Wealth Redistribution... It's very REAL!!!!
Conservatives often complain that taxes, welfare, and social safety-net programs like Medicare and Social Security are liberal efforts to "redistribute wealth." Well... fair enough... as a liberal I have to agree. But none of those things are intended to create absolute wealth equality across the board, or anything even remotely like the socialist welfare state conservatives assert is the liberal objective. Progressive taxes and social safety-net programs are simply an effort to slow down the very real wealth redistribution that is moving American wealth from the middle class to a very small segment of the extremely wealthy. Most Americans have no idea how unfairly distributed American wealth actually is. The following video illustrates this very well...

I will pop in from time to time to check on this article... but I'm kinda busy right now, so I won't necessarily be doing a lot of moderating. The video makes its point far better than I ever could... and it has references to its sources at the end of the video...
Until the tax code is fixed, this trend will continue. And that is not going to happen, since along with this dramatic income trend, comes the power to buy off the representatives that are suppose to help all of us, help only this one group.
I honestly don't blame the conservatives alone, Mal. But annoys me about this, is that they are trying to make is sound like the democrats are trying to make a welfare state or class war, for political fodder. In fact, both parties are the fault of this... with each side pointing their fingers at each other
I thought FOX was a more republican-based site.
I agree that both parties are to blame, but I don't think it does much good to point out the ultra rich and their party affiliation. What I would like to know is who is making campaign contributions to whom and why.
I would like a complete overhaul of the tax code, and a reset to the tax code of the 1970s. UGH!
Link.
Top All-Time Donors, 1989-2012
= Leans Dem/Repub (60%-69%)
= Strongly Dem/Repub (70%-89%)
= Solidly Dem/Repub (over 90%)
candidates or outside spending groups and PACs not affiliated with either party.
Mal's proposal for an NEW tax code...
RULE #1: This rule isimmutable. All other rules, along with this rule, rule #1, must be listed together and described in their entirety on one side of one 8.5 x 11 sheet of paper in 12 point type. Any rules which cannot be made to fit on said sheet of paper are not valid.
The issue of reforming the tax code could be about several things . It could be focused on redistribution or focused on jobs creation . I vote for the latter .
Thanks for making that point, John. I'll add my two bits...
I think it is fair to say that almost every politician is influenced by corporate money... Money can flow into politics MUCH too easily and if one side does it the other side has no choice but to follow suit or be overwhelmed. But suggesting that Democrats and Republicans are equally complicit is a false equivalency... pure BS. Look at what the Democrats have done in spite of whatever money they may have taken... The democrats created Social Security and Medicare... From the day those programs were started the Republicans have been trying to destroy those programs... The Democrats want to place sensible limits on corporate practices... The Republicans want to deregulate everything... create a "free market"... The free market has proven that if it has the freedom to tilt the playing field to its advantage, then it will do that without hesitation... usually very abusively. The "all politicians are bad big government" is, as you said John, a distraction... an effort to keep people from paying attention to the stated goals of the various parties. Actually, it is often the case with the Republicans that what they do is very different from what they have told us they want to do.
Thanks for the list, Dean.
In regards to those ... it seems the Dems are far more hypocritical .
That seems like a rather subjective statement for someone who is so fond of empirical data...
Not everything is easy to empiricise .
I have no doubt you have lots and lots of data, Sixpick...
Yes, the roles have been reversed many times... So... since you want some empirical data, how about this... (copying a comment I left on Chole's article)...
All of the presidents that preceded President Obama COMBINED have had 86 nominees filibustered. President Obama alone has had 82 of his nominees filibustered. That makes it pretty clear that the rule which was put in place to give a bit more power to the minority has been egregiously abused by the current minority.
Senator Mitch "Lucy" McConnell yanked the football away from Senator Harry "Charlie Brown" Reid one too many times.
If they had used their filibuster privilege responsibly, they would still have it to use today.
In 2006 the Democrats used there filibuster privilege as a minority party, and they were certainly upset at the prospect of having that privilege taken away when they wanted to use it... but the Republicans did not need to change that rule as they had threatened to do... because the Democrats used their their filibuster privilege responsibly.
And if you want a source for that info...
Officially, it came from the Congressional Research Service ... It was release by the Office of the Majority Leader...
More info here ...
Thanks, PJ! I don't think an actual list is available...
Good advice John! I admire your persistence... PJ's too... Right nowI just don't have as much patience as you two do... I even got duped into going off topic myself... *sigh*
Our current code is doing a fine job of helping kill the middle class. You can only tax people who make money, Petey. Job creation would help the over all economy, but not the average lives of the working and middle classes.
That depends on the state. NYS has a lux tax, and no tax periods for non lux items.
Wrong Six. In fact according to the Pew, it is independents that are the non party of the rich:
Nope and they like it that way.
The easier to hide behind...
Six,
Please. One could say the same thing for Cheney and Halliburton. Or the Bushes and their compound in Kennebunkport. This is one thing that the affluent in both parties agree on... keeping their wealth. That is why tax reform has always been at the bottom of list of things to do, with just token code changes that expire usually during the next dudes administration. I'm an accountant and I have seen this, since the 80's. That was when the middle class lost some of their biggest tax deductions, whole life insurance (which also served as a forced savings account), and interest on credit cards. This was the start of the big shift.
This is true. But so is this:
The fact is when it comes to Washington, the only ones they are concerned with are themselves.
A dog that lost his scent? Oh no!
Then it is just an opinion.
Good one!
[Mal bows down to PJ...]
Mal is so pleased to make your acquaintance PJ...
Actually PJ, I do remember infrastructure, and where before I was against it, I just recently read an article about somewhere in Scandinavia, that they taxed the oil companies, into paying for a new high tech rail system. Gotta say I loved that idea.
PJ,
I never said it was Obama's fault.....alone. He just never addressed it at all. And because he was so fixated on health care and the fiscal cliff, taxes just actually went up on the middle class.
And although it was through the love of our congress that this happened, if our prez had said something...anything... this might not have happened.
I am perplexed by this. I actually think that most of our conservative friends are very middle class. I think that is far more complex than just mine, mine, mine, as they have everything to lose.
I read the article and the comments and remember a couple of quotes on the subject, one of which was by William Boetcker "The Ten Cannots"
No reasonable person thinks that the income equality gap should be as wide as it is today, but there is wisdom in the list of cannots that should not be ignored
Bob,
Although I think that there is a bit of the "browning" of America involved, I actually don't think that it is as much as you think it is.
If I think back to the Clinton years, he was hounded from the moment he stepped into office. First YEARS of "Whitewater", and when that yielded nothing, his sex life was drawn into it.
I personally see it as nothing more than typical politicizing the opposite team. This actually helps neither team... or have you not all heard about the growing independents.... we would rather see action then political fighting.
It appears that some comments from Sixpick are missing ...
He must of self deleted.
There is truth in both what Robert and John have said. Which goes to show that everything should be in moderation.
That is not inevitable .
Every system exploits someone .
John
Competition between the classes and struggles to climb the "class ladder" are inevitable but the bumper sticker comment "class warfare" is pure rhetoric and hyperbole in my view
The point, which you seem to have missed, of the ten cannots is that tearing down one group to build the other is not the answer, but rather the lower earners must indeed be raised up and the higher earners need to help but not simply by giving up what they have.
John
Do you disagree with Petey's point that every socio-economic system exploits some group?
If so, which one?
This is true. But we don't have to except extreme versions ofcapitalismin a democratic society.
Football helmet too tight John ?
OK . The problem is :
How to overcome the influence of money in politics without discouraging capitalists from contributing to our economy .
By changing the tax code!
I hate the term "class war". Yes, income inequality is a very real thing and it needs to be addressed. But the term "class war", historically, calls for revolution, which I see as hardly necessary. Nothing that a third party couldn't help.
Certainly that is a valid issue BUT how do we accomplish that when the highly monied can affect the political process ? They will resist those changes .
I hope you are aware that you went off topic first . Your 1st reply to me made me the subject .
Since the topic is "wealth redistribution" my observation is on topic . Your obsessive focus prevents you from seeing that but not from getting defensive .
John
This is a typical non responsive comment from you.
Perrie
Exactly
But if one accepts that they cannot use the chant of class, warfare class warfare
I agree.
NYS has both regular sales tax and lux sales tax. We also have several periods during the year that non lux items don't get any sales tax.
During his administration he let a tax break for the middle class run out. Hence my link. He never addressed it... it just lapsed. That is on his watch. Who takes responsibility then?
And although I don't love Obama for a bunch of other reasons... I also don't hate him either. Frankly, I haven't liked a Prez since or before since Clinton.
Bob,
It's not a fence. I call each issue as I see them. I have never figured out why I have to belong to a team. And in fact, more and more Americans agree. But besides that point, I do believe we need a third party to stop that pendulum from swinging. I would like it to be a moderate party.. but I doubt I will ever get my way.
It is a shame that racism is alive in America. I must say that living in NY, I am not faced with overt racism, but I am not blind to it, either.
This is true, but there really is no other way. It was by legislation that ended the "robber barons". You can't count on SCOTUS, who thinks that corporations are individuals. I guess limitation of funds by PACS and other special interest groups.
This is true.... but Warren Buffet also does this:
If all of our billionaire did this, we wouldn't have a problem... or as much of one.
LOL Bob,
Most people's personality traits are cast in stone... including yours. Not that there is anything wrong with that...
And I luv ya anyway, too!