The Cost of Increasing the Minimum Wage
Mark Emmer, Author, Speaker, Consultant and Expert in Strategic Planning is President of Optimize Inc ., a management consulting firm, specializing in Strategic Planning. Marc can be reached at marc@optimizeinc.net
I am not a political columnist, and this is not a political column. This post does not pontificate the merits for or against the increase in the minimum wage. The value it has to society can be debated by the political pundits on Fox and MSNBC . This commentary purely relates to the cost of the changes to the minimum wage for purposes of planning labor costs, price increases and the like.
I believe that the debate is centered on the cost of raising the wages of the lowest paid employees, but that only sheds light on part of the story. Lets assume that we stratify wages into four groups: front line employees, supervisors, managers (administrators) and executives. At least three of these groups will be impacted by minimum wage increases.
Say an entry level employee moves from $9 per hour, to $12 or $15 per hour. The employees already at that hourly rate will also expect a raise based on their experience or skills. The margin between these worker types may be reduced, but it will still need to be maintained.
All other wages calculated on the base rate will also move upward. The scale moves on time and half (for overtime pay), sick pay, vacation pay, internships and workers compensation will all increase significantly.
But perhaps the real hidden burden is in indirect costs. Supervisors and managers are usually exempt employees and must be paid double the minimum wage (in some states such as California). Commissioned sales people (generally inside) must earn 1.5 times the minimum wage.
In Los Angeles or San Francisco, the minimum wage will be $15 per hour by 2017 and 2018 respectively. As a result, the minimum wage for every exempt worker will be over $60K and a commissioned inside salesperson (or customer service) will be $45k+.
Labor rates (as a percentage of revenue) vary dramatically from business to business. For the sake of comparison let us consider the following scenario (which assumes that average rate for front line workers is $9 per hour):
Company Revenue $20,000,000
Direct Labor Cost $4,000,000
Indirect Labor Cost $1,000,000
Increase in 5 Years Direct ($9-$15)
Increase in 5 Years Indirect ($15-$30)
Hours per year per worker 2140
Increased Cost Direct $664,000
Increased Cost Indirect $132,800
Increase in overtime & other costs $75,000
Total Cost Increase $872,464
In this scenario, if the company earned a 15% EBITDA (Earnings before Interest, Taxes, Depreciation and Amortization) or $3,000,000, the minimum wage increase would reduce profits by 29%. For a 10% EBITDA company, the burden is over 43% of the current profit.
So depending on the labor spend of the employer, the minimum wage increase will certainly materially affect profitability and competitiveness. Plan your decisions on business location and budget accordingly.
Tags
Who is online
87 visitors

There have been too many articles to count on News Talkers and on all other vehicles of the news media concerning the minimum wage, the need to raise the minimum wage an to what level to raise the minimum wage.
This article is not an argument for or against raising the minimum wage, but rather a look at the numbers, the cost of raising the minimum wage and the effect that cost could have on businesses big and small. Unintended consequences are often ignored by political zealots in their eagerness to promote their own agenda and the realities dismissed in discussions of what is right or wrong or what should or should not be done.
I personally think the minimum wage should be raised in a reasoned manner, such as President Obama proposed - $10,00 immediately and then tied to the cost of living index for annual increases in the future. I also believe that the minimum wage should be a national standard, without individual states setting their own levels.
I would appreciate it if comments were on the topic of the article -- the costs to businesses of raising the minimum wage (a scenario is provided in the article) and the likely consequences positive and negative of the increase. Bear in mind that the workers receiving the largest wage increases (positive effect) will not be immune from some of the negative consequences (job eliminations, business closures, etc)
Please discuss the topic and while I encourage disagreement and robust debate, I request a civil debate without personal attacks and encourage you to comment on what a person says rather than giving your interpretation of what they meant (which you cannot know).
Thanks in advance to all who might participate in the discussion.
True enough, but a minimum wage (entry level) that rises over time and matches up with the COL can also be a valuable tool in keeping the wage strategies of corporations and small businesses in touch with and driven by the reality of not only the (stock)market but also the market place where people shop and survive.
Here are a few thoughts I have about the min wage.
First of all, I too agree with the way Pres. Obama is doing it. This gives time for business who are smaller and are working on a close profit margin, not to lay people off. Which brings me to my second thought. Not all business are created equal. Some can afford to raise it, like Walmart, but don't. So what we should have is some sort of sliding scale for min wage vs profits. Those companies who can pay more, should (of course this would also be dependent on job skill, seniority, etc). This would get more people off of subsidies that they now need in order to survive.
Perrie
Actually WalMart took a small (very small) step in the direction of increasing wages and improving the work environment and it is showing in lower profits
Sliding scales do not work because like the tax code loopholes will be found an ways around the system will be gamed.
Tying the COL to annual increases (with a link to poverty level - not sure exactly how) would accomplish the elimination of subsidy from the government over time
I really appreciate your perspective and feedback
Funny that you should bring up tax loopholes, since I am against them... (personally they keep my accounting busy, but they are unfair).
COLA is really just meant to keep up with inflation. BTW right, most people's annual raise doesn't keep up with COLA, hence why so many people are falling out of the middle class. Yet many of these companies are showing record profits. That is a big issue.
What I meant about a sliding scale is that if you are a small business owner who employs under a certain number of people, you should just pay min wage, as proposed by Obama. Those who don't meet this criteria should be held to COLA or an approximation of it.
So someone making min wage at a "mom and pop" shop would be paid less than someone making min wage at a corporation ?
Does the government then subsidize the worker at the mom and pop shop to equalize his wage with the other ?
Which would then be in effect subsidizing the mom and pop shop.You get jobs where you can find them. If you can only get a job at a mom and pop store, than probably you don't have an alternative (small town, or no or little skills). No one promised parity in wages, John. All we can do is set a min.
That depends. Food stamps and school lunches I can see if a family falls below a certain level.
No it wouldn't be. If min wages are set to high, these stores would go out of business. What we are doing is keeping both business alive and having jobs available. It would be a subsidy if the those shops actually got money, which I am not proposing here.
If there is a "minimum wage", and some businesses are exempt (from THAT minimum wage , for whatever reason, maybe even a good one,) and then the employees of that company are given entitlements (food stamps, etc, ) because their INCOME is too low, then , in effect the exempt business is being subsidized as to their payroll. , aka, they don't have to pay the higher minimum wage, but someone else ( the big companies) does.
I have no problem with such subsidization - but everyone has to end up with the same minimum wage or it's not really a minimum wage.
Perrie
I am against tax loopholes as well _ I would like to see a progressive set of tax rates lower than they are today, a set amount that is non-taxable perhaps $30K and then everyone pays tax on the amount over that nontaxable amount, no deductions, no credits, no loopholes
If there is to be a minimum wage it must be for all jobs at all companies across the nation
L G L
I don't say this very often, but I agree with John on this one. A minimum wage must be for everyone or there will be abuses and gaming of the system.
Perrie
If the wage is raised slowly and steadily the spending will increase along with the added costs and it will be a bit easier.
There ill be jobs lost no doubt but a gradual increase and a tie to COL will make the hurt as minimal as it could be.
No one should be exempt from the minimum wage - whatever it happens to be set at and as the wages rise the level of subsidies will lower and eventually (hopefully) disappear.
The key is that the change must be gradual to minimize the unintended consequences.
While I am not an expert on economics and finance, and there are some terrific arguments here for and against raising the minimum wage across the board, there is one teensy-weensy little item that I almost never see mentioned: what do people do with the money they have, and what would they do if they had more of it?
We all live on a budget. We all want things. Some of us would like a new wardrobe, or a new TV, or the latest smartphone, or perhaps toys for our kids, or for ourselves... when we have the money, we go shopping: Walmart, Target, Amazon.com, the local pub, the local book store... we each have our favorite places to get what we want, along with what we need. Most of us have that wish-list, and now fast-forward to the employees of the various shops in your community, and imagine what those shops would be like if only ten more customers per day would drop by and actually spend real cash on something... and now take a good look at the faces of those customers: some of them are employees at places where YOU shop; they may be servers in your favorite restaurant, or the cashier at your favorite bookstore. Yes, those customers are also employees, and they cannot spend in your business money that they are not making in theirs.
That is really the bottom line. However the ledgers are stacked, a business that attracts people who spend money will have a better bottom line than a business where the community cannot afford to patronize it. I believe in the need for profits, but at some point obscene profits at the expense of the citizens and the workers defeat the entire system. Part with some cash now (by raising the minimum wage) and if all businesses do this, then everyone's employees will be able to afford to spend more money at other people's businesses, and their employees will spend more money in your business. Profits won't suffer, except in the short term. All else being equal, eventually the profits will reflect the increase in spending by people who are making more money.
Our so-called "middle class" is becoming an endangered species. Things are so out of synch that it is nearly impossible to predict any ultimate outcome. Housing costs are such that only the wealthiest few can now afford to buy homes in most markets. Rents have skyrocketed to where most people are priced out of those markets, too. The only ones who really care any more are the ones who are suffering. But the ones who should care are so busy enjoying the perks of their good fortune that they don't see that they are one small disaster away from joining the great unwashed who have been priced out of existence. The situation is beyond intolerable; it has become just short of a revolution. At some point the critical mass will be reached and heaven only knows what will happen then, but it doesn't take a psychic to know it won't be pretty.
Maybe, just maybe, raising the minimum wage will put a few more people in a position to live decent lives. Maybe they won't be wealthy, but will be tolerably able to maintain a degree of comfort for themselves and their families. Most people don't aspire to the kind of obscene wealth as that of Rupert Murdoch, of Warren Buffet. Most people just want a tiny corner of this planet in which to raise their families and live a reasonably comfortable life. And, our communities benefit from that kind of diversity. We can see what the current "status quo" has gotten us; why not try something different? Why not raise that minimum wage and see if it has the desired effect? Clearly, what we are doing now is NOT working at all.
bitemore
Thank you very much for the detailed feedback and perspective.
You have stated some self evident truths -
But in all honesty, I do not think the situation is as dire as you paint it or that it is irreversible. One thing we agree on, which is why I support a gradual and steady increase in the minimum wage (and thus all wages), is that the money will be spent and eventually business incomes will benefit from the increased spending power and the cycle will support itself
You present your perspective clearly and while I may not agree with your conclusions, I respect your position on the issue.
Thanks again for the feedback.
Thanks for posting an interesting and very timely article! It is definitely relevant, considering today's many issues!
LGL,
I am not sure what you are trying to say with your cartoon. There are business that are greedy, but plenty of mom and pops who run on a tight budget.
You should conclude that this person is as stupid as John Russell , obviously !
Bitey,
Great post!
On the subject of how much money does it take to make a family happy, I recently read that it seems that with each $10k increment, a person's happiness level increases, since it relives the stresses of how to pay your bills. This of course depends on where you live. Here is an article about that:
I was with you before Perrie, up to a point. Then you suggested two different minimum wages dependent on the size of the employer. The minimum wage isn't for the employer, it's for the employee.
We could have government subsidies for the mom and pop operation to assist them to pay the minimum wage.
The cartoon speaks for itself.
Who are you as dumb as, a ROCKy ?
What does corrupt politician have to do with the conversation?
notemore
I would do it more often, if more direct feedback on the topic was provided as you did.
We did not agree on key points but we each presented our views and provided feedback on the other's point as well
And no one called anyone names, or applied labels - wow discussion works
Thanks again for the feedback.
Petey
Personal attacks are not appreciated or welcome on my articles - cease and desist please or do not bother participating.
LGL
Do not encourage him please!
Woodie
I question the specifics you cite, e.g. those who are on welfare want their hours cut so they can stay on welfare, which appear to be rhetoric rather than fact, but agree with you that we must "Look at all the aspects of the cost of the raises."
Thanks for the persepective
Perrie
Isn't "happiness" like beauty in the eyes of the beholder and thus impossible to empirically measure?
I am talking specifically about whether "people who want their hours cut, with the new minimum wage, so that they can stay on welfare.
I think that is between urban myth and outright b.s.
But that is only my opinion - empirical evidence might change my mind, but not anecdotal quotes.
Like I said you are relaying anecdotal rather than empirical data - he or she said that he knew someone who would rather .... etc etc
RiO ,
I am not attacking a member of the site . There is no one here by the name of John Russell ...
Thanks, Perrie. I like that "happiness level" connection. On a personal level, I definitely recall when paying bills caused enough stress that I couldn't sleep at night for worrying about it. I've always had this "ethic" about paying bills on time, all of the time. I practically lived on credit, which made the situation even more stressful. This was especially true when I lived in New York, where the cost of living was sky-high compared to almost everywhere else, and wages couldn't keep up, not even if you made twice the minimum wage at the time. I survived on overtime. It was the only way I could make ends meet. Leaving New York was the best thing I ever did... next-best was finally getting a college education. My last job was my best-paying job... but I feel acutely sympathetic to people who work their butts off only to make ends meet, with doggoned little left over for "discretionary" spending of the kind that really makes the economy flourish.
I'm retired, now, fairly comfortably, too... so my "happiness level" is rather high. At worst, it is stable, dragged down only because I genuinely feel for people caught in the downdraft of the sinking middle class. If I were Warren Buffet, I'd be spending everything I had just to try to lift people out of the morass. But, I'm not. All I can do is watch, and cringe... and be ever so grateful that I can survive without having to sacrifice a necessity just to eat.
bitemore
I am glad that "happiness level" is rather high.
I am also retired and would say that this is perhaps the most stress free time of my life, but I remember the time of two jobs and one for the wife and still trying to coach the boys, attend all the school meetings, help with homework and occasionally sneak out for dinner with my bride and those times were stressful.
Call me a cockeyed optimist, but as I move through my 7th decade I am confident that we will see a revival of the U.S. manufacturing/production base and thus a revival of the middle class (and by we I mean before I leave this earthly existence).
woodie
Your choice when you want to interject what you say are facts into a discussion you should provide a source not tell others to look it up.
Pointing out that your comment is anecdotal rather than empirical is not a put down but merely a statement of fact.
If you are so confident that I could "look them up" then you should be able to do the same thing and provide the link to the data
Until you prove it, with a source to empirical data it is merely an anecdote that you are sharing, a story .....
Oh, would I love to see that happen before I head for the reincarnation factory! Actually, the ultimate survival of our country sorta depends on exactly that happening; at some point, either through legislation or simply business "common-sense," a lot of what is being done outside our borders will have to come home if only to keep costs down, especially shipping costs, which, eventually, virtually have to rise, regardless of what kinds of fuel are available. Other countries are also undergoing an economic revolution of sorts as their workers are beginning to demand higher wages and better living conditions, so eventually a lot of stuff they export now will be kept within their own borders as their own consumers begin to buy more.
While probably not in our lifetime, I predict that the only goods and products that someday will be exported from anywhere to anywhere will be those items requiring natural resources found only in some places and not others.
Right now, we import so much stuff only because, even with shipping costs, many items are still being manufactured more cheaply somewhere else. That is bound to change; and that will not only mean that manufacturing jobs will come back to within our own borders, but our manufactured products will probably also end up being exported in greater quantities than is now the case.
However, before any of this happens, I predict that there will be some serious upheavals in our most fragile areas, with housing topping the list.
Remember in the 1980's when housing costs soared and interest on loans was in the double-digits, roughly 22%? It got to where no one could afford to buy a house. I was renting an apartment in Ossining, NY, at that time, and in the first year I lived there the building (a four-family dwelling converted into apartments from a single-family dwelling) changed owners twice. The last landlord who bought the place got royally screwed because the bottom fell out of the market so fast that he couldn't afford to keep that place plus the house he lived in. He managed to sell or rent his house and he moved into the first-floor apartment of the place I lived in (I had the top floor; there were an additional two small apartments on the middle floor; he took over the ground floor).
These days, even with low interest rates, prices have risen to where, in many places, only the wealthy can afford to buy. Home ownership is at its lowest, percentage-wise, that it has been at since the bubble of the 80's. The main difference between now and then is that interest rates are still so low that housing still gets sold, but at a much slower rate than, say, five years ago. Rents, on the other hand, in many markets, have shot up so fast that finding tenants is becoming difficult. Something has to give... but what, exactly, that may be is anybody's guess. Yesterday's small crash of the Dow Jones Industrials may be portending a more-severe crisis... Monday should provide a clue... apparently, what's happening in China has something to do with it. The Eurozone debacle isn't helping any, either.
Sigh... I don't begrudge anyone whatever wealth they have or wish to have; but at some point people need to realize that only by eagerly sharing the wealth and doing what is necessary to make the attainment of some of it a possibility, will everyone be in good enough shape to weather tiny shake-ups. Right now, the worst enemy of the 1% is... the 1%. Something has to give. Those who have nothing won't feel it too much... but what is left of the middle class and, of course, the 1%, will feel it horribly. Better that the 1% start doing the right thing while they can, before they cut off their own noses to spite their faces. We shall see... hopefully while we're still in this incarnation!
woodie
An economic topicsis based on data not anecdotes - until you can back up your input, it will remain just a story you want people to take on faith ... not gonna happen
So you can shale your fist and call people names like a child but that changes nothing - back up your story with facts or accept that it is just a story.
And again you prove the diminutiveness of your intellect and personality
What you should do is not comment on my articles since you seem unable to add anything to a serious topic except name calling
Do you have anything to say about the topic "The Cost of Increasing the Minimum Wage"?
If not, I think we are done
No actually I was interested and asked you to provide facts to back up the statements that you were presenting as facts and you declined to do so, at which point I said that your story was then merely an anecdote and your feelings were hurt and you started the name calling
I am very interested in facts that support your story and interested in discussing those facts when they are presented.
You are the only one that has lashed out and started your name calling because your feelings are hurt and you have no facts to back up your story
And hat is your problem -
And the whining continues.....all the time and effort you have spent whining and name calling you could have looked up your facts, provided a link and we could have discussed them.
Assuming of course that there are facts rather than anecdotal information behind your story.
And speaking of the last word and our whining
I agree and that s all you have done since you were asked to provide proof of what you said was a fact and could not do it.
Name calling does not make you position stronger, but rather reinforces the fact that you have nothing of value to say
I guess when you retire and spend all your time talking about all the great things we should do with someone else money, you're out of the loop, so to speak. No offense, but it is not all BS or Urban Myth Robert.
I personally know a fellow who worked for Bank of America. When the recession hit, he was laid off and got hired by Walmart. I personally didn't hear what he told me happened, but I live in the real world out here and can tell you Woodie isn't telling you a bunch of BS. My friend is a very honest person and wouldn't lie.
Let me tell you what this friend told me.
In working for Walmart, he would talk to his co-workers or the other employees as we all do when we have so many employees at a location. He went to work in their financial department and not stocking shelves.
He told me he asked this girl, who was a cashier, how long she had been with Walmart. She told him she had been with them over 5 years. He was just trying to help her see a little better future than remaining a check-out employee. He asked her had she not considered trying to get into management since she had been there for over 5 years and he told me she told him very quickly "No way, if I do that I will lose my benefits". She wasn't talking about company benefits either.
Now I'm not saying every person is like her, but to completely swipe the idea it exist off like a bug on your arm is willful blindness to the reality of the situation.
I don't know how in the hell everyone gets the idea we are going to do anything about any of this anyway, like we have any power thus far shown to have any effect in changing the income inequality.
The income inequality is becoming less between the poor and the middle income, but not those two and the 1% or the .1%. Everything always comes back to the middle income, not class, a communist term. Those are the losers, the middle income. They are the ones who are going down. The bottom income or no income are no worse off today than they have been in years, but the top 1% and higher are doing well. Actually most of them live off investment income like some of you do for the most part which is taxed at a lower level. Well, why not? They've already paid the tax on receiving it as earned income. How many times do you want to tax these people on their money?
By the way, my friend has found another job since then and is making more, but I bet since that was 5 or 6 years ago that girl, if she is still working, is still checking out groceries and other products.
After Getting $15 Minimum Wage, Seattle Employees Now Want Less Hours So They Can Stay On Welfare
Posted by Bob Amoroso / July 26, 2015
Be careful what you wish for, or in this case what you demonstrate for! Because even though you may win, you may actually lose, as proponents for the $15 minimum wage are finding out.
Astoundingly those who advocated for the increase in Seattle are now asking their employers for fewer hours so they can keep their welfare benefits.
Home nursing a nonprofit Full Life Care service told local news KIRO-TV that several workers have asked for fewerhours.
It seems the unintended consequences of those public demonstrations to give every worker a living wage in truth was simply a way of extorting a few extra dollars.
If they cut down their hours to stay on those subsidies because the $15 per hour minimum wage didnt actually help get them out of poverty, said KIRO-FM radio host Jason Rantz, all youve done is put a burden on the business and given false hope to a lot of people.
The obvious scam for many of those demonstrating was apparently never to actually get off the welfare gravy train , but rather flees those businesses into giving more money per hour, while refusing to put in more hours of work
Statistics provide more evidence. Washingtons Basic Food program enrollment fell by only 475 cases when the higher wage began in Seattle in April, despite a strong economy throughout western Washington, Fox Orlando reported.
Its what happens when the government imposes a restriction on the labor market that normally wouldnt be there, and marginal businesses get hit the hardest, and usually those are small, neighborhood businesses, said Paul Guppy, of the Washington Policy Center.
Bullshit
All you had to do is what Six did below provide a link to the point to show where it came from
But you had to take it is so because I said so position
It is you who was the ass in this situation.
Sixpick
Thanks for the link
This is still anecdotal in that it is a report of what unidentified people said, but it is documentation which is all that I asked Woodie for.
When I see people demonstrating in the streets with signs for fewer hours so that they can keep their subsidies then I will accept it even more.
The small drop in food stamps could be a coincidence - let us see if there is a dramatic decease in the average number of hours worked now that the wage has gone up
Thanks again for the linked article.
You have to be kidding me Robert? You won't be convinced until you see people protesting in the streets with signs for fewer hours so that they can keep their subsidies then you will accept it even more. At least you did say "even more".
Let me do a little experiment here then. Do you know there are people who are keeping their incomes down so they don't have to pay anything for Obamacare or do you think that is a possibility?
Now for the experiment....
If you made $36,000 a year, would you take a $5.00 per hour raise and work one more hour per day 5 days a week to increase your income to $46,000?
No you made the assertion it was up to you to provide the supporting link, the proof that is how debate works.
If you note how easily I accepted the data once Six provided it and then I made a comment on that data - we could have done that hours ago had you provided the info to back up your statement
But you would rather continue your jackassery and name calling - like a child
I see no value in what ifs and would you do it
Make your point
I do not doubt that a small number of people are doing as you suggest to keep subsidies but I have doubts that it is as common as some would like to believe
Maybe you see no point because you are blind to the facts and as I've found it to be true, there aren't any ifs or points that will make any difference in some people's beliefs.
When someone says they would have to see people protesting in the street to believe something so natural it's futile to try and explain it, although I still try in vain.
People wait until they are 65 or 66 to start receiving Social Security if they are still working in order to avoid giving up money for every dollar above a certain amount allowed. It's no different in this case. I know people who retired at 62 who still work, but will not work but so many hours so they don't get penalized. Remember that word, because that is how these people look at it.
By the way my point is the person making $36K and then working 1 more hour per day with a $5.00 raise would earn $10k more that year, but they would pay an extra $5k in Obamacare premium and pay an extra $2700 plus in Federal tax plus state tax of about $1k, so they would take home less than $2k at the end of the year realizing a net pay of $1 per hour for the extra 2064 hours worked that year.
Tell me where the motivation is in that. This is based on a 63 year old male as I figured it out where those who would realize the biggest incentive or should I say least motivation to increase his/her income. And the same male making around $20k or less doesn't pay anything at all, but if he brings his income up he starts paying. And this was before the rates started jumping several years ago. Who knows what it is today.
Anyway, I posted logical comments with proof and links. Thanks.