A Forgivable Genocide (Part 1 - Historical background)
By Robert Nelson
Ottoman Middle East
To the victors go the spoils
Defeat in the Great War brought down the house of cards that was the Ottoman Empire. The victors, Great Britain and France, scrambled to gather up as much influence, oil, land and population as possible. At the time, European countries still held their world-wide empires, so they naturally considered their action in the Middle East to be a just another form of empire-building.
The Ottomans' admin istrative units (known as " sanjak " and named for the administrative seat) were ignored when the Allies drew their lines on their maps, just as ethnic groups and relief features had been ignored in Africa.
The land east of the Jordan River, Sanjak Kerak , ha d been ruled from Damascus under the Ottomans. Damascus was in the French sphere, so the British, who intended to control the region through the local sheiks with whom they had allied themselves against the Turks, needed a means of carving it loose.
They found a means in the "Palestine Mandate". The "mandates" were agreements among the Allies, confirmed by the League of Nations, for the administration of former Ottoman territories. The British "traded" the Golan Heights, which the French wanted as part of their "Syrian Mandate", for the land east of the Jordan River... or perhaps east of the Hejaz Railway, the limits being very unclear!
During the Great War, the British were most magnanimous! They were quick to distribute land to people they wanted as frien ds... land that they did not in fact control... land that was still part of the Ottoman Empire. Sometimes they were so magnanimous that they gave the same land to two different people! Or at least they were not very careful about the boundaries of their "g ifts", leaving a bit of overlap here and there between them.
In 1915, they promised land (McMahon-Hussein correspondence) to the Arabs... without actually defining its limits. The British specified areas that were not included... but did not specify what l and was included! In any case, this land was "somewhere" east of the Jordan.
Also during the war, the British promised a homeland to the Jews -- th e famous Balfour Declaration of 1917... which did not specify any boundaries, either! Balfour himself considered that the new country should "extend east of the Jordan but not include the Hejaz Railway".
| |
| British Palestine |
These two British promises are each so vague that they may... or may not... overlap geographically. They also may or may not overlap politically.
The Balfour Declaration included the phrase, "it being clearly understood that nothing shall be done which may prejudice the civil and relig ious rights of existing non-Jewish communities in Palestine"... without defining its meaning. At the time, displacing a few hundred thousand people would not have been considered unacceptable, if it was done humanely, and if living conditions on arrival we re as good as those left behind. The same sort of massive displacement was done all over Europe, to collect all of an ethnic group within its national boundaries. Quotes from Balfour seem to indicate that this was his presumption for Jews and Muslims in Pa lestine, but nothing was explicit, and certainly nothing was official.
In 1920, the British were afraid that their Arab allies from the Great War would attack the French in Damascus. The British felt they needed to find political solutions that would "calm " the Arabs. The Cairo Conference of March 1921 decided (among others) to give the land east of the Jordan to Abdullah ibn Hussein, while excluding that land from any eventual Jewish homeland... but not excluding it from the Muslim portion of the Balfour D eclaration...
Thus was created the Emirate of Transjordan.
Tags
Who is online
140 visitors

It's really important to understand the historical background to understand why were are where we are today.
Ah ... this series from NV . Excellent ! Raven , this is a 4 part series . You need to read the rest when it gets published ...
Raven,
You ain't seen nothing yet! I haven't read the series, but I have studied a fair amount about the early history of the region. The British and French involvement (and German, Russian and Turkish) reads like a how to manual for screwing up international politics. Many people think that the US is a master of such screw ups, but, we aren't even in the same league with those guys.
Although the article begins with the period during and after WWI, the causative factors actually began to take form as far back as the Napoleonic Wars, when both the British and French fought through the area and set up their allies in power. The article starts with the WWI period because that's when the missteps became more clearly defined.
The scholars, and the ambassadors from each country were usually experts in the country in which they were interested or to which they were assigned; and their reports were listened to by each Foreign Ministry. The problem was that, prior to WWI, the Ambassador to Egypt would be an expert on Egypt, while the Ambassador to Turkey would be an expert on Turkey. No one at the Foreign Ministries ever thought to coordinate all of that information on a regional basis. They thought in terms of single countries that just happened to be located next to each other.
I am completely befuddled as to the title of the seed. Exactly what genocide is being referred, and why would any genocide be forgivable?
Hi Mik,
You'll see why and the context that the series of articles has that name.
Fair enough Perrie.
In his original posting of this 4 part series, Bob Nelson posted some excellent maps that explained a lot-- hopefully someone can find them and re-post them here.
In the meantime, here is an excellent presentation that shows the history of the area from ancient times. (In is interesting to note when the first independent Jewish state appears in the area-- also when the first state of Palestine appears):
Really cool video Krish! Amazing how many times the land changed hands and by who.
Once again I highly recommend, to those interested in this topic, that you check out, bookmark and explore the best web site on the history of the Jewish/Arab conflict: . The essays go beyond the superficial. Following is a sample article from a sub-link of "Fact and Fantasy in the Middle East:".
British Plans against France, and against the Jews in 1915
France had to give up claim to Lebanon and Syria by the Arab Revolt's "right of conquest," & on her claim to Palestine by the Jews "right to a homeland" - both ruses to enhance British control
British policy in the Middle East was not confined to Palestine. Its purpose, though now a defeated anachronism, informs British attitudes even today. It had its genesis in a historic misrepresentation: the inflation, out of all relation to the reality, of the so-called Arab Revolt during the First World War. This hoax was part of the intricate manoeuvres of the great powers at the end of that war. It was at first directed against France.
Early in the First World War, after the defeat at Gallipoli, a group of senior British officials serving in the countries on the fringe of the Ottoman Empire -- in Egypt and the Sudan -- conceived the idea of bringing the vast Arab-speaking areas of the Ottoman Empire under British control after the war. In the words of the then Governor General of the Sudan, Sir Reginald Wingate, they envisaged "a federation of semi-independent Arab States under European guidance and supervision . . . owing spiritual allegiance to a single Arab primate, and looking to Great Britain as its patron and protector." 1
The early disaster to British arms in the Gallipoli Campaign in 1915 provided the impulse. The British government called on its agents with contacts in the Arab-speaking countries to make an effort to detach the Arabs from the Turks. The men on the spot in Cairo and Khartoum decided that Hussein ibn-Ali, Sherif of Mecca, Guardian of the Moslem Holy Places, a semi-autonomous chieftain in Hejaz (Arabia proper), was the suitable candidate for levering all the Arabs out of the Turkish war machine. While London was interested in immediate military relief, the Arabists in Cairo and Khartoum contrived to, steer and manipulate the relations with Hussein toward their own more grandiose schemes. Hussein asked a high price for his participation in liberating his people from Turkish rule, even at one stage threatening to fight on the side of the Turks. He demanded all the territory in Asia that had ever been in the Moslem Empire. He was, of course, employing the accepted Oriental gambit in a bout of bargaining: he asked for much more than he expected to get. Moreover the negotiators were warned from London that the British government had made other commitments in the area, concerning Palestine, Lebanon, and the Mosul area in Mesopotamia (Iraq). In return for the promise of liberation in his own territory and the gift of part of the other Arabic-speaking areas, together with vast sums of money (in gold) and considerable quantities of arms, Hussein launched his revolt, led in the field by his son Faisal.
British officer named Thomas Edward Lawrence "of Arabia"
Toward the end of the First World War, and increasingly after the war, it became common knowledge and part of the popular literature of the age that in the defeat of the Turks a specific and notable part was played by the Arab revolt and that its leaders had enjoyed the indispensable co-operation and advice of a brilliant young British officer named Thomas Edward Lawrence. This revolt, according to the account, began in Arabia, displacing the Turks, spread over into Syria, and reached a climax in the capture of Damascus. In the end, so the story ran, the promises to the Arabs were broken. The Arabs based their later vociferous propaganda -- and their claim to vast additions of territory, including Palestine -- on this account.
The major part of this story of the revolt was a fabrication, largely created in Lawrence's imagination. It grew and grew and was not exposed for many years. It suited the makers of British policy at the time so well that Lawrence, who was a yam-spinner of quite extraordinary proportions 2 was able to impose himself, and to be imposed, on the British public and on the world, as one of the great heroes and as one of the most brilliant brains of the First World War. Lawrence's monumental book on the subject, The Seven Pillars of Wisdom (of which Revolt in the Desert was an abridged popular edition), was published and publicised and widely accepted as authentic history. In fact, it was largely a work of fiction. On the basis of this fiction, however, the British government was able to initiate and pursue its predominant policy in the Middle East and fight for it in the international arena. Directed at first primarily against France, much of its momentum and later fury was concentrated against the Jewish restoration in Palestine. It was the Lawrence fiction that for many years provided the main propaganda ammunition for the Arabs.
The Lawrence legend was finally demolished in 1955 in a remarkable "biographical enquiry" by the British writer Richard Aldington. His findings on the political and military facts were based on an exhaustive study of all the available sources, especially Lawrences own copious writings and those he inspired and encouraged. They have been amplified and deepened by the research since made possible by the release of secret British documents of the period. It has consequently become fashionable in Britain today to write with contempt and denigration of Lawrence and to speculate in psychoanalytical overtones on the reasons for his aberrations.
Though the myth has been exploded, the exposure has not yet brought any recognition of the implications, historical and political, of the myth as a central pillar of British policy. The admission in Britain of the Lawrence myth is a confession of the tricking of the French after the First World War and of the falsehoods and fabrications employed to promote the betrayal of the British trust in Palestine and of Britain's undertakings to the Jewish people. That betrayal had far-reaching consequences in fostering and reinforcing the pan-Arab attack on the Jewish restoration, with all the resultant suffering and bloodshed that continue to this day.
More at:
Lots of the material in the eretzyisroel.com website is from two books I have read and recommend:
Battleground: Fact & Fantasy in Palestine by Samuel Katz
...
Get the updated 2002 edition.
and:
From Time Immemorial: The Origins of the Arab-Jewish Conflict over ... by Joan Peters (Feb 1, 2001)
...
EG,
Our forefathers quickly found that was not possible. Even the nature of our own war for independence, brought the Germans, Scots, and France. Then right into the Barbary wars. It is not possible to live in isolation, not then when it was easier and not now.
Pretty much.
Len,
People have to want to read all that. And while you have people arguing on your article about stuff they have little background on, look at how few have commented here.
Len, you mean well my friend but you are wasting your time. Those of us who know history and those who seek the truth can easily avail themselves of the tools in search of it. Then there are those who are willfully blind and will continue to spread their lies and distortions.
What I also find interesting is when an independent Palestinian state first appeared in the area.
As Perrie mentioned, its not possible to avoid "foreign entanglements". In WWII, for example, America wanted to stay out of it. At the time it seemed like it was taking place in distant places, and was none of our business. We didn't want to get involved, but when Japan attacked Pearl Harbour, we had no choice.
What war between Israel and Iran? I don't see no war between Israel and Iran.
Don't be silly . That's not why they are attacking .
US nuclear weapons to Israel ? You know that how exactly ?
So oil has no effect on your decisions then ? When Bush 1 attacked Iraq you would have been OK with not getting involved in the attack on Kuwait ?
Hmmm....
No one is pretending that Israel doesn't have nuclear weapons....
Nice red herring . Why don't you support your own statement that Israeli nukes are from the US ?
You call that silly ? Kowtowing to Arab demands can be dangerous ... and cowardly . They call Israel little Satan and the US big Satan . If Israel was to disappear the US would still be the big Satan and subject to attacks .
Israeli nukes were not developed with any help from the U.S.! (In fact, the U.S. strongly opposed giving any help to Israel in that regard. So they turned to Britain and France!)
Nelson's writings are alsonot exactly short. I introduced eretzyisroel.com because it is encyclopedic both as to topic and depth, but also because it details the double dealing and scheming of Britain; trying (and succeeding)to subvert France, mandating land for Zionist settlement with one hand, removing it with the other, appointing the outlawed Jerusalem Mufti (Arafat's uncle) who, with Britain's acquiescence,singlehandedly ran jihad against Jews from 1920 through WW-2, when hemet with, and supported,Hitler to encourage the Holocaust and the war against Britain. So it turned out that, what Britain did to the Jews, the Mufti ended up doing to Britain.
How many here know, for instance,that:
That was shortly before the Mufti came to power and murdered any and allArabswho were friendly to Zionists.