╌>

Raising the Minimum Wage & then what's next?

  

Category:  News & Politics

Via:  robert-in-ohio  •  13 years ago  •  70 comments

Raising the Minimum Wage & then what's next?

Income inequality and the wage disparity are real problems in the United States that deserve real solutions and not just a lot of theatrics and posturing by politicians and talking heads looking to capture popular support to further their political agendas.

Some would argue that we should just raise the minimum wage to $10, $12, $25 or even higher and that will take care of the problem and the middle class will be revitalized, the American Dream will be available to all citizens and the economic skies will be blue and sunny for the rest of days. Wealth redistribution is another solution advocated by certain political ideologues who proffer a variety of ways to affect this redistribution, but the crux of it is taking money from people who have earned it or acquired it through inheritance and give it to people who have not been so fortunate in their economic endeavors but still want the money they feel they deserve.

There are problems and obstacles with both of these approaches which doom both to failure. The former ignores ancillary economic and social factors critical to individual success and attainment of the American Dream as well as Newtons Law which declares that for all actions there are equal and opposite reactions and some of those reactions can be just as serious as the original problem. The problem with the latter solution is quite obvious, the people who have earned or legitimately acquired wealth and/or positions with high incomes are justifiably adverse to having their money ripped from their hands and given to someone who they may or may not feel has expended sufficient individual effort to succeed on their own.

Actions and reactions sound very scientific and that should appeal to folks who want facts to trump feelings, emotions and beliefs about what happens or does not happen.

Let us consider for a moment the following scenario. The federal minimum wage is increased by 50% which would put it at approximately $12.00 per hour throughout the nation. Hard to argue that this would not be a welcome and celebrated event for millions of American workers, but that is not the end of the story. What happens next?

There would be a natural and corresponding increase in the cost of doing business for employers which would be arithmetically greater than the actual salary increase for the workers owing to the actual increased wages, increased payroll tax costs and increased costs of retirement plans and other benefits provided to employees. It can be argued that many businesses could simply absorb these added costs but the reality of the world we live in is that the increased costs of doing business would be passed along as price increases on goods and services to consumers, which would negate to some degree the benefit of the wage increase. The raising of the floor of the wage structure in the country would also create corresponding increases (not necessarily the same percentage increase) at wage levels above the minimum wage all the way to the top of a companys salary structure, as increasing costs in the economy would require higher wages for workers to maintain their standards of living resulting in even higher operating costs for businesses.

Some people might argue that many, many jobs would simply be eliminated but I think that is unlikely as most businesses have contracted their work forces as much as possible already and cannot continue to cut the number of employees to cut costs. Therefore, the prices of goods and services would rise in proportion equal to or perhaps even greater than the wage increase and since the rising tide would raise all boats, the poverty level might go up a little but those living in poverty would likely remain there.

So a more complex solution is needed to the economic woes of the middle class and the working poor in the United States, which must include a resurgence of a manufacturing/production base in the U.S., tax code reform and regulation enforcement that encourages corporate domestic development and expansion along with improvements in the education system to better prepare American workers for new, more technically demanding jobs in the new middle class.

I am fully supportive of raising the minimum wage and tying future increases to the CPI, but we should not be so nave as to see an increase in the minimum wage as a cure for the woes of the working poor or the economy when it is only a small part of the solution that is needed and that it will have unintended consequences that will also require solutions.


Tags

jrDiscussion - desc
[]
 
Robert in Ohio
Professor Guide
link   seeder  Robert in Ohio    13 years ago

Minimum wage and the revitalization of the middle class - the former may be part of the process to accomplish the latter but in and of itself it is nor the solution to the woes of the middle class and the working poor

I look forward to the ideas, opinions and suggested solution tracks from everyone

 
 
 
FLYNAVY1
Professor Quiet
link   FLYNAVY1    13 years ago

I fear the damage is done to the point to where there is no recovery to be had. The money is pooled into too few hands, and it is being horded with no reason for it to move back into the greater economy as real cash flow.

When cash flow started to leak outside of the US market into foreign markets for products back in the 1970s the writing was on the wall. The next nail in the coffin was the push towards heavy use of robotics and automation in the late 1980s to cut labor costs and cut decent wage jobs. The next nail was the reduction of capital gains taxes in the early 2000s which allowed those that didn't really for their earning to keep most of it. At that point middle class people burned through all of the equity they may have amassed in their houses and maxed out their credit cards creating the bubble that burst in 2008. By then the majority of cash flow had been emptied out of the working class markets.

There is no incentive for those that have that cash to put it back into circulation. I just don't see any way out of this situation. We both know that re-instituting a 40% capital gains tax will pass on capital has a snowballs chance in hell in passing. As I said, I don't see a way out of the current situation.

 
 
 
Chloe
Freshman Silent
link   Chloe    13 years ago

..And then what? It all depends on the industry and the product, as I see it... and it can have devastating effects for the working poor, if the industry to which they are employed has to lay them off due to inflation.

i.e.:

According to Forbes, "inflation is simply a rise in the average price of goods and services in the macroeconomy."

The results would seem to be varying depending on the product, increased/decreased sales, the need to increase/decrease labor force, and/or the need to increase price, if the product competition warrants it. In other words, will it be a good thing or a bad thing for that particular business to have increased the minimum wage.... just depends.

The bottom line is that the business is not going to accept losing money -- the wage increase needs to be met by 'increased productivity' as a calculation ratio to revenues, or the company is forced to reduce the labor force. If inflation for that business means increased sales, then productivity can be met, as well as the wage increase.

Inflation is a double-edged sword. :)

 
 
 
Larry Hampton
Professor Quiet
link   Larry Hampton    13 years ago

Institute an across-the-board flat tax on all.

 
 
 
FLYNAVY1
Professor Quiet
link   FLYNAVY1    13 years ago

Larry... A flat tax will cement the pooled money right where it is.

The trick is to get that pooled money off of the sidelines and back into circulation in the way of cash flow. Money has to work by changing hands, and a flat tax cannot do that.

 
 
 
A. Macarthur
Professor Guide
link   A. Macarthur    13 years ago
  • Increasing the federal minimum wage to $9.80 by July 1, 2014, would raise the wages of about 28 million workers, who would receive nearly $40 billion in additional wages over the phase-in period. 2
  • Across the phase-in period of the minimum-wage increase, GDP would increase by roughly $25 billion, resulting in the creation of approximately 100,000 net new jobs over that period.
  • Those who would see wage increases do not fit some of the stereotypes of minimum-wage workers.
    • Women would be disproportionately affected, comprising nearly 55 percent of those who would benefit.
    • Nearly 88 percent of workers who would benefit are at least 20 years old.
    • Although workers of all races and ethnicities would benefit from the increase, non-Hispanic white workers comprise the largest share (about 56 percent) of those who would be affected.
    • About 42 percent of affected workers have at least some college education.
    • Around 54 percent of affected workers work full time, over 70 percent are in families with incomes of less than $60,000, more than a quarter are parents, and over a third are married.
    • The average affected worker earns about half of his or her familys total income.

That's just the Federal minimum wage private sector increases would add more to the economy.

Reasons for Raising the Minimum Wage

1. The minimum wage is below the living wage, exacerbating poverty in the United States.

A living wage ensures that a worker can pay for basic necessities like housing, food, transportation to work and health care. A common definition states that the living wage should be high enough that no more than 30% of take-home payneeds to be spent on housing. (Learn how to set up your budget according to the 50/20/30 Rule .)

But full-time employeesbeing paidthe current minimum wagewill have incomesbelow the living wage in most areas of the country.In dollar terms, that means that if you area full-time worker supporting a family of four on the current minimum wage, your household income is $7,000 below the poverty line. Proponents of raising the minimum wage to a living wage argue that doing so would give workers and their families a better chance of climbing out of debt and poverty.(Find out why the U.S. has less class mobility than Canada or Britain .)

As an increasing number of workers take on low-wage jobs, poverty in the United States has increased: In 2005, 12.6% of Americans were living in poverty, compared to 15.7% this year (almost 50 million citizens)the highest rate of poverty since 1965 . Raising the minimum wage to a living wage would hopefully help to reverse this trend.

2. A higher minimum wage means more consumer spending overall.

Higher wages dont just benefit the individual earner, they also help the economy at large by increasing consumer spending. One 2011 study by the Chicago Federal Reserve Bank showed that every dollar added to the hourly minimum wage resulted in $2,800 in yearly additional consumer spending by that workers household.

Additionally, a 2009 study from the Economic Policy Institute predicted that upping the minimum wage to $9.50 an hour would result in $60 billion in additional spending over two years. Furthermore, this additional consumer spending would lead to more job creationan estimated 100,000 new full-time jobs .

RELATED: Which Helps the Economy More: Saving or Spending?

3. Workers making more than the minimum wage would also see their earnings increase.

Many workers who earn more than the minimum wage28 million, in factwould also see their earnings increase as a result of raising the minimum wage, says the Economic Policy Institute .Why? The minimum wage is seen as the base number from which their wages are calculated, so if that number is raised, their earnings will increase accordingly which will lead to even more consumer spending. (Find out why employers are likely to be stingy with raises in 2013 .)

Is There a Good Reason Not to Raise the Minimum Wage?

With all the seeming benefits to raising the minimum wage, is there a compelling reason not to raise it, at the very least to a living wage? And why shouldnt it be indexed to inflation?

Those opposed to raising it often argue that doing so will put too great a strain on employers concerned with keeping costs down, which will ultimately lead to companies being forced to slash jobs to stay afloat. However, economists like Arindrajit Dube of the University of Massachusetts-Amherst showed that over a 16-year period, areas that raised the minimum wage did not see more employment loss than comparable areas with lower minimum wages.

Additionally, two-thirds of the low-wage workers in the United States work for large companies with 100 or more employees who are more able to absorb the higher cost of hourly wages, as opposed to small mom-and-pop operations. Looking at the 50 largest employers of low-wage workers (companies like Wal-Mart, KFC and McDonalds),more than 90% were profitable last year, meaning that they are unlikely to be in a position where raising the minimum wage to a living wage would significantly affect their ability to retain the same number of employees. (Find out how McDonalds is turning unhealthy foods into a healthy stock price .)

RELATED: 29 Million Jobs Available Not Requiring a College Degree

So, Will the Bill Pass?

While over 100 Democrats helped to introduce the bill in the House of Representatives during the summer to raise the minimum wage, most Republicans will likely argue that the fragile economy prohibits such a drastic change to the minimum wage. Though President Obama campaigned in 2008 on the promise to raise the minimum wage, he has not been active in that fight in some time, and in March, Mitt Romney retracted comments he had made as recently as January saying that he would like to see the minimum wage indexed to inflation.

Despite the likely political standstill on the minimum wage issue, recent polls have shown that 70% of Americans support raising the minimum wage and believe that doing so has the power to help the economy in these uncertain times.

...

Too much information? Don't read it all.

Interested in specifics related to the discussion you're now informed and can decide the pros and cons for yourself.

 
 
 
Petey Coober
Freshman Silent
link   Petey Coober    13 years ago

Looking at the 50 largest employers of low-wage workers (companies like Wal-Mart, KFC and McDonalds), more than 90% were profitable last year, meaning that they are unlikely to be in a position where raising the minimum wage to a living wage would significantly affect their ability to retain the same number of employees.

This is mostly nonsense .
KFC and McDonalds do not hire those large numbers of workers since they are franchise operations . The profits that were mentioned only refer to the corporate franchise headquarters & not the individual shops . Thus raising the minimum wage for those individual shops would directly their bottom lines in a severe amount . It would probably put the majority of them out of business hurting not only their current employees but also the shop ownwers who paid large amounts for the privilege of owning a big name franchise shop .

Too much information? Don't read it all.

Thanks much for making me wade through a ton of misleading crap to find the atrocious error ...

 
 
 
Dowser
Sophomore Silent
link   Dowser    13 years ago

I'm all for that, Mike. Smile.gif

 
 
 
pat wilson
Professor Quiet
link   pat wilson    13 years ago

They're coming for your wealth, Robert, no, they're not. just kidding.

 
 
 
Aeonpax
Freshman Silent
link   Aeonpax    13 years ago

Minimum wage, whatever it is, will not revitalize the middle class, at least not in this current "maximum profit" corporate environment. Raising it will just skew the statistics. I've always viewed so-called middle class wages as being like a bungee cord, it can stretch or shrink.

Generally, if wages go up for unskilled and semi-skilled labor, wages also go up the professional, managerial and skilled which are a tier above them. A domino effect. While some corporations can absorb the cost, most (whom are used to their high profits) will not. To combat this, corps will reduce staff, shrink portions or sizes, increase staff workloads and then still will end up surreptitiously slowly raise prices.

This will have a greater impact on small business (ex: corner bakery) who do not have the capitol or financial assets to weather this.

Raising the minimum wage is not a panacea. I agree with those who state the tax codes need to be re-written.

 
 
 
Robert in Ohio
Professor Guide
link   seeder  Robert in Ohio    13 years ago

Mike

I agree and have been saying that for years

 
 
 
Robert in Ohio
Professor Guide
link   seeder  Robert in Ohio    13 years ago

J F T

Agreed, but perhaps a set tax rate for each income group (with some amount excluded say $25K) and then eliminate deductions, credits and adjustments and eliminate all the loopholes for everyone

 
 
 
Robert in Ohio
Professor Guide
link   seeder  Robert in Ohio    13 years ago

FLYNAVY1

Thanks for sharing your perspective

I fear the damage is done to the point to where there is no recovery to be had.

I refuse to give up on this great country and have to disagree

There is no incentive for those that have that cash to put it back into circulation.

The it is imperative that we find incentives and penalties that will encourage domestic investment and expansion and not reward off shore operations

 
 
 
Robert in Ohio
Professor Guide
link   seeder  Robert in Ohio    13 years ago

Chloe

Appreciate your feedback

and it can have devastating effects for the working poor, if the industry to which they are employed has to lay them off due to inflation.

One of those reactions that are possible to the action of raising the minimum wage in a vacuum that was talking about above.

the wage increaseneeds to be met by'increased productivity'

Perhaps it could also be new sales in new markets of new products and services produced by a new and vibrant middle class

Inflation is a double-edged sword.

And it cuts very sharply and deeply if ignored

 
 
 
Robert in Ohio
Professor Guide
link   seeder  Robert in Ohio    13 years ago

Larry

Rather than a flat tax perhaps set tax rates at all income levels without deductions, credits or adjustments except for a set non taxable amount (ay $25K) for all citizens and after that you pay the income tax rate for your remaining income without adjustment of any kind

 
 
 
Robert in Ohio
Professor Guide
link   seeder  Robert in Ohio    13 years ago

FLYNAVY1

Agreed there are inherent dangers and pitfalls to a simply flat tax

 
 
 
Robert in Ohio
Professor Guide
link   seeder  Robert in Ohio    13 years ago

BadFish

It is the economic effect of 1% of a small income and 1% of a large income on the earner

The lower the earned amount the greater the impact

 
 
 
Robert in Ohio
Professor Guide
link   seeder  Robert in Ohio    13 years ago

Robert

Good movie and good clip but the exact relevance is a little vague

Are you suggesting that a good PR campaign is needed to give them hope for change (no pun intended)?

Please elaborate

 
 
 
Robert in Ohio
Professor Guide
link   seeder  Robert in Ohio    13 years ago

A Mac

No one is arguing (at lest I am not) that the minimum wage needs to be raised, the position I presented was simply doing that in a vacuum will likely not create the desired results in the long term.

Thanks for cutting and pasting so much data, but I am more interested in what you think the path forward needs to be and simply raise the minimum wage does not seem to cut it as we must deal with the economic issues that will occur after the raise occurs

 
 
 
Robert in Ohio
Professor Guide
link   seeder  Robert in Ohio    13 years ago

Petey

Especially when you consider that KFC, McDonalds and many other businesses that employ significant numbers of low wage earners are franchises and the costs are not to the mega-corporation but rather ta small business with few employees.

A narrow minded few of the problem and the single path solution of raise th minimum wage is part of the problem in my view

Appreciate your feedback

 
 
 
Robert in Ohio
Professor Guide
link   seeder  Robert in Ohio    13 years ago

BadFish

Could indeed happen if we are not careful

 
 
 
FLYNAVY1
Professor Quiet
link   FLYNAVY1    13 years ago

I don't want to give up either Robert, but try as I might, I can't think of a reason or method by which the status quo can be changed.

What.... you want to appeal to their sense of patriotic duty? That's how off-shore bank accounts came into being.

 
 
 
Robert in Ohio
Professor Guide
link   seeder  Robert in Ohio    13 years ago

pat Wilson

Well if they find "my wealth" I hope I get a cut because I have sure not found it in the first 60 years of my life and if it is "my wealth" I would at leas like to touch it

Thanks for the perspective and feedback

Smile.gif

 
 
 
Robert in Ohio
Professor Guide
link   seeder  Robert in Ohio    13 years ago

A P

Minimum wage, whatever it is, will not revitalize the middle class, at least not in this current "maximum profit" corporate environment.

100% correct and the reason for the article as I was thinking the same way

A domino effect.

Exactly again and that domino effect has a variety of forms and each must be dealt with, if we truly wish to revitalize and expand the middle class and raise up the working poor

Raising the minimum wage is not a panacea.

A very succinct summary of the point and the problem

Thanks a lot for the feedback and perspective

 
 
 
Robert in Ohio
Professor Guide
link   seeder  Robert in Ohio    13 years ago

John

Most of this thread is just plain silly.

Is that because your perspective is "raise the minimum wage" and all will be well?

I think so

If you had read the article you would have noticed that I said

I am fully supportive of raising the minimum wage and tying future increases to the CPI

but as the article pointed out and many of the comments have elaborated on that is only the beginning step in a process to rebuild the manufacturing/production in the U.S., to revitalize the middle class and to provide a means for the working poor to elevate themselves into that middle class.

You hit all the talking points that we have heard for years while nothing has gotten de. It is time for a new conversation.

 
 
 
Robert in Ohio
Professor Guide
link   seeder  Robert in Ohio    13 years ago

FLYNAVY1

No I think it time for a new conversation and new actions to make real change and it is up to we the people to elect representatives and senators that will make those tough choices and do the hard work to put together the solutions

 
 
 
Robert in Ohio
Professor Guide
link   seeder  Robert in Ohio    13 years ago

John

So in answering to what's next after raising the minimum wage it seems that you think nothing is and that raising it will be the solution to the woes of the working poor

A very narrow look at a broad problem to be solved

 
 
 
Robert in Ohio
Professor Guide
link   seeder  Robert in Ohio    13 years ago

John

Very classy answer

Either you are being rude or are trying to inject religion into the debate, neither is appropriate in my view but you have your own standards which I accept

Your rhetoric and attitude add nothing of value to the discussion

People have the right to earn what their skills bring them in the market place and we should do the myriad of things necessary to make sure that the marketplace is able to pay sufficient wages to make the workers ability make a living a reality.

If you read and understand the article you will understand that raising the minimum wage creates domino effects that must be dealt with otherwise the increased wage will be absorbed and bot benefit the worker as you seem think it will benefit them

 
 
 
Robert in Ohio
Professor Guide
link   seeder  Robert in Ohio    13 years ago

John

If you knew as much about the issue as you want people to think you do, you would know that many of the low wage workers (especially in the fast food industry) work for franchises and not for the mega corporation with huge profits

But that would mean actually looking at the issue

Your answer for low income workers appears to be, despite all your "concern" for them, "tough shit", "deal with it". That's not the answer Robert.

That comment alone shows exactly how little you understood the article and how little you understand the issue and the ramifications of the issue. There is nothing in my article or my comments that reflects that attitude actually quite the opposite as I proffered the idea that a complex solution was needed so that whatever increase in wages was received by low income earners would actually benefit them. But is hard to see that broader issues with your blinders on so I understand your confusion which is nothing new for you actually.

You lost interest in the issue and resorted to name calling a little earlier than usual and it is good to see that your "internet bravado" is intact. It is incredibly amusing and ironic that you would call anyone a cheerleader for any position or entity

 
 
 
A. Macarthur
Professor Guide
link   A. Macarthur    13 years ago

The entire tax code needs to be rewritten from the ground up, for everybody, and that means everybody, rich poor and middle class.

And NOT BY CORPORATE LOBBYISTS and LAWYERS!

 
 
 
A. Macarthur
Professor Guide
link   A. Macarthur    13 years ago

Thanks for cutting and pasting so much data, but I am more interested in what you think the path forward needs to be and simply raise the minimum wage does not seem to cut it as we must deal with the economic issues that will occur after the raise occurs

What is your problem with the posting of specific and relevant information regarding a topic at hand?

My path forward is based on the information I posted; by raising the minimum wage, the level of consumerism is immediately raised and an economy that is 70% consumer-driven REQUIRES CONSUMPTION OF GOODS AND SERVICES.

More consumerism = more profits = more jobs = more revenue from tax payers and business profit taxes = LESS LIABILITY ON TAXPAYERS AS THE NEED FOR UNEMPLOYMENT BENEFITS DROPS.

Henry Ford understood that if he paid his workers better wages, they'd be able to by his Fords!

Because the Wal-Marts and McDonalds of the country pay (by definition) poverty wages, that makes their employees food-stamp eligible which MEANS YOU AND I ARE SUBSIDIZING WAL-MART!

 
 
 
Chloe
Freshman Silent
link   Chloe    13 years ago

No one seems to be addressing or understanding the point I've made in this article and several others re wages. Wages are not arbitrarily assigned. Many of you are sounding like you think, "Oh, just give them more and don't be so cheap." That's not how it works. Wages are a calculated ratio. Wages go up when revenues do, not profits. Wages are tied to productivity. Inflation is a concern if it negatively affects revenues, and the labor force has to be adjusted. Also, when a union negotiates a pay raise - it's offset with something else as a loss - you don't balance the books by giving and not taking away from the other side of the sheet. In the case of Walmart, McDs and others, if they are forced to raise the wage, then I would guess they would have to adjust the hours the employees can work as an offset to meet productivity.

 
 
 
A. Macarthur
Professor Guide
link   A. Macarthur    13 years ago
Wages are based on a number of factors and employers typically will keep them as low as possible. When a business makes profits in the billions per year, pays its CEO millions and satisfies its shareholders, to pay its workers poverty level wages is unconscionable.

If one does not know the history of labor in America, including the exploitation of child labor, one cannot realistically address the wage disparities that continue to exist.

Aside from that, the stupidity of the greed of the oligarchical corporate structure not only screws the worker, it myopically screws itself by keeping money on the sidelines rather than putting more into an economy whereby even it would additionally prosper!
 
 
 
Chloe
Freshman Silent
link   Chloe    13 years ago

Unions changed history, so in many ways, history does not apply to the current environment.

Additionally, on a smaller scale, small business uses margins as well. When times are good, they increase profits, not to be greedy when not put back into the economy, but as a buffer for the bad times. That's how they stay in business. You are still skirting the point that wages are a calculated ratio to productivity, not a number thrown out to make someone happy. If wages are out of balance to revenues, then the labor force has to be reduced, or the hours worked reduced.

 
 
 
Swamijim sez
Freshman Silent
link   Swamijim sez    13 years ago

RiO--

Tnx and a tip of the Swami's turban for a nice article and attempting (yet again) to promote multiple POV and input on a significant topic. I admire your efforts to generate dialogue that moves past simplistic reactions from polarized positions (including mine, lol).

Gotta admit up front that I share FN1's pessimism on this. I'd agree that lifting the minimum wage in combo with tax reform would contribute to some economic progress, but my gut feeling is that meaningful changes in the tax structure are highly unlikely.

While I think his aggravation has resulted in reduced communication here, I can understand John Russell's frustration with regard to discussion about economics. I think/guess that JR's main point is that major corporations are entrenched in maintaining profit levels that work just fine for stockholders & upper management, but not necessarily for American society overalland/or the lower-income workers. When full-time or double part-time employees stillqualify for food stamps, HEAP and other programs, taxpayers are indeed 'subsidizing' Walmart, McD's etc. I appreciate your point about McD's 'franchise' structure, and yet that amounts to saying that franchise owners have to screw their employees because franchisers are getting screwed by corporate... We keep dancing around the issue that 'corporate citizens' are getting richer while 'meat citizens' are getting shafted, and 'corporate citizens' perceive themselves as 'entitled' to the highest possible profit margin regardless.

America now has (effectively) two economic structures, which are becoming increasingly separate. Multi-national / international corps and banking/finance entities are one picture of the economy, the one that shows up in the DOW, etc; SBO's and wage-earners are another perspective, often only tangentially related to the 'major economic indicators'. The 'economy' that's recoveringat this point is the upper-level economy, not the second-tier that's primarily inhabited by 'meat citizens'. I certainly agree w/ your statement above about 'encouraging corporate domestic development', but have difficulty seeing how that ecouragement will be fostered. We're in a situation now where corporate citizens effectively blackmail States into major tax breaks in exchange for doing anything that will produce new jobs, creating a 'race to the bottom' in an effort to increase employment while insuring that States are in the same position as the Fed-- taxing the meat citizens to subsidize the corps. As you stated above "...many businesses could simply absorb ... added costs but the reality of the world we live in is that the increased costs of doing business would be passed along as price increases on goods and services..."

SO... what might possibly be effective amounts to major tax overhaul, domestic businessdevelopment & education investment, combined withsome re-evaluation and/or management of corporate profit-margins. Oops, a stumble at the finish line-- anticipating 'humanitarian' considerations from corporate citizens.

I honestly hope someone will offer ideas or a perspective that will change my views, and I'm looking forward to others' responses to your dialogue here-- I really don't thrive on being a pessimist...

 
 
 
Chloe
Freshman Silent
link   Chloe    13 years ago

I think/guess that JR's main point is that major corporations are entrenched in maintaining profit levels that work just fine for stockholders & upper management, but not necessarily for American society overalland/or the lower-income workers.

That's exactly right. Why do people, corporations, partnerships, LLCs or whatever go into business in the first place? To make money for themselves, of course. Labor is exploited as a natural course or means to one's end. That's it. We have the choice to work for someone -using their calculations- or we have the choice to try and make it on or own. As I see it, we DO NOT have the right or authority, and should not -- to tell another how to run their business, pay their labor, or dictate their policies. If we don't like it -- then don't work there. ..Our nation was built on entrepreneurship, not on socialism or equality of personhood - but it was built on equality to be independent, to not be forced to be under someone else's rule dictating our 'choices' in life.

 
 
 
Robert in Ohio
Professor Guide
link   seeder  Robert in Ohio    13 years ago

A Mac

That is the first step replacing the professional politicians with public servants

 
 
 
Robert in Ohio
Professor Guide
link   seeder  Robert in Ohio    13 years ago

Chloe

I get what you meant, I spent nearly 20 years in HR and worked with finance year after year on those ratios and salary range calculations based on market conditions

 
 
 
Robert in Ohio
Professor Guide
link   seeder  Robert in Ohio    13 years ago

A Mac

You are right wages and salary ranges for positions are based on various factors and are calculated based on industry, business size, market conditions, education and experience requirements etc

 
 
 
Robert in Ohio
Professor Guide
link   seeder  Robert in Ohio    13 years ago

A Mac

Thank you that is what I wanted to read - your thoughts and ideas in addition to the cut and pasted data (which I read and thanked you for sharing)

The Ford example is oft used and mostly relevant and I thank you for bringing it up in this context.

I still disagree that simply raising the minimum wage is what needs to be done but your perspective is clear and shared by many

 
 
 
Robert in Ohio
Professor Guide
link   seeder  Robert in Ohio    13 years ago

Gunny

Good points

 
 
 
A. Macarthur
Professor Guide
link   A. Macarthur    13 years ago

history does not apply to the current environment.

Disagree,

History is the prologue.

If wages are out of balance to revenues, then the labor force has to be reduced, or the hours worked reduced.

We're talking the very opposite -- revenues are far outpacing the wages of the workers whose labor generates those revenues and profits. The disparity in wages does not reflect the productivity of the workers of Wal-Mart, McDonalds, etc..

When times are good

For businesses like Wal-Mart, times are the best ever.

Corporate Profits Hit Records Highs in Q3 2013

The BEA released corporate profits for Q3 2013 along with GDP and anyway you slice it, corporate profits are soaring to the stratosphere. Corporate profits after tax increased 2.8% from Q2 2013 to $1,871.7 billion. Corporate profits after tax are also up 5.8% from a year ago. Corporate profits as a percentage of GDP are at an all time high and after tax profit margins per unit are also soaring to the stratosphere.

 
 
 
Robert in Ohio
Professor Guide
link   seeder  Robert in Ohio    13 years ago

Swami

Always appreciate your perspective and feedback

Your pints on the difficult of making the needed changes are very, very true and that means it will be hard but in my view it will be worth it in the end

I understand what you say about JR's point but the fact that he thinks just raising the minimum wage saves the day is shortsighted, the whole point of the article is the fact that the minimum wage needs to be raised but that there are numerous other things that need to be done as well or the poor will remain the poor making a little more and paying a little more and really making no progress.

 
 
 
A. Macarthur
Professor Guide
link   A. Macarthur    13 years ago

Labor is exploited as a natural course or means to one's end. That's it.

No, that's not it! This is it.

5313_discussions.jpg

If we don't like it -- then don't work there. ..Our nation was built on entrepreneurship, not on socialism or equality of personhood

Do we have a right to expect businesses to pay women the same wages as they pay men for doing the same work? Is that socialistic?

 
 
 
Chloe
Freshman Silent
link   Chloe    13 years ago

The disparity in wages does not reflect the productivity of the workers of Wal-Mart, McDonalds, etc..

From an economics stance, totally disagree with that as a logical fallacy.

 
 
 
Chloe
Freshman Silent
link   Chloe    13 years ago

Thank you for commenting on that, Robert. My knowledge comes from a wide base of exposure, too. Smile.gif

 
 
 
Robert in Ohio
Professor Guide
link   seeder  Robert in Ohio    13 years ago

Chloe

The only way this problem will really be solved is if many ideas from many people are put together and broad plan to revitalize the middle class is devised.

SO long as it is merely a political talking point and not a priority of either party there will be lots of talk and not much action

 
 
 
Chloe
Freshman Silent
link   Chloe    13 years ago

AMac, oh please...we're not stupid. Show me one Walmart or McDs worker from today's environment that looks like that. Corporations and Franchises aren't stupid, either. They know what must be done to 'stay in business' - not just for the short-term, but for the long term.

I know you are a Union person. I am not -- totally against them. Most of my attitude comes from personal experience, but is also influenced by a deceased family member that was an executive with a non-union corporation. From experience, I watched my company go from having a good relationship with employees, yes...some favoritism, but that happens in the union environment as well, in an open-shop environment, to watching communication and good relationships dissolve under a closed-shop environment -- it was no longer about honesty and ethics - now it was about government, politics and making money for unions. I am not dumb. I see, as many do, the social disservices [forcing employees, when a company doesn't see them as an asset - as an example], and economic destruction that unions have caused in our nation. I think you are sending us off-topic from Robert's article premise.

 
 
 
A. Macarthur
Professor Guide
link   A. Macarthur    13 years ago

AMac, oh please...we're not stupid. Show me one Walmart or McDs worker from today's environment that looks like that.

Don't put words in my mouth and don't play "victim," we're having a discussion.

Poverty is poverty and exploitation of workers when the top earners are "earning" hundreds of times more than their labor, is not only greedy, it's detrimental to an economy.

Contrary to popular belief, the percentage of the population that directly encounters poverty is exceedingly high. My research indicates that nearly 40 percent of Americans between the ages of 25 and 60 will experience at least one year below the official poverty line during that period ($23,492 for a family of four), and 54 percent will spend a year in poverty or near poverty (below 150 percent of the poverty line).

Even more astounding, if we add in related conditions like welfare use, near-poverty and unemployment, four out of five Americans will encounter one or more of these events.

In addition, half of all American children will at some point during their childhood reside in a household that uses food stamps for a period of time.

Put simply, poverty is a mainstream event experienced by a majority of Americans. For most of us, the question is not whether we will experience poverty, but when.

...

Regarding,

I know you are a Union person. I am not -- totally against them. Most of my attitude comes from personal experience, but is also influenced by a deceased family member that was an executive with a non-union corporation.

Be specific please.

I think you are sending us off-topic from Robert's article premise.

The topic is the workplace and wages; I dislike intensely when a conversation logically evolves to related issues, when it's called "off-topic". If the workplace, fairness, working conditions, the economy and wage disparity are not somehow germane to discussion of the "minimum wage," I'd be interested in knowing specifically why not.

And you did not answer the equal pay for equal work question I asked.

No one called you dumb or any other disparaging name so don't try and make me defend what I haven't done because that's "sending us off-topic."

 
 
 
Chloe
Freshman Silent
link   Chloe    13 years ago

The only way this problem will really be solved

Robert, when you say "this problem," I assume you mean the value of minimum wage. The problem I see is not with the minimum wage, but with the attitude of the people involved. They are coming across like they don't understand incentive and stepping-stone positions...we [societies] 'need' those positions for motivation and to give value to positions of more responsibility. I don't see a problem to be solved...I see people that think they are 'entitled' to something that they are not.

Should every position, in any context, be paid as well as a position that carries more responsibility within a corporation or business? Or in other words, should every position in the stepping-stone environment, be considered a 'living-wage' position? I say no. Those positions are valued according to the revenues they bring in, as well as the responsibility required to perform them. If a union negotiates a higher wage for those positions, then there will be a trade-off somewhere else. What I have seen happen is that the corp won't afford as many of those positions, and will require their 'salaried' employees to add those labors to their expectations, maintaining productivity for the business, but not increasing pay for the salaried employee.

 
 
 
Robert in Ohio
Professor Guide
link   seeder  Robert in Ohio    13 years ago

A Mac

the workplace, fairness, working conditions, the economy and wage disparity are not somehow germane to discussion of the "minimum wage,"

All are germane to the conversation as is tax reform, business regulation, public/private partnerships, education and workforce training

A Mac and Chloe

Let us discuss the issues and not each other

Feedback from both of you is importantto the article and to me

 
 
 
Robert in Ohio
Professor Guide
link   seeder  Robert in Ohio    13 years ago

John

I don't think so, source of data please

Check this out

Average number of employees - 50 Part-time

 
 
 
A. Macarthur
Professor Guide
link   A. Macarthur    13 years ago

Those positions are valued according to the revenues they bring in, as well as the responsibility required to perform them.

Exactly; if a corporation profits in the billions year-after-year because a worker who flips hamburgers or bags fries comes to work on-time day-after day and does the very job that contributes to those billions, he's entitled to a living wage!

What I have seen happen is that the corp won't afford as many of those positions, and will require their 'salaried' employees to add those labors to their expectations, maintaining productivity for the business, but not increasing pay for the salaried employee.

The realities do not bear that out.

The Most Rigorous Research Shows Minimum Wage Increases Do Not Reduce Employment

The opinion of the economics profession on the impact of the minimum wage has shifted significantly over the past fifteen years. Today, the most rigorous research shows little evidence of job reductions from a higher minimum wage. Indicative is a 2013 survey by the University of Chicagos Booth School of Business in which leading economists agreed by a nearly 4 to 1 margin that the benefits of raising and indexing the minimum wage outweigh the costs.

This page reviews the most widely-cited and influential studies on the impact of minimum wage increases on employment, and examines the primary reasons why low-wage employers can afford higher wages today.

Doucouliagos-Chart.png

 
 
 
Robert in Ohio
Professor Guide
link   seeder  Robert in Ohio    13 years ago

Chloe

The real problem is the revitalization of the middle class, raising the minimum wage is merely part of the solution to that problem

Every position should be paid according to the prevailing market within the parameters of minimum wage and other business and economic conditions

 
 
 
Robert in Ohio
Professor Guide
link   seeder  Robert in Ohio    13 years ago

A Mac

Here is a differing view from a respected economist

Theres a misconception going around about the effect of the minimum wage on employmentnamely that there isnt one.

This past weekend, New York Times columnist and Nobel Prize winner Paul Krugman came right out and said it: hiking the minimum wage has little or no adverse effect on employment.
The current New Yorker sounds the same drumbeat. Writer Steve Coll lauded a 63% minimum wage increase in the SeaTac suburb of Seattle, Washington and said it would not have a significant impact on other job seekers or on total employment. He concedes there exists a theoretical level where increasing the minimum wage might impair job creation, but apparently this whopping increase isnt it. He goes on to cite a study, his best evidence, where pairs of neighboring counties with differing minimum pay found that higher wages had no adverse effect on restaurant jobs.
Theyre wrong. Or at least they might be.
The certainty suggested by both Coll and Krugman simply doesnt exist.
A survey of economists asked if a $9 federal minimum wage would make it noticeablyharder for low-skilled workers to find jobs. A third of the economists agreed, a third disagreed and about a quarter were uncertain.
Indeed, there are few issues more divisive among economists than the minimum wage. Yet even the economists who dont think the wage is a job-killer include an important caveat: small increases dont matter. Big ones, like what SeaTac just passed, is much larger than whats been studied and what the economists based their opinions on.
The disagreement among economists reflects that overwhelming evidence one way or another doesnt exist. Top scholars, arguing both sides, have written books and countless journal articles on employment and the minimum wage. A review of the literature has been well summarized by both left- and right-leaning commentators. But not surprising, each side tends to reach a different conclusion.
If our ultimate objective is alleviating poverty, perhaps asking whether a higher wage kills jobs isnt the right question. Recent research by Jon Meer and Jeremy West studied how many low-skill jobs were created under a higher minimum wage. They believe a minimum increase hinders low-skill job creationand that makes the poor worse off.
So where does this leave us? Theres no evidence yet about what a large increase would do to jobs. But considering the evidence is mixed on small increases, a large increase is a risky strategy. It is misleading to suggest otherwise and suggest any economic consensus exists on this issue.
...
Let the battling experts begin
That there are differing views from respected economists highlights the complexity of the issue
 
 
 
Swamijim sez
Freshman Silent
link   Swamijim sez    13 years ago

My hunch is that John would agree that simply raising the minimum wage wouldn't save the day all by itself (maybe I'm puttiing words in his mouth)-- my own frustration is that most of the time there are a couple topics that are implicitly 'off the table' in discussions about business: one is increased taxes for high-profit corps and another is the 'ethic' of max profit regardless of the impact on the society that made the corp possible in the first place.

You have at least acknowledged the need for some tax adjustment as part of economic growth & reforms, which I do appreciate. The speed with which another poster justifiescorporate profit at the expense of both the employees and the rest of society which effectively subsidizes keeping thoseworkers underpaid is a prime example of the sort of attitude that rouses my ire (and evidently others' as well). There's a certain irony in hearing people excuse corporate practices that result in employees being eligible for food stamps & other support in order to simplystay fed & warm, and in the next breath bitching about 'government handouts, 'socialism' and the evils of collective bargaining. (I'm not directing this little rant at you since it wasn't your statement.)

It seems ludicrous to me that anyone would insist that McD's (for example) makes millions while paying the rank & file so meagerly that the workers can't afford to eat there...

 
 
 
A. Macarthur
Professor Guide
link   A. Macarthur    13 years ago

RIO,

I read that earlier today.

Until the minimum wage is increased and done so in such a way as to reflect the cost-of-living area-by-area, we won't know for certain.

I like to ask a question about raising the minimum wage in a different way, namely

"What if there was a sudden and significant infusion of spending money into our economy?"

I'd be interested to see how the question is answered when asked in that way.

 
 
 
Robert in Ohio
Professor Guide
link   seeder  Robert in Ohio    13 years ago

A Mac

I thinkthe significancedepends on where the sudden infusion comes from and how sustainable it is

 
 
 
Chloe
Freshman Silent
link   Chloe    13 years ago

Don't put words in my mouth and don't play "victim," we're having a discussion.

I didn't put words in your mouth; not sure how you come to that conclusion, and I'm not playing a victim--don't know how you would have extrapolated that, either.

I never stated anyone called me dumb--that was implicative as to 'why' I don't buy into tactical language as an attempt to be persuasive towards one's rhetoric -- something I don't do to others, so I don't appreciate it when it's directed towards me. You bring up - "equal pay for equal work" -- I've never bought into that concept simply because that would always be a perspective. "Equal" would have to be quantified - not always possible, as sometimes intangible qualities dictate inequality. i.e. a certain 'persona' can force outcomes that would not happen if another gender was involved -- we are individuals as well - not robots of the same genders.

I agree with you when an author calls "off topic" when the conversation has evolved. To be fair, I brought that up only because the last time I was in one of Robert's discussions - the conversation did digress and I commented in sequence to the digression. Robert reminded us to get back with the topic, and I promised him that I wouldn't do that in the future....so, unions seemed like a digression, and I wanted to respect Robert. That's all. Smile.gif

We'll have to disagree on the premise point, AMac.

Just to note, I don't want to sound like a snooty person, and hope I am not being perceived that way by anyone...especially John.

When I started my first 40 hour a week job at minimum pay, I could not make ends meet. Would I have loved it if they would have paid my position more so that I could have afforded myself? Of course! I struggled---resorted to not eating very often, not affording much of anything else than my rent and bills. That didn't work out so well. The only way I could make ends meet on minimum wage was to have roommates and share expenses....and that wasn't a very quality life. So, I understand hard times. And, I understand the value of a position, and how it is determined in a corporate environment.

 
 
 
A. Macarthur
Professor Guide
link   A. Macarthur    13 years ago

We'll have to disagree on the premise point, AMac.

And we're still friends.

 
 
 
Chloe
Freshman Silent
link   Chloe    13 years ago

Is that someone, me, swami? I do have two Nephews that started as burger flippers at McDs, and didn't want to do that for very long. One used it as a part-time job through school, and another stayed, and educated himself to qualify for Management in that Franchise. I realize not everyone is motivated to move on, but I do think they used the minimum wage positions as they were intended to be used.

 
 
 
Robert in Ohio
Professor Guide
link   seeder  Robert in Ohio    13 years ago

Swami

Tax reform, higher minimum wage, better trained work force, regulation and incentives for domestic expansion and innovation are all parts of the puzzle that needs to be put together.

Many of the McD employees are paid by smaller business owners (franchises) without the deep pockets of the corporation so even that is not a cut and dried issue but everyone with skin n the game needs to be ready to contribute to the solution that is for sure.

 
 
 
Chloe
Freshman Silent
link   Chloe    13 years ago

The real problem is the revitalization of the middle class, raising the minimum wage is merely part of the solution to that problem

I agree with that, in addition to the issue of a growing class of working poor, trying to have a life on minimum wage, sometimes two or more jobs at minimum wage. I wish I saw a solution, considering opportunity seems to be withering.

Actually, I proposed a potential solution in a comment once, but I see no way that TPTB would ever let it happen.

The pulse of communities was always small business, but Big Box is changing their scope and the scope of the local economies. So, in that light, my economic 'solution' might not be effective.

To comment on it anyway, My understanding is that money is injected into the system by the FED via the commercial banks, they monetize and make loans, and the flow trickles down the ladder into local economies. The problem is, the value of the dollar started lesser at the time of injection, and by the time it reaches us, it's at an inflated value. The Wall St. banks were in a position to profit for themselves; had the FED started the injection from the local economies, allowing each not to profit just themselves, but to profit the 'whole' with business start-ups, more employees, improvements, etc., I would think that would "revitalize" the middle class.

I agree with your second paragraph, too.

 
 
 
Robert in Ohio
Professor Guide
link   seeder  Robert in Ohio    13 years ago

Chloe

Sometimes the powers that be in the government and in the private sector are the real impediments to progress in this and other areas of our society and economy

 
 
 
Chloe
Freshman Silent
link   Chloe    13 years ago

And we're still friends.

Always.

I know you respect and value the right to an opinion, as do I, and no matter what is said, nothing negates my regard for you as a fellow human being that shares many of the same values, wants and needs as I and others do.

I also know that through all of the heat, emotion and passion we all can feel about a topic - that we're just venting. Not one of us, or even a group of us, can change the political structure of government or business.

In that light...none of our opinions really matter. What's left is how we treat each otherSmile.gif .

 
 
 
A. Macarthur
Professor Guide
link   A. Macarthur    13 years ago

Chloe,

If we weren't 3000 away from one another, it would be fun to go out for coffee a day or two every week.

Peace.

 
 
 
Chloe
Freshman Silent
link   Chloe    13 years ago

Sometimes the powers that be in the government and in the private sector are the real impediments to progress in this and other areas of our society and economy

Yes they are. It's the 'Boom/bust' cycles, imo, by the FED causing the value of the dollar to drastically fluctuate, and then the domino effect from there, that hurts us...and then the debt to GDP, to consider, that could wipe us out.

 
 
 
Chloe
Freshman Silent
link   Chloe    13 years ago

If we weren't 3000 away from one another, it would be fun to go out for coffee a day or two every week.

Peace.

That's a very nice thought. Thank you, sir. Smile.gif

 
 
 
Robert in Ohio
Professor Guide
link   seeder  Robert in Ohio    13 years ago

A Mac and Chloe

My thanks to both of you for all of the feedback, the opinions and information.

The vigorous and aggressive debate with civility is why I enjoy NT

Thanks again

 
 
 
Chloe
Freshman Silent
link   Chloe    13 years ago

Robert,

Thank you for commenting on that. I agree. I'm also of similar thought as Bob Nelson, that rather than just wanting to stay in-line with site expectations, I want to respect an author's expectations for their comment section. I am so happy to see NT maintain the 'individual' perspective, instead of 'group' everything, that can be unfairly powerful.

Hope you have a good afternoon!

 
 

Who is online



JohnRussell


101 visitors