NSA whistleblower Edward Snowden is nominated for Nobel Peace Prize
Barack Obama may have a to-do pile full of Edward Snowden-related headaches, but the NSA whistleblower might be joining him on one of the world's more prestigious clubs.
Mr Snowden has been nominated by two Norwegian MPs for the Nobel Peace Prize, a gong the President himself won in 2009.
Baard Vegard Solhjell, a former environment minister, and Snorre Valen said on Wednesday the public debate and policy changes "in the wake of Snowden's whistleblowing has contributed to a more stable and peaceful world order."
Mr Snowden, who had worked as a contractor for the National Security Agency, made global headlines beginning in June last year when he unleashed revelation after revelation about government snooping in various countries.
His releases sparked diplomatic grumbles aplenty. One of the more problematic was the revelation that US spies tapped the German Chancellor Angela Merkel's personal mobile phone. - http://www.independent.co.uk/news/world/americas/nsa-whistleblower-edward-snowden-nominated-for-nobel-peace-prize-9093215.html
~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~
Ever since Obama falsely received the Nobel Peace Prize in 2009, I've had little or no regard for that award. Still, it would seem ironic if he did indeed win it.
Tags
Who is online
71 visitors

The Nobel definitely lost its luster when Obama received it, but I would say the Snowden deserves it far more than Obama did. Perhaps the two of them can settle the score in a celebrity boxing match.
While I agree that giving a "Peace" prize to someone who gives orders to kill other humans is a questionable award. "One bad apple", there have been many more deserving awards through the years. I'll have to see more of a trend to give up on rewarding a prestigious award for those who better this world.
Snowden's actions helped who? How many? Made life better?
Arguably, the Nobel Peace Prize is the pice de rsistance of all world wide awards. Those who further and promote peace need to recognized. Sadly, it has taken a political bend thus losing its luster.
Traitor is a ridiculous word for a whistleblower. If Snowden had taken the "government approved" route for whistleblowing, none of us would have ever heard of the guy, or of the government's overreach.
Traitor is the accurate depiction Hal. I was pretty middle of the road on this for quite awhile, but Based upon the information that he has disclosed to the Russians on embedded programming on Chinese computers, the bastard has put lives at risk. I'm sure that I need not remind you of the level of cyber attacks on US networks originating from China hackers.
I doubt Angela Merkel has much sympathy. If this system wasn't being abused, Snowden would still be an NSA analyst, using it the way the governmentclaims it was designed to be used. By the way, I'm still unconvinced that Snowden isn't simply a planneddistraction to unveil our new toy to the world. In government, sometimes it's best if the tail wags the dog.
My sentiments are the same, APax. And, yes, how ironic it would be if it happened!
(Just a silly notation, but I think Snowden looks different -- not only aged, but matured/experienced---that same loss of innocence that I saw in Tiger Woods eyes and expressions after he became popular:)
Does this mean you were in favor of Yassir Arafat's award ?
obama should get the prize again, for increasing and expanding george w bush's domestic civilian surveilance program.
It makes no sense to announce the capability of this sort of information/intelligence gathering system. Unless it was a way to see what networks went silent that they had been tracking after the announcement, this system would seem to work best without it being known about.
Have you given it a consideration that the system could be used to root out intelligence moles in our government and that of our allies? Just a possibility, and I have no proof of the same.
I'll stand by my use of the word 'traitor'. He decided all on his own to violate the law, violate the agreements (non-disclosure) he signed and has put and continues to put lives in danger, as long as new items come to light.
Angela Merkel's outrage is a politician's outrage-and it is for show. Countries, even friends have spied on each other since the dawn of civilization. It's not something that is said aloud in the diplomatic encounters countries ahve with each other, but it exists and will continue to exist. How many embassies in Washington D.C. do you think have an espionage arm? Most, if not all would be the right answer....
We were 'friends' with Russia after the cold war....and yet, they never removed their sleeper agents in the U.S. until they were exposed and deported.
It's the world we live in.
The spying you are talking about is much different than the spying, and outright abuse, that this system is capable of. We have impeached a sitting president for doing exactly what our current administrationis doing, and they are doing itwithout even having to leave their seat, without anymeaningful oversight, and without any accountability.Without someone stepping forward to disclose to the American citizens what is happening, we never would have even known about it. And before you continue arguing how this system is designed for a good purpose, read this article about the guy who designed it has to say about it:
...
This system is set up for the highly unconstitutional purposes of parallel construction. You are no longer living in the country you thought you were living in.
I see interesting options -
Snowden accepts the Nobel Prize in absentia (dressed in prison orange)
or
Seal Team Six extracts Mr Snowden from the award ceremony
Either would work for me
Snowden is sitting comfortably out of reach from US prosecution, in a country presided over by one of the world's most notorious former spies. Meanwhile, back home there is controversial banter swaying public opinion in the direction of granting Snowden immunity, while the government quietly pretends to remain resolute. I predict that in the long run, he will not be prosecuted, havingultimately let the cat out of the bag in a manner that sheds the best light onthe US government.Then everyone can be happy, and the world can just move on with the understanding thatthe UShas the ability towatch you, listen to you, and plunder your private correspondence at will.
You ask why it makes sense to unveil the secret program? Simple - it is far too big to successfully keep hidden any longer. With millions of contractor analysts our there accessing the treasure trove of information being stored in Utah, eventually it will become public knowledge. Better to orchestrate that release in a manner which the government can control it, than to have it exposed by a wildcard.
Your latter comment makes sense on the disclosure.
Right - nothing to see here ... remember that constitution thing you learned about in school? Just forget about that, it no longer applies. Technology now rules the day, and every day that passes introducessome new advancement in technology to get more insight into your private affairs. Just accept it people - one daythe television in your living roomwill double as a camera that can be activated at will by people whose salariesare paid by you, in order to keep you safe from terrorism, of course.
It's also is ironic that the GOP/conservatives agree with Obama that Snowden is a traitor. Worldwide, he's considered a hero.
No AP..... World wide he is NOT considered a hero.
Just like in the US you find people on both sides of the issue and differing opinions.
Guess you're not a fan of the Constitution. Are you a fan of George Orwell?
Hal
Can you cite the specific part of the Constitution that allows a citizen to divulge classified information to our enemies?
Just curious
p.s.
I liked Animal Farm but none of the other Orwell novels
I dont think you quite understand, or appreciate the technical nuances it takes to store and process information. You dont understand what a codec is, digital formats are or what proprietary coding encompasses.
You dont understand the different dynamics in which data is stored and how each process is difference is coded differently and cannot communicate with each other.
To this date, proprietary and storage by the telecoms is a safe way to insure privacy UNLESS there is not a third party surreptitiously gathers and processes this info. ISPs never used it, phone companies alsountil the NSA unconstitutionally stepped in and demanded their records under the lie of national defense.
What Snowden did was a reaction to a far bigger miscarriage of the constitution, by our own government. This system is being used by law enforcement to obtain information without a warrant, then make arrests and falsify information to be used in a court of law. If it is being so flagrantly abused in that fashion, then why on earth would anyone believe that it isn't being exploited in any number of ways to game the system in the areas of insider trading, theft of intellectual property, political attacks, illegal information gathering to advance legal cases, etc. etc.? All you need is to know the right person, and currently our tax dollars are paying the salaries of 4.5 million security clearance holders who have access to that ocean of information. Are you nave enough to think that there's no chance that any of them would sacrifice their integrity for the right price? Hell, Snowden did it for free. If only 0.01% of them would be willing to accept cash for information, that's 450 people.
Snowden, Assange, Manning, Vanunu - the true heroes of our time - Whistle blowers are still regarded as traitors, but the real traitors are those who were responsible for the acts they exposed.
Maybe you should ask the relatives of the eleven innocent people, including a Reuters news photographer and his driver, who were accidentally mowed down by a US helicopter gunship in Iraq, caught on a classified video tape never meant to see the light of day. On the video, the aircrew can be heard laughing and calling the victims dead bastards. Is that how you regard your family? Would you prefer to let that disgusting mistake remain a secret?
Hal
Thanks for the feedback from which I take it that your answer to my question is NO
Let's expand upon the futility of your question: If 100,000 people had their investmentsruined because of some insider trading that resulted from information illegally gleaned from PRISM, who would you be more concerned about prosecuting? The guy who illegally obtained and sold the information, or the guy who exposed the scam by leaking evidence of the crime?
Hal
You can keep deflecting and spinning all you want
The answer to the question I asked(which is emphasized by your endless defection) is that you cannot show me where the constitution allows citizens to give classified material to our enemies.
I said thank you for the answer even though you are doing everything possible not to simply say it
You must be joking. I'm spinning?! Your willingness to overlook how your government is committing massive fraud is truly embarrassing. This isn't hearsay, it's openly admitted to by the people who are engaging in it. I have no reason to engage with amindless defense of such flagrantly un-American secret policy against their own citizens, so go ask your idiotic question in the echo chamber that you seek.
Incidentally, there has been nothing leaked by Snowden that has a potential for anything other than exposure of a dishonest ally, and embarrassing behavior unbecoming of a government official.
Hal
Yes you are spinning
I asked a simple question and instead of answering it (because the answer contradicts a point you made earlier) you go on and on with deflections rather than answering a simple question
and BTW, there is no way you (or anyone else) can be sure of what has been leaked by Snowden while he has been in Russia
Fine Robert, I'll play your game, but if I honestly answer your question, youshould feelobligated to answer mine. The events I am concerned with predate the one you are so hopelessly chasing after.
I'm no lawyer, but I would guess that no, there is nothing in the Constitution that specificallyallows for divulging classified information which could end up in the hands of our enemies. Since you have already admitted that there is no way to know if any actually damaging information has crossed that threshold, you can stop pretending that it must be true now.
Your turn: Is the US legal system completely dysfunctional and blatantly discriminatory when law enforcement is allowed to arrest, prosecute and imprison its citizensbased upon information illegally obtained without a warrant? Please expand upon your answer to indicate that you do understand that this is not just a minor problem, and that it is clearly indicative of a system prone to abuse of many potential varieties.
Hal
The level of damage the information will cause is immaterial, if it was classified and divulged by Snowden a crime was committed and that crime is likely treason
Thanks for the answer.
The answer to your question is NO, though there are instances of the malfeasance and inappropriate prosecution
So that's a "I'm perfectly fine withthe government ignoring theConstitution, but any citizen who does should be prosecuted to the fullest extent of the law." Got it.
Funny, comingfrom someone who routinely accuses Obama of unconstitutional behavior.
RiO;
Can you cite the specific part of the Constitution that not allow a citizen to divulge classified information of our government committing crimes?
Just curious.
A P
No and I made no assertion that there was one
I do know that there are laws in the books that do not allow it
For example
Good point. Apparently the only part of the Constitution that addresses how to deal with a tyrannical government is the Second Amendment. Don't divulge the tyranny, just shoot it.
Hal
If that is the appropriate response in your mind the you should try it I guess
Good luck with that
No one cares. Lol.
I bet they are concerned - they might have to go back to doing police work the old fashioned way - by seeking a warrant, instead of framing citizens and lying to the judge in order to put them in prison!
I beg to differ. Every intelligent American I know cares about these abuses.
Yes Bruce. An FBI program that was to sniff out all stuff on the internet and it did until it was replaced with better software called NarusInsight.
And I have to agree with Bruce here. The only real thing that Snowden told us were specifics.
I don't view him as atraitoror a hero. He answered to his own conscience. Offering his name up for a Peace Prize just makes that stupid award that much more worthless... but we knew that already.
Excuse me, but a lot of people think the true traitors are the ones that lie to us and violate our rights, and abuse the powers they have garnered through the very people they are screwing.
Don't you think the people responsible for the NSA breaking the law should be jailed too?
Hal,
Gotta agree with that, too. I have to say, that this is a topic that I do feel is important. I don't think that the government has the right to spy on us in this capacity. I do believe in whistle blowers. But it's Snowden's hosts in Russia, that I am not too fond of.
96WS6
If violations of the law and the FISA Court orders occurred then yes those that perpetuated (the higher ups) should be prosecuted and if convicted punished
Hal
I had not heard that and now that I have I doubt that it is true
I do appreciate your attempt at sarcasm though
AP--at 10 hours ago--lol, that is amusing. That's another realization and proof to me that the partisan view is somewhat all for show. Both 'sides' have something to lose in being exposed. People/citizens worldwide probably loved finding out what's been going on behind their backs, even if it mostly involved their Leadership. On the other hand, some might be irate to have found out their phone companies have a deal with their government to access submarine cable -- and who's paying for their government to do that--their taxpayers, I would assume.
Nixon's resignation was the result of an impending impeachment. Had he not resigned, he most certainly would have been impeached for his involvement in doing exactly what any current or future president now has the clandestine ability to do, without anyone ever knowing about it - thanks to the current state of surveillance technology. You may argue about the minutia of exactly how he left office, but the facts are clear about why he left office.
Google the form SF-312. Everyone ever granted access to clasisfied information has signed this form signalling their agreement with the rules contained therein.
This assclown decided all by himself that he had the right to decide what should or should not be public knowledge. In direct contravention of the agreement he signed to protect and not disclose. He is not a hero.He failed to follow channels that were available to him and broke the law.
2 wrongs don't make a right is what comes to mind here.
It happened in 2007, and was leaked in 2010. At what point do you suppose this secret was to be let out? What amoronic far fetchedassumption.
Thanks for pointing out that he leaked classified information. However,it's quite obvious thateverybody already knows that, and your comment contributes nothing to this conversation. The channels that are available to a whistleblower lead directly to a gag order, and possibly prosecution for some trumped up accusation designed to discredit the whistleblower and turn any opinions against them. This is exactly what happened to Bill Binney, the original NSA architect of the clandestine surveillance software, when he quit over his observations of how it was being used unconstitutionally against US citizens, and took the "available whistleblowing route."
The Growing Campaign to Revoke Obama's Nobel Peace Prize -
I saw this today on the news......
Did Russia Snoop?
Yeah, everyone does it. The manufactured outrage from the leadership of countries is just that....it's a pro forma thing.
Funny-very little useful reporting here. Like how many times has the committee actually 'revoked' an award? Do they also force the recipient to give back the money? If so, how? Would they even actually do a revocation-as that would force them to admit they 'FUBAR-ed' that award in the first place?
Seems like this is just a petition that allows people to admit they screwed up in celebrating the 'He's Not Bush' Award in the first place.
From Did Russia Snoop?
This only adds further credence to the possibility that the entire surveillance situation, including Snowden, the NSA, the Obama administration, and Putin, is nothing but a contrived effort to introduce the world to the new reality that privacy is no longer guaranteed with private communications of any sort. Note that Snowden is safely out of reach of the US, who is doing nothing to try and change that, and he is taking refuge under Putin - who now appears to have the same type of freedom to plunder private communications from anywhere as the NSA does.
In this narrative, Snowdenmight be nothing more than a willing pawn in the effort to unveil something far too big to hide anymore. His purposemight beto play the villain of US government for a while, while the US government softens and eventually pardons his actions based on populist support for a whistleblower. In the end, what is left is a world that is now conditioned to the reality that there are agencies thatcan snoop anywherethey want with impunity. The US government then pretends to accommodate citizen outrage over the intrusion of privacy by claiming to make some tweaks to their methods, which are top secret anyways so nobody would be the wiser if these changes occurred at all, then everybody is supposed to be happy.
Snowden may be more deserving of a Grammy than a Nobel Peace Prize.
Funny....now this piece of news:
She's not too upset about the methodology of where this information came from......so, if you're going to have standards, you should make them double....just so you have more.....
wasnt he one of the govt contractor types obama just gave a cola increase guarantee to?
money well spent.