Thousands of protesters marched in Chinatown, Los Angeles, on June 30, 2012, to protest wages and working conditions at Wal-Mart
( Joe Klamar/AFP/GettyImages )
Anthony Goytia isnt protesting because he hates Wal-Mart.
Goytia has worked part-time stocking shelves on the overnight shift at store No. 2401, in Duarte, Calif., for a little over a year.
I actually do like my job. Its fast-paced, and time goes by quick, he said. But last year I made $12,000. Im a husband. I have four kids. Its not enough. Im living in poverty.
Goytia is a member of Organization United for Respect at Walmart (OUR Walmart), which is backed by the United Food and Commercial Workers union. He has taken part in several protests for better wages and working conditions at the store, including one in early November, when 54 people were arrested during protests at a new Wal-Mart store in Los Angeles.
Goytia willalso take part in widespread protests against Wal-Mart on Black Friday, the day after Thanksgiving, when stores across the country discount merchandise to entice holiday shoppers.
As retailers gear up for what they say will be a shopping season of unprecedented profits, activist groups and small-business organizations are hoping to capitalize on a year of public anger overlabor practices at retailers such as Wal-Mart.
Anger over Wal-Mart policies is nothing new. But analysts say that increasing attention to income inequality makes this years Black Friday a potential turning point in the low-wage-labor movement.
Some consumers, however, have already begun the wait in line for Black Friday sales. And it is unclear whether increased attention will translate into a change in consumer sentiment.
A controversial year for retailers
Wal-Mart is not the only corporation in the spotlight, but it is by far the biggest and this year proved an especially potent one for Wal-Mart controversy.
Read what problems retailers have faced :
Related;
It seem to me this is a lose lose situation. If WM starts paying its' people a living wage they will have to raise their prices causing them to lose their competitive edge and their customers. Either that or they will have to start selling cheap junk merchandise causing them to lose their competitive edge and their customers.
Of course they can stand firm and tell everybody to fuck off, which is what they will probably do.
Who would you rather see take the hit, the customers of the employees?
Jerry, I must admit my lack of understanding [saying it that way to start this on a less antagonistic basis] for this issue, why I generally avoid this discussion, but I'm interested in your thoughts. This:
Inequal to what/whom? If one works in a relatively cheap/low-price store, then one should expect low wages, yes? Conversely, if one works in a high-priced store, then one should expect a higher wage, yes?
Regardless of the profit ratios and margins of a company, it makes sense to me that labor and price of the goods would go hand-in-hand. The reason? Because profits can't be controlled/assumed, but the other two variables can be; a business needs that advantage to assure a future.
What are your thoughts?
The employees. Imo, they already sell cheap junk, why I never shop there.
I agree with that, jwc. A couple years ago when the Stock Market increased, and the media propaganda was wanting us to believe the economy had improved, it wasn't due to a healthier economy, but rather that businesses had cut labor forces.
It seems to be a conundrum to me, as Jerry also implied in his opening comment. If the price of labor is lesser, then a company will afford more employees; if the price of labor goes up, then the co. will cut their force and adjust the price of their goods to compensate. They will have to 'expect' more from each employee [overtime], and will have to 'reap' more from each customer. Unless a store has 'location' advantage, or 'specialty goods' advantage, I can see how they would want to be competitive by having lower-priced goods, and have lesser-paid employees and 'more' of them...especially part-time, so they don't have to pay out benefits.
Do I like that situation? No. But, I understand it and see it as 'right' in a sovereign nation. The answer would be to put natural pressure on them by not working or shopping there. But with a forced welfare state....it's hardly possible, when 'cheap' is what many seem to want. They expect to buy 'cheap' but work 'high-paid' -- it logically can't work that way.
Income inequality has existed in every modern society-- and probably always will.
Some well-meaning individuals-- even political movements-- have attempted to change that.Especially Communism and various forms of Socialism. But even in its hay-day, the USSR (to cite but one example) had tremendous income inequality.
There will always be income inequality because people are different.
Nice 'nutshell,' Krish.
Labor Relations Board OKs unions paying people to protest Walmart
National Labor Relations Board lawyers okayed a major union's practice of paying people to protest against Walmart in a legal memorandum earlier this month, the Washington Examiner reports.
The federal labor law enforcement agency said the practice of paying workers $50 apiece to join protests did not constitute unlawful coercion of employees.
In a Nov. 15 memorandum from the NLRB's general counsel office regarding the so-called Black Friday protests staged by United Food and Commercial Workers against the nonunion retailer last year, the NLRB lawyers determined that the UFCW's offer of $50 gift cards to anyone who showed up to protest was a non-excessive strike benefit.
I would like to see the billionaire owners of Walmart take the hit. THEY are the ones that are out of touch with reality-- and need to be thumped.
J4T.... I met a young man at a laundry mat a couple of years ago. My heating element had gone bad in my dryer and I carried some clothes I'd washed to the laundry mat and this fellow had been laid off from Bank of America.
We started talking. He had gotten a job with Wal-Mart in their accounting department. He told me a story of a girl he had talked to there who was working the check out line. He asked her how long she had been working there and she said 5 years. He said he asked her had she ever thought of trying to get a higher paying job with Wal-Mart and he said she immediately told him she didn't want to make any more because she would lose her benefits. He said he ran into situations like that more times than not since he had been working there.
Do you realize she would have to be paid at least $15 an hour just to come close to the value of her benefits and she would have to work either more or get paid more in order to accomplish that?
I can agree with you Wal-Mart isn't a high paying job, but if you aren't aware of situations like this or the amount of money it takes to make it more beneficial to actually earn enough to come out better by working then we can come down on Wal-Mart, but this country is looking at a lot worse situation than low wages in the near future.
This is a gross oversimplification of what has happened . Quite clearly workers in some 3rd world counties have had great improvements in their lives while those in the 1st world have seen the opposite .
BTW the communist phrase "workers of the world " makes it sound as if they were a united front . But they never showed signs of any global union ...
ACK! I am not dispassionate nor a Libertarian, as I have explained to you more than once.
I know why you try to 'personalize' these discussions - it's a tactic hoping to undermine reasoning by attacking character values [as you disingenuously perceive them] of others hoping they will go into emotional override.
People that argue for higher-wages in jobs that require no skills other than the physical ability to stock shelves never use any logic - just self-interested emotion.
Those jobs were never designed to be 30 year employment [which seem to be disappearing--why the need, today, to keep changing], with benefits and pensions, etc....why many employers don't hire full-time for those positions. A burger-flipper wasn't meant for long-term employment, either. Just because an employee might 'wish' they were paid the same as someone with skills -- should never mean a company should have to pay them more than they are 'worth' to their business -- in other words - easily replaced. Conversely, it's common knowledge that a CEO is paid what they are 'worth' to the company -- not strictly based on their schooling and experience that could be equal to someone else with those same experiences. It makes sense to me that Corporations would put their money into their most valuable and less abundant resources.
I'm not "treating people" any particular way -- I'm being sensible and pragmatic.
I'm not wealthy by my definition, and I don't judge people by their 'worth' to me - I'm a dime a dozen and no better than anyone else; but that doesn't mean a Corporation or Business needs to have human traits and use emotionalism in running their industry.
The only thing people have in common is our species, and we should have equal humane treatment, e.g. no slavery or used as animals. As for aptitude and IQ and even physical capability - people are vastly different.
Badfish made a good point.
Dear Friend Jerry: If I recall correctly, you are also domiciled in Upstate NY, correct?
If so, kindly email me., We should ge3t together. It would be my pleasure to meet you personally.
Peace and Abundant Blessings on this special good day.
Enoch.
1.) There would have to be an agreed definition of the word 'work.' 2.) There would have to be a universally agreed and assigned value or worth to a particular job [or perceived as a job]. But if there were universal pay assignments, then we would have lost our sovereignty, and I hope that day never comes.
Worth is generally based on what someone else is willing to pay. So, if a person mows lawns for 40 hours a week - regardless of what people are 'willing to pay and feel the labor is worth' - we should force society to pay a 'living wage' [whatever that means--I don't think everyone 'lives' the same, or wants the same]?...Likewise, someone waits tables in the local cafe and does other odds and ends [buses dishes, is the receptionist, maintains Restrooms, because business isn't prolific, and is granted 40 hours a week. And that person should be 'granted' a living wage, regardless of how that works out for the owner? ...Or someone that decides to spend 40 hours a week enjoying their hobby playing their musical instrument in bars and taverns, or singing or whatever ? Because the owner of those establishments agreed to expose them -- society had better make sure that those businesses payed a living wage?
The list of what people do with their lives and what the worth of that particular form of labor is to someone else would have to be disproportionate - not a standard, but relative to other variables.
Yes, unions do make a difference, but they're also balanced against inflation to which they help contribute, not ending in a better position, necessarily, at contract time - because of inflation. Also, all unions aren't as greedy, and it doesn't always work out as one might expect. Additionally, some small businesses and even large corporations [relative validated] function very well without unions, with happy employees. Obviously, Walmart isn't one of them. So now we're getting back to my underlying point; if one isn't happy or feeling like they are being paid what they are worth to that Company... then move on.
"Artificially suppressed " ? Not at all . It is just market forces following immutable laws . In the same year this country was born someone named Adam Smith wrote an important book on that very subject . It still applies today .
But I doubt :
1] you know what book that was
2] you have any interest in history
That's why I'm not gonna-botha to post the title ...
jwc --- Just my thoughts, but I think of your auto tech work as skilled; someone that didn't learn that on their own, would need training. I looked up the min. wage for that year. It was $2.10. You had a good wage to go with a job that carried responsibility. If you messed up, it could hurt the employer. My personal thought on wages and a basis for them should be not only the amount of skill required, but the amount of responsibility and the consequences of doing a poor job.
OTOH, stocking shelves is something anyone could do without a training course, and would have minimal impact on the customer, it seems.
All I want to do is pick up my mother's prescriptions and go to the grocery tomorrow, (Black Friday). I hope that I'll be able to do so.
I don't blame Walmart employees, and feel that those big fat billionaire Walmart owners should pay a living wage. Same for McDonalds, etc.
Tomorrow is going to be hard enough without having to battle protesters, too...
I think this Forbes article makes some good points, particularly about how "productivity" and higher wage go hand in hand, as well as the high risks involved in ending up with labor surpluses.
They don't allow copying, so I couldn't excerpt, but the last *4* paragraphs emphasize some of that, as well as making other good points re Walmart.
I do wish there was a way to optimize a safety net for these jobs. Yes, John, I am compassionate for those that feel the pressure of the current times [as do I], and see no other hope. And I *do not* agree with removing Food Stamps or the cards. But, if higher wages did lead to surplus employees due to not having increased productivity -- then the situation would be made worse when jobs are increasingly difficult to come by---what's better - a job or no job?
I don't think so Jerry. Having worked for WalMart in my youth and having been entrusted with a "telxon" I had first hand knowledge of the exact cost (production and transport) of what goods the store sold and in most cases the mark-up was well over 500% easily.
They could easily give better wages and benefits without raising prices but the Walton Family enjoys their extremely obscene profit margins.
Has it ever occurred to you that most employers are deliberately phasing out FULL-TIME jobs in lieu of cheaper part-time employees?
Whats Behind the Increase in Part-Time Work?
My advice to Anthony would be to continue looking for FT employment but in the meantime, fight for better wages and benefits for PT status.
Jerry
I started my own protest this morning when I pleaded with the wife to please not go to the mall today?
Hope you and yours had a great holiday
Which means that the American taxpayer is actually subsidizing Wal-Mart.
If Congress set the minimum wage at $15, people getting HEAP, SNAP and Child Care benefits, would be able to pay those expenses themselves, effectively causing the employer to provide the funds to pay those expenses instead of the taxpayer.
Of course the employees would end up with the same amount of expendable income, but the taxpayers would be able to get some relief giving them additional expendable income which would go back into the economy.
There is no way such a proposal would be passed by the Republicans, the Koch brothers would simply not allow such a thing.
(Btw, it'slaundromat, not laundry mat - j ust sayin'
)
It's reasonable to assume Anthony would like to work full time, but is one of the millions of Americans that can't find a full time job, can't fine a second part time job, and knows there is line of people waiting to take the part time job he has now if threatens to quit WM if they don't pay him more money.
Your correct Enoch. I live in the Warren County about 70 miles north of Albany, 20 miles NW of Lake George and 100 yards from Loon Lake. There is another NT member that lives fairly close to me, I proposed the same idea to them, but the did not respond and I can 't find correspondence we have going and I can't recall their name.
I'll email you and we'll exchange tel #s so we can discuss a possible meet.
Same for everybody. See this comment .
I was able to copy the last paragraph from the Forbes article by scrolling form the bottom up, (great find Chloe! Thank,s for the link) I think the lastparagraphsummarizestheissuein a nut shell.
Its important to highlight the plight of the working poor. At a time when food stamps are being cut and some on the right attempt to argue against the basic idea of a safety net it is useful to show what actual need looks like in this country, and that many who work hard still encounter real economic hardship. So by all means, lets talk about increasing the EITC , ( Earned Income Tax Credit ) making a better and more robust safety net, and ways to improve the welfare of low-income people in this country. But lets not pretend that a huge percentage of the context in which this story is being discussed isnt that it is Walmarts duty to raise the wages above the current market level. Im happy to talk about economic hardship and things to do about it, but lets not ignore the conversation most people are actually having and the bad ideas actually being proposed.
Thanks Robert, same to you and yours.
My wife went to a Black Friday sale 10 years ago, and I haven't seen her since.
I'd report her missing, but I'm afraid they'd find her and send her back.
Thanks, Jerry! I am so happy you were able to highlight that paragraph - I thought it made a good point also.
Bob Nelson also discussed the "social safety net," and I understand that -- even addressed the issue in an economics article and also in a comment on one of my own articles in 'why' we need to have income inequality [by country] to make world economics work - without that, the whole global system would likely fail.
I made a point of going and shopping there, and will continue to do so. didn't see any union hired non-wallmart employee "strikers" making their $50 though.
LOL...
She's been assimilated and preserved, Jerry. You'll see her again when you need more plastic storage containers.
She may be assimilated, but she's not all that well preserved.
And I've got plenty of plastic storage containers thank you.
A " Telxon " is nothing more than a price scanner. I would like you to explain to us exactly how a price scanner enabled you to determine the "exact cost" of a product, including production and transportation cost.
As a student of accounting, an ex-business owner and one time employee of WIS International , a service merchandising and inventory company that has Wal-mart as one of it's clients, I can assure you that no general merchandise retailer, be it Wal-Mart, or your local variety store, enjoys a a 500% markup. Jewelry stores, designer clothing and accessory shops, camera shops ... they have 500% markups, but then they have a very low volume of sales.
Large retail outlets such as Wal-Mart and K-Mart have a mark-up, after factoring in ALL the cost* between the manufacturer and the point-of-sale, struggle to maintain as much as a 1% markup. But then again, it's all a matter of sales volume.
*All the cost include, packaging, shipping, warehousing (a huge cost), inventory services, advertising, retail facilities, POS fixtures (counters and display racks), checkout counters, cash registers and the people to run them, lost, damaged and returned merchandise, accounts, bookkeepers, buyers, market researchers, security personnel, janitorial services, parking lot maintenance...... there's a lot more, but that's just off the top of my head.
I can go into the warehousing cost if you want me to, but I think you get the picture.