Enforcement of Work Requirements for Food Stamp Recipients Resumes
More than 10,000 Ohio residents lost food stamp benefits this month because they failed to meet newly enforced work requirements.
About 140,000 adults who dont have dependent children can receive assistance only if they spend at least 20 hours a week working, attending school or job training, or volunteering.
Advocates for the poor and human services officials said that number will likely increase sharply next month because county caseworkers, particularly in urban areas, have not yet completed required assessments to determine whether current recipients must comply with the new rules.
Food-stamp recipients may be exempted due to mental illness, substance abuse or other issues.
The work requirement has been in place since 1996, but Ohio has used a federal waiver for the past six years to exempt food-stamp recipients from work because the economic recession had made jobs so scarce.
But Republican Gov. John Kasich announced last year that Ohio would begin enforcing the work requirement Oct. 1 in all but 16 counties with high unemployment, even though the state still qualified for the waiver.
Thousands of recipients about 75 percent in some counties have also failed to respond to letters asking them to go to county Job and Family Services officers for assessment, and many of them will likely be removed from the rolls next month.
About 10 percent of the mailings were returned because the person no longer lived at the address on file.
http://www.rawstory.com/rs/2014/01/24/more-than-10000-lose-food-stamps-as-ohio-resumes-enforcement-of-work-requirement/

Is this to much to ask?
Once again, your feedback is appreciated though the vitriolic labeling of people is not appreciated.
People, at times need a hand up and support through the bad times, the point of the article was to discuss the validity of the work/train/volunteer requirements for some food stamp recipients in Ohio not to denigrate anyone
You are welcome to provide comments and views as you see fit and I a free to call them meaningless vitriol that adds nothing to the discussion of the topic presented.
That you would compare people to cockroaches says more about you than it does about the group you are attempting to denigrate
In case you missed it!
No, and more states should be using the same guidelines.
screminmimi
Appreciate the feedback and the perspective
He speaks the truth and isn't the only one that feels that way. Its time we stand up and free ourselves from government slavery. Half my working life I've spent a slave to the government. I'm sick of them stealing my earnings and handing it over to every Tom, Dick and Harry on skid row.
''One of the biggest, and first mistakes we made in this country was to vilify "judging people", because that lack of labeling people for what they really are, is at the root of our conjoined inability to weed-out the worthless, because our society decided that calling some people worthless was wrong.''
Mike, to judge people is one thing. To get to the point to they are considered to be ''worthless'' is a step to far. Many societies have done this, (Nazi Germany) for one. So if people are worthless, that in makes them sub-human, the next step is to consider eliminating them.
What do you propose as the tool to eliminating them Mike? Shall we put themon reservations, maybe IntermentCamps. That way they would be out of sight and we could ship them some commodities, you know spam and crap like that. Much cheaper and soon they would die off.
Let me give you an example Mike, you were a Marine at one time. Well, I know this Marine that is disabled, seriously disabled from an enemy suicide bomb attack. He gets a grand total of $16 per month in food stamps. You know what he does with that $16? He buys what little groceries he can with it, and donates it to an home for abused children. He says that they need it more than he does.
You see Mike, NO ONE is worthless.
Are there some that abuse the system, of course there are. By implementing the rules that Ohio is doing, should help to weed out those that are not deserving of the help.
When one considers him or herself in the position that people can be worthless, it's time for them to re access their moral compass.
You are not America not even close, your attitude represents nothing of what this country is about.
And your reading comprehension is need of some work - I did not defend anyone getting or not getting benefits but rather presented the changes that Ohio has made and asked if the requirements wereunreasonable.
Of course you were to eager to label and hate to understand that
Kavika
Thanks for your wise perspective on this issue
As always I appreciate and learn from your feedback
That you served is admirable and I thank you for your service.
But your attitude and words are counter to all that the S. is bout and stands for.
Pardon the typo
It should have read
I would love to see the Civilian Conservation Corps come back to life. During the World Wars when there were men who could not serve in the military due to physical problems that kept them from being passed as fit for combat, they would join the CCC in order to do something to be of service to the country and earn money for their families.
The CCC is largely responsible for the massive infrastructure we have that is now falling apart. There is nothing at all wrong with placing these capable men and women on a payroll and providing them with a purpose and some dignity to their lives while taking care of America at the same time.
Adults, like children, will live down to expectations. Give them a reason to look up.
The pure arrogance with which you se yourself as the judge of who is worthless and what is right and wrong indicates to me that the compass needs a little calibrating
I would appreciate your thoughts on whether the requirement to work, attend school or a training program or to volunteer in the community is a reasonable requirement for the receipt of food stamps by the group of people affected
If all you have is labeling, name calling and hate then I will thank you for stopping by
Mike,
The point of the article was that Ohio was doing something to change it. I have no problem, that those that refuse to work, or want to be dependent on the gov't to be taken off the program.
It's the broad paint brush used to blast all of them and usingthe terms worthless and cockroach, that you used.That isbelow you Mike.
My reference to the disabled Marine wasn't him so much as it was the $16 that he gives every month to help what some consider ''throw away kids''. In other words, ''worthless''.
Dear Friend Mimi: Well said. I concur.
We have structural problems in this economy. Not enough jobs to go around, people working multiple jobs that don'tmake enough to sustain families.
Putting American back to work to rebuild infrastructure, clean up pollution, taxing corporations fairly, so they pay for the benefits of that infrastructure, training people to fill open jobs where commerce and industry need help, but cannot find people with the skills to do the work are all sensible approaches.
To address Robert's questions, and get the article back on tract, unless there is a disability which prevents it, requiring people to receive training, and go to work when they are trained and work is available to them makes strong sense. It will boost their self-esteem, give them a path out of poverty and dependence. In the case of jobs which don' pay enough initially for them to make ends meet, raising minimum wage and keeping intact the social safety net to people don't have work disincentives. but also can't rejectwork inc3eintives through benefit enrollment and participation standards seem to me not too much to ask of the working able.
My answer to Robert's question is that I do not, with certain already stated qualifications have a problem with using these programs to help peopleget back to self-sufficiency. That is where dignityis onthe individual level. It is also where sustainable growth is on the national economic level.
mimi, Enoch,
I don't know if your aware of it, but the CCC had an Indian CCC division in Minnesota.
This is a great link for it. Click on the photo entitled, entitled ''CCC Crew Grand Portage''. There are a couple of my relatives. The guy kneeling down is a very close relative of mine.
...
My relatives lived in the CCC camps and got $30.00 per month. $22.50 was sent to the family. I was told that it was easy work for them, because they were used to the bittercold and hard labor, havinglived in the northern timber there whole lives. They were tough. I have a couple of old photos that show them when they went deer hunting while working at with the CCC.
That is cool, Kavika!
My Dad had a heart problem and wasn't allowed to enlist in the military with his brothers so he joined the CCC. He was stationed in the Smoky Mountains during one of the worst winters they had in years, and often talked about wading through the snow up to his knees. He was the boxing champ for his company.
I was not aware of an Indian CCC division. Was that because of a segregation policy?
BTW, I typed this before checking out the link you posted. Going there now.
Robert, I believe more states should do what Ohio is doing but probably won't because it would require hiring staff to check the paperwork and verify that participants actually looked for jobs. As it is now, computers just add money to the debit cards. I know it takes a human to key in the data to do that, but it would require face time to verify job hunting.
Dear Friend Kavika: Great article. Thanks for sharing it.
This shows how public-private partnerships do work when petty partisan politics don't prevent people working together toward commonly shared values, goals and aspirations.
It also shows how Native Americans when not having their hands tied by societal prejudice, discrimination, or bureaucracies can produce results far beyond resources given them.
That is how it is for us all.
All most of us need is a chance, not a system set up to prevent our success.
To Having Chances, Creating Progress; and Enjoying the Bounty That Produces.
Enoch.
''Was that because of a segregation policy?''...Do it wasn't mimi. At first there wasn't going to be an Indian CCC, but some prevailed on the gov't to add them, because of the long depression and how they were suffering. So they started the Indian CCC.
In 1942 the gentleman kneeing, joined the military and fought all through the Pacific and did a couple of other in the photo.
Happy that you enjoyed it my friend. Yes, in times of need, like now, private/public do work.
Remove the barriers that are put up and all can do really well in their endevors.
Went to the link and read the entire article. I never realized what a boost the CCC was for the Indians as well as the rest of the unemployed young men in the country at the time. The article goes into great depth about the amazing accomplishments and hard work the Indians dedicated to the conservation of the areas they were responsible for.
The description of the camps they built and the fact that there were educational classes available was a surprise. The CCC was such a success; I can understand it being discontinued because WWII made supplies scarce, but I can't see why something of its nature can't be brought about today.
The guys who entered the program even signed an agreement to send the majority of their money home to help their families who had no means of support.
HELLO!!!!
It was very important to all Americans mimi. Times were really tough for a number of years. I was told by relatives, that they would try to find coal that had fallen off trains and use it for heating. This is done by ''walking'' the tracks in below zero weather.
I agree, I think that it would take some modifications but could give a real boost to many people.
There are a lot of stories that I have about the Indian CCC, all from relatives and elders that were there, and actually did the work.
Kavika
No one, most especially a child, is worthless!
Thanks for the perspective
J F T
Thanks for dropping in with your perspective, always appreciated
scremminmimi
The CCC and other programs similar to it could be created to get people into a mode of contributing, to the the extent that they are able to physically, for the benefits they are receiving.
Answering a phone, working in a day care center, light janitorial work, stocking shelves, yard work, school volunteers in a variety of ways etc would all be contributing positions to the good of the community.
Exactly
Enich
I always appreciate your perspective and wise, well reasoned input
Thanks for your view of this issue which is of great interest in the Buckeye State right now.
Kavika
Thanks for sharing the link, excellent article
Enoch
So very well said, from your lips to the ears of all citizens and especially our elected representatives
John
A serious question
Are thee really a lot of $1 per our jobs in your area?
None in Ohio where the restrictions in this article are taking effect
The work/volunteer requirements in Ohio are for adults, without dependent children, and do not seem onerous to me.
Dear Friend Robert in OH: Thanks.
Peace Abundant Blessings and Prosperity in this New Year and always.
Enoch.
Dear Friend Robert: Ohio is a wonderful state. More cities than any other in the union.
I always enjoyed my times there.
I wish all in the Buckeye State only the best life has to offer.
E.
Enoch
Thanks you for those good wishes
Living in a small farming village in the NE of the state, we have the tranquility and beauty that we consider the best and we all consider ourselves blessed
Good wishes and blessings to you as well
Enoch
And toyou as well
John,
Many people getting less than $600 in food stamps are also getting almost free housing, and drastically reduced electric services. They are also getting some form of Medicare.
If you add all the benefits they are receiving then yes, they should qualify for a work program and training program of some sort and if they refuse they do not deserve the services. If they are men who have dependent children whose mothers are dependent on social services and they refuse to sign over a portion of their wages to the mothers so that the mothers can cut their dependency on social services, then they need to be put in jail and made to work on community work projects with all their "earned" money going toward child support.
Yes, I said it.
It takes manpower to verify the applicants actually went job hunting. That's the only drawback.
Dr Rock
It would be great if a lot (if not all) of the folks who are unemployed and receiving assistance were able to find and then take jobs, then these restrictions would not apply to them if they were still eligible for assistance
Egilman
When I lived in Milwaukee, the state called it "W2 or Welfare to Work"
screminmimi
Could be jobs for some of those affected perhaps?
The new face of food stamps: working-age Americans - ...
Some of the change is due to demographics, such as the trend toward having fewer children. But a slow economic recovery with high unemployment, stagnant wages and an increasing gulf between low-wage and high-skill jobs also plays a big role. It suggests that government spending on the $80 billion-a-year food stamp program twice what it cost five years ago may not subside significantly anytime soon.
Note to Conservatives -Food Stamps; It's not just for blacks anymore,
A P
Not sure what race has to do with discussion of whether the work/training/school/volunteer restrictions on persons (without children) in order to receive food stamp support is reasonable or not?
The question (and therefore the answer) has nothing to do with race
The voucher approach is a great idea, and would only need spot checking.
Egilman
Interesting point ad perspective thanks for sharing it with us
I wrote this article on the CCC Camps back in 2010 and put it up on NV then brought it here in 2012. I still think it is a viable way to address the welfare rolls.
A National Civilian Conservation Corps Could It Work Again?
Larry
Or some variation there of
That approach could indeed be part of the solution to getting the nation back on track
Thanks for sharing the artcle
Thanks for your remarks Robert, it would be one way of getting people moving in the right direction again. I'm sure there are those who would be opposed to the idea and they are probably the ones to lazy to work anyway.
John
Or they could take part in job training or go to school (on a pell grant or other aid) to prepare themselves for a better job while they continue to receive the food stamp aid they get.
Either of those options or even volunteering would seem to be a better option than simply doing nothing.
Maybe I am old fashioned in that belief but that is how see it.
And as to the math in your example if they receive $100 for 20 hours (of whatever option they choose) then the rate would be $5 per hour 5 x 20 = 100
John
My mistake I was thinking of 100 per week and you are correct it is 100 per month for some
I am glad to hear you say
That means a process could be worked out by compromise and if they were working they would be receiving the minimum wage and their food stamps so they would be ahead of where they are now.
Again apologies for the week vs month mix up in my head
didnt the first black president, bill clinton, agree to work requirements, before the second black president, took them away?
JoAnne
You keep replacing your own comments as the worst and most useless ever posted on one of my articles
Congratulations