My father served on a carrier in WW2, and as I get older I become increasingly interested in and aware of how the Depression & the War shaped my parents' generation and events thereafter. Interesting to see howdecisions made by Allen & John Foster Dulles under Eisenhower's admin set the stage for so many political scenarios we are still playing out today...
You better quit while you still sound sane. Equating the Pearl Harbor attack with being merely nostalgia is a direct insult to the men and women who died there.
I guess you need a lecture. Your insensitivity and sheer lack of historical content rate your replies as rather, shall we say, confused, at best.
Nobody looks at the events of WWII as nostalgia, which means a sentimentality for the past, typically for a period or place with happy personal associations. Your gross neglect and dismissal of the lives lost not only when Pearl Harbor was attacked, but for the ensuing carnage that was WWII is an affront to every Veteran who laid down their lives for this country.
Today we do not have the men who would willingly fight a global war...
I don't think that's the case, G... I'd bet our service men (and women) would answer that call as willingly as the 'past' generation, but (thank god) there's not such a clearly identifiable 'global evil' facing us today. The communists are busy becoming capitalists, and the most visible threats now are skulking pissant anonymous religious fanatics too craven even to put on uniforms. The dedication of American armed forces personnel is demonstrated by their willingness to serve in armed conflicts rooted in dumbass political/economic schemes over 'resource aquisition' and untrustworty 'allies of convenience' instead of more honest or honorable causes...
Here is to those that forevermore..... remain on patrol.
I had the true honor of rendering honors to the USS Arizona as we passed by on our way in and out of Pearl Harbor back in 1983 and again in 1984. Thirty years later I can still recall where I was on the catwalk, and the cold empty feeling that came over me as I looked at the memorial. As we secured from manning the rails, all of us said the same thing. We weren't going to let that happen to our boat. The moment simultaneously generated both tears, and a steeled determination.
John, Not the point of the article, but just to note that I too was fortunate to have teachers [actually two] that impacted me in the same way, but it was in the Sciences from both.
I do agree AP and John, that Pearl Harbor is a day of Infamy. There are many Japanese settlers as a result of the Camps, in my area, with the older generations still harboring resentment, seemingly.
I don't know a lot about History, and especially of the Wars from the past, but WWII will always be significant to me from a personal perspective. My Father joined the Navy after the war had ended and was on one of the first ships to go back to the areas hard hit after the bomb. He became very ill ten years later, with cancer having ravaged his organs, stomach and esophagus. There had never been any history of those cancers on that side of the family, so it is thought that exposure to high levels of radiation, radiated dishes, objects [they hold it] and foods caused his death as a relatively young man. He was also stationed at Pearl Harbor for a while. So while I respect what many went through with that devastation from a Japanese perspective, I will always have a level of umbrage and antipathy, at the same time.
What I've learned about WWII, the real story, was directly from people who lived through it. I've been associated with Nursing homes first as an employee in college and later, as a volunteer.
As a personal project, I would talk to these people and record their stories. I have over 60 cassette tapes of people recounting how it was, both as military and civilians at home, and NONE look at it nostalgically and in all cases, talking about it brought tears to their and my eyes.
You can keep your Hollywood marketing definition of nostalgia, that's not real life....unless you consider Hogan's Hero's factual history.
American history is full of lies, from the Native Americans to this supposed threat by Iran. I believe in what people tell me, when I can look them in the eye.
A local Veterans held a memorial this morning which me and my daughters attended...as fricken cold as it is here. Many young faces, maybe a few Vietnam vets, but mainly from Iraq/Afghanistan. I'll take my cue from them, there is a lesson Pearl Harbor taught that should never be forgotten.
Not to disparage the WW2 vets but this occasion is never used to honor the vets of other wars . Korean vets are merely ignored . Vietnam vets are still despised ...
Robert G., I'm so happy you asked that, because at the time, I almost asked it, too, but wasn't brave enough. I have my own thoughts, but would like to read others'.
Not to disparage the WW2 vets but this occasion is never used to honor the vets of other wars . Korean vets are merely ignored . Vietnam vets are still despised ...
True.
Remember this famous photo-- Jane Fonda sitting on a North Vietnamese anti-aircraft gun-- showing her support for those men who were trying to murder U.S. servicemen:
...to this day some Americans still consider her to be a true "hero"...
The statement is " rhetorical . " Badfish brought up one thought, another one might be to keep vigilant. Also considering that the Japanese were negotiating with Washington about improved relations when Pearl Harbor was attacked suggests another train of thought.
(OT, Robert, just to note - your plastic surgery came out well, and a shirt and tie are a nice addition. I'll admit that your other outfit had me thinking you were from a Star Trek episode.)
You two need to stop slap-fighting. The difference you are arguing about is more a definition of terms more than anything else. Seems to be more ego than intelligence at work. Nostalgia does not equate to celebrating. John is right in this particular case.
Interesting exchange between you two. I see Robert's point as being that of extrapolation from 'previous' facts. That's what we usually do when we draw conclusions, as a basis for reasoning.
As was confirmed during the Hellenistic period, it was brute force by the Greeks and Romans, but the Asians, generally lacking the physiology, used intelligence to accomplish the same. I see this as a logical extrapolation concerning WWII, and given that size was an issue, any small nation is going to realize they need to work smarter, not necessarily forcefully harder. Just my thoughts, that I hope have some correlation to both of yours'.
So what you are saying is that this tragic event has outlived it's usefulness?
Given that train of thought, should the generations yet to come discard the 9/11 because everyone who lived through it is dead?
My father served on a carrier in WW2, and as I get older I become increasingly interested in and aware of how the Depression & the War shaped my parents' generation and events thereafter. Interesting to see howdecisions made by Allen & John Foster Dulles under Eisenhower's admin set the stage for so many political scenarios we are still playing out today...
You better quit while you still sound sane. Equating the Pearl Harbor attack with being merely nostalgia is a direct insult to the men and women who died there.
I guess you need a lecture. Your insensitivity and sheer lack of historical content rate your replies as rather, shall we say, confused, at best.
Nobody looks at the events of WWII as nostalgia, which means a sentimentality for the past, typically for a period or place with happy personal associations. Your gross neglect and dismissal of the lives lost not only when Pearl Harbor was attacked, but for the ensuing carnage that was WWII is an affront to every Veteran who laid down their lives for this country.
Pitiful.
Holy foreign policy E... an area of common agreement. 'A day that will live in infamy'...
Gunny--
I don't think that's the case, G... I'd bet our service men (and women) would answer that call as willingly as the 'past' generation, but (thank god) there's not such a clearly identifiable 'global evil' facing us today. The communists are busy becoming capitalists, and the most visible threats now are skulking pissant anonymous religious fanatics too craven even to put on uniforms. The dedication of American armed forces personnel is demonstrated by their willingness to serve in armed conflicts rooted in dumbass political/economic schemes over 'resource aquisition' and untrustworty 'allies of convenience' instead of more honest or honorable causes...
No disagreement on that score, G...
Here is to those that forevermore..... remain on patrol.
I had the true honor of rendering honors to the USS Arizona as we passed by on our way in and out of Pearl Harbor back in 1983 and again in 1984. Thirty years later I can still recall where I was on the catwalk, and the cold empty feeling that came over me as I looked at the memorial. As we secured from manning the rails, all of us said the same thing. We weren't going to let that happen to our boat. The moment simultaneously generated both tears, and a steeled determination.
John, Not the point of the article, but just to note that I too was fortunate to have teachers [actually two] that impacted me in the same way, but it was in the Sciences from both.
I do agree AP and John, that Pearl Harbor is a day of Infamy. There are many Japanese settlers as a result of the Camps, in my area, with the older generations still harboring resentment, seemingly.
I don't know a lot about History, and especially of the Wars from the past, but WWII will always be significant to me from a personal perspective. My Father joined the Navy after the war had ended and was on one of the first ships to go back to the areas hard hit after the bomb. He became very ill ten years later, with cancer having ravaged his organs, stomach and esophagus. There had never been any history of those cancers on that side of the family, so it is thought that exposure to high levels of radiation, radiated dishes, objects [they hold it] and foods caused his death as a relatively young man. He was also stationed at Pearl Harbor for a while. So while I respect what many went through with that devastation from a Japanese perspective, I will always have a level of umbrage and antipathy, at the same time.
What I've learned about WWII, the real story, was directly from people who lived through it. I've been associated with Nursing homes first as an employee in college and later, as a volunteer.
As a personal project, I would talk to these people and record their stories. I have over 60 cassette tapes of people recounting how it was, both as military and civilians at home, and NONE look at it nostalgically and in all cases, talking about it brought tears to their and my eyes.
You can keep your Hollywood marketing definition of nostalgia, that's not real life....unless you consider Hogan's Hero's factual history.
American history is full of lies, from the Native Americans to this supposed threat by Iran. I believe in what people tell me, when I can look them in the eye.
A local Veterans held a memorial this morning which me and my daughters attended...as fricken cold as it is here. Many young faces, maybe a few Vietnam vets, but mainly from Iraq/Afghanistan. I'll take my cue from them, there is a lesson Pearl Harbor taught that should never be forgotten.
Not to disparage the WW2 vets but this occasion is never used to honor the vets of other wars . Korean vets are merely ignored . Vietnam vets are still despised ...
Robert G., I'm so happy you asked that, because at the time, I almost asked it, too, but wasn't brave enough.
I have my own thoughts, but would like to read others'.
True.
Remember this famous photo-- Jane Fonda sitting on a North Vietnamese anti-aircraft gun-- showing her support for those men who were trying to murder U.S. servicemen:
...to this day some Americans still consider her to be a true "hero"...
Petey, I didn't ask this before, but why, in your opinion, the ignored and despised?
Write a letter to the New York Times about it.
The statement is " rhetorical . " Badfish brought up one thought, another one might be to keep vigilant. Also considering that the Japanese were negotiating with Washington about improved relations when Pearl Harbor was attacked suggests another train of thought.
BF's point and keep vigilant are very good responses, as well as don't make assumptions just because they are smaller than you are.
(OT, Robert, just to note - your plastic surgery came out well, and a shirt and tie are a nice addition. I'll admit that your other outfit had me thinking you were from a Star Trek episode.)
Good idea. Isn't that what they mean by 'formal' discussion?!
With the exception that you don't have a mouth, it came out very well.
we flew the stars and stripes on the 7th!
thanks poppy!!
You two need to stop slap-fighting. The difference you are arguing about is more a definition of terms more than anything else. Seems to be more ego than intelligence at work. Nostalgia does not equate to celebrating. John is right in this particular case.
I agree, Spikegary. Nostalgia is remembering and honoring, not celebrating.
Egilman & Robert,
Interesting exchange between you two. I see Robert's point as being that of extrapolation from 'previous' facts. That's what we usually do when we draw conclusions, as a basis for reasoning.
As was confirmed during the Hellenistic period, it was brute force by the Greeks and Romans, but the Asians, generally lacking the physiology, used intelligence to accomplish the same. I see this as a logical extrapolation concerning WWII, and given that size was an issue, any small nation is going to realize they need to work smarter, not necessarily forcefully harder. Just my thoughts, that I hope have some correlation to both of yours'.