“Let’s Burn the Jew” is not Anti-Semitic?
Lets Burn the Jew is not Anti-Semitic?
By Christine Williams, The Gatestone Institute, January 15, 2014
The judge's ruling that it was not anti-Semitic for the fifteen-year-old to declare, "Let's burn the Jew" as he set fire to his classmate's hair is a disturbing case that reveals the talons of anti-Semitism in both the courtroom and the school system, and represents an open tolerance for again hating "the Jew."
This is not an actual photo of the incident, but it is a composite rendition of what it might be like to be a girl whose hair has been set on fire.
Anti-semitism sank to a new low in Canada after a Winnipeg judge ruled that grabbing a Jewish classmate, flicking a lighter to her hair and saying, "Let's burn the Jew," was not anti-Semitic. The incident took place between two fifteen-year-old classmates, where the defendant pleaded guilty to assault with a weapon. The lawyer for the defendant implied that it was the girl's fault that her hair caught fire -- because she pulled away. Then Manitoba Provincial Court Judge Robert Finlayson agreed with the defense that the action was one of teen impulsiveness.
The victim not only stated that the incident "changed her world upside down," but that she needed therapy to deal with her fears and felt that she was blamed by some people in the school for making too much out of the incident.
Friends of Simon Weisenthal Centre in Canada expressed horror at Finlayson's ruling. In a press release , CEO Avi Benlolo stated that he could not imagine "the same decision would have been rendered had the perpetrator targeted any other minority group in a similar way."
One need only imagine the far-reaching outcry had the word "Jew" been substituted for "gay", "black" or "Muslim," and rightly so; yet "let's burn the Jew" was dismissed as virtually child's play. Benlolo also noted a broader implication: "To ignore the racial overtones -- the perpetrator's direct reference to the Holocaust and the burning of six million Jews in the concentration camps -- is almost incomprehensible." The court's ruling conjures up the lest-we-forget-idiom in memory of the Holocaust era, where tolerance for the intolerable, bystander "blindness," media bias, propaganda and unreasonable targeting of the Jews were endemic.
A B'nai Brith statement points out: "The finding is disappointing in the sense that it muddies the waters of hate crime legislation while giving a most unfortunate license to those that hate and bully -- particularly in the school system." Now B'nai Brith Canada is calling on the Attorney General to review its guidelines in imposing enhanced sentences in hate-motivated crime cases.
This case is not an isolated occurrence when it comes to collective attitudes about anti-Semitism past and present. Historically , many members of the German public were bystanders and did nothing to condemn the Nazi racial policies against the Jews, fellow patriotic citizens who made sweeping contributions to the cultural, economic and social building of Germany . Just prior to the Holocaust, as Jews faced mounting persecution and humiliation, Nazis began introducing anti-Jewish decrees which lead to the elimination of the rights of Jewish citizens. Public indifference went beyond the borders of Germany and Europe . Today we hear little about the "Holocaust in American Life" . American historian Peter Novick points out: "the culpable, sometimes willed obliviousness of American gentiles to the murder of European Jews; the indifference to their brethren's fate by a timid and self-absorbed American Jewry." An additional horror seems to be the same "willed obliviousness" to the slaughter of Christians in Egypt, Iraq , Syria, Nigeria and the Sudan .
No, my dear, these ovens in Auschwitz were not for baking pizza.
In describing the post Holocaust decades, Novick explains that by the 1970s and beyond, the Holocaust had become a "shocking, massive, and distinctive thing," but it had been unseen by many -- even Jews-- while the Holocaust was actually being carried out. He argues that the Holocaust was largely a retrospective construction, something that would not have been recognizable to most people at the time. He points to a lack of interest precipitated by human preconceptions. For example, he states: people are "interested in the televangelist caught with the bimbo, the gangster who is devout in his religious observance: vice where we expect virtue, virtue where we expect vice; that which shatters our preconceptions."
Today, we ignore a creeping anti-Semitism that singles out Jews unfairly, and targets the state of Israel . In addressing the New Anti-Semitism , Victor Davis Hanson, Senior Fellow at the Hoover Institution, discusses how Israel is being singled out by the international community, with over 75% of recent UN resolutions targeting Israel for human rights violations, far more than for more deserving countries such as Sudan, Congo or Rwanda in which millions have been killed in genocides. In answer to the question "why is the international community so anti-Israel?", Hanson points to a "new sort of fashionable and socially acceptable anti-Semitism" that looms large.
This blame-the-Jew, blame-Israel trend is a disturbing one, all too reminiscent of the era when Nazis used propaganda campaigns to promote a lethal hatred of Jews, who were portrayed as sub-human, and interested primarily in their own economic gain. Hitler used the Jews as a scapegoat, blaming them for Germany 's economic and social problems. A major tool of the Nazis' propaganda machine was the popular weekly Nazi newspaper, Der Strmer . At the bottom of the front page of every issue was written in bold letters: "The Jews are our misfortune!" Der Strmer also regularly featured vicious caricatures of Jews.
Currently, there is a strong and consistent bias against Israel that keeps growing; it fuels anti-Semitism, especially in mainstream media outlets, where Israel is portrayed as a racist and murderous state. The BBC, according to the journalist Tom Gross , "breaking its own charter to be balanced, is already repeating lies on its website that Sharon caused the Second Intifada." BBC Radio News "eulogized Sharon by giving the floor as the sole speaker to a Palestinian man who claimed Sharon should not have been allowed to die of natural causes."
It is under-reported that Israel has taken extraordinary measures to avoid harming Palestinian noncombatants, even when Hamas not only does just the reverse, but aims to increase casualties among its own people to be able to blame Israel for those as well. One Gaza eyewitness told reporters that Hamas " wanted the [Israelis] to shoot at the [the civilians'] houses so they could accuse them of more war crimes." In highlighting media bias, the Committee for Accuracy for Middle East Reporting in America (CAMERA) conducted a six-month study of the New York Times and detailed how the newspaper indicted Israel , and even omitted context, in order to promote the Palestinian narrative. Honest Reporting is another media watchdog group that "monitors the news for bias, inaccuracy, or other breach of journalistic standards in coverage of the Arab-Israeli conflict."
Hezbollah leader Hassan Nasrallah has repeatedly made anti-Semitic remarks , yet his premises and sentiments seem to have seeped into a level of acceptance by the mainstream. As Nasrallah refers to the State of Israel as a "cancerous entity" of "ultimate evil" whose "annihilation ... is a definite matter;" and says, "if we searched the entire world for a person more cowardly, despicable, weak and feeble in psyche, mind, ideology and religion, we would not find anyone like the Jew . Notice, I do not say the Israeli."
Nasrallah continues: "If they (Jews) all gather in Israel , it will save us the trouble of going after them worldwide," and discusses Hezbollah's goals in an interview on Egyptian television:
"[T]his is an illegal state; it is a cancerous entity and the root of all the crises and wars and cannot be a factor in bringing about a true and just peace in this region. Therefore, we cannot acknowledge the existence of a state called Israel , not even far in the future, as some people have tried to suggest. Time does not cancel the legitimacy of the Palestinian claim."
As indictments of Israel and the fabrication of Palestinian history continue, this new anti-Semitism intensifies, and the propaganda mill creates a further warping. This new anti-Semitism now can be found as well in a growing trend among evangelical Christians, once overwhelmingly sympathetic to Israel . Peter Wehner, a senior fellow at the Ethics and Public Policy Center , and who has worked in the administrations of Ronald Reagan, George H.W. Bush, and George W. Bush, explains this pro-Palestinian trend in his article, " Israel and Evangelical Christians ". He calls it a "movement," and states that it rests in part on the uninformed and unexamined view that Israel 's founding was illegitimate and immoral, and that Israel has become an enemy of justice and peace. In this line of thinking, no matter how erroneous, it follows that "authentic Christianity therefore requires one to embrace the pro-Palestinian narrative on the basis of their faith."
* * *
The Manitoba judge's ruling that it was not anti-Semitic for the fifteen-year-old to declare "let's burn the Jew" as he set fire to his classmate's hair is a disturbing case that reveals the talons of anti-Semitism in both the courtroom and in the school system, and represents an open tolerance for again hating "the Jew." This anti-Semitism -- further fanned and fueled by propaganda -- requires a prompt commitment by Western leaders of every country to use "all its might against anti-Semitism in all its forms," as stated by France 's President Franois Hollande. It is also time for Canadians to invoke the Ottawa Protocol on Combating Antisemitism , signed in November 2010 by then-Citizenship, Immigration and Multiculturalism Minister Jason Kenney and Foreign Affairs Minister John Baird. Parliamentarians and experts from 50 countries on six continents had assembled for a Conference on Combating Anti-Semitism in Ottawa where the Ottawa Protocol was released. In it was the groundbreaking alarm against state-sanctioned anti-Semitism and the resurgence of anti-Jewish libels. We hope to have learned, from the bitter lessons of the Holocaust, the detriments of remaining "oblivious bystanders."
Tags
Who is online
80 visitors

It is getting worse. Where will this end up?
"You're not like me".
A fifteen year old said and did something thoughtless and stupid? Shocking, but not without significant precedent. Sincere anti-Semitism? Hardly, IMO. Kids don't always think about how depraved their actions can beconsidered to beby others. I remember in ahigh school science class, the morning that the space shuttle Challenger blew up with a teacher on board, and the news was solemnly played on the tvduring class. Our teacher had tears in his eyes, and exploded on the class clown who thought it would be funny to mock the tragedy.
It was a boy who grabbed a girl an did this, Mike, so what we have is a two fold crime.
A male bully who is well on his way to being a wife abuser, since he thinks it's okay to over power a female and force her into submission for abuse, and the further non-crime according to this judge of burning a Jew.
While I am concerned about the hate and bigotry instilled in this young man, his confidence that the school is lax enough in its bullying policies that he could get away with it, the cowardice of his fellow classmates to stand there while it happened...
I am most alarmed that the man purporting to stand for justice and law occupying the bench in Canada did not see this as a hate crime.
Anti-Semitism is growing at an alarming rate.
She probably learned it from the Occupy Wall Street movement.
I think the anti Jewish movement is also a big part of the even bigger anti Christian movement being caused by right wing Politicians and extremest who also as well as Hate women, Religious control of our government and attempts at controlling foreign governments.. If being set on fire because your Jewish is not anti semitism and burning Christians at the stake must be equally tolerable.
Funny where idiots draw te line.
But the movement is understandable as al Religions are in a cituation where they feel they must fight back to continue to exist. Jesus was a Jew and the hatred of Jesus doesn't take a stretch as the Christians have done many of the recent attrocities. US invasion of Iraq, basically a take over in Afghanistan. The scriptures are designed to utilize extreme action flood the World. Parting of the seas to set a trap to kill hundreds of thousands how many unknown.
When the Legal System this Judge is a part of is that far out of kilter with common decency it reeks of a Religious hate act by the boy and the Judge.
If the statement of "Let the Jew burn." was witnessed and is accurate, then it was both. The guilty party should be punished first as perpetrating a vicious act against another human being, then secondly under laws involving anti-Semitic activity.
If he said, "Burn the Muslim" you can bet your ass it would have been called a hate crime. If the victim had been black and he had said, "Burn the nigger" it would have been a hate crime. If the victim had been Hispanic and he had said, "Burn the spic" it would have been a hate crime.
As it was a Jew, it was only a youthful, thoughtless and stupid prank. Now I get it.
I guarantee you that stupid kids have said "burn the nigger" and "burn the Muslim" on countless occasions throughout the US, many times just goofing off with their black and Muslim friends who understand that it was just tasteless humor,who thenrespond back with more tasteless retorts. That's kids these days, not all of them but certainly some of them.
I think many kidsare too innocent and accepting of their peers tocomprehend the hatred of their ancestors. They are increasingly accepting and even welcoming of their school mates of different ethnicities and/or sexualities, which in and of itself is a good thing. I'm not condoningcomments that have derogatory undertones - I'm just pointing out that we don'twalk in their shoes, and I can understand how some of them don't grasp the gravity of such words. As far asflicking the lighter goes, I'm thinking that wasa foolish part of the tasteless joke that went way wrong.
We have a daughter in high school, andshe has friends of everyethnicity, and when they get together at our house I am reminded of just how different it is to be a kid today than when I was a kid. They constantly joke about their ethnicities, and routinely joke around using comebacks like "it's cuz I'm black right?". I didn't quite know what to say one day when we were playing cards with a group of them, and one was talking about her current boyfriend ... and comparing him to her ex-girlfriend. The other kids didn't even blink an eye to this. Times have changed, and they are definitely getting better as a whole. This sounds to me like an instance of juvenilitybeing wrongly interpreted.
This girl was NOT one of his friends.
I understand what you are saying about the kids. My grandsons have friends of various ethnicities as well and they do the same; this was not the case.
I can't tell what their relationship was, based on the information in this article. It seems like the girl may have just been indifferent to the guy, until his stupid attention seeking joke went awry. I struggle to envision a teenager today actually doing this out of sheer malice to someone because of their ethnicity, religion or sexuality. That kind of kid would have probably been booted from school before anything like that could have happened. My feeling is that it is the adults of this scenario that are forcing it into the frame of a hate crime.
We had an attention seeker come to a Halloween party our daughter threw at our house. He had invited himself, we learned after he was gone. He emptied half the left over Halloween candy that we were passing out to trick or treatersinto a bag for himself, thinking he was being cute. Later, I walked into the room he was showing off in, to find him standing on top of our glass top coffee table. We locked eyes, and the "you better get the fuck off my furniture and never, ever do something that stupid and rude again" look in my eye caused him to step down and start behaving himself. In retrospect, I could see him flicking a lighter in some poor Jewish girl's hair while hurling a thoughtlessly playful insult at her. The other kids were happy when he finally left.
It's no secret that I am seriously pro-Israel and pro-Jew, and my first reactions to this story were deep anger at the boy and at the ruling. I still stand by my comment that had the girl been Muslim, black, Hispanic it would have turned out quite different.
But I have just read this paragraph of yours:
Without being given any more information about how the boy spoke and acted prior to this incident, whether he tried to act as a class clown or not, I am willing to give you points on your comment. You have made your case. He should spend a lot of time apologizing to the girl and trying to convince her, however.
If it comes out he has a history of racist comments, I will go back to my original judgment.
@Robert G: I found this using google:
Intentionally lighting fire to a person's hair is obviously not sufficient to invoke REAL punishment, just a slap on the wrist. As I'm sure Kavika can tell you, Winnipeg, and Manitoba in general, is not exactly a utopia for equal treatment or consideration of the rights of minorities.
The very fact that he flicked and lit a lighter and said "Let's burn the Jew", even discounting the fact that her hair caught fire, would have been enough when I was young to earn him a beating he would never forget - never mind the "innocent childhood remarks" bullshit. The fact that he even made that statement means to me that he was simply emulating what he had learned, probably from his parents.
From the Winnipeg Free Press, January 15, 2014
This is the kind of thing that has already been proven to lead to suicide among young girls.
I'm sorry, Hal, I can't whitewash the incident as easily as you can.
I think the parents of the juvenile boy carry the responsibility for his actions. They should have suffered a damn good monetary penalty (or incarceration if they failed to pay the fine as a penalty for that failure). That will give the parents some incentive to teach their little bully some proper manners. When I think about what the girl is now suffering due to the attack she is undergoing on Facebook I think it's time the Human Rights Commission got involved, since the judge did not treat the incident with the seriousness that was deserved.
At the very least the Judge should have required the boy to undergo education about The Holocaust to see what he has mocked.
Would you feel the same way if they did this to a black kid and said "Let's lynch the blacks"?
Or would you feel the same way if they grabbed a teenage Indian girl and said "Let's rape this little Indian"? What effect do you think that will have on the innocent girl?
IMO the war in Iraq was not a "Christian thing". It was done because we (i.e. our gov't at the time) wanted their oil. If Iraq was a Christian country and was not cooperating with the US. re their oil, I think Bush still would've attacked.
Without a doubt. This was part of the Perle/Wolfowitz/Abrams/Bolton "Project for the New American Century". Iraq and Iran were clearly in the cross-hairs of PNAC when came into being in 1998.
No, I wouldn't Buzz. Having a really hard time with this.
I'm not trying to whitewash anything. I'm just pointing out that the likelihood that this kid is truly an anti-Semite of such extreme as to purposefully announce and light a Jewish girl's hair on fire in plain view of his peers is unrealistic. I agree, he did something awful, and he should be punished - but it seems more realistic that he should be being punished for saying and doing something unfathomably ignorant, than for executing a premeditated hate crime.
I highly doubt this kid would ever do something so stupid again, but a true anti-Semite would likely continue through a life of bigotry unfazed. I'll change my assessment when I hear that he continues to spout off discriminatory statements towards the Jewish community.