Looking Left and Right for Answers – The Pursuit of Happiness
The Declaration of Independence tells us that Life, Liberty and the Pursuit of Happiness are unalienable rights that have been endowed to each citizen and the preamble to the Constitution informs us that the new nation (and the constitution) was created in order to promote the general Welfare, and secure the Blessings of Liberty to ourselves and our Posterity
The founding fathers laid the legislative framework within which our country has evolved and periodically struggled, suffered, flourished and triumphed over the past two hundred thirty seven years. As wise and forward looking as the founding fathers were in the creation of the constitution as the basis for how a government of the people and by the people would look and function, we are still interpreting their words and in many cases inferring what they meant by their words or extrapolating from those words to fit the constitution to twenty-first century reality.
There are as many interpretations of what the founding fathers meant in the documents fundamental to the beginnings and enduring legacy of our country as there are scholars, or would be scholars that read those documents and decide what it really meant in the eighteenth century and more importantly what it means now.
There are tomes of opinions and interpretations of what the founding fathers meant by their words in this documents so fundamental to our nation and our way of life written by constitutional law scholars, politicians and even documents written by the founding fathers themselves before, during and after the Constitution and the Declaration were written. And yet, still today there are vast differences of opinion on what the documents mean then and what they mean now and these differences are polarizing factors in the political free for all that has been common place in recent years.
I wish to discuss the most basic purposes of the federal government, using the Preamble to the Constitution and the opening sentence in the second paragraph of the Declaration of Independence as context.
We the People of the United States, in Order to form a more perfect Union, establish Justice, insure domestic Tranquility, provide for the common defense, promote the general Welfare, and secure the Blessings of Liberty to ourselves and our Posterity, do ordain and establish this Constitution for the United States of America.
We hold these truths to be self-evident, that all men are created equal, that they are endowed by their Creator with certain unalienable rights, that among these are Life, Liberty and the pursuit of Happiness.
I highlighted two passages which, in my view, are part of the polarizing differences between the right and the left in defining the role, responsibilities and powers of the federal government.
In the first passage it is stipulated that one of the reasons for forming the government is to promote the general welfare and in the second passage codifies every citizens right to the pursuit of happiness.
The verbiage and the interpretation of the words are both important in understanding the differing views of what the reach and involvement of the federal government should be in our society.
The passage from the Constitution states that the government will be responsible for promoting the public welfare, but this interpreted by some to mean that the government is responsible for providing and insuring the general welfare and by others as meaning that the government should promote an environment that allows for the general welfare to flourish.
The passage from the Declaration of Independence states that the pursuit of happiness is the right of every citizen and this is interpreted by some to mean that only the opportunity to pursue happiness (success) is guaranteed and the actual achievement remains an individual responsibility and not that of the government.
How are the interpretations of these passages relevant to issues facing the nation?
It is not hard to see how these basic concepts play into areas like Affirmative Action, Government Subsidies for Education, Government Subsidies for Housing, Social Safety Net programs, States Rights and other policy issues.
There is no argument that we, as citizens, have the right to the pursuit of happiness, but how much should the government be involved in that pursuit? Since the right to the pursuit of happiness is guaranteed for every citizen, if the government provides assistance in any area should it be provided to all citizens without regard to socio-economic situation?
The government is responsible for the promotion of the general welfare, but should there be limitations on what restrictions on penalties should be placed on one group in order to benefit other groups? Is there a distinct difference between the federal government promoting the general welfare and directly providing resources to specific groups of the society?
These are difficult questions, which spark passionate and aggressive positions and when the differences are highlighted while the common positions are downplayed or ignored little progress is made in addressing issues facing the society.
I do not pretend to have the answers to all of these questions (or even any of them), but is imperative that we the people come to common ground on these issues rather than continuing to make the distance between opposing positions wider and wider.
Tags
Who is online
93 visitors

The pursuit of happiness is a difficult journey, unique for each citizen.
Is it up to us to expend the bulk of the energy and effort in the pursuit of happiness.
I think so
What do you think?
flameaway
Thanks for the perspective - glad you enjoyed the article
Excellent cut and paste effort as well and useful information
Glad you could join the discussion and provide valuable insight
John
Perhaps some are doing better in their pursuit of happiness (so far as making money goes) than others
YOU are absolutely correct that those who make more should pay more in taxes
Nah . I do not want to expend anything to make Lindsey Lohan happier . The same applies to Paris Hilton ...
Not yet
The ruthless or those that try the hardest - different views of the same picture
John
Nice avatar
Never said it was, I merely said that some were perhaps trying harder in their pursuit of happiness
flameaway
Are you being disingenuous or obtuse?
One's pursuit of happiness is through intellectual effort (CEO) and the other's pursuit is through physical labor (laborer) and not directly comparable.
flameaway
I am sure that many find you cute, but to me your approach is merely annoying.
Your self absorbed arrogance in assuming to speak for anyone is not unexpected
You do very well below talking to yourself and I would prefer that you talk to yourself rather than to me
flameaway
If you read the line from the Declaration that I included in my article, citizens are not guaranteed success but rather the right to pursue happiness not actually a guarantee of achieving success or happiness.
Big difference
good article
unfortunate the founders could not have imagined how promoting the general welfare could later be interpreted.
You used the term "elitist" . I'm fairly sure that it does not apply to what you are trying to apply it to .
flameaway
I have stated my position, you disagree and I accept your disagreement as we are entitled to opposing opinions, perhaps you could accept my position for the same reason.
As to the difference between functions od the CEO and laborer, there is nothing to elaborate as the difference between intellectual, creative effort and physical effort is apparent.
flameaway
Financial success, educational success, social success all play into the pursuit of happiness and none of them are guaranteed merely the ability to apply yourself to pursue them is guaranteed.
Everyone pursues happiness differently so I do not see it as a matter of equally
"impasse"
Sounds good to me
You know guys.. Robert took a lot of time to write this article. You don't have to agree with it, but don't be disrespectful either. Debate, but don't denigrate.
Happiness is an internal state of being.
Many a poor person is happier than a rich one.
So what are we discussing? The assumption being that only money brings happiness.
There was a study back a few years ago by Princeton University. Apparently, about $75,000 brings you happiness.
The interesting thing about this study showed that anything after that amount didn't bring any more happiness.
But let's go back to the discussion at hand.
Not every person is born into the same position in life. It is far easier for a child of parents who are both professionals to achieve their goals, since they have access to things that no inner city child born to parents who work at Burger King has.
That being said, it isn't impossible, just less plausible. But this is a fact world wide.
Life isn't fair. Some nasty folks live on, while good ones die.
Poor can be living in the projects of NYC or poor can be living on the streets of India. I guarantee that the poor of India will view the poor of NYC as rich. It's all a matter of perspective and expectation.
So no, it isn't possible for all to pursue happiness equally, but they can pursue it none the less.
Perrie
Thanks very much for the feedback
You make a couple of excellent points but themost important and the truest is
Thanks for the feedback and the link to the study
egilman
And you make very clear the point of it all -
An unequivocal and unqualified yes! your are assured the right to pursue, and on that basis the right is the same for everyone.
There is no guarantee of success in the pursuit of happiness...
Thanks a lot for the feedback and the perspective
Well my idea is pretty simple. I believe it is my moral obligation to help those who can not help themselves and help those who can help themselves do so. I don't believe our forefathers intended for half the country to be receiving more than they were paying in to accomplish these things today.
....or the happiness of pursuit.
John,
I was looking at the question from a philosophical perspective. And yes I am well aware that that $75,000 is more than the median income right now, but my point was even having more than that, didn't bring any more happiness.
Of course, less than that, brings less happiness, for some.
So ware we talking now about income distribution. If we are, as a CPA, I would suggest to look at the tax code. One of our worse causes.
Then there is job creation. Just yesterday reported, that it's slow to recover and the jobs coming out are not quality jobs.
As a country we have economic times like this before. At the turn of the last century, "The Robber Barons". It isn't right, but it is. It's a by product of confines of our economic structure. We can chose to change that structure, but that we must do as a nation. But no where is it guaranteed by our government.
That being said, Ghandi said that, "The true measure of any society can be found by how it treats it's most vulnerable members". I guess we are not measuring up, if money is the measure of happiness.
A P
In the best of cases you have the latter while doing the former