The Massive Liberal Failure on Race Part One
A liberal takes what promises to be a fascinating multi-part look at the failures of American race policy that goes far beyond the simplistic blame white republicans meme that many liberals seem incapable of getting past. Its examination of the failures of busing in part 1 is the type of analysis you rarely see.
"Fifty years after the March on Washington, Americas high school cafeterias are as racially divided as ever, income inequality is growing, and mass incarceration has hobbled an entire generation of young black men. Do we really think this is entirely due to Republican obstruction? Or is it also possible that the party charged with taking black Americans to the Promised Land has been running around in circles?
The left has been ceded a monopoly on caring about black people, and monopolies are dangerous. They create ossified institutions, paralyzed by groupthink and incapable of self-reflection. To the extent that liberals are willing to be self-critical, its generally to flagellate themselves for not being liberal enough , for failing to stand fast with the old, accepted orthodoxies. Monopolies also lead to arrogance and entitlement, and the left is nothing if not arrogant when it comes to constantly and loudly asserting its place as the One True Friend of Black America. And yet, as good as liberal policies on race sound in speeches, many of them dont hold up in the real world....
this day, the language of racial balance, as used by the left, keeps us talking about integrated schools. But institutions dont integrate. People do. If a school is 3 percent black, but all of those students are actively engaged in making friends and participating in student activities, then those children are well and fully integrated. If a school is 20 percent black but all the black students stay on their own side of the cafeteria and then get bused home at 3 p.m. every day, then there is no integration taking place at that school. Trying to measure integration with percentages is like trying to measure your weight in inches....
With Jim Crow, black America lived under an onerous, top-down system that told them where their children could and could not go to school. Now, with busing, black America lived under an onerous, top-down system that told them where their children could and could not go to school. A 1972 Gallup poll showed that 77 percent of whites were against busing. The same poll showed 47 percent of blacks were against it as well. Many black Americans did believe in the school bus and the access it provided, and busing might have been a viable tool for those families had it been smartly and surgically applied. It wasnt. It was presented in a sweeping fashion that denied many blacks the agency they sought."
http://www.slate.com/articles/life/history/features/2014/the_liberal_failure_on_race/how_the_left_s_embrace_of_busing_hurt_the_cause_of_integration.html

I don't disagree with you, the article contains the standard simplistic straw-men and name calling that characterizes every piece written by a liberal on race relations. I assume that stuff is mandatory if its going to be published in a rag like Slate. It felt to me like the author felt he had to justify that he really, truly is a good liberal and felt he had to go through the usual silliness of establishing his bush hating bona fides before he could get to the actual substance.
What I found surprising is that within the usual anti-republican cliches there is actual recognition that liberal policies have hurt blacks. Its rare to find an open minded progressive who can look at actual results rather than just congratulating themselves for their intentions. Its a good first step if this country is ever going to help blacks overcome what liberals have done to them over the last 50 years or so.
Why do you assume blacks are incapable of of obtaining free photo Ids?
Thanks though for illustrating so perfectly my larger point. Rather than examine the havoc your policies have wreaked on the black community in cities like Chicago you immediately start fear mongering with made up accusations about denying blacks the right to vote.
There may not have been voter fraud in the past elections. But we have over 20million illegal aliens in this country who can change the landscape of our politics and it is time for voter identification.
It should be made free to everyone. Citizens have no problem identifying themselves for social services and they should have no problem providing identification for voter registration.
Here's one for you John.
That's probably the most coherent post you've put together. Good to see.
Whether or not its necessary to prevent voter fraud, I'm still curious why you assume that:
.
"this question, which eventually works its way through the entire black community is "why are these people INSISTING on something that is not needed ?" would only work its way through the entire black community? AreLatinosandCaucasianstoo dumb to think of it, or are they too smart? What is itaboutblacks that makes them believe showing a free identification card to a voting judgeconstitutesa scam?
Then you don't read me much
That's absolutely true.
Under what drug or alcohol induced psychosis do conservatives think that minorities or women would have bettered their causes by supporting republicans over the last 50 years? Minorities and women knew that the party of WASPs would never give them a voice in matters.
conservative
Under what drug or alcohol induced psychosis do conservatives think that minorities or women would have bettered their causes by supporting republicans over the last 50 years?
FN1,
I'm pretty sure that this isn't what the article's all about. I don't believe there was any claim that the conservatives could have done better. I don't believe there was any alternate plan floated. I do believe this is about liberal hubris; it's about a group that felt that nobody but nobody could have possibly addressed this issue; no one had the right credentials to right this wrong than they.
Schools of thought and political factions know when things go wrong. Unfortunately, they get the best idea when they've been voted out. November will not go well for the extreme elements in either party. The country recognizes the extremities in political thought and figures.
Moderation works in sooooo many quarters...
imho, the liberals did not fail on race. by enslaving generations with lies and substiance level handout dependancy on them, they have secured their votes without question. on a less broad basis, race bating liberals like jessie, the rev, and other hate and division promotion artists have done very well for themselves financially by exploiting race.
yes, i would say it was a resounding win by the liberals, and their efforts continue to pay off.
Not really a fault of the US invasion . Even now [after the troops have been pulled out] there is still massive killing of Iraqi civilians happening ... led by some Al Qaeda guy named Hammadi .
The suppression of Shia by S. Hussein was a suppression of that [un]civil conflict . They couldn't get a revolt started because he had too much power . But it was bound to happen sooner or later with or without the US involvement .
How many did Hussein kill ? It might be a similar number ...
You are saying that it had no advantages to the US ... but it did . Here are 2 :
1] It brought about a diversion of Al Qaeda forces aimed at Iraq and away from the mainland US
2] It got us solid allies in Kurdish Iraq .
You seem to be missing the point that they were under constant vicious attacks from S. Hussein . That is no longer happening because we invaded & destroyed the power structure . Now we have them as an established ally & trading partner .
There are many factors which determine a providential time to act . The country lacked the political will to attack then . I'm sure the Kurds are happy now that the deed is done ...
While the article is needlessly verbose, it does capture the essence of one of the lefts largest sociological engineering feat and biggest failure; Bussing.
The damage bussing caused is still felt today in our neighborhoods and schools. It caused white flight from the city to the suburbs. And along with that, an entire tax base. It caused many urban schools to be turned into mini-prisons with security staff all around.
I left the city a bit over 10 years ago because of the dismal job the Milwaukee Public Schools was doing. Others, decided to use the Choice plan and if eligible, chose to send their children to private schools. This has left an MPS school system with predominantly black students, many whom are hostile to education.
It is a good article about a problem that festers like a sore in all urban environments.
I don't agree . Real allies in the strife ridden middle east are both rare & much needed . Turkey never was our ally so no loss there . And that's also why Israel is so important to ourmiddle east policy .
Perhaps all of us should take a long, hard look at the policies that have worked and those that haven't worked. About all races, cultures, etc.
I live in a very diverse city- Louisville, KY. Over 120 languages are spoken here. Years ago, in the 1980s, Louisville moved a lot of public housing facilities to the suburbs, so that the landscape would be more culturally diverse. Busing started in the 1960s and a lot of people left Louisville for other communities, for the "better" school systems in neighboring counties. We just have one school system, here, for the entire county, which has also merged into one government.
At present, the schools bus children all over the city to reach a specific "quota" of racially diverse elements. This means that if you are Chinese, and you live across the street from a school, you may not be allowed to attend that school, because another school way over on the other side of town has no Chinese students. The only part that really bothers me about all this, is that little kids ride the bus from 7 to 9 am, and again from 4 to 6 pm. That is a long school day for little kids.
This is a very multi-faceted problem, involving more than just African Americans, and more than just busing. Perhaps all of us should stop and take a look at what hasn't worked, and try to figure out what will.
Some ally */S
The story comes just days after a Wall Street Journal report that American officials believe Turkeys powerful spymaster, Hakan Fidan, handed Iran crucial intelligence collected not just by Israel but also by the United States.
If the reports are correct, Turkey is not just failing in its duties as a NATO ally, it is also acting as an enemy of the United States and its European allies, members of NATO. If the allegations are true, Ankara undermined a campaign focused on what is probably the most important of all strategic concerns for the West: preventing Iran from developing nuclear weapons.
J4T @
Back to the original point about offending Turkey ... it doesn't matter . They are not a real ally .
Dowser, no one is going to admit that bussing hasn't worked. They can't, even though it has been such a colossal failure in so many ways. It was the end of communities that supported schools, the end of parents and teachers working together as partners for the sake of the students... that closeness was the inevitable cost of bussing.
Even the friendships that students used to form with each other has been lost as a result, and when friendships form at school, the relationships don't carry over into the homes so that parents can get to know who their kids are hanging with or get the opportunity to meet the parents of those kids the way they used to, because of the logistics, the increased homework burden on today's kids, and the homes where both parents are working to make ends meet.
Unfortunately, after billions of dollars later, black students test scores and dropout rates are far WORSE than before busing, 40 years later.
Busing rates a FAIL all across the board.
You're right. No one is ever going to look for an honest solution, because no one can admit that something that cost millions of dollars didn't work.
You do make a valid point actually, John. Photo ID shouldnt be requisite to voting. I'd say it definitely prevents a lot of people from voting who might otherwise have. I think it hits the elderly especially hard, and seems to target minorities specifically.
I believe the stat for voter fraud in the last election was something like 85 people (out of how many million or so who actually voted?). Seems like a non issue (voter fraud) being made into an issue by forcing peoples hands unfairly.
I was referring to the law makers and politicians, Robert.