, which for some reason was towed a couple of counties over, and it would cost him $600 to get it.

I've checked a few times but haven't been able to find out if the FBI ever found the manpower to prosecute this crime. Not holding my breath, and don't suppose there is enough attention span here to talk about Patty Dawson who will never be normal again because she was caught being Indian and off the rez.

 
 
 
1stwarrior
Professor Participates
link   1stwarrior    12 years ago

No, I don't see this as a "trail" - but one that the Rehnquist court took out of the hands of the Tribes - and now they are getting it back, bit by bit.

No, you are not "more" sovereign - you are still a dependent Indian Nation - dependent on the U. S. to protect you from foreign invaders, states and (yeah, I know) homesteaders. The tribes have always had sovereignty over their nations - the courts call it "inherent sovereignty" - and it has existed way before "discovery".

When Rehnquist was selected to serve on SCOTUS, he started with three cases that were favorable to the tribes, He then began his march to ensure states rights superseded tribal rights in 1976. Almost immediately upon taking his seat on the Supreme Court, Justice Rehnquist began to move the Court away from established Indian law jurisprudence which had stood largely intact since Chief Justice Marshall wrote the trilogy of Johnson, Cherokee, and Worcester in the early 19th century. In the area of taxation, his attempts to generate bright line rules turned instead into fact-specific analysis that emphasized states rights. In the area of jurisdiction, he found that tribes do not have criminal jurisdiction over non-Indians on the reservation, and that tribes do not have civil jurisdiction over non-Indian activities on fee land within the reservation. His analysis of tribal sovereignty emphasized what he viewed as the dependent status of the tribes on the federal government. He developed analytical techniques that relied heavily on use of historical facts chosen to prove his point. And he relied heavily on a dissenting opinion from Fletcher v. Peck, which was written thirteen years before the first case in the Marshall trilogy.

While Rehnquist is no longer on the Supreme Court, his body of jurisprudence stands as precedent in any future Indian law cases the Court considers. Chief Justice Roberts, in Plains Commerce Bank v. Long Family Land and Cattle Co., cited Atkinson for the Montana rule, or the general proposition that the inherent sovereign powers of an Indian tribe do not extend to the activities of nonmembers of the tribe. It is likely that any future decision of the Court regarding the extent of tribal authority would need to address one or more opinions authored by Rehnquist, with the result that the trend away from the recognition of inherent tribal sovereignty in the Courts jurisprudence may well continue for some time to come.

Prior to Rehnquist becoming Chief Justice, the tribes had enjoyed an 86% win ratio with the court. After Rehnquist, that ratio went to 20%. Under Roberts, the ratio is now at 12%.

 
 
 
1stwarrior
Professor Participates
link   1stwarrior    12 years ago

My opinion is based on the law. Baby Veronica was not based on law - ICWA- read Kegan and Sotomayer's opinions where they very specifically state the law was not followed. Roberts and Thomas are both adoptive parents and ruled in favor of the adoptive parents and not in favor of the law. The states are the deciding factors in ICWA cases and all of South Carolina's courts, prior to SCOTUS, ruled in favor of ICWA. After SCOTUS, SC ruled with the SCOTUS decision because - well, there are a number of underlying factors which involve Roberts.

Totally true that the sovereignty has been a disaster. It really depends on who's doing the reading - the courts or Congress. As we know, Congress don't give a crap - they have "plenary" power over the tribes - so they think - hence any and all decisions they make regarding tribes is "right".

In the description I listed, it was as a highlight of the ladder that Rehnquist climbed, taking out the tribal equation and replacing it with state/federal - and applying the "plenary" power thought process - wrong way to go.

 
 
 
palma
Freshman Silent
link   palma    12 years ago

Domestic violence crimes perpetrated on reservations or pueblos are largely not reported or not prosecuted because of loopholes in jurisdictional authority.

Arrests occur in only 13 percent of sexual assaults reported by Native women, compared with 35 percent for blacks and 32 percent for whites, according to the Justice Department.

According to government data, U.S. attorneys decline about 67 percent of sexual assault cases referred from Indian Country. Enforcement gaps created by PL 83-280 and indifferent attitudes help to perpetuate cyclical violence against Native women

Essentially, the system allows non-Natives who commit domestic violence crimes to act without fear of penalty.Statistics show that non-Natives commit 88 percent of violent crimes against Native women

Sexual violence against Indigenous women in the USA is widespread. According to US government statistics, Native American and Alaska Native women are more than 2.5 times more likely to be raped or sexually assaulted than other women in the USA.

Though rape is always an act of violence, there is evidence that Indigenous women are more likely than other women to suffer additional violence at the hands of their attackers. According to the US Department of Justice, in at least 86 per cent of the reported cases of rape or sexual assault against American Indian and Alaska Native women, survivors report that the perpetrators are non-Native men

Sexual violence against Indigenous women is the result of a number of factors and continues a history of widespread human rights abuses against Indigenous peoples in the USA. Historically, Indigenous women were raped by settlers and soldiers, including during the Trail of Tears and the Long Walk. Such attacks were not random or individual; they were tools of conquest and colonization. The attitudes towards Indigenous peoples that underpin such human rights abuses continue to be present in in the USA today. They contribute to the present high rates of sexual violence perpetrated against Indigenous women and help to shield their attackers from justice.

Indigenous peoples in the USA face deeply entrenched marginalization the result of a long history of systemic and pervasive abuse and persecution. Sexual violence against Indigenous women today is informed and conditioned by this legacy of widespread and egregious human rights abuses.

American Indians are 2.5 times more likely to experience sexual assault crimes compared to all other races, and one in three Indian women reports having been raped during her lifetime.

And last, but not least

Its like theyve [Native women] become this mythical creature, and when you mystify something, you tend to destroy it, El-Fakahanysays. There is an ill-conceived idea that they are not real people. If you dont believe in something, it is really easy to destroy it.

 
 
 
Dowser
Sophomore Silent
link   Dowser    12 years ago

Enoch, again, you put it so succinctly, well, and with such truth.

There has been a really good series about Alaska and rape that I've been reading:

The Lawless End of the Land

While many of us will dismiss this as "It's Alaska, what do you expect?" There is a lot of good information in the articles that applies to the lower 48 states, as well. I would recommend the entire series as good reading about this issue. Source: CNN

 
 
 
palma
Freshman Silent
link   palma    12 years ago

where and when did this happen mimi?

 
 
 
1stwarrior
Professor Participates
link   1stwarrior    12 years ago

Johnny Bonta and his wife Lisa.Frown.gif

 
 
 
1stwarrior
Professor Participates
link   1stwarrior    12 years ago

Robert - I apologize - Kegan recused herself, she wasn't part of the dissent.

 
 
 
palma
Freshman Silent
link   palma    12 years ago

Thanks 1st. The saddest thing is that nothing happened in terms of justice. Did a search and there's nothing besides news of the attack in 2011. This is just unbelievable. And one questions why people don't come forward - the big question is, what for?

 
 
 
1stwarrior
Professor Participates
link   1stwarrior    12 years ago

And another question that so many of us have is- why hasn't anything been done about this???

Oh yeah - we're Indians and we're invisible.

 
 
 
screminmimi
Freshman Silent
link   screminmimi    12 years ago

Patty Dawson, Clovis CA.

It went to trial, you can read what happened to her. She was on her way back from the airport having dropped her uncle off after a visit.

Thank you, 1stwarrior. I just got to this thread.

 
 
 
screminmimi
Freshman Silent
link   screminmimi    12 years ago

Exactly! Why hasn't something been done?

Now, Robert, when an Indian on NT says that Indians don't bother to come forward because law enforcement won't do anything about it, please don't question them... you have proof of it, and believe me, this is not an isolated incident.

The victim was placed in jail, bleeding. Authorities maliciously moved his car several counties away, told him when he asked where it was they didn't know and he had to hunt it down himself.

And people want to know why Indians can't just "get over it."

Why didn't the fricking governor get involved here? If the FBI can't take care of business, why can't the governor take care of business in his own state? Are Indians not people? Not constituents? Where is the ACLU? Do they only take care of blacks and Hispanics?

 
 
 
1stwarrior
Professor Participates
link   1stwarrior    12 years ago

Thanks mimi - here's the list of Patty's trials -

 
 
 
1stwarrior
Professor Participates
link   1stwarrior    12 years ago

Sorry - you're right - Kagan. Had an employee I had to fire named "Kegan" - bad memories must be coming back.Frown.gif

 
 
 
palma
Freshman Silent
link   palma    12 years ago

Thanks 1st, good that she got justice although one year doesn't sound like justice to me; people got longer sentences for lesser crimes. But, by reading the story and the complete disregard from authorities I think a year is an accomplishment.

Sadly the Bontas didn;t get the same justice.

 
 
 
palma
Freshman Silent
link   palma    12 years ago

Assuming that what has been presented is all there is.

why? because they're Indians there should be more to the story? like "they had it coming"?

How can you be so soulless?

 
 
 
1stwarrior
Professor Participates
link   1stwarrior    12 years ago

Robert - after checking all the comments a couple of times, I can't find that particular one. Where might it be??Grin.gif

 
 
 
1stwarrior
Professor Participates
link   1stwarrior    12 years ago

Not really - depending on the state, the reservation, whether PL-280 state, even the DOJ documentation lists the "average" as 67%.

So, yeah, for that particular area, 88% could be a sound number. Sadly, that is a very sickening statistic - one that, with more support from DOJ and Congress, the tribes can gain jurisdiction over this particular Major Crime.

Thanks for your comment and for checking out the sources.

 
 
 
Larry Crehore
Freshman Silent
link   Larry Crehore    12 years ago

Robert G,

Palma made reference to this document:

...

In which you will find the figures she quoted such as the one you are questioning:

In paragraph 20: Quote, "Essentially, the system allows non-Natives who commit domestic violence crimes to ct without fear of penalty.Statistics show that non-Natives commit 88 percent of violent crimes against Native women."

 
 
 
1stwarrior
Professor Participates
link   1stwarrior    12 years ago

From the Indian Law Resource Center -"RACIALDISCRIMINATIONANDDENIALOFEQUALITYUNDERTHELAW

It is outrageous that the vast majority of these women never see their abusers or rapists brought to justice. An unworkable, race-based criminal jurisdictional scheme created by the United States has limited the ability of Indian nations to protect Native women from violence and to provide them with meaningful remedies. For more than 35 years, United States law has stripped Indian nations of all criminal authority over non-Indians. As a result, Indian nations are unable to prosecute non-Indians, who reportedly commit 88% of the violent crimes against Native women on tribal lands. The Census Bureau reports that non-Indians now comprise 76% of the population on tribal lands and 68% of the population in Alaska Native villages. Many Native women have married non-Indians. However, it is unacceptable that a non-Indian who chooses to marry a Native woman, live on her reservation, and commit acts of domestic violence against her, cannot be criminally prosecuted by an Indian nation and more often than not will never be prosecuted by anygovernment.

Federal and state officials having authority to protect Native women and girls are failing to do so at alarming rates. By their own account, between 2005 and 2009,U.S.attorneys declined to prosecute 67% of the Indian country matters referred to them involving sexual abuse and related matters. Even grimmer, due to the lack of law enforcement, many of these crimes in Native communities are not eveninvestigated.

United States law creates a discriminatory system for administering justice in Native communitiesa system that allows criminals to act with impunity in Indian country, threatens the lives and violates the human rights of Native women and girls daily, and perpetuates an escalating cycle of violence in Native communities. Women who are subjected to violence should not be treated differently and discriminated against just because they are Native and were assaulted on an Indian reservation or in an Alaska Nativevillage!"

I, as a habit, don't research the source of the information if it comes from a "reputable" source. The Indian Law Resource Center is a very reputable source.

However, if you're interested - "Founded in 1978, the Center provides assistance to Indian nations and indigenous peoples in the United States and throughout the Americas. The Center has an international Board of Directors, and is a Non-Governmental Organization in consultative status with the United Nations Economic and Social Council. The Indian Law Resource Center is a tax-exempt organization under section 501(c)(3) of the Internal Revenue Code. We are funded by grants and contributions from individuals, foundations, and Indian nations. The Center accepts no governmentsupport." They are utilized by numerous organizations, including the DOJ, as assistance providers.

 
 
 
Larry Crehore
Freshman Silent
link   Larry Crehore    12 years ago

I was able to back track the original statement to this publication:

Native Strength

Authored by:

Tina Olson, co-director of Mending the Sacred Hoop in Duluth, Minnesota. According to its website, the group works to end violence against Native women and children while restoring the safety, sovereignty, and sacredness of Native women. Olson says assault cases often are not even investigated. One woman told me, I would have validated my rape if someone had called or followed up, she says.........

Others blame PL 83-280. The obstacles presented by Public Law 280 to address sexual assault relate to data collection, training or awareness, lack of resources targeted at tribal communities, lack of well-funded tribal police departments, animosity toward tribal communities and lack of reporting from tribal community members, the Tribal Law and Policy Institute in West Hollywood, California, reported in December 2007.

Essentially, the system allows non-Natives who commit domestic violence crimes to act without fear of penalty. Statistics show that non-Natives commit 88 percent of violent crimes against Native women.

Mending the Sacred Hoop, Inc. is supported by the U. S. Dept. of Justice, Office on Violence Against Women; the Minnesota Office of Justice Programs; and generous contributions from individual donors. Migwiich!

 
 
 
Larry Crehore
Freshman Silent
link   Larry Crehore    12 years ago

Your Amnesty International link works the other doesn't work. Which leaves us at an impasse as I don't take Amnesty International as a final source just as you call it "reported" source.

We also need to compare date written Mendin The Hoop was authored in 2012.

 
 
 
Larry Crehore
Freshman Silent
link   Larry Crehore    12 years ago

Of course it matters, the other 2% you seem so concerned about is probably something like simple assault. The wording in the original post said "violent crimes" now you want to change the wording to suit your argument to "reported rapes or other sexual assault". I say its an impasse. You can't change the wording to suit yourself, apples and oranges you know.

 
 
 
Larry Crehore
Freshman Silent
link   Larry Crehore    12 years ago

Amnesty International is nothing more than a compiler and reporting agency. The same as any reporting writer.

 
 
 
Larry Crehore
Freshman Silent
link   Larry Crehore    12 years ago

You also quoted:

"

Amnesty Report from Justice link...

At least 86 percent of reported rapes or other sexual assaults against indigenous women are committed by non-Indian men"

Where is your Justice link it doesn't exist.

 
 
 
Larry Crehore
Freshman Silent
link   Larry Crehore    12 years ago

For the second time, your first link worked fine and Amnessty International is only repeating in a report. Your second link is busted and doesn't work. As for the pictures if that's what your going by good luck convincing anyone of your validity.

 
 
 
Nona62
Professor Silent
link   Nona62    12 years ago
 
 
 
1stwarrior
Professor Participates
link   1stwarrior    12 years ago

Grin.gif

 
 
 
1stwarrior
Professor Participates
link   1stwarrior    12 years ago

Sorry Robert, but we can't help you anymore. Unfortunately, you are asking for information from a federal agency (DOJ) who is not doing the job they are required by law to do - and you expect them to report to the public that they're not doing their job????24.gif 24.gif 24.gif 24.gif 24.gif 24.gif

You have been given enough data from more than enough sources to tell you - IT IS WRONG.

Thanks for your comments.

Gary - thanks so much for bring this up/out for others to see and, hopefully, understand. Sorry I dominated your discussion Frown.gif

 
 
 
palma
Freshman Silent
link   palma    12 years ago

so tape and sexual attack are not violent crimes? should they be considered blessings in your view?

 
 
 
palma
Freshman Silent
link   palma    12 years ago

Do the numbers matter?

you're the one bothered by them.

To me and many others, 1% or 100%, it doesn't matter, it shouldn;t happen. One crime is one crime too many

 
 
 
1stwarrior
Professor Participates
link   1stwarrior    12 years ago

IT - what is the topic of the thread??? That is what IT is - the thread's topic - violence against Indian women can now be handled by THREE out of 566 Indian tribes. Don't think those THREE tribes will account for the 88%/86%/67%/0% numbers you're looking for. The point of the discussion is that DOJ has realized they can't/won't do the job of protecting Indian women from violence, so, through the utilization of the Violence Against Women Act, DOJ is utilizing tools Congress gave them. The tools are needed to reduce VAW on Indian reservations - even if it only starts with three. Only got 563 more tribes to get into the fold.

 
 
 
Nona62
Professor Silent
link   Nona62    12 years ago
 
 
 
A. Macarthur
Professor Guide
link   A. Macarthur    12 years ago

Tribal sovereignty in the United States is the inherent authority of indigenous tribes to govern themselves within the borders of the United States of America.

The federal government recognizes tribal nations as "domestic dependent nations" and has established a number of laws attempting to clarify the relationship between the federal, state, and tribal governments.

The Constitution[1] and later federal laws grant local sovereignty to tribal nations, but do not grant full sovereignty equivalent to that of foreign nations, hence the term "domestic dependent nations".

The law of the land is not trumped by tribal sovereignty, it works in conjunction with it. If tribal sovereignty did trump the law of the land, Native Americans could take back what has been stolen from them "legally" and prosecute the government for all of the Native Americans it murdered under the law of the land.

 
 
 
1stwarrior
Professor Participates
link   1stwarrior    12 years ago

Yes -that's the answer. Your issue is?

 
 
 
1stwarrior
Professor Participates
link   1stwarrior    12 years ago

Spikegary - thank you for bringing this terrible rightthat is slowly being fixed to the view of the public.

I have to apologize to you for stepping in and "talking" too damn much. I've said what needs to be said in support of the initiative being taken.

I'm gone.

Thank you again.

 
 
 
Spikegary
Junior Quiet
link   seeder  Spikegary    12 years ago

No problem 1st....I've been watching the discussion and see people far more knowledgeable than I making comments......it's a learning situation for me.

 
 
 
Kavika
Professor Expert
link   Kavika     12 years ago

Robert, your comment is very bigoted, racist and ignorant. But, I wouldn't expect anything lessfrom you.

Congratulations, you hit the trifecta.Grin.gif

 
 
 
screminmimi
Freshman Silent
link   screminmimi    12 years ago

Should "non-Indians" try to avoid going near Indian reservations

Works for me.

 
 
 
Nona62
Professor Silent
link   Nona62    12 years ago

Comment removed for CoC violation [ph]

 
 
 
Kavika
Professor Expert
link   Kavika     12 years ago

I thought it had a lot of redeeming value, but that's just me.

 
 
 
Kavika
Professor Expert
link   Kavika     12 years ago

''Cool. A rare forward to moderators. I never do, but you have offered no redeeming value.''

But Robert, you just said that you NEVER do, but you did. Does this mean that you speak with forked tongue?Smile.gif

 
 
 
Larry Crehore
Freshman Silent
link   Larry Crehore    12 years ago

I have to agree Kavika a lot of redeeming value. JMHO

 
 
 
Kavika
Professor Expert
link   Kavika     12 years ago

Yes Robert, your reason is quite clear.

th?id=HN.607989256859027898&pid=3.1&w=300&h=300&p=0

 
 
 
Kavika
Professor Expert
link   Kavika     12 years ago

Oh my, a legacy of bullshit. Well Robert, soon all the tribes will have jurisdiction, then you can really scream bullshit, and continue your unending whining and crying.

th?id=HN.608015524879270393&w=368&h=188&c=7&rs=1&pid=1.7

Have a wonderful day Robert.

 
 
 
Kavika
Professor Expert
link   Kavika     12 years ago

According to you Robert, it's seems that you've lost the battle. We will have jurisdiction on the reservations.

You'll have to get over it Robert, it's happening.Smile.gif

Ain't America great!!

 
 
 
Kavika
Professor Expert
link   Kavika     12 years ago

Not possible Robert, I'm Red, remember.Smile.gif

 
 
 
Larry Crehore
Freshman Silent
link   Larry Crehore    12 years ago

Reminded me of this one Kavika

th?id=H.4598558315841223&pid=15.1

 
 
 
Kavika
Professor Expert
link   Kavika     12 years ago

Spot on Larry...Smile.gif

 
 
 
screminmimi
Freshman Silent
link   screminmimi    12 years ago

the low prosecution rate is attributable to a lack of evidence, or issues with witnesses in the majority of cases.

Reservations don't have hospitals available the way cities and towns do, Robert, with emergency staff available to employ a rape kit at a moment's notice. Most of them don't even have a makeshift clinic. A rape victim may have to wait over 24 hours or more to even get to the authorities to report the crime, and by the time the traumatized victim gets the attention of the local enforcement and it gets shuffled off to the FBI, it's no more than a "he said, she said," with intimidation playing a large part in the "issues" with the witnesses.

 
 
 
1stwarrior
Professor Participates
link   1stwarrior    12 years ago

Excellent answer Dingo.Smile.gif

 
 
 
screminmimi
Freshman Silent
link   screminmimi    12 years ago

On the contrary, Robert.

If the local Tribal police has the authority to arrest and prosecute criminals on Tribal land, they will be given funds to administer that authority. As assault/rape is one of the most common problems, no doubt rape kits and a professional to handle the tests will most likely be placed on the reservations.

Now, when a woman or child reports a violation, the Tribal police can immediately pursue the offender and apprehend him, with the victim making a timely identification instead of having to wait possibly weeks or even months, making a trip of a hundred or more miles into a hostile environment to do so.

No one is expecting an instantaneous miraculous turnaround in the plight of abused Native American women and children, but anyone with any intelligence at all has to see that this will be a positive step for Indians to be able to take care of human predators on their reservations, especially when you consider that 78% of people on Indian reservations are NOT Indians and up to now could pretty well do as they pleased, having no fear of Tribal police authority knowing that Federal authority was far away anduninterested in anything short of outright murder... and even with murder, as long as it was an Indian, it would take an Act of Congress to get them moving on it.

 
 
 
1stwarrior
Professor Participates
link   1stwarrior    12 years ago

Casino cops, both tribal and local, can/will apprehend. The person would be tried in Fed court since it occurred on an Indian reservation.

Tell your friend not to try it - local cops are rougher than tribal cops - they can get away with it.Grin.gif

 
 
 
Nigel Dogberry
Freshman Silent
link   Nigel Dogberry    12 years ago

You are all acting like Wobert has something to offer. You are mistaken. He doesn't.

 
 
 
Kavika
Professor Expert
link   Kavika     12 years ago

Your correct Grump.

 
 
 
Nona62
Professor Silent
link   Nona62    12 years ago

Ha . .at first glance, I thought you said "You're "corrupt" Grump. :-)

 
 
 
palma
Freshman Silent
link   palma    12 years ago

because you thought that might be... bigoted?

do you read what you write? You may find the answer right there

 
 
 
palma
Freshman Silent
link   palma    12 years ago

Some indications that Indian men DO rape

Even if, and it might, it doesn't translate into a "free for all" for non-Indians

 
 
 
palma
Freshman Silent
link   palma    12 years ago

have you seen this article mimi?

 
 
 
Spikegary
Junior Quiet
link   seeder  Spikegary    12 years ago

Doing an endzone dance because someone else got 'moderated' is beneath you, Robert.

 
 
 
1stwarrior
Professor Participates
link   1stwarrior    12 years ago

Great Op article palma.

 
 
 
1stwarrior
Professor Participates
link   1stwarrior    12 years ago

You - Robert - YOU prove it's wrong and I will totally agree with you. All you've done so far is repeat - repeat - repeat - with no justification other than you don't/won't accept the sources that the sources used to obtain their source.

That's your problem - not ours.

So - prove it is wrong Robert and quit repeating yourself.

 
 
 
palma
Freshman Silent
link   palma    12 years ago

Thought so too 1st

 
 
 
Larry Crehore
Freshman Silent
link   Larry Crehore    12 years ago

Gunny makes a good point.

 
 
 
1stwarrior
Professor Participates
link   1stwarrior    12 years ago

Well, this damn thing doesn't want to respond to a reply so - sorry Robert - broken records are not proof - constant questioning without adding additional support aren't proof - thowing out phraseology with no substantiation is not proof.

You are lambasting sources - fine - go to the source and lambast them.

Unless you have PROOF that they are wrong - enough of the broken record tyraid.

 
 
 
Larry Crehore
Freshman Silent
link   Larry Crehore    12 years ago

First: Amnesty International is a report

Second: They report on a Justice Department link that doesn't exist

Third: Don't you ever get tired of being wrong?

I asked you to prove your figure a long time back and yet you still haven't, why because you can't. You have only your own agenda and refuse to allow that anyone else could have different information. Get over your ego.

 
 
 
palma
Freshman Silent
link   palma    12 years ago

1dfd1b559668145f2503da834fcf46b4.jpg

I think it is appropriate

 
 
 
Kavika
Professor Expert
link   Kavika     12 years ago

The bottom line is that Robert is red assed (much like his head) over the fact, that it's a done deal.

Sorry Robert, you'll have to, ''get over it''.Grin.gif

 
 
 
Larry Crehore
Freshman Silent
link   Larry Crehore    12 years ago

"I am beginning to notice an impassable chasm based on IQ."

Yes and yours needs some real work on it.

 
 
 
Nona62
Professor Silent
link   Nona62    12 years ago

ROFL good one!!

 
 
 
Nona62
Professor Silent
link   Nona62    12 years ago

I'm scarred for life now . .

 
 
 
Mrs D
Freshman Silent
link   Mrs D    12 years ago

This is wonderful news Gary and a time to celebrate! Equal justice is suppose to be for ALL and I hope that I am still alive to see the day that all of the American Indian Tribes (First People) get the same authority to dispense justice for all crimes committed on their land. Unfortunately, arrogance in some people seems to breed a lack of compassion for their fellow human beings... which is so sad.

 
 
 
Al-316
Professor Silent
link   Al-316    12 years ago

According to the Census Bureau, 77 percent of residents on reservations and other Native lands are non-Natives, and about 56 percent of Native women are married to non-Natives. Still, tribes have no authority to prosecute a non-Native for domestic violence, even if the offender resides on the reservation where the assault occurred or is married to a tribal member.

With statistics like this, an Indian living on a reservation is a victim just waiting for a crime.

Maybe justice will return with this ruling, and with justice, hope will follow.

Good article, Spikegary.

 
 
 
palma
Freshman Silent
link   palma    12 years ago

Great post Al

 
 
 
Kavika
Professor Expert
link   Kavika     12 years ago

I believe that most people believe that only Indians live on the rez, or that Indians own all the rez land. Both are false, really false.

 
 
 
palma
Freshman Silent
link   palma    12 years ago

I read somewhere that they don't even own their homes. Is that true?

 
 
 
Kavika
Professor Expert
link   Kavika     12 years ago

That isn't true Palma.

 
 
 
1stwarrior
Professor Participates
link   1stwarrior    12 years ago

The Indians own the homes, but not the land- that belongs to "Big White Father"

 
 
 
palma
Freshman Silent
link   palma    12 years ago

Thanks, maybe I misheard but in some way it is kind of the same thing. Can they sell their homes?

 
 
 
Al-316
Professor Silent
link   Al-316    12 years ago

The Indians own the homes, but not the land- that belongs to "Big White Father"

1stwarrior, is this why the proposed oil pipeline to runthrough Indian Country is still on track despite the Indians saying "No"?

 
 
 
1stwarrior
Professor Participates
link   1stwarrior    12 years ago

Pretty much - but then they run into the cultural/traditional aspects which fall underdifferent laws that are "supposed" to be evaluated/consulted on during the environmental review.

 
 
 
1stwarrior
Professor Participates
link   1stwarrior    12 years ago

Need to clarify - not all the tribes allow the Indians to own the home - they may have been given permission to build/rent/live at that location. However, the land is still trust land and that is owned by the U. S., not the tribes.Frown.gif

 
 
 
1stwarrior
Professor Participates
link   1stwarrior    12 years ago

With tribal permission and only to another Indian, preferably of the same nation.

 
 
 
Al-316
Professor Silent
link   Al-316    12 years ago

:) Thanks, palma.

 
 
 
Al-316
Professor Silent
link   Al-316    12 years ago

I can see the merit of individuals not owning tribal land. This reflects the old ways as I understand them.

The kicker is that the Government, a non-Indian entity which understands and cares very little about Indian ways has the final say regarding land matters.

I wonder though, could the tribes do a better job? I don't know.

Regardless, in my opinion, the ownership of the land and mineral rights should never be transferable. Those rights should remain the property of the tribe(s) in perpetuity.

 
 
 
palma
Freshman Silent
link   palma    12 years ago

Thanks, now I understand. And agree

 
 
 
1stwarrior
Professor Participates
link   1stwarrior    12 years ago

Ideally, that is what the Self-Determination and Educational Assistance Act of 1975 "blueprinted" to happen - tribes operate tribes - feds operate feds.

 
 
 
Al-316
Professor Silent
link   Al-316    12 years ago

Robert, I have no reservations that the tribes are capable of recognizing criminal behavior and maintaining a justice system.

My concern is whether the individual tribes, if given absolute control over their land to include determining its use, preservation, disposal, and management would not suffer from personal ambition, greed, and indifference, much as what is happening now with the federal government in control.

 
 
 
1stwarrior
Professor Participates
link   1stwarrior    12 years ago

Unfortunately, that happens in all societies. You have to have strong people to stop the crud.

 
 
 
Spikegary
Junior Quiet
link   seeder  Spikegary    12 years ago

Well, obviously you haven't been keeping very good track of my comments Robert, nor reading them for comprehension.

Commenting about forwarding stuff to the mods is not needed either. Comment on the article, comment on the discussion, don't bother addressing comments about who or why you're going to tell omn someone. Not on my seeds/articles. Thank you in advance for your compliance.

 
 
 
1stwarrior
Professor Participates
link   1stwarrior    12 years ago

And, of 'course you neglected the part about the Indian men getting raped too, right?Grin.gif

 
 
 
1stwarrior
Professor Participates
link   1stwarrior    12 years ago

Ya know - in all seriousness, this could/should go with another thread 'cause I see it as a really broad range for discussion with lots of parameters to look at. And - the need for reviewing the BIA and state's records of cases not referred to the FBI and why.

Thanks for the link Robert.

 
 
 
1stwarrior
Professor Participates
link   1stwarrior    12 years ago

Robert - I want to thank you for the research you've done. This is a part of the Tribal Law and Order Act background that a lot of folks aren't aware of and I, while studying for Indian Law, certainly appreciate the link.

I didn't see your other link that you mention above - not your previous links to AI - do you have another?

The mention of the PL-280 states having jurisdiction - the PL-280 law only gave those states jurisdiction over civil crimes, not the criminal crimes listed in the Major Crimes Act. The tribes and states have concurrent jurisdiction, but, ultimately, it's the FBI that has "final" say-so. But, then again, that is referenced in the report you posted.

Robert - thank you again for the information - and the comment about "seeing another side". If I can help you, let me know.Smile.gif

 
 
 
Al-316
Professor Silent
link   Al-316    12 years ago

Robert, I commend you for providing this link. It is great. Thanks.

 
 
 
1stwarrior
Professor Participates
link   1stwarrior    12 years ago

Just out of curiosity Robert - what is and where do you find "verified sources"?Smile.gif

 
 
 
screminmimi
Freshman Silent
link   screminmimi    12 years ago

Al, even if they do... isn't it their right to do so?

The federal government is already doing it to the Tribes; they have the right self determination.

 
 
 
Al-316
Professor Silent
link   Al-316    12 years ago

Robert, once again I must acknowledge your statistical insights mentioned above as well as your link to the:

Bureau of Justice Statistics

A BJS Statistical Profile, 1992-2002

American Indians and Crime

 
 
 
Al-316
Professor Silent
link   Al-316    12 years ago

Absolutely, mimi, the Tribes should have the absolute right to determine their destiny in everyaspect of their lives, including their land.

In my opinion, the government has taken control of Indianland and mangled it. Never-the-less, as things stand now the Tribes still have the potential remedy of suing thegovernment to rectify past errors.

If the Tribes take over and make the same mistakes, it will be tough luck. Perhaps that should not worry me.I just don't want to see the Tribesswindled again. The government (and salesmen) can talk sweeter and faster then we can listen.

 
 
 
palma
Freshman Silent
link   palma    12 years ago

The Keystone oil pipeline is an example Al

 
 
 
1stwarrior
Professor Participates
link   1stwarrior    12 years ago

mimi - the Indian Self Determination and Education Assistance Act of 1975 set the path for tribes handling their own self direction. Now, if we could only get Congress to quit interfering, the tribes, in my opinion, could/would do a much better job than the government has ever done.Grin.gif

 
 
 
palma
Freshman Silent
link   palma    12 years ago

This Congress? Good luck with thatSmile.gif

 
 
 
1stwarrior
Professor Participates
link   1stwarrior    12 years ago

Yeah - guess I'm gonna hafta give up drinking that Super Caf stuff, eh?Grin.gif

 
 

Who is online

JohnRussell


89 visitors