Trump eyes mass deportations for millions
Trump eyes mass deportations for millions
08/17/15 08:00 AM
It was just a couple of weeks ago when Republican presidential hopeful Donald Trump first raised the prospect of mass deportations for millions of immigrants already in the United States. The GOP candidate quickly joined what the Washington Post s Greg Sargent calls the Cattle Car Caucus .
At the time, Trump made no effort to explain how, exactly, he intends to identify, detain, and deport roughly 11 million people, or how he intends to pay for such a massive undertaking. Politicians arent going to find them because they have no clue, Trump said. We will find them, we will get them out.
As MSNBCs Anna Brand noted , Trump is now going into a little more detail on the issue thats helped propel him to the front of the Republican pack.
Donald Trump on Sunday released his detailed immigration reform plan, encompassing the sentiment he expressed in an interview on Meet the Press that aired just an hour earlier: Undocumented immigrants have to go.
Watching the interview yesterday, the exchange pointed to an apparent contradiction. Meet the Press host Chuck Todd asked the GOP candidate, Youre going to split up families. Youre going to deport children?
No, no, Trump responded. Were going to keep the families together. We have to keep the families together.
Todd followed up, But youre going to kick them out? To which Trump replied, simply, They have to go.
If this seems like a policy mess, theres a good reason for that. There are many undocumented immigrants, for example, whose children are American citizens, born in the United States. Deporting every immigrant who entered the country illegally, in practical terms, would mean separating parents from their own children.
Except under the Trump plan, the Republican doesnt want to do that. That leads to some alarming possibilities.
First, Trump may intend to deport citizens of the United States from the United States, which would be illegal. Second, Trump may intend to deny citizenship to people born in the United States, which would be unconstitutional. Or third, Trump may hope to do both.
The Republicans campaign website now includes a relatively detailed, 1,900-word outline of the Trump immigration plan, which does in fact call for the end of birthright citizenship, the 14th Amendment to the U.S. Constitution be damned . But in context, Trump appears to support deporting Americans, too its the practical result of a policy that plans to keep families together, while also vowing mass deportations of all undocumented immigrants.
For good measure, also note that Trumps plan includes a provision that would build a border wall, which he still expects Mexico to pay for.
As ridiculous as the Trump immigrant plan is and it really is masterful in its absurdity its worth noting that Trump is the first leading GOP presidential candidate to post a position paper of sorts online, inviting public scrutiny. Id welcome the chance to review Jeb Bushs and Scott Walkers immigration plans, too, but for now, they dont exist.

"(CNN) They have got to go. That about sums up the immigration ideas laid out by Donald Trump on Sunday's "Meet the Press," and in an accompanying 1,900-word policy paper . After making opposition to illegal immigration a cornerstone of his circus-like presidential campaign, The Donald has finally ventured into specifics with an immigration policy plan centered on increased border security and immigration enforcement.
While it is a good sign that Trump has ventured into actual policy proposals, his ideas are impractical at best and at worst inhumane. His ideas veer far to the right of the American mainstream. Far from stabilizing our economy, his plans could well stunt our economic growth.
Consider: Trump wants to build a wall all across our southern border with Mexico. To those for whom fighting illegal immigration is a top priority, this might sound like a smart, common-sense plan. But this line of thinking ignores reality. The border is more secure than it has been in years; an analysis this year by The Washington Post found that illegal crossings along the Mexican border were at their lowest level in two decades.
Meanwhile, our country's population of undocumented immigrants has dropped by about 1 million over the last several years, according to the Pew Research Center. We don't need that wall; what we do need is smarter immigration enforcement.
Trump says that his administration would force the Mexican government to pay for this wall. With all due respect, such an idea is laughable. A spokesman for Mexican President Enrique Pea Nieto, when told of Trump's plan to have Mexico foot the bill for a wall between our two countries, told Bloomberg News , "It reflects an enormous ignorance for what Mexico represents, and also the irresponsibility of the candidate who's saying it." He's right on both counts.
To force Mexico to pay for this wall, Trump says he would impose import tariffs for its construction. The big problem here is simple math. Consider that the total value of Mexican imports to the United States in 2014 was about $294 million -- while the 2013 "Gang of Eight" immigration proposal (which stalled in the House of Representatives) allotted $1.5 billion for more border fencing.
In other words, the total worth of all of Mexico's annual imports would not even cover the costs of expanding our southern border fencing, let alone make it into the kind of impenetrable barrier that Trump envisions. And imagine how disruptive it would be if "President Trump" were to enter into an all-out economic battle with one of our top three trade partners.
The most troubling part of Trump's immigration plan is that he has, in effect, endorsed mass deportations of the undocumented. "We're going to keep the families together, but they have to go," he said on "Meet the Press." Think about what this would mean: Our undocumented population is estimated at about 11 million , roughly equivalent to the population of Ohio.
Think of the tremendous economic upheaval, human suffering and community destabilization that would occur if our government were to round up and remove 11 million people. Such an idea is staggering in its lack of compassion, especially since a reported 62% of the undocumented have lived here for at least a decade, most as productive members of their American communities.
The costs of mass deportations would be, to use a favorite Trump term, "huge." The conservative American Action Forum has estimated that deporting all of our undocumented immigrants would cost between $400 billion and $600 billion, and would take about 20 years. Under such a scenario, real gross domestic product would fall by nearly $1.6 trillion.
For all Trump's lip service about "keeping families together," what about the U.S.-born children who live with undocumented parents? In 2008, the National Council of La Raza estimated that three-quarters of children with at least one undocumented parent were U.S.-born citizens. Would these kids be sent back to countries that are foreign to them, places where they might not speak the language?
Even worse, Trump has called for an end to birthright citizenship, saying it "remains the biggest magnet for illegal immigration." There is little to no analytical evidence to support this notion. The overwhelming majority of undocumented immigrants come to this country to work and provide for their families. Besides, birthright citizenship has been established by the 14th Amendment to the Constitution and upheld by the U.S. Supreme Court as far back as the Wong Kim Ark case in 1898.
There are many other similarly flawed ideas in Trump's immigration plan. Any first-year economics student could tell him that that his proposal to "pause" the issuing of all green cards would have a negative impact on our technology and business sectors by turning off the inflow of qualified, legal workers."
Do me a favor. Never ever again complain on this forum about anyone else changing their screen names.
I can't bear the thought of the monumental embarrassment you inflict on yourself every time you do so.
Interesting to note - SCOTUS has said in cases that illegal alien children born in the U.S. are not natural-born U.S. citizens because their parents STILL have allegiance with a foreign country.
The intent of the 14th was not to give U.S. citizenship to all newborns UNLESS their parents/one of their parents was a U. S. citizen.
Trump is spot on with that observation.
Just so people who come late to this thread know - you changed your screen name three times today.
11 million people are not going to be deported so what is your plan B ?
Get rid of the parents - the kids will follow.
Best plan of mice and men.
As I said, we are not going to deport 11 million people. Since you lack an alternative plan, why don't we just go with Obama's ?
Interesting. I did not know SCOTUS had made that ruling.
They haven't. Any child born within the borders United States, even those born here whose parents are here illegally, are automatically American citizens by right of birth and the SCOTUS has never said otherwise.
The SCOTUS has said that a child born overseas where at least one of the parents was an American is an American citizen. That's why McCain and Cruz can run for President even though they were not born in the United States. The same with the children of any service members or ambassadors, etc., are also American citizens even if not born in the US.
Sorry Randy - when you learn what you're talking about - then you can chime in.
"May 30 began with Senator Howard proposing to add the citizenship clause to 1 of the Fourteenth Amendment as follows: "All persons born in the United States, and subject to the jurisdiction thereof, are citizens of the United States and of the States wherein they reside." [138] This language was designed to settle the issue raised in Dred Scott that is, who are citizens and thus have the bundle of rights appertaining to citizenship. After a raucous debate over making Indians, coolies, and gypsies citizens, the Senate passed Howard's language. [139] "
"In 1866, Senator Jacob Howard clearly spelled out the intent of the 14 th Amendment by stating:
"Every person born within the limits of the United States, and subject to their jurisdiction, is by virtue of natural law and national law a citizen of the United States. This will not, of course, include persons born in the United States who are foreigners, aliens, who belong to the families of ambassadors or foreign ministers accredited to the Government of the United States, but will include every other class of persons. It settles the great question of citizenship and removes all doubt as to what persons are or are not citizens of the United States. This has long been a great desideratum in the jurisprudence and legislation of this country."
This understanding was reaffirmed by Senator Edward Cowan, who stated:
"[A foreigner in the United States] has a right to the protection of the laws; but he is not a citizen in the ordinary acceptance of the word..."
The phrase "subject to the jurisdiction thereof" was intended to exclude American-born persons from automatic citizenship whose allegiance to the United States was not complete. With illegal aliens who are unlawfully in the United States, their native country has a claim of allegiance on the child. Thus, the completeness of their allegiance to the United States is impaired, which therefore precludes automatic citizenship."
Off the top of my head, I would say this is the relevant passage.
This will not, of course, include persons born in the United States who are foreigners, aliens, who belong to the families of ambassadors or foreign ministers accredited to the Government of the United States, but will include every other class of persons.
A child born , in the United States, to the Mexican ambassador to the U.S. and his/her spouse, is not an American citizen. "every other class of persons" would be.
...
"Children of undocumented (illegal) immigrants who were, like their parents, born outside the United States have no more rights to U.S. citizenship than their parents do. Despite various legislative proposals, the U.S. immigration laws currently contain no special provisions based on the age at which a person arrived in the United States.
However, children of undocumented immigrants who were born in the United States become U.S. citizens automatically. The parent(s)' immigration status is not taken into account. This is due to the 14th Amendment of the U.S. Constitution, which reads that:
"All persons born or naturalized in the United States, and subject to the jurisdiction thereof, are citizens of the United States and the State wherein they reside.
Citizenship is the highest status available under the U.S. immigration laws. As a native-born U.S. citizen, the child in question will be granted all of the rights that every other citizen is entitled to, such as the rights to vote, assume public office, and be immune from deportation (removal)."
Sorry 1st, but those are just the opinions of those legislators, but they are not rulings of the SCOTUS and they do not carry the rule of law.
Birthright citizenship in the United States refers to a person's acquisition of United States citizenship by virtue of the circumstances of his or her birth. It contrasts with citizenship acquired in other ways, for example by naturalization later in life. Birthright citizenship may be conferred by jus soli or jus sanguinis . Under United States law, U.S. citizenship is automatically granted to any person born within and subject to the jurisdiction of the U.S. This includes the territories of Puerto Rico , the Marianas ( Guam and the Northern Mariana Islands ) and the U.S. Virgin Islands , and also applies to children born elsewhere in the world to U.S. citizens (with certain exceptions). [1] [2]
The Citizenship Clause of the Fourteenth Amendment to the United States Constitution states that "All persons born or naturalized in the United States, and subject to the jurisdiction thereof, are citizens of the United States and of the State wherein they reside."
Please read most of this from the source so I don't have to cut and paste all of the relevant parts and then show me a SCOTUS case since this case,
United States v. Wong Kim Ark
In the case of United States v. Wong Kim Ark , 169 U.S. 649 (1898), the Supreme Court ruled that a person who
becomes, at the time of his birth, a citizen of the United States by virtue of the first clause of the 14th Amendment of the Constitution .
where they have overturned that ruling. They have not because such a case does not exist and it still stands, according to the SCOTUS that any person born in the United States is granted citizenship at birth.
Lately some have tried to change this:
Modern dispute
In the late 1990s opposition arose over the longstanding practice of granting automatic citizenship on a jus soli basis [56] as fears grew in some circles that the existing law encouraged parents-to-be to come to the United States to have children in order to improve the parents' chances of attaining legal residency themselves. [57] [58] Some media correspondents [59] [60] and public leaders, including former congressman Virgil Goode , have controversially dubbed this the " anchor baby " situation, [61] [62] and politicians have proposed legislation on this basis that might alter how birthright citizenship is awarded. [63]
The Pew Hispanic Center determined that according to an analysis of Census Bureau data about 8 percent of children born in the United States in 2008 about 340,000 were offspring of illegal immigrants. In total, about four million American-born children of illegal immigrant parents resided in this country in 2009, along with about 1.1 million foreign-born children of illegal immigrant parents. [64] The Center for Immigration Studies a think tank which favors stricter controls on immigrationclaims that between 300,000 and 400,000 children are born each year to illegal immigrants in the U.S. [65] [66]
Bills have been introduced from time to time in Congress which have sought to declare American-born children of foreign nationals not to be "subject to the jurisdiction of the United States", and thus not entitled to citizenship via the 14th Amendment, unless at least one parent was an American citizen or a lawful permanent resident .
Both Democrats and Republicans have introduced legislation aimed at narrowing the application of the Citizenship Clause. In 1993, Sen. Harry Reid (D-Nev.) introduced legislation that would limit birthright citizenship to the children of U.S. citizens and legally resident aliens, and similar bills have been introduced by other legislators in every Congress since. [66] For example, U.S. Representative Nathan Deal , a Republican from the State of Georgia , introduced the " Citizenship Reform Act of 2005 " (H.R. 698) in the 109th Congress , [67] the "Birthright Citizenship Act of 2007" (H.R. 1940) [68] in the 110th Congress , and the "Birthright Citizenship Act of 2009" (H.R. 1868) [69] in the 111th Congress . However, neither these nor any similar bill has ever been passed by Congress.
Some legislators, unsure whether such Acts of Congress would survive court challenges, have proposed that the Citizenship Clause be changed through a constitutional amendment . [70] Senate Joint Resolution 6, introduced on January 16, 2009 in the 111th Congress, proposes such an amendment; [71] however, neither this, nor any other proposed amendment, has yet been approved by Congress for ratification by the states.
The most recent judge to weigh in on the issue as to whether a constitutional amendment would be necessary to change the policy is Judge Richard Posner who remarked in a 2003 case that "Congress would not be flouting the Constitution if it amended the Immigration and Nationality Act to put an end to the nonsense." He explained, "A constitutional amendment may be required to change the rule whereby birth in this country automatically confers U.S. citizenship, but I doubt it." Posner also wrote, that automatic birthright citizenship is a policy that "Congress should rethink" and that the United States "should not be encouraging foreigners to come to the United States solely to enable them to confer U.S. citizenship on their future children." [72]
Please note that Judge Posner is not a Justice of the SCOTUS and is only expressing his opinion.
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Birthright_citizenship_in_the_United_...
Nice try Randy - Pressy v. Ferguson, Elk v. Wilkins, Slaughter-House cases, Plyer v. Doe, Vance v. Terrazas - each of the cases state, in essence, that if the parents are in the U. S. "LEGALLY", then the child would be born as a U. S. citizen.
Illegal aliens are not in the country legally - their children born in the U. S. are not U. S. citizens.
Obama has no plan - mine is better.
children of undocumented immigrants who were born in the United States become U.S. citizens automatically. The parent(s)' immigration status is not taken into account. This is due to the 14th Amendment of the U.S. Constitution, which reads that:
"All persons born or naturalized in the United States, and subject to the jurisdiction thereof, are citizens of the United States and the State wherein they reside.
-
You may have talked yourself into believing they are not citizens, but that is not the reality.
There is a Plessy v Ferguson, but There is no Pressy V. Ferguson that I can find. Plessy over turns racial segregation.
Elk held that NA's born on reservations at that point were not citizens because the reservations were not considered to be part of the United States. It's not on point. Besides, that was changed by The Indian Citizenship Act of 1924 which made all NA citizens of the US.
The Slaughterhouse cases were concerning the Privileges or Immunities Clause of the 14th Amendment, and did not adress anything to do with the citizenship clause. Again, nope, does not over turn birth right citizenship and in fact say nothing about it.
Plyer actually reinforces the citizenship clause, if anything, because it struck down a Texas law saying that they did not have to provide an education to children here illegally (the SCOTUS said they do have to), but again it does not address birth right citizenship.
Vance says that you can not take American citizenship away from an American holding dual citizenship.
Of course if both parents are here legally a child born to them is a legal citizen. However the 14th Amendment does not restrict (and neither has the SCOTUS) to just those parents and none of those cases say so. In fact if you read those cases, not a one of them changes the citizenship part of the 14th Amendment in any manner at all and actually none of them even tries to. Birthright citizenship was not an issue decided in any of them. Please, read the cases and show me where the SCOTUS over-ruled that clause.
Show me one case from the SCOTUS that says children of illegal parents are not citizens, because none of those cases do that. ALL children born in the United States automatically acquire US citizenship at birth.
Under United States law, U.S. citizenship is automatically granted to any person born within and subject to the jurisdiction of the U.S.
Please read the links I provided in my last post.
Pressy v. Ferguson, Elk v. Wilkins, Slaughter-House cases, Plyer v. Doe, Vance v. Terrazas - each of the cases state, in essence, that if the parents are in the U. S. "LEGALLY", then the child would be born as a U. S. citizen.
Actually none of them state that at all or anything close to that. In essence or in fact. Got any cases that DO over-ride citizenship by birthright in the US? Because these don't. Sorry, but they just don't.
I'm not John, but I have little doubt that most of them would prefer to have them in them American foster system (which will overwhelm it BTW), then to have them return to a country they know little or nothing about and in which their lives may be endangered. I would if I were them. This is their children's home country and as they are citizens, it is up to us to take care of them until they reach 18 or are out of school. As a parent I would want that, even if I would miss them terribly. I would want what is best for my child, not for me and that is a future in the United States of America. Given the choice, I think most of them will feel the same way.
The idea that millions of minor children would be deliberately separated from their birth parents, today, by order of the government of the United States is one of the most absurd things I have ever heard.
True. Even Trump says he would keep families together and he can't kick out the American Citizen children. Besides it's all academic. Not he nor anyone else is going to deport the 11 million undocumented workers (or illegal aliens) anyway. It's just feel good for the right wing politi-speech.
As a Canadian citizen here on a work visa, I hope he doesn't include me.
Wong states the only reason the son could become a U.S. citizen was because his parents were legally allowed to be in the U.S., regardless/irrespective of the Chinese Exclusion Act. As they were here legally, the child qualified.
Plyer stated that the child could not become a U. S. citizen because his parents were illegal aliens BUT the state of Texas couldn't prevent him from gaining an education.
Did you "NOT" read Trump's plan???
Trump is saying, they will not be splitting up Families, they would "DEPORT" everyone including the children who are citizens, how could they leave children to fend for themselves.."TRUMP THE NEW HITLER!!!!!
All you Haters of Immigrants that thinks this is a good idea, your time will be next, you may not be qualified to be deported, but the plans, TRUMP has next for you, you may very well wish you had A Country to be deported to...
WHY, would you DOUBT the Man's Words???he says what he means and he means what he says!!!
Randy, I know is seems unlikely, that's because you have a good heart and it is not within your realm of comprehension..TRUMP is a pig of the lowest denominator in my opinion, I live in NYC, I have worked with PIGS like those daily, it means NOTHING to that PIG and does not matter the cost to him to get rid of people he hates...
I have no doubt that people like TRUMP would specify the people he wants out, Hispanics and Blacks..That I believe...
Glad to see that your personal opinions don't overlook the facts of a good discussion.
jennilee - that is exactly what the Obama administration and the Democratic party are "hoping" will happen - that people will get tired of discussing and issue blanket amnesty for all.
That's exactly what Reagan did jennilee.
The ULTIMATE PROBLEM is NOT the ILLEGAL WORKER, RATHER THE GREEDY, DISHONEST AMERICAN EMPLOYERS WHO HIRE THEM KNOWINGLY IN ORDER TO FATTEN THE BOTTOM LINE BY PAYING SHIT WAGES.
Lock them up, shut down their businesses and that will remove the greatest incentives for those coming here illegally to find work.
I love it when a hypocrite Republican talks "deportation," that without noting the CORPORATE FARMS (Republican-supporters) which are the single, largest employers or migrant workers.
In the meantime, advocating "closing the barn door after the horse runs away" and failing to understand the economic gains of dealing with what is, rather than what feels good xenophobically, is typical of the ignorant, hater-mentality.
An Immigration Stimulus: The Economic Benefits of a Legalization Program
...
Please refrain from one-line-quip "rebuttals" to the above; if you haven't done your homework, don't embarrass yourself.
I speak what I hear, there are many people that hates Hispanics and Blacks, I know its supposed to be hush, hush...I don't care, Its Fact....
BLAH, BLAH, you know its truth....Oh, I bet you would like me to say TRUMP is a reasonable person...BS...He has revealed who he is...
1st. Can you tell me how the Republicans have tried to resolve this immigration situation???
212 bills had been submitted to the Senate from the Repub House - Harry Reid sat on each and every one and refused to bring them up for discussion.
That's what the Repubs did and that's what the Dems did.
Who was working for immigration then?
LMAO!!!!! TRUMP would be first in line...
DO YOU ACTUALLY THINK TRUMP IS ANY DIFFERENT THAN ROMNEY???WHO SENT JOBS TO CHINA!!!
Report: Several illegal immigrants work at Trump hotel construction site in D.C.
Following Donald Trumps comments on Latinos, several legal and illegal immigrants now fear for their jobs working at the construction site of Trump International Hotel.
WASHINGTON (MEDIA GENERAL) Business tycoon Donald Trump has stolen the national spotlight after announcing his candidacy for the 2016 presidential election while making disparaging comments on Latinos and illegal immigrants.
Trump said illegal immigrants, entering the United States through Mexico, are bringing drugs. Theyre bringing crime. Theyre rapists.
several undocumented immigrants are working on the construction site of Trumps new $200 million hotel in Washington D.C.
According to the Post, the majority of the workers on the site of the future Trump International Hotel in D.C. are Hispanic, many of whom entered the country illegally.
According to stonemason Ivan Arellano, who is from Mexico and now is legally in America through marriage, Trumps comments have dominated discussion around the construction site.
The majority of us are Hispanics, many who came illegally. And were all here working very hard to build a better life for our families, Arellano told the Washington Post.
Following Trumps comments, many are concerned, legal citizens or not, that they will be fired.
He might come one day and pretty much tell us to get the heck out of here, said Daniel Gonzalez, a sheet metal worker who was granted asylum in the U.S. from war-torn El Salvador.
Ramon Alvarez, a window worker from El Salvador, posited a hypothetical question to Mr. Trump.
Asked Alvarez: Do you think that when were hanging out there from the eighth floor, that were raping or selling drugs? Were risking our lives and our health. A lot of the chemicals we deal with are toxic.
A spokesperson for the Trump Organization issued a statement that said the company and its contractors follow all U.S. immigration laws in its hiring process. The statement also said it is the obligation of the lead contractor of the hotel to verify employees legal status.
And I luv it when you "conveniently" forget how the Dems futched Reagan in '86 when he was attempting to get the corporate dollar and business owners shut down over illegal immigration and hiring illegal aliens. What did the Dems do???? Told Reagan - sorry - we got what we wanted, now screw the American people. "The law granted amnesty to nearly 3 million illegal immigrants, yet was largely considered unsuccessful because the strict sanctions on employers were stripped out of the bill for passage." and who stripped it??? The Dems.
Here's why.
When a state like Arizona enacts a law that allows individuals to be stopped by police because they "LOOK LIKE ILLEGALS," while at the same time HAVING PRIVATIZED PRISONS WHERE PEOPLE SUCH AS ONE OF ARIZONA GOVERNOR'S TOP ASSISTANTS HAVE A FINANCIAL STAKE
That screams of potential abuses where filling the prisons (i.e. with alleged "illegals) put dollars in the hands of privateers and gives kickbacks to state legislators who enable such an outrage!
Let's bring out all the DNC articles - to "prove" that there were no "high tricks" pulled by the Dems -
Randy, I know is seems unlikely, that's because you have a good heart and it is not within your realm of comprehension..TRUMP is a pig of the lowest denominator in my opinion, I live in NYC, I have worked with PIGS like those daily, it means NOTHING to that PIG and does not matter the cost to him to get rid of people he hates...
All that you say about him is true, but kicking out American citizens, just because they were born to undocumented workers is unconstitutional. It would immediately be stopped while being challenged in the court and he would lose. Even the MOST conservative court would stand by the 14th Amendment. It's the same with any new anti-birthright law that Congress might pass. It will be ruled against by the SCOTUS. It would take an amendment to the Constitution to allow it and that's not going to happen. In fact 90% of what he says he is going to do is either illegal, unConstitutional or both. He's just blowing smoke out his ass to make extreme right wingers happy.
Besides, it's all academic. Donald Trump is never going to be the President. It's not going to happen.
Plyer stated that the child could not become a U. S. citizen because his parents were illegal aliens BUT the state of Texas couldn't prevent him from gaining an education.
No. it does not. If it did then American citizenship would have already been denied to the tens of thousands who have been born here of illegal immigrants (since Plyer (and that has not happened)) and are in fact American citizens and the GOP House wouldn't be falling all over itself trying to change it (and Reid even tried to at one point, but couldn't) and Trump wouldn't be saying that he is going to stop birthright citizenship. They are all trying to stop something that you claim has already been ruled against by the SCOTUS and would therefore be the law of the land because of that ruling? They are all saying they will stop something that you say doesn't exist, birthright citizenship?
The reason it is not now the law of the land and citizenship is still being granted to every child born of illegal immigrants is because Plyer did NOT overturn birthright citizenship. It simply says that a child who is already illegal (Not born here. Brought into the country as a child or infant) must be educated, but that the decision does not grant citizenship to them. A child who was and is born here is not an illegal child, even if their parents are here illegally, so therefore the ruling does not apply to them and Plyer does not say that it does.
If a person is not automatically granted citizenship by birth, as you claim Plyer says (and doesn't) then why are so many on the right trying to change something that you claim now doesn't exist because it was already changed by Plyer? Your argument makes no sense.
Here's what I would do.
Everyone now living in the U.S. is allowed to stay, permanently , provided that they do not have a felony record and provided that they get a photo id within the next 30 days that also shows a current address.
After a set date, no one without that photo id is allowed to work, anywhere in the United States. Any company or individual that hires a non id person to work for them is subject to severe fines and punishments on an escalating scale up to and including lengthy jail time.
Then enforce these rules.
We cannot remove those that are already here, we can only prevent the motivation for more to come.
After a set date, only legal immigrants could acquire the id, they would be closed to those without legal immigration documents.
Then you have to strictly enforce who is hiring these people , and every time someone is caught hiring someone who doesn't have the id they are severely punished.
It would be expensive to create a national work id that could not be counterfeited, but it would be worth it compared to what we go through now.
Then you have to strictly enforce who is hiring these people , and every time someone is caught hiring someone who doesn't have the id they are severely punished.
Therein lies one of the problems. A LOT of wealthy people/employers do NOT want illegal immigrants kicked out or stopped from coming because they can exploit them. They know they have undocumented workers working for them (because they simply don't check the presented SS #'s as the law says they must) because they don't want to know and they know they are not going to get punished because they (especially agribusiness) have powerful lobbies in Congress. I think your proposal makes a lot of sense, if we could get the GOP to go along and if the laws on employers would actually be enforced. But that is a HUGE if.
1st,
You posted a "definitive" allegation; I responded with "information" -- if you can find documentation rebutting what I posted, I'll concede the point.
Wong states the only reason the son could become a U.S. citizen was because his parents were legally allowed to be in the U.S., regardless/irrespective of the Chinese Exclusion Act. As they were here legally, the child qualified.
Oh and no, Wong does not say that. It just says that the parents have a permanent domicile or residence, not that they have to be here legally as resident aliens or citizens.
In fact Wong won his citizenship case because he had been born in San Fransisco, left the country and then was denied re-entry into the country by being told he was not a U.S. Citizen under the then "Chinese Exclusion Act of 1882" which said that Chinese may not immigrate to the U.S. and that those here may not become "naturalized" citizens. In other words American citizenship by the Chinese, all Chinese, was illegal then under this Act. Old American racism at it's ugliest. The Supreme Court held however that, since he had been born here, he was in fact a U.S. citizen by birthright already and did not need to become one . So The Chinese Exclusion Act did not apply to people born in America.
Since the 1990s, however, controversy has arisen over the longstanding practice of granting automatic citizenship to U.S.-born children of illegal immigrants , and legal scholars disagree over whether the Wong Kim Ark precedent applies when alien parents are in the country illegally. [4] [5] Attempts have been made from time to time in Congress to restrict birthright citizenship, either via statutory redefinition of the term jurisdiction, or by overriding both the Wong Kim Ark ruling and the Citizenship Clause itself through an amendment to the Constitution , but no such proposal has been enacted .
U.S. v Wong has never been overturned, changed (or even addressed) by the SCOTUS since and attempts to change it by Congress have been unsuccessful.
Randy - please quit using wikipedia for your legal sources. Instead, use or
or
or
or
They're all free and they're all accurate, whereas wikipedia is subject, sometimes quite heavily, to bias in their information.
Good responses though.
Thanks for the "Good Responses".
I usually reach for Wiki because it's convenient (force of habit really) and I generally (though not always) check out the attributions in the footnotes at the bottom of the page. I will try to break this habit and use the sites you suggest though. I know I have used Cornell several times in the past and they are very good. Maybe I'll make them my "go to" when it comes to the law.
And, did you know that is one of the primary primus' of the Constitution????
I GUESS THAT'S THE WRONG THING TO DO - STATES RIGHTS, EH?
Mac - if you're gonna try to talk - do so - don't shout 'cause that will turn me off in an instant.
First, you don't know squat 'bout SB 86 - it does not address "looking like an illegal alien." Second, an assistant having money in an operation is how different from Congress people making money hand over fist for their insider information/kick-backs - apples and oranges Mac - apples and oranges.
Sorry - there can be no defense if the only position you wish to use is the Dem position.
Advertising?
I'm talking about Arizona SB 1070.
It's a conflict-of-interests aside from which, the privatization mode encourages high arrest rates and phony convictions for the purpose of profiteering.
Private Prison Companies Behind the Scenes of Arizonas Immigration Law
As for "States Rights," among other things
States rights was invoked by slave owners to protest abolition , even to the point of seceding from the union. States rights was then used to defend segregation from national reform. Later, it was trotted out to oppose integration of schools, as demanded by the U.S. Supreme Court in Brown v. Board of Education. To this day, it is used to justify state restrictions on voting, often imposed to constrict the right of the minorities and the poor to vote.
Alan Simpson was a Republican
Fair enough wrong post I deleted it.
My bad.
States rights are enforceable under the 10th amendment - "The Tenth Amendment ( Amendment X ) to the United States Constitution , which is part of the Bill of Rights , was ratified on December 15, 1791. [1] It expresses the principle of federalism , which undergirds the entire plan of the original Constitution, by stating that the federal government possesses only those powers delegated to it by the Constitution. All remaining powers are reserved for the states or the people ."
If you want to address conflict of interest - set up a separate thread/article and make sure you include all of the references pertaining to Congress people.
I would certainly be interested in following an article like that.
Please note he said "they took the guts right out." - they - the Dems.
I would too Randy.
I wonder if those willing to change the 14th Amendment so as to essentially "rescind," ex-post facto, the birth right of children of illegals born in America if they would also be willing to rescind portions of the 2nd Amendment!
After all, if the presence of the children of illegals i.e. " is having an adverse effect on America" then logically, no rational person could argue against the obvious realities that guns are also having an adverse effect, and, must then agree that consequently the Constitutional right-to-bear-arms needs some serious clipping.
Let's see whose reasonable by way of something more substantive than a one-line quip or a personal insult.
I have those days too
What's to change? It's already there.
In 1866, Senator Jacob Howard clearly spelled out the intent of the 14thAmendment by stating:
"Every person born within the limits of the United States, and subject to their jurisdiction, is by virtue of natural law and national law a citizen of the United States. This will not, of course, include persons born in the United States who are foreigners, aliens, who belong to the families of ambassadors or foreign ministers accredited to the Government of the United States, but will include every other class of persons. It settles the great question of citizenship and removes all doubt as to what persons are or are not citizens of the United States. This has long been a great desideratum in the jurisprudence and legislation of this country."
This understanding was reaffirmed by Senator Edward Cowan, who stated:
"[A foreigner in the United States] has a right to the protection of the laws; but he is not a citizen in the ordinary acceptance of the word..."
The phrase"subject to the jurisdiction thereof"was intended to exclude American-born persons from automatic citizenship whose allegiance to the United States was not complete. With illegal aliens who are unlawfully in the United States, their native country has a claim of allegiance on the child. Thus, the completeness of their allegiance to the United States is impaired, which therefore precludes automatic citizenship.
And like actual "guts," at times some proposed laws are filled with excrement.
I noted the potential injustices in specific terms and how historically, the logistics of the "gutted" elements have been cited and used in ways to abrogate Constitutional rights of certain demographics.
It was correct, IMO, to remove the "excrement" from the "guts" and take a dump.
Well, like the hit-man in Godfather 2 said when Tom Hagan said it would be impossible to hit Hyman Roth, "Not impossible. Difficult, but not impossible."
Opportunities to excel Randy - opportunities to excel.
The one thing that very few people have the nerve to say, mostly out of fear of being called a racist, is that if we don't stem this tide of Hispanic illegals, from Mexico down to the northern part of South America, this country will NEVER recover, and it will never be the country we grew up in again.
Now that's a absolute fact!
Accepting a near unending tide of undereducated, undocumented, Catholic "children having" aliens, will turn the US into a Hispanic majority state.
And while that might be fine if it happened over the course of centuries, having it happen the way that is, and will continue to, will destroy this country.
It's already keeping wages flat, filling our prisons, destroying public education, and putting a huge burden on our social safety net, while NOT filling the coffers of our tax driven government.
We NEVER should have let it get this bad, but we did.
Deportation is highly impractical, but what else is there? Amnesty? Again?
It's like a flashing neon sign saying "come on in, we're OPEN!"
They will flood in for the next 30-40 years if we do that.
Sorry folks, deportation, and a actual wall is our only hope at survival, otherwise, in 30-40 years, the US becomes Mexico Norte.
Let's see, you say you can't stand Trump, but you are totally behind two of his big ideas, deportation of Mexicans and confrontation with Iran.
Do you even vote ?
In 30 or 40 years, wall or not, we're still going to be a predominately Hispanic nation, just because legal American citizens of what is considered "Hispanic" decent are reproducing at a much higher rate then White or Black Americans (though Asian/Americans are reproducing at a higher rate then Hispanics, but are starting from smaller numbers). We are going to become a Hispanic nation no matter what anyone does. Though mixed races Americans are reproducing fastest of all, so someday we'll be one big blend. Everyone will be brown. Not white. Not Black. Brown.
...
I can't stand Trump, but that doesn't make legal border enforcement wrong.
Trump is a dumbass idiot, but the primary reason that his caveman message is taking root is because most of us realize that the country is being overwhelmed with illegal immigrants.
Have you ever been to a commercial construction site?
I go to one every single day, trust me, OVERWHELMED!
I never supported his stance on Iran, I just don't think we need to act like they don't mean it when they chant death to America.
Trump isn't right about anything, but his message resonates because he at least sees the problem, even if his solutions are absurd.
And Yes, I do vote, do you?
dennis,
I believe that the most prevalent scenario is that the children are not told by the parents that they (the parents) are here illegally; the dilemma is then with regard to punishing innocent people who, like it or not, by law, are American citizens.