Judge: NSA Phone Program Likely Unconstitutional
A federal judge ruled Monday that the National Security Agency program which collects information on nearly all telephone calls made to, from or within the United States is likely to be unconstitutional.
http://http://www.politico.com/story/2013/12/national-security-agency-phones-judge-101203.html
Tags
Who is online
86 visitors

Acting on a lawsuit brought by conservative legal activist Larry Klayman, Leon issued a preliminary injunction barring the NSA from collecting metadata pertaining to the Verizon accounts of Klayman and one of his clients. However, the judge stayed the order to allow for an appeal
Read more:
A step in the right direction I hope.
if venue is dc circut, good luck
it is exactly to end any chance of judicial recourse that obama ordered the senate to go nuclear, so he can pack the court and eliminate the peoples right to prosecute unconsitutionality.
not since fdr and george the 3rd have we seen such and unbridled contempt for the citizenry.
Interesting development . How the courts decide this will be quite informative ...
Damn - you beat me to posting this article. Apparently the person who keeps insisting that "nobody cares" about this issue, was quite wrong.
if you like your privacy, you can keep your privacy, period
This was my article and I would appreciate it if you wouldn't use it for the purpose you did.
Feel free to comment on the topic at hand.
I think this is one issue where both sides can meet in the middle. The secret courts might be giving the NSA a free pass on this but at least the real courts are going to have a say in the matter.
Thanks for commenting.
We knew this thing was heading to the SCOTUS, and that is where it belongs.
None of us here on NT have enough background in constitutional law, or related cases showing precedence in this matter to talk beyond what the talking heads want to spew.
Right now if I had to bet on a SCOTUS ruling....60:40 in favor of continuing the program with modification.
I agree Hal. I care and I know a lot of people who are from both sides of the aisle and indies who care. Our government has become way too invasive and it's about time that it was brought back in line. This will go straight up to SCOTUS though.
Like clockwork, out come your two favorite distractions. Of course you don't want to address the four real issues - crippling cost, proven ineffectiveness, transparency, and potential for abuse. While you are raising hell about extending unemployment benefits, perhaps you could recognize how much more easily that could be facilitated if this administration wasn't so busy funneling hundreds of billions of dollars into an ineffective surveillance system with no oversight, that has already been shown to be abused on numerous occasions by some of the millions of average joes who have a security clearance, whose salaries are paid by tax payers, using unconstitutional technology unwittingly paid for by tax payers.
Who cares who Klayman is? If he is an American who values his right to privacy, the topic of political ideology here is non sequitur.
Prior to this, the EFF (Electronic Frontier Foundation) filed an amicus curiae on behalf of the plaintiff in Hepting v. AT&T long before the Snowden leaks. It was eventually dismissed by SCOTUS.
This particular case, Klayman VS Obama , this suit was squarely aimed at Obama and not the NSA, whom can be seen a the perpetrator behind the NSAs activities.
This is far from over. Aside from going to appellate court next, you can expect the Obama administration to dig their heels in on this. They want to know every facet of innocent Americans lives.
Also, expect more suits, especially from the ACLU and EFF.
Who are the traitors?!
There is NO larger issue, except for you. Obama & Co. usurping my rights is as large as it gets.
This has been a very interesting development. The right was against the FISA court as an unconstitutional restriction on the Executive Branch. Now many on the right realize that a Democratic POTUS shouldn't be trusted, and the FISA court isn't enough.
Good.
The more things stay the same, the more they change.
Some believe that the opposite is true too.
Glad to help John . Your comments are endlessly entertaining even if not informative ...
anyone else catch bernie (independant...ROTFFL...vt) sandeers yesterday? he was pretty upset because he sent a letter to the nsa asking if congress' (oh, the horror) phones/emails are being tracked as well.
the nsa responded with: congress enjoys the same protections as the general population
well, aint that special? poor sir bernie, being a socialist who objects to government intrusion must be a bitch!
of course, he said it was his fear that a future president may have this power. he trusts his monarch of course....period