The Greatness of Presidents
These are the topline results of a YouGov/Economist survey of 1000 US adults interviewed October 26-28, 2013 on the greatness of Presidents.
The results show that Americans think JFK is one of the greatest Presidents since 1900, along with FDR and Reagan. The margin of error is 4.3%.
http://d25d2506sfb94s.cloudfront.net/cumulus_uploads/document/gjum88rmae/econTabReport.pdf

Presidents Clinton, Reagan, Kennedy, F Roosevelt and T Roosevelt are the top five.
To view the entire poll and related data
BadFish
I can always count on you being able to make me chuckle no matter the subject
Thanks
Have a great holiday
Gunny
I do not think that President Obama is the worst by any means and more importantly that is a determination for historians to make after he leaves office, in other words too early to tell.
I also disagree with President Clinton being on the worst side of the list, he has personal faults as we all do but he got a lot done while in office that benefited the nation.
Appreciate you sharing your perspective and hope you have a good turkey day
1000 random adults, basing their answers on what they actually know about past presidents. I can't think of a less meaningful venture. How shocking that the order ofbiggest "failures"goes Obama, Dubya, Nixon and Carter, with a wide margin to the next biggest failure.The information thatthese participants used tobase their answers could probably fit in a short paragraph - a mixture of what they retained from a high school report they had to do onsome president, and the one, if any, legacy orientedmemory about the others.
Mike
Too soon to issue a final pass or fail grade until at least a few years after a president leaves office and the effect of the presidency on the nation and its future
I would grade President Obama incomplete at this point but that is only my view of course
Thanks for the perspective and hope you have a great holiday
For being "totally transformed", it sure looks about the same as it did before he was elected. What aspect of your life is fundamentally different now?
Hal
Polls are a group of people being asked questions about which they have opinions (thus the nomenclature opinion poll) that are then collated into a summary
If you had been part of the polling pool your "opinion" would have been part of the aggregate result
Interesting that you have so much insight how bright a group of people you know nothing about are or are not. Or it could be just your opinion about their opinion
Egilman
All poll results are reflective of the participants' knowledge of the issue being polled.
Thanks for your perspective
well, perhaps the engineers don't have to worry about Obama's ears on rushmore now.
Sean
He gave us the space program, had the vision for civil rights and was taken too soon
He was also very charismatic which causes people to overlook any faults he may have had
John
I give him an incomplete and do not think he will be judged one of the worst or one of the best but I would say history will see him as above average when time has passed and actions and results are viewed objectively
Hal
Good point
Nothing has changed that much in my view either
Robert G
Now now
Play nice please
Reagan?
A P
Well at least you have an opinion about one president on the list
Thanks for sharing
Have a nice Thanksgiving
JoAnne
You might know this but there are a lot of presidents not on Mt Rushmore
History will judge President Obama and it is to early to say what that judgment will be
I have no idea how bright this group was, other than to say that if it is composedof an average cross section of American citizens, there are going to be plenty of participants who fit the mold I suggested. (think aboutJay Leno in Jaywalking) The results are somewhatindicative of that. I doubt that many of them base their analysis of Jimmy Carter on anything more than him being a former peanut farmer, and Nixon for being impeached and resigning his office .... ironically, for being involved with something that all presidential administrations do, his just got caught. Nowadays, wiretaps and bugs at that level are probably not a something that a POTUS has to worry about, since they will no doubt have access to a surveillance system so massive that finding out what anyone said on any given date is just a matter of leisurelydigging through an archive.
Hal
No argument with the points you make
The very same thing can be said about every group, polled on every subject by every polling organization
When the group consensus is not as we ourselves think we attribute it to the group not being knowledgeable enough about the subject being polled.
I am guilty of the same thoughts when I see some polls on subjects that "I think" I know a lot about ad cannot fathom why the polled group thinks otherwise
history? what party controls the public education system?
I thought he had something to do with resolving some missile crisis thingy too ...
JoAnne
You are not so shallow and uninformed to think that comment has any relevance to the point that history and contemporary supporters or detractors judge the effectiveness of a president
And the party that controls public education is the party that happens to be in the White House at any given point in time.
JoAnne
At long last an introspectivecomment
oops a typo, sorry about that
where it says
it should say
Hal
Obviously correct I was not trying to write his biography just giving a couple of examples but you are quite correct that was an important accomplishment as well
Kennedy muttering under his breath : " I did have sex with those women . It was my great hair ."
Hal
In that case, my somewhat snarky response was in error and I apologize
Hope you have a great turkey day
Petey
Just as I do not judge President Clinton's effectiveness by his philandering manner neither do I judge President Kennedy by his speculative/proven prowess with the ladies or other presidents by single successes or failures and in my view history doesn't either.
Have a great holiday
John
Thanks for the indepth, well thought out comment on the topic at hand
Hope you and yours have a great holiday
Egilman
You may get some blowback on this one
Hope you and yours are having a great Thanksgiving
Rather than discuss people's opinions on great or not great presidents I would prefer to see a discussion of what principles make for greatness and what detracts from it . But I expect I am alone in that preference ...
Egilman ,
If people had a clear idea of what is involved in creating greatness it might tend to reduce some of the partisan bickering . The performance of a president needs to be judged against the times he governed in . For example Reagan was the leader in a time of economic difficulties . If that is factored in to his results it might change the picture for those who are ignorant of that fact ... at least I hope itwould .
Another factor is that the results of an admin's actions often happen after he leaves office .
Have any presidents been former marines ?