Nuclear (Option) Fallout
The rules of the Senate have been changed and legislative process in the Congress upper chamber will never be the same again. Majority Leader Reid pushed the red button that had been avoided by previous leaders of the Senate majority in order to further a short term political agenda with what seems little concern for the long term and lasting effects of his action.
Thanks to Lisa Benson Townhall Cartoons for the graphic
http://townhall.com/political-cartoons/2013/11/22/113725
It is possible that the democrats will be in the majority in the Senate forever, but is unlikely and when the control of the chamber shifts the proverbial shoe will be on the other foot.
Thanks to Steve Kelley Townhall Cartoons for the graphic
http://townhall.com/political-cartoons/2013/11/22/113746
The democrats are in the majority and it is within the rules of the Senate to change the rules of the Senate and they have changed the rules of the Senate. It is time for everyone to accept that which they cannot change and quit bitching about it. I would expect the same acceptance when the majority changes rules in the House to suit political needs and also that there will be no angst when the democrats lose the majority in the Senate and this new rule remains in effect.
A respected Democrat made the following observation in 2005, when the then majority Republicans were considering changing the Senate rules in response to Democratic obstruction of nominees from President Bush
"I urge my Republican colleagues not to go through with changing these rules," he said on the Senate floor in 2005. "In the long run it is not a good result for either party. One day Democrats will be in the majority again and this rule change will be no fairer to a Republican minority than it is to a Democratic minority."
The speaker was President (then Senator) Obama and his words ring as true today as they did then.
What will the actual fallout (from the nuclear option) look like?
Senator McCain recently opined
"This changes everything, this changes everything," veteran GOP Sen. John McCain of Arizona told reporters. He blamed newer Democratic senators who never served as the minority party for pushing the issue, adding: "They succeeded and they will pay a very, very heavy price for it."
What might those consequences look like?
I wonder if this action will have a tangible effect on what gets done in the Senate. Will it foster a feeling of trust and a desire for the minority and the majority to work together? Will the minority leaders be more or less inclined to try and influence the leadership of the House to work with the opposition?
I wonder if the progress towards a budget deal will slow and the Republicans will be content to allow the sequestration cuts to continue in 2014. I am sure this change in the rules will be considered as they contemplate compromise and cooperation with the opposition party.
George Will opined about a possible dramatic outcome of this rules change, which while seeming remote at this point is indeed possible
While Democrats claim the new rule only applies to nominations and not Supreme Court picks or legislation conservative commentator George Will is among those who pointed out that theres no reason to think the majority rule wont be expanded to other issues in the Senate .
Theres no limiting principle in the principle theyre invoking, Will said on Special Report on Fox News on Thursday night. That is majorities should rule all the time.
According to Will, that means that Republicans could end up having the last laugh and using the nuclear option to repeal Obamacare:
And thats something that could help Republicans repeal Obamacare if they win the presidency in 2016, win the Senate and keep control of the House.
He continued: What this means is if in the spring of 2017 theres a Republican president, which there could be, the Republicans still hold the House, and they have 51 senators, they can repeal Obamacare with 51 votes. And Im not sure the people who did this today have thought this.
Is any of this potential fallout good for the country? I think not, but should any or all of it occur I am equally convinced that none on the left will attribute the cause of those consequences being Leader Reid going nuclear.
One thing we can be sure, it will be interesting if the majority in the Senate changes in 2014 and equally as interesting in the months between now and then.
One final thought from one of my favorite old movies War Games, in which the computer makes this determination about the nuclear option ..nuclear warfare is "a strange game" in which "the only winning move is not to play." the same may be true of the Senate nuclear option.

I have been following the discussions of the Senate rules change with interest, with a little apprehension, with some skepticism as to where it will lead and with some amusement as to the ways and words people will use to justify and praise it or to vilify it.
In any case, I am interested in what you folks think regardless of your position on the subject.
Try to be civil and discuss the issue and its ramifications for the future and f you can't do that I am still interested in your views. I type my articles in back and red white so red box rules don't work for me.
Other than the sections indicated as quotations, the rest of the article is my view of the matter and it is neither right or wrong but it is my opinion. Let's hear yours.
I reminded of the old saying, ''What goes around, comes around''...
I am not that sure that this is such a bad idea. Like all things this is a game...as you said. And I do believe that that the current gerrymandering that has happened, caused this. But what is good for the goose...
I think this is basically the death knell for the Senate as the world's greatest deliberative body. The trend towards turning the Senate into a smaller version of the House with very little protection for the minority party has been proceeding apace even before Reid went nuclear. As Will points out, there's no limiting principle to this evisceration of the filibuster. The remaining right to filibuster will simply be swept away when circumstances dictate.
No longer will the Senate force moderation of the more radical legislation. We can expect more hyper partisan bills like the ACA, where the party in power can essentially do whatever it wants so long as it has 51 votes in the Senate. Divided government is really the only thing that stands between the radicals of both sides being free to implement their agendas at this point.
Kavika
That is the point that Senator McCain was making in my view an I have heard a lot of others make the same pronouncement and also to opine that that is the reason that it has not been done before
Thanks for the perspective
Perrie
I agree the goose is always going to be happy with total control but the gander not so much
And the roles of goose and gander seem to change every few years and they could change again in 2014
I am not sure I understand how you see gerrymandering affecting the Senate though
Sean
Excellent perspective on the situation and I think that I see the future of the Senate in much the same way that you do and indeed think that this rules change will be expanded when it is politically expedient
Thanks for the feedback and your perspective on the matter
i am shocked at how few seem to realize the huge reprecussions of this action. it is not pandora's box as some pundits say, as in that story, hope remained. i am sure the rino's descretely winked as the executive directed the liberal controlled senate to begin the elimination of minority influence.
anyone who believesthat this will be limited to appointingjudges to thwart constitutional challenges to the obamatax is a fool.
this is only the beginning, it is precedent, and has been initiated by the liberal democrats.
mark my words, this is the start of replacing the consitional republic with national socialism...nothing less.
Isn't this change similar to what is already being done in the House ?
gerrymandering only influences the house.
JoAnne
Not exactly true as it also affects state elections as well
JoAnne
Will the effect expand? Probably
Is it the tipping point to the downfall of the republic? Absolutely not!
Petey
The minority power was a differentiator between the two chambers and it forced the Senate to be a more collaborative body where reasoned debate and compromise were the order of the day
But no more
Now the two chambers will eliminate the power and voice of the minority
Not being familiar with the history of the House I need to ask if they have done business that way for a very long time ...
i thought the discussion was about the US Senate
odd how the "news" goes on and on about how the gop is fillibustering everything obama wants, while on the other hand reporting the latest polls clearly stating less people trust obama, than trust him.
It is but theproblemof gerrymandering is not limited to the U.S. House of Representatives is the point, though I agreed that it was not an issue in the Senate
Egilman
Thanks for sharing your perspective
You make a number of good points about the future impact of this action which I agree with totally.
I do not think that the 17th amendment weakened the Senate and in fact I am more comfortable with Senators being elected rather than elected (appointed) by the state legislatures which are mostly caldrons of mismanagement themselves
JoAnne
Interesting factoid but not relevant to this discussion directly
Thanks for sharing it though
Petey
I am not a historian of the House or the government but I think that the answer to your question is YES, the House has functioned pretty much as it does today quite some time , though there are rules changes made in every session there have been none as drastic as this change in the Senate that I am aware of.
I got around to reading the Sunday paper a couple of hours ago and came across an article by Susan Estrich on the Senate rules change which had some interesting points
As I was perusing articles on this subject I ran across this graphic which seems to depict the narrow focus used when the rules change was made not thinking about future implications when the Republicans gain control of the Senate or the Democrats decide that it is politically expedient to change the rules further.
Thanks to Nate Beeler Cagle Post
Thanks Robert . I guess it's not surprising that the House would utilize more suppressive techniques merely because it is a much larger body and would tend to be more chaotic if they didn't .
Petey
I think the intent was that the larger organization, elected more locally would more broadly represent the views of more of the people and that natural coalitions would form on different legislative initiatives (not much lately)
That does seem to be what recent history has suggested . The really large changes to government have , in my experience come from the Dems .