╌>

Senate guts filibuster power

  

Category:  News & Politics

Via:  chloe  •  13 years ago  •  93 comments

Senate guts filibuster power

The Senate voted Thursday to change its rules to prevent the minority party from filibustering any nominations other than nods to the Supreme Court.

The change was approved after Senate Majority Leader Harry Reid (D-Nev.) triggered the nuclear option, which allows a change to Senate rules by majority vote.

The 52-48 vote dramatically changes the rules of the Senate and limits the minority party's ability to prevent confirmation of presidential nominees. Sens. Carl Levin (Mich.), Mark Pryor (Ark.) and Joe Manchin (W.Va.) were the only Democrats to vote against Reid's rules change.

http://thehill.com/homenews/senate/191042-dems-reid-may-go-nuclear-thursday


Tags

jrDiscussion - desc
[]
 
Chloe
Freshman Silent
link   seeder  Chloe    13 years ago

51 votes now... Get things going again, but only in favor of the majority. I thought this wasn't a Democracy?

It will allow all three of President Obama's nominees to the D.C. Circuit Court of Appeals to go forward, as well as his nomination of Rep. Mel Watt (D-N.C.) to lead a housing regulatory agency.

Obama praised the action.

The gears of government have to work and the step that a majority of senators took today I think will help make those gears work just a little bit better, he said in a statement from the White House briefing room.

Reid said the change was necessary to get the Senate working again.

Its time to change the Senate before this institution becomes obsolete, Reid said on the Senate floor.

 
 
 
FLYNAVY1
Professor Quiet
link   FLYNAVY1    13 years ago

Republicans had the power and many opportunities to avoid this over the last four years. They abused the the right to make use of the filibuster as a governing tool, once they decided it was to become a political tool.

 
 
 
Chloe
Freshman Silent
link   seeder  Chloe    13 years ago

Thanks for commenting, J4T. I don't know if this info was already seeded today. I didn't notice it earlier, but that doesn't mean anything when I'm hours behind the east coast.

The Senate is majority Democrat, yes? How is that fair when the President and the Senate are aligned? My opinion is that they are doing it again -- changing one side of the equation, but not the other (relative to adding social programs, but not closing the borders to make it fair to the nation). I don't think of myself as Tea Party, so I'm not going down that road with my thoughts, but just taking a pragmatic view of what's likely to happen now --- loss of representational fairness; tyranny of the majority so to speak. Wiki:

"The phrase "tyranny of the majority" was used by John Adams in 1788. [3] The phrase gained prominence after its appearance in 1835 in Democracy in America , by Alexis de Tocqueville , where it is the title of a section. [4] It was further popularised by John Stuart Mill , who cites Tocqueville, in On Liberty (1859). The Federalist Papers refer to the broad concept, as in Federalist 10 , first published in 1787, which speaks of "the superior force of an interested and overbearing majority."

Lord Acton also used this term, saying:

The one pervading evil of democracy is the tyranny of the majority, or rather of that party, not always the majority, that succeeds, by force or fraud, in carrying elections.

The History of Freedom in Antiquity , 1877 "
 
 
 
Chloe
Freshman Silent
link   seeder  Chloe    13 years ago

Thanks for your comments, PJ. Yes, I was aware that Filibuster was not part of the Constitution. No, I don't need 5th grade Civics class. I've had more conversations about Democracy, and that we are 'not' one in the full sense of the term.. on the Vine.. over the course of four years, than I care to remember. :) We are a Republic that uses democratic procedure.

A republic and a democracy are identical in every aspect except one. In a republic the sovereignty is in each individual person. In a democracy the sovereignty is in the group.

Republic. That form of government in which the powers of sovereignty are vested in the people and are exercised by the people, either directly, or through representatives chosen by the people, to whome those powers are specially delegated. [ NOTE: The word "people" may be either plural or singular. In a republic the group only has advisory powers; the sovereign individual is free to reject the majority group-think . USA/exception: if 100% of a jury convicts, then the individual loses sovereignty and is subject to group-think as in a democracy.]

Democracy. That form of government in which the sovereign power resides in and is exercised by the whole body of free citizens directly or indirectly through a system of representation, as distinguished from a monarchy, aristocracy, or oligarchy. [ NOTE: In a pure democracy, 51% beats 49%. In other words, the minority has no rights. The minority only has those privileges granted by the dictatorship of the majority.]

And....that's what I'm talking about.. this isn't a Democracy; what they are doing is unethical !

(No, I'm not officially Tea Party...but I am a Constitutionalist and believe in fair taxation.)

 
 
 
Chloe
Freshman Silent
link   seeder  Chloe    13 years ago

J4T,

I thought this chart and article was an interesting explanation on what happened to 'mess up' so to speak, filibustering:

The chart above, based on the work of political scientists Keith T. Poole of the University of Georgia and Howard Rosenthal of NYU , shows how both houses of Congress have changed. From the late 19th century through the first few years of the 20th, Congress was sharply polarized between the two parties. But from the 1920s through the 1970s, party lines blurred, in part because of the large number of Southern conservatives in the otherwise liberal Democratic Party.

PHOTOS: 2013's memorable political moments

Those Southern, white conservative Democrats shaped the Senate of the 20th century into a place that elaborately protected the rights of a legislative minority -- themselves. They used the minoritys power to block civil rights measures for decades. Over time, other groups in the Senate picked up the same strategy, using filibusters to block legislation or nominations they opposed.

But the Senates elaborate protections of minority rights survived in large part because party discipline in the Senate, indeed in Congress as a whole, was weak during that period.

The idea that a majority should be able to work its will was hard to enforce when the majority was a frequently shifting, bipartisan coalition that changed from issue to issue.

In more recent decades, as Southern whites shifted out of the Democratic party and northern social moderates deserted the GOP, the two parties have once again reached 19th century levels of polarization. The most liberal Republicans in Congress are several steps to the right of the most conservative Democrats. As a result, Congress has moved toward a parliamentary system characterized by near-lock-step party voting and deep, consistent ideological differences between the two parties.

...

Party polarization

 
 
 
FLYNAVY1
Professor Quiet
link   FLYNAVY1    13 years ago

The article itself also referenced that in any case the survival of the fillibuster was doomed in time. It looks as though that time has come.

 
 
 
Chloe
Freshman Silent
link   seeder  Chloe    13 years ago

True, FLY.

Just to note, I always thought it was a good measure for government, meaning if there was blockage - that it meant the system was working. However, it sounds like it always a political tool, as they mentioned in that article that in the past it was used to prevent minority rights.

It must not be the best 'check' tool, but I think we still need something.

 
 
 
FLYNAVY1
Professor Quiet
link   FLYNAVY1    13 years ago

In the rules of warfare it has always been true that the weaker opponent must choose it's battles well if it is to succeed. If you project this onto politics of which warfare is an extension of, the minority of late did not follow that advice, thus it will lose more because of it.

The constant "no's" by the right, even on things they once supported and championed led to this. Countless ex members of congress on the right have said that republicans have become to ridged and obstructionist in nature. Alan Greenspan has also recently said: "I've never seen it like this. Clearly the problem is within the Republican Party. If you make every issue uncompromisable, you cannot have laws."

 
 
 
Chloe
Freshman Silent
link   seeder  Chloe    13 years ago

Run-away Government. To aid Separation of Powers. To 'check' Enumerated Powers.

 
 
 
Chloe
Freshman Silent
link   seeder  Chloe    13 years ago

No worries, there will be more.

 
 
 
Chloe
Freshman Silent
link   seeder  Chloe    13 years ago

The President could step in....and doesn't when it works in his favor.

 
 
 
JoAnne Odel
Freshman Silent
link   JoAnne Odel    13 years ago

i posted this on a similar seed, but spent so much time on it, apologize but hope you will allow me to post here as well:

i caught some cspan yesterday, carl levin had the floor. no big fan of his since he wrote letters asking the irs to profile tea party, but on the seed he had some points. i understand he, manchin and pryor all voted against this new precedent in our senate. sen. levin spoke of the reprecussions, of opening the possiblity for this precedent to be sighted for SCOTUS appointments, and yes, for legislation. he also discussed something i was not aware of: that if the majority held firm, it would force the minority to do an actual, physical fillibuster (ala james steward/rand paul). he pointed out that there existed procedure to thwart opposition thru simply the threat of fillibuster, and other statesmanlike points.

when i see opeiniong like "If they win the presidency and the senate in the next three years they probably deserve to get their way in policy." it saddens me how few seem to grasp the gravity of opening pandora's box.

obviously this is only to remove the first hurdle to unconstitutional filings in the DC court against obamacare, but that is only one part of the problem with this decision.

consider the necessity of the separation of powers, and of the centuries where the minority interests tempered hurried decisions and law.

i had to this point been apposed to term limits for our senate, while promoting that restriction upon the representatives. today i have no choice but to consider both houses equal in need of guidence by limiting the time each member has to simply raid the treasury, at the expense of the nation.

i say i will not be pleased when the gop takes the executive and both houses, and uses this beginnings of a monarchy to its advantage. and we know this will now come. that there is now very little separation between the executive and our senate, should give every thinking citizen great pause. the short sighted interests of lesser minds will destroy this republic, if left to their own devices. i would in fact not be surprised if many in the establishment gop gave a descrete nod to their counterparts in the senate when this infection was being whispered.

when i hear taps today for a different matter, i will think instead of today possibly being the day not to remember the death of one man, but rather the death of our constitutional republic.

 
 
 
Chloe
Freshman Silent
link   seeder  Chloe    13 years ago

Thank you for bringing up the manipulation that goes on, like the House passing Acts that sit in the Senate....especially that affect budget control and debt ceiling increases...how convenient, but someone doesn't think that's Obstructionism. The House wanted to 'compromise' on Obamacoverage (not 'care'), but being the spoiled brat he is and having 'his' way at any cost, Obama refused to compromise on the forced coverages and mandates he wanted...Oh, but it's only the Republicans fault.

 
 
 
Chloe
Freshman Silent
link   seeder  Chloe    13 years ago

Thank you, JoAnne. Please don't ever feel the need to apologize for posting related information or opinions. It's appreciated.

I'm not sure I understand how a minority can implement a filibuster with this change. If they've made it so that they win with 'majority rule' (mob rule) at any oppression or disagreement from the minority -- then isn't that the 'end'? Aren't we now no different than the oppressive ME countries run by their controlling, cleric oligarchies??

 
 
 
Spikegary
Junior Quiet
link   Spikegary    13 years ago

Yeah I posted this up yesterday afternoon. What a bad idea this is.

 
 
 
Spikegary
Junior Quiet
link   Spikegary    13 years ago

As opposed ot the democrats that are doing their best to make illegal aliens citizens to receive that permanent voting block?

You paint with a very wide brush, PJ, but not neccessarily in an accurate way.

 
 
 
Chloe
Freshman Silent
link   seeder  Chloe    13 years ago

Oh, I wondered if anyone else had. Thank you for letting me know, Spike. I'm on the west coast so don't see the FP until later. Agreed on it being a bad idea. Laws must benefit the nation, not an oligarchy of the 'wealthiest' --whom the Senate represent. They might have used this as a 'tool' in the past and present, but without it, I see that we will have no alerts that will aid us to be wary. Career politicians are the absolute worst thing to have happened to this nation, and now they are wiping out the voice of the individual -- whom the Constitution was created to protect.

 
 
 
Chloe
Freshman Silent
link   seeder  Chloe    13 years ago

Let me try that statement again,

The President could step in....and doesn't when it works in his favor.

He doesn't step in to allow run-away government.

(that highlight of mine was in response to your saying you don't agree with the NSA - a President could intervene, but why would he when removing privacy and spying on his people [as well as abroad] is to his own advantage to implement censorship and control speech - in addition to circumvention of critical information.)

 
 
 
Chloe
Freshman Silent
link   seeder  Chloe    13 years ago

Congress is out of control - double entendre there. In both passing legislation, and in being overridden by an impatient and spoiled brat President, that if he doesn't get his way, he just pulls EOs or Privilege, as well as a corrupt Justice that legislates from the bench.

No, I am not going to spend hours playing the linky games.

Add all of those up and you get - lack of Separation of Powers and--- "Runaway Government."

That's all I care to further comment on the subject.

 
 
 
Chloe
Freshman Silent
link   seeder  Chloe    13 years ago

"Good or bad for the country" is not the subject, here.

What? You bet it is!!

Preventing the minority from filibustering was their objective -- that is very bad for the nation and the 'individual,' and goes against the premise of the Constitution.

 
 
 
Chloe
Freshman Silent
link   seeder  Chloe    13 years ago

Then there must be moral, intellectual and Constitutional comprehension involved, because I don't follow information from either of those two sources.

Obfuscating again, I see. Opposing the filibuster or allowing one isn't in the Constitution, but it [filibuster] utilizes moral principle in the same way -- protection of the individual.


If you are incapable of seeing that, then yes, let's break off now.

 
 
 
Aeonpax
Freshman Silent
link   Aeonpax    13 years ago

Excellent post PJ. Summed things up very exquisitely.

 
 
 
Chloe
Freshman Silent
link   seeder  Chloe    13 years ago

51 votes now.

How much clearer can it be made for you, PJ? Majority rules now! What don't you get? Majority rules is pure democracy! ..Mob rule.

 
 
 
Chloe
Freshman Silent
link   seeder  Chloe    13 years ago

Which is changing the point of contention in an attempt to dictate the terms of the debate by narrowing it to a situation favorable to your argument

Which is exactly the tactic he's been using on me all day long. I've always thought that people that intentionally 'divert and obfuscate' - not to discuss - but to dominate the discussion, should be penalized with a CoC violation.

 
 
 
Chloe
Freshman Silent
link   seeder  Chloe    13 years ago

It is unfortunate.

I wasn't going to show my cards...but...Grin.gif

I'm onto him. I've exchanged with him/her in the past under another name, and I think I know who he/she is.

I played along, even acted a little frustrated, to play the part.

Thanks, PJ.

 
 
 
Chloe
Freshman Silent
link   seeder  Chloe    13 years ago

Nice try, but no cigar!

The individual is protected under due process. We're talking about majority rule in Congress.

You really should stop obfuscating; your slip is showing. Grin.gif

 
 
 
Chloe
Freshman Silent
link   seeder  Chloe    13 years ago

Thanks, Mike. I replied to one of the comments somewhere without realizing it was spam.

 
 
 
Petey Coober
Freshman Silent
link   Petey Coober    13 years ago

The Republican Party is working furiously in all the Red States to limit the possibility of voting for all categories that usually vote Democratic.

OTOH , the Dems are working furiously to make illegal aliens into US citizens so they can include them on the voting rolls ... And unlike the Repubs they are far more likely to effect changes to the voting population .

 
 
 
Chloe
Freshman Silent
link   seeder  Chloe    13 years ago

I'm not sure what you've been talking about throughout -- but my point has always been 'majority rule' in Congress as a way to ignore the minority. That's 'mob rule'. From Wiki under Nuclear Option:

In most proposed variations of the nuclear option, the presiding officer of the Senate would rule that a simple majority vote is sufficient to end debate, and if the ruling were challenged, a majority would be required to overturn the ruling. This would mean, for example, that 51 Senators who favor a nomination could use their majority to uphold the presiding officer's ruling that only 51 votes are needed to end debate and proceed to a final vote, and once the 51 had voted to end debate, they would then have sufficient votes to confirm the nomination. This would end what had effectively become a 60-vote requirement for confirmation of an executive or judicial nominee, or the passage of legislation.

 
 
 
Chloe
Freshman Silent
link   seeder  Chloe    13 years ago

OTOH , the Dems are working furiously to make illegal aliens into US citizens so they can include them on the voting rolls ... And unlike the Repubs they are far more likely to effect changes to the voting population .

That is my belief, too, as well as many others.

 
 
 
Chloe
Freshman Silent
link   seeder  Chloe    13 years ago

PJ, that's silly...I don't speak in riddles or change my premise--the consistency has been there all along; you just intentionally use red herring or obfuscation to divert the point. I provided definitions from law notes of Democracy and Republic, with notation of what constitutes pure democracy, and I provided you with the definition of nuclear option. My premise [not words] has never changed--without a condition in Congress to block majority rules - we would have majority rule -- pure democracy in the form of mob rule. That's the way it adds up.

Yes, I knew who you were from the very start because of the rose...but I was playing it out with you. I don't like to show my cards...but as far I'm concerned, I won with nuclear option... so, I laid them on the table.

 
 
 
Chloe
Freshman Silent
link   seeder  Chloe    13 years ago

Oh c'mon, Bob, let's not play semantics games...I said Congress because the Senate is part of Congress...anyone following the discussion would know 'which' part of Congress was discussed in the article.

I quoted the definition of nuclear option for you, that explained how 51 votes are all that is needed in that example to end the debate, and once 51 had voted to end the debate, well...that's all she he wrote, folks! ..as my/the modified saying goes. Grin.gif

 
 
 
Petey Coober
Freshman Silent
link   Petey Coober    13 years ago

When 1 party starts the vote buying the other has to compete ...

 
 
 
Chloe
Freshman Silent
link   seeder  Chloe    13 years ago

That is not an adrenalin-charged mob.

How do you know...maybe you didn't see the Hot intern wearing hot pants, or see how many cups of coffee they had! Grin.gif (Seriously, I got your point.)

This is true: I truly didn't know anyone/group called out, "mob rule." I read that as part of the definition somewhere along the road years ago, and decided it makes the point quite well, so I sometimes use it.

As for wanting to keep it in the context of Filibuster...well, that's what the article is about, so...

I remember that discussion between you and BD from a long time ago on my NV Column (women and their memories - what can I say?!:). It was clear that the Block was preventing the Obama Admin from proceeding with all of the Legislation they wanted to put through at the time (but there was and still is a lot of back and forth--some sits in the Senate and some sits in the House--it's not all coming from the Reps, but I know you know that).

It is preventing the duly elected representatives of the people from doing the will of the people.

The House is 'the people,' yes? There are Dems there as well, unless you are speaking strictly of Mr. Boehner. I realize you think he is acting out of pressure from the TP, and maybe so, but I prefer to think he was acting according to his constituents (what? where's my tin foil hat logic? --oh, I see you're wearing it!), and following procedure as the voice of the People. ..I believe that was the "will of the people."

And the faithful go to online forums and repeat those Fox talking points...

Truly, I'm not a follower -- I even told JoAnne that one time, saying I'm a "sympathizer." I just happen to agree with two of their issues - the Constitution is our Bible, so to speak, and I want fair taxes. Another sympathizer issue - Libertarianism; I don't agree with the total philosophy, but I agree with gun rights and support 'individual' rights.

Just because I agree with 'parts' of both ideologies - does not make me either one.

__

I still think a Filibuster is a very necessary tool, because I agree with others that have said that this is going to create animosity and notch-up the level of anger amongst the people. It feels as though the wealthy Senate and President Obama just rubbed in our faces, "We can do whatever we want, and because our money gives us great power in Government, we will continue passing Legislation that works best for us, and we 'will' make you pay for it." ..And that doesn't feel very good.

 
 
 
Chloe
Freshman Silent
link   seeder  Chloe    13 years ago

PJ,

Just curious about this one question you asked the others:

Do you agree with me that the Tea Party's preventing the passage of immigration reform is deadly for the Reps down the line?

Why do 'you' think the TP and the Reps are against immigration reform?

I have my own thoughts, but then I don't align the Tea Party with either Koch & friends (yes, I know they accept financing from them), or with moderate Republicans. I thought it was based on 'principle' as the reason why. I'm interested in reading your reasoning.

 
 
 
Petey Coober
Freshman Silent
link   Petey Coober    13 years ago

Is that "buying votes" or is it "helping people"?

These terms are both political hot buttons . I have no idea what the limits of either of them is .
Helping some people could involve hurting other people . Give me something to work with here .

Buying votes doesn't necessarily preclude "helping people" . The converse might also be true .
But you guyz have fun !

 
 
 
Petey Coober
Freshman Silent
link   Petey Coober    13 years ago

I guess it was just a thoughtless drive-by . But in my defense the liberal term "helping people" makes me cringe . Let me know if you want more details about that ...Grin.gif

 
 
 
Chloe
Freshman Silent
link   seeder  Chloe    13 years ago

The "Hastert Rule".

Thank you for explaining that. Being "unofficial," gives me questions, but I'll reserve them for after I've read more about the rule.

Former Speaker (Dennis?) Hastert made an unofficial rule: never bring up a bill that does not have a majority of the majority. The result is that 26% of the House can block anything.

Interesting. Thank you for commenting on that, too. Also, the Immigration Reform Bill - wouldn't having all of those extra people on the dole be a burden, making the programs exceedingly more expensive for taxpayers? Why do you view the Bill as a good thing?

I presume you are interested in exchanging ideas.

Yes. We're the same in that regard - I like to understand why people think the way they do (and I have no idea why I'm so curious to know - it's not that I expect to change them; must be that I simply like to understand the 'why' of things).

You seem to be intelligent, even if you are not accustomed to focused conversation -- which is why we were all over the place. But still... in the end I think this exchange has been informative, for me at least.

LOL!...a sort of back-handed compliment. :) Thank you.

It's not that I don't ever want focused conversation with most; I do. But generally, only with those I feel aren't trying to back me into a corner - so I answer or respond to their comments when it's oppositional and diversionary commentary and then move on. Also, I felt I made the one and only point at the on-set - majority rule as a result of the nuclear option...it's plainly stated and I see it as nothing more can be said. It's done.

I felt you were trying to divert to get me to see filibustering as a bad thing, using the reasoning that it's all the House's fault. But, as I've already stated, I see it's both of their faults for not working out concessions. So, I felt there wasn't much more to say -- it wasn't that I felt unfocused.

You are probably correct on the Hummingbird. I don't like to get too righteous, nor too long-winded. Just like to speak my peace, let others speak theirs, and that's about it. Getting pushy, or ending with a frustrated attitude is not my desire or style, though I have ended with that feeling, but I try to avoid it. What difference does it make when we're not going to change another's values.

I always learn new things from you and have enjoyed discussions with you over the years, even when we don't agree.

 
 
 
Petey Coober
Freshman Silent
link   Petey Coober    13 years ago

Whenever a conservative says "both sides do it"... you can be sure that they're covering the fact that they know that their own side does "it" more.

This expression is likely difficult to support with examples . Since it uses the "Whenever" qualifier all it would take is one example to shoot down ...

 
 
 
MalamuteMan
Professor Silent
link   MalamuteMan    13 years ago

All of the presidents that preceded President Obama COMBINED have had 86 nominees filibustered. President Obama alone has had 82 of his nominees filibustered. That makes it pretty clear that the rule which was put in place to give a bit more power to the minority has been egregiously abused by the current minority.

Senator Mitch "Lucy" McConnell yanked the football away from Senator Harry "Charlie Brown" Reid one too many times.

If they had used their filibuster privilege responsibly, they would still have it to use today.

 
 
 
Petey Coober
Freshman Silent
link   Petey Coober    13 years ago

Do you have a source for those numbers ?

 
 
 
MalamuteMan
Professor Silent
link   MalamuteMan    13 years ago

Do you have a source for those numbers ?

I first heard about it last night on Rachel Maddow...It is pretty much all over the internet... Officially, it came from the Congressional Research Service ... It was release by the Office of the Majority Leader...

More info here ...

As the Office of the Majority Leader explains, according to the Congressional Research Service, "nearly half of all the filibusters waged on nominations in the history of the United States have been waged by Republicans under President Obama. In the history of the U.S., 168 nominees have been filibustered - with 82 occurring during the Obama administration. In the history of the U.S., 23 district court nominees have been filibustered - with 20 being Obama nominees."

pssst... Your punctuation style is a dead giveaway to your identity... :-)

 
 
 
ArkansasHermit
Freshman Silent
link   ArkansasHermit    13 years ago

Petey, that " 86 total with 82 being filibustered during Pres Obamas time", came from Harry Reed and it is a little miss leading because it didnt take into account that some of the nominees were blocked more than once.

The more accurate break down is even more damming of todays Republican parties overuse of the cloture option.

From PolitiFact:

"The most recent of the two documents, a CRS memo, said, "In brief, out of the 168 cloture motions ever filed (or reconsidered) on nominations, 82 (49 percent) were cloture motions on nominations made since 2009."

This means that the numbers in the graphic -- 82 presidential nominees blocked under Obama and 86 nominees blocked previously -- were described incorrectly. The figures actually represent the number of cloture attempts that had been made, not the people who were nominated .

This matters because some of the nominations resulted in multiple cloture efforts. By our calculation, there were actually 68 individual nominees blocked prior to Obama taking office and 79 (so far) during Obamas term, for a total of 147.

Reids point is actually a bit stronger using these revised numbers. Using these figures, blockages under Obama actually accounted for more than half of the total, not less than half.

Either way, it's disproportionate by historical standards."

 
 
 
Chloe
Freshman Silent
link   seeder  Chloe    13 years ago

PJ, Bob (Bob in his PJs:),

You have always had a way of adding heart & humanity to your thoughts in a more compelling manner than others, imo. I think it's because it's real--a different kind of real than basic caring; not used for effect, or Party promotion. Your words carried visions of people that weren't privileged, just looking for a start in life, something I identify with, too, but not in the same context or lifestyle. I understand their needs, but I also see the existing needs of the residing citizens. We already have people living here that fall through the cracks, but have similar levels of subsistence. It seems that a stratification also exists at the lower level, that no hopes of ever getting out. They might be those that only see hope in crime or drugs. Some say that's where it leads for the Latinos, as well. Also, when our Ancestors were starting over, they knew they either had to find a way to make it, or they went back. That makes more sense to me than having program assistance that gets manipulated, gamed. Then too, as you pointed out, some Latinos are paying into the system as well, so a generalization possibly isn't accurate in an overall view. I do like your reminder that we know people generally "go from poor conditions to good ones," that I would hope would truly be viewed as incentive, rather than entitlement (speaking out of another context - but I think that's not an easy achievement).

Nor is "taking jobs from real Americans" a serious problem. Our winter home is in Yuma, the "winter produce captial of America". Square mile after square mile of lettuce of all sorts. All the labor -- all of it -- is latino. Because it is hard. Literally "back-breaking", not because of heavy lifting but because of being bent over all the time. "Real Americans" don't want that kind of job.

Yes, and being bent over all of the time would seem to cause health problems, too. True, low pay and high pain isn't desired. We always had options, but I wonder if those are slowly dwindling away. Then too, it seems like technology is making head-way in that Industry. I do wonder if taking in a lot of workers/pickers could end up meaning there won't eventually be enough work in Ag -or- other Industries for an influx of people, due to Tech, leaving us with a worst case scenario in our nation -- 70% on welfare and only 30% at top level jobs -- no middle. I hope not.

I think that's part of the "immigration problem" in the US. Thinking about immigration leads to thinking about social stratification, and that makes people uncomfortable in a country "dedicated to the notion that all men are created equal".

You had me thinking with that one. I always thought that all men were created equal in a humanitarian perspective - not animals; should be 'treated' with equal respect as human beings. But I have never put that into a context of classism, which is a result of a complex set of circumstances. I agree; it's uncomfortable being reminded that opportunity isn't always equal.

 
 
 
Chloe
Freshman Silent
link   seeder  Chloe    13 years ago

Thank you, Bob. You made several good points re: Immigration and how it affects the host countries, yesterday and today.

As you point out, they come anyway, and it's better than what they had. You remind me of something once stated in a News report. I wouldn't say that I like the idea of out-sourcing, but it was pointed out that what American businesses were paying, was triple what they were earning for similar work in their own countries. There's some good goin' on with that bad. :) We sure wouldn't want to have to compete with those lower wages, yet it's good to realize there's a positive side to our loss. If only we could get business to lower the price when they go to sell the product here.

This is a problem. Latinos are not "real Americans", and cannot be "real Americans", regardless of their ctizenship. So either most Americans can get beyond the notion of "real American"... or there are going to be serious problems.

The funny thing (in the not-at-all-funny sense) is that by refusing "real American" status to latinos -- by isolating them -- we ensure that they will not want to assimilate.

I agree that this is not a simple problem. 1 in 6 is higher than I had realized, and the gap will continue to lessen.

What an excellent point that changing our view/definition of an "American" is now imperative. That's difficult for me too, because it's been apparent to me that a large part of our nation's problem is the lack of 'roots,' that create an American Culture, wanting to preserve the protections in our documents, that those before us fought so hard to give us freedom from the wealthy Aristocrats, property owners and slave-holders, as well as other liberties that other countries don't allow. When I say "roots" and "culture," I'm not implying genetics, but rather the genesis of our country, and why those original people came to this land. National Pride (not exceptional), appreciation, and a desire to want to maintain those strides. New people would have no reason to have pride and appreciation for what it took so they can enjoy the fruits of their labor...that, imo, we continue to lose with every 'choice' that is removed, today. Despite the passion, there is another new face in America that will struggle to be accepted, but with perseverance on their part and change on ours', they will find their place.

I understand your point that they are contributors to the social safety net. (This isn't meant as criticism as all, but an Ant population came to mind, with structure and built-in safety nets - stratification - I wonder if they have unions and strikes for equal time off or something:); carrying water would seem harder work than gathering food, too, and those poor hill diggers! ..lol )

Interesting on Germany and the Turks, and France and the North African Muslims... each with their own sets of issues. Good points to correlate putting it all in perspective. It's about change and acceptance, the common-good, respect for each other and compromise. I hope it all works out. Smile.gif

 
 
 
Chloe
Freshman Silent
link   seeder  Chloe    13 years ago

Bob, I lost my last "Reply" box...it must be around here somewhere!

Well, it has the other half of my comment in it...so, if my comment sounds a little 'whacked [off],' you know why.

I can see how the Arabs would have difficulty assimilating, along with the educational issue.

My wife and I are both avid tourists, so we've visited most of the three-star site in the Southwest over the llast few years. Did you know that the Spanish had settlements in "Arizona" in the 1540s -- sixty years before the first English colony, in Virginia?

That complicates the problem...

Wow, it sure would complicate the issue. No, I didn't know that, for sure - Synthesis that used to be on the Vine might have mentioned that when we were talking about the evolution of Christians that hasn't [and won't?] happened with Muslims.

You have mentioned in the past that you travelled extensively down there. Interesting country, but I had always guessed it would be scary being that close to the border. Must not be, or I doubt you'd still be there.

Thank you for the exquisite and informative chat! Have a good night [or day?]!

 
 
 
Sean Treacy
Professor Principal
link   Sean Treacy    13 years ago

Cloture motions are not the same thing as filibusters.

Per the Congressional Research Service:

lthough cloture affords the Senate a means for overcoming a filibuster,it is erroneous to assume that cases in which cloture is sought are always the same as those in which a filibuster occurs. Filibusters may occur without cloture being sought, andcloture may be sought when no filibuster is taking place. The reason is that cloture is sought by supporters of a matter, whereas filibusters are conducted by its opponents.

For [various] reasons [that the CRS report spells out],it would be a misuse of the following data, which identify nominations on which cloture was sought, to treat them as identifying nominations subjected to filibuster. [Pp. 2-3 (emphasis added).]

 
 
 
JoAnne Odel
Freshman Silent
link   JoAnne Odel    13 years ago

gerrymandering only effects the house

 
 
 
JoAnne Odel
Freshman Silent
link   JoAnne Odel    13 years ago

Obama has had a higher percentage of his circuit court nominees confirmed during his first term than Bush did. The CRS report notes that 71.4 percent of Obamas circuit court nominees were confirmed in his first term, compared with 67.3 percent in Bushs first term.

 
 

Who is online

CB
JohnRussell


126 visitors