Atlas Shrugged Is A Book About Pride In One's Work, And The Success That Results
By Steve Simpson
Do fishermen enjoy Hemingways The Old Man and the Sea ? Do generals like Tolstoys War and Peace ? I have no idea, but Im reasonably sure no one looks to these novels for advice on how to catch fish or wage war. The purpose of a novel is not to provide concrete advice on particular tasks, but to present a vision of man and his place in the universe.
In Atlas Shrugged , Ayn Rand presents a vision of man that is unlike anything ever written. Rands ideal man is the visionary, the genius, the producer. Her foremost representatives of this ideal are businessmen, whom she portrays, at their best, as heroes, not villains; creators, not parasites.
Rands vision has inspired successful people from all walks of life for generations. They love the book, not because it tells them how to make better yoga clothing or run a better taxi service, but because it offers profound insights about the principles that lead to success (or failure) in any field, and it shows those principles playing out in the lives of the novels characters.
The book has been criticized often in the five decades since it was published. Most frustrating for those of us who love it are critiques that misunderstand its essential points and end up attacking straw men. Rand, they often say, believed that only the strong should survive or that a mans worth is measured by the size of his wallet. Writing in the Business Insider , Max Nisen does all this but adds a new twist. In Atlas Shrugged is Full of Terrible Business Advice , Nisen criticizes the book for not being a better version of the Seven Habits of Highly Effective People .
Of course, Atlas Shrugged isnt a business how-to manual. But it is full of powerful advice if youre willing to consider what Rand actually says. Here are some of the real lessons in the novel that make it a favorite of so many productive, successful people.
Take pride in your success.
Like so many critics of Atlas Shrugged , Nisen claims Rand conveyed that successful people are inherently superior to everyone else. But anyone who has read the novel knows it is filled with noble characters who achieve only modest financial success. Eddie Willers, friend and ally to railway magnate Dagny Taggart; Gwen Ives, industrialist Hank Reardens superlative secretary; Cherryl Brooks, the store clerk who tragically marries a villain thinking he is a hero; Jeff Allen, the proud tramp who stows away on a Taggart train and is hired by Dagny; even a young bureaucrat who is assigned to monitor Rearden Steel and ends up becoming Reardens ally. The heroes in the novel dont look down on these characters. They treat them as friends and allies. Clearly, Rand recognizes that moral character stems from the choices people make, not their wealth or status.
So Rand doesnt condemn anyone for failing to become rich and successful. But she does condemn those who despise others because they are rich and successful. The hallmark of the second-rater, she has one of her characters say, is resentment of another mans achievement. She spends much of the novel showing just how resentment of achievementwhich she called hatred of the good for being the goodis destroying society.
Was she right? Well, President Obama thinks that you didnt build that. We hear every day that we should despise and tax the 1% because they are wealthy. Evidence of the resentment of success is all around us. Ayn Rand saw that in 1957, when Atlas Shrugged was published. And she knew that this attitude could prevail only if the successful allowed it to, by feeling guilty for their achievements. Rands response was clear: take pride in any success youve earned and never apologize for it.
Pursue your own happiness and achieve it.
Another common criticism of Atlas Shrugged , which Nisen repeats, is that its characters are motivated by money alone. This is an odd claim about a novel that is filled with characters who love their work and continually strive to achieve more and more, often at great short-term cost. Hank Rearden spends ten years developing a new alloy. Dagny leaves a secure position at Taggart Transcontinental and works around the clock to develop a new railroad, the John Galt line. Is money important to these characters? Yes, of course, but making money is not their primary motive. Money, as Rand recognizes, is not an end in itself, but only a means. The endthe purpose of all that hard workis achieving happiness. And Rand believes that is possible. As her protagonist, John Galt, says, The world you desired can be won, it exists, it is real, it is possible, its yours.
Money is the product of virtue.
Speaking of money, critics also often misunderstand Ayn Rands view of it. In the novel, she gives that explanation to copper magnate Francisco dAnconia, who answers the claim that money is the root of all evil. Nisen picks out one paragraph where dAnconia says gold is an objective form of money because, unlike paper, it cannot be manipulated by government. Nisen cites a couple of articles that supposedly show the gold standard is bad, not good. They even have graphs. And he recommends that readers watch a video of Fed Chairman Ben Bernanke saying the same thing.
Certainly, if you are interested in all the debates about the gold standard, you can watch the governments chief money manipulator respond to the view that he shouldnt manipulate the money supply. After that, you might read the hundreds of books and articles on monetary policy from the last eight decades or so. Ayn Rand doesnt try to address all of that in Atlas Shrugged . There are no graphs in the novel.
Instead, Rand focuses on fundamental questions about money, just as she focuses on fundamental questions on every issue. She asks: what is money and what role does it play in our lives? She argues that it isnt the root of all evil, but the product of all the hard work and thought that sustains us. Money, as Rand says, is the creation of the best power within you, and your passkey to trade your effort for the effort of the best among men. If you value your mind, your work, and your life, Rand holds, then you will value money. And if government can control and devalue our money, then government can control and devalue our lives.
When have you ever heard an economist say that?
Trade is a virtue, but sacrifice is not.
Nisen says that the businessmen in Atlas Shrugged have contempt for their customers because in one scene, Hank Rearden says he would rather destroy his metal than sell it to anyone who demands that he produce it for them as his duty. But Rands point is that there is a big difference between trade, which is a virtue, and sacrifice, which is a vice. In fact, the heroes in the novel treat their real customersthose who want to trade with them, rather than take from themwith great respect. Rearden, for example, spends much of the novel figuring out how to produce enough of his metal to satisfy customers who are becoming more and more desperate for it as the economy collapses. But one of the primary points of the novel is that no one should work for their own destruction. Today, we see calls for businessmen to sacrifice more and more every day. Is that good business advice?
Government is a necessary good.
Finally, Rand does not treat government as a pure antagonist as Nisen and other critics claim, but as an essential institution that protects the rights on which individuals and businesses depend every day. Of course, Rand does illustrate the evil of a government that becomes a violator rather than a protector of rights. If you think she is wrong, look around. Is our ever-expanding government really the solution to what ails us today, or the problem?
The bottom line is that Atlas Shrugged isnt an economics text or a business how-to manual, its a brilliant novel of ideas that challenges conventional thinking on every major issue in lifenot just money, but work, family, politics, and even sex. It does contain great advice, just not the sort of advice that critics like Nisen prefer.
But if you want to see that, my advice is to go read it yourself.
Steve Simpson is the Director of Legal Studies at the Ayn Rand Institute.
Tags
Who is online
129 visitors

My advice is to wait until this comes out in comic book format then use it to start fires.
I use my copy as a door stop in the winter, and a beer coaster the rest of the year.
This was on our reading list for our senior year in high school. It added spice to the American Government class. Usually one out of the thirty kids in a class thought it was the way to go, and earned the verbal beat-down they received from the other twenty-nine.
A P
You advocate burning books, hum very interesting policy
You don't have to wait any longer Aeon.
Ayn Rand is the latest offering from Blue Waters Female Force series of comic books. Written by John Blundell, former director of the Institute for Economic Studies, it makes a good introduction for those unfamiliar withRandor her works. The publisher says:
You were fortunate to attend school prior to the creation of the Department of Education and the liberals systematic destruction of our education system. I suspect removing Atlas Shrugged from the curriculum was one of the first things they did in an attempt to dumb down the population for their political gain.
Barb btco
I nearly had my coffee in my laptop
You always make me laugh but that is quite a visual
What is the relationship between the pages of the book and the spicy foods?
Thanks for the laugh
Obviously Ayn Rand was inspired to write the books "Atlas Shrugged" as well as "The Fountainhead" like others who have been inspired for reasons many may not understand.
I think as a child growing up in Russia and living through the revolutions had an impact on her that motivated her to recognize the flaws in an imperial autocracy and communism she was able to recognize the two more than someone never living under those circumstances and conveyed the life changes in her two books that many of us can not relate to.
She left Russia (USSR) in 1926 to come to the USA. She saw the despondency encompassing her country growing up in it and living in it until she escaped from it in 1926. Having lived through the revolution of 1917 and seeing the changes coming about in her home country as it progressed and the trauma of having to leave in order to gain freedom had a profound effect on this young lady.
With this insight, this gifted novelist writer was able to transform her experiences and those of others into one of the most influential books of the 20th century, "Atlas Shrugged", even if it was inspired beyond the person she was.
She witnessed the transformation of her country from an imperial autocracy into a collective line of thinking promoted and forced upon the common people. She watched as the government as it transformed into what would become The Union of Soviet Socialist Republics or Soviet Union.
There are many people who lived their lives one way and at the same time are well known for books or artistry they left behind in spite of the mental or character disorders they may have suffered.
Many musicians have been great artist, but their lives were in shambles. That's why many of our greatest musicians who should be with us today are not. Mental problems or success they were unable to overcome destroyed them, but not the art they were able to produce or other accomplishments they had made in their lives.
Yuri Bezmenov an ex KGB agent said back in the 80's the USA was ripe for communism even at that time and the communists were amazed at the progress they had accomplished in such a short period of time.
He said they spent most of their efforts in infiltrating the system and it may take one, two or even three generations, but as long as they continued to do so when it was complete, you could carry a person and show them the gulags and they would be so brainwashed they would deny it ever occurred.
You know we're heading in the wrong direction when your biggest cheerleaders are socialist or communist and that has been the case for a number of years now. At this time we are nearing the completion of the desire to transform this country and that is why there is no longer a fear in actually saying so. As Alinsky said:
"From the moment the organizer enters a community he lives, dreams only one thing and that is to build the mass power base of what he calls the army. Until he has developed that mass power base, he confronts no major issues. Until he has those means and power instruments, his 'tactics' are very different from power tactics. Therefore, every move revolves around one central point: how many recruits will this bring into the organization, whether by means of local organization, churches, service groups, labor Unions, corner gangs, or as individuals." "Change come from power, and power comes from organization."
"The organizer's first job is to create the issues or problems,' and ' organizations must be based on many issues. 'The organizer 'must first rub raw the resentment of the people of the community, fan the latent hostilities of many of the people to the point of overt expression. He must search out controversy and issues, rather than avoid them, for unless there is controversy people are not concerned enough to act. An organizer must stir up dissatisfaction and discontent."
In Ayn Rand's book it is not the rich against the poor. It is about the government theft from the producers of this country. The producers are not by holding people down or building their wealth off the people's backs. It's the government who is doing that with their back room deals and their hunger for power over everyone including the producers.
It's about the despair in the common man's life totally caused by these criminal government officials who basically want to put everyone under their thumb by providing them with just enough to exist and removing their motivation to improve their lives.
Those favored by the government have been bought and paid for by the government and receive special deals and positions they aren't qualified for in order to fully implement total control over the people. Those who have not given into this are punished by the government and their aids in corruption.
In the end the producers escape the government and keep producing leaving everyone behind. With no producers the government fails and there is nothing but turmoil which is what we're looking at in our future if we don't start to understand and give the power back to the people where everyone has the power to prosper and the government is put in its place.
The book is a far cry from what the collective progressives want everyone to think. It is to their detriment for the people to have the ability to see the truth so they spread their propaganda and know most will not investigate it enough to really understand what they are doing to us. Some do it because they have been corrupted and some do it because of their ignorance.
Good summary Six ..
Thanks Petey. After reading it the first time, it opened my eyes, but I needed to read it a second time to really get the full impact of the overall theme of the book.
After doing so much research over the last few years I can say I recognize history is repeating itself.
At one time "Atlas Shrugged" was required reading, but you would probably receive an automatic failing grade these days if a professor were to see it in your book bag.
I've talked to many who have arrived in the last few years into this country. I always like to discuss a little political ideology with someone coming into this country and many times they tell me how Americans are blind to what is happening in this country today.
Some have said what they ran away from they recognize is spreading to this country and are really disappointed about it.
After the third time I think I really had it down. It's not an easy read. She really goes into colorful descriptions that paint a very good picture, but are cumbersome and 1000 pages of small print for these eyes can be difficult as well.
I separated the author from the book and just realize her environment compelled her to write it, but her success and determination became an open door for critics, especially Progressives who would rather she never wrote it in the first place.
Yes ... the reviewers did a very poor job .
And you appeal to socialistic concepts as the ultimate good . But I won't hold it against you !
I see several of you can't seem to separate the book from the author. It is rated as one of the top 3 philosophical novels of the 20th century.
Just because I think the book is of value doesn't mean I agree with everything about Ayn Rand. I can see growing up in Russia as a child, living through the 1917 revolution and the communist taking over the country and understand why she could have extreme feelings that none of us would agree with or even understand, but the underlying theme of the novel was the government in their corruptness punished the producers and provided no hope for the poor to ever become anything more than they already were.
I would say Ayn Rand was not a sane person. All of the notes you refer to are not long after she arrived here in the USA and like I said, I think she was inspired to write "Atlas Shrugged" and I can see the conditions she came from had an extreme effect on her.
The book itself was a very good book and rated #3 in philosophical books. NO I don't agree with Ayn Rand's total vision of the way it should be, but the main theme of the book was not about the people being leeches. It was about the corruption of the government to take control over the producers by punishing them for not abiding by their wishes as it is now.
But in saying that I can definitely see your point of view and it is a worthy one.
Atlas Shrugged Is A Book About Pride In One's Work, And The Success That Results
That is a dumb declaration it is simple minded and far from the truth.
Money is not necessarily the product of virtue.
The monies earned by a contract killer is not the product of virtue.
The monies earned by a corrupt politician is not the product of virtue.
The monies earned by a merchant of child pornography is not the product of virtue.
The monies earned by exploiting the labor of poor people including many children is not the product of virtue.... etc ... etc ...
Trade is not a virtue, trade is a generic transactional activity for profit, trade is just trade.
Virtue is a component of morality, trade is not about morality it is rather about profit; trade is just trade.
I haven't read the book, but from the sampling that I've seen in this article, it sounds like anarrow and simplistic distillation of bumper sticker slogans trying to pass as legitimate philosophical precepts.
From what I understand Ayn Rand believed that one should do for one's self with out depending on the government.
But correct me if I am wrong, didn't Ayn Rand receive help from Social Security in her later years?
OK . The examples you proceeded to give are not virtuous ones . But all of them depend on the larger economy for support ...
The basis for the US position in the world has been about promoting trade from its inception . The fact that you are not aware of that is but another example of your an-historical experience .
The colonies were against the UK when they tried to impose trade barriers on the colonies . It was the basis for the 1776 revolution . Later , when the US encountered Barbary pirates in the Mediterranean they fought a war to free up trade in that region . During the civil war the North fought to free up the trade for paid labor by freeing the slaves . The peace treaties after WW2 were also about restoring normalized trade instead of imposing punishing fines on Germany .
Bottom line : Learn some history before you keep showing your wide and deep ignorance ...
OK , my mistake . But you seem to think that appeals to self interest are the ultimate evil . I'm not sure what that says about your ideas on the good ...
As usual you feel the need to butt your butt-head into an ongoing conversation . This is not your thread to call anything off topic . Start your own silly-ass thread ...
Well ... maybe you don't know how but the examples of companies who do are numerous ...
OH so that's why !Soooo glad you got that figured out . /sarc
The examples during the historicaldevelopment of the basic US economy are many . They include the development of the ship building and railroad infrastructures , the telegraph and telephone communications , the broadcasting of radio & TV , the electrification of the country , the development of the automobile as the primary means of transportation . The list goes on & on . Have fun tearing these down [as you use these services every day] .
The one I was referring to was this one for rating. I thought it was #3 but it was #8 and as it is here people just don't agree.
I can see both sides of this debate in a way. I don't think people today can imagine what it was like growing up in Russia starting in 1905 when Ayn Rand was born and living under an Imperial Autocracy, living through the 1917 Revolution and the eventual take over by the Communist before she escaped to America in 1926. This made her only 21 years old when she left Russia.
The first year she arrived here in the USA is when she wrote the notes on William Hickman who committed the atrocity December 1927 on this 12 year old girl. Well all those notes Rescue posted were done at that time. Ayn Rand was a nobody and feeling very much alienated from anyone.
As you may be aware a person 21 may not feel anything like they do 10 years later. I'm sure Ayn Rand was terribly affected by her childhood and she really never got over it. She evidently was a hard woman, definitely not the kind of person you'd want for a grandmother. And in that book Rescue mentioned Ayn Rand actually wanted to use the character of William Hickman without the degeneracy. Although I feel you or I would just want to beat him to death and could not see any good in him.
I separated the author from the book. First of all she was an atheist and I'm not. I had to separate that before I even started reading it. I read it for the insight I may gain by doing so. And I did gain insight from it.
The main theme to me was as I've said the corrupt politicians and their corrupt friends living high while the poor suffered and then in addition to that trying to destroy the producers that were left in this country. And they were doing it one by one throughout the book.
I can find no redeeming reason why we have at least 50% of this country receiving more than they pay into the government. And it is not the corporations that have put them there. It has been and is the policies the corrupt politicians who have become muti-millionaires either during their time in office or since they've left.
Sorry a little ridiculous brightstarone. I wouldn't even bother reading the book if I were you. I can assure you would despise it.
Actually J4T, you may be correct in you assumption or recollection. Ayn Rand did not appear to be a very warm hearted person at all. But the book brought out the fight in a person who saw their county going down the tube from the corrupt politicians and their cohorts agendas.
You should dust off The Fountainhead and read it again. Howard Roark spent much of his early career struggling financially. Not because nobody would pay him for his talent but because he would not be a puppet to them in return for financial gain. He was willing to live poor rather than compromise his principles in return for money.
Dean,
I don't know what you are talking about. My daughters readAtlas Shrugged, as part of their Civics class and the Fountainhead in 12th grade English lit and they went to public school.
People have ethics. Corporations are business entities that are supposed to produce profit, for their boards and for their stock holders. They have no ethics other than to produce profit.
Six,
My mom was born in a gulag in Siberia,Russia during WWII. At the end of the war, they ended up in England, dirt poor. She was 7. They had no clothing or housing except for what the red cross gave them, and my grandparents went to work in a brush factory. 5 people lived in a one two room flat. My grandfather caught pigeons for dinner. So my mom understood the same life that Ayn Rand had.
When she married my dad and moved to this country, life was still hard. After my dad left the Navy, he worked for several aviation companies that went belly up. If it wasn't for the food stamps, we wouldn't have eaten. But I have a memory of my mom crying as she used those stamps. She couldn't get out of the store quick enough. It was then that I knew we were poor and that there was a shame that went along with that. I said something about it to my mom and she said, that is what happens when you are not in control of your own destiny. She eventually started a little shop and from that, she and my dad have everything that they have today. At the end of the day, after over 30 years with Grumman, they screwed my dad and forced him into retirement.
Her and my dad are now both very well off. More than most could hope for. But my mom never forgot being on the other end of the spectrum. She feels privileged to have achieved through "luck and hard work", for we all know that many work hard, but achieve not much. And she also says that it's just as easy to look down and see the suffering as it is to look up and be greedy. She is extremely charitable, humble and despises conspicuous consumption. It seems that Ayn and my mom took away a different message from their experiences.
Petey,
I think by focusing on that one line, you missed the the bigger picture. Yes, people came to this country to be prosperous and trade was part of that, as was land ownership and freedom of religion. But trade as a function is just for profit. It doesn't have a morality or ethics about it, per se, unless those who engage in it, do. So this phrase:
Is true. It doesn't make profit a dirty word, but it also doesn't make it virtuous.
I disagree Six. If someone is going to make commentary, one should have the basis to do so, even if they might end up despising it. Knowledge is a wonderful thing.
I agree.
Although I was never too fond of the idea that you are incapable of loving anyone else until you have met your own needs.
Sure its true from the POV of the individual trader . But from the POV of the entire market , nothing is more damaging than the destruction of free trade . Piracy is the antithesis of free trade and it brings about much damage not just to the bodies of the victims but to their souls .
Which is true, but also why it so unappealing. Two men may open the same shop and work the same long hours. One may do well, by timing, or location, or family help and the the other may do the same things and luck was not in their cards.
50% of all new business will fail in their first year.
I doubt her ideals would play any significant factor in the kind of person that succeeded. But it would make for a very cold, hard and selfish person.
I don't deny that EG, which is why I think all extremism is dangerous. But hate is hate, no matter what the excuse is.
I really see no difference in hate over wealth. Actually it is natural. Like being the favorite child. Look at what happened to Joseph in the bible. The wealth of his beautiful coat brought his brothers hate upon him.
Well no one would disagree about that.
BTW saw the movie Captain Phillips. It is interesting to see why this is currently happening.
"Atlas Shrugged" was NEVER on any of my reading lists in high school or college, although Niccol Machiavelli's "The Prince" was.
Sure, if that is what is what I implied, which I didn't. You inability to read and detect satire doesn't surprise me.
The school of economics is a sham and Blue Waters Female Forcecollection includes Hillary Clinton, Sarah Palin, Michelle Obama, and Caroline Kennedy. John Blundell has been involved in the creation and development of numerous free-market think tanks.
I'll pass...propaganda.
One of my dam locks broke and allowed me flow freely for a moment. Absolutely you are correct. Good or bad. That was my original argument, but it seems so many are already set in their beliefs as I was being in that comment that no matter what it will not make any difference.
For some one like Hank Rearden who worked years to come up with the formula to make his supreme steel and then have the government come along and tell him he had to give his formula to everyone else and forget the sacrifices he had made in accomplishing his task was not right.
That is a problem I saw in the book that people worked their tails off and then the government comes along and wants them to redistribute their rewards to everyone else who have done nothing to deserve these rewards.
Ayn Rand may have been a radical as it has been proven, but I separated the author from the book and see the people today with no motivation while others are working to high heaven trying to be successful and not be a burden on society and just when they really start to succeed the government comes down on them.
I know of one businessman in particular I'm very familiar with who started out with nothing, worked like a slave to grow the business and is constantly harassed by the government with new regulations and requirements that are obviously done to promote one or more of the lobbyist in Washington which is constantly costing him much more money just to continue his business.
Let me give you an example of such a situation:
You have a product or piece of equipment you put in a store. For every store you put this equipment in it may cost you over $3K, but you hope to recoup that cost in a year or two and start making a profit. In some stores you start to see a profit in 6 months, but in others you don't see a profit for a couple of years, and in others you really never see a profit, but you do it anyway because if you didn't you wouldn't get the opportunity to put it in one of the more profitable stores.
Just about the time you start leveling off and can start seeing a profit, a new regulation or guideline comes down the tube from Washington that makes most of your equipment obsolete and fines you if you don't buy a newer version that meets the requirement which is going to make no difference at all in the function of that equipment 98% of the time, but lobbyist in Washington want to promote the sales of their product which is your equipment since they've flooded the market and their sales are down.
So they get on of those asshole Congressmen to pass a bill with a sentence in there that says, Oh in addition to this bill we need to require all the equipment out in those stores only be 3.5 feet high now and if the existing ones in the store aren't changed out by a set time limit, the owner of the obsolete equipment faces a $2k or so fine and the business can be shut down for not abiding by the new regulations.
So the man who has worked his tail off, sacrificed, went in debt hoping to build a successful business has to turn around and spend thousands more dollars to comply with the new regulations only because the corrupt politicians and their lobbyist friends have come up with a way to increase their business off the backs of the fellow who followed the rules, spent the money and time to establish his business.
Well that's part of what I got out of the book. You can center you attention on Radical Rand or you can look a little deeper and see other things as well if you desire to do so.
How perceptive of you to notice.
Nice non-sequitur Petey
Again my hats of to ya, nice double talk,
your skill at going of topic is unmatched.
The real bottom line is that you are still pouting like a childish oaf;
from our previous back and fourths, and you are looking to get back at me with insults and dumb off topic comments that do not speak directly to the points that I made,
so that you can satisfy your childish need to get back at me.
Thus:
you did not contribute anything of substance, you just made a fool of yourself.
You're very sad.
I don't think what we are seeing today in this country is hate. I think it's frustration. We see a government that doesn't work. We see a shrinking middle class. Our dollar buys less and less, yet pay increases are about at 3% if that. It is hard to be content, when before now, every generation did better than the last, but that is no longer true.
Billy Joel said it well in "Allentown"
Well we're waiting here in Allentown
For the Pennsylvania we never found
For the promises our teachers gave
If we worked hard
If we behaved.
Every child had a pretty good shot
To get at least as far as their old man got.
but something happened on the way to that place
They threw an American flag in our face, oh oh oh.
In other words, it is perceived that you are unAmerican if you complain, yet, how can one not, if you were living in Allentown?
RD,
Stalin killed his own son....
But I agree about Ayn. She was a ego maniac.
OK , you're going to need to explain how that is a non-sequitur . Enlighten us oh great logician ...
That's pretty much what I expected of someone coming from a position of vast ignorance . You know nothing so you make personal attacks on those trying to teach . I won't make that mistake again . From now on I will admonish your stupid comments up front . Seriously , learn some history or STFU ... you sad fool . You are the member here who is most proud of his own ignorance . Disgraceful ...
Perrie ,
I agree .
Unfortunately not everyone wants to learn :
BF,
Nice try. But Billy Joel's personal life has nothing to do with his capacity to evaluate what the average guy feels. He came from a working class family in Hicksville. He would know.
A matter or perspective that can't be proved. But I will counter by saying that I was raised by a very self confident woman, who was called a bitch, since she played a mans game in business, by men, but never was she called an ego maniac.
As she should have... but you must have missed my post here:
She spoke out about a lot of other things that are far more troubling than herpositionon communism, which I happen to agree with her on.
I pretty much agree with you Robert.
Right back atcha you leftist dupe !
Aww shit you made my spit my beer out with that one.
Petey Coober, regarding reply:
OK Petey, I'll go slow so you can keep up.
The examples of profiteering with a depraved morality;such as the merchants of child pornography or people who gain wealth from the exploitation of workers and child labor ... etc, were speaking to the topic of conversation which was about the alleged virtue of making money according to the book of ~Saint Rand~
Your bogus response :
...was a non-sequitur that did not speak to my point and did not make sense because it was obviously off topic.
At least obvious to anyone with normal cognitive function, which seems to be your problem.
Yup that's the truth ... don't hate the messenger, just accept the reality.
Yeah you already stated your spurious opinion about my alleged vast ignorance. You're repeating yourself Petey, how interesting and original.
Oh I see you're a teacher.
I didn't know that, must be because of that vast ignorance that you were talking about Petey .
OH NO!!! .... PLEASE OH GREAT TEACHER Petey !
Don't admonish me up front, I won't be able to survive your upfront admonishments .... have mercy on me ... OH THE HUMANITY!!!
Temper, Temper Petey watch that potty mouth and personal insults, remember you're the great TEACHER and you should comport yourself with more dignity and self control.
Oops .... you're repeating yourself again Petey , like I said; how original and interesting.
Petey Coober, regarding reply to John:
Any participant has the right to comment on this website, our exchanges are not private, we are all on a public website Petey , please try and keep up will you.
I disagree completely, you cannot tell other participants in the news talkers community what they can or cannot say.
What is silly here is your childishly angry response to John, he was just telling you the truth, you're so angry Petey .
Really Petey , take a deep breath and calm down
Instead of getting hysterical with people who tell you the truth maybe youcould concentrate on growing up.
She wrote more than fiction. Everyone always talks about her fiction work but the nonfiction is where she really shows her intellect.
OK fine . You feel that greed is the ultimate evil . Don't go ducking your gestalt . You hate greed so much that you can't stop bitching about it . So now all you need to do is define the line between mere self interest and actual greed ...
I have never read the book, so I really can't comment on that. I did see the movie, starring a young Patricia Neal and Gary Cooper. But, that hardly counts. It's never been a book that I would choose to read, but rather one that would be on my "educational" reading list-- right up there with the Rise and Fall of the Roman Empire. 3 volumes of unpronounceable names, etc. I made it through one volume, and decided that my self-education needed to find something else.
This appears to be a lively article and discussion-- Bravo to you, Dean. I just don't know enough to offer an opinion. Take care!