Hospitals Fear Cuts in Aid for Care to Illegal Immigrants
President Obamas health care law is putting new strains on some of the nations most hard-pressed hospitals, by cutting aid they use to pay for emergency care for illegal immigrants, which they have long been required to provide.
The federal government has been spending $20 billion annually to reimburse these hospitals most in poor urban and rural areas for treating more than their share of the uninsured, including illegal immigrants. The health care law will eventually cut that money in half, based on the premise that fewer people will lack insurance after the law takes effect.
But the estimated 11 million people now living illegally in the United States are not covered by the health care law. Its sponsors, seeking to sidestep the contentious debate over immigration , excluded them from the laws benefits.
As a result, so-called safety-net hospitals said the cuts would deal a severe blow to their finances.
I know this is an older article but I believe is still pertinent to the issue at hand. This seed is NOT for bashing the ACA, but for discussing facts and possible solutions.
Tags
Who is online
100 visitors

My concern is that hospitals will close unless there is some sorta reimbursement to cover all the cost of providing care for patients who are uninsured and here illegally. If there is no safety net in place, hospital closures will have a domino effect, as uninsured patients will only move from a closedER to an open one and overburden that system.
Please tell me I'm wrong about this.
It's not, by any stretch, just illegal immigrants. It's folks like me. Here in a deep red state where medicaid will not expand I am still in that hole. Medicaid expansion would have lifted most of us into the system which provides preventive care and access to care outside those hospitals. Over time that would drastically reduce overall costs.
Anyone can surely understand it is less costly to treat a diabetic, or someone with high blood pressure or any number of undetectable impending issues before they become an emergency.
I'm guessing that the same lack of coverage will apply to US citizens who choose to not even pay the fine for PPACA .
Exactly so.
What I don't get is how the Fed expects hospitals to make it giving away what will amount to free care. It's a catastrophe in the making.
Did you just find out about this? It's been going on now...as well as I can make it out, nine years. If it wasn't "illegals" it was "blacks". Same difference to some people.
I'm not understanding your point Aeon.
Up to this point hospitals have been recieving some sorta reimbursement for the uninsured regardless of their status or color.
When hospitals were truly non-profit...like when the penguins, churches or fraternal organizations ran hospitals (before Reagan) funding for the poor was taken care of through any profits they made. Win-win...except for the "profiteers".
That aid will be replaced by medicaid expansion which will reduce overall costs. It is the states refusing expansion that will suffer.
More republican obstruction designed to force the failure of the ACA at the expense of the people most in need. A plan, incidently originated by the Heritage foundation, which they only turned their backs on in their determination to obstruct this president. They dragged themselves down the rabbit hole of obstruction and now refuse to come out.
Ok thanks.
Many non-profit hospitals went broke and closed precisely because they simply didn't have the funding. They made no profits because their patients were poor and had no money.
Even with medicaid expansion, many hospitals that serve poorer and more unisnured neighborhoods won't come close to breaking even. There are a lotta hospitals who's pateint base in the ER is populated by a large percentage of illegal immigrants who are uninsured. That funding will have to come from somewhere or the hospitals will simply go under.
Increase medicaid to cover it.
Susan you are absolutely correct but have faith I believe the Republican states who are holding out against 100 % government funding of Medicaid and I belies 85 percent after that drops to 80% in 2025. Cannot remember exactly as I read it yesterday and memory at my age is not my strong suit. The next election should likely be the death of the Republican party as we have known it. Between attacking womens rights and Continuing racism and War mongering protecting the use oftax payer money to send middle class jobs overseas will ring in the ears of voters and has pretty well sealed their fate. Hate and descension is all over the internet with Politicians from their party Governors and future Presidential canidates have recorded it for posperity.
Don't say it won't unlessyou have somefacts to back it up. My wife works for a large hospital group. Spreading smoke and bull is rather tiring.
That sounds good but illegal immigrants are not eligible for medicaid either except in some emergency situations (emergency surgeries and childbirth) and in many cases not until after 5 years of residency. And if we change those stipulations, what would keep our ER's country-wide from being completely crashed by those coming to America only because they can get some free health care and then go back home? I dunno, it seems all fucked-up to me.
NON profit does not mean you don't make money. They have many doctors associated with the hospitals who make a substancial wage guess thats a profit. They use money taken in to pay for repairs provide free clinics flu shots for the poor many services for the under privilaged but they make enough money to build hospitals but other hospitals its happening today and has been happening for a long time. Big hospitalsreplace little hositals that are outdated. Huge hospitals here currently are replacing three others all owned by the same company the old and the new.
Excuse me?!
I am doing neither of those things, please point to where I am. If I am wrong about a particular I will be the first to acknowledge it and I would appreciate the correction.I and my wife have combined 60 years of experience working in the medical field in a variety of situations and faciltities. I as a Lab tech and my wife as an RN. Tell me rmeR, what does your wife do that gives you the expertise to start railing on me for not knowing what I am talking, or attempting to claim that I am wantonly and purposefully spreading falsehood?
Medicaid Helps Hospitals Pay For Illegal Immigrants Care
Rising health care costs put focus on illegal immigrants
Larry,
Other than increased spending or leaving all uninsured people in the parking lot to die, do you have an alternative to offer?
No and I wish I did.
I live in a highly agricultural area and have had the opportunity to befriend a couple of illeagals over the years. Both of my children are part Indian and part Mexican, their Mexican biological father coming to the US originally illegaly. I have a heart for people in need and understand that America as the "Great Melting Pot" is part-and-parcel of who we claim and aim to be.
I don't blame them one bit for wanting to be here and anybody I know personally would most likely take the same road to America that many of these illegals have taken. I also firmly believe in Universal health care.
What I do not believe in are politicians in DC that play political games with the lives of folks and their families. The entire ACA debate debacle has come down to us being pawns in the hands of our political representatives, with not one willing to take the risk of standing up and saying "hey we aren't being honest, we are ignoring the elephant in the room, and in the long run it's going hurt much more than it helps. We MUST do the right thing and take-up this debate with a firm goal of finding a solution". Instead, they are doing nothing except passing the ball to someone else in the hopes that they don't get tackled. We have very few politiicans anymore with an ounce of cajones.
The first step in resolving the issue is to stop politicizing and start working, something DC seems to have forgotten how to do.
True enough, I would venture to say that you and I are not very far apart on this one. Would that DC had the will to have such a discussion.
One of the things this state has done , while refusing medicaid expansion, is to expand the # of clinics offering income based fees. They are funded with medicaid $ as well as community partnerships..This has the effect of reducing ER visits and offering routine care for anyone, even illegals, as the funding is not entirely from the state. The downside is that by moving medicaid dollars to that area it is lost to indiv. who used to qualify.
I could write a book about how the rules have been written to create almost as many donut holes as there is coverage.
Susan,
Do you mind me asking what state you live in? It's no problem if you don't want to reveal as I completely understand.
This is an important and often overlooked fact. Preventative healthcare is by far the best and most cost-effective solution to much of America's health needs. It is alsoway, way toounderfundedfrom whatI can see from my own experience with our own (mine and my wife's) health insurance.
That's because we have too many politicians who are looking out more for Insurance's profits rather than their constituent's well being. There should be no holes anywhere; if a hole is found it should be an abberation rather then the seeming general fact it is.
I am in Georgia. Over the past fifteen years I have battled to find any kind of coverage for my sons. State regulations create a giant gap in eligibility between medicaid and the states CHIP program.
She works in Corporate accounting for multiple hospitals and doctor accounts cash intake and expenses currently for over 500 doctors. I don't know what state your in and it really doesn't matter. Hospitals are expanding capability with new ER capabilities labs fire suppression air cleaning and monitoring technologies. Plus a lot more I'm not privy to. But new Hospitals are going up as we speak and many others are expanding to handle the additional patients expected from the Affordable Health Care Law.
Bernie Sanders is one of the few that even tries. I've only known a couple of illegals picked up one in the desert and gave her a ride and believe she was an illegal but didn't ask I believe in helping people in need. She spoke very little English But no purse or baggage and only leather flip flops. Took her to Phoenix where I was going.
I am a huge Bernie fan. Almost got to see him at a town hall yesterday but had car trouble again.
I would hope this is not a ploy to get immigration reform legislation passed into law; don't get me wrong, such reform is needed but I prefer when legislators (and people in general) go for things in straight-forward fashion.
My thinking as well A. Mac.
Immigration reform needs to happen, and healthcare may be affected by that, but should not play a decisive role in untangeling immigration and status issues. Sure we are talking a few million other people, but the issues are two seperate issues.
I have great grandchildren who are half Hispanic. Their grandparents are legal and wonderful people, and sometimes when we have family gatherings they bring additional "friends" who we are pretty sure are here illegally. We don't ask but just welcome the "cousins" as family. The adults are always reserved and shy, the children just like the rest of the kids, loud and playful, hungry and sorry to go.
When you meet and interact with people on a personal level, in a family situation, it is easy to love and care for them. On the other hand, on more than one occasion, I have had to fire my rifle in the air to run Hispanic males out of my barn in the middle of the night who were trying to take possession of MY possessions.
Illegal aliens are a complicated and emotional subject, but they cannot be denied basic health care if they are here. It is, ultimately, for the safety of everyone that they receive it. Where do we think an epidemic will start... if one ever does... in the area code of the wealthy with the elective upper tier medical plan?
Do I advocate amnesty? NO! But that's another subject for another article.
As long as the health of people is treated as a market commodity, hospitals in poorer areas will always be in trouble.
Larry - hospitals are not "required" to provide the care to the illegals that they are - only to prevent a life-threatening situation. Cuts, bruises, pregnancies, headaches, upset stomachs and the myriad of other "daily" illnesses are to be paid for - out of pocket - but they're not.
LA has closed 10 hospitals because of the tremendous overflow of illegals. This year, they are looking at closing another 5 - possibly 8 - because of the financial loss cause by the illegals who use the hospitals for "everyday" uses.
Yup, thanks forhelping to make that clearer1stwarrior.
I have also heard others mention hospital closures as a consequence of the overburden of illegal immigrants. If it is already causing significant hardship, what will it be like after the ACA completely kicks in? We have got to get a handle on this asthe issue is going to get worse, not better, if we don't.
You said it Chucky.
If we are serious about healthcare we must understand the economic impact; but, alsounderstand that it is truely basic, human frailty we are attempting to deal with. Equal and fair healthcare should mean precisely that.
You made me smile mimi...
:~)
:~)
:~)
...and described manyof the family gatherings in our home over the last few years.
That sucks Susan and it would be interesting to know how this works out for you and your family. We'll keep you guys in our prayers and thoughts as you tackle the issue. Many blessings Susan.
:~)
That was exactly my first thought, Petey. If an individual can't afford the insurance, how the heck did these geniuses figure that they would find the money to pay the fine? Without going too far afield here, I have no problems helping legal US citizens having hard times but I do deeply resent paying for someone who is here illegally.
There were quite a few kids there this day as well, but they were too busy to stop long enough for picture!
:~)
Great looking group Larry! Who is in the hoodie?
That is one of our kids brothers Santos. My son Florencio is to his left in the black tank, my daughter Crystal is second from the left in the grey sweatshirt. These are some of their siblings and their wives and husbands.. I can't tell ya how proud I am of all of them. If I had to go through half the shit they did as children I don't think I'd be where I am today. We would have adopted everyone of them if we could have.
Wrong - Read the Emergency Medical Treatment and Active Labor Act to wit;
I can't tell ya how proud I am of all of them.
As well you should be!! Great looking bunch!
Related NT'ers article.