Hating the American Indian, A Time Honored Tradition
From the Examiner.
It's always there. It hides well and often appears to be a bygone product of history but make no mistake, it's presence is as much a fact as the sunrise in the east. It only takes a whisper, one event or a single issue to peel back the camouflage of serenity and reveal it in all its glory. It's apparently a permanent part of the American psyche despite all thoughts to the contrary. Don't look now, because it is once again on the loose and running wild all over the continent. What is "it" you ask? Why it's anti-Indian sentiment, the lesser known brother of racism that most Americans would rather not discuss but the First Nations of this country know intimately.
http://www.examiner.com/article/hating-the-american-indian-a-time-honored-tradition
Tags
Who is online
78 visitors

You will be attacked based on the source of the article, but I seriously doubt many, other than those who regularly do, will comment on this because it does cause them discomfort. "Get over it" is a very true mindset to many in the U.S. because they can't/won't face the truth.
Actually Robert, I should have elaborated a bit. It is based on lack of knowledge. Not having that knowledge puts you in a dangerous place in a discussion because you have no foundation to draw from. Seriously, there is less about Indian history taught in schools as there is regarding Blacks, Hispanics and Asians - that is a fact. Question is why is there less? Can you answer that one?
Even better - explain, if you can, why this sets "you back a few rungs"??
Guess you're right
what's the problem with the source? is the content assessed by its package? does it make it less of a truth?
The important thing is what is being sad and no one can say what's said in this article is not true. The history of this country, on itself, endorses it
Four months ago I went to a new eye doctor for an exam and new contacts. My friend, Bobbie, wanted me to try her doctor who she was so mad about. He was handsome, he was caring, he took all the time in the world to satisfy your vision requirements, and the entire staff was friendly and helpful.
The initial contact was great; everyone was friendly at the front desk, and I began filling out the required paperwork. I passed the paperwork back to the bookkeeper who noticed I had somehow failed to check my "race." For the first time instead of "white" I wrote "NA" in the "Other" spot.
She looked at my braided hair, my jeans, my knee boots, my vest, and I could see the withdrawal in her eyes, the change in her attitude. "You're Indian?" she asked. I smiled and said, "Yes, but I haven't scalped anyone in ages."
The rest of the people in the room laughed. She drew back as though I held a tomahawk in my hand. I've decided to keep using that doctor. He was great.
Yes, palma, it is indeed a time honored tradition to hate Indians.
I have also noticed however that in the Deep South there are many pockets where people have begun to express great interest in Indians and the history and traditions of the First People. They are seeking knowledge of agriculture and Indian medicine, and many people who work with horses are seeking knowledge of the American Indian way of creating a bond with them.
When my town has its Heritage Day festival, there are a group of Choctaw who dance, and the children are in awe of them. If only they could retain that special feeling...
Robert, as for history endorsing, you quite right. When you have experienced it, that it is true history, and I am endorsing it.
You, on the other hand do not have the experience, so yourcomment hold's no water.
And, of course, you haven't answered my two questions either Robert.
And, yes it is a "historical fact". Re-read the article and you'll see how often that is said.
I'd truly like to have you explain # 3 to me John. There are many on NT who are over the age of 50 and they have experienced the prejudice/racism for over 50 years. Based on that alone, how can you say/question whether or not it exists?
They will mimi, they will. I have a feeling more people will come seeking your knowledge and experience and even the way of life. I truly hope this remains the truth.
I have seen people around me change their attitude and show more interest just by talking to them and presenting facts.
How painful must it be for someone to hide his/her heritage and ancestry
As recently as last year when I visited my family on the reservation in AZ when I went to a bar to have a beer I was spotted and told in very plain English, and I quote "You know where the back door is if you want to buy something", when I refused the police were called and even they said he had the right to refuse service to me. So I left having made both my point and not making a purchase. The thing that makes this so funny is I am a halfbreed and I look white, the man at the bar knows my family and my heritage and has always treated us this way. That is a history I have lived with for 67 years and will probably die with. Change is very slow even today.
palma, for clarification, almost everything I have learned about my heritage has been on Kavika's site and with the help of the Anishinaabe brothers and sisters, and from research I have done.
It was only recently that my family has admitted what I have always known but was not allowed to acknowledge... that we were Indian.
My mother's father was Choctaw, her mother Cherokee. My father's mother was Lakota Sioux, his father Scots/Irish. My Choctaw grandfather and Cherokee grandmother claimed on their death beds they were "Black Dutch." Their parents hid from the Removal, and were taken in by Dutch settlers who claimed they were relatives who had just arrived from Holland and couldn't speak English, when the soldiers came around.
I am not registered with any Tribe and have never visited a reservation, although all our family vacations, my Dad took us to the Cherokee reservation area of the Great Smoky Mountains. My mother would never go. We stayed in the tourist areas, and my first kiss at age 11 was a most beautiful Cherokee boy... I wanted to run away with him.
There are thousands of us... "breeds"... who know we are Indians but have no Tribe, no registration, no Nation, no Chief... we are proud of our ancestors and heritage, but we hunger for the link denied us, the legends, the culture of our history. My elusive dream is to sit at the feet of an Elder and listen. Just listen.
Some of us have siblings who have never felt the call of the blood. My younger sister and I did, even as toddlers. My older sister is only now, at the age of 65, expressing an interest. Much has been lost and scattered of the soul of the Indian. It not only resides in the pure blood, but in those like me, and some of the soul of the Indian resides in those such as Enoch, Grump, Mrs D, and others who feel all the way to the blood and bone the atrocities experienced by the First People.
I didn't intend to ramble on. Just didn't want to mislead you as to my "credentials."
Oh mimi, it was beautiful and I can't even begin to imagine how hard it must've been. I truly believe things will change and people will come around. They may tip-toe but as long as they tip-toe forward the destination will arrive at some time. A lot has changed.
I'm not Indian but this has been my dream for a long long time too
In Arizona? on the reservation?
I should have been more specific, the bar was in town not on the Reservation. This wouldn't have happened on the reservation believe me.
You forgot the Muslims, 1st. Myfriend's grandson says they are studying the history and culture of Muslims so that there will be greater understanding and tolerance instead of so much misplaced fear and misunderstanding.
My question to her was how can you study the history and culture of Muslims without studying Islam, which is a religion. She is looking into exactly what he is studying, as she found him and a friend pretending to pray to Allah. He is in fifth grade.
palma, have you ever seen a moviecalled "Billy Jack?"
It's quite violent and I've never watched it but once, but some say in spite of its lack of cinematic worthiness, it sets forth a valid representation of how life was around the reservations at the time the movie was made. It was released in 1971, and re-released in 1973.
The title song for it was "One Tin Soldier Rides Away."
When I saw that movie, I couldn't believe things like that could happen in America, the land of Law and Order. It just couldn't. I grew up in Huntsville, AL, and at the time, it was a small town. Many things happened in my teens around the country that we were isolated from because, well, if it didn't directly affectour town, we didn't need to know about it.
I could tell you all about rockets, the space program, NASA, anything about space exploration and our race with the Russians, but I knew nothing about the kind of things that movie was about, and our newspapers didn't print it.
Growing up was ugly and painful, and the learning hasn't stopped.
Had been back from 'Nam for awhile when I saw Billy Jack. Made a helluva impression on me.
''One Tin Soldier'' is one great song. I didn't care much for the movie, I've only seen it about 20 times...
Gotcha, Guess I read it wrong.
Thanks John.
Sorry to hear that you had to put up with that shit Larry. But it happens to all of us, one way or the other.
I see two causes for the problem:
1. Xenophobia (ignorance leads to fear, fear leads to hatred)
2. Inherited guilt (The picture shows the slaughter of Indians by Christopher Columbus, as an example.)
Dear Friend Buzz of the Orient: I concur with your analysis.
Ignorance indeed leads to fear. Fear does beget hatred.
There is a mechanism of defense when there is guilt. If one can demonize those unfairly treated, then they do not need to address the discomfort of admitting something was wrong. Even if they didn't do it, they may not have done anything to stop it.
Even if it happened when they were not their, if they have done nothing to address it, it is still an uncomfortablefeeling. There is a saying inNichirinBuddhism. "The finger points with ease in any direction. Only with great difficulty can it point to itself". Indeed!
I was brought in after a fair hearing of discrimination by the State Education Department when an Honorable State Administrative Law Judge found that State services had unlawfully been denied to a member of the Mohawk Nation. The reason the State brought me in is that I have a track record ofpromptly turning around self employment cases for adults with profound disabilities cases of many different types of minority citizens whoare unlawfully deniedequal treatment regarding State and Federal programs.
This case had been tied up in bureaucratic activity for years. Within72 hours of our meeting, the petitioner, a proud member of the Mohawk Nation was satisfied with the solution I proposed to resolve the issue. In less than two weeks he got the help he needed, andto which he was entitled under the Americans with Disabilities Act as Amended.
From that point forward, the Mohawk, Tuscarora, Cayuga, Seneca and Onondaga Nations wanted me to handle their cases exclusively. That is contrary to State and Federal law.
Exclusive contracts can result in back scratching arrangements. As trustees of the public funds, governments are supposed to rely on competitive bidding, and place limits on "in class" contract awards (except in cases of affirmative action and other programs to address past grievances).
I was asked by the State Public Service WorkshopPrograms, run by the State University System to "Train the Trainers" on how to resolve finding at State and Federal Petitions at Fair Hearings and Office of Hearings and Appeals cases.
One of the things that came back to me when I conducted six and nine month PIR's (Post Implementation Reviews) is that allsides felt a lot more comfortable around each other when they realized how much they had in common.
A good and often fruitful way to defang the worst in all of us is to find ways to create win-win situations where people of different backgrounds work together as equals to achieve common goals for mutual benefit.
Respect leads to understanding. Understanding to harmony. Harmony to progress.
Peace, Abundant Blessings and Progress Together for Us All.
Enoch.
It's curious that two major studios got involved with making the movie and pulled out. There were reports that they were uncomfortable with content and subject material, and the explicit violence. In the end, it reached the screen because Tom Maclaughlin financed it himself.
Funny how a film about the treatment of Indians caused concern about the content and violence depicted, but a previous film starring the actor that involved bikers, and showing extreme violence, rape and things of that nature didn't bother anyone at all.
Only 20 times, Kavika? Better watch it again, might catch something you missed.....
I agree with you, Gunny. I think of the song every time I read a story about the ongoing wars around the globe.
The application of this theory works so well in inter-relationships of Palestinians and Israelis. It is a shame it is discouraged by the Palestinians as "normalization".
I could only watch it one time, 1stwarrior.
I was so tense throughout the entire movie that when I tried to sleep that night my arms and legs jerked and twitched because when I drifted into sleep my muscles were relaxing and would spasm.
I had been so involved in the movie I hadsat through the entire film with my muscles tightly clenched in anger and fear for the characters.
At the end, when the people stood along the road as the patrol car drove him away and the theme song played, I was sobbing so badly my chest was hurting. I couldn't watch it again, and still choke up when I hear the song. It is the perfect embodiment of what happened to the First People when Europeans came... they offered to share, and instead were slaughtered out of greed. "One Tin Soldier" tells it all.
Great point.
What a coincidence Buzz. Just saw this on FB this morning
Amen Enoch. If only people would listen. Unfortunately, in mny cases, ego and pride get in the way
That is perfect Palma.
Found it on Netflix. Is it the one with Tom Laughling? Is this the one?
sorry to hear mimi and as I said before I can't even begin to imagine how painful must've been.. Worst part is that it is still alive even though people blindly deny it
That's what I thought. Thanks.
And this is the 21st century, right?
And some people have the nerve to deny it exists
I can't open the picture or video, palma. What is it? Besides, I'm no good at acronyms - what is FB?
What I mean by "inherited guilt" is, for a hypothetical, that the grandchild of Dr. Mengele could possibly feel guilty for what his/her grandfather did. I didn't say it existed, I said it COULD exist as a possibility. The fact that you disagree with me means absolutely nothing to me but for the sake of others I responded to your question. Go ahead - scoff away.
Robert always reads into comments what he wants. Nothing new about that. Of course ''I spit'' on his assessment ofyour comment Buzz.
And you still haven't answered these two questions Robert -
" Not having that knowledge puts you in a dangerous place in a discussion because you have no foundation to draw from. Seriously, there is less about Indian history taught in schools as there is regarding Blacks, Hispanics and Asians - that is a fact. Question is why is there less ? Can you answer that one?
Even better - explain, if you can, why this sets "you back a few rungs"?? "
Yes, palma, that's the one. I misspelled his name, sorry. If you have the time and can stomach it, watch the movie and let us know what you think. If you like, you can post it on Anishinaabe.
Buzz, FB is Facebook.
Don't tell me about the freaking Trayvon Martins and how I should have inherited guilt for his anger about being followed that caused him to turn around and walk to his death instead of walking forward into the safety of his home. I don't feel guilty about a damn thing that happened to blacks during the slave days... I wasn't there and neither were my ancestors who were busy either hiding and running for their lives from the soldiers, being forced along the Trail of Tears, being butchered in the Black Hills, or working as white slaves called "bondsmen/bondswomen" with no hope of paying back the overlords who paid their passage from Ireland and Scotland to the New World and even forced their children into bonded slavery to pay these passages.
I am only accountable for my own prejudices, here and now, in this time and place. There are blacks and Hispanics in my family, and in my close friendships. I love and honor them. It doesn't mean I have to automatically embrace every lame and prejudiced "you-owe-me" thought and word uttered by the jackasses who push the African American and Hispanicagenda.
And I will say this... there is a time and place for everything. The first and most egregiously injured and with a legally binding claim should have been the first honored and CLEARED by this government, and that is the American Indian.
The African American and now the Hispanic illegals never stop, they never shut up, they never find an end to the "you-owe-me-white-man" rhetoric.
You don't have to have inherited guilt about the Indian, but at the least Americans should have a sense of justice to the law and order we claim to hold so dear. Not one single treaty has been fully honored. Not one. And if I were an attorney I would spend my life and every dime I possessed filing everything I could throw at the justice system to try and prevent them from allocating any funds to any group until they CLEARED the standing treaties signed by this freaking government with the Nations.
Can't sue the US government? Bullshit! It's being done all the time. I'd die trying to find a way around that bovine feces. Every time a black or Hispanic entity received funds I'd file a motion of some kind to attach the money on the grounds it was stolen from Indians. I don't care how frivolous it was.
If a bullshit black pimp can file a $100million lawsuit against Nike for not placing a warning label on its shoes saying they were dangerous weapons because he was given a 100 year sentence for stomping a man's face in with a "dangerous weapon"... anything can be done.
Just call me "The Enraged Dingo."
I'll watch it tonight, will tell you tomorrow.
I guess by now nothing surprises me anymore. Granted the movie is from the 70s but as we so often see not much has changed since then. Unfortunately
no, she didn't
you got to be kidding me.
Are you looking at yourself in the mirror? comes to mind
Now THAT I would like to have proof on (considering that the author of this article is a bigot, believing and pushing the idea of collective, ancestral, racial guilt and shame.) You actually, personally, know Lawrence Sampson???
But, of course, you don't.
Still waiting on that "proof" thing Robert. All I'm seeing from you is "cut'n'paste" with cute comments.
Showus some "proof" that Lawrence is a BIGOT !!!!!
Believe me - just because y ou say it doesn't make it so.
The argument of "ancestral guilt" has been the driving mantra of the black, and now the Hispanic propaganda machines. They have beat the American public over the head with it until we became immune to it, then we became sick of it, now we are enraged by it.
The situation with Indians is quite different. Every person in this country can tell you the history of slavery but the truth about the genocide of Indians, the boarding schools, how far into the 20th century it lasted, the continuing bigotry and racism, the sterilization of the women, the continuing rapes on reservations that go unpunished... all of this and more.... is unknown by the majority of the people of the United States.
Americans know next to nothing about the history or the current status of Indians. We're not talking inherited guilt here, we're talking teaching history to bring in line the problems encountered on a daily basis today. The only inherited guilt for what happened to Indians falls on the government of the United States of America because it has done nothing to redress the wrongs and continues to perpetrate them.
If you are a member of Congress or the Supreme Court and you find yourself facing a decision concerning Indians, and the Tribal Council or Representative and its attorney has clearly laid before you in the form of a signed Treaty that has not been honored.... or a Treaty that is being violated because a corporation wants the mineral or timber rights of the Tribal land.... and you say, "Screw it, that was over a hundred years ago, I'm not gonna read through all that crap," then you have both inherited guilt because you refused to right the wrong of your office and your own guilt because you are self serving sleezy bastard who should be hung by his balls over an open flame.
Just my personal opinion.
Explain how he "proves himself" to be a bigot/racist.
When did you put a tie on your avatar??
The U. S. government has shown that it has no reason to live up to the contracts/treaties they make. That's a historical fact. Who's at fault? The politicians and lobbiests - and, ultimately, we, the people for continuing to re-elect the same people over and over and over 'cause "it feels comfortable".
Should you have an interest in inherent guilt? Not necessarily. Should you have an interest in following the law, even if it's Common Law? You betchur boots. If you do me wrong "legally", I will let you know by the means available - courts.
You'll find that the vast majority of U. S. citizens are getting sick and tired of the Black/Hispanic/Latino "you owe me" routine because there is no legal driver for their demands - it's just "I WANT" - that's how they were taught.
The Indians, on the other hand, have plenty of legal drivers and that is what is emphasizing the "hate" for the Indians. Why??? Because the U. S. truly OWES the Indian and refuses to pay/live up to their legal agreements.
No, for the Indian to want what is legally due them is not racist/bigoted - it is based on political/judicial decisions that HAVE NOT been lived up to. You try the same thing with a bank, credit union, auto store, hardware store, grocery store, etc and then tell me/all of us just how racist/bigoted the bank, credit union, auto store, etc. is for not giving you what you want because YOU DIDN'T PAY FOR IT. Racist??? Bigoted???
And they screwed usafter WWI, until present BF. If you would like a list of those ''screws'' I'll provide them for you.
BF, I'm not saying that your family was involved. The point is, that many like to use the ''it's in the past'' refrain, which is pure bullshit.
I've read all the comments on this thread Robert and, of all the comments made, you have yet to address any of the points brought up in the article other than stating that the author (Lawrence Sampson) is a bigot/racist - and don't explain why you're making a blanket statement without know the author. You have, by not explaining, proven that you have no knowledge with which to discuss your points - you just spray words out hoping they defuse the discussion.
That is not a "historical endorsement" of -"You will be attacked based on the source of the article" because youhave proven my point by not discussing the article but, instead, attempting to debase the author.
Thanks.
What you just said, 1stwarrior.
It just sounds so much more sensible when it comes from you.
Quoting definitions from a dictionary/Pictionary doesn't show how the author has "proven" that he is racist/bigoted. Reach into the article, pull out a statement made by the author and then use "your" rationale to explain how that is racist/bigoted.
The author is using the "everyday" usage of language to make his case. Whether that language is specifically his (which he says is not) or someone else's, the "everyday" language used by many, as explained in his article, still implies a "hate" towards Indians.
He, personally, in the article, does not state a person - but, he does, quite profusely, state a generality of groups of people. Don't think that can be counted as racist/bigoted, 'specially when he describes their specific actions.
There's the freaking damn problem right there. Property claims. That's all the rest of the country wants to talk about when it comes to the Indian... property, land claims.
AND IT PISSES THEM OFF AND THEY SHUT DOWN!
Most Americans think Indians are living in cute little tipis or trailers or log homes on FUCKING FREE LAND they don't have to pay for, with FREE FUCKING ELECTRICITY and they DON'T HAVE TO PAY FUCKING TAXES!
Do you think the average American struggling to pay the mortgage and bills for his own home CARES about FREE property and land rights for ANYONE ELSE?
We have to stop centering the Indian history and education of the past on land and property rights; it's about the genocide and ongoing poverty and lack of resources for education, medical access, sanitation.
Americans know aboutblack families being separated on the slave blocks as they were sold, but they know NOTHING about Indian children being ripped from their families by the government and forced into so called boarding schools where they were horribly abused, raped, beaten, forbidden to speak their own language, never allowed to see their parents, denied the ability to practice their spiritual culture...they know nothing of Indian babieshaving their heads smashed by soldiers against trees, pregnant women being gutted by bayonets.
It isn'ttaught in history classes, it isn't spoken of... everybody wants to know why the Indian can't just "get over it" since it's all about the land, and well, doncha know, it's just so silly, because, well, any stupid idiot knows they ain't gonna get the land back and they already get everything for free already, geeeez!!!
How about that Native American Heritage Month, did you hear even one radio station dedicate one day to accomplishments by Native Americans? Did you see even one TV broadcast station dedicate a month or even a week of 60 second spots to honor Native Americans or even mention a Native American? Wasthere a two hour special on the life of ANY memorable Native American from ANY Tribe?
Now let's compare Black History Month and Hispanic National Appreciation Month...
It's not all about the land. Blacks and Hispanics have no affinity whatsoever to any particular area of land in the US; they are spread all over the entire country and if one of them sneezes it's a major tragedy for the government, the media, the liberal organizations.
Indians can be raped, assaulted on the highways, children stolen and given to adoption agencies, carved up in hospital beds, denied essential social services available to other minorities, ridiculed by a major TV broadcast station in a sitcom that refuses to apologize, told by the government that a Hispanic likeness in a monument represents Indians in the military, and somehow no matter what we say it's only because we're pissed about property claims... you know, cause we want to live on land for free while all the hard working real Americans have to pay for theirs.... that's all Indians really care about.
Your quotes, FROM THE ARTICLE - " So whether you live in Washington D.C. and root for that abomination of a football team mascot, or in Riverton Wyoming and have found you're subject to aboriginal title, or anywhere else on this continent once populated by millions of Indigenous people, it's time to ask yourself a question. How do you really feel about the Native American and why? Are you personally willing to take responsibility for historical wrongs, as a beneficiary of genocidal policies ?"
Don't see anything in that section that states he is racist/bigoted.
Another quote - " Are you personally willing to take responsibility for historical wrongs, as a beneficiary of genocidal policies ?"
Hmmm - looks like a duplicate - still nothing said about being a racist/bigot.
" Every American lives their daily live knowing deep down they are the recipient of benefits born of genocide. " - nope - don't see it unless he is a non-American and is bigoted against Americans.
" And along the way, the American redneck or racist or social conservative, choose your own superlative, goes down slowly, always kicking and screaming about the good old days," Ahhhhh - as usual, taken out of context. You did read the three references to the recent Court Cases where the "locals" lost their butts to the Indian tribes and the "locals" cried - "That's not fair - Indians aren't supposed to win in court." as they tried to file their appeals and the courts said - nope - you lost , not appealable. Is that the one where he is being racist or bigoted because he described what the redneck or racist of social conservative did upon losing to the "minority"???? Stay in context next time Robert.
"Are you personally willing to take responsibility for historical wrongs, as a beneficiary of genocidal policies? " Already discussed - ad nauseum.
Well, those are all your quotes FROM THE ARTICLE and none of your discussion regarding the quotes offers proof that the author is racist/bigoted - which was my question and, which was not answered.
I think I'm descended from the Russian Princess Anastasia, but if I say that publicly the Bolsheviks are going to come and get me.
Ah, no wonder I didn't know. Facebook is banned in China, as is YouTube.
But you didn't tell me what the picture of video showed.
BF, ''Government shouldn't give special rights to people based on race or ethnicity, that defines racism.''
Interesting statement. Isn't that what the US government has done for the past 500 years. Of course it was in favor of dominant society.
Also, the ''special rights'', I'll haveto takeexception to. The so called special rights, are not special rights at all. All of these rights are spelled out in treaties between the US government and Indian tribes. Which the US government has broken or violated each and every one, that they agreed to.
In your state of Texas, the federal courts found that the government, both state and federal owed a tribe there 240 million dollars for stealing and misappropriating monies of the tribe. That was in 2006, and 8 years later not one penny has been paid to the tribe. You see it's pretty easy to be pissed off.
A reading of the ''Declaration of Independence'' will tell you, quite clearly the view of American Indians by the people and our ''Founding Fathers''.
So you see BF, we are asking for nothing that isn't due us by the what is called the supreme law of the land, treaties.
That my friend, is the crux of the matter.
As for the racism portion of it. It exists, always has and probably always will. If you face racism from the time your born, throughout your life, your life experience is very different than that of those that never have faced being hated for your skin color, or whatever racist hate.
What the author of the article said or proposed, is simply asking, or in his opinion possiblya truthism. I am not one to believe in ''sins of the father''. What I am abeliever in, is that if wrongs are being committed, and the person is aware of them. To ignore them, or say they don't exist is in itself a form of racism.
(Sigh)
In spite of my lengthy, bizarre rant you missed the entire point of it.
Which was, you appear to believe, along with most of the rest of America, that the only thing Indians have to complain about are "property claims."
Nothing else is ever mentioned. And my point was that as long as the land claims are all that Americans are willing to acknowledge about the injustices done to Indians, there will never be any support for the Indian people.... because there is a funny little urban legend that all Indians have their own FREE plot of land and live for FREE off the federal government and get FREE checks and pay NO TAXES so they don't need any more land.
The smoke screen that all Indian grievances are totally related to land obscures everything else.
Kavika, Gunny, thank you for your support.
Excellent comment, Kavika.
"some of us are just born wrong." - agree with you on that one.
And, not to mention, those "special rights" are based on the political status of the tribes, not the racial status, as SCOTUS so vividly points out in a number of cases. Political as in Sovereign Nation and inherent authority based on aboriginal title and the U. S. Constitution.
watched the movie last night mimi.
That movie is so much the 70s. Brought back memories, happy ones I have to say as I didn;t have to endure what so many here had to and it is sad to watch it. I think the movie just scratches the surface of it. What always gets me is the fact, and a true one at that, that cowards never act alone, they are only "brave" when in a pack.
The song is awesome and it really touches you especially at the end of the movie. Thanks for the indication mimi
Buzz, it is the screen of a text message conversation where one person tells the other he/she is watching a movie about the first American serial killer and the other answers with a question "Christopher Columbus"?
and this is what brought me to this group. One day at the office we were talking about several issues and the topic of "entitlement' came up (many here at the office are avid watchers of FoxNews, sigh). Out of nowhere one of my colleagues sprouted "look at the Indians, they get everything for free, house, food, utilities, don't pay taxes, etc, etc). I told her I could not debate her as I was not aware of the facts but that sounded so not possibly true. I started looking for answers; the internet can be your friend or your enemy and I came across so many different and opposing information Iended up being more confused. I started looking for someone to help me out and this is how I found Kavika on Newsvine and he then told me about this group and this is how I joined.
And you are right mimi, I was not aware of many, many things. Never believed the crap about Indians have everything but I knew about broken treaties. Didn't know about the TRail of Tears, didn't know aboutboarding schools, didn't know about the levels of poverty on reservations, and my list could go on and on and on. I am still learning and I am pretty sure there's a lot more to learn. But one thing that has touched me deeply was a statement from, I believe, Russel Meansin a documentary in which he said "all we want is to be seen as human beings". So much of what you said goes into that sentence
If we could get just 1/4 of the population to read "Custer Died For Your Sins" and/or "God is Red", both by Vine Deloria, that incorrect information would be dispelled immediately. Vine discusses and explains so vividly the many misunderstandings the vast majority of the population has regarding Indians.
Let's make it a trifecta 1st. Add to those two, Vine Deloria, ''Red Earth, White Lies''.
added them to my list
you don't see things like this published in regular media, it is always "hidden"
Read more atso what is your solution BF? I think this is the key question. A lot has been tried and not has changed much in hundreds of years. The one way is through education but this is being omitted from many schools and even from mainstream media as mimi mentioned.
BF - I can't tell you how to live your life as a white person (assuming that you are white) because I haven't lived the white life. I've encountered it, worked in it/with it, but haven't lived it.
You, by the same token, can't tell me how to live my live as an Indian because you haven't lived as an Indian.
Sadly, based on a number of responses you've made relating to Indian discussions, you also don't have that much knowledge/experience about Indian history - from the Indian side -hence you answer from your perspective - which is all you know, and that is understandable.
What I would like to see from you are questions as to why/where/when/who has caused the concerns/issues we are expressing instead of putting your answers in our mouths.
"Walk a mile" is a good start.
BF, I'm calling BS on your comment.
First off, what makes you believe that we haven't voted for something other then democratic or republican? Are you aware that the first women to run on a presidential ticket was an American Indian? it was Winona LaDuke on the Green party.
You comment about us asking to you to submit to guilt is really off the wall. I clearly stated in my last comment to you that I do not believe in ''sins of the father''. So dragging that into the debate is simply a diversion.
And voting for dem or repub we are responsible for our own suffering!!!! Are you kidding me, what makes you think that if there was a 3rd, 4th or 5th party that they would treat Indians any differently?
BF - is that the Libertarian?
Hate is the father of all evil.
David Gemmell , Fall of Kings
BF, thanks for stating your parties platform. I'm assuming that it's Libertarian. If not please advise what party it is.
I agree with the platform as stated in your comment. Now, if we can continue in that vein, perhaps we can come to an understanding of the what really is happening in the government and it's treatment of American Indians.
The problem with finding a solution is that both sides have to want it. As demonstrated by the current climate towards Indians, and this applies to dems, repubs, wigs, etc is that they do not want to find a solution. The status quo is much more comfortable for them.
Their ability to dictate the terms is in keeping with the history of the US.
That said, in recent years Indians have become more involved in the political process. Both as voters and as people running for office. It's an approach of ''change from within''.
Many cities, counties and states are seeing Indians running for office and winning. This is bringing about a sea change in the electoral process with many states.
I, personally, am neither dem or repub. Some call me an anarchist. I am infact, for overwhelming change in our system of government.
Whether that is Libertarian, Green, or the Red(not communist)party, I'm for it.
I was really surprised that Gary didn't get more coverage and support. Let's see what happens on the next go-around.
BF, good to know the information on the Libertarian platform.
I'll relate a true story to you. The administration went to the different tribes, and told them that they were having a $2,500 to $5,000 a plate dinner to help raise funds for the administration. Some Indian leaders donated to it.
One leader of a tribe, made this comment. $5,000 for a dinner! It sounds like another white Thanksgiving to me. He, of course did not donate to the ''cause''.
I am behind his tribal leader 100 per cent.
You have to remember. That came out when the Western was still in its heyday. Oater dominance was fading by then but they were still topping the popularity lists. Since they featured Indian wars, Billy Jack indicted their premise: that whites were heroic and Indians were villains. So the studios were protecting their investment in these movies and the stars that made them.
Besides, violence against women is entertainment, don't you know? We get a steady diet of it on TV and in the movies. Inflicting violence on women is a time honored tradition in our society and how "men" prove their macho worth. /s
Loved Billy Jack. Too bad there aren't more movies like it that highlight the ugly underbelly of our society when it comes to how "the other" is treated in our white Christian heterosexual male dominated society.
That is not a racist statement, Robert. It's stupid to pretend it is. That's a reality. Everyone who lives in the US, except American Indians, is a recipient of the benefits of the historical wrongs inflicted upon American Indians.
How else would we own our property or live in this nation? How else would this nation even exist?
I own property that was stolen from Indians by the Catholic church in their mission building quest. I am not personally responsible for the atrocities Father Juniper Serra and other priests did to Indians, but I have to admit I own land that before the atrocities was occupied by American Indians. It would be silly to deny it since it is historically true.
I probably would have been born in England if the English didn't send their invaders to this continent and murder American Indians in order to steal their land and if their descendants hadn't rebelled from England and established the United States of America. So why would I deny that I benefit in that way too simply by being able to call myself an American?
I love where I live and the nation I live in, but so did the American Indians long before anyone in Europe even knew this continent existed. It was their continent, and anyone who can't admit that is lying to themselves.
AABAMII (RESIST)
BF, here is the link to the story.
Canada, an armed confrontation between First Nations people and the RCMP.
...
The caption is mine and written in the Ojibwe language...AABAMII - RESIST
You're missing the big picture. Your family would not be here if not for genocidal policies inflicted by invading Europeans, so yes, you do benefit whether or not your family did anything wrong. That doesn't mean you personally are responsible or need to carry guilt, just that you do benefit because this nation would not exist and you would not be an American if not for what was done to the Indians.
I remember the article that accompanied that picture, Kavika. Idle No More and AIM should make it the poster for both their organizations for 2014 and send it world wide.
Exactly Mac.
I believe that INM has been using that photo on a regular basis mimi.